Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No. 56 of 2014
Vs.
Prof. Man Mohan Singh
Date of Decision: 11.02.2021
Union of India & Ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice BiswanathSomadder, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S.Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)/Appellant(s):
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. V.K. Jindal, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. E. Marwein, Adv.
Mr. R. Debnath, GCG (For R 1)
Mr. B. Deb, Adv. (For R 2)
Mr. S. Sen, Adv. (For R 3-6)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
The Court:1.
This instant appeal has been preferred against the
judgment and order dated 4th June, 2014 passed in WP(C) No. 245 of
2012. The case of the writ appellant (writ petitioner) – who has since
retired – is that he was directly appointed as a Professor from
12.07.1991 in the North Eastern Hill University, Shillong. His
grievances as put forth, centre around two aspects:- (i) First, that the
respondent University had not implemented the Scheme of Revision of
Pay in accordance with the recommendations of the 6th Pay
Commission, and had acted contrary to MHRD letter dated 31.12.2008
which was approved by the Ministry of Finance vide memorandum
dated 30.08.2008 as also the CCS (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 and (ii)
secondly, the denial of three increments meant for PhD holders, a type
of incentive for higher qualification. By the impugned order, the said
WA No. 56 of 2014
writ petition was dismissed by the learned Single Judge, who observed
that the writ appellant had utterly failed to make out any case.
2.
Mr. V.K. Jindal, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. E.
Marwein, learned counsel for the appellant submits that the appellant,
being a directly recruited professor, his pay falls under the category of
(XIV) of clause 2A of the recommendation of the Government of India
dated 31.12.2008 under the caption, „the pay structure for different
categories of teachers and equivalent position shall be as indicated
below (a) Assistant Professor/Associate Professor/Professor in
Colleges and Universities……’. Learned senior counsel submits that as
per the said clause of the recommendation, the pay of a directly
recruited professor should have been fixed not below Rs. 43,000/- in
the Pay Band of Rs. 37,400-67,000/- with Academic Grade Pay (AGP)
of Rs 10,000/-. It is further submitted that the respondent University
downgraded and reduced the Basic Pay of the appellant from Rs.
51,850/- to 48,870/- with retrospective effect from 01.01.2006, vide
the impugned order dated 04.12.2009, in utter violation of the
recommendation of the 6th Pay Commission. Learned senior counsel
has also contended that the revised pay fixation of the incumbent
Professors by the use of fitment table is arbitrary, inasmuch as, per the
6th Central Pay Commission, the pay of a directly recruited professor
should be fixed on the level not below Rs. 43,000/- in the Pay Band of
37,400-67,000/- with AGP of Rs. 10,000/-.
3.
The learned Senior counsel submits that the appellant has
also been wrongly denied three advance increments, due as an
incentive to teachers possessing a PhD degree, in terms of order dated
WA No. 56 of 2014
31.12.2008 issued by the Ministry of HRD and UGC Regulation dated
30.06.2010 (Annexure P/5). In assailing the order of the learned Single
Judge, learned senior counsel reiterates his submissions that the
respondent University failed to implement the recommendation of the
6th Pay Commission pursuant to the MHRD letter dated 31.12.2008,
and further that the directions of the Ministry of Finance, dated
30.08.2008, CCS (Revised Pay) Rules issued by the Ministry of
Personnel etc. dated 13.09.2008, which were communicated to the
UGC vide Memo dated 31.12.2008, were totally ignored by the
learned Single Judge. As such, he submits that the impugned judgment
& order be set aside and quashed and the reliefs as prayed in the writ
petition be allowed.
4.
Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel for the respondent University
which has been arrayed as respondents No. 3 to 6, countering the
submissions of the counsel for the appellant has submitted that the
allegations that the University has downgraded the revised Basic Pay
Scale of the appellant is misplaced and factually incorrect and no
illegality can be said to have been committed in placing the appellant
in the appropriate revised Basic Pay, which was as per the
recommendation of the UGC and based on the 6th Pay Commission. He
further submits that the provisional fixation of pay of the appellant at
Rs. 51,850/- by the University, was only for the purpose of facilitating
the release of 40% of the arrears pending the receipt of the fitment
table for final and appropriate fixation of the revised pay scale.
5.
With regard to the point on the alleged deprivation of
three increments, the learned counsel for the respondent University has
WA No. 56 of 2014
taken this Court to the affidavit filed on 10.05.2019, to further
substantiate the fact that there has been no such denial of three
increments as alleged. Mr. S. Sen submits that even when the writ
appellant was initially appointed to the post of Reader, a PhD degree
or an equivalent qualification was an essential criterion for the said
post and to substantiate the same, he has referred to the advertisement
dated 27.02.1984 (Annexure A to the affidavit dated 10.05.2019). He
further submits that at the time when the writ appellant was appointed
to the said post there was neither any regulation nor directive from the
UGC providing for any incentive by way of increment for the
equivalent qualifications of PhD for the post of Reader. He then
submits that a PhD degree now also being an essential qualification for
the post of Professor which was last held by the writ appellant, no
Professor possessing a PhD qualification has been granted any
incentive in the form of advance increment. In this regard he has also
placed a letter dated 24.07.2002 (Annexure B to the affidavit) issued
by the UGC which clarified that the benefit of two advance increments
shall not be admissible to teachers who were recruited/promoted to a
post for which PhD was an essential qualification. As such, he submits
the appellant holding the post of Professor – wherein a PhD is an
essential qualification – was not entitled in any manner to the advance
increments as prayed.
6.
In closing his submissions, the learned counsel for the
respondents submits that the revised pay scale of the 6th Central Pay
Commission has been extended to the University by a regulation
namely, „the UGC Regulations on a minimum qualification for
WA No. 56 of 2014
appointment of teachers and other academic staff in Universities and
Colleges and measures for the maintenance of standard in education
of 2010‟. He submits that as per the said Regulation of 2010, revised
salary of teachers was to be fixed strictly in accordance with the
decision of the MHRD and the fixation formula developed by UGC
and approved by the MHRD, as contained in Appendix-1&II of the
Regulation. A bare perusal of the Regulation, he submits, would show
that the revised pay scale for Professor was to be fixed strictly in
accordance with the fitment table-5 as given in Appendix-II. On the
contention of the appellant that his pay had been downgraded by the
respondent University when the provisional fixation of pay of the
appellant was at Rs. 51,850/-, the learned counsel submits that the
appellant had himself signed an undertaking on 28.01.2009 to the
effect that any excess payment made to him as a result of incorrect
fixation or any other reasons would be refunded by him. Learned
counsel strongly contends that not only was this undertaking
suppressed at the time of filing the writ petition, but in fact demolishes
the case of the appellant from its very root itself. He then concludes his
submissions, by maintaining that the learned Single Judge had rightly
decided the matter and that the writ appeal deserves no consideration.
7.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and
considered their submissions. As noted earlier and also as advanced by
the learned counsel for the parties, the only two aspects on which the
entire case of the writ appellant hinges upon are re-fixation of the pay
scale and the purported denial of advance increments. In this backdrop,
in an Intra-Court Mandamus appeal, we are required therefore only to
WA No. 56 of 2014
examine whether the impugned judgment suffers from any palpable
infirmity or perversity based on the findings arrived at by the learned
Single Judge in respect of the two aspects indicated hereinabove.
8.
From the impugned order, it is evident that the learned
Single Judge has gone into great detail and examined all aspects of the
matter, as put forth by the appellant and countered by the respondents.
It is noted from paragraph-3 of the judgment itself, that the learned
Single Judge has observed as follows:
“3. It appears from the pleaded case of the petitioner in
the writ petition that the writ petitioner had interpreted the
scheme of revision of pay of teachers and equivalent
cadres in the universities and colleges following the
revision of pay scales of Central Govt. employees on the
recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission
under the letter of the Govt. of India, Ministry of Human
Resource Development, Department of Higher Education,
New Delhi dated 31.12.2008 to the Secretary, UGC and
the fitments tables for fixation of salary prepared by the
UGC in pursuance to the scheme of revision of pay (a)
teachers and equivalent cadres and (b) administrative
posts in the universities and colleges following the revision
of pay scales of the Central Govt. employees on the
recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission in
such a manner that the revision of pay scales of Professors
of NEHU once made by the authority of NEHU, even if it
is provisional, could not be altered to the disadvantage of
the petitioner and also the petitioner is trying to justify,
without any rational reasons, the provisional fixation of
revised pay of Professors by the University-NEHU before
receiving the fitments table for fixation of salary prepared
by the UGC vide Resolution No. 6 of the 23rd Emergent
Meeting of the Executive Council of NEHU wherein, the
Executive
Council
resolved
to
approve
the
recommendation of the academic council to accept the
revision of pay scales etc. as per MHRD‟s letter dated
31.12.2008 and the payment of arrears up to 40% of the
total arrears be made latest by Wednesday 25th February,
2009 and also the petitioner by relying on the Circular
dated 28.07.2011 issued by the NEHU claimed for three
advance increments for holding Ph.D. degree as grant for
incentives.”
WA No. 56 of 2014
9.
The learned Single Judge has noted that the Ministry of
Human Resources Development, Department of Higher Education,
under letter dated 31.12.2008 had informed the Scheme of Revision of
Pay of teachers and equivalent cadres in the Universities and Colleges,
following the recommendations of the 6th Central Pay Commission to
the Secretary, UGC. The Scheme also mandated that the Universities
implementing the Scheme shall be advised by UGC to amend the
relevant Statutes and Ordinances in line with the UGC Regulations
within 3(three) months from the date of issue of the letter.
Accordingly, the respondent University, pursuant to the said Scheme
of Revision of Pay scales dated 31.12.2008 at the 23rd Emergent
meeting of the Executive Council held on 20.02.2009, resolved to
approve the recommendations of the Academic Council to accept the
Revision of Pay scales, etc. and that payment of arrears upto 40% of
the total arrears were to be made latest by 25.02.2009. It is apparent
that it was only in this context that the respondent University
provisionally revised the pay scale of the writ appellant and other
Professors and the provisional revised pay of the petitioner on the basis
of the basic pay, which was Rs. 21,900/- per month as on 01.01.2006
was fixed at Rs. 51,850/- in the pay band of Rs. 37,400-67,000/- +
Academic Grade Pay of Rs. 10,000/-.
10.
Consequently, the UGC in pursuance to the Scheme dated
31.12.2008 on 30.06.2010 brought out “The UGC Regulations on
minimum qualifications for appointment of teachers and other
academic staff in Universities and Colleges and measures for
maintenance of standards in higher education, 2010. Under this
WA No. 56 of 2014
Regulation of 2010, the essential qualifications of PhD for Professor
was mentioned and also the fitment table of fixation of salary of
Professors in the Universities and Colleges was given. As per the said
fitment table, which is reproduced in the impugned order at paragraph8, it can be clearly seen that the pre-revised pay of the writ appellant
which was Rs. 21,900/-, as on 01.01.2006, by application of the
fitment table would now be in the pay band of Rs. 48,870 with the
revised basic pay fixed at Rs. 58,870/-. As such, the fitment being as
per the prescribed fitment table, the claim of the writ- appellant that his
revised scale be reckoned from the pay provisionally fixed by the
respondent University (NEHU) at Rs. 51,870/- as on 01.01.2006
instead of the admitted amount of Rs. 21,900/- as on 01.01.2006, does
not hold any water and the findings of the learned Single Judge in this
regard cannot be faulted with.
11.
As discussed and noted earlier, the respondent University
had revised the pay scale of the writ appellant and other teachers
provisionally only for the purpose of releasing 40% of the arrears and
that on receipt of the Fitment Table, the writ-appellant as well as other
Professors had been placed in the appropriate pay band. The writ
appellant himself – it can be safely inferred – being aware that the pay
was provisional had executed an undertaking on 06.03.2009 to refund
any amount caused by incorrect fixation of pay in a revised scale, in
order to avail of the 40% arrears, which was based on the provisional
fixation. This undertaking was never disclosed by the writ petitioner in
his writ petition. The suppression by the writ appellant of this fact has
also been noted and recorded by the learned Single Judge, and the said
WA No. 56 of 2014
undertaking is also reproduced at paragraph-14 of the impugned
judgment.
12.
At this stage, we must observe, it is palpably evident that
the writ-appellant had suppressed material facts before the First Court.
As such, his bona fides immediately became suspect. Discretionary
relief under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is not available to a
person such as the writ-appellant. He has, in fact, abused the process of
Court by indulging in such suppression of material facts by not
disclosing the undertaking which he had himself furnished before the
respondent University. In this context, the observations of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in three of its judgments were noticed by one of us
(Biswanath Somadder), while rendering a judgment on 3rd August,
2016 in W.P. 5296 (W) of 2016 (Madhusudan Ghosh vs. State of West
Bengal) reported in AIR 2016 (NOC) 740 (CAL.) = 2017(1) CHN
(CAL) 233, in paragraphs 7, 8 and 9, which are reproduced
hereinbelow:“7. In this context, one may take notice of the judgments
rendered by the Supreme Court in Prestige Lights Ltd.
vs. State Bank of India, reported in (2007) 8 SCC 449:
(2007 AIR SCW 5350); K.D. Sharma vs. Steel Authority
of India Limited, reported in (2008) 12 SCC 481 : (AIR
2009 SC (Supp) 1309) and Dalip Singh vs. State of Uttar
Pradesh and others, reported in (2010) 2 SCC 114 :
(AIR 2010 SC (Supp)116).
8. As it is palpably evident that the petitioner has
suppressed material facts, his bonafides immediately
become suspect. Discretionary relief under Article 226
of the Constitution of India is not available to a person
such as the writ petitioner. However, should the writ
Court stop at that? The answer is a clear and
unequivocal, no. The ratio of the judgments of the
Supreme Court„ “referred hereinbefore „ “goes even a
step further. While following the ratio of the decision
rendered by the King— s Bench in R. v. Kensington
Income Tax Commissioners, reported in (1917) 1 KB
WA No. 56 of 2014
486 (CA), it has been observed to the effect that a writ
petitioner who does not come with candid facts and
„clean breast‟ cannot hold a writ of the Court with
„soiled hands‟. Suppression or concealment of material
facts is not an advocacy. It is a jugglery, manipulation,
manoeuvring or misrepresentation, which has no place
in equitable and prerogative jurisdiction. If the writ
petitioner does not disclose all material facts fairly and
truly, but states them in a distorted manner and
misleads the Court, the Court has inherent power in
order to protect itself and to prevent an abuse of its
process to discharge the Rule NISI and refuse to
proceed further with the examination of the case on
merits. If the Court does not reject the petition on that
ground, the Court would be failing in its duty. In fact,
such a writ petitioner requires to be dealt with for
contempt of Court for abusing the process of the Court.
9. Based on the above observations„ “ culled out from
the ratio of the three judgments of the Supreme Court‟
“ and applying them in the facts of the instant case,
this Court is of the view that not only the bona fides of
the writ petitioner are suspect‟ “having suppressed
material facts‟ “ by such action, he has also abused the
process of Court by seeking to invoke the high
prerogative jurisdiction of this Court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India, which is essentially
discretionary in nature.”
Madhusudan Ghosh (supra) was later relied upon and
followed by a Division Bench of the High Court at Calcutta in a
judgment and order rendered on 7th February, 2017 in FMA 19 of
2017 with CAN 10660 of 2016 (Raj Kapoor Jaiswal & Anr vs. State
of West Bengal & Ors).
13.
On the second aspect, i.e. the entitlement to draw three
advance increments, the arguments, as put forward and averred on
affidavit by the respondent University and as also observed by the
learned Single Judge, that a PhD being a minimum requirement for the
post of Professor which the writ-appellant is holding, the claim for
advance increments on the attendant facts and circumstances is totally
misplaced and unsustainable.
WA No. 56 of 2014
14.
For reasons stated above, in the absence of any palpable
infirmity or perversity, we do not find any cogent or justifiable reason
to interfere with the impugned judgment and order passed by the
learned Single Judge while sitting in an Intra-Court Mandamus
Appellate jurisdiction. The writ-appeal is therefore liable to be
dismissed and stands accordingly dismissed.
(H.S. Thangkhiew)
Judge
(BiswanathSomadder)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
11.02.2021
“V. Lyndem PS”
WA No. 56 of 2014
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review