Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 21ST DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 632 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
PROMAC ENGINEERING INDUSTRIES LIMITED
INCORPORATED UNDER THE
COMPANIES ACT, 1956
OFF KANAKAPURA ROAD ALAHALLI,
ANJANAPAURA POST
BENGALURU - 560 062
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR
S. JAYARAM REDDY
Digitally
signed by
NIRMALA
DEVI
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. AJESH KUMAR S, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
ZAMIL STEEL BUILDINGS INDIA PVT LTD
OFFICE NO.1, FIRST FLOOR,
PLOT NO.2, S. NO.8,
ALMONTE SOFTWARE PARK,
KHARADI-411 014, PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
REP. BY ITS AUTHORISED
REPRESENTATIVE,
SHRI ANOOPAM RAJANNA
ALSO AT
-2NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
ZAMIL STEEL BUILDINGS INDIA PVT LTD.,
NO.6, 2ND FLOOR,
ASHA TOWERS, NO.35/13,
LANGFORD ROAD CROSS,
BENGALURU -560 025
2.
JUSTICE K.N. KESHAVANARAYANA,
FORMER JUDGE,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
C/O ARBITRATION AND
CONCILIATION CENTRE
BENGALURU (DOMESTIC AND
INTERNATIONAL) 3RD FLOOR,
EAST WING, KHANIJA BHAVAN,
NO.49, RACE COURSE ROAD
BENGALURU -560 001
…RESPONDENTS
THIS COMAP IS FILED UNDER SECTION 13(1-A) OF
COMMERCIAL COURT ACT, 2015 R/W SECTION 37 OF THE
ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 196 PRAYING TO
CALLING FOR THE RECORDS IN COM.AP NO.79/2024 PASSED
BY THE COURT OF LXXXVI ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND
SESSIONS JUDGE, AT BENGALURU (CCH-87) AND SET ASIDE
JUDGMENT DATED 06.08.2025 PASSED BY THE LEARNED
LXXXVI ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, AT
BENGALURU, AS PER ANNEXURE A AND CONSEQUENTLY
ALLOWING THE APPLICATION UNDER SECTION 34 OF THE
ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996, AS PER
ANNEXURE B.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA
-3NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA)
1. For the reasons stated in the application ‒ I.A No.1/2025, the
same is allowed and the delay in filing the appeal is condoned.
2. The present appeal is filed under Section 13(1-A) of the
Commercial Court Act, 2015 [CC Act] read with Section 37 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 [A&C Act] impugning an
order dated 06.08.2025 passed in Com.A.P.No.79/2024 by the
LXXXVI Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru
[Commercial Court], whereunder the application filed by the
appellant under Section 34 of the A&C Act to set aside the arbitral
award dated 15.12.2023 passed in AC No.217/2021 by the Sole
Arbitrator [Arbitral Tribunal] was rejected.
3. The relevant facts in a nutshell are that the appellant is a
company which was approached by the respondent/claimant for
design, engineering, manufacturing and supply of PEB for 1x125
MW Thermal Power Plant for its Sendou project at Senegal [said
project]. Accordingly, the appellant issued a letter of intent on
26.11.2014 [LOI], pursuant
to which purchase order dated
-4NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
11.02.2016
[PO]
was
placed
by
the
appellant
with
the
respondent/claimant for a total sum of ₹18.30 crores. The said PO
required the respondent/claimant to supply steel structures for the
said project. The scope of supply of steel and the value of the PO
was revised to ₹21,21,65,476/- ( Rupees twenty one crores twenty
one lakh sixty five thousand and four hundred seventy six only)
from its original price of ₹18.30 crores. Various disputes arose
between the parties regarding the LOI and PO, as a result of which
arbitration proceedings were initiated by the respondent/claimant.
4. The respondent/claimant made a total claim of ₹66,27,380/towards unpaid dues relating to the project in question, together
with interest at 18%; interest at 10% on the outstanding amount of
claim towards damages sustained by the respondent/claimant, as
also ₹3,00,000/- towards cost.
5. The appellant entered an appearance before the Arbitral
Tribunal and filed its statement of objections, denying the claims
put forth by the respondent/claimant. The appellant also made
counterclaims summarised as under:
-5NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
a) for a sum of `7,41,609/- made as excess
payment towards the invoices raised by the
respondent/claimant.
b) demurrage and other charges incurred by the
appellant at the Port which are liable to be
reimbursed by the respondent/claimant in a sum
of `39,48,354/-.
c) costs incurred by the appellant by engaging
other agency for erection of the PEB which is
payable by the respondent/claimant in a sum of
`Rs.49,96,100/-.
d)
liquidated
damages
payable
by
the
respondent/claimant in a sum of `1,03,48,303/-.
6.
The counter claim made by the appellant was in a total sum
of `1,85,54,218/-, which amount was claimed together with interest
at 18% per annum
7. The Arbitral Tribunal, by its award dated 15.12.2023, partly
allowed the claim and counterclaim and ordered as under:(1) Claim No.1 covered by Issue No.1 and 2 is allowed in
part in a sum of Rs.51,77,404/- (Rupees Fifty One Lakhs
Seventy Seven Thousand Four Hundred and Four Only) as
against the claim of Rs.66,27,380/- (Rupees Sixty Six Lakhs
-6NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
Twenty Seven Thousand Three Hundred and Eighty Only)
and Respondent to pay the said amount to Claimant.
(2) Claim No.2 covered by Issue No.3 is allowed in part
directing payment of pendente lite interest at 9% per annum
on the principal amount of Rs.51,77,404/-(Rupees Fifty One
Lakhs Seventy Seven Thousand Four Hundred and Four
Only) from 5.2.2019 up to the date of this Award which is
quantified as Rs.22,65,113/- (Rupees Twenty Two Lakhs
Sixty Five Thousand One Hundred and Thirteen Only) and
Respondent to pay the said amount to Claimant along with
future interest at 9% PA on Rs.51,77,404/- (Rupees Fifty
One Lakhs Seventy Seven Thousand Four Hundred and
Four Only) from the date of this Award up to the date of
actual payment.
(3) Claim No.3 covered by Issue No.4 and the additional
claim covered by Issue No.5 are rejected in their entirety.
(4) Respondent to pay to Claimant Rs.3,00,000/-(Rupees
Three Lakhs Only) being the cost of this Arbitral
Proceeding. This amount shall be paid within a period of 3
months from the date of this Award, failing which it shall
carry interest from the date of Award at 6% PA up to the
date of payment.
(5) Counterclaim Nos. 1 to 4 covered by Issue Nos.7, 9, 11,
and 13 put forth by Respondent are rejected in their
entirety. Respondent to bear its own cost on the
-7NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
Counterclaims and pay to Claimant its cost of this Arbitral
proceeding as quantified at (4) above.
(6) With the pronouncement and publication of the Award,
this arbitral proceeding stands terminated as per Section
32(1) of the Act.
(7) This award is signed and issued in 3 originals, one for
the record of Arbitration & Conciliation Centre and rests to
each of the parties.
8. Being aggrieved, the appellant filed an application under
Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 before the
Commercial Court.
The Commercial Court by its order dated
06.08.2025 dismissed the said petition. Being aggrieved, the
present appeal is filed.
9. The primary contention put forth by the learned counsel for the
appellant is that the Arbitral Tribunal has erred in holding that the
appellant did not prove the meeting dated 18.01.2017, a copy of
the minutes of which was produced as Ex.R1 before the Arbitral
Tribunal.
10.
In this context, it is pertinent to note issue No.1 framed by the
Arbitral Tribunal, which is as under:-
-8NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
Whether, Claimant proves that there was underpayment on
the part of Respondent against the value of each of the
invoices issued by him in respect of the work in question, on
account of which in all an amount of Rs.66,27,380/remained unpaid at the completion of the work?
11.
While considering the said issue No.1, it was noticed by the
Tribunal that although the revised PO was for an amount of
₹21,21,65,476/- (as per Ex.P9),
the respondent/claimant had
issued invoices for a total sum of ₹20,69,60,604/- and it had
admittedly received a sum of ₹20,17,83,200/- leaving a balance of
₹51,77,404/-. Further, the respondent/claimant claimed a sum of
₹10,67,200/- in respect of testing and trial assembly charges and a
sum of ₹2,88,000/- towards assembly charges which amounted to
a total sum ₹66,27,380/-.
12.
The appellant contended that the respondent/claimant had
raised various invoices amounting to ₹21,37,35,273/-, in respect of
which
in
all
the
appellant
claimed
to
have
paid
the
respondent/claimant a total sum of ₹20,17,83,200/- leaving a
balance of ₹1,19,52,073/-. From the said amount, the appellant
sought to retain a sum of ₹47,44,371/- on the premise that in the
-9NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
meeting held on 18.01.2017, it was agreed that the said amount be
retained by the appellant as a guarantee against demurrage
charges to be paid.
13.
While considering the said case of the parties, the Tribunal
held as under:
44. Thus, from the above, it is clear that Respondent has
admitted the fact of Claimant having issued invoices of
various dates totally amounting to Rs.21,37,35,273/- and
as against this, even as per the Respondent's statement
the total amount paid including the advance of Rs.30 lakhs
and
two
more
payments
of
Rs.64,05,000/-
and
Rs.61,50,000/- as advance, is Rs.20,17,83,200/-, thereby
leaving balance of Rs.1,19,52,073/-. From the above
statement, it is further clear that a sum of Rs.47,44,371/was retained by Respondent on the premise that in the
meeting said to have been held on 18.1.2017, it was
agreed that the said amount be retained by Respondent as
guarantee against demurrage charges to be paid.
45. According to Respondent, on account of reduction in
the total tonnage, the revised contract value was reduced
to Rs.20,69,60,604/- and Claimant said to have withdrawn
and cancelled some of
its invoices amounting to
Rs.67,74,669/- and thus the actual amount payable by
Respondent to Claimant was Rs.20,69,60,604/- against
which
Respondent
said
to
have
paid
a
sum
of
Rs.20,17,83,200/- leaving a balance of Rs.51,77,404/-.
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
According to Respondent, this amount has been adjusted
towards the demurrage charges and the amount debited to
the account of claimant being the adjustment of excess
amount said to have been paid to old erection contractor.
Thus, according to Respondent, an excess payment of
Rs.7,41,609/- has been made by Respondent to Claimant.
Thus, there has been an admission on the part of
Respondent that a sum of Rs.51,77,404/- was due and
payable to Claimant towards the total amount covered by
invoices. The amounts towards which the balance amount
of Rs. 51,77,404/- payable said to have been adjusted and
the alleged excess payment are the very amounts claimed
under counterclaim Nos.l to 3 which Claimant has denied.
Therefore, in the light of the admission made by
Respondent in the SOD as referred supra, it has to be held
that Claimant has proved its entitlement to an extent of
Rs.51,77,404/- being the balance amount payable by
Respondent. However, this is subject to the finding that
may be recorded on the counterclaims put forth by
Respondent.
(emphasis supplied)
14.
With regard to the minutes of the meeting held on
18.01.2017 (Ex.R1) it was noticed by the Tribunal that the appellant
had alleged that on behalf of the respondent/claimant one
Mr.Shrikumar, Mr.Anoopam and Mr.Girish were alleged to have
attended the said meeting. However, the respondent/claimant had
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
denied the same and disputed Ex.R1. The witness examined on
behalf of the respondent/claimant - PW.1, in the cross-examination,
denied the suggestion that there was a meeting held on
18.01.2017. PW.1 however admitted that the persons mentioned
were his colleagues and is conversant with their signatures. PW.1
has denied that Ex.R1 contained the signatures of the persons
mentioned therein.
15.
The representative of the appellant, who was examined as
RW.1 asserted that a meeting was held on 18.01.2017 and that
Ex.R1 was the minutes of the said meeting. It was noticed that on
behalf of the respondent/claimant the said minutes were signed by
Mr.Shrikumar who was the Director - Sales Marketing and
Business Development. The said minutes was sent by e-mail by
Mr.Anoopam of the respondent/claimant to the respondent and
others from his e-mail ID, which e-mail was also sent to PW.1.
However, RW.1 admitted that he was not present in the said
meeting dated 18.01.2017. The appellant has not examined any
witness who allegedly attended the said meeting dated 18.01.2017
on their behalf.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
16.
It was further noticed by the Tribunal that although Ex.R1
was produced along with a certificate under section 65B of the
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 [Evidence Act] by way of an affidavit
sworn to by RW.1 (which was marked as Ex.R19), in the said
certificate RW.1 had not stated that at the relevant time he was in
lawful control over the use of the computer in which the said emails were stored.
17.
The Arbitral Tribunal noticed that no official of the appellant
who had attended the meeting dated 18.01.2017 had been
examined and after holding that the certificate produced to prove
Ex.R1 did not satisfy the requirement of law held that "there was no
acceptable evidence placed by the respondent to establish that the
revised contract value was mutually fixed at ₹20,69,60,604/- and
that the respondent/claimant agreed to bear the demurrage and
storage charges, as also agreed for retention of amounts payable
to the respondent/claimant by the respondent as guarantee
towards demurrage charges."
18.
The
Tribunal
has
appreciated
the
various
e-mail
correspondences exchanged between the parties and held that the
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
appellant was liable to pay the respondent/claimant a sum of
₹51,77,404/- towards unpaid invoices amount.
It was further
noticed that although the respondent/claimant had claimed a sum
of
₹66,27,380/-
as
payable
from
the
appellant,
the
respondent/claimant had not produced any material to demonstrate
the same. Hence, the Tribunal held that the respondent/claimant
had proved that the appellant was liable to pay a sum of
₹51,77,404/- towards unpaid invoices.
19.
The Tribunal while noticing the counter claims had held that
the appellant had not adduced any material in support of the said
claims and hence rejected the same.
20.
The Commercial Court while considering the appeal filed by
the appellant with respect to the amounts claimed by the
respondent/claimant under the invoices, held as under:
13. In paragraph No.16 of the statement of defense, under
the heading 'Payments made by respondents to claimant' the
petitioner admitted that the respondent had raised its
invoices on various dates amounting to a total value of
Rs 21,37,35,273/- against which the petitioner made a
Payment of Rs.20,17,83,200/- by leaving the balance of
Rs. 1,19,52,073/-. On the basis of averments made in the
statement of defense, the learned arbitral tribunal in
paragraph No.44 recorded its finding that a sum of
Rs.47,44,371/- was retained by the petitioner on the premise
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
that in the meeting said to have been held on 18.01.2017, it
was agreed that the said amount be retained by the
respondent as guarantee against demurrage charges to be
paid. According to the petitioner on account of reduction in
the total tonnage, the revised contract value was reduced to
Rs.20,69,60,604/- and the respondent said to have
withdrawn and canceled some its invoices amounting to
Rs.67,74,669/- and thus, the balance would Rs.51,77,404/-.
Thus, it is clear that only on the basis of the averments made
in the statement of defense, the learned arbitral tribunal
came to the conclusion that the petitioner was liable to pay
the respondent a sum of Rs.20,69,60,604/- against which
the petitioner has paid Rs.20,17,83,200/- and thus, the
balance payable by the petitioner to the respondent was
Rs.51,77,404/-. The basis for the decision of the learned
arbitral tribunal was the pleadings of the petitioner and not
the evidence adduced by the respondent. Therefore, the
decision of the learned arbitral tribunal in so far as directing
the petitioner to pay the respondent a sum of Rs.51,77,404/cannot be termed as an award without evidence. It should be
bear in mind that evidence includes the admissions. As per
Section 17 of the Indian Evidence Act, an admission is a
relevant fact. An admission is a statement made oral and
writing by the party to the proceedings with respect to facts
in issue or relevant fact. In the present case, the learned
arbitral tribunal on the basis of facts admitted by the
petitioner has came to the conclusion that the petitioner is
liable to pay Rs.51,77,404/- to the respondent and therefore,
this court does not find any acceptable reason to interfere
with the arbitral award. The learned arbitral tribunal has
granted the respondent interest at the rate of 9% p.a. On the
principal amount of Rs.51,77,404/-. The arbitral tribunal has
a discretion to grant interest on the award amount.
Therefore, this court does not wish to interfere with the
findings of the arbitral tribunal in so far as granting of interest
at the rate of 9% is concerned.
(emphasis supplied)
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
21.
It is clear that the commercial court noticed the fact that the
appellant in its statement of defence had admitted that the
respondent/claimant
had
supplied
goods
of
a
sum
of
`20,69,60,604/- and that the appellant had admittedly paid a sum
of `20,17,83,200/-. Accordingly, it was held that the finding of the
arbitral
tribunal
that
appellant
was
liable
to
pay
the
respondent/claimant a sum of `51,77,404/- cannot be said to be
without evidence. The commercial court had arrived at the said
finding without going into the question as to whether the appellant
had proved the meeting dated 18.01.2017.
22.
As noticed above, although the respondent/claimant had
claimed a sum of `66,27,380/-, it had not produced the invoices in
support of the said claimed amount. The summary of the invoices
[Exhibit P16] was not accepted/relied upon both by the arbitral
tribunal as well as the Commercial Court. However, the appellant in
its statement of defence had admitted that the respondent/claimant
had supplied goods to a total sum of `20,69,60,604/-. The
respondent/claimant
had
admittedly
received
a
sum
of
`
20,17,83,200/-. Hence, the balance amount to `51,77,404/- was
held due and payable by the appellant to the respondent/claimant.
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
23.
The appellant sought to retain a sum of `47,44,371/- by
placing the reliance on the meeting date of 18.01.2017 (Ex.R1) by
stating that the said fact was agreed between the parties in the said
meeting. Although the minutes of meeting dated 18.1.2017 was
produced,
the
said
meeting
having
been
denied
by
the
respondent/claimant, the claimant was required to prove the said
meeting. The appellant did not examine any of its representative
who had participated in the said meeting. Further, although the
appellant had produced a copy of the minutes of the said meeting
along with a certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act, the
Tribunal held that the said certificate did not comply with the
requirements of Section 65B of the Evidence Act.
24.
Although it is the vehement contention of the learned counsel
for the appellant that the Evidence Act is not applicable to
arbitration proceeding and the finding of the Tribunal is erroneous,
the Tribunal having noticed the said certificate and having recorded
a finding that the said certificate does not comply with Section 65B
of Evidence Act, as also that since the appellant did not examine
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:4516-DB
COMAP No. 632 of 2025
HC-KAR
any of its representatives who allegedly participated in the meeting
on 18.01.2017, the appellant had failed to prove the said meeting.
25.
It is well settled that the Arbitral Tribunal is the master of the
quality and quantity of evidence, and the court cannot re-evaluate
the evidence and supplant its view in place of that of the Arbitral
Tribunal. In the present case, the Arbitral Tribunal's finding cannot
be said to be patently illegal, as it is a plausible view based on the
material on the record. The said finding does not merit an
interference under Section 34 of the A&C Act.
26.
In view of the same, the above appeal is dismissed as being
devoid of merit.
Sd/(VIBHU BAKHRU)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/(C.M. POONACHA)
JUDGE
nd/BS
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review