Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC012533362017
+
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
PROF. DR. RASHMI BHARDWAJ
.....Petitioner
Through: Ms. Megha Sharma, Advocate.
versus
VICE CHANCELLOR, GURU GOBIND SINGH INDRAPRASTHA
UNIVERSITY & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Jasbir Bidhuri, Mr. Aditya Mani
Sharma, Advocates for R-1 & 2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
19.08.2026
%
1.
The short controversy is whether the Petitioner’s service as an ad hoc
Lecturer in Mathematics at Acharya Narendra Dev College [“ANDC”]
(University of Delhi) from 31st August 1996 to 21st June 1999 counts as
qualifying past service for career advancement at Guru Gobind Singh
Indraprastha University [“GGSIPU”]. GGSIPU reviewed her claim multiple
times and ultimately rejected it by a decision dated 21 st November 2016,
which is now challenged in this petition.
Factual Background
2.
The Petitioner joined ANDC on 31st August, 1996. Her initial
appointment was expressly on an ad hoc basis, for a period not exceeding
four months or until the end of the term, whichever was earlier. Similar
appointments followed thereafter. The last such term ended on 30 th April,
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
1999. On 22nd June, 1999, she joined GGSIPU as a regularly selected
Lecturer in Mathematics.
3.
The events between 30th April and 22nd June, 1999 are central to the
controversy. A certificate issued by ANDC on 26 th June, 2006 records that
the Petitioner worked as an ad hoc Lecturer in Mathematics from 31st
August, 1996 to 30th April, 1999 “with usual breaks” and functioned as
Deputy Superintendent of the annual theory examinations from 1st May to
21st June, 1999. A subsequent certificate dated 8th February, 2010, also
issued by ANDC, records that she was paid ex gratia on account of summer
vacation salary for the period from 1st May to 21st June, 1999.
4.
DU was asked to clarify, and in its response of 14 th March, 2012,
confirmed that the Petitioner served as an ad hoc Lecturer from 31st August,
1996 to 21st June, 1999, with vacation payments made as ex gratia. DU also
stated these payments did not break service and were counted under its
Merit Promotion Scheme.
5.
The Petitioner sought counting of this service for her placement as
Lecturer (Senior Scale) and for consequential progression under the Career
Advancement Scheme. Her claim was examined on more than one occasion.
Ultimately, by communication dated 21st November, 2016, GGSIPU
informed her that the Committee constituted for the purpose had concluded
that the “requirements for counting of past service are not fulfilled”.
Petitioner’s Contentions
6.
Ms. Megha Sharma, counsel for the Petitioner, makes the following
submissions:
6.1.
GGSIPU wrongly assumed that the ad hoc nature of prior
appointments excluded them from service consideration. GGSIPU’s Statute
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
31, Clause 11.1.6 allows for ad hoc service over one year to count towards
career advancement if conditions are met. The Petitioner served
continuously at ANDC since 31st August, 1996, in the Lecturer’s scale, and
these appointments should be viewed as a single academic engagement, not
as unrelated terms.
6.2.
The ex gratia summer vacation salary paid from 1st May to 21st June,
1999, along with DU’s clarification that this did not interrupt service for the
Merit Promotion Scheme, confirms service continuity. The Petitioner also
served as Deputy Superintendent of the annual theory examinations during
this period and received remuneration, further supporting ongoing
engagement with ANDC.
6.3.
The requirement for selection by a duly constituted Selection
Committee was met. The Petitioner was appointed from the Department of
Mathematics, DU’s ad hoc panel, with a recommendation documented by
the Head of Department via the Selection Committee. ANDC’s later
statement to the Central Information Commission about missing selection
records does not prove that no Selection Committee existed.
6.4.
The requirement to apply through the proper channel was
unwarranted, as the Petitioner’s appointment at ANDC ended on 30th April,
1999, and she applied on 4th May, 1999, when she held no position for
routing her application.
GGSIPU’s Contentions
7.
Opposing the petition, Mr. Jasbir Bidhuri, counsel for Respondents
No. 1 and 2, submits as follows:
7.1.
The petition is liable to be dismissed on delay and laches. The
Petitioner’s claim was previously rejected and communicated in 2009, but
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
no timely challenge was made. Despite ongoing representations, the
Petitioner only approached the Court in 2017 regarding a placement from
2000, after accepting career advancements. Changing these dates now could
impact the seniority of other faculty members not involved in this petition.
7.2.
The Petitioner does not meet multiple cumulative conditions for
counting past service. Each ANDC appointment was ad hoc for no more
than four months, with new appointments issued rather than continuous
employment. Thus, the time from 31st August, 1996 to 21st June, 1999
cannot be considered as uninterrupted ad hoc service. Additionally, her
application to GGSIPU acknowledged her tenure at ANDC ended on 30 th
April, 1999, and since she joined GGSIPU on 22nd June, 1999, a break in
service occurred.
7.3.
The payment to the Petitioner between 1st May and 21st June, 1999
does not show she remained a Lecturer after her appointment ended on 30 th
April, 1999. She performed duties as Deputy Superintendent of the annual
theory examinations during this time. DU’s communication about vacation
salary does not define her appointment status, which must be confirmed by
ANDC records. The 26th June, 2006 certificate from ANDC also notes her
ad hoc service included “usual breaks”.
7.4.
The Petitioner failed to apply through the proper channel, as her
application to GGSIPU was not routed via ANDC per Clause 11.1.3 of
GGSIPU’s Statute 31.
7.5.
The appointment did not follow the requirement for a duly constituted
Selection Committee. According to ANDC’s letter dated 3rd February, 2012,
no such Committee existed; instead, the Petitioner was appointed from the
Department of Mathematics, DU’s ad hoc panel.
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
Analysis
Statutory Framework Governing Counting of Past Service
8.
Clause 11 of GGSIPU’s Statute 31, on which both sides have placed
substantial reliance, provides for counting past service for placement in
Senior Scale/Selection Grade and reads as follows:
“11. COUNTING OF PAST SERVICE
11.1 Previous service, if any, without any break as a lecturer or
equivalent in a university, college, national laboratory, or other
scientific organizations, e.g. CSIR, ICAR, DRDO, UGC, ICSSR, ICHR
and as a UGC research scientist, shall be counted for placement of
lecturer in senior scale/selection grade provided that
11.1.1 the post had an equivalent grade/scale of pay as that of a
lecturer in the University.
11.1.2 the qualifications for the post were not lower than the
qualifications prescribed by the University for the post of lecturer.
11.1.3 the teachers applied to the University for appointment through
proper channel.
11.1.4 the concerned lecturer possesses the minimum qualifications
prescribed by the University for appointment as lecturer.
11.1.5 the post at which he is currently working in the University was
filled in accordance with the prescribed selection procedure as laid
down by the University.
11.1.6 the appointment was not ad-hoc or against a leave vacancy of
less than one year’s duration. Ad-hoc service of more than one year’s
duration can be counted provided that
(a) the incumbent was appointed on the recommendation of a
duly constituted selection committee; and
(b) the incumbent was selected to the permanent post in
continuation to the ad-hoc service without any break.
11.2 Provisions of clause 11.1 above will also be applicable mutatis
mutandis while considering eligibility for promotion to the posts of
reader (promotion) and professor (promotion).”
[Emphasis Supplied]
9.
Clause 11 allows prior service as a Lecturer or equivalent to be
counted toward placement in the Senior Scale/Selection Grade, provided
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
certain conditions are met. Clause 11.1.6 covers ad hoc service over one
year, requiring appointment by a Selection Committee and selection to a
permanent post without interruption. All other Clause 11.1 requirements,
including applying through proper channels, also apply.
10.
The significance of this scheme is that the description of an
appointment as “ad hoc” is not, by itself, determinative. The provision itself
recognises ad hoc service as capable of being counted where the conditions
prescribed therein are satisfied.
Whether the Petitioner’s Service Constituted Qualifying Continuous Service
11.
GGSIPU notes that the Petitioners’ appointment orders never
exceeded four months or an academic term, but this alone is not decisive.
Clause 11.1.6 refers to “ad hoc service of more than one year’s duration”,
without requiring a single uninterrupted appointment. When ad hoc
appointments are made consecutively each term, the key issue is whether
these amount to qualifying service over the required period, and if there
were breaks as defined by the rule.
12.
According to a 31st August, 2010 GGSIPU committee review, ad hoc
service periods with intermittent paid vacations are not considered breaks in
service under Clause 4 of DU’s Ordinance XII. Thus, issuing separate
appointment orders alone does not break continuity of service.
13.
GGSIPU claims there was a service break between 1 st May and 21st
June, 1999. Some documents, like the Petitioner’s application from 4th May,
1999 and an ANDC certificate from 26th June, 2006, show her ad hoc
appointment ended on 30th April, 1999, with “usual breaks” noted. She also
served as Deputy Superintendent of the annual theory examinations from 1st
May to 21st June, 1999. However, these records only confirm the teaching
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
term ended on 30th April and do not prove the summer vacation was a break
in service.
14.
The vacation period was clarified when ANDC certified the Petitioner
received ex gratia summer salary from 1st May to 21st June, 1999. DU’s
response on 14th March, 2012 confirmed she served as an ad hoc Lecturer
from 31st August, 1996 to 21st June, 1999, including the paid vacation, and
that such payment did not constitute a break in service but was countable
under the Merit Promotion Scheme. Therefore, the vacation period was
considered part of her service.
15.
GGSIPU refers to Clause 4 of DU’s Ordinance XII, asserting that
vacation counts as continuous service only if the teacher is reappointed and
present on reopening day. Since the Petitioner did not return after summer
break, GGSIPU argues she cannot benefit from this clause. However, DU
addressed this specific case, counting service up to 21 st June 1999 as part of
her ad hoc service for the Merit Promotion Scheme. The Petitioner does not
claim service beyond 21st June, having joined GGSIPU on 22nd June. Given
these facts, considering 1st May to 21st June as a service gap is unwarranted.
Whether the Selection Committee Requirement Was Satisfied
16.
The objection regarding the Selection Committee merits closer
review. On 3rd February 2012, ANDC informed GGSIPU that “there was no
duly constituted Selection Committee” and that the Petitioner’s ad hoc
appointment had been made from an ad hoc panel formed by the
Department of Mathematics, DU. If this were the end of the matter, the
objection would be valid.
17.
However, the matter did not end there. The Petitioner has furnished a
letter dated 10th January, 2001 requesting the Head of the Department of
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
Mathematics, DU to certify that her name had been recommended by the
duly constituted committee for ad hoc appointments. The handwritten
endorsement made by the Head on the letter records:
“Her name was recommended through the selection committee for ad hoc
appointments in the colleges.”
18.
There is an additional issue with ANDC’s categorical claim in 2012:
when the Petitioner requested the panel, committee constitution, and minutes
under the Right to Information Act, ANDC responded via affidavit that the
information was “not available with the College”. On 24th December, 2013,
the Central Information Commission noted that ANDC could not clarify its
earlier reference to the DU ad hoc panel and ordered a renewed search for
the records.
19.
Clause 11.1.6 does not stipulate that the Selection Committee must
issue the appointment letter, nor that a new committee be constituted by
each college. It only requires that the appointment follows the
recommendation of a duly formed Selection Committee. Given the facts,
this requirement should not be held against the Petitioner.
Whether Requirement of Applying Through Proper Channel Was Satisfied
20.
The only remaining issue is the requirement to apply through the
proper channel. Rules on counting past service should be interpreted
consistently.
21.
The Petitioner applied to GGSIPU on 4th May 1999, stating her
engagement with ANDC ended on 30th April 1999 and that she had no
current employment. If this is accurate, there was no employment on 4 th
May, 1999 to route the application through. Thus, requiring compliance with
the proper-channel rule contradicts GGSIPU’s own facts.
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
Delay and Laches
22.
The objection regarding delay merits consideration. Repeated
representations, by themselves, do not revive a stale service claim or furnish
a fresh cause of action, as recognised in C. Jacob v. Director of Geology
and Mining & Anr.1 and Union of India & Ors. v. M.K. Sarkar2.
23.
However, the present case does not warrant outright rejection of the
writ petition. After the 2009 decision, further material emerged, including
the ANDC certificate dated 8th February, 2010 regarding ex gratia summer
vacation salary and the clarification issued by DU on 14 th March, 2012.
GGSIPU also continued to constitute committees and consider the claim
until 2016, culminating in the decision dated 21st November, 2016.
24.
The passage of time must nevertheless be taken into account while
moulding the relief. As held in Union of India & Ors. v. Tarsem Singh3,
claims relating to seniority or promotion are more susceptible to delay and
laches where the rights of others may be affected, while consequential
monetary relief for a past period may ordinarily be restricted to three years
preceding the filing of the writ petition.
Conclusion and Relief
25.
Promotional benefits should not be granted automatically as
requested. Qualifying service length is determined by counting past service.
Placement under the Career Advancement Scheme also requires meeting
additional conditions such as assessments, prescribed courses, and
performance criteria. GGSIPU must reassess after crediting previously
excluded service.
(2008) 10 SCC 115.
(2010) 2 SCC 59.
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
26.
The writ petition is, accordingly, allowed in the following terms:
(i)
The order dated 21st November, 2016 is set aside.
(ii)
The Petitioner’s service as Lecturer at ANDC from 31st August, 1996
to 21st June, 1999 will count as qualifying past service under the Career
Advancement Scheme.
(iii)
GGSIPU must recalculate the Petitioner’s eligibility for placement as
Lecturer (Senior Scale) and all subsequent stages under the applicable
Career Advancement Scheme, giving credit for this prior service. Notional
placements will be granted from the dates when she met the requirements
for each stage.
(iv)
If an assessment or selection is needed for a particular stage, GGSIPU
shall conduct it based on the relevant service record for that period.
(v)
The exercise shall not disturb the inter se seniority or any settled
rights of third parties.
(vi)
Monetary arrears, if found payable upon consequential refixation of
pay, shall be confined to the period of three years preceding the filing of this
writ petition. In view of the delay with which the claim has reached the
Court, no interest shall be payable on such arrears.
(vii) The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within twelve weeks from
today.
27.
The present writ petition, along with any pending application(s), is
disposed of in the above terms.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
AUGUST 19, 2026/ab
(2008) 8 SCC 648.
W.P.(C) 4767/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 29/08/2026 at 16:23:15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review