Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3514 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF OCTOBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
SMT
THE HONOURABLE
WRIT PETITI ON NO: 25151 0F 2026
Between:
Pulamoni Srinivasaulu, S/o P. Narasimha Aged aboul 42 years' Occ'
l.iorarian, offlce of the ESIC Medical College and Hospital, No 7-2.108714'
Raja Rajeshwari Nagar, B.K. Guda, Sanath Nagar, Hyderabad - 500038'
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Union of lndia,, Rep. by its Secretary, Ministry of Labour and Employment'
Central Secretariat, New Delhi - 110001 .
2. The Chairman,, National Medical Commission, Pocket - 14' Sector - 8'
Dwarka Phase - 1, New Delhi - 110077.
3. The Director General,, Employees State lnsurance Corporation, Headquarters
Office, Panchdeep Bhawan, C.l.G. Marg, New Delhi - 110002'
4.TheRegionalDirector"RegionalOffice,ESlC,HillfortRoad'Adarshnagar'
Hyderabad - 500063.
5'TheDean/Medicalsuperintendent,,EslCMedicalCollegeandHospital'
Sanathnagar, S.R. Nagar' Hyderabad - 500038'
6.TheAssistantDirector/JointDirector(Admin),,ESICMedicalCollegeand
Hospital, Sanathnagar' S.R. Nagar' Hyderabad - 500038'
7. The Central Administrative Tribunal,, Hyderabad Bench, Rep. by its Registrar,
No.5-10-193, 1st Floor, HACA Bhavan, Hyderabad - 500004'
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Nlicle 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
may be pleased
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court
to issue a wdt of certiorari, or any other appropriate writ, order or direction,
calling
for the records relating to and setting aside the order dated 30.04.2026 passed by
the 7th Respondent Tribunal in ltem No.3, Diary No.661/2026 (OASR No.
66112026), whereby the Registry's objection to the numbering/registration of the
Petitioner's Originai Application was sustained and the papers were directed to be
returned without the Petitioner's specific submissions being independently examined
or reasons being assrgned, as being illegal, arbitrary, unreasoned and violative of the
principles of natural justice and Articles 14 and 1 6 of the Constitution of lndia.
consequently quash and set aside the impugned Officer Order No. 1'1 of 2023 issued
vide No. Al77120'22-AdminlMCH-Part(1) dated 09.02.2023, whereby the Petitioner
was tra nsferredi posted from the post of Chief Librarian/Librarian to the Nursing
Station as Nursing Orderly, as arbitrary, illegal, without authority, violative of MCI
Norms, without jurisdiction, violative of Articles '14 and 16 of the Constitution of lndia,
and violative of the principles of natural justice.
l.A. NO: 2OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay the
operation and implementation of the impugned Officer Order A 17712022-AdminlMCH-
Part (1) dated 09.02.2023 consequently directing the Respondents to permit the
Petitioner to cont nue rn the post of Librarian.
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
Respondents to determine the employment status of the petitioner for the period
September 2016 to February 2023 and to pass a reasoned and speaking order in
that regard.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI ANS VENKATESH, REPRESENTTNG
M/s ELITE LEX LLP
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRl. N BHUJANGA RAO,
DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI GORANTLA SRt RANGA pUJ|THA
Counsel for the Respondents No.3 To 6 : SRI PASHAM SRINTVASULU
Counsel for the Respondent No.7 : -The Court made the following: ORDER
HIGH COURT F'OR TH ESTATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BTIATTACHARYA
AND
SMT.
JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
THE HON'BLE
WRIT PETIT roN No.2515L OF 2026
(cNR NO.HBHCO 105 194 120261
DATE OT ORI) ER: 28.10.2O26
RESERVED ON: 16. 1O.2026
PRONOUNCED ON: 28' 10.2026
UPLOADED ON: 29.10.2026
BETWEEN:
Pulamoni Srinivasaulu.
.....Petitioner
ANI)
Union of India,
Rep. by- its SecretarY,
Ministry of Labour and EmPloYment,
Central Secretariat, New Delhi - 110001 And Six Others'
. . . Respondents
Mr. ANS. Venkatesh, learned counsel representing M/s. Etite Lex LLP appearing for
the petitioner
Ms. Gorantla Sri RangaPujitha, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No 2'
Mr'Pashamsrtnivasulu,thelearnedStandingCounselappearingfortherespondent
Nos.3 to 6
ORDER: @er Llon'ble Justtce Moushumr f]hattacharya)
1.
The Writ Petition has been {iled against an order dated
30.O4.2026 passed by the Central Administralivc 'l'ribunal, Hyderabad
(Telangana), HACA Bhavan, Hyderabad ('the Tribunal'), in ltem No 3 of
DiaryNo.OASRNo.66lof2026,whercbytheTribunalsustainedthe
Registry,sobjectiontothenumbering/registrationofthepetitioner,S
Original Applicat.ion and directed that the papers be returned to the
petrtioner
'2.
The impugnerd order of the Tribunal, w,hich is recorded in a
four-line tabula t,:d format, uphords the objection raised b1- the Registry
and directs the Registry to return the papers, holding that the
applicant (u'rit petirioner) may find out the appropriate remedy.
3.
The case of thr: petitioner, as argued b1, learned counsel, is that
the Registry's olrjection erroneousry conflated the prese.t application
u,ith an earlier applicarion filed by thc petitioner namely O.A.No.51 of
2024. In the eirljer application, the petitioner sought to call for the
records pertaining t() the proceedings dated 17.1I.2023. q.herebv the
petitioner's clairn for appointment to the posr of Librarian by wa1, of
transfer was rejr:cred. and to declare that the petitioner u,as entitled for
consideration f,tr a ppointment to the post of Librarian, w-rth all
consequential bent:fi ts.
4.
Counsel sultmits that the prayer in the proposed new. O.A.
(O.A.S.R.No. 66 1 of 2026) is entirelv clistincr, as it challe nges Office
Order No. 17 of 2023 datcd 09.O2.2023, n,hereby the petitioner r,",as
transferred / postecl lrom tl-re post of chief Librarian / Librarian to the
Nursing Station as a Nursing orderll . counsel further submits that
the objection raise'd b'the Registry predicated on the ground that the
earlier o.A.No.51 of 2024 had been dismissed and that a writ petition
(W.P.No. 19177 of 2025) filed by the petitioner is pending before the
High Court for the State of Telangana, is without basis'
5.
Counsel reiteratcs that the pra)ers irl O A No 5I of 2024 and the
proposed new O.A. are entirely different, since O'A No'51 of 2024 was
filed against the proceedings dated 17 11 2023, whereas the proposed
new O.A. is filed challenging thc Oificc Ordcr ciated 09 02 2023'
6.
The Iearned Standing Counsel appcaring for the respondent
Nos.3 to 6 submits that the order dated 1'7 71 2023' which was the
subject matter of O.A. No.51 of 2024, and thc ordcr datcd 09 02 2023'
which is proposed to be challenged in the nevv O A ' lorm part of the
same proceedings, since the Office Order dated 09 02 2023 marked
the
commencement of the petitioner's posting as a Nursing Orderly'
7.
lt is submitlcd t.hat rhe subscquent order dated l7 '17 2023 was
a reasoned order whereby the Competent Authority rejected the
petitioner's claim for appointment to [he post of Librarian ' whiie the
primary order dated Og.O2.2O23 directed the transfer/ posting of the
petitioner to the Nursing Station as a Nursing Orderly u'ith immediate
elfect
8.
The Standing Counsel further submits t hat thc petitioner's
Office Order dated
prcvious O.A. (No.51 of 2024),
fi led against ltre
17 .1 | .2023, was dismissed b1
the Tribunal on 07.O4.2025. The
.1
petttioner subs.qLtenrl]-filed a Writ petirion
of dismissal br:fbrc t]ris High Court,
9.
challenging the said order
r,".hich is presently pending.
lt is als;o submitted that the petitioner
O.A.No.21lO73 o1 2023, which was
dismissed
07.o3.2023. ,\ Wrrt Pelirion (W.p.No.9848
petrttoner against thc said dismrssal r.i,as
had earlier liled
by the Tribunal on
of 2023) filed by the
also clisposed of bv the F[igh
Court on 25 .C7 ).O 23 , dr rec ting thc petitioner
to submit a fresh
.
representation belbrc the respondents
for appointment
to the post of
Librarian for recrulLment bv transler
and further directing
respondents to consider such representation
orders thereon ''i'ithin a periocr of
the
and pass appropriate
three months from the date of recelDt
of the represent ttirtrL
10. Pursuant to thc said direcLions, thc petitioner,s
dated 18.08.20:t3 r'r'as dulr, consiclcrcd
same \4'as re ject'.:d vidc orde r dated
b_r. the responclents and
i 7. 1 r .2023 as being devoid
and is rn gross riolation ol }?ccrurtment
dated
representation
17 .11.2()il3 fornts the subject
the
of merit
Ilegulatlons ol trSIC The order
mattcr of the petitroner,s second
O.A. (No.51 of '.2{)21)
1. [t is evidr:nt lrom the submissions madc
that the petitiorl(rr hers:rpproachcd thc
challengc the C)fficc (lrdcrs passcd
Tribunar on severar occasions
b_r,Lhc r:emp6tcnt authori[v
the petitioner as a N ursing Orderlv
subsequent Oltcc Orders form
on behalf of the parties
to
posting
at the Nursrng Station. The
part of a contlnLLous chain
of
proceedings arising out of the petitioner's claim for appointment to the
post of Librarian by the Competent Authorlty.
12. It appears that the petitioner has sought to invoke the statutory
remedy available before the Tribunal at various stages of proceedings'
during n hich the Authoritie s consistently rejected the petitioner's
claim. However, it is a well settled principle that the petitioner is
entitled to know Lhe specific reasons as to whY the Tribunal upheld the
Registry's objection to lhe registration of the proposed new O A The
Tribunal is, rherefore, und.er an obligation to record its reasons for
sustaining the Registry's objections This duty becomes even more
paramountintheprcsentcasewhcrcthcpel-itionerresubmittedits
reasons staLrng that tlte praycr in O A No 5l of 2021 u'as cntrrely
different and distinct from the prayer sought in the proposed new- 0 A'
In this context, it is important to set oul the objection taken by the
Regrstry.
'(1)
(I I)
Relief already discussed and dismissed in O A No'51 of2024'
The order is under challenge in the Honble High Court of Telangana
Hence. sub ntdice '
1'he impugned order clatcri 30.O4 '2026 passt--d b1 thc Tribunal
set out below
'Heard, Mr. ANS Venkatesh. learned counst--l for the applicant
Registr! 's obJection sustained.
Registr)'is directed to return lhe papcrs
,lppticant rna-r find or-lt thc approprlaLc re m'd\"'
is
14. A perusal of the above r,,.ouid shor,,. that neither the objection
taken by the [le51is1^'nor thc subscqucnt order passed
clearly contains arry rcasons. l3oth the objection
and tht: order are
cryptic and opa,:luc. ,\nv appiicant approaching the
other judiciar ro-urn
'''.
br, thc.rribunar
Tribunal or anv
ho is bcing non-suited has an absolute right to
know the reason s lor such rejection.
5. Although , this Court has now had the benefit of analyzing the
underlying contcxl-, the Tribunal cannot presume that
a superior court
which the petitrone. rnight urLimatei' approach * ould
deduce the effect, rmport or background of.the r:arlier
automarrcarv
ordcrs passed bv
the Tribunal in thr: abscnce ofa reasoncd order.
16. Hence, in our r.ir,,"r, it is rmperzrtivc that anv order of rcjection
or
any decision non-surting a litigant must be supported
bl.reasons. The
Registry of thr: Tr-Lbr-rnal cannot be permitted to act
as an absolute
gatekeeper to exciurl,- applicants who approach
the Tribunal secking
statutorv relief E'e: il thc 'r'ribunar is of the r ieu' that
the appricant is
a habitual litig.rnt or that the proposed application is vcxatious,
Tribunal must cLearlr state the reasons for reaching such
a conclusion
in its orcler ol r-ejcction. .I.he clirection bv the l.ribunal
instructing the llegisrr-r. to return the papers fails to
the
simply
satrs11. thc test of a
reasoned order
l'7 '
Hcnce, vrr' zrre inclineci Lo ariou tr-re writ petition
thr: impugned or-dcr clatcd 30.O4.2026. .l.hc
and set aside
matLer is remanded to thc
centra'l Administrative Tribunar, Hyderabad. The
Trrbunar is directed
to list the proposed new O.A. and pass a reasoncd
order thereon.
18. It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion
the merits of the matter, nor has lhc Court considered
on
any submission
on the merits thereof from learned counsel.
19. W.P.No.25l5I ol 2026, along with all connected applications, is
accordingly allowed and disposed of by serting aside
the impugned
order dated 30.o4.2026 passed by the centrar Administrative
Tribunal,
Hyderabad
SD/-M.OSMAN ALI BAIG
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Secretary, Ministry of Labour and Employment, Unron of lndia, Central
Secretariat, New Delhi - '1 1000'l
.
2. The Chairman,, National Medical Commissron, pocket - 14, Sector - B,
Dwarka Phase - l, New Delhi - 1'10077.
3. The Director General,, Employees State lnsurance Corporation, Headquarters
Office, Panchdeep Bhawan, C.l.G. Marg, New Delhi - 11OOO2.
4. The Regional Director,, Regional Office, ESIC, Hillfort Road, Adarshnagar,
Hyderabad - 500063.
5. The Dean / Medical Superintendent,, ESIC Medical College and Hospitat,
Sanathnagar, S.R. Nagar, Hyderabad - 500038.
6. The Assistant Director / Joint Director (Admin),, ESIC Medical College and
Hospital, Sanathnagar, S.R. Nagar, Hyderabad - 500038.
7. The Central Administrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, Rep. by its Registrar,
No. 5-10-193, 1st Floor, HACA Bhavan, Hyderabad - 5OOOO4.
8. One CC to M/s ELITE LEX LLP, Advocate [OPUC]
9. One CC to SRl. N BHUJANGA RAO, Deputy Soticitor Generat of tndia
loPUCl
10.One CC to SRI GORANTLA SRI RANGA PUJ|THA, Advocate tOpUCl
11.One CC to SRI PASHAM SRINIVASULU, Advocate tOpUCl
12. Two CD Copies
DAN
PB
l
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2811012026
ORDER
--a=
WP.No.25151 of 2026
z tu"
|.:
)
PETITION WITHOUT COSTS
Gr
t
rl
a6
)
.)
t-,.)
'::,'./l
\
ALLOWING THE WRIT
rtE S14
$-
11 trt0t, f,tzfi
:. i l,'
iI
ti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review