The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. Accordingly, this Court finds no reason to interfere with the well- reasoned Order passed by the learned Single Judge, which warrants to be upheld.
19. This court affirms that the finding of the learned Single Judge is correct, based on a proper appreciation of the regulatory framework, and deserves to be upheld in its entirety.
20. Resultantly, the present Appeal is dismissed along with pending application(s), if any.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 7th JANUARY, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
+
LPA 421/2025 & CM APPL. 38924/2025, CM APPL. 38926/2025,
CM APPL. 38927/2025
PUNJAB AND SIND BANK
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Kittu Bajaj, Advocate
versus
AMARJIT SINGH
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Puneet K. Verma, Advocate
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIMAL KUMAR YADAV
JUDGMENT
SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J.
1.
The present Appeal has been filed on behalf of the Appellant against
the Impugned Judgment dated 21.10.2024, passed by the learned Single
Judge of this Court in W.P. (C) 1289/2015, allowing the Writ Petition filed
by the Respondent herein assailing the charge-sheet dated 12.09.2009 and
Order dated 02.02.2013, by which a penalty of withholding of pension to the
extent of Rs.12,000/- per month for a period of 15 years was imposed on the
Respondent herein. In the Writ Petition, the Respondent herein had also
challenged the Order dated 22.04.2013 by which the Appellate Authority
dismissed the Appeal filed by the Respondent herein against the penalty
Order dated 02.02.2013.
2.
Shorn of the unnecessary details, the facts leading to the present
Appeal are:
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
a)
The Respondent was the Chief Manager of the Appellant Bank
when he sought and was granted voluntary retirement after
rendering a service of 34 years and 7 months in different
positions and at different places in the Appellant Bank, and
consequent thereto, he was relieved on 24.07.2008.
b)
On 15.07.2009, after over one year of retirement, a charge-sheet
was issued against the Respondent, which was challenged by
him in this Court on several grounds in Writ Petitioner being
W.P. (C) 10968.2009 and the Petition was allowed on
21.11.2013, against which the Appeal filed by the Appellant
Bank is pending.
c)
Thereafter, another charge-sheet was issued on 12.09.2009,
pursuant to which the disciplinary proceedings were initiated
and the Inquiry Officer („IO‟) tendered his Report dated
27.10.2011 with a finding that the charges were proved against
the Respondent.
d)
Further, the Petitioner submitted his Representation against the
Report on 02.12.2011.
e)
Thereafter, the Chairman and Managing Director („CMD‟)
passed an Order on 02.02.2013 imposing the penalty of
withholding of pension to the extent of Rs.12,000/- per month
for 15 years but without ascertaining any alleged loss caused to
the Appellant Bank.
f)
Thereafter, the Appellant filed an Appeal before the Board of
Directors („BOD‟) on 22.04.2013, which was duly rejected by a
non-speaking Order on 25.11.2013 and subsequently, the
Review Petitions filed on 26.02.2014 and 10.05.2014 suffered
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
the same fate and were rejected on 02.06.2014 on the ground
that there was no provision to review the Order of the Appellate
Authority.
g)
Thereafter, the Petitioner filed an Application under the Right to
Information Act, 2005 („RTI Act‟) to which a response was
received on 16.06.2014 that the alleged loss suffered by the
Appellant Bank was yet to be assessed. Further, vide Letter
dated 07.08.2014, the Petitioner was informed that loss of more
than Rs.20,00,00,000/- had been recovered by the Appellant
Bank from Whitefield International Private Limited after filing
a suit of recovery.
h)
It is these Orders being charge-sheet dated 12.09.2009, Penalty
Order dated 02.02.2013 and Order dated 25.11.2013 (by which
the Appellate Authority dismissed the Appeal dated 22.04.2013)
which were challenged in the W.P. (C) 1289/2015, which was
allowed by the learned Single Judge vide Judgment dated
21.10.2024.
i)
It is this Judgment dated 21.10.2024 passed by the learned
Single Judge which is under challenge in the present Appeal.
3.
The question before this Court in the present Appeal is whether (i) a
charge-sheet issued by the General Manager of the Appellant Bank being the
Disciplinary Authority envisaged under the Punjab & Sind Bank Officer
Employees‟ (Discipline and Appeal) Regulations, 1981 (“Discipline and
Appeal Regulations”) after the retirement of an employee of the Appellant
Bank, is valid, legal and within the jurisdiction of the Appellant Bank and
subsequently the penalty order withholding the pension of the Appellant has
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
been imposed by the Competent Authority or by an Authority subordinate to
the Competent Authority.
4.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant submitted that Disciplinary
Authority as defined under the service rules, is empowered to initiate
proceedings, and only the Competent Authority can award penalties under
the Punjab & Sind Bank Employees‟ Pension Regulations 1995 (“Pension
Regulations”). He further submitted that the argument that only the
Competent Authority can issue a charge-sheet to a retired employee is
legally untenable and that the issuance of the charge-sheet is merely a
procedural trigger and is not a punitive act which can be issued by any
authority empowered to initiate disciplinary action, including the
Disciplinary Authority or other designated official.
5.
He also submits that charge-sheet is merely an intimation of
allegations and initiation of inquiry. Further, the Competent Authority‟s role
only arises at the stage of awarding punishment, if any, after following the
due process. He also submitted that courts have upheld the validity of postretirement disciplinary proceedings initiated by appropriate authorities. He
states what actually matters is whether the authority was empowered under
the applicable rules to initiate such proceeding.
6.
Learned Counsel for the Appellant further contended that under the
Discipline & Appeal Regulations, General Manager was competent to issue
the charge-sheet to the Respondent herein. He also contended that issuing a
charge-sheet is a procedural act, not a punitive one – that it only initiates
inquiry and does not require the authority to be the Competent Authority to
pass the order of penalty.
7.
Per contra learned Counsel for the Respondent submitted that since
the Respondent herein had retired, only the Pension Regulations are
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
applicable on the Respondent and in the case of Disciplinary Inquiry, only
the procedure (Regulation 6) in the Discipline & Appeal regulations would
be applicable and hence, there is only a limited application of Discipline &
Appeal regulations to a retired employee.
8.
Learned Counsel for the Respondent placed reliance on Regulation 45
of Pension Regulations. The same is being reproduced hereinbelow for ease
of reference of:
9.
“45. Pension guilty of grave misconduct
In a case not falling under regulation 44 if the
Competent Authority considers that the pensioner is
prima facie guilty of grave misconduct, it shall, before
passing an order, follow the procedure specified in
Punjab & Sind Bank Officer Employees’ (Discipline &
Appeal) Regulations, 1982 or in Settlement as the case
may be.”
He contended that the said Regulation clearly stipulates that the
Competent Authority can only issue the charge sheet as the procedure of
inquiry undoubtedly included issuance of charge-sheet and it is also trite law
that inquiry would be deemed to be instituted only from the issuance of
charge-sheet. Further, there is no provision of delegation of power in the
Pension Regulations, hence, it is only the Competent Authority which can
issue the charge-sheet.
10.
He further submitted that the Pension Regulations do not confer any
power upon the Competent Authority to act as a Disciplinary Authority. He
also contended that the CMD of the Appellant Bank had issued the
punishment Order dated 02.02.2013 as Disciplinary Authority and as the
Competent Authority, whereas, the General Manager had already issued the
charge-sheet as Disciplinary Authority.
11.
Heard learned counsels for the parties and examined their contentions.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
12.
At this juncture, it is apposite to look into the Circular bearing
No.2374 dated 20.12.1995 issued by the Appellant Bank. The same is being
reproduced hereinbelow for ease of reference:
“
ANNEXURE......
PUNJAB & SIND BANK
(A Government of India Undertaking)
From
H.O. PROVIDENT FUND DEPTT
SAFDARJUNG ENCLAVE
NEW DELHI - 110029
Staff Circular No. 2374
To
All Branches/
Controlling offices
Dated: 20.12.1995
All Branches / Controlling Offices.
Reg: Punjab & Sind Bank (Employees')
Pension Regulations, 1995
In terms of the Punjab & Sind Bank Pension (Employees') Regulations, 1995
the following Competent / Appellate Authorities have been appointed by the
Board of Directors of the Bank:S.No. Category of Staff
Competent Authority
1.
Award Staff posted in Zonal Manager
Branches and Zonal
Offices
2.
Award Staff posted in
Head Office Deptts.
3.
Officers in Scale I, II
and III
Appellate
Authority
DGM (P)
DGM (P)
GM (P)
DGM (P)
GM (P)
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
4.
Officers in Scale IV and
above
CMD
Board of
Directors
This is for the Information of all the staff members.”
13.
The Circular, admittedly governs the field. The Circular clearly
stipulates that in case of officers in Scale-IV and above, the Competent
Authority is the CMD, while the Board of Directors is the Appellate
Authority. In view thereof, the learned Single Judge has rightly concluded
that no Authority other than the CMD has the jurisdiction to issue the
charge-sheet, and certainly not a subordinate officer such as the General
Manager. The finding that the charge-sheet, having been issued by an
authority not competent to issue the charge-sheet, was illegal and without
jurisdiction is based on a correct and sound appreciation of the factual and
legal position.
14.
A bare perusal of the above-mentioned Circular indicates that under
the Pension Regulations, the Appellant Bank had issued the said Circular
prescribing the Competent Authority which has the power and jurisdiction to
initiate proceedings and pass Order under Regulation 43. For ready
reference Regulation 43 is reproduced hereinbelow:
“43. Withholding or withdrawal of pension
The Competent authority may, by order in writing, withhold or
withdraw a pension or a part thereof, whether permanently or
for a specified period, if the pensioner is convicted of a serious
crime or criminal breach of trust or forgery or acting
fraudulently or is found guilty of grave misconduct:
Provided that where a part of pension is withheld or
withdrawn the amount of such pension shall not be reduced
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
below the minimum pension per mensem payable under these
regulations.”
15.
A plain reading of Regulation 43 makes it clear as day that it is only
the „Competent Authority‟ which has the power to withhold or withdraw
pension or a part thereof of a pensioner if he is guilty of a serious crime or
any grave misconduct and it needs no reiteration that the Appellant Bank
itself understands the difference between a „Disciplinary Authority‟ and
„Competent Authority‟ and that is why the two Regulations have separately
described these Authorities, one in the context of disciplinary proceedings
when an employee is in service and one in the context of Pension
Regulations, when an employee has retired and is in receipt of pension,
provisional or regular. Since only the Competent Authority can exercise
powers under Regulation 43 and in the instant case, the charge-sheet has not
been issued by the Competent Authority, the same being without
jurisdiction, further proceedings thereto automatically stand vitiated.
16.
The finding of the learned Single Judge that the power to withhold or
withdraw pension under Regulation 43 can be exercised only by the
Competent Authority i.e., the CMD, and not by any subordinate authority,
does not warrant interference. Once the Pension Regulations occupy the
field with respect to retired employees, the Discipline & Appeal Regulations
applicable to serving employees cannot be utilized to justify any action
taken against the pensioner.
17.
The learned Single Judge has rightly held that Regulation 45 merely
incorporates the procedure prescribed in the Discipline & Appeal
Regulations for conducting an inquiry, but does not confer any substantive
power upon the Disciplinary Authority to initiate such proceedings against a
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
retired employee. The Appellant herein has failed to point out any provision
empowering the Disciplinary Authority to act against a retired officer, the
conclusion that the charge-sheet was issued without jurisdiction is fully
justified.
18.
Accordingly, this Court finds no reason to interfere with the well-
reasoned Order passed by the learned Single Judge, which warrants to be
upheld.
19.
This court affirms that the finding of the learned Single Judge is
correct, based on a proper appreciation of the regulatory framework, and
deserves to be upheld in its entirety.
20.
Resultantly, the present Appeal is dismissed along with pending
application(s), if any.
SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J
JANUARY 07, 2026
JR
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 421/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review