Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No.J(2)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present : The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya
&
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandip Kumar De
WPLRT 133 of 2013
Sri Prodeep Chatterjee and Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal and Ors.
with
WPLRT 206 of 2013
Sri Prodeep Chatterjee @ Pradip Kumar Chatterjee and Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal and Ors.
For the petitioners in both
matters
:
Mr. Mrinal Kanti Ghosh,
Mr. Santimay Bhattacharyya,
Mr. Anirban Das,
Ms. Aloka Bhattacharyya, Advs.
For the State in WPLRT
133 of 2013
:
Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharjee,
Senior Standing Counsel,
Ms. Ayana Banerjee,
Mr. Nilanjan Paul, Advs.
For the State in WPLRT
206 of 2013
:
Mr. Nilanjan Bhattacharjee,
Senior Standing Counsel,
Mr. Abhilash Chatterjee,
Ms. Ayana Banerjee, Advs.
Heard on
:
September 10, 2026.
Judgment on
:
September 10, 2026.
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya , J.:
1.
Both the writ petitions are being taken up for hearing together in
view of the identity of the issues involved.
2.
The present challenge has been preferred against a common
judgment whereby the learned Tribunal affirmed the decision of the
Appellate Authority, thereby setting aside orders passed under Section
17 of the West Bengal Land Reforms Act, 1955 terminating the
cultivation by the bargadars i.e. the private respondent in each of the
matters on the ground that the land was not cultivated by the
bargadars personally.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that initially an order
was obtained under Section 16 of the 1955 Act by the writ petitioners
against the private respondent in each of the matters, where the private
respondents were directed to deliver their share of produce to the writ
petitioners. However, it is submitted that such order was not complied
with and execution proceeding has to be initiated in that regard.
Subsequently, the writ petitioners took out applications for termination
of the private respondent in each of the cases as bargadars on the
ground that the possession and right of cultivation in respect of the
subject lands were parted by them in favour of third parties; thus, the
private respondents no longer cultivated the said lands.
4.
Orders were accordingly passed by the concerned authority
terminating the cultivation of the private respondents as bargadars.
5.
Appeals were preferred against the said orders, which were allowed.
Being aggrieved thereby, the Tribunal was approached by the writ
petitioners by way of two Original Applications, leading to the present
impugned common judgment dismissing both the challenges. In the
meantime, the writ petitioners had approached the writ court for
deleting the names of the private respondents as bargadars, which was
disposed of by directing the authorities to consider the representation
of the writ petitioners in that regard.
6.
It is contended by learned counsel for the petitioners that the
Tribunal as well as the Appellate Authority proceeded on three
premises. First, that the proceedings under Section 17 were initiated
suo motu. Secondly, no opportunity of hearing was given to the private
respondents. Thirdly, there was no execution of the termination orders,
thus, the pre-requisite of Section 17 not being satisfied.
7.
Learned counsel places at length the several orders passed by the
by the Bhag Chas Officer which indicate that notice was directed to be
given to the private respondents. Although one of the private
respondents, being Sk. Ali Hossain, did not appear before the authority
consistently, his brother Niyamat had been appearing before the Bhag
Chas Officer and had been specifically directed to either file a power of
attorney on behalf of his brother or to notify the said brother Sk. Ali
Hossain to appear personally. Despite such repeated directions, Sk. Ali
Hossain never appeared to contest the proceeding. Hence, it is
submitted that the ground of lack of opportunity of hearing being given
to the private respondents is not supported by the records.
8.
Secondly, the proceedings were not initiated suo motu but on
specific applications under Section 17 being filed by the writ
petitioners.
9.
not
Thirdly, the question of execution of the termination orders does
arise,
since
Section
itself
contemplates
termination
of
cultivation by bargadars in the event the bargadar is not cultivating the
land personally. Thus, the learned Tribunal and the Appellate
Authority erred in law in proceeding on such premise.
10.
Learned counsel takes the Court through the orders of the Bhag
Chas Officer for the further purpose of showing that initially a field
enquiry was held, as per the directive of the Bhag Chas Officer, by the
concerned S.D.O. and B.L. & L.R.O. The report filed upon such enquiry
being conducted indicated the names of several persons who were in
apparently unauthorized occupation of the subject lands. Opportunity
was given to those persons to appear before the Bhag Chas Officer,
upon which their deposition was taken. At least one of those persons
categorically deposed that there was an arrangement entered into upon
consideration between the said person and the private respondents for
cultivating the lands, which had continued for more than two years.
Relying on the same, the Bhag Chas Officer passed an order under
Section 17 of the 1955 Act.
11.
It is submitted that much later, the Tribunal proceeded on the
premise
of
subsequent
reports
apparently,
filed
by the
police
authorities as well as the then B.L. & L.R.O., which indicated that the
private respondents were forcibly evicted with the help of police and
paramilitary forces by the petitioners, taking advantage of their “good
office”.
12.
However, it also came out in evidence as recorded by the Tribunal
that the petitioner conducting the matter was an employee of the Post
and Telegraph Department; thus, he could not have anything to do
with any paramilitary force. Moreover, such contention was never
raised by the private respondents before the Bhag Chas Officer at the
relevant point of time.
13.
Learned counsel places reliance on an unreported judgment of a
coordinate Bench of this Court dated April 3, 2025, passed in WPLRT
39 of 2024, where it was held that non-cultivation of the land for two
consecutive years by itself is a good ground for eviction of a bargadar
under the provisions of Section 17 of the 1955 Act. It was further held
that the quantum fixed in the bhag chas case found to be due and
payable by the private respondents to the writ petitioner was not paid
by the private respondents and non-payment of the share of crop is
another ground for eviction of the bargadar.
14.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel appearing for the State points out
that before the Appellate Authority and the Tribunal, sufficient
materials were produced by way of reports authored by the B.L. &
L.R.O. as well as the police authorities to indicate that there was foul
play on the part of the writ petitioners in forcibly evicting the private
respondents, who were existing bargadars at the relevant point of time,
with the help of police and paramilitary forces. It is submitted that
such reports ought not to be brushed aside.
15.
Furthermore, the learned Tribunal came to a conclusion on the
basis of materials before it that the writ petitioner had concocted a
story about the bargadars/private respondents having parted with the
property in favour of third parties, by implanting a witness with whom
the writ petitioners had an arrangement to sell the subject lands. It is
thus submitted that at best, the matter ought to be remanded to the
Bhag Chas Officer to consider such subsequent developments and to
come to a reasoned conclusion in the light thereof.
16.
Learned Senior Standing Counsel takes the Court at length
through the observations of the learned Tribunal in support of his
contentions.
17.
It is further submitted by learned Senior Standing Counsel that the
ground of non-payment of share of crops cannot stand any more, since
it was recorded by the Appellate Authority that the existence of several
receipts were admitted by the person conducting the litigation on was
sufficient proof of payment of their share of the produce by the private
respondents/bargadars.
18.
Upon a careful perusal of the materials before us, we find that the
ground of lack of opportunity being given to the private respondents by
the Bhag Chas Officer cannot be sustained. From at least seven to
eight orders passed by the Bhag Chas Officer, we find that several
directions were given to serve notice on the non-appearing private
respondent Sk. Ali Hossain. At the same time, his brother Niyamat,
who was all along contesting the proceeding, was present and
contested the proceeding tooth and nail.
19.
We do not find any objection on the part of the private respondents
to the fact that a direction was issued by the Bhag Chas Officer on
Niyamat to furnish a power of attorney from his brother Sk. Ali Hossain
on the next occasion and/or to ask Sk. Ali Hossain to be personally
present. Despite such repeated opportunities, Sk. Ali Hossain, one of
the private respondents, did not appear personally.
However, his
interest was sufficiently represented by Niyamat, his brother, who is
the other private respondent and stands on similar footing as Sk. Ali
Hussain. It is nobody’s case that the relation between Niyamat and Sk.
Ali Hussain, being brothers, was ever strained or that they had
different interests in the litigation.
20.
More importantly, the question of the conducting writ petitioner
using his office to evict the private respondent with the help of police
and paramilitary forces can easily be ruled out in view of the finding of
the learned Tribunal itself that the said writ petitioner was an employee
of the Post and Telegraph Department. No connection whatsoever
between the writ petitioners and the paramilitary forces or the police
has been established before any of the forums below.
21.
Secondly, it is a complete third case made out for the first time
before the Appellate Authority and the Tribunal. Despite several
opportunities and several hearings, such point was never urged by
Niyamat or the absentee private respondent Sk. Ali Hussain before the
Bhag Chas Officer. Not a whisper of any forcible eviction by the writ
petitioners with the help of police and paramilitary forces was ever
raised before the Bhag Chas Officer throughout the proceedings, which
went on for a considerable period of time, involving several orders.
Thus, the private respondents cannot be permitted to raise a third case
on such count subsequently.
22.
More importantly, it could not be a case that the writ petitioners
“implanted” witnesses to substantiate their case. We find from the
orders of the Bhag Chas Officer that an independent enquiry was
directed to be made on the field by the S.D.O. and the B.L. & L.R.O.
upon which a report in that regard was filed after such enquiry, from
which the specific names of the persons who were in unauthorized
occupation of the subject lands were disclosed. Thus, it is not the writ
petitioners
who
had
produced
the
transferees
of
the
private
respondents as witnesses, but the names of such transferees came out
from an independent field inquiry report authored by the then S.D.O.
and B.L. & L.R.O. There is not an iota of allegation against the integrity
of the S.D.O. and the B.L. & L.R.O. concerned. The Bhag Chas Officer
even went to the extent of directing a notice of such enquiry to be given
to Sk. Ali Hussain whereas Niyamat, the other private respondent, was
very well in the know of the said order.
23.
It is only on the premise of such report that those third
parties/unauthorised occupants were also directed to appear before
the Bhag Chas Officer by the Bhag Chas Officer himself, upon which
some of those persons physically appeared. Thereafter, at least one of
them gave deposition before the Bhag Chas Officer, as recorded in the
orders of the Bhag Chas Officer, and categorically admitted a financial
arrangement between the private respondents and the said person
regarding the subject properties, whereby the private respondents
permitted those third parties to cultivate on the lands, thereby ceasing
to cultivate the lands themselves.
24.
Throughout the proceedings, the petitioners had nothing to do with
the unauthorised occupants and did not bring the witnesses of their
own, but the witnesses were named in a report authored by
independent authorities and were also directed to appear before the
Bhag Chas Officer. They did appear and depose before the Bhag Chas
Officer, which was never rebutted by any cogent evidence by the private
respondents.
Thus, as on the date of passing of the orders under
Section 17 by the Bhag Chas Officer, all evidence unerringly pointed to
the fact that the private respondents had parted with the cultivation of
the subject lands in favour of third parties in an unauthorised manner
and therefore came within the mischief of Section 17(1)(b) of the 1955
Act.
25.
Another important aspect of the matter is that the learned Tribunal
relied on certain purported reports filed post facto as an afterthought.
Such reports were apparently of the year 1996, that is, seven years
after the order of the Bhag Chas Officer. It defies logic as to how, seven
years after the alleged incident, the police or the then B.L. & L.R.O.
could become aware of the fact that there was forcible eviction with the
help of police and paramilitary forces seven years back.
26.
Evidently,
such
reports
are
not
corroborated
by
the
contemporaneous events which happened at the time of passing of the
order in the year 1989 by the Bhag Chas Officer and/or even the stand
taken by the private respondents at that relevant juncture.
27.
Thus, the orders of the Appellate Authority and the Tribunal are
palpably perverse, being based not on any cogent evidence but on
conjecture and surmise not borne out by any contemporaneous
material which was before the Bhag Chas Officer at the time of passing
of the orders under Section 17 of the 1955 Act. Subsequent reports,
uncorroborated by any real evidence of forcible dispossession of the
private respondents, without even a single application by any of the
private respondents under Section 19B of the 1955 Act alleging
dispossession and seeking restoration of possession at any point of
time, cannot be the substitute of concrete evidence, on the strength of
which the Bhag Chas Officer passed the orders under Section 17. Such
post facto frivolous reports are not even worth the paper on which they
were written and, as such, could not be taken into consideration
subsequently to vitiate retrospectively orders passed seven years back
by the Bhag Chas Officer. Thus, the entire premise of the impugned
judgment and those of the Appellate Authority are based on loose sand.
28.
In such view of the matter, WPLRT 133 of 2013 and WPLRT 116 of
2022 are allowed on contest, thereby setting aside the impugned
common judgment dated January 4, 2013 passed by the Fourth Bench
of the West Bengal Land Reforms and Tenancy Tribunal in TA No. 23 of
2002 and TA No. 24 of 2002 (LRTT) as well as the common judgment of
the Appellate Authority which was affirmed by the Tribunal.
29.
Accordingly, the orders passed under Section 17 of the 1955 Act by
the Bhag Chas Officer, terminating the cultivation by the private
respondents in the capacity of bargadars in both the matters, are
upheld.
30.
Liberty is given to the writ petitioners to take appropriate steps for
correction of the Records of Rights in consonance with the orders of the
Bhag
Chas
Officer
terminating
the
cultivation
of
the
private
respondents as bargadars. If such steps are taken, the concerned
authorities shall decide the same in accordance with law by passing
reasoned orders.
31.
There will be no order as to costs.
32.
Urgent Photostat certified copies of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of requisite formalities.
I agree.
(Sandip Kumar De, J.)
AD -4-5
Ct No.16
(SSS)
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review