Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:540-DB
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.30/2024
Reserved on : 07.06.2024
Pronounced on: 14.06.2024
Priyanchi R. Marak
.....Appellant
- Versus -
1.
State of Meghalaya, represented by
the Chief Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong.
2.
Deputy Commissioner (Revenue),
North Garo Hills District,
Resubelpara, Meghalaya.
3.
The Deputy Secretary,
Revenue & Disaster Management Department,
Meghalaya, Shillong.
4.
The Joint Secretary,
Revenue & Disaster Management Department,
Meghalaya, Shillong.
5.
District A.H. and Veterinary Officer,
North Garo Hills,
Resubelpara, Meghalaya.
.....Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Vaidyanathan, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.
For the Respondents : Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:540-DB
JUDGMENT
(Made by Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
The present appeal has been preferred against the judgment and
order of the learned Single Judge dated 26.04.2024.
2. The learned Single Judge has gone into the merits of the
matter and come to the conclusion that there is a disputed question of
fact even though A. Kumar, learned AG submitted that there is a delay
of seven years and that in order to overcome the laches in approaching
the civil court as any civil suit that may be filed is time-barred, the writ
petition had been filed to bypass the limitation and get the grievance
redressed, more so, the disputed question of fact.
3. We are not inclined to accept the contention of learned AG as
the learned Single Judge in paragraph 31 of the judgment has
categorically discussed with the plea taken by learned AG in paragraph
21. For the sake of convenience, paragraphs 21 and 31 are extracted
below:
“21. The learned AG has also submitted that the petitioners has
approached this Court only in the month of October, 2021, that
is after almost seven years of the alleged supply with a prayer
for direction to make payment of the bill amounting to ₹
2,20,00,000/- (Rupees two crore twenty lakh) only and in the
other case, for payment of the bill amounting to ₹ 6,00,00,000/(Rupees six crore) only. These petitions are therefore not
maintainable solely on the ground of delay and laches. ”
2024:MLHC:540-DB
******
31. The argument of the petitioner in this regard is found
acceptable by this Court and the authority in the case of P.C.
Sethi (supra) at para 22 of the same is also found relevant
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that “The
learned Counsel for the respondents strenuously contended that
the petition may be dismissed on account of delay and laches. In
view of the entire circumstances of the case and the hopes held
out by the Government from time to time we are not prepared to
accede to this submission”. Therefore, there is no question of
delay or laches while filing this petition.”
4. This Court has specifically posed a question to the learned
Senior Counsel as to whether an amount of 2.21 crore is liable to be
paid by the respondents and whether there is any admission.
Admittedly, the appellant is not in a position to state that there is
admission. The fact of payment by the respondents to the appellant is
being disputed.
5. Alternative remedy may not be a bar to approach if the facts
are not disputed. The Apex Court in the case of Hindustan Petroleum
Corporation Ltd. v. Dolly Das reported in (1999) 4 SCC 450 has
considered the question of delay and alternative remedy as follows:
“8. So far the contention regarding laches of the respondent in
filing the writ petition is concerned, delay, by itself, may not
defeat the claim for relief unless the position of the appellant
had been so altered which cannot be retracted on account of
lapse of time or inaction of the other party. This aspect being
dependent upon the examination of the facts of the case and
such a contention not having been raised before the High Court,
it would not be appropriate to allow the appellants to raise such
2024:MLHC:540-DB
a contention for the first time before us. Besides, we may notice
that the period for which the option of renewal has been
exercised has not come to an end. During the subsistence of
such a period certainly the respondent could make a complaint
that such exercise of option was not available to the appellants
and, therefore, the jurisdiction of the High Court could be
invoked even at a later stage. Further, the appellants are not put
to undue hardship in any manner by reason of this delay in
approaching the High Court for a relief.
9. …Where interpretation of a contract arises in relation to
immovable property and in working such a contract or relief
thereof or any other fallout thereto may have the effect of giving
rise to an action in tort or for damages, the appropriate remedy
would be a civil suit. But if the facts pleaded before the court are
of such a nature which do not involve any complicated questions
of fact needing elaborate investigation of the same, the High
Court could also exercise writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution in such matters. There can be no hard and fast
rule in such matters. When the High Court has chosen to
exercise its power under Article 226 of the Constitution we
cannot say that the discretion exercised in entertaining the
petition is wrong.”
6. Learned Senior Counsel has referred to page 63 of the typed
set of papers, namely, the communication of the District Animal &
Husbandry and Veterinary Officer, North Garo Hills District,
Resubelpara to state that if necessary papers or receipts, payment will
be made as and when funds are available. It cannot be said that there is
admission. After going through the papers or receipts, it is open to the
Government to refuse to accede to the request. Learned Senior Counsel
has also taken a stand in paragraphs 8 & 10 of the affidavit dated
2024:MLHC:540-DB
13.04.2022. Paragraphs 8 and 10 of the affidavit dated 13.04.2022 is
extracted below:
“8. That it is submitted that the writ petition is also bereft of
material except for the minutes of the meeting allegedly took
place on 05.12.2014 for approving rate of supply of feed. It is
also relevant to note here that no document has been shown that
the approval of the Government of Meghalaya has been obtained
for approving rate of supply of feed. Further, perusal of the
minutes of the meeting dated 05.12.2014 allegedly shows that in
the alleged meeting chaired by Shri. D.D. Sangma, MCS,
Additional Deputy Commissioner, Revenue, what was the basis
of approving the three firms/suppliers supply of cattle and
poultry feed. It is matter of record that the empanelment of
supplier/firm for supply of feed to Government have to be
carried out in a fair and transparent manner as per the Govt. of
Meghalaya memorandum it is clearly stated that any purchase
above, 50,000/- has to be done in fair and transparent manner.
Even assuming without admitting that the order was placed by
Deputy Commissioner, Revenue, in violation of the above
Government order, the same is illegal and without any authority
and it cannot bind the State Government.”
“10. That it is submitted that a bare perusal of letter of Deputy
Commissioner, Revenue dated 05.12.2014 (Annexure A2)
shows that the petitioner has given a letter on 24.11.2014 even
prior to the meeting of the Committee to allegedly approve the
rate. It appears that the entire transaction is shrouded in mystery
and has not been carried out in fair and transparent manner. That
it is further submitted that even a perusal of a letter of Animal
Husbandry and Veterinary Officer dated 08.12.2014, it is not
clear as to how Animal Husbandry and Veterinary reached or
arrived at the quantity of cattle feed and pig feed. There is no
assessment to how many animal are stranded or requiring cattle
feed/pig feed after 73 days of flood. Similarly, the order dated
21.01.2015 placing further order from the supplier to supply
poultry feed is also without any basis and no reason has been
given as to why poultry feed having quantity of 1428,571
quintal is required.”
2024:MLHC:540-DB
7. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that by an order
dated 27.03.2023, the Government has sanctioned a sum of
Rs.1,34,39,437/- to the other suppliers being the partial cost of supply of
medicine and livestock feeds and that non-payment of the amount to the
appellant is discriminatory and that the amount due to them has got to
be paid.
8. Learned AG reiterated that there is a delay in seven years and
that the facts are disputed. The learned Single Judge has referred to the
contention of the petitioners in paragraph 21 of the judgment and finally
rendered a finding with regard to delay in paragraph 21 and the same
are extracted supra. It is very clear that the learned Single Judge had not
condoned the delay as such. The learned Single Judge has condoned the
period of delay during which the matter is pending before this Court
needs to be excluded. Reading of paragraph 40 of the judgment would
make it very clear that while excluding the period of limitation during
which the matter was pending before the Court, the petitioner needs to
approach the civil court seeking damages and the writ petition cannot be
entertained on the ground of disputed question of facts. Paragraph 40
the judgment is extracted below:
“40. It is the considered opinion of this Court that the remedy
for redressal of the petitioners’ grievances seeking damages
would only lie with a civil court. To this extent, discounting the
2024:MLHC:540-DB
period spent in these proceedings for which condonation is
hereby accorded, the parties may approach such forum, if so
advised.”
9. In view of the above, we find no error apparent on the face of
the records and the order of the learned Single Jude is sustained and the
writ appeal is dismissed.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
Judge
(S. Vaidyanathan)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
14.06.2024
signed by
SYLVANA LIZ Digitally
SYLVANA LIZ KHARBHIH
Date: 2024.06.14 11:56:24
KHARBHIH +05'30'
PRE-DELIVERY JUDGMENT IN
WA No.30 of 2024
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review