Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 12.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 23.02.2026
+
O.M.P. (COMM) 297/2024
PRIMETALS TECHNOLOGIES INDIA PRIVATE
LIMITED
Through: Mr. Rajesh Markanda, Mr.
Keshri Kumar & Mr. Saurav
Markanda, Advs.
versus
STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA LIMITED
& ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Siddharth Yadav, Sr. Adv
with Mr. Ashish Tiwari, Mr.
Anurag Tiwari and Mr. Sahib
Patel, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
JUDGMENT
1.
This petition is filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short „the Act‟) challenging the arbitral
award dated 24.05.2024.
FACTS
2.
A conspectus of the facts necessary for disposal of the case is
that the parties to the lis executed a contract on 12.10.2007 (for
brevity „the contract‟) for installation of the „Power Supply Facility
(package-II) for 700 TPD ASU-4 in Oxygen Plant no. II‟ at Bhilai
Steel Plant (for short „BSP‟). The work was to be completed by the
petitioner within fifteen months and
was for a price of
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
Rs.18,45,54,310/-. The contract was executed, the commission
certificate and the final acceptance certificate were issued on
20.06.2012 and 12.12.2013 respectively. The petitioner submitted
final invoices on 12.02.2019 and Rs.1,07,61,378/- was deducted for
shortfall in minimum guaranteed CENVAT credit (for short
„MGCC‟). Upon failure of conciliation attempts, arbitration
proceedings under clause 6 of the General Conditions of the Contract
(for short „GCC‟) were invoked on 07.02.2022.
3.
The only dispute involved in the present petition is vis-a-vis
claim nos.3 and 4 framed by the arbitrator, which read as under:
“3. Whether the Claimant is entitled to the declaration
from this Hon‟ble Tribunal that the amount of
Rs.1,07,61,378 deducted by the Respondent on account
of shortfall of guaranteed CENVAT is bad in law ?
4. Whether the Claimant is entitled to reimbursement of
Rs.1,07,61,378 deducted by the Respondent on account
of shortfall of guaranteed CENVAT ?”
4.
The issues were decided against the petitioner/claimant. Hence,
the present petition.
SUBMISSION OF THE PETITIONER
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that the arbitrator
travelled beyond the terms of the contract. In the absence of clause
permitting deduction for shortfall in MGCC the arbitrator erred in
upholding the deduction. The contention is that clause 14.5.2 of the
contract provides only for non-reimbursement of excise duty. It is
submitted that the award was passed without application of mind and
that the arbitrator relied upon a non-existent clause providing that in
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
case of excess CENVAT, the petitioner would be entitled to 50%
thereof.
SUBMISSION OF THE RESPONDENTS
6.
Per contra, the petitioner violated the terms of the contract.
Upon failure of the petitioner to pass on the MGCC as provided under
Article 2.1 of the contract, the respondents were entitled to deduct the
amount of shortfall in MGCC. It is argued that Article 2.1 of the
contract overrides the GCC. Further that, as per the petitioner, the
shortfall in MGCC was due to variation in the rate of taxes but neither
clause 14.6.2 was complied with by submitting proof of variation in
the rate of taxes within the stipulated time nor such evidence was
adduced before the arbitrator. It is canvassed that under clauses 14.6.1,
14.6.2 and 14.6.3, the contract price can be adjusted only in case of
variation in the rate of taxes leviable on finished equipments and not
on raw materials, parts, component, intermediate components,
assemblies, sub-assemblies etc.
6.1
It is emphasized that the scope of interference is limited to the
grounds available under Section 34 of the Act. The view taken by the
arbitrator is plausible and no case is made out for interference by this
court.
RELEVANT CLAUSES OF THE CONTRACT
7.
Before proceeding further, it would be relevant to reproduce
Article 2.1 of the Contract and clauses 11.1, 11.2, 11.2.1, 14.5.2,
14.6.1, 14.6.2 and 14.6.3 of the GCC.
“2.1 Contract Price (Reference GCC Clause 11 &
Appendix-1)
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
The Employer hereby agrees to pay to the Contractor
the Contract Price in consideration of the performance
by the Contractor of its obligations hereunder. The
Contract Price shall be Rs.18,45,54,310/- (Rupees
eighteen crore forty five lakh fifty four thousand and
three hundred ten only), or such other sums as may be
determined in accordance with the terms and
conditions of the Contract. A minimum amount of
Rs.2,16,42,894/- (Rupees two crore sixteen lakh forty
two thousand and eight hundred ninety four only) is to
be passed on to BSP as CENVAT credit.
11. Contract Price
11.1 The Contract Price shall be as specified in Article
2 (Contract Price and Terms of Payment) of the
Contract Agreement. The break-up of the Contract
Price is given in the Appendix-1 to the Contract
Agreement.
11.2. Price Basis
11.2.1 The Contract Price shall be for the entire scope
of the Facilities including spares, oils, grease,
lubricants, flushing liquor, chemicals for pickling etc.
required till commissioning of the Facilities, imported
surplus material and scrap in any form generated in
side the plant premises. The contract price shall be
inclusive of all taxes and duties and comprise inter-alia
of Basic price, excise duty, sales tax, VAT including
sales tax/VAT on works contract / Works Contract
Tax), octroi, Turn Over Tax (TOT), Entry Tax, Service
Tax, Education Cess and any other duties, taxes and
levies, as may be applicable and prevailing on the base
date of the contract and insurance. The payment of
duties, taxes, levies, etc. will be reimbursed (on actual)
against documentary evidence to be produced by the
contractor, subject to a ceiling indicated in the price
schedule of the contract.
In no case the reimbursement towards duties and taxes,
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
etc., shall exceed the amount indicated in Appendix-1
towards duties, taxes, levies, etc. except as indicated in
Sub-Clause 14.6.1, hereof.
14.5 CENVAT Credit
14.5.2 The Contractor shall submit the necessary
documents required by the Employer to avail the
CENVAT Credit. In case the Contractor fails to submit
the required document for claiming the CENVAT
Credit by the Employer in respect of certain plant &
equipment, the amount of Excise Duty on such
indigenous plant & equipment and Counter Veiling
Duty on such imported plant & equipment, shall not be
paid by the Employer to the Contractor.
14.6 Variations in Taxes & Duties
14.6.1 For the purpose of the Contract, it is agreed that
the 'Contract Price' specified in Article 2 ("Contract
Price" & "Terms of Payment") of the Contract
Agreement is based on the taxes, duties, levies and
charges prevailing on Base date (hereinafter called
"Tax" in this Sub-Clause 14.6 hereof). If any rate of
tax is increased or decreased, a new tax is introduced,
an existing tax is abolished, or any change in
interpretation or application of any tax occurs in the
course of the performance of Contract, which was or
will be assessed on the Contractor, Sub-Contractors or
their employees in connection with performance of the
Contract, an adjustment of the Contract Price shall be
made as per Sub-Clauses 14.6.2 & 14.6.3, hereof, by
addition to the Contract Price or deduction therefrom,
as the case may be.
14.6.2 The adjustment in the Contract Price towards
variation in the taxes shall be made by the Employer
on production of the documentary evidences by the
Contractor.
14.6.3 The Contract Price shall be adjusted towards
variations in taxes in respect of only finished
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
equipment supplied by the Contractor to the Employer.
No adjustment in the Contract price shall be made for
variations in the taxes on raw materials, parts,
component / intermediate components, assemblies /
sub-assemblies, etc.”
8.
The „contract price‟ as defined in Article 2.1 of the contract is
Rs.18,45,54,310/-, a minimum CENVAT amount of Rs.2,16,42,894/was to be passed on by the petitioner to BSP.
8.1
As per Clause 11 of the GCC, the basis of the contract price was
the scope of facilities including the consumables required for
commissioning of the facilities, imported surplus material and scrap
generated inside the plant. The contract price was inclusive of taxes,
duties, cess, entry tax applicable and prevailing on the base date of the
contract as well as insurance. The payments of the taxes, duties and
levies were to be reimbursed on actual basis subject to production of
documentary evidence by the petitioner. The reimbursement was
subject to the ceiling indicated in the price schedule except for service
tax.
8.2
Clause 14 deals with taxes and duties. Clause 14.5.2 obligated
the petitioner to submit necessary documents to BSP for availing the
CENVAT credit. Duty was not to be reimbursed on failure of the
petitioner to furnish documents for availing the CENVAT credit.
8.3
Clause 14.6 relates to variation in taxes and duties. Clause
14.6.1 provides that on increase or decrease in the tax rate,
introduction of a new tax, abolition of an existing tax, change in
interpretation or application of tax during the course of performance
of the contract, the contract price shall be adjusted as per clauses
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
14.6.2 and 14.6.3 by making the required addition or reduction in the
contract price. Under clause 14.6.2, adjustment of the contract price
for variation in taxes was to be made by the respondents on production
of the documentary evidence by the petitioner. Under clause 14.6.3,
the contract price was to be adjusted on variation in taxes in respect of
finished equipments supplied and not for variation in taxes on raw
materials, parts, components, intermediatory components, assemblies
or sub-assemblies.
ISSUE
9.
Issue is whether the shortfall in MGCC which was not
reimbursed could be deducted from the invoices?
ANALYSIS
10.
The execution of the work and commissioning of the facilities
are not in dispute. The admitted position is that there was a shortfall of
Rs.1,07,61,378/- in MGCC, which was not reimbursed to the
petitioner and deduction was made from the invoices raised.
11.
It would be relevant to note that the gross contract price
consisted of the following items:
S.
No.
1.
2.
3.
Description
Siemens
Indian Rupees
Supply of Plant & Equipment
(a) Imported (FOB) (Refer
Table-3)
17,07,83,162/(b) Indigenous (At site) (Refer
Table-4)
Civil
Engineering
Work
including Supplies (Refer 74,25,665/Table-9)
Storage, Handling, Erection, 63,45,483/-
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
4.
5.
6.
12.
Commissioning, and P.G.
Tests of Plant & Equipment
(Refer Table-11)
Total contract Price (1 to 13)
18,45,54,310/CENVAT Credit
2,16,42,894
Contract Price (Net of 16,29,11,416/CENVAT)
Article 2.1 provides that the petitioner shall ensure passing on
the MGCC of Rs.2,16,42,894/-. The effect is that the gross contract
price was Rs.18,45,54,310/- but after availing the benefit of MGCC
the cost of the work for the respondents would be Rs.16,29,11,416/which is the net contract price after credit of CENVAT and VAT.
Clause 14.5.2 provides that upon failure of the petitioner to submit the
required documents for claiming CENVAT there shall be no
reimbursement of excise duty. Albeit in the case in hand, less excise
duty paid resulted in a shortfall in MGCC but for this eventuality there
is no clause in the contract providing for deduction of the amount for
such shortfall. There cannot be quarrel with the proposition that no
clause can be read into the contract entered between the parties.
13.
The contention of the learned counsel for the respondents that
Article 2.1 of the contract shall override the terms of the GCC is of no
avail. Article 2.1 provides for MGCC to be passed on but it does not
deal with the consequences in case of a shortfall.
14.
The contract value is an amount payable to the petitioner for the
work executed and is inclusive of taxes and duties. The MGCC is not
a sum due for the work done but is a reimbursement of the duty paid
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
which may vary consequent to several factors including variation in
the rate of taxes and change in the price of items.
15.
The matter needs to be considered from another angle. The
gross contract value was Rs.18,45,54,310/-. After giving credit of
Rs.2,16,42,894/- towards MGCC, the work would cost the
respondents Rs.16,29,11,416 /- (Net Contract Value). The position
remained
unchanged
despite
the
shortfall
in
MGCC.
The
reimbursement of duty paid was Rs.1,08,81,516/- for which the
respondents shall get CENVAT credit. By not reimbursing the
shortfall in MGCC the respondents retained the balance amount of
Rs.1,07,61,378/- and the net cost of the contract remained
Rs.16,29,11,4161/-. In other words, for getting an MGCC of
Rs.2,16,47,894/- the respondents had to pay Rs.18,45,54,310/- but
upon reimbursement of excise duty of Rs.1,08,81,516/-, the
respondents paid a sum of Rs.17,37,92,932/- i.e., Rs.1,07,61,378/- less
than the gross contract value. Consequently, the net contract price
payable for the work done remained unaffected by the shortfall in
MGCC as it was not reimbursed and the amount remained with the
respondents.
16.
Whether variation in the rate of tax resulted in shortfall in
MGCC and if contract price could be adjusted as per clause 14.6.1 for
variation in rate of taxes on raw materials, components etc., need not
be dilated upon. The arbitrator rightly held that the shortfall in MGCC
shall not be reimbursed but there cannot be deduction for such
shortfall thereby rendering the reasons for shortfall to be
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
inconsequential. For this very reason, non compliance of clause 14.6.2
shall not be fatal to the claim of the petitioner.
17.
The arbitrator rightly took into account that the MGCC formed
the basis of the tender valuation but failed to consider that despite the
shortfall in MGCC, the net value of the contract remained unchanged.
18.
The arbitrator travelled beyond the terms of the contract to
reject the claim. To justify the conclusion arrived at, reference was
made to a non-existing clause in the contract that 50% benefit of
CENVAT would go to the petitioner. At the cost of repetition there is
no clause for deducting the shortfall in MGCC from the invoices. It is
a trite law that an arbitrator has to decide the dispute within the four
corners of the terms and conditions of the contract. The venture of the
arbitrator beyond the terms and conditions vitiates the award by patent
illegality. Reference in this regard be made to the following decisions
of the Supreme Court:
18.1 In Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd. v. Shree Ganesh Petroleum,
(2022) 4 SCC 463 held as under:
“43. An Arbitral Tribunal being a creature of contract,
is bound to act in terms of the contract under which it
is constituted. An award can be said to be patently
illegal where the Arbitral Tribunal has failed to act in
terms of the contract or has ignored the specific terms
of a contract.”
18.2 In State of Chhattisgarh v. SAL Udyog (P) Ltd., (2022) 2
SCC 275 held as under:
“26. ………. We are, therefore, of the view that failure
on the part of the learned sole arbitrator to decide in
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
accordance with the terms of the contract governing the
parties, would certainly attract the “patent illegality
ground”, as the said oversight amounts to gross
contravention of Section 28(3) of the 1996 Act, that
enjoins the Arbitral Tribunal to take into account the
terms of the contract while making an award. The said
“patent illegality” is not only apparent on the face of
the award, it goes to the very root of the matter and
deserves interference……….”
18.3 In Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. v. Annapurna Construction,
(2003) 8 SCC 154 held as under:
“22. There lies a clear distinction between an error
within the jurisdiction and error in excess of
jurisdiction. Thus, the role of the arbitrator is to
arbitrate within the terms of the contract. He has no
power apart from what the parties have given him
under the contract. If he has travelled beyond the
contract, he would be acting without jurisdiction,
whereas if he has remained inside the parameters of the
contract, his award cannot be questioned on the ground
that it contains an error apparent on the face of the
record.”
(emphasis supplied)
19.
The law is well settled that the parties are bound by the terms of
the contract and the arbitrator cannot go into the fairness of the terms
and conditions. In the case in hand in absence of a clause providing
for deduction on account of shortfall in MGCC, the arbitrator
proceeded on the basis that the petitioner had to make good the
shortfall in MGCC but failed to point out the clause for providing such
deduction.
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
20.
The arbitrator erred in holding that the tax component formed
part of the contract price and not the MGCC, whereas MGCC was the
credit of excise duty paid which was part of the contract price.
21.
The arbitrator relying upon clauses 11.2.1 and 14.5.2 of GCC
and Article 2.1 of the contract rightly concluded that the petitioner had
to ensure MGCC. However, while referring to clause 14.6.2 the
arbitrator overlooked that no clause in the contract provides for
deduction of shortfall in MGCC. On the contrary, under clause 14.5.2
in case of failure of the petitioner to submit documents enabling the
respondents to avail CENVAT credit, the duty paid to that extent was
not to be reimbursed. Moreover, clause 14.6.2 cannot be pressed into
service in isolation and is to be read along with clauses 14.6.1 and
14.6.3. Clause 14.6.3 states that the adjustment in contract price would
be made only for variation in taxes in respect of finished equipment
supplied by the petitioner and not for variation in taxes on raw
material, parts, component, intermediate components, assemblies, subassemblies etc., and is not applicable in facts of the present case.
22.
The arbitrator while holding that the net outgoing would be the
contract price reduced by MGCC, failed to consider that the net
outflow of the respondents was not affected by any shortfall in
MGCC. There was no basis to hold that the shortfall in MGCC could
be deducted from the invoices and this tantamounts to adding terms to
the contract between the parties which is not permissible in law.
CONCLUSION
23.
In view of the above discussion, there is no clause in the
contract for deducting the shortfall in MGCC; clause 14.5.2 only
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
stipulates that upon failure of the petitioner to produce documents
enabling the respondents to avail CENVAT credit there shall be no
reimbursement of the duty paid; despite the shortfall in MGCC the net
value of the contract remained unchanged; and the arbitrator relied
upon a non-existent clause to the effect that in case of excess
CENVAT, the petitioner would gain by 50%. The arbitrator travelled
beyond the clauses of the contract and the award is vitiated by patent
illegality.
24.
The petition is allowed and the impugned arbitral award is set
aside.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J.
FEBRUARY 23, 2026
Ch
Reportable:- Yes
Signed By:HONEY
ARORA
O.M.P.(COMM) 297/2024
15:33:38
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review