The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. We are, therefore, of the view that the learned Single Judge has drawn an appropriate conclusion, which cannot be faulted. This appeal being devoid of merit and is, therefore, dismissed.
15. Learned advocate for the Appellants submits that since the Applicants in Civil Application Nos.1 and 2 of 2026 in W.P.A. 20825 of 2026, had also approached the learned Single Judge and were given audience in the hearing and their submissions were also recorded after hearing the learned Senior Advocate, Sri Subir Sanyal, that these Applicants may be arrayed as Respondents in the present appeal. Hence, Civil Application No.1 and 2 of 2026 are allowed by consent, to the extent of adding these Applicants as Respondents in the appeal. Addition be carried out within a week’s time. Re-verification is dispensed with.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ORDER SHEET
WBCHCA0478422026
Ct. No.1
Sl. No.4
PG/KS
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
MAT 1567 of 2026
with
I.A. No. CAN 1 of 2026
PROBIR KUMAR MUKHOPADHYAY & ANR.
Versus
THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS.
Appearance:
Mr. Biswaroop Bhattacharya
Mr. Arka Kumar Nag
Ms. Shrobana Sengupta
Mr. Kaushik Bandyopadhyay
Ms. Sneha Sarkar
Mr. Srijib Chakraborty
Mr. Aditya Mondal
Ms. Sudeshna Mondal
Mr. Subir Sanyal
Mr. Surojit Mukherjee
…..Advocates For the Appellants
…..Advocates For the Applicant
I.A. No. CAN 2 of 2026 in
WPA 20825 of 2026
….Advocates For the Applicant in
I.A. No. CAN 1 of 2026 in
WPA 20825 of 2026
CORAM : RAVINDRA VITHALRAO GHUGE,
CHIEF JUSTICE
&
ARIJIT BANERJEE, J.
2/9
DATE : 18.09.2026
FINAL ORDER (per: Ravindra Vithalrao Ghuge, CJ)
1.
We have heard the learned Counsel appearing for the
parties at length and with their consent, we are disposing off the
Appeal.
3.
The Appellants are before us, being aggrieved by the
order passed by the learned Single Judge dated 28.08.2026 in WPA
20825 of 2026 with CAN 1 of 2026 and CAN 2 of 2026.
4.
The learned Counsel for the Appellants has extensively
canvassed the grounds before us, which can be summarised as under:
(a)
The Police Authorities are partisan and are not
impartially performing their duties.
(b)
A political party was occupying Premises No. 42,
Sadananda Road, Kolkata-700026, which was let out by Late
Aparesh Mukherjee to Appellant No. 1, under a written agreement
dated 01.04.2000. The said premises were utilised for establishing
and operating a party office of a political party, for Kolkata
Municipal Corporation, Ward No. 83.
3/9
(c)
Sri Aparesh Mukherjee passed away on 19.01.2026.
On 04.08.2026, at about 7.15 p.m., a large number of unidentified
persons assembled around the premises and allegedly, forcibly
entered into the party office by breaking the lock of the main
entrance and forcefully dispossessed the Appellants.
(d)
They were allegedly carrying weapons and fire arms.
The premises were vandalised and several articles, furniture,
Computers, Television Set, Sound System, Wi-Fi devices,
Electrical fittings, documents and other office articles, were
damaged and/or removed.
(e)
The unidentified persons threatened the Appellants
with physical harm.
(f)
Appellant No. 1 lodged a written Police complaint on
04.08.2026 before the Officer-in-Charge, Kalighat Police Station
and requested for registration of an F.I.R.
(g)
No F.I.R. was registered by the Police authorities.
The Police personnel attached to the Kalighat Police Station
entered the premises, prepared an inventory of the articles lying
therein on the basis of a General Diary Entry and affixed a
padlock to the entrance of the premises.
5.
It is submitted that Police should not have sealed the
4/9
premises. The Police should have handed over possession of the
immovable property to the original Petitioners. The Police authorities
are bound by the law laid down by the Division Bench of this Court
vide Judgment dated 13.08.2021 in the case of The State of West
Bengal & Ors. vs. Fulkumari Paswan & Ors. (AST 37 of 2019) and
other connected matter.
6.
The learned Advocate General has contended that the
submissions of the Appellants, will have to be substantiated. Without
establishing the claims made by the Appellants, the Police authorities,
in the face of a dispute between the Appellants and those claiming to be
the landlord or a person possessing the property, cannot adjudicate on
such disputes. This is a civil dispute. The learned Single Judge has
rightly observed that the Appellants should approach the Civil Court
and get their rights established.
7.
The learned Advocates representing the respective
Applicants in Civil Application Nos. 1 and 2 of 2026 in WPA 20825 of
2026, which were also filed before the learned Single Judge, claim that
the deceased Aparesh Mukherjee was not the owner of the Premises
No. 42. He was a tenant. The Applicant in Civil Application No. 2 of
2026, claims to be the owner and title holder of the property. Aparesh
5/9
Mukherjee has illegally sub-let Premises No. 42 to the Appellants. The
landlord of Premises No. 42 resides on the 1 st Floor of the building and
he claims to be the owner and possessor of the entire building.
According to him, a false case is put up by the Appellants.
8.
The learned Advocate for the Appellants submits that the
Appellants never claimed to be the owners of the property. They have
always maintained that they have a lease agreement with late Aparesh
Mukherjee. They were in possession and the Police authorities should
have restored their possession instead of applying a padlock.
9.
We have considered the judgment delivered by this Court
in Fulkumari Paswan (supra). A close look at the facts of the said
case would clearly indicate that they are completely distinct and
distinguishable from the facts of the case in hand.
In Fulkumari
Paswan (supra), the Learned Division Bench of this Court noted that
one, Ms. Saluja Motey was the focal point of the litigation. She was
supported in her case by Fulkumari Paswan, who was her employer.
Fulkumari Paswan was operating a Restaurant cum Bar under the
business name ‘Golden Valley Restaurant’ in the heart of the city in
Jalpaiguri.
The premises were raided by the police on purported
complaints that immoral acts are being committed in the said premises.
6/9
Police had sealed the said commercial establishment only on the
complaint that there are immoral activities being purportedly
committed inside the said commercial establishment. With a detailed
judgment, the learned Division Bench of this Court concluded that the
order of the concerned Magistrate directing the de-sealing/opening of
Golden Valley Restaurant was not fit to be interfered with. This Court
concluded that the impugned order could not be branded as being
perverse or erroneous in the facts and circumstances of the case.
10.
In the case before us, there is a clear dispute as regards,
who was in possession of Premises No.42. The Appellants claimed to
be occupying the premises under an agreement with the deceased
Aparesh Mukherjee.
The Applicants, who have preferred Civil
Applications, claimed to be the landlords of the entire property. They
are willing to establish their title over the said property. The facts
appearing from the records indicate to us that when the police arrived
at the scene, the premises were empty and there were signs of physical
altercation.
The appellants have stated in their pleadings that on
04.08.2026 at 7:30 p.m., there was nobody inside the premises and the
Appellants had applied a lock to the main door.
7/9
11.
In the above backdrop, the police deemed it appropriate to
create an inventory of the fixtures and the equipment that were found
inside the premises. It is also stated before us that the said fixtures and
equipment are being preserved by the police authorities.
12.
In the above factual matrix, we are of the view that the
learned Single Judge has rightly concluded that the Appellants were not
evicted by the police. The premises were empty and under a lock. The
complaint by the Appellants reached the police station on the ground
that the lock was broken and somebody had entered the premises. It is
also canvassed by the Appellants that though they were not landlords,
they have an agreement with a deceased person and they could not
have been evicted from the premises either by the landlord or by his
relatives or by the police.
13.
In this backdrop, the learned Single Judge noticed that
there was no material before him to conclude that the Appellants were
forcibly evicted by the police authorities. Hence, the learned Single
Judge recorded that since the civil rights of the parties are at issue, they
would be at liberty to approach the Civil Court. We endorse the view
of the Learned Single Judge for the reason that the police authorities do
not have any jurisdiction to be judgmental and draw a conclusion that a
8/9
particular person deserves to be put in possession of a disputed
property.
It is for the Civil Court to decide on the basis of oral and
documentary evidence, as to who establishes his/her possession and
who should, therefore, be put in possession of the suit property.
14.
We are, therefore, of the view that the learned Single Judge
has drawn an appropriate conclusion, which cannot be faulted. This
appeal being devoid of merit and is, therefore, dismissed.
15.
Learned advocate for the Appellants submits that since the
Applicants in Civil Application Nos.1 and 2 of 2026 in W.P.A. 20825
of 2026, had also approached the learned Single Judge and were given
audience in the hearing and their submissions were also recorded after
hearing the learned Senior Advocate, Sri Subir Sanyal, that these
Applicants may be arrayed as Respondents in the present appeal.
Hence, Civil Application No.1 and 2 of 2026 are allowed by consent, to
the extent of adding these Applicants as Respondents in the appeal.
Addition be carried out within a week’s time.
Re-verification is
dispensed with.
16.
Learned Advocates appearing for the Applicants have
caused their appearance in the hearing on the appeal.
9/9
17.
The issue as to whether the police, in order to restore law and
order and protect the rights of all the claimants have locked the premises
and in the backdrop of the submission of the Appellants as to what right
does the Appellants have to lock the premises, are left open for the Civil
Court to decide, since, prima facie, we find that the police has only
protected the property in the backdrop of two groups claiming to have a
right over the property.
18.
Parties are at liberty to act upon the print-out copy of this order
obtained from the Official Website of the Calcutta High Court.
(ARIJIT BANERJEE, J.)
(RAVINDRA V. GHUGE)
CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review