Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No. 16 of 2023
Date of Decision: 25.08.2023
Public Works Department
(National Highway)
Vs.
M/s BSC - C&C (JV)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv.
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. R. Banerji, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. K. Ch. Gautam, Adv.
Ms. G.C. Marboh, Adv.
Mr. R. Prakash, Adv.
Mr. A. Pande, Adv.
Ms. S. Gangar, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This Application under Section 115 read with Section 151 of
the CPC is against orders dated 26.06.2023, 27.07.2023 and
10.08.2023, passed by the Court of the Learned Judge, Commercial
Court, Shillong, in Commercial Arbitration Execution No. 1 of 2022.
The grievance of the petitioner is first, against order dated 26.06.2023,
with regard to the rejection of their objections against the execution of
the arbitral award dated 27.07.2021, including the impleadment of a 3 rd
party namely the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways in the
execution proceedings, as also order dated 27.07.2023, whereby the
application seeking stay of execution proceedings due to pendency of
the matter before the Supreme Court was rejected, and the last order
dated 10.08.2023, which is asserted was passed without taking note of
the order of the Supreme Court dated 07.08.2023, passed in SLP, Diary
No. 282231of 2023.
2.
Keeping the facts within a short compass, as the challenge in
the present proceedings is directed only against the 3 impugned orders
which has been detailed above, which were passed in the execution
proceedings pursuant to an arbitral award dated 27.07.2021, this Court
will only examine the purport of the impugned orders in the context of
the said execution proceedings.
3.
It has been contended by the learned counsel for the petitioner
that, the arbitral proceedings and execution proceedings in view of
Section 36(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, stand on a
different footing altogether, and the findings or conclusions arrived at
in the course of arbitral proceedings, which though tested and subjected
to Section 34 and Section 37 applications, will have no bearing in the
execution proceedings which were to be dealt with under the provisions
of the CPC. This argument, has been advanced to further the objection
taken before the Executing Court, that the point of impleadment of a 3 rd
Party namely MoRTH was a matter that had to be examined afresh.
This objection however, had been rejected by the Learned Commercial
Court, on the ground that the arbitral tribunal had already dealt with the
same, which was then confirmed in the applications under Section 34
and Section 37, under the A&C Act.
4.
The respondent Senior counsel, Mr. R. Banerji, has strongly
refuted the submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioner and has
taken the Court to the entire sequence of events, and placed orders
dated 27.07.2021 passed by the Arbitral Tribunal, order dated
17.05.2023 passed by the Learned Commercial Court, order dated
19.06.2023 of the Division Bench of this Court passed in Arb. A. No. 6
of 2023 (Public Works Department (National Highway) vs. M/s BSCCC & JV, 6-2-913/914), and order dated 07.08.2023 passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP (Civil) No. 16223/2023. In these series
of orders, it is submitted the issue regarding the impleadment of
MoRTH as a necessary party, has been addressed and rejected. Further,
the contents of the order impugned herein, has been read out by the
learned Senior counsel to show that the petitioner had only sought time
for satisfaction of the decree and that even in the last order dated
10.08.2023, it has been recorded that the Judgment Debtor was ready to
make the payment and was thus allowed further time, to complete the
same. As such, he submits the petitioner by pursuing a dead issue is
only seeking to avoid execution of the decree.
5.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties and
examined the materials on record, at the outset, it is noted that certified
copies of the orders impugned herein, have not been supplied or filed
with the Revision Application. Further, one Revision Application has
been preferred against three orders. These two aspects, make the
maintainability of the instant Revision Application questionable, but
however, as noted earlier, the issue involved being short, this Revision
Application is taken up for consideration on its merits. At this juncture,
the three impugned orders dated 26.06.2023, 27.07.2023 and
10.08.2023, for the sake of easy reference are reproduced herein below.
“26.06.2023
CR put up before me.
Decree Holder is represented by Shri. Ranjit
Prakash, Advocate who appeared via V/C.
Judgment Debtor is represented by Shri.
Shaurya Sahay, Advocate who also appeared via V/C.
He is assisted by Shri. E.R. Chyne and J.N. Rynjah,
Advocates.
Ld counsel for the Decree Holder submits that
in view of the Judgment rendered in Arbitration
Appeal No. 6 of 2023, the Decree may be executed by
directing the Judgment Debtor to satisfy the decree as
the Judgment Debtor has already exhausted the
remedies provided in the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act.
Ld counsel for the Judgment Debtor objected to
the execution on two grounds viz. (1) That the award
is not stamped and (2) That the award is to be satisfied
by a 3rd Party, i.e. MoRTH and prayed that notice may
be issued to MoRTH. In this regard, the Ld counsel
relied on Order 41 Rule 46D CPC.
With regard to the first leg of submission, the Ld
counsel for the Decree Holder submits that the stamp
has already been paid as per the Meghalaya Stamp
Act.
There is no dispute that the stamp duty has been
paid by the Decree Holder and therefore this point of
objection has become redundant.
With regard to the second leg of submission, it
may be stated here that Order 41 Rule 46D CPC
provides for the procedure when debt belongs to third
persons. The relevant provision is reproduced below:“46D. Procedure where debt belongs to third
person.- Where it is suggested or appears to be
probable that the debt belongs to some third person, or
that any third person has a lien or charge on, or other
interest in, such debt, the Court may order such third
person to appear and state the nature and particulars
of his claim, if any, to such debt and prove the same.”
The Judgment Debtor has tried to impress upon
this court that the MoRTH is the principle and the
State PWD is merely the executor of the project. In
this regard, the issue whether MoRTH is a necessary
party to the Arbitration proceedings has already been
decided by the Ld Arbitrator, confirmed in the
application U/s 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act and further in the application U/s 37 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Therefore, this court
is of the view that this leg of objection raised by the
Judgment Debtor is no longer in dispute. Further, an
executing court cannot go behind the decree and when
the decree specifically is against the PWD (NH) Govt.
of Meghalaya, this court is not inclined to accept the
objections raised by the Ld counsel for the Judgment
Debtor.
The Judgment Debtor is hereby directed to
satisfy the award along with the cost Rs.10,00,000/within 1 (one) month from the date of this order.
Fix 26.07.2023 for report on payment.
27.07.2023
CR put up before me.
Decree Holder is represented by Shri.
Anshuman Pandey who appeared via V/C.
Judgment Debtor is represented by Shri. A.S.
Pandey, Advocate who appeared via V/C and E.R.
Chyne and J.N. Rynjah.
This court in Commercial Misc Case No. 4 of
2023 has rejected the prayer of the Judgment Debtor
for stay. The Ld Counsel for the Judgment Debtor
therefore prays that 4 weeks time may be given to the
Judgment Debtor to satisfy the decree.
The Ld Counsel for the Decree Holder objected
to the prayer stating that it would amount to granting
a stay and submitted that the court may consider 1 or 2
weeks time be given to the Judgment Debtor to satisfy
the decree.
Having heard the Ld Counsels, the Judgment
Debtor is given 2 weeks time to satisfy the decree.
Fix 10.08.2023 for report.
10.08.2023
CR put up before me.
Decree Holder is represented by Shri. Ranjit
Prakash, Advocate who appeared via V/C.
Judgment Debtor is represented by Miss Y.
Pallavi, Advocate who appeared via V/C. Mr. A.H.
Kharwanlang and Shri. E.R. Chyne, Advocates are
also appeared physically.
Ld. counsels for both sides informed the court
that SLP has been dismissed.
Ld. counsels for the Judgment Debtor Miss Y.
Pallavi submits that the order has been communicated
to the Government and prays for 4(four) weeks time to
make the payment.
Ld. counsel for the Decree Holder submits that
the Judgment Debtor has been given sufficient time to
make the payment but has time and again delayed in
the payment and prayed that show cause may be
issued to the Chief Engineer (N.H) PWD (Roads) to
show cause as to why coercive action by way of
detention in civil prison should not be taken against
him for failure to satisfy the decree.
Having heard the Ld. counsels for both sides,
the Judgment Debtor had been granted 4 weeks time
to make the payment and another extension of 2 weeks
was granted to satisfy the decree. However, till date the
Decree Holder has failed to make the payment.
However, since the Judgment Debtor is ready to make
the payment and already 6(six) weeks has been
granted to them to make the payment, this court
hereby grant the Judgment Debtor further time of
2(two) weeks to satisfy the decree failing which the
Chief Engineer (NH) PWD (Roads) shall file his show
cause as to why coercive action by way of detention in
civil prison should not be taken against him for failure
to satisfy the decree.
Send a copy of this order to the Judgment
Debtor.
Fix 28.08.2023 for payment and report.
Sd/Judge
Commercial Court,
Shillong.
6.
A perusal of the orders given hereinabove reflects that, due
consideration had been given to the objections raised by the petitioners,
with regard to the necessity of impleadment of MoRTH, in view of the
fact that the same had been decided by the Arbitral Tribunal and in the
subsequent proceedings under Section 34 and Section 37 of the A&C
Act, and further that the decree is specifically against the petitioner,
PWD (NH), Government of Meghalaya. Further, it is also noted that, as
recorded in the order dated 27.07.2023, 4(four) weeks’ time was prayed
by the petitioner Judgment Debtor to satisfy the decree and on
10.08.2023, further 4(four) weeks’ time was prayed for.
7.
At this juncture, it is also useful to refer to the judgment dated
19.06.2023, passed in Arbitration Appeal No. 6 of 2023 under Section
37, wherein the Division Bench of this Court at Para – 34, had observed
as follows.
“34. There are other specious excuses which are
proffered and irrelevant references made in this
matter which has been a complete waste of
judicial time. Notwithstanding the contract
being between the appellant and the contractor,
a fact which is undeniable and is clearly
admitted,
the
appellant
refers
to
the
correspondence it exchanged with the relevant
Union Ministry and the advice that it is received
from such Ministry. In a contract between two
parties, neither is governed by the conduct of a
third party, whatever may be such third party’s
control over the other party. Indeed, an issue
has been sought to be raised quite seriously that
the Union Ministry of Road Transport and
Highways was a necessary and a proper party to
the present proceedings. Surprises never cease.
Such ludicrous assertion may probably be
because the officials who are behind the
appellant; who do not need to pay from their
own pockets for their recalcitrance and it is the
tax-payers’ money that being squandered.”
8.
On the matter being taken up by way of an SLP being SLP
(Civil) No. 16223/2023 before the Supreme Court, the order was not
interfered with, and the SLP was dismissed vide order dated
07.08.2023, though the rights and contentions of the parties were kept
open. An overview of the orders therefore, can lead to only one
inevitable conclusion, that is, the issue regarding impleadment of the
MoRTH, notwithstanding the fact that the same has been brought up
again in these execution proceedings which as argued by the petitioner
is under the CPC, and as such, should be re-looked at, is an issue which
is no longer available for consideration.
9.
Order XXI of the Code elaborately deals with the subject
relating to execution of decrees and the provisions extend from
attachment of properties sale and auction thereof and to many other
methods on the powers of the Court to enforce execution. These
provisions, it can be seen deal with, and are restricted to questions that
would be connected with steps that may be taken by a court in the
course of execution of a decree and cannot be regarded as a challenge
to the validity of the award. Though it may be open to the Executing
Court to apply the principles contained in Order XXI in the course of
enforcement of an arbitral award, in the considered view of this Court,
it would however, not mean that the proceedings before the Executing
Court by the application of the CPC, can lose sight of and disregard
cogent findings that have been arrived at, in the arbitral proceedings.
As such therefore, there is no further scope for the re-examination of
the question of impleadment of the MoRTH, moreso, with the
categorical undertaking that has been given by the petitioner, as seen
from the impugned orders.
10.
However, it is noted that the Executing Court by order dated
10.08.2023, has directed the Chief Engineer, (NH) PWD (Roads) to file
a show-cause, as to why coercive action by way of detention in civil
prison should not be taken against him for failure to satisfy the decree.
In this context, it is noted that the powers of the Court, to enforce
execution is given in Section 51 of the CPC. The proviso to Section 51
reads as follows; “
“Provided that, where the decree is for the payment of
money, execution by detention in prison shall not be ordered
unless, after giving the judgment-debtor an opportunity of
showing cause why he should not be committed to prison, the
Court for reasons recorded in writing, is satisfied-
(a) that the judgment-debtor, with the object or effect of
obstructing or delaying the execution of the decree,-(i) is likely to abscond or leave the local limits of the
jurisdiction of the Court, or
(ii) has, after the institution of the suit in which the
decree was passed, dishonestly transferred, concealed,
or removed any part of his property, or committed any
other act of bad faith in relation to his property, or
(b) that the judgment-debtor has, or has had since the
date of the decree, the means to pay the amount of the
decree or some substantial part thereof and refuses or
neglects or has refused or neglected to pay the same, or
(c) that the decree is for a sum for which the judgmentdebtor was bound in a fiduciary capacity to account.”
11.
The decree in question, though being a money decree, the
Judgment Debtor is the PWD (Roads) (NH), through the Chief
Engineer, and as such, the same is not in the personal capacity of the
Chief Engineer. Taking this into consideration therefore, the
Executing Court to enforce execution can resort to other provisions as
contained in Section 51, for enforcement of the decree. It is further
provided that, as the time limit allowed is to expire very shortly, in the
interest of justice, a further 4(four) weeks’ time is allowed from
28.08.2023, for satisfaction of the decree by the Judgment Debtor.
12.
This Civil Revision Application, therefore for the reasons
aforementioned accordingly stands disposed of, however, with no
order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
25.08.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review