Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010712222025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
[3327]
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY,THE THIRD DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SREENIVASA REDDY
WRIT PETITION NO: 36493/2025
Between:
Progressive Engineering Enterprises
...PETITIONER
AND
Union Of India and Others
...RESPONDENT(S)
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. BUTTA VIJAYA BHASKER
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. Y V ANIL KUMAR (Central Government Counsel)
The Court made the following:
THE HON?BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
WRIT PETITION No.36493 of 2025
ORDER :
The present Writ Petition was filed, originally, seeking
a direction to the respondents to consider petitioner?s
technical bid submitted pursuant to Tender No.STCKRPUV-G_D-GOT116, dated 7.11.2025 issued by 3rd respondent,
without reference to the petitioner?s bank guarantee for a
period of 180 days validity from 20.11.2025 to 19.5.2026,
instead of 01.12.2025 to 31.05.2026.
2.
Case of the writ petitioner is as follows:
(a) Respondent No.3 issued the subject Tender dated
07.11.2025 for the work viz. Supply, Installation, Design &
Commissioning
of
New
Electronic
Interlocking
(Hot-
standby) with Distributed Architecture at Gate Junction
(GJC) station, Duvvada (DVD) and Gopalapatnam (GPT)
station,
and
Commissioning
Supply,
of
Installation,
Alteration
in
Design
existing
and
Electronic
Interlocking (Distributed) of M/s.Kyosan at Vadlapudi
(VDPD) station in connection with 3rd and 4th line between
VDPD-GJC and DVD-GPT sections, and provision of
automatic block working between VDPD-GJC & DVD-GPT
section including Utility shifting of infringing LC Gate,
Cables,
Location
boxes,
other
Signalling
&
Tele-
communication gears, in Waltair Division of East Coast
Railway.
(b) The participants in the tender process are required
to submit a technical bid along with a financial bid.
Technical bids would be opened first, and the participants,
who qualify in the technical bid, will be shortlisted for the
financial bid stage.
Thereafter, financial bids of the
shortlisted participants are opened and the bidders are
sorted in ascending order, with the lowest bidders being L1,
the second lowest bidder being declared as L2, and so on.
(c) Pursuant to the aforesaid Tender Notification, the
petitioner submitted its technical bid on 01.12.2025
through online.
Rs.33,17,000/Jayanagar,
The petitioner submitted bid security of
with
Kotak
Mahindra
Bangalore
vide
B.G.No.0421IGP251118430,
dated 20.11.2025.
Bank
Limited,
As per the terms of the Tender, the
Bank Guarantee (B.G.) bond shall be valid for a period of
90 days beyond the bid valid period.
But, instead of
mentioning the effective date in the B.G. submitted by the
petitioner
as
>from
01.12.2025?,
it
is
mentioned
as
20.11.2025, and the mistake is human error and not
intentional. In view of the said mistake, the validity of B.G.
would fall short of 10 days i.e. instead of 01.12.2025 to
31.5.2026, it was mentioned as 20.11.2025 to 19.5.2026.
The
said
mistake
does
not
substantially
affect
the
conditions of tender document nor does it cause any
hardship or prejudice to the respondents.
(d) It is stated that there is no deficiency in the
amount mentioned in the B.G. and the petitioner fulfilled
all other conditions required for submission of the technical
bid, and the short fall of 10 days in validity period of 180
days from 01.12.2025 would not affect or cause any
prejudice to the terms of the Tender.
The petitioner
apprehends that the respondents are likely to reject the
petitioner?s technical bid on the said ground, in which
event, it would result in great hardship to the petitioner. It
is stated that the Central Vigilance Commission Guidelines
make it clear that unless a bidder is blacklisted or
prematurely terminated because of poor performance, his
bids cannot be rejected on any other grounds.
Hence, the
Writ Petition.
3.
On 30.12.2025, when the Writ Petition came up
for admission, it was posted to 02.01.2026 for getting
instructions.
On 02.01.2026, the learned counsel for
respondents brought to the notice of the Court that the
technical bid was finalized on 31.12.2025 and financial bid
was opened on that day i.e. 02.01.2026. Pursuant thereto,
the petitioner filed I.A.No.1 of 2026, seeking amendment of
prayer and filed additional affidavit.
In the said prayer,
the petitioner sought to declare the action of respondents in
rejecting the petitioner?s technical bid on 01.01.2026
pursuant to the subject Tender issued by the respondent
No.3 as illegal and arbitrary, and consequently direct the
respondents
to
consider
the
technical
bid,
without
reference to the petitioner?s B.G. for a period of 180 days
validity
from
20.11.2025
to
19.05.2026,
instead
of
01.12.2025
to
31.05.2026,
and
further
direct
the
respondents to open petitioner?s financial bid and allow the
petitioner to participate in reverse auction (e-RA).
4.
On 05.01.2026, this Court, while ordering the
said amendment petition vide I.A.No.1 of 2026, directed the
petitioner to make a fresh representation along with an
application
mentioning
the
fresh
dates
of
B.G.
to
respondents 2 and 3 within the time stipulated therein, and
thereupon, directed respondents 2 and 3 to consider the
same and pass appropriate orders after giving a reasonable
opportunity of hearing to the petitioner.
5.
Thereafter, the petitioner filed I.A.No.2 of 2026,
amendment petition. It is stated in the said petition that
pursuant to the aforesaid direction dated 05.01.2026 of
this Court, the petitioner made a representation dated
07.01.2026 by enclosing B.G., however, the respondents
issued
proceedings
dated
16.1.2026,
rejecting
the
representation and upholding the earlier decision regarding
rejection of the technical bid of the petitioner.
Hence, the
petitioner sought to declare the action of the respondents in
rejecting the petitioner?s technical bid submitted pursuant
to the subject Tender dated 01.01.2026 and subsequent
rejection order dated 16.1.2026 issued by 3rd respondent as
illegal and arbitrary, and consequently to set aside the
rejection order dated 01.01.2026 and the subsequent
rejection order dated 16.1.2026 issued by 3rd respondent
and
direct
the
respondents
to
consider
petitioner?s
technical bid, open petitioner?s financial bid and allow the
petitioner to participate in reverse auction (e-RA).
The
said petition is allowed today.
6.
Respondent No.3 filed counter affidavit denying
the material averments in the writ affidavit and contending
inter alia as follows.
(a)
The
petitioner
deliberately
suppressed
many
fundamental and imperative material facts which are
relevant and necessary for deciding the Writ Petition; that
the subject Tender was issued strictly in conformity with
the extant railway procurement Rules and the established
tendering procedures applicable to the railways, and the
terms and conditions governing the Tender are explicit and
applicable
to
all
prospective
bidders,
including
the
petitioner; that the Tender document consists of 10
schedules forming an integral part thereof, and every
participating bidder is required to scrupulously comply
with the same without any deviation or relaxation.
(b) It is further stated that the closing date and time
for submission of bids as per the Tender Notification is
15.30 hrs on 01.12.2025; that the tender evaluation
process was duly completed on 31.12.2025 and the
outcome was communicated to all participating tenderers;
that
the
tender
process
was
conducted
strictly
in
accordance with the prescribed schedule without any
alteration or deviation.
(c) It is further stated that under the express
provisions of the Tender Form (Second Sheet), Annexure-I
Clause 6 (bid security), the bid security furnished in the
form of a Bank Guarantee must be valid for a period of 90
days beyond the tender validity period, and since the tender
validity period was stipulated to subsist up to 01.03.2026,
the corresponding bid security was mandatorily required to
remain valid up to 30.05.2026, which is an essential
eligibility condition forming part of the tender framework;
that the petitioner furnished a B.G. valid only up to
19.05.2026, which falls short of the mandatory validity
period prescribed under the Tender conditions, and the
same is non-compliance of an essential tender requirement,
which renders the bid inherently defective and nonresponsive.
It is further stated that validity period of bid
security is a substantive, mandatory and non-negotiable
condition of eligibility, and non-fulfilment thereof ipso facto
renders the bid non-responsive and makes it liable for
rejection at threshold; that the reason assigned therefor, by
the petitioner as >human error? is not tenable.
(d) It is further stated that the Central Vigilance
Commission
Guidelines
are
intended
to
ensure
transparency and probity in public procurement, but do
not over-ride, dilute or supplant the express conditions of a
particular tender; that the said Guidelines do not mandate
acceptance of a non-responsive bid or authorize relaxation
of an essential eligibility condition; that the rejection of
petitioner?s technical bid is not a punitive in nature, but it
is an inevitable consequence of non-compliance with a
mandatory tender stipulation.
(e) It is further stated that any request for extension or
substitution of B.G. after opening of the technical bid
amounts to post-bid modification, which is expressly
prohibited under the tender conditions and the settled
principles of public procurement; that eligibility and
responsiveness of a bid must be assessed strictly with
reference to the documents as they existed on the date of
bid
opening
and
material
defects
cannot
be
cured
retrospectively. It is further stated that Courts, while
exercising
writ
jurisdiction,
ordinarily
refrain
from
interfering in contractual and tender matters, unless the
decision making is shown to be arbitrary, mala fide,
irrational or in violation of any statutory provision.
7.
It is further stated in the counter affidavit that
the petitioner made a representation dated 07.01.2026
pursuant to the Order of this Court dated 05.01.2026 and
the same was duly considered by 3rd respondent and a
reasoned speaking order dated 16.01.2026 was passed
after due examination of the governing tender conditions,
the nature and materiality of the defect and the established
norms of tender evaluation, rejecting the representation.
Hence, it is prayed to dismiss the Writ Petition.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contended
that in pursuance to the subject Tender Notification dated
7.11.2025, the petitioner submitted its technical bid, along
with B.G. issued by the Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited,
Jayanagar, Bangalore; that as per the terms of the Tender,
the B.G. shall be valid for a period of 90 days beyond the
bid valid period i.e. 01.12.2025 to 31.05.2026, but by
mistake, B.G. which is effective from 20.11.2025 to
19.5.2026 was submitted by the petitioner; that it is a
human error; that there is no deficiency in the amount of
B.G. to be submitted by the petitioner, but the validity of
the B.G. falls short of 10 days; that the same does not
substantially affect the conditions of tender document and
no
prejudice
or
hardship
would
be
caused
to
the
respondents; that the petitioner fulfilled all other conditions
required for submission of the bid.
He submits that inspite of the same, the respondents
rejected the technical bid of the petitioner on 01.01.2026,
on the ground of non-compliance of the commercial
compliance part of the eligibility criteria; that the action of
the respondents in rejecting the petitioner?s technical bid
on the said ground, is untenable; that had the respondents
considered the petitioner?s technical bid, the petitioner
would have become eligible to participate in reverse tender
auction/bid (e-RA)
as
per
Clause
of the
Special
Conditions of Contract;
He further submits that pursuant to the Order dated
05.01.2026 passed by this Court, the petitioner submitted
representation dated 07.01.2026 by enclosing the B.G., but
the same was erroneously rejected by 3rd respondent vide
proceedings dated 16.01.2026 on the ground that the
petitioner?s
bid
security/B.G.
was
valid
only
up
to
19.05.2026 and falls short of the mandatory validity period
prescribed under the tender conditions; that in the B.G., it
is specifically mentioned that the beneficiary?s right as well
as the Bank?s liability under the said Guarantee shall stand
extinguished unless a written claim or demand is made
under this Guarantee on or before completion of one year
from expiry date i.e. 19.05.2027, and hence, the B.G.
remains and valid till 19.05.2027 i.e. beyond 180 days, as
required by the respondents.
He submits that in view of
the same, rejection of the technical bid of the petitioner on
the aforesaid ground is untenable and hence, he prays to
allow the Writ Petition.
In support of his contention, the learned counsel for
the petitioner relied on an Order of the High Court for the
State of Telangana in M/s. Hytronics Enterprises v. Union of
India1 case.
9.
On the other hand, the learned counsel for the
respondents, while reiterating the averments in the counter
affidavit, contended that the subject Tender document
consists of 10 schedules which form an integral part
thereof, and all the bidders are required to scrupulously
Order dated 10.10.2023 in W.P.No.25868 of 2023
comply with the same without any deviation, and tender
process was conducted strictly adhering to the prescribed
schedule and in conformity with the terms and conditions
of the Tender, without any deviation. He submits that as
per the tender conditions, the bid security in the form of a
B.G. has to remain valid for a period of 90 days beyond the
tender validity, and since the tender validity was up to
01.03.2026, the bid security (B.G.) is to be valid up to
30.05.2026, but the bid security (B.G.) submitted by the
petitioner was valid only up to 19.05.2026, which falls
short of the mandatory validity period prescribed under the
Tender conditions.
He submits that if the extended B.G.
submitted by the petitioner along with the representation
dated 07.01.2026 is accepted, it would amount to post-bid
modification and would result in unequal treatment of
bidders, which is not permissible, and considering these
aspects, the respondents rightly rejected the petitioner?s
technical bid, and there are no grounds warranting
interference of this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, with the
action taken by the respondents. Hence, he prays to
dismiss the Writ Petition.
In support of his contention, the learned counsel
relied on a decision in Tata Motors Limited v. Brihan
Mumbai Electric Supply and Transport Undertaking (Best) &
others2.
10.
Now, the point that arises for consideration of
this Court in this Writ Petition is whether there are any
grounds to interfere with the decision of 3rd respondent,
rejecting the tender document submitted by the petitioner
pursuant
to
the
Tender
No.STCKRPU-V-G_D-GOT116,
dated 7.11.2025 issued by 3rd respondent ?
11.
The factual matrix is not in dispute.
The
petitioner participated in the Tender process pursuant to a
Tender
No.STCKRPU-V-G_D-GOT116,
dated
7.11.2025
issued by 3rd respondent and submitted its technical bid on
01.12.2025. It is not in dispute that along with the bid, the
petitioner submitted bid security of Rs.33,17,000/- vide
B.G.No.0421IGP251118430, dated 20.11.2025 issued by
(2023) 19 SCC 1
Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited, Jayanagar, Bangalore, and
the validity period mentioned in the said B.G. is from
20.11.2025 to 19.05.2026.
12.
It is also not in dispute that the tender
conditions inter alia {Clause 6 of Annexure-I of the Tender
Form (Second Sheet)} stipulate that the bid security in the
form of a B.G. has to remain valid for a period of 90 days
beyond the tender validity. In the case on hand, the tender
validity was up to 01.03.2026 and so, the bid security
(B.G.) is to be valid up to 30.05.2026.
Admittedly, the bid
security submitted by the petitioner by way of the subject
B.G. was valid only till 19.05.2026. It is not in conformity
with the conditions stipulated under the subject Tender
and falls short of the mandatory validity period prescribed
under the Tender conditions.
13.
In fact, the petitioner also admits that the B.G.
submitted by it falls short of 10 days of the validity period
prescribed in the Tender.
According to the petitioner, it is
only a human error and not intentional, and that the B.G.
was valid for a period of 180 days but the validity period is
mistakenly mentioned as 20.11.2025 to 19.5.2026, instead
of 01.12.2025 to 31.5.2026.
It is the contention of the
petitioner that the petitioner fulfilled all other conditions
required for submission of the technical bid, and the said
mistake does not substantially affect the conditions of
tender document and it does not cause any hardship or
prejudice to the respondents, and that there is no
deficiency in the amount mentioned in the B.G. According
to the learned counsel for the respondents, the said
mistake renders the bid inherently defective and nonresponsive.
14.
There cannot be any dispute that the Tender
conditions are integral part of the Tender, and all the
bidders are required to scrupulously comply with the same
without any deviation.
It is also not in dispute that the
respondents too are required to adhere to the Tender
conditions and schedule, while processing the Tenders, and
there cannot be any discrimination or deviation. As stated
supra, according to the Tender conditions, the bid security
to be submitted by the participants in the Tender process
must be in the form of a Bank Guarantee and the same has
to remain valid for a period of 90 days beyond the tender
validity.
As the tender validity period was up to
01.03.2026, the bid security (B.G.) has to be valid
invariably up to 30.05.2026, but the bid security submitted
by the petitioner in the form of the subject B.G. falls short
of 10 days.
This amounts to a patent non-compliance of
one of the essential requirements under the Tender
document, which renders the bid inherently defective and
non-responsive.
Any extension of time or any permission
for substitution of the B.G. after opening of the technical
would, admittedly, amount to post-bid modification, which
is not permitted under the Tender conditions.
15.
The facts in the said present case and the facts
in the decision in M/s. Hytronics Enterprises v. Union of
India case (1 supra), relied on by the learned counsel for the
petitioner, are distinguishable. In the said case, though the
petitioner therein furnished the security commencing from
12.07.2023 to 30.04.2025, a mistake crept in, in filling the
tender form and the date was filled as ?30.04.2024?, instead
of >30.04.2025?.
Considering the said fact and in view of
the fact that the respondents therein stated in the counter
affidavit that the technical bid was not yet finalized as on
the said date of the decision, the said Writ Petition was
disposed of, directing the respondents 1 and 2 therein to
consider the representation of the petitioner therein and
pass a reasoned order.
In the case on hand, even
according to the petitioner, the bid security submitted by it,
in the form of B.G. falls short of the mandatory validity
period prescribed under the Tender conditions, and the
same would amount to non-compliance of an essential
tender requirement. In the facts and circumstances of the
present case, the decision in M/s. Hytronics Enterprises v.
Union of India case (1 supra), relied on by the learned
counsel for the petitioner, does not render any assistance to
the case of the petitioner.
16.
Moreover,
pursuant
to
the
order
dated
05.01.2026 passed by this Court, the petitioner made a
representation dated 07.01.2026, and upon considering the
same, the respondents passed a detailed Order dated
16.01.2026, rejecting the said representation, upholding its
earlier decision to reject technical bid.
17.
In Tata Motors Limited v. Brihan Mumbai Electric
Supply and Transport Undertaking (Best) & others (2 supra),
the Hon?ble Apex Could held thus: (paragraph 50)
“50. This Court being the guardian of fundamental
rights is duty-bound to interfere when there is
arbitrariness, irrationality, mala fides and bias.
However, this Court has cautioned time and again that
courts should exercise a lot of restraint while
exercising their powers of judicial review in contractual
or commercial matters. This Court is normally loathe
to interfere in contractual matters unless a clear-cut
case of arbitrariness or mala fides or bias or
irrationality is made out. One must remember that
today many public sector undertakings compete with
the private industry. The contracts entered into
between private parties are not subject to scrutiny
under writ jurisdiction. No doubt, the bodies which are
State within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution are bound to act fairly and are amenable
to the writ jurisdiction of superior courts but this
discretionary power must be exercised with a great
deal of restraint and caution. The courts must realise
their limitations and the havoc which needless
interference in commercial matters can cause. In
contracts involving technical issues the courts should
be even more reluctant because most of us in Judges'
robes do not have the necessary expertise to adjudicate
upon technical issues beyond our domain. The courts
should not use a magnifying glass while scanning the
tenders and make every small mistake appear like a
big blunder. In fact, the courts must give <fair play in
the joints= to the government and public sector
undertakings in matters of contract. Courts must also
not interfere where such interference will cause
unnecessary loss to the public exchequer. (See Silppi
Constructions Contractors v. Union of India [Silppi
Constructions Contractors v. Union of India, (2020) 16
SCC 489] ).=
18.
It is settled proposition of law that this Court, in
exercise of its powers of judicial review under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India, would interfere when there is
arbitrariness, irrationality, mala fides and bias.
It is also
settled that a lot of restraint has to be exercised by this
Court while exercising its powers of judicial review in
contractual or commercial matters. Having failed to submit
the Tender Security as stipulated in the Tender document,
the petitioner cannot now seek redressal from this Court in
exercise of its powers of judicial review under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.
As rightly contended by the
learned counsel for the respondents, if the extended B.G.
submitted by the petitioner along with the representation
dated 07.01.2026 is accepted, it would amount to post-bid
modification and would result in unequal treatment of
bidders.
Further more, when once the technical bid was
finalized on 31.12.2025 and financial bid was opened on
that day i.e. 02.01.2026, the petitioner cannot be permitted
to correct the mistake by submitting the extended bid
security by way of B.G. Therefore, the procedure adopted
by the respondents is strictly in accordance with the Tender
conditions. The Tender conditions are not under challenge.
Therefore, there are no grounds calling for interference of
this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.
19.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed. No
costs.
Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, in the Writ
Petition shall stand closed.
(JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY)
DRK
3.3.2026
THE HON?BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
WRIT PETITION No.36493 of 2025
3.3.2026
DRK
HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
****
WRIT PETITION NO: 36493/2025
Between:
Progressive Engineering Enterprises
...PETITIONER
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
Union Of India and Others
*****
DATE OF JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED
:
3.3.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SREENIVASA REDDY
1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers
may be allowed to see the Order?
Yes/No
2. Whether the copy of Order may be
marked to Law Reporters/Journals?
Yes/No
3. Whether His Lordship wish to see the
fair copy of the Order?
Yes/No
JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
* HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
+ WRIT PETITION NO: 36493/2025
% 03.03.2026
# Between:
...PETITIONER
Progressive Engineering Enterprises
AND
...RESPONDENT(S)
Union Of India and Others
Counsel for the petitioner
:
Sri Butta Vijaya Bhasker
:
Sri Y.V.Anil Kumar (Central
Government counsel)
!
^ Counsel for Respondents
< Gist:
> Head Note:
? Cases referred:
1 Order dated 10.10.2023 in W.P.No.25868 of 2023 passed by the High Court
for the State of Telangana
(2023) 19 SCC 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review