Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 19th January, 2026
Date of Decision: 27th February, 2026
Uploaded on: 27th February, 2026
+
W.P.(C) 6918/2014, CM APPL. 16302/2014, CM APPL. 41674/2016
PUNJAB & SIND BANK
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Rajat Arora, Mr. Niraj
Kumar & Mr. Sourabh Mahila,
Advs.
versus
RAMESH CHANDRA SEMWAL
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Sandeep Sharma, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Hunny Singh and Mr. Ankit
Parindiyal, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
SHAIL JAIN, J.
1.
The present Writ Petition has been filed under Article 226/227 of the
Constitution of India, inter-alia, assailing the Award dated 09.06.2014 (hereinafter
‘Impugned Award’) passed by Ld. Central Government Industrial Tribunal II,
New Delhi (hereinafter ‘CGIT’) answering the reference in negative terms holding
the termination of the Respondent/Workman to be void and that the
Respondent/Workman is entitled for reinstatement with regularization of his
services as Orderly/ Daftari.
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
BRIEF FACTS:
2.
The Petitioner is a Nationalized Bank constituted under the Banking
Companies (Acquisition & Transfer of Undertaking) Act, 1980 having its branches
all over India including its branch at Mussoorie in Dehradun District, Uttarakhand.
3.
The Respondent/Workman was employed with the Petitioner/bank since
1988 in the capacity of a temporary employee (Peon) at its Zonal Office in
Dehradun vide appointment letter dated 19th September 1988. The initial
appointment was for a period of 30 days w.e.f. 21st September 1988, the terms and
conditions of appointment stipulated that the engagement was temporary in nature.
4.
In the year 1992, the Petitioner/Bank terminated the services of the
Respondent/Workman without any notice, in pursuance to which the
Respondent/workman raised an industrial dispute. Consequently, vide Order dated
22.08.1997, the Central Government declined to make a reference of the dispute to
the Industrial Tribunal for adjudication under Section 12(5) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter ‘the Act’), holding that the Respondent had
worked only intermittently, namely: 87 days in 1988, 111 days in 1989, 26 days in
1990, 20 days in 1991, and 20 days in 1992. Therefore, it was held that the
Respondent had not completed 240 days of continuous service in any twelve
calendar months preceding the date of termination of his services.
5.
In the interregnum, the Respondent/workman was reappointed by the bank
on 16.12.1996 and was engaged as a temporary employee against a vacant post on
the panel of subordinate staff, on the post of Orderly(Temporary), at the Punjab
and Sind Bank, Mussoorie Branch, Dehradun.
6.
During his tenure of serving as temporary orderly, the Workman raised a
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
demand before the management seeking regularization of his services which were
not regularized; instead, another individual was appointed by the management on
compassionate grounds. Workman thereafter, filed Petition No. 205 of 2003 (SS)
before the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital seeking regularization of his
services; however, the same was dismissed with liberty to avail appropriate
remedies before the competent forum.
7.
Thereafter, the Respondent/Workman continued to discharge his duties as a
temporary employee on the bona fide belief and legitimate expectation that his
services would be regularized, as he had been assured by the Petitioner/Bank that
necessary communications in that regard had already been forwarded to the
competent higher authorities.
However, on 11.05.2003, the services of the
Respondent were terminated abruptly by the Petitioner/Bank without issuing any
notice whatsoever. At the time of such termination, the last drawn salary of the
Respondent/Workman was Rs.2,750/- per month, besides other admissible
allowances. In pursuance to which, the Respondent raised an industrial dispute
under Section 2A of the Act challenging the illegal termination of his services.
Thereafter, upon failure of conciliation proceedings conducted under Section 12 of
the Act, the appropriate Government, in exercise of its powers under Section 10(1)
read with Section 10(2A) of the Act, referred the dispute for adjudication to the
CGIT vide Notification No. L-12012/59/2007 dated 17th October, 2007. The
Tribunal was called upon to adjudicate the following reference question:
“Whether the action of the Management of Punjab &
Sind Bank in terminating/disengaging Shri Ramesh
Chandra Semwal employed as a sub-staff at Mussoorie
Branch of Punjab & Sind Bank w.e.f. 11.05.2003
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
without any notice and compensation under the
provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is legal
and justified. If not, to what relief is the concerned
workman entitled and from which date?"
8.
Before the CGIT, the Workman in his statement of claim filed under Rule
10B of the Act averred that Respondent/Workman had been employed with the
Petitioner/Bank since 1996 and was illegally retrenched from the services. In
response thereto, the Petitioner herein, filed a preliminary objection to the said
claim on the grounds of delay and laches. On merits, it was submitted that the
Respondent was engaged purely on a temporary basis and never completed 240
days of service in preceding calendar year. It was further submitted that the
termination of the Respondent was in accordance with the contractual terms, which
permitted termination without notice or without assigning any reason.
Consequently, no legitimate expectation of regularization could arise.
9.
Consequently, the learned CGIT upon appreciation of the pleadings and
evidence(s) led by the parties vide ‘Impugned award’ held the termination to be
void ab initio. The Tribunal further observed that once the Respondent had prima
facie established continuous service, the onus shifted upon the Bank to rebut the
same; however, despite being afforded sufficient opportunities, the Bank failed to
discharge the said burden. The Tribunal thus answered the reference in favour of
the Respondent-workman, directing his reinstatement with continuity of service
with no back wages, and regularization with effect from the date of termination.
The award of the CGIT reads as under:
“On the basis of aforesaid discussion I am of
considered view that reference is liable to be decided
in favour of workman and against management. Which
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
is accordingly decided.
Workman Sh. Ramesh Chand Samwal in the instant
case rendered service as a casual worker as Orderly/
Daftari for more than 240 days in each calendar year
to management. So, he is entitled for reinstatement
with regularization of his services. Management is
directed to reinstate workman Sh. Ramesh Chand
Samwal and regularized him as Orderly/ Daftari after
expiry of period of limitation of available remedy
against award but workman is not entitled for back
wages as he has neither pleaded in his claim statement
nor proved that he remained unemployed since his
termination on 11.05.2003 upto the date of Award.
This will meet the ends of justice.
Award is accordingly passed.”
10.
Being aggrieved by the Impugned order, passed by CGIT, the present Writ
Petition is filed by the Petitioner/Bank assailing the same praying that the said
award be set aside. The Petitioner further prayed for an ad interim Order
restraining the execution of the said award.
ISSUES INVOLVED:
The sole question before this Court at present is:
● Whether the Learned CGIT was justified in answering the reference in
favour of the workman by directing reinstatement and regularization of
his service?
SUBMISSIONS OF PARTIES:
11.
As for the submissions of the parties, the preliminary objection raised by the
Petitioner is that the reference itself suffers from gross and unexplained delay. The
termination is stated to be dated 11.05.2003, whereas the industrial dispute was
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
raised only in the year 2007, after a lapse of approximately four years. According
to Petitioner, the Respondent took no steps during this interregnum therefore, such
unexplained delay and laches ought to have weighed with the appropriate
Government while considering the question of reference, and the learned CGIT
ought to have taken this aspect into account while adjudicating the dispute and
granting relief.
12.
The first and foremost submission on behalf of the Petitioner on merits is
that Section 25F of the Act is not attracted in the facts of the present case and the
learned CGIT has proceeded on an erroneous understanding that the requirement of
completion of 240 days can be assessed with reference to any calendar year.
Petitioner contends that in law, however, the requirement of 240 days’ continuous
service is to be computed with reference to the twelve months immediately
preceding the date of termination, and not on the basis of a calendar year or yearwise calculation. He goes on to submit that in the present case, the date of
termination is 11.05.2003 and, therefore, the relevant period for determining
whether the Respondent had completed 240 days would be from 12.05.2002 to
11.05.2003 therefore, the CGIT has fallen into patent error in assessing the
completion of 240 days on a calendar-year basis, which is legally unsustainable.
13.
The next submission on behalf of the Petitioner is that the Respondent had
earlier approached the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital seeking
regularization and other reliefs. The said Writ petition was disposed of with liberty
to withdraw the same and to avail appropriate remedy before appropriate forum in
accordance with law hence, this clearly demonstrates that the Respondent had
already invoked judicial remedies prior to initiating the present proceedings.
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
14.
Counsel for the Petitioner further submits that in relation to an earlier
dispute raised by the Respondent, the learned Conciliation Officer, by order dated
22.08.1997, declined to make a reference under Sec 10 of the act. Learned Counsel
goes on to submit that in the said order, it was specifically recorded that the
workman had worked only 87 days in 1988, 111 days in 1989, 26 days in 1990, 20
days in 1991 and 20 days in 1992 and it was observed that the workman had not
completed 240 days in any completed period of twelve calendar months preceding
the alleged termination and, therefore, the provisions of Section 25F were not
attracted. He further mentions that although the said order pertains to an earlier
period (1988–1992) and the present dispute relates to a subsequent period (1996–
2003) however, this background is relevant to demonstrate the intermittent, casual
and non-continuous nature of the Respondent’s engagement throughout.
15.
It is further submitted by the Petitioner that the burden of proving
completion of 240 days squarely lies upon the workman. He contends that it being
a settled principle of law that the initial onus to establish continuous service rests
on the employee, the burden shifts to the management only after the workman
discharges his primary obligation by producing cogent material, such as
appointment records, wage slips, documentary evidence, or by taking appropriate
steps calling upon the employer to produce muster rolls or other relevant records.
In the present case, there is no appointment letter evidencing regular employment,
no termination letter, and only temporary engagement letters relating to
PTS/temporary arrangements. Therefore, in the absence of foundational evidence
from the workman, the learned CGIT has erroneously shifted the burden upon the
Bank merely on the ground that muster rolls were not produced. Such an approach
is contrary to settled legal principles and is unsustainable in law. In support of the
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
said contention counsel has relied upon the decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court
in Essen Deinki v. Rajiv Kumar, (2002) 8 SCC 400 in which it was held that the
onus to prove 240 days lies primarily on the workman and not on employer.
16.
He also contends that the CGIT’s conclusion that the Respondent had
completed 240 days is itself vitiated, as it is founded upon an incorrect mode of
computation and does not assess the period immediately preceding the date of
termination. On this ground alone, the impugned finding deserves to be set aside.
He places reliance upon Mohd. Ali v. State of H.P., (2018) 15 SCC 641,
contending that for the purposes of Section 25-B(2) of the Act, the computation of
240 days must be made by reckoning the 12 calendar months immediately
preceding the date of termination, and not with reference to any other anterior or
arbitrary year.
17.
Lastly, it is submitted by the counsel for the Petitioner that, assuming
without admitting that the Respondent were to succeed on merits, the question of
appropriate relief would then arise for consideration. The termination in the present
case dates back to the year 2003 and, as on date, nearly 23 years have elapsed. The
Respondent was admittedly engaged as a PTS/Daftari on daily wages and, as per
his own case, was earning approximately Rs. 970/- per month at the relevant time,
in view of the considerable lapse of time, the purely temporary and casual nature of
the engagement, and the fact that the Respondent is now approximately 55–58
years of age and thus in close proximity to the age of superannuation, the grant of
reinstatement would neither be practical nor equitable.
18.
Accordingly, it is prayed by the Petitioner that even if this Court were to
return a finding against the management on other issues, the only just and
appropriate relief, if any, would be the award of lump-sum monetary compensation
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
in lieu of reinstatement and back wages, and not an order directing reinstatement
with consequential benefits. In support of the said contention counsel has relied
upon the decisions of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in B.S.N.L. v. Bhurumal, (2014)
7 SCC 177 in which the Supreme Court held that even where termination is found
to be in violation of Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
reinstatement with back wages is not automatic; compensation in lieu of
reinstatement may be appropriate, particularly in cases of short-term or daily-wage
employment. Similarly, in Jasmer Singh v. State of Rajasthan, (2015) 4 SCC 458
the Supreme Court reiterated that relief must be moulded based on the facts and
circumstances of each case, and that long lapse of time or irregular appointment
may justify awarding monetary compensation instead of directing reinstatement.
19.
In contradistinction, ld. counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondents
made an attempt to sustain the finding(s) which have been arrived at by learned
CGIT by urging that burden to disprove completion of 240 days of continuous
service lay upon the Petitioner/Bank and not upon the workman as the workman
had duly discharged the burden of proving completion of 240 days of continuous
service in the twelve months preceding the date of termination. It was contended
that, in the counter-affidavit filed before the CGIT, the Branch Manager of the
Petitioner/Bank had himself admitted that the Respondent had continuously
worked for more than 240 days. In view of such a categorical admission, the
burden stood shifted upon the Petitioner-Bank to establish to the contrary, which it
failed to do.
20.
It was further submitted that the Respondent was paid arrears amounting to
₹16,759/- by the management pursuant to a bi-partite settlement on account of
short payment made to the workman from 1997 to 2001. According to learned
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
counsel for respondent, such payment unequivocally establishes the existence of an
employer–employee relationship between the Respondent and the Petitioner-Bank.
21.
Additionally, it was also pointed out that during cross-examination, one of
the witnesses examined on behalf of the Petitioner admitted that the Respondent
had worked during his tenure/postings. In addition, various letters exchanged
between the Respondent and the Branch Manager were placed on record, which,
according to learned counsel, clearly demonstrate that the Respondent was engaged
in the services of the Petitioner/Bank. Counsel for the respondent also goes on to
submit that the Branch Manager of Punjab and Sindh Bank Branch, Masoorie had
written letter to Zonal Manager through which they demanded that there is no Sub
Staff in the Branch and the workman is the only sub staff who is a fit person to be
regularized as Orderly /Daftari etc as per the norms of the bank which is also
specifically mentioned in his claim statement made before the CGIT.
22.
It was further submitted by the counsel for the Respondent that, apart from a
bald assertion in the Written statement that the workman had not completed 240
days of service, there was no specific or categorical denial in the counter affidavit
filed by the Bank before the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital disputing that
the workman was working with the Bank. On the contrary, the counsel for the
Respondent urged that the pleadings disclose an implicit admission of engagement,
moreover, for the period from 1997 to 2003, several communications were
addressed by Branch Managers and other competent authorities of the Bank
acknowledging that the workman had been continuously working with the Bank.
He further contends that even the Branch Managers posted at the Branch
Office, Mussoorie, had addressed communications to the Zonal Office specifically
stating that there was no sanctioned sub-staff available at the Branch and that the
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
Respondent/workman was the only person discharging duties as sub-staff and in
view of the exigencies of work and the continued requirement of his services, it
was recommended that the Respondent/workman be regularized against the said
post.
23.
Learned counsel further contended that the Respondent’s engagement stood
corroborated by attendance records and payment vouchers which were also
produced before ld. CGIT. Additionally, despite specific directions issued by the
Tribunal, the Petitioner-Bank failed to produce the muster rolls and attendance
registers for the relevant period so as to establish the actual number of days the
Respondent/workman has worked. Therefore, in these circumstances, an adverse
inference was liable to be drawn against the management.
24.
Learned counsel for the Respondent concluded his arguments by submitting
that the workman had duly discharged the burden of proving completion of 240
days of continuous service, coupled with the fact that he had worked from 1996 till
2003, before the learned CGIT. It was contended by the Respondent that the
Award records a categorical finding that once the workman had led evidence in
support of his claim, no documentary evidence to the contrary was produced by the
Bank, in view of the matter, the learned CGIT observed that the workman had
produced all possible evidence available to him to establish that he had worked for
240 days in each calendar year which remains unrebutted. Moreover, the Award
further notes that, on the basis of such material, the Branch Manager of the
concerned branch of Punjab & Sind Bank had addressed a communication to the
higher authorities recommending the regularization of the workman. This,
according to the Tribunal, lends support to the plea of continuous engagement.
25.
In addition, counsel for the Respondent submits that it has been recorded
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
that the management failed to produce the relevant muster rolls or attendance
records to rebut the workman’s assertion that he had completed 240 days of service
in each calendar year and relying upon the principles laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in H.D. Singh v. Reserve Bank of India, (1985) 4 SCC 201, the
learned CGIT held that, in the absence of rebuttal evidence from the management,
the workman’s evidence remained uncontroverted and deemed admitted.
Consequently, the provisions of Section 25F of the Act were held to be attracted.
26.
With regard to the judgments relied upon by the Petitioner, namely
Bhurumal (supra) and Mohd. Ali (supra), it was submitted that the reliance
placed thereon is misconceived. It was argued that in Bhurumal(supra), the
Hon’ble Supreme Court did not lay down that reinstatement must invariably be
denied in cases of illegal termination; rather, it recognised that compensation in
lieu of reinstatement may be granted depending upon the facts and circumstances
of a given case. The said decision does not mandate denial of reinstatement where
a clear violation of Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 is established.
27.
Insofar as Mohd. Ali(supra) is concerned, it was submitted that the said
judgment turned on its own peculiar facts, where the workman had failed to
establish completion of 240 days of service in the twelve months preceding
termination, and there was also unexplained delay coupled with circumstances
indicating abandonment of service. In those facts, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
declined reinstatement due to the absence of statutory entitlement under Section
25F of the Act. It was, therefore, contended that the said decision has no
application to the present case, which is governed by materially different facts.
28.
Learned counsel for the Respondent placed reliance upon the recent
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shripal & Anr. v. Nagar Nigam,
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
Ghaziabad, decided on 31 January 2025 in Civil Appeal No. 8157 of 2024,
wherein the legal position has been clarified. It was submitted that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that where there is a violation of mandatory statutory
provisions, including Section 6-N of the U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (which
is pari materia with Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947),
reinstatement with continuity of service and consequential benefits is the normal
rule, and denial thereof would amount to rewarding the employer for an illegal act.
29.
It was further submitted that the said judgment marks a clear departure from
the approach adopted in Bhurumal(supra) where compensation was awarded in
the exercise of extraordinary powers, and categorically holds that reinstatement
with continuity of service and consequential benefits must ordinarily follow where
illegal termination and continuous engagement are conclusively established. The
Respondent also relied upon documentary evidence, including letters issued by the
Petitioner-management, to demonstrate continuous engagement from 1988 to
2003, thereby distinguishing the present case from Mohd. Ali (supra).
30.
Accordingly, it was submitted that the present case is squarely covered by
the ratio laid down in Shripal & Anr.(supra), and that reinstatement with
continuity of service and consequential benefits is the legally justified and
appropriate relief.
DISCUSSION:
31.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties at length and upon perusal of
the material placed on record, it is evident that the controversy lies within a narrow
compass. The principal grievance of the Petitioner is not that the workman was
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
never engaged with the Petitioner/Bank or that he never worked for 240 days at all,
but rather that the workman did not complete 240 days of continuous service in the
preceding year so as to attract the provisions of Section 25F of the Act.
32.
On the other hand, the workman has, since the inception of the dispute,
consistently maintained that he had fulfilled the pre-requisites of Section 25F by
establishing that he had completed the requisite period of continuous service. It is
contended by the Respondent that the said assertion has remained unrebutted, as
the Bank has failed to controvert the same in any manner whatsoever.
33.
The CGIT, after due consideration of the pleadings and the documents
placed on record, answered the reference in favour of the workman and directed
his reinstatement and regularization. It further held that the workman, upon whom
the initial onus lay to establish completion of 240 days of continuous service, had,
to a substantial extent, discharged the said burden. Thereafter, the onus shifted
upon the Petitioner to demonstrate that the workman had not completed the
requisite period so as to attract the protection of Section 25F; however, the
Petitioner failed to discharge the said burden. Consequently, in consonance with
the settled judicial precedents governing the field, the CGIT granted relief in
favour of the workman.
34.
Now adverting to the rival submissions urged on behalf of the parties. The
preliminary objection of the Petitioner/Bank is that the reference suffers from gross
and unexplained delay, the termination having taken place on 11.05.2003 and the
dispute having been raised in the year 2007. It is well settled that the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 does not prescribe any period of limitation for raising an
industrial dispute. Though delay and laches may, in appropriate cases, be a relevant
consideration while moulding relief, mere delay by itself does not render the
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
reference incompetent, particularly where the relationship of employment and the
legality of termination are in issue. Also, mere passage of time does not validate an
otherwise illegal refusal of employment nor does it extinguish statutory rights
under the Industrial Dispute act. It would be apposite to mention that where the
illegality goes to the root of the employer’s action, the wrong partakes the
character of a continuing one until lawfully remedied. The appropriate
Government, being satisfied that an industrial dispute existed or was apprehended,
made the reference under Section 10 of the Act. The validity of such administrative
satisfaction cannot be lightly interfered with unless shown to be perverse or mala
fide, which does not seem to be the case here.
35.
Reliance can be placed upon the decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in
Ajaib Singh v. Sirhind Coop. Marketing-cum-Processing Service Society Ltd.,
(1999) 6 SCC 82, wherein the Supreme Court held that Article 137 of the
Limitation Act does not apply to proceedings under the Industrial Disputes Act,
and relief cannot be denied merely on the ground of delay unless actual prejudice
is proved. The Court further held that it is not for courts to prescribe a limitation
period where the legislature has consciously omitted one, though relief such as
back wages may be moulded in cases of delay. The relevant paragraph reads as
under:
“10. It follows, therefore, that the provisions of Article 137 of the
Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 are not applicable to the
proceedings under the Act and that the relief under it cannot be denied
to the workman merely on the ground of delay. The plea of delay if
raised by the employer is required to be proved as a matter of fact by
showing the real prejudice and not as a merely hypothetical defence. No
reference to the Labour Court can be generally questioned on the
ground of delay alone. Even in a case where the delay is shown to be
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
existing, the tribunal, labour court or board, dealing with the case can
appropriately mould the relief by declining to grant back wages to the
workman till the date he raised the demand regarding his illegal
retrenchment/termination or dismissal. The court may also in
appropriate cases direct the payment of part of the back wages instead
of full back wages. Reliance of the learned counsel for the respondent
management on the Full Bench judgment of the Punjab and Haryana
High Court in Ram Chander Morya v. State of Haryana [(1999) 1 SCT
141 (P&H) : ILR (1999) 1 P& H 93 (FB)] is also of no help to him. In
that case the High Court nowhere held that the provisions of Article 137
of the Limitation Act were applicable in the proceedings under the Act.
The Court specifically held “neither any limitation has been provided
nor any guidelines to determine as to what shall be the period of
limitation in such cases”. However, it went on further to say that
“reasonable time in the cases of labour for demand of
reference or dispute by appropriate Government to labour
tribunals will be five years after which the Government can refuse
to make a reference on the ground of delay and laches if there is
no explanation to the delay”.
We are of the opinion that the Punjab and Haryana High Court was
not justified in prescribing the limitation for getting the reference made
or an application under Section 33-C of the Act to be adjudicated. It is
not the function of the court to prescribe the limitation where the
legislature in its wisdom had thought it fit not to prescribe any period.
The courts admittedly interpret law and do not make laws. Personal
views of the Judges presiding over the Court cannot be stretched to
authorise them to interpret law in such a manner which would amount to
legislation intentionally left over by the legislature. The judgment of the
Full Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court has completely
ignored the object of the Act and various pronouncements of this Court
as noted hereinabove and thus is not a good law on the point of the
applicability of the period of limitation for the purposes of invoking the
jurisdiction of the courts/boards and tribunal under the Act.”
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
36.
Moreover, the record discloses that the Respondent had earlier approached
judicial fora seeking redress. The fact that the Respondent–Workman was actively
pursuing remedies, albeit before a forum that may not have been strictly
appropriate, clearly demonstrates that he was not indolent or negligent in asserting
his rights. On the contrary, it reflects a bona fide effort on his part to ventilate his
grievance and seek redress through such legal avenues as were available to him. In
these circumstances, the delay of approximately four years cannot be said to be
fatal so as to vitiate the reference itself. The preliminary objection is accordingly
rejected.
37.
Coming to the principal contention of the Petitioner on merits that the
learned CGIT erred in computing 240 days of continuous service on a calendaryear basis instead of with reference to the twelve months immediately preceding
the date of termination, i.e., 12.05.2002 to 11.05.2003.
38.
In order to appreciate the contention advanced by the Petitioner, it would be
apposite to advert to Section 25B of the Act, which defines the expression
“continuous service” as:
“25B. Definition of continuous service.—For the purposes of
this Chapter,—
(1) a workman shall be said to be in continuous service for a
period if he is, for that period, in uninterrupted service, including
service which may be interrupted on account of sickness or
authorised leave or an accident or a strike which is not illegal, or
a lock-out or a cessation of work which is not due to any fault on
the part of the workman;
(2) where a workman is not in continuous service within the
meaning of clause (1) for a period of one year or six months, he
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
shall be deemed to be in continuous service under an employer—
(a) for a period of one year, if the workman, during a period of
twelve calendar months preceding the date with reference to
which calculation is to be made, has actually worked under the
employer for not less than—
(i) one hundred and ninety days in the case of a workman
employed below ground in a mine; and
(ii) two hundred and forty days, in any other case;
(b) for a period of six months, if the workman, during a period of
six calendar months preceding the date with reference to which
calculation is to be made, has actually worked under the
employer for not less than—
(i) ninety-five days, in the case of a workman employed
below ground in a mine; and
(ii) one hundred and twenty days, in any other case.”
39.
There can be no quarrel with the legal proposition that, for the purposes of
Section 25F read with Section 25B of the Act, the relevant period is twelve
calendar months immediately preceding the date of termination. However, the
controversy in the present case is not merely one of the modes of computation, but
whether the Respondent had, in fact, completed 240 days of continuous service in
the relevant period.
40.
The Award records a categorical finding that the workman had led both oral
as well as documentary evidence to establish his engagement from 1996 till 2003.
It further notes that the Branch Manager, in various communications addressed to
the higher authorities, expressly acknowledged that the Respondent/Workman was
working in the Branch and even recommended his regularisation itself. Moreover,
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
arrears amounting to ₹16,759/- were paid to the Respondent pursuant to a bipartite
settlement for the period 1997–2001, thereby unequivocally affirming the
existence of an employer–employee relationship between the parties, say at least
for five years. In addition, thereto, a witness examined on behalf of the
management admitted in cross-examination that the Respondent had worked
during his tenure, which further corroborates the case of the Workman.
41.
Most significantly, the learned CGIT noted that despite specific directions,
the management failed to produce the muster rolls and attendance registers for the
relevant period. In law, the initial burden to assert completion of 240 days lies
upon the workman. However, such a burden is not to be, rather cannot be
discharged by production of documents which are exclusively in the custody of the
employer. Once the workman steps into the witness box, affirms continuous
engagement, produces such material as is available to him, and calls upon the
management to produce statutory records, the onus shifts to the employer itself.
42.
In the present case, the management was in possession of muster rolls,
attendance registers and wage records. No plausible explanation has been offered
for their non-production by the Petitioner/bank. In such circumstances, the learned
CGIT was justified in drawing an adverse inference against the management by
relying upon the principle laid down in H.D. Singh v. Reserve Bank of India,
(1985) 4 SCC 201. The legal position with regard to burden of proof under Section
25-B is well settled. The principle enunciated by Hon’ble the Supreme Court in
H.D. Singh (supra), squarely applies in the present case where the
Respondent/Workman has not only led oral evidence but has also relied upon the
admissions made by the Petitioner/Bank in its counter-affidavit. The PetitionerBank, despite being called upon to do so, has failed to produce the attendance
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
registers, muster rolls, or wage records, all of which were admittedly within its
exclusive control. Therefore, the workman’s evidence cannot be brushed aside.
The relevant extract reads as under:
“Employer's failure to produce the attendance register
to controvert the workman's claim as to the number of
days he had actually worked will lead to an inference
of the correctness of the workman's claim."
43.
The aforesaid principle was further reiterated by the Full Bench of Hon’ble
Apex Court in R.M. Yellatti v. Asstt. Executive Engineer, (2006) 1 SCC 106,
wherein, after considering and relying upon its earlier decisions, in Range Forest
Officer v. S.T. Hadimani (2002) 3 SCC 25; Rajasthan State Ganganagar S. Mills
Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan (2004) 8 SCC 195; M.P. Electricity Board v. Haririam
(2004) 8 SCC 246; Manager, Reserve Bank of India v. S. Mani (2005) 5 SCC
100; and Municipal Corporation, Faridabad v. Siri Niwas (2004) 8 SCC 195, the
Supreme Court clarified that strict proof by way of documentary evidence is not
invariably possible for a workman. It was held that oral evidence adduced by the
workman, coupled with the non-production of relevant records by the employer,
would be sufficient to discharge the initial burden of establishing completion of
240 days of continuous service. The relevant extract reads as under:
“17. Analysing the above decisions of this Court, it is
clear that the provisions of the Evidence Act in terms
do not apply to the proceedings under Section 10 of the
Industrial Disputes Act. However, applying general
principles and on reading the aforestated judgments,
we find that this Court has repeatedly taken the view
that the burden of proof is on the claimant to show that
he had worked for 240 days in a given year. This
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
burden is discharged only upon the workman stepping
in the witness box. This burden is discharged upon the
workman adducing cogent evidence, both oral and
documentary. In cases of termination of services of
daily-waged earners, there will be no letter of
appointment or termination. There will also be no
receipt or proof of payment. Thus in most cases, the
workman (the claimant) can only call upon the
employer to produce before the court the nominal
muster roll for the given period, the letter of
appointment or termination, if any, the wage register,
the attendance register, etc.
18. Now applying the above decision to the facts of the
present case, we find that the workman herein had
stepped into the witness box. He had called upon the
management to produce the nominal muster rolls for
the period commencing from 22-11-1988 to 20-6-1994.
This period is the period borne out by the certificate
(Ext. W-1) issued by the former Assistant Executive
Engineer. The evidence in rebuttal from the side of the
management needs to be noticed. The management
produced five nominal muster rolls (NMRs), out of
which 3 NMRs, Exts. M-1, M-2 and M-3, did not even
relate to the period concerned. The relevant NMRs
produced by the management were Exts. M-4 and M-5,
which indicated that the workmen had worked for 43
days during the period 21-1-1994 to 20-2-1994 and
21-3-1994 to 20-4-1994 respectively. There is no
explanation from the side of the management as to why
for the remaining period the nominal muster rolls were
not produced. The Labour Court has rightly held that
there is nothing to disbelieve the certificate (Ext. W-1).
The High Court in its impugned judgment has not
given reasons for discarding the said certificate. In the
circumstances, we are of the view that the Division
Bench of the High Court ought not to have interfered
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
with the concurrent findings of fact recorded by the
Labour Court and confirmed by the learned Single
Judge vide order dated 7-6-2000 in Writ Petition No.
17636 of 2000. This is not, therefore, a case where the
allegations of the workman are founded merely on an
affidavit. He has produced cogent evidence in support
of his case. The workman was working in SD-1, Athani
and Ext. W-1 was issued by the former Assistant
Executive Engineer, Hipparagi Dam Construction
Division No. 1, Athani 591 304. In the present case, the
defence of the management was that although Ext. W-1
refers to the period 22-11-1988 to 20-6-1994, the
workman had not worked as a daily-wager on all days
during that period. If so, the management was dutybound to produce before the Labour Court the nominal
muster rolls for the relevant period, particularly when
it was summoned to do so. We are not placing this
judgment on the shifting of the burden. We are not
placing this case on drawing of adverse inference. In
the present case, we are of the view that the workman
had stepped in the witness box and his case that he had
worked for 240 days in a given year was supported by
the certificate (Ext. W-1). In the circumstances, the
Division Bench of the High Court had erred in
interfering with the concurrent findings of fact.”
[emphasis applied]
44.
The contention of the Petitioner that the finding is vitiated on account of
computation on a calendar-year basis does not persuade this Court. The Award,
read as a whole, indicates that the Tribunal was satisfied about the continuous
nature of engagement till the date of termination. The existence of uninterrupted
engagement from 1996 to 2003, supported by admissions and documentary
communications, clearly encompasses the twelve months preceding 11.05.2003.
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
The Petitioner has not produced any material to demonstrate that during
12.05.2002 to 11.05.2003 the Respondent had not completed 240 days the onus to
prove which was entirely upon the Bank as can be seen from above judicial
precedents.
45.
Thus, the finding that the Respondent had completed 240 days of continuous
service in the twelve months preceding termination does not suffer from perversity
or patent illegality warranting interference under Article 226/227.
46.
The reliance placed by the Petitioner on the order dated 22.08.1997
pertaining to the period 1988–1992 is not relevant as the present dispute relates to
a subsequent period, i.e., 1996–2003. Even if the workman had not completed 240
days in an earlier spell, that circumstance has no determinative bearing on his
status during the later period. Each alleged termination and each spell of
employment must be examined on its own facts. The earlier order declining
reference cannot operate as res judicata nor can it dilute the evidence relating to
the later engagement.
47.
To properly examine the contention raised by the Petitioner that the
Respondent was engaged as a PTS/Daftari on daily wages therefore is not entitled
to the benefit of Section 25F of the Act, it is necessary to refer to Section 25F of
the Act, which sets out the pre-requisites of retrenchment, it reads as follows:
“25F. Conditions precedent to retrenchment of
workmen.—No workman employed in any industry
who has been in continuous service for not less than
one year under an employer shall be retrenched by that
employer until—
(a) the workman has been given one month’s notice in
writing indicating the reasons for retrenchment and the
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
period of notice has expired, or the workman has been
paid in lieu of such notice, wages for the period of the
notice;
(b) the workman has been paid, at the time of
retrenchment, compensation which shall be equivalent
to fifteen days' average pay 2 [for every completed
year of continuous service] or any part thereof in
excess of six months; and
(c) notice in the prescribed manner is served on the
appropriate Government 3 [or such authority as may
be specified by the appropriate Government by
notification in the Official Gazette]”
48.
Section 25F of the Act prescribes the mandatory conditions precedent to
retrenchment of a workman who has completed at least one year of continuous
service, conferring a statutory right upon every such workman irrespective of the
nature or capacity of his employment. It obligates the employer to issue one
month’s notice (or wages in lieu thereof), pay retrenchment compensation
equivalent to fifteen days’ average pay for every completed year of service (or part
thereof exceeding six months).
49.
The Petitioner has sought to emphasise that the Respondent was engaged
merely as a PTS/Daftari on a daily-wage basis. However, the provisions of the Act
do not carve out any exception in respect of casual, temporary or daily-rated
employees; once such a workman satisfies the statutory requirement of completing
240 days of continuous service, the protection envisaged under Section 25F
becomes equally applicable. The determinative test is not the nomenclature of
employment but whether the workman was in continuous service as defined under
Section 25B. The nature of the initial appointment, therefore, becomes wholly
irrelevant once the statutory threshold is met.
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
50.
Moreover, it is also an admitted position that no notice, notice pay, or
retrenchment compensation, as contemplated under Section 25F of the Act, was
paid to the Respondent prior to or at the time of termination. Further, the materials
relied upon by the CGIT including communications recommending regularisation
and acknowledgment of the Respondent being the only sub-staff in the branch
negate the plea of purely intermittent or sporadic engagement. Accordingly, the
Bank has acted in clear contravention of the mandatory provisions of Section 25F
of the Act, thereby infringing the statutory rights and lawful entitlement of the
workman.
51.
Lastly, counsel for the Petitioner urged that, in view of the lapse of time and
the age of the workman, reinstatement would be inequitable and that compensation
alone may be granted. While it is true that reinstatement is not an automatic
consequence in every case of illegal retrenchment, relief in industrial adjudication
must be moulded having regard to the totality of circumstances, including the
length of service, nature of employment, passage of time, supervening
developments and the practical feasibility of restoring the employer-employee
relationship. The facts of the present case disclose that the termination was effected
without compliance with Section 25F of the Act, the engagement was not for a
short or fixed-term project but extended over several years (1996–2003) and the
workman was continuously discharging duties akin to sub-staff, and his
regularisation was recommended by the Branch Manager.
52.
It is also a settled position of law that reinstatement cannot be a natural
consequence if the termination is found to be in contravention of provisions of
Section 25F of the ID Act. In Telecom District Manager and Ors. Vs. Keshab Deb
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
(2008) 8 SCC 402 the Apex court has held as under:—
“27. Even if the provisions of Section 25F of the
Industrial Disputes Act had not been complied with,
respondent was only entitled to be paid a just
compensation. While, however, determining the
amount of compensation we must also take into
consideration the stand taken by the appellants. They
took not only an unreasonable stand but raised a
contention in regard to absence of jurisdiction in the
Tribunal. They admittedly did not comply with the
order passed by the Tribunal for a long time. It had
raised contention which are not otherwise tenable.”
53.
In Bhurumal (supra), Hon’ble the Supreme Court held that even where
termination is found to be in violation of Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes
Act, 1947, reinstatement with back wages is not automatic; compensation in lieu of
reinstatement may be appropriate, particularly in cases of short-term or daily-wage
employment which reads as under:—
“33. It is clear from the reading of the aforesaid
judgments that the ordinary principle of grant of
reinstatement with full back wages, when the
termination is found to be illegal is not applied
mechanically in all cases. While that may be a position
where services of a regular/permanent workman are
terminated illegally and/or malafide and/or by way of
victimization, unfair labour practice etc. However,
when it comes to the case of termination of a daily
wage worker and where the termination is found
illegal because of procedural defect, namely in
violation of Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act,
this Court is consistent in taking the view in such cases
reinstatement with back wages is not automatic and
instead the workman should be given monetary
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
compensation which will meet the ends of justice.
Rationale for shifting in this direction is obvious.”
54.
Reliance can also be placed upon the judgment of Jagbir Singh vs. Haryana
State Agriculture Marketing (2009) 15 SCC 327, in which the Hon’ble Apex
Court dealt with similar issues and held that:
“7. It is true that earlier view of this Court articulated
in many decisions reflected the legal position that if the
termination of all employee was found to be illegal, the
relief of reinstatement with full back wages would
ordinarily follow. However, in recent past, there has
been a shift in the legal position and in long line of
cases, this Court has consistently taken the view that
relief by way of reinstatement with back wages is not
automatic and may be wholly inappropriate in a given
fact situation even though the termination of an
employee is in contravention to the prescribed
procedure. Compensation instead of reinstatement has
been held to meet the ends of justice.
14. It would be, thus, seen that by a catena of
decisions in recent time, this Court has clearly laid
down that an order of retrenchment if passed in
violation of Section 25-F although may be set aside but
an award of reinstatement should not, however, be
automatically passed. The award of reinstatement with
full back wages in a case where the workman has
completed 240 days of work in a year preceding the
date of termination, particularly, daily wagers has not
been found to be proper by this Court and instead
compensation has been awarded. This Court has
distinguished between a daily wager who does not hold
a post and a permanent employee.
17. While awarding compensation, the host of factors,
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
interalia, matter and method of appointment, nature of
employment and length of service are relevant. Of
course, each case will depend upon its own facts and
circumstances.”
55.
As is evident in the present case, the refusal of employment dates back more
than two decades, the workman is close to the age of superannuation, reinstatement
at this belated stage would serve no useful purpose. Accordingly, while upholding
the impugned Award on merits insofar as it records a categorical finding of illegal
refusal of employment, the relief of reinstatement is modified and substituted with
payment of lump-sum monetary compensation. This modification reflects a
pragmatic and equitable calibration of relief and does not in any manner dilute,
efface, or reopen the finding of illegality recorded against the management, which
remains intact and undisturbed.
56.
The aforesaid course is fully consistent with the settled principle that relief
under Article 226 of the Constitution is discretionary, flexible, and capable of
being moulded to subserve the ends of justice. A Constitution Bench of Hon’ble
the Supreme Court in Charanjit Lal vs. Union of India, AIR 1951 SC 41 held that
a petition under Article 226 should not be thrown away merely on the ground that
proper relief is not asked for. Thus, under Article 226 relief can be granted by the
Court even by moulding the relief, if justice so requires. The substitution of
reinstatement with monetary compensation in the present case is thus not a
reassessment of culpability, but a judicious balancing of equities in light of
supervening circumstances.
57.
The ancillary issue that arises for consideration is the quantum of lump-sum
compensation which is required to be paid to the Respondents/Workman. If
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
Petitioner/Bank was to follow provisions of Section 25F of the ID Act,
Respondents would have received retrenchment compensation and one month's
notice or pay in lieu thereof.
58.
At this stage, it is apposite to refer to the decision of the Supreme Court in
Amit Kumar Dubey v. M.P.P.K.V.V. Co. Ltd. &Anr. (Civil Appeal arising out of
SLP (C) No. 20902/2024 and connected matters, decided on 29 January 2025),
which lays down clear guidelines for determination of the quantum of
compensation in cases where reinstatement is substituted with monetary relief.
Herein, the Apex Court has categorically held that compensation cannot be
nominal, uniform, or arbitrary, and must bear a direct nexus with the length of
service rendered by the workman. It was emphasised that a blanket award of
compensation, without regard to the duration of employment, would violate the
principle of proportionality. The relevant part of the judgment is extracted here
under“9. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the
matters, we deem it fit to enhance the compensation
granted to the appellants by the High Court. We hold
that the appellants would be entitled to enhanced
compensation at the rate of Rs. 1.5 lakhs per year for
the period they have worked and in case, they have
worked for a part of the year, then the amount of
compensation is to be calculated at the same rate to be
applied on a pro-rata basis.[...]”
59.
In light of the above principles, as enunciated by the Supreme Court in Amit
Kumar Dubey v. M.P.P.K.V.V. Co. Ltd. & Anr. (supra), this Court deems it fit
and appropriate that the compensation in the present case be awarded in
accordance with the aforesaid parameters, having due regard to the duration of
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
service rendered by the Respondents and the attendant facts and circumstances.
60.
It is also noticed that the learned CGIT, while directing reinstatement, has
also proceeded to grant the relief of regularization of the services of the workman.
Whereas, the reference was only with regard to the termination & compensation to
which the workman is entitled under the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act,
1947. A perusal of the pleadings indicates that no specific prayer whatsoever was
made in the Statement of Claim filed by the workman seeking regularization.
61.
Also, the Reference made to CGIT did not cover the aspect of regularization.
It is further evident that the CGIT also did not frame any specific issue pertaining
to regularization. In absence of reference and framing of issue, CGIT has
erroneously proceeded to adjudicate the issue of regularization. It is a settled law
that the Labour/Industrial Court cannot travel beyond the scope of Reference. In
this regard, it would be useful to make reference to the judgment of the Apex Court
in Tata Iron and Steel Company Ltd. (2014) 1 SCC 536, the relevant para reads as
under:
“16. The Industrial Tribunal/Labour Court constituted
under the Industrial Disputes Act is a creature of that
statute. It acquires jurisdiction on the basis of
reference made to it. The Tribunal has to confine itself
within the scope of the subject-matter of reference and
cannot travel beyond the same. This is the view taken
by this Court in a number of cases including in
National Engg. Industries Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan. It
is for this reason that it becomes the bounden duty of
the appropriate Government to make the reference
appropriately which is reflective of the real/exact
nature of "dispute" between the parties.”
62.
Reliance can also be placed upon the decision rendered by the Full Bench of
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in Hochtief Gammon v. Industrial Tribunal, AIR
1964 SC 1746, which deals with the jurisdiction a tribunal exercises while
answering a reference. The relevant portion is extracted below:
“7. In dealing with this question, it is necessary to bear
in mind one essential fact, and that is that the
Industrial Tribunal is a Tribunal of limited
jurisdiction. Its jurisdiction is to try an industrial
dispute referred to it for its adjudication by the
appropriate Government by an order of reference
passed under Section 10. It is not open to the Tribunal
to travel materially beyond the terms of reference, for
it is well-settled that the terms of reference determine
the scope of its power and jurisdiction from case to
case. Section 10 itself has been subsequently amended
from time to time. Act 18 of 1952 made substantial
amendments in Section 10. One of these amendments
was that Section 10(1)(d) now empowers the
appropriate Government to refer the dispute or any
matter appearing to be connected with, or relevant to,
the dispute, whether it relates to any matter specified in
the Second Schedule, or the Third Schedule, to a
Tribunal for adjudication. In other words under
Section 10(1)(d). The appropriate Government can
refer to he Industrial Tribunal not only a specific
industrial dispute, but can also refer along with it
matters appearing to be connected with, or relevant to,
the said dispute. In that sense the power of the
appropriate Government has been enlarged in regard
to the reference of industrial disputes to the Tribunal.
[emphasis applied]
63.
In Pottery Mazdoor Panchayat v. Perfect Pottery Co. Ltd., (1979) 3 SCC
762, Hon’ble the Supreme Court held that an Industrial Tribunal’s jurisdiction is
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
strictly confined to the terms of reference and it cannot travel beyond them to
adjudicate issues not referred. Where the reference is limited to examining the
propriety or justification of a closure, the Tribunal has no authority to question the
factum of closure itself. Likewise, in the case at hand, the reference was confined
only to the question of termination and the entitlement, if any, to retrenchment
compensation. Therefore, the CGIT ought not to have, on its own motion, ventured
to grant the relief of regularisation, which was beyond the scope of the reference.
64.
A co-ordinate Bench of Madhya Pradesh High court in Birla Corporation
Ltd. v. Deputy Labour Commissioner, 2016 SCC OnLine MP 7995 while
delineating the scope of Industrial Tribunal went on to interpreted the words
‘incidental thereto’ appearing in Section 10(4) of the Act in the following terms:
9. In this regard, we may take note of the provisions of
section 10(4) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,
which contemplates that when an industrial dispute is
referred for adjudication to a Labour Court, Tribunal
or a National Tribunal, on a point specified by the
appropriate Government for adjudication, the Labour
Court or the Tribunal or the National Tribunal as the
case made be, shall confine its adjudication to the
matters referred and the matters incidental thereto.
The words ‘incidental thereto’ appearing in section
10(4), according to the well settled principle of law,
relate to matters which arise for consideration
‘incidentally’ while deciding the dispute, referred for
adjudication. For example - when an industrial dispute
is raised, the Tribunal or the Labour Court while
adjudicating the dispute is required to determine
whether the matter placed before it is infact an
‘Industrial Dispute’, as defined in section 2(k) of the
Industrial Disputes Act; whether the person whose
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
cases are referred for adjudication are ‘workman’ as
defined under section 2(s) of the Act; and, whether the
undertaking where the dispute has arisen is an
‘Industry’ within the meaning of section 2(j); and, such
questions which go to the root of the matter and which
have to be decided as a collateral issue pertaining to
the jurisdiction of the Tribunal.
10. Even though it is a well settled principle of law that
an Industrial Tribunal or a Labour Court while
adjudicating a dispute has no power to vary or alter
the points or issues referred for adjudication, however,
on the basis of pleadings made by the parties, the
Tribunal is entitled to frame certain issues which fall in
the category of ‘incidental issues’ which are either
issues of law or mixed question of law and fact. Such
‘incidental’, ‘additional’ or ‘ancillary issues’ are
required to be determined by the Tribunal as they
pertain to the jurisdictional question and are normally
required to be decided as a preliminary issue. If the
issue goes to the root of the matter and is an issue or
an objection pertaining to the maintainability of the
Industrial Dispute referred for adjudication or the
jurisdiction of the Tribunal itself, the Tribunal is well
within its right to go into this question as an
‘incidental issue’ and decide it as a preliminary issue.
If the Tribunal on such examination comes to the
conclusion that it has no jurisdiction, the Tribunal is
free to reject the reference.
65.
In the present case as well, the CGIT has not conducted any enquiry as to
whether initial engagement of Respondents was made on regularly sanctioned
posts or not. The relief of regularization cannot be granted in services of the Bank
merely on completion of 240 days of service. There is a difference between
directing permanency in a private establishment on completion of 240 days of
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
service and directing regularisation in services of a State Instrumentality.
Therefore, the scheme for conferment of benefit of permanency on completion of
240 days of service needs to be harmoniously construed with the law laid down by
the Constitution Bench of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in Secretary, State of
Karnataka vs. Uma Devi (2006) 4 SCC 1 especially when it comes to granting
regularisation in services in a State instrumentality. The relevant extracts reads as
under:
“47. When a person enters a temporary employment or
gets engagement as a contractual or casual worker and
the engagement is not based on a proper selection as
recognised by the relevant rules or procedure, he is
aware of the consequences of the appointment being
temporary, casual or contractual in nature. Such a
person cannot invoke the theory of legitimate
expectation for being confirmed in the post when an
appointment to the post could be made only by
following a proper procedure for selection and in
cases concerned, in consultation with the Public
Service Commission. Therefore, the theory of
legitimate expectation cannot be successfully advanced
by temporary, contractual or casual employees. It
cannot also be held that the State has held out any
promise while engaging these persons either to
continue them where they are or to make them
permanent. The State cannot constitutionally make
such a promise. It is also obvious that the theory
cannot be invoked to seek a positive relief of being
made permanent in the post.”
66.
In view of this court, therefore the direction of CGIT for regularisation of
services of Respondents is unsustainable. The direction is issued by traveling
outside the scope of Reference and without even framing an issue. Even on merits,
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
the direction is otherwise unsustainable. The jurisdiction of the CGIT is
circumscribed by the terms of reference made to it by the Conciliation Officer
under Section 10 of the Act, 1947. The relief of regularization was neither
specifically sought nor formed part of the reference for adjudication. In
adjudicating an industrial dispute, the CGIT is bound by the scope of the reference
and cannot travel beyond it.
67.
It is apposite to mention that the Tribunal does not exercise Writ jurisdiction
so as to mould reliefs dehors the pleadings or grant benefits not contemplated
within the reference. Accordingly, the direction relating to regularization of the
workman’s services is held to be beyond jurisdiction and is set aside as being ultra
vires as the engagement was made in an informal manner without subjecting the
workman to any selection process.
68.
Accordingly, the following directions are passed:
i. The Impugned Award is partly quashed and partly modified. The award
regarding illegal termination of service of Respondent/Workman is upheld. But
the award regarding regularization is quashed. As regards the award relating to
the relief of reinstatement, the same is modified to the extent that, in lieu of
reinstatement, the workman shall be entitled to a consolidated sum of
compensation;
ii. Petitioner
shall
pay
to
the
Respondent/Workman
a
consolidated
compensation of Rs.11,00,000/- (Rupees Eleven Lakhs only) within a period of
three months from the date of this Order. In the event of default, the said
amount shall carry interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of default
until the date of actual payment to the Respondent/Workman. Further, payment,
if any, made to the Respondent/workman under Section 17B of the Act shall be
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
set off while calculating the final amount to be paid and;
iii. The relief regarding regularization as Orderly/Daftari is set aside.
69.
In the aforesaid terms, the Writ Petition along with pending application(s), if
any, stand disposed of. No order as to cost(s).
SHAIL JAIN
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 27, 2026
H.P.
W.P.(C) 6918/2014
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
16:42:11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review