Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
KHOIROM Digitally
KHOIROM
BIPINCHANDRA
BIPINCHAN Date: 2024.01.18SINGH
DRA SINGH 16:27:30 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 30 OF 2023
Shri Prince Kumar, aged about 29 years, S/o Late Sh.
Tribhuvan Ram of Village Khojapur, P.O. Fadanpur,
District-Ghazipu, Uttar Pradesh-233001 and A/P
residing at C/o Rina, Railway Club, Raja Ali Road, PO
& PS Tinsukia, Assam-786602.
…. Petitioner
- Versus Intelligence Officer, NCB, Imphal, Manipur-795140.
…. Respondent
BEFORE
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU
For the petitioner
:
Mr. L. Seityandra, Advocate
For the respondent
:
Mr. Darakishore, Senior PCCG
Date of hearing
:
14.12.2023
Date of order
:
18.01.2024
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. L. Seityandra, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner and Mr. Darakishore, learned senior PCCG assisted by
Miss Niana, learned counsel appearing for the respondent at length.
[2]
The present Bail Application has been filed under section
439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 praying inter-alia for
releasing the Accused/Petitioner on bail during the pendency of NCB
P a g e 1 | 12
Crime No. 11/NCB/Imp/2022 dated 28/11/2022 u/s 8(c) r/w S. 21(c)
ND&PS Act, in connection with the order dated 26.06.20233 passed
by the Ld. Special Judge (ND&PS), Manipur, at Lamphelpat in Cril.
Misc. (B) No. 122 of 2023 by necessary/appropriate bond(s),
surety/sureties as deem fit for the satisfaction of the Hon’ble Court.
The prayer of the application reads as follows:
“(i)
to call for the reports/records concerned.
(ii) to release the Accused/Petitioner on bail under section
439 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 during the pendency
of the above said NCB crime in connection with the order
dated 26.06.2023 passed by the Ld. Special Judge (ND&PS),
Manipur, at Lamphelpat in Cril. Misc. (B) No. 122 of 2023 Ref:
NCB Crime No. 11/NCB/Imp/2022 dated 28/11/22 u/s 8(c)
r/w S. 37 ND&PS Act by furnishing necessary/appropriate
bond(s), surety/sureties as deem fit for the satisfaction of the
Hon’ble Court.
(iii) to pass any other appropriate order(s) as the Hon’ble
Court deems fit and proper for the ends of justice.”
[3]
follows :
The grounds for filing the present application are as
A)
There is non-compliance of Section 50 of the ND&PS
Act which is a mandatory requirement.
B)
The present petitioner/accused person is entitled for
equality under Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
C)
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has clearly observed that in
case Section 50 of the ND&PS Act is not complied with the
applicant is entitled to bail.
D)
The present accused expressed his desire to be
searched before a Gazetted Officer ad Sh. Suresh Kumar
Singh, Superintendent NCB, Imphal Was requested to
participate in the search proceedings.
It is submitted that the SP, NCB is an interested person
as it is mentioned in the Charge Sheet that the written source
report was submitted to him by SI Thangtinlen Haokip on
28.11.2022.
E)
The Final Compliant/Charge Sheet has already been
filed implying that investigation about the said case is over so,
it is no more necessary to detain the petitioner in custody.
P a g e 2 | 12
F)
The accused/petitioner is languishing in the judicial
custody for almost a year and due to the present turmoil of
ethnic clashes in the State of Manipur the trial is probably not
to conclude in the near future.
[4]
The learned senior PCCG appearing for the respondent
has filed objection to the present application as thus:
“1.
The Respondent herein vehemently oppose and deny all
the averments and contentions in the instant application made
by the petitioner. Save and except those which are specifically
admitted herein. Anything that has not been specifically
admitted is hereby denied. Nothing shall be deemed to be
admitted for want of specific traverse. The Respondents
reserve their right to file a detailed reply and submissions at a
subsequent stage.
2.
With regard to the averments made in Paras no. 1 to 3
of the bail application, the answering respondents have no
comment.
3.
With regard to the averment made in para no. 4 of the
bail application, it is submitted before the Hon’ble High Court
that, from the bare perusal of the charge sheet and voluntary
statement of all the accused, it is evidently clear that the
petitioner has been a habitual offender who has been involving
in illicit trafficking of contraband substance for the past may
years, all the allegation of his involvement are substantiated by
the voluntary statement of co-accused. Furthermore, it is also
found that the accused was supplying the contraband
substances to many of his associates such as; Mrs. Urmila, Dip
Das, amongst other, the same is mentioned in the Chargesheet
which is not repeated herein for the sake of brevity. Moreover,
the process of investigation is still underway in order to trace
the whereabout and chain of operation of all the accomplices of
the accused, and as such, the petitioner being the kingpin,
releasing him on bail can temper the evidence and witness,
which will frustrate the whole process of investigation.
4.
With regard to the averment made in para no. 5 of the
bail application, the answering respondent have no comment.
5.
With regard to the averment made in para no. 6 of the
bail application. It is submitted before the Hon’ble High Court
that, the accused was caught red-handed for a possession of
1.05 Kg of Heroin and 01 Kg of Methanphetamine, the same
allegation is affirmed by the 2 (independent witness) namely;
Sh. Shaikhom Haridas and Sh. Laishram Nilkamal and are
P a g e 3 | 12
substantiated by the statement of co-accused P. Khrishna and
Bhanwar Singh Rathor therefore, considering that the accused
being a main member of the syndicate in illicit trafficking, and
examining the prima facie evidence available on record, the Ld.
Special Judge (ND&PS) Manipur has rightly rejected the bail
application of the accused.
It is also imperative to mentioned herein that, obtaining
CFSL report is beyond the reach of Investigating Officer and
the purpose of filing supplementary charge sheet is to
corroborate the evidence with the investigation and is a matter
of trial and cannot be gone into at this stage, therefore, nonfiling of FSL report cannot be the ground to grant bail, the
same principle was held in a plethora of cases.
It is also further submitted that the petitioner is not
entitled to grant of bail under section 167(2) Cr.P.C. for nonfiling of the FSL report along with the charge sheet, although
the police are not permitted to sent an incomplete report under
section 173(2) of the Code, yet the investigation except for the
report of an expert like the Serologist or Scientific Officer and
Chemical Examiner is complete. Therefore, the Magistrate is
empowered to take cognizance of the offence on a police
report which does not include the expert’s opinion hence,
under section 173 of the Code there is no mandate that a
police report must enclose the document purporting to be a
report under the hand of a Government scientific expert. In the
present cases, as cognizance of the offences taken by the
Magistrate was proper and valid, no order releasing the
petitioners on bail under section 167(2) of the Code was
required to be passed.
The settled law also persists in the view that non filing
of FSL report with the charge sheet does not fall within the
realms of Section 173(2) of the Cr.P.C. so as to consider it as
“incomplete report”. In the present case although FSL report
has not been filed, however, the charge sheet was already filed
on 26.05.2023 within the time period as per law. Further, the
amount of quantity recovered from the accused is of
commercial nature baring the accused from bail under section
37 of the NDPS Act.
It is also pertinent to mentioned herein that, the
Forensic Examination Report issued by Central Forensic Science
Laboratory, Directorate of Forensic Science Service, Ministry of
Home Affairs, Govt. of India confirming the presence of illegal
contrabands has been submitted before the Special Judge,
(NDPS), Lamphelpat on 11.08.2023.
6.
With regard to the averment made in para no. 7 of the
bail application it is humbly submitted that, merely discharging
P a g e 4 | 12
an accomplice does not entitle the kingpin to be discharge on
the same ground. The accused alone can still be convicted in
accordance with the availability of evidence against the accused
under the provision of NDPS. It is true that, an order that
25.08.2023 was passed in Special Trial No. 25 of 2023 by Ld.
Special Judge, ND&PS thereby wrongly discharging the two
accused namely, Shri P. Krishna @ Mani and Shri. Bhanwar
Singh. However, the aforesaid order is erroneous, perverse,
and bad in law as it was passed without application of judicial
frame of mind despite there are enough prima facie evidence
available on record against the two accused. As a result, a
Criminal Revision Petition No. 18 of 2023 has been filed before
this Hon’ble Court against the aforesaid impugned order dated
25.08.2023 to set aside the same and Notice has been issued
returnable by 04.12.2023.
Further, it is also submitted that, whether there are
enough evidence available on record to substantiate the
allegation against the accused is a matter for the trail court to
decide at the stage of trial not at the stage of bail application.
Therefore, interference of this court on weighing the evidence
by going deep into the probative value of evidence at this stage
is highly premature and hence, uncalled.
7.
With regard to the averment made in para no. 7 (a to f)
of the bail application. It is humbly submitted that, the accused
was arrested by complying all the legal formalities, and as
such, there is no question of non-compliance with respect to
arrest, seizure and recovery under section 50 of ND&PS Act,
the Superintendent NCB namely, Suresh Kumar Singh was very
much present. The same compliance report available in para
no. 5 of charge sheet (Annexed in Bail Application No. 30 of
2023) is reproduced herein below for your lordship
convenience;
“That, thereafter the suspected person was asked to
enter the premises of Manipur State Road Transport
Corporation which was just at the distance of 50 meter
for safety and security purpose and to conduct search
properly as it was not safe and proper to complete the
search proceedings on the road side as it was already
dark. As instructed the suspected person got ready to
go inside the premises of MSRTC. Thereafter, the
suspected person namely Prince Kumar was informed
that his personal search and search of his luggage
would be carried out as per the provisions of section 50
of NDPS Act, 1985. He was also informed about his
legal rights that he shall be searched before a
Magistrate or a Gazette Officer is he so desire,
whereupon he expressed/wished to be searched before
a Gazette Officer Thereafter Sh. Suresh Kumar Singh,
P a g e 5 | 12
Superintendent reached at the MSRTC office at about
1900 hours and personal search of the person namely
Prince Kumar was commenced at about 1915 hours in
presence of the tow independent witnesses during
personal search of Prince Kumar on mobile phone, 09
debit cards, Driving license, Aadhar card and one PAN
card were recovered from his possession”
It is furthermore submitted that, in case, even if search
and seizure was not made in stern compliance therewith, it
cannot vitiate the case as it does not affect/goes to the root of
the case, it just constitutes a part of procedural law.
It is an admitted fact that the contraband illicit substance was
recovered from the possession of the accused therefore, all this
prima facie evidence available on record cannot be outrightly
thrown out by merely questioning the competency of the
Gazetted Officer. Nevertheless, all this issue is to be decided at
the stage of trial. And as such, the same issue was also not
raised before the Speical Judge.
8.
With regard to the averment made in para no. 9 to 10
of the bail application. It is humbly submitted that, from the
bare perusal of the material available on record, it is evidently
clear that, the accused being a part of drug cartel having its
operation in different part of India, who have been involve in
trafficking of contraband substance for the past many years,
releasing the accused on bail without bearing in mind the
gravity of the offence, and without considering the fact that,
the Respondent is trying hard to further trace the network of
all his associates will frustrate the whole process of pending
investigation and adversely affect the entire society and the
objective of smacking a stringent provision for control of illicit
traffic in ND&PS Act will ultimately be defeated”.
[5]
On perusal of record, it is evident that charge sheet has
already been filed by the I.O of the case in connection with the case, at
Para No. 5 of the present application. The petitioner states that Final
Report/Charge sheet, in connection with the case, was filed one day
ahead of the expiry/lapse of the statutory period in respect of the
accused.
[6]
It is admitted fact that the accused is entitled to release
on bail after expiry of the statutory period for remand, if the
prosecution failed to submit Charge sheet in connection with the case.
As per Catena of decisions rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and
P a g e 6 | 12
in particular in Ritu Chhabaria Vs Union of India & Ors. (Writ Petition
(Criminal) No. 60 of 2023).
[7]
Further, in the present case, the prosecution has already
filed Charge sheet before the expiry of the statutory period for trial.
[8]
During the course of hearing, the learned counsel for the
petitioner fervently submitted that during the seizure of the seized
article the arresting authority failed to comply with the provision laid
down under section 50 of the ND&PS Act, the mandatory provision laid
down for seizure under the ND&PS Act.
[9]
On the other hand, the learned senior PCCG submitted
that from the contention of the Charge sheet filed by the I.O and
voluntary statement of the accused, it is evidently cleared that the
petitioner has been a habitual offender who has been involving in illicit
trafficking of contraband substance.
[10]
It is further submitted that the CFSL report is not yet
received and the I.O is going to file supplementary charge sheet to
corroborate the evidence with the investigation. As such, non-filing of
CFSL report cannot be the ground for Bail.
[11]
It is further submitted by the learned senior PCCG that
the State has already filed Criminal Revision Petition No. 18 of 2023
before this Hon’ble High Court against the impugned order dated
25.08.2023 discharging of the 2(two) accused namely Shri P Khrishna
@ Mani and Shri. Bhanwar Singh and the same is pending before this
Hon’ble High Court.
[12]
It is further submitted by the learned senior PCCG that
there is no question of none compliance with respect to arrest, seizure
and recovery under section 50 of ND&PS Act. The same compliance
P a g e 7 | 12
report mentioned in Para no. 7 of the objection filed by the respondent
is reproduced herein below:
That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 7
“7.
(a to f) of the bail application. It is humbly submitted that, the
accused was arrested by complying all the legal formalities, and
as such, there is no question of non-compliance with respect to
arrest, seizure and recovery under section 50 of ND&PS Act,
the Superintendent NCB namely, Suresh Kumar Singh was very
much present. The same compliance report available in para
no. 5 of charge sheet (Annexed in Bail Application No. 30 of
2023) is reproduced herein below for your lordship
convenience;
“That, thereafter the suspected person was asked to
enter the premises of Manipur State Road Transport
Corporation which was just at the distance of 50 meter
for safety and security purpose and to conduct search
properly as it was not safe and proper to complete the
search proceedings on the road side as it was already
dark. As instructed the suspected person got ready to
go inside the premises of MSRTC. Thereafter, the
suspected person namely Prince Kumar was informed
that his personal search and search of his luggage
would be carried out as per the provisions of section 50
of NDPS Act, 1985. He was also informed about his
legal rights that he shall be searched before a
Magistrate or a Gazette Officer is he so desire,
whereupon he expressed/wished to be searched before
a Gazette Officer Thereafter Sh. Suresh Kumar Singh,
Superintendent reached at the MSRTC office at about
1900 hours and personal search of the person namely
Prince Kumar was commenced at about 1915 hours in
presence of the tow independent witnesses during
personal search of Prince Kumar on mobile phone, 09
debit cards, Driving license, Aadhaar card and one PAN
card were recovered from his possession”
It is furthermore submitted that, in case, even if search
and seizure was not made in stern compliance therewith, it
cannot vitiate the case as it does not affect/goes to the root of
the case, it just constitutes a part of procedural law.
It is an admitted fact that the contraband illicit substance was
recovered from the possession of the accused therefore, all this
prima facie evidence available on record cannot be outrightly
thrown out by merely questioning the competency of the
Gazetted Officer. Nevertheless, all this issue is to be decided at
the stage of trial. And as such, the same issue was also not
raised before the Special Judge.”
P a g e 8 | 12
[13]
For the sake of convenience, I extract the operative
portion of the impugned order of the Ld. Special Judge (ND & PS),
Manipur, Lamphelpat dated 26.06.2023 is reproduced as follows:
“8.
In my view, the satisfaction of the investigating office
and members of the raiding party during seizure of the
contraband that what was recovered were Heroin and
Methamphetamine on the basis of the field testing using Drug
Detection Kit on the spot, which is also documented in the
Inventory of Seized Narcotic Drugs, Psychotrophic Substances,
Controlled Substances and Conveyances under S. 52 A(2) of
the ND & PS Act, cannot be doubted at this stage. There are
statements of the independent witnesses under Section 67 of
the ND & PS Act in this regard. As per record, the IO has
already taken steps to obtain the chemical examination report
by sending and submitting the exhibits / samples for forensic
analysis to Central Forensic Science Laboratory, (CFSL)
Kamrup, Assam and the same has already reached the
concerned authority / Director of CFSL Kamrup, Assam.
9.
In Rafael Palafox Garcia V. Union of India, 2008
All MR (Cri) 3031, it was held by the High Court of Allahabad
that even though the report of C.A. (Chemical Analyzer) was
not filed, it cannot be said that an incomplete chargesheet has
been filed and the accused was not entitled for bail under
Section 167 (2) of the CrPC. In the said case, it was observed
by the HC that the complaint and Panchanama, specifically
mention about field testing kit being taken to the spot and
samples were tested and result was positive. Similarly, the
High Court of Kerala in Sameer V. State of Kerala on 8
September, 2021, BAIL APPL. NO 5747 OF 2021 took a view
that, as per Section 2(h) of the CrPC, investigation includes all
the proceedings under CrPC for collection of evidence
conducted by a police officer or by any person (other than a
Magistrate), who is authorized by a Magistrate in this behalf
and therefore, the investigation includes all the proceedings
under the Code for collection of evidence and the investigating
officer has already taken proceedings to get the analyst report
by submitting requisition before the Court concerned and it has
already reached the laboratory and therefore, it cannot be said
that simply because the analyst report is not received from the
laboratory, the investigation is not complete.
10.
In Tara Singh V. State AIR 1951 SC 441, it was
held that a police report which is not accompanied by the
expert opinion is to be held as complete report as long as the
witnesses who are acquainted with the circumstances of the
case have been examined. In Kishan Lal V. State 39 (1989)
DLT 392, relying on the above decision of the Apex Court
P a g e 9 | 12
observed that the argument that for offences under ND & PS
Act, the report under Section 173(2) of the Code, which in law
was complete, was to be considered incomplete in the absence
of the opinion of the expert, was entirely misconceived. It was
observed by the Delhi HC in the said case that as far as the
expert report was concerned by virtue of Subsection (4) of
Section 293 of the Code, any document purporting to be a
report under the hand of Director or a Deputy Director of a
CFSL or SFSL can be used as evidence in any enquiry, trial or
other proceedings under the Code and it was open to the Court
where it thinks fit to summon and examine the scientific expert
and that under Section 173 CrPC there is no mandate that a
police report must enclose the documents purporting to be a
report under the hand of a Government scientific expert.
11.
In Navinkumar Pandu Jatot V. State of
Maharashtra, the Bombay High Court on 31st January 2022
(CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTINO BAIL APPLICATION NO.
301 of 2020 with Bail Application Nos. 3505 & 3506 of 2019)
after discussing several decision of the various High Court and
the Apex Court, held that mere absence of CA/FSL repot with
the chargesheet would not result in declaring the stipulated
time, the question of default bail does not arise.
12.
In the facts and case, in the light of aforementioned
decisions, it cannot be said that simply because the chemical
examination report is not yet received by the IO from the
laboratory, the investigation is not complete in as much as so
far as the job of the IO for collecting the evidence is
concerned, that is over the moment he despatches the material
for the opinion expert. The chemical report can be submitted
later as and when it is received from the concerned authority
of CFSL, Kamrup, Assam.
13.
In Central Bureau of Investigation V. RS. Pai and
Another AIR 2002 SC 1644, it was held that the scheme of
sub-section (8) of Section 173 of CrPC makes it absolutely clear
that even after the chargesheet is submitted, further
investigation is not precluded, then there is no question of not
permitting the prosecution to produce additional documents
which were gathered prior to or subsequent to investigation
and that in such cases, there cannot be any prejudice to the
accused.
14.
The facts in Ritu Chhabaria (supra) cited by the
applicant’s counsel were altogether different. In the said case,
indisputably, the investigation was in progress, but as the
statutory time period to file the chargeshet was coming to an
end, the chargesheet was filed charifying that the investigation
was still pending. In such circumstances, the Hon’ble Apex
Court took the view that there is no question of filing any
P a g e 10 | 12
supplementary chargesheet, taking the aid of sub-section (8)
of Section 173 of CrPC, as sub-section (8) of Section 173 of the
CrPC comes into play only after the investigation is completed
and the chargesheet is laid.
15.
The aforesaid decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court is of
no avail to the accused in the present case. In Judgebir
Singh @ Jasbir Singh Sarma @ Jasbir & Ors. V. National
Investigation Agency decided on 01/0-5/2023 in CRIMINAL
APPEAL NO. 1012 OF 2023, the Hon’ble SC observed that once
a final report has been filed, that is the proof of completion of
investigation and if final report is filed within the period of 180
days or 90 days or 60 days from the initial date of remand of
accused concerned, he cannot claim that a right has accrued to
him to be released on bail for want of filing of sanction order.
In the instate case, the final complaint was filed after the entire
investigation was purportedly completed except for want of the
chemical examination repot/expert opinion.
16.
Therefore, there is not merit in the argument of the
applicant’s counsel hat the final complaint without the chemical
examination report is not a complete one.
17.
There is no bas is for grant of bail on the grounds
mentioned in the present application in as much as the same
had already been considered on merit in the earlier order dated
28/04/2023 in Cril. Misc. (B) Case No. 21 of 2023 of this Court.
Further, in the light of the above decisions of the High Courts
and the Hon’ble SC, the prayer of the applicant to grant default
bail is also rejected.
18.
[14]
The application stands disposed of.”
It is evident that the Ld. Trial Court rightly rejected the
bail application as the Trial Court passed the order after discussing all
the materials on record with careful conspectus of legal spectrum,
juxtaposed with its view on the facts and merit of the case.
[15]
Having examined the materials on record, after hearing
both the learned counsel for the parties and also after perusal of the
impugned order dated 26.06.2023 passed in Cril. Misc. (B) Case No.
122 of 2023 by the learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Manipur, Imphal,
there is no ground for releasing the accused on bail as the prosecution
has rebutted all the allegations made in the application.
P a g e 11 | 12
[16]
Regarding the non-compliance of Section 50 of the ND &
PS Act, the State respondent explained in detail about it at Para No. 7
of the objection affidavit.
[17]
Accordingly, the present Bail Application No. 30 of 2023 is
dismissed and disposed of. However, the petitioner is given liberty to
file a fresh application on other grounds, if desired.
[18]
Send an extract copy of this order to the Court of Special
Judge (ND&PS), Manipur.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Lucy
P a g e 12 | 12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review