Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:22753
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
WP(C) No.4148 of 2020
----Priyarani, D/o Sailesh Kumar Mishra, R/o Sarda Colony, Power
House Road, Chutia, P.O. & P.S.-Chutia, Dist.-Ranchi
… Petitioner(s).
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand through its Chief Secretary, Project
Bhawan, P.O. & P.S.-Dhurwa, Dist.-Ranchi
2. Secretary, Higher & Technical Education Department,
Government of Jharkhand, Nepal House, P.O. & P.S.-Doranda,
Dist.-Ranchi
3. Spl. Secretary, Higher & Technical Education Department,
Government of Jharkhand, Nepal House, P.O. & P.S.-Doranda,
Dist.-Ranchi
4. Controller of Examination, State Board of Technical
Education, Jharkhand Science & Technology Campus, Sirka
Toli, Namkom, P.O. & P.S.-Namkom, Dist.-Ranchi
… Respondent(s).
CORAM
:
SRI ANANDA SEN, J.
-----For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. A.K. Sahni, Advocate
For the State
: Mr. Ashwini Bhushan, AC to Sr. SC-II
For the University
: Mr. Mrinal Kanti Roy, Advocate
…......
11 /29.07.2026: In compliance with the order dated 11.06.2026, the
counsel for the respondents submits photocopies of the petitioner's
5th and 6th Semester Tabulation Registers and Answer sheets to
the Court.
2.
These documents are taken on record.
3.
Heard the learned counsel representing the petitioner and
the learned counsel representing the respondents.
4.
By filing this writ petition the petitioner has prayed for
following relief: “For issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus of any other
appropriate writ(s)/order(s)/Direction commanding upon the
respondent No.2 to consider and to decide the representation of the
petitioner (Annexure-7) in the shape of an appeal against the socalled reasoned order dated 02.09.2016 (Annexure-5) and within a
specified period and for issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari
or any other writ/order for quashing the reasoned order dated
02.09.2016 (Annexure-5) whereby and whereunder the respondent
No.4 purported to have cancelled the Mark-Sheet of 5th and 6th
semesters, Original Diploma passing Certificate and Migration
Page | 1
2026:JHHC:22753
Certificate issued to her.”
5.
The case of the petitioner as appears from the records and
from the arguments, is that the petitioner was a student of Xavier
Institute of Polytechnic & Technology, Namkum. She had
completed her course from the said institute, however, one student
namely Sneha Kumari made a complaint to the Hon'ble Chief
Minister alleging irregularities in the preparation of marks-sheet of
the petitioner. The office of the Hon'ble Chief Minister forwarded
the said complaint to the Department of Higher & Technical
Education, Govt. of Jharkhand and on the basis of the complaint
the answer-sheet of the petitioner and the Tabulation Register was
compared. On such comparison it was found that the allegations
were correct. The Tabulation Register reflected more marks
against the name of the petitioner, as compared to the
corresponding
answer-sheets.
Further,
transpired
that
the
petitioner was the daughter of Shri Shailesh Kumar Mishra, who
was posted in the State Board of Technical Education, Ranchi, the
Board which conducted the examination, as Head Clerk. At the
relevant time of preparation of result, the Tabulation Register had
been outsourced to a private agency namely M/s. Meverick
Consultancy Services Pvt. Ltd.
6.
An F.I.R. was instituted against M/s. Meverick Consultancy
Services Pvt. Ltd. against its proprietor Rohit Raman, Vikash
Kumar (employee of the agency), Sri Navlesh Kumar (Principal of
XIPT) and Arshad Ahmad, Assistant in Examination Department.
Show cause (Annexure-3) was issued to the petitioner as to why
her result of the 5th Semester be not cancelled. After due
consideration of the reply, her result of the 5th and 6th semester has
been cancelled by the order dated 02.09.2016 (Annexure-5)
passed by the respondent No.4-Controller of Examination, State
Board of Technical Education, Jharkhand.
7.
Mr. A.K. Sahni, learned Counsel for the petitioner submits
that the petitioner was a regular student for the Sessions 2011-14.
She appeared in each and every Semester and passed
Page | 2
2026:JHHC:22753
examinations. Mark sheets were issued by the Examination
Controller and thereafter Migration Certificate was also issued.
There is no dispute with regard to the Mark sheets of the petitioner
issued till 4th Semester. Subsequently, by the impugned letter
dated 02.09.2016, the Examination Controller cancelled the Mark
sheets issued to the petitioner for 5th and 6th Semesters as a result
whereof her educational certificate became of no use. Even
assuming, for sake the of argument, if the allegations made against
the petitioner to be true on its face value, then also the Examination
Controller was required to issue Mark sheets on the basis of actual
marks obtained by the petitioner then also the petitioner passed the
said Semester. There was no jurisdiction on the part of the
respondents to cancel her entire Mark sheet and Migration
Certificate. It is further submitted that as per hierarchy, respondent
No.2-Secretary,
Higher,
Technical
Education
and
Skill
Development Department, Government of Jharkhand is the higher
authority of the Examination Controller under the State Board of
Technical Education. He thus, submits that a direction may be
issued to the respondent No.2 to consider and to decide the
representation of the petitioner (Annexure-7) in the shape of an
appeal against order dated 02.09.2016.
8.
Per contra, Mr. Mrinal Kanti Roy, learned Counsel for the
University on the complaint of Susri Sneha Kumari to the Hon’ble
Chief Minister, Govt. of Jharkhand vide order dated 18.01.2016 an
enquiry has been initiated, wherein it is found that marks obtained
in Answer sheets and that of mentioned in Tabulation Registers of
the petitioner in 5th and 6th Semesters are not same. Thereafter,
vide order dated 05.08.2016 show-cause was issued to the
petitioner to which she submitted her explanation on 17.08.2016.
On finding her reply unsatisfactory, her Marks sheet 5th and 6th
semesters, original diploma passing certificate and Migration
Certificate of the petitioner cancelled by the respondent No.4. He
also referred photocopies of the Answer Sheets and Tabulation
Registers of subject “Principles of Comp. Arch. & Maint.” (code
Page | 3
2026:JHHC:22753
12186) and “Industrial Electronics” (code 12189) of 5th semester
and “Management” (code 12219) & “Control Systems” (code
12270) of the 6th Semester and submits that the petitioner’s marks
have been enhanced in the Tabulation Register by playing fraud
therefore marks in Tabulation Register reflected more marks as
compared to the Answer sheet. Thus, he submitted that since the
petitioner was the beneficiary of immoral act and unfair means
adopted in the preparation of marks-sheet, appropriate action has
been taken against her.
9.
After considering the submissions of the parties and
perusing the records specially the Answer sheets and Tabulation
Registers of 5th and 6th Semester of the petitioners, I find that marks
reflected in the answer sheet of subject “Principles of Comp. Arch.
& Maint.” (code 12186) and “Industrial Electronics” (code 12189) of
5th semester is 60 and 20 whereas in Tabulation Register it is
showing 66 and 40 respectively. Further, answer sheets of subject
“Management” (code 12219) & “Control Systems” (code 12270) of
the 6th Semester showing Marks 40 and 43 whereas in Tabulation
Register it is made 60 and 57 respectively. Thus, the allegation that
marks of the petitioner was fraudulently enhanced in the Tabulation
Registers of 5th and 6th Semester, is correct. Commission of this
type of fraud stakes the foundation of a strong education system of
this Country. These cracks in the system needs to be plugged
without and sympathy. Faith of people in the education system and
sanctity of education cannot be allowed to erode by any means.
10.
It is well settled that fraud vitiates every solemn act. In S.P.
Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath, (1994) 1 SCC 1 the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has observed that “Property grabbers, tax-evaders,
bank-loan-dodgers and other unscrupulous persons from all walks
of life find the court-process a convenient lever to retain the illegal
gains indefinitely. We have no hesitation to say that a person, who's
case is based on falsehood, has no right to approach the court. He
can be summarily thrown out at any stage of the litigation.”
11.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vishnu Vardhan v. State
Page | 4
2026:JHHC:22753
of U.P., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1501 has summaries law on fraud
as follows:
1. In Nidhi Kaim v. State of Madhya Pradesh, a three-Judge Bench
of this Court emphatically asserted “… stated simply, nothing …
nothing … and nothing, obtained by fraud, can be sustained, as
fraud unravels everything.”
2. At the end of the last century, this Court in S.P. Chengalvaraya
Naidu v. Jagannath noticed the growing trend of abuse of the
process of law by dishonest litigants playing fraud on courts. Fraud
was held to be an act of deliberate deception with the design of
securing something by taking unfair advantage of another: a
deception in order to gain by another's loss. The opening paragraph
of such decision reads as follows:
“Fraud avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical or temporal”
observed Chief Justice Edward Coke of England about three
centuries ago. It is the settled proposition of law that a judgment
or decree obtained by playing fraud on the court is a nullity and
non est in the eyes of law. Such a judgment/decree — by the
first court or by the highest court — has to be treated as a nullity
by every court, whether superior or inferior. It can be challenged
in any court even in collateral proceedings.
This Court then warned that:
5. The principle of “finality of litigation” cannot be pressed to the
extent of such an absurdity that it becomes an engine of fraud
in the hands of dishonest litigants. The courts of law are meant
for imparting justice between the parties. One who comes to the
court, must come with clean hands. We are constrained to say
that more often than not, process of the court is being abused.
Property grabbers, tax-evaders, bank-loan-dodgers and other
unscrupulous persons from all walks of life find the courtprocess a convenient lever to retain the illegal gains indefinitely.
We have no hesitation to say that a person, who's case is based
on falsehood, has no right to approach the court. He can be
summarily thrown out at any stage of the litigation.
3. “Fraud unravels everything” was famously said by Lord Denning
in Lazarus Estates Ltd. v. Beasley3, emphasising that fraud can
invalidate judgments, contracts and all transactions. The principle
highlights the importance of honesty and transparency in legal
proceedings and transactions. However, it is a cardinal principle of
law that fraud has to be pleaded and proved. Order VI Rule 4, of
the Civil Procedure Code, 19084 may be referred to ordaining that
particulars, inter alia, of fraud have to be stated in the pleadings.
4. From the multiple decisions of this Court on ‘fraud’, what follows
is that fraud and justice cannot dwell together, the legislature never
intends to guard fraud, the question of limitation to exercise power
does not arise, if fraud is proved, and even finality of litigation cannot
be pressed into service to absurd limits when a fraud is unravelled.
5. The issue of fraud unravelling everything is pertinent here due to
the nature of dispute we are tasked to adjudicate; hence, its
reference at the beginning of our judgment.
6. The primary parties involved in these proceedings are the
appellant-writ petitioner-applicant, Vishnu Vardhan5, and the
respondent no. 7, Reddy Veeranna6. Vishnu has alleged that fraud
has been played by Reddy on courts to reap benefits behind
Vishnu's back. The tangled facts involved in these proceedings, the
complex web of activities of the primary parties and their associates
and the relief claimed in the civil appeal as well as the writ petition
by Vishnu would have to be examined in great depth to ascertain
Page | 5
2026:JHHC:22753
whether fraud, as alleged by him, is established; and, if so, how it
has affected the flow of judicial proceedings and the manner in which
the same has to be dealt with. In the process, other
petitions/applications that are on record would also require due
consideration.
12.
Further, contention of the petitioner is that a direction may
be issued to the respondent No.2 to consider and to decide the
representation of the petitioner (Annexure-7) in the shape of an
appeal against order dated 02.09.2016. Refuting this the counsel
for the respondents submits that there is no provision of appeal
hence the prayer of the petitioner to consider her representation
(Annexure-7) in appeal against order dated 02.09.2016 cannot be
accorded.
13.
In the light of what has been held above, I find that no
ground is made out to interfere with the order dated 02.09.2016
(Annexure-5) passed by the respondent No.4-Controller of
Examination, State Board of Technical Education, Jharkhand
which are under challenge. Further, this Court cannot give a
direction to the respondent No.2 to consider and to decide the
representation of the petitioner (Annexure-7) in the shape of an
appeal against order dated 02.09.2016 in absence of any provision
of appeal.
14.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed.
15.
Pending interlocutory applications, if any, stand disposed
of.
(ANANDA SEN, J.)
29.07.2026
S.K.D./CP-2
A.F.R.
Uploaded on 03.08.2026
Page | 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review