Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (WA) No.41 of 2023 in
WA No.20 of 2023
Date of Decision: 06.12.2023
The Principal/Principal-in-charge Vs. Shri. Langpoklakpam Kamal &
Of Naorem Birahari College,
Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting)
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Applicant(s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
:
i)
ii)
Mr. H.S. Paonam, Sr.Adv with
Mr. A. Arunkumar Singh, Adv
Mr. B.P. Sahu, Sr Adv. with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv.
Mr. M. Rarry, Adv. (for profoma R:3 – 7)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
(As per B. Bhattacharjee, J)
This application under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure has
been filed by the applicant seeking closure of the Writ Appeal No. 20 of
2023 on the ground of same being infructuous.
1.
The applicant contends that pursuant to the order dated 31-08-2023
passed in the Writ Appeal, the State Government has cancelled the
impugned order dated 29-09-2021 by the order dated 01-09-2023 and 03-092023. It is submitted that in terms of the liberty given in the said order dated
31-08-2023, the State Government by another order dated 12-09-2023
declared the Governing Body of Naorem Birahari College constituted vide
order dated 02-03-2021 as null and void on the grounds unrelatable to the
cause of action involved in the present matter. It is, thus, contended that
since the Governing Body of the college became non-existent, the cause of
action basing on which the writ petitions were filed, does not survive and the
writ appeal has become unnecessary. It is further submitted that in view of
the issuance of the orders dated 01-09-2023 and 03-09-2023 by the State
Government, challenge to the impugned orders dated 29-09-2021 and 18-122021 do not survive and resultantly the writ appeal has become pointless and
requires to be closed forthwith.
It is also contended that if the writ
petitioners/respondents in this present application have any fresh cause of
action, they can assail the same by filing separate writ petition before the
jurisdictional High Court as this Court will have no jurisdiction over any
fresh cause of action. In support of the contentions, reliance has been placed
on the decisions of the Apex Court reported in (2004) 11 SCC 168, (2012) 9
SCC 310, and (1996) 6 SCC 291.
2.
The respondents, per contra, contend that the orders, basing on which
the closure of the writ appeal is sought for by the applicant, were passed by
the State Government consequent to the orders passed by this Court and, as
such, are not independent orders and are connected to the issues pending
adjudication before this Court in the writ appeal. By referring to the various
orders passed in the writ appeal, it is submitted that the cause of action still
survives as no remedial action has been taken by the State Government as
required and expected. It is further contended that the actions basing on
which the closure of the writ appeal is sought for by the appellants, are all an
eye-wash and aimed at by-passing the main issue involved in the matter. It
is also contended that the order dated 12-09-2023 passed by the State
Government
is not consistent with the various orders passed in the writ
appeal by this Court and the same can be questioned in the present
proceeding. The decisions reported in (2011) 6 SSC 199, (2012) 9 SCC 310
and (1997) 1 SCC 621 have been pressed in service to support the contention
of the respondents.
3.
The proforma-respondents support the contentions made on behalf of
the applicant.
4.
For a just and proper adjudication of this application, it is important to
take note of the relevant orders passed by this Court during the course of
hearing of writ appeal No. 20 of 2020. The first such order dated 31-082023 reads as follows: “Prima facie, upon hearing both the appellants and the State, it
does not appear that the impugned judgment and order can be
sustained or there could have been any justification for the
impugned dissolution notice of September 29, 2021 having been
issued. At any rate, the relevant notice of dissolution appears to
be contrary to the provision of the grant-in-aid code that it
quotes.
In such a scenario, the State of Manipur is afforded an
opportunity to take remedial measures as suggested and which
need not be recorded. However, considering the gravity of the
matter and the colossal illegality in the issuance of the relevant
notice, the time afforded to the State is till September 4,
2023…….”
5.
Thereafter, the matter was listed on 04-09-2023 on which date this
Court after noticing that the State of Manipur in compliance of the order
dated 31-08-2023 passed an order dated 01-09-2023, passed the following
order:“It is heartening to note that following the order dated August
31, 2023, the State of Manipur has graciously passed an order
on September 1, 2023 by which the impugned government order
of September 29, 2021 pertaining to the dissolution of the
governing body of the Naorem Birahari College, Khundrakpam
has been cancelled.
2. Paragraph 4 of the recent government order of September 1,
2023 issued by the Joint Secretary (Higher and Technical
Education), Government of Manipur expressly records as
follows:
“Now therefore, the Governor of Manipur is
hereby pleased to cancel the said
Government Order no. 10/26/2017(HE)(Pt.) dated 29-09-2021, with immediate
effect and convey the approval to the
Directorate of University & Higher
Education, Government of Manipur to issue
an appropriate order in this regard.”
3. Doubtless, the relevant appropriate order from the
Directorate of University and Higher Education will follow.
Since the governing body of the relevant college stood dissolved
by the government order of September 29, 2021, which has now
been cancelled, the governing body stands restored.
4. However, it will be open to the State of Manipur to take
further steps in respect of the relevant college in accordance
with law particularly in terms of the provision of the grant-inaid code operating in such State.
5. Since the appellants says that the appeal should be kept
pending to await the immediate future steps taken by the State,
let the appeal now appear four weeks hence.
6. The pendency of the appeal will be without prejudice to the
rights and contentions of both the appellants and the State.
7. List on October 4, 2023.”
6.
On 04-10-2023, when the writ appeal was taken up for further
hearing, this Court took notice of the fact that by subsequent action of the
State, the impact of the order of cancellation dated 01-09-2023 stood
negated. The relevant part of the order dated 04-10-2023 is reproduced
hereinbelow: “5. In the order dated September 4, 2023, the operative part of
the order of cancellation was set out and it was observed that
the appropriate consequential order from the Directorate of
University and Higher Education would follow. It was also
recorded that as a consequence of the cancellation of the notice
of dissolution, the governing body of the college stood restored.
7.
6. It, however, transpires that despite cancelling the notice of
dissolution of September 29, 2021, subsequent steps taken by
the State, in effect, negated the impact of the order of
cancellation of September 1, 2023. The appellants complain
that despite the order of cancellation, the governing body was
not allowed to function nor was it recognised to have been
restored. Applications have been filed for contempt.
7. The State seeks some time and says that there is a good
explanation to justify how the State acted after issuing the order
of cancellation. Prima facie, it appears that the State may never
have been interested in effectively annulling the illegal notice of
dissolution of September 29, 2021 to restore the governing body
of the college for such governing body to continue to run the
educational institution. This would make the act of the State an
act of contempt as the State may have deceived the Court into
believing that a state of things had been brought about without
such state of things being put in place.
8. Accordingly, since the State seeks some time to explain its
subsequent conduct, it is afforded a fortnight to file an affidavit
in such regard. All actions taken by the State subsequent to the
order dated September 4, 2023 will abide by the result of the
appeal and may be scrutinised in this appeal, particularly
considering the State’s representation to the Court as recorded
in the order dated September 4, 2023.
9. Let the appeal and the connected matters appear three weeks
hence.
10. List on November 2, 2023.”
It transpires from the above that on the basis of the initial observation
of the Court with regard to the merit of the case, the State of Manipur was
afforded an opportunity to take remedial measure in the matter. The State
Government acted on the basis of the said observation and issued an order
dated 01-09-2023 by which the order impugned in the connected writ
petition as well as the instant writ appeal was cancelled. However, with the
issuance of subsequent order dated 12-09-2023, the situation took a different
turn and it appears that the remedial action which was taken by the State by
issuing the order dated 01-09-2023 stood diluted, in other words the impact
of the order dated was negated.
8.
This Court by order dated 04-10-2023 made it clear that all actions
taken by the State subsequent to the order dated 04-09-2023 passed in the
writ appeal, will abide by the result of the appeal and may be scrutinized in
the appeal, particularly considering the State representation to the Court as
recorded in the order dated 04-09-2023.
9.
In view of the above, it cannot be held at this stage that there remains
no cause of action surviving in the present writ appeal and the same has
become infructuous.
10.
The present application, as such, is devoid of any merit and stands
rejected.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
Judge
(H. S. Thangkhiew)
Chief Justice (Acting)
Meghalaya
06.12.2023
“Biswarup-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review