Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 10.11.2025
Judgment delivered on: 16.01.2026
+
LPA 1242/2024, CM APPL. 75626/2024, CM APPL. 75629/2024 &
CM APPL. 64851/2025
PRESS COUNCIL OF INDIA
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Vikramjit Banerjee, ASG with
Mr. T. Singhdev, Mr. Bhanu Gulati,
Ms. Yamini Singh, Mr. Abhijit
Chakravarty, Ms. Anum Hussain, Ms.
R. Kaur, Ms. Akansha, Mr. S. Kumar,
Mr. T. Srivastava, Mr. P. Rawat, Mr.
Vedant Sood, Advs. for PCI
versus
PRESS CLUB, MUMBAI & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Akhil Sibal, Sr. Adv with Mr.
Salim A.Inamdar, Ms. Janvi Sindhu
and Mr. Krishnesh Bapat, Advs for R1.
Mr. Rohan Jaitly, CGSC with Mr.
Dev Pratap Shahi and Mr. Varun
Pratap Singh, Advs. for UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TUSHAR RAO GEDELA
JUDGMENT
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, C.J.
CHALLENGE
1.
This intra-Court appeal takes exception to the judgment and order
dated 22.11.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge whereby W.P.(C.) No.
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
16202/2024 filed by the respondent No.1 – petitioner (the Press Club,
Mumbai) has been allowed and the recommendation of the Scrutiny
Committee dated 10.09.2024 so far as it relates to respondent No.1 whereby
it was not included in the list of notified “associations of persons” for the
purposes of re-constitution of the 15th Press Council of India (the
appellant), has been quashed.
FACTS
2.
Press Council of India is a statutory body incorporated under Section
4 of the Press Council Act, 1978 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”) and is
a body corporate having perpetual succession and a common seal.
3.
Section 5 of the Act provides for composition of the Council which
consists of a Chairman and twenty eight other Members. Out of twenty eight
other Members of the Council, thirteen are nominated from amongst the
working Journalists of whom six are Editors of newspapers and seven are
working Journalists other than Editors. Six persons are to be nominated from
amongst persons who own or carry on business of management of
newspapers. One Member is nominated amongst persons who manage news
agencies and three persons are those who have special knowledge or
practical experience in education, science, law and literature and culture, of
whom one is nominated by University Grants Commission, one by the Bar
Council of India and one by the Sahitya Academy. Rest five Members are
Members of Parliament of whom three are nominated by the Speaker from
amongst the Members of the Lok Sabha and two are nominated by the
Chairman of the Rajya Sabha from amongst its Members. For the purposes
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
of nomination of thirteen Members from amongst working Journalists and
also for nominating six persons from amongst persons who own or carrying
on business of management of newspapers and also for nominating one
Member from persons who manage news agencies, the retiring Chairperson
of the previous Council has to invite panels of names comprising twice the
number of Members to be nominated, from “associations of persons” of the
working Journalists, those who own or carry on the business of management
of newspapers and also those who manage news agencies. All persons are
nominated as Members of the Council by the Council except in the case of
the First Council and on nomination of persons as Members, the Central
Government notifies names of persons nominated by the Council. So far as
the present case is concerned, we are concerned with nominations of
working Journalists in terms of Section 5(3)(a) of the Act.
4.
Section 5 of the Act is extracted herein below:
“5. Composition of the Council.—(1) The Council shall consist of a
Chairman and twenty-eight other members.
(2) The Chairman shall be a person nominated by a Committee consisting
of the Chairman of the Council of States (Rajya Sabha), the Speaker of the
House of the People (Lok Sabha) and a person elected by the members of
the Council under sub-section (6) and the nomination so made shall take
effect from the date on which it is notified by the Central Government in
the Official Gazette.
(3) Of the other members—
(a) thirteen shall be nominated in accordance with such procedure
as may be prescribed from among the working journalists, of
whom six shall be editors of newspapers and the remaining seven
shall be working journalists other than editors; so, however, that
the number of such editors and working journalists other than
editors in relation to newspapers published in Indian languages
shall be not less than three and four respectively;
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
(b) six shall be nominated in accordance with such procedure as
may be prescribed from among persons who own or carry on the
business of management of newspapers, so, however, that there
shall be two representatives from each of the categories of big
newspapers, medium newspapers and small newspapers;
(c) one shall be nominated in accordance with such procedure as
may be prescribed from among persons who manage news
agencies;
(d) three shall be persons having special knowledge or practical
experience in respect of education and science, law, and literature
and culture of whom respectively one shall be nominated by the
University Grants Commission, one by the Bar Council of India
and one by the Sahitya Academy;
(e) five shall be members of Parliament of whom three shall be
nominated by the Speaker from among the members of the House
of the People (Lok Sabha) and two shall be nominated by the
Chairman of the Council of States (Rajya Sabha) from among its
members:
Provided that no working journalist who owns, or carries on the business
of management of, any newspaper shall be eligible for nomination under
clause (a):
Provided further that the nominations under clause (a) and clause (b)
shall be so made that among the persons nominated there is not more than
one person interested in any newspaper or group of newspapers under the
same control or management.
[Explanation.—For the purposes of clause (b), a “newspaper” shall be
deemed to be categorised as big, medium or small newspaper on the basis
of its circulation per issue, as the Central Government may, by
notification in the Official Gazette, notify from time to time.]
(4) Before making any nomination under clause (a), clause (b) or clause
(c) of sub-section (3), the Central Government in the case of the first
Council and the retiring Chairman of the previous Council in the case of
any subsequent Council shall, in the prescribed manner, invite panels of
names comprising twice the number of members to be nominated from
such associations of persons of the categories referred to in the said
clause (a), clause (b) or clause (c) as may be notified in this behalf by the
Central Government in the case of the first Council and by the Council
itself in the case of subsequent Councils:
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
Provided that where there is no association of persons of the category
referred to in the said clause (c), the panels of names shall be invited from
such news agencies as may be notified as aforesaid.
(5) The Central Government shall notify the names of persons nominated
as members under sub-section (3) in the Official Gazette and every such
nomination shall take effect from the date on which it is notified.
(6) The members of the Council notified under sub-section (5) shall elect
from among themselves in accordance with such procedure as may be
prescribed, a person to be a member of the Committee referred to in subsection (2) and a meeting of the members of the Council for the purpose of
such election shall be presided over by a person chosen from among
themselves.”
5.
Prescribing the procedure for notification of “associations of persons”
for the purposes of constitution of the Council, the Central Government has
framed rules known as the Press Council (Procedure for Notification of
Associations of Persons) Rules, 2021 (hereinafter referred to as the “Rules,
2021”) in exercise of its powers conferred on it under Section 25 read with
Section 5(4) of the Act. As per Rule 3, in case of a Council subsequent to
the First Council, the retiring Chairman has to invite filing of claims from
eligible “associations of persons” by giving wide publicity. Rule 4 of the
Rules, 2021 provides for the eligibility of “association of persons” for being
eligible to file claims. According to Rule 4, to be eligible an “association of
persons” must have been registered under the relevant law for at least six
years prior to last date of filing of the claims and must be conducting its
business continuously thereafter. Rule 4 also requires the “association of
persons” seeking its nomination to submit documents duly certified by the
competent authority under the relevant law under which the association is
registered.
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
6.
Rule 5 provides for scrutiny of such claims of “associations of
persons” by a Scrutiny Committee comprising of three persons to be
nominated by the Chairperson from amongst the Members of the Council
and such Scrutiny Committee is required to submit its report to the Council.
Sub Rule 2 of Rule 5 provides that the Council on consideration of the
report submitted by the Scrutiny Committee shall take appropriate decision
and notify the “associations of persons” in terms of the requirement of
Section 5(4) of the Act. The Rules, 2021 are extracted herein below:
“In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-sections (1) and (2) of Section
25 read with sub-section (4) of Section 5 of the Press Council Act, 1978
(37 of 1978), the Central Government hereby makes the following rules,
namely—
1. Short title and commencement.—(1) These rules may be called
the Press Council (Procedure for Notification of Associations of Persons)
Rules, 2021.
(2) They shall come into force on the date of their publication in the
Official Gazette.
2. Definitions.—In these rules—
(a) “Act” means the Press Council Act, 1978 (37 of 1978);
(b) “associations of persons” means associations of persons of the
categories referred to in clause (a), clause (b) and clause (c) of
sub-section (3) of Section 5;
(c) “Committee” means the Scrutiny Committee constituted by the
Chairman under Rule 5 in exercise of powers under Section 8;
(d) “section” means a section of the Act;
(e) words and expressions used but not defined herein shall have
the meanings assigned to them in the Act.
3. Associations of persons to be notified.—The Central Government in the
case of first Council and the retiring Chairman of the previous Council in
the case of any subsequent Council shall, for the purpose of notifying
associations of persons under sub-section (4) of Section 5, invite filing of
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
claims from eligible associations of persons by giving wide publicity in at
least two widely circulated national daily newspapers.
4. Eligibility of association of persons.—For being eligible to file claims
under Rule 3, an association of persons must have been registered under
the relevant laws for the time being in force for at least six years prior to
last date of filing of the claims and must be conducting its business
continuously thereafter, and shall submit documents in proof thereof, duly
certified by the competent authority under such relevant laws:
Provided that the memorandum of association of such association of
persons shall not restrict its membership to any particular religion, race,
caste or language.
5. Scrutiny of Claims.—(1) The claims filed by associations of persons
under Rule 3 shall be scrutinized by a Scrutiny Committee consisting of
three persons to be nominated by the Chairman from amongst members of
the Council who are not associated in any manner with any of such
claimant associations and shall submit its report to the Council.
(2) The Council shall, after considering the report submitted by the
Scrutiny Committee, take appropriate decision and notify the
associations of persons as required under sub-section (4) of
Section 5:
Provided that where the decision of the Council is at variance with the
recommendations of the Scrutiny Committee, such decision shall be taken
by not less than three-fourth majority of members, other than members of
the Scrutiny Committee, present and voting, and in case of equality of
votes, the Chairman shall have the casting vote.”
7.
The term of the 14th Press Council of India expired on 05.10.2024.
Before the expiry of its term, the Council issued a notice on 09.06.2024
inviting filing of claims for notification of “associations of persons” for
constituting 15th Press Council of India under Rule 3 of the Rules, 2021.
The notice dated 09.06.2024 mentions eligibility of “association of persons”
which is extracted herein below:
“Eligibility of Association of Persons:
Association of Persons must have following:
a) It must have been registered under the relevant laws for the time being
in force for at least six years prior to last date of filing of the claims;
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
b) It must be conducting its business continuously thereafter, and shall
submit documents in proof thereof, duly certified by the competent
authority under such relevant laws;
c) The Memorandum of Association (MoA) of such association of persons
shall not restrict its membership to any particular religion, race, caste
or language.
The claims shall be filed in a sealed envelope superscribed “Claims with the
name of the Association” on the letter head of the association carrying the
registered address for correspondence, email i.d., contact numbers with the
CHAIRPERSON PRESS COUNCIL OF INDIA, SOOCHNA BHAWAN, 8, CGO
COMPLEX, LODHI ROAD, NEW DELHI-110003, so as to reach on or before
5:00 PM of 24thJuly, 2024.”
8.
The said notice also mentioned the supportive documents to be filed which are as
under:
“SUPPORTIVE DOCUMENTS TO BE FILED
The claims should be accompanied by supportive documents showing that
the associations eligible in terms of the Act and the Rules made thereunder
to represent anyone of the categories set out above and also to establish
that it is qualified to represent the category under which it is staking its
claim.
Following documents authenticated by Notary Public need to be filed:
(a)
A copy of the MoA/Constitution/MoU of the Association;
(b)
Copy of the Registration Certificate of the claimant body,
with up to date renewal certificate wherever applicable;
(c)
Minutes of the General Body meetings for the last six years
preceding the issuance of advertisement filed before the
appropriate authority i.e. Registrar of Societies or such authorities
under relevant laws under which the Associations of persons is
registered to show their existence for at least six years prior to last
date of filing of the claims;
(d)
Certificate of the Competent Authority under relevant law
in the following format:
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
Dated:
Certificate
I ________________ (Full Name) do hereby certify
________________ (Name of the Association) has been
registered/incorporated under (Name of the Act) on_________
(Date, Month & Year) and conducting its business continuously
thereafter.
(Signature and Seal of the Competent Authority)
(e) An upto date detailed list of its members representing the
category under which the claim is being filed with complete
particulars as set out below, in hardcopy as well as soft copy in
Pen Drive:
(1) SURNAME, FIRST NAME
(2) RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS OF THE MEMBER(S)
(3) TITLE OF THE NEWSPAPER BEING REPRESENTED ALONGWITH
REGISTRATION NUMBER
(4) LANGUAGE IN WHICH THE NEWSPAPER IS PUBLISHED
(5) NEWSPAPER PUBLICATION ADDRESS ALONG WITH STATE
NAME
(6) OFFICE ADDRESS WITH NAME OF THE STATE AT WHICH THE
MEMBER IS CURRENTLY POSTED
(7) DESIGNATION IN THE NEWSPAPER i.e. EDITOR, WORKING
JOURNALIST OTHER THAN EDITORS, OWNER/PUBLISHER
ORMANAGER
(8) CIRCULATION OF THE NEWSPAPER OWNED OR MANAGED BY
THE MEMBER [INFORMATION REGARDING THIS POINT TO BE
PROVIDED BY ASSOCIATIONS FILING CLAIM UNDER SECTION
5(3)(b)]
(9) WHETHER MEMBER OF ANY OTHER PARALLEL ASSOCIATION
(10)YEAR OF JOINING THE ASSOCIATION AND
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
(11)MEMBERSHIP FEE UPTO DATE OR OUTSTANDING
THE ASSOCIATION SHALL SPECIFY THE CATEGORY UNDER
WHICH THEYARE STAKING THEIR CLAIM.
The President/Secretary/authorized signatory to the association shall
make and subscribe to a declaration to be sworn before the Notary Public,
verifying that he/she has been duly authorized by the Association of
Persons to file the claim and the facts stated in the claim application and
the particulars attached thereto are true to the best of his/her knowledge
and belief and information.
The claimant association shall also subscribe to a declaration establishing
that the claim of the said body is valid and free from all
encumbrances/disputes/litigation. The Press Council may at its discretion
reject any claim if any such encumbrances are brought to its notice.
No claim made by any person other than a person duly authorized under
the Constitution of the association shall be entertained.
Any claim not in conformity with the above is liable to be rejected.
The Press Council of India will be within its right to call for such
additional information or verify such information as might be considered
necessary.
The associations notified for the present term of the Press Council (20212024) may also take note of this Notice and file fresh claim applications.
The list of the claimant's Associations shall be published on the website of
the Council on or before 25thJuly, 2024. Any person can file objection
questioning the eligibility of claimant‟s Associations by 1stAugust, 2024.
The claims shall be decided by the Scrutiny Committee thereafter.
No claim made after 5:00 PM of 24thJuly, 2024 will be entertained.”
9.
The notice dated 09.06.2024 also required the claimant association to
subscribe a declaration establishing that claim of the concerned association
is valid and free from all encumbrances/ disputes/ litigations. It also
provided that the Council may at its discretion reject any claim if any such
encumbrances are bought to its notice. According to the said notice no
claim made by a person other than a person duly authorized under the
constitution of the association shall be entertained and any claim which is
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
found not in conformity with such requirements is liable to be rejected. It
was further provided therein that the Press Council of India will be within its
right to call for such additional information or verify such additional
information as might be considered necessary.
10.
The respondent No.1 – the Press Club, Mumbai submitted its
application pursuant to the notice dated 09.06.2024. The application of the
petitioner and those of other associations were scrutinized by the Scrutiny
Committee which submitted its report/ recommendation on 10.09.2024. In
respect of the application of the respondent No.1 – the Press Club, Mumbai
recommendation made by the Scrutiny Committee in its report dated
10.09.2024 was to reject the application for the reasons stated in the said
recommendation. The recommendation made in respect of the respondent
No.1 – the Press Club, Mumbai is as follows:
27.
Mumbai Press Club
filed by Shri Rajesh
Mascarenhas,
Honorary Secretary
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
REJECTED1. Copy of Registration Certificate is not legible.
2. Certificate issued by competent authority is in the
name of Press Club Bombay but the application is in
the name of Mumbai Press Club. This is a
fundamental discrepancy which makes the
application liable for rejection.
3. Scrutiny Committee observed that all the pages of
the documents must carry signature along with seal
of notary for authentication by Notary public to be
valid.
Only the first and last page of List of members
are notarized.
Only the last page of constitution carries the
signature along with Notary seal and stamp
Only the first page and two other pages of the
Minutes of the meetings submitted by the
association carry the signature of notary
4. No proof of submission of minutes to the appropriate
Authority.
5. There is no clear authorization letter to fil the claim.
However, it has been mentioned in a paragraph of
the declaration.
11.
The Press Council of India, vide notification dated 28.10.2024
notified “associations of persons” pertaining to different categories,
including the category with which this matter is concerned with, namely the
category as provided for in Section 5(3)(a) of the Act, however, accepting
the recommendation made by the Scrutiny Committee dated 10.09.2024,
name of the respondent No.1 – the Press Club, Mumbai was not included in
the list of “association of persons” as notified by the Press Council on
28.10.2024. It may also be noticed that the recommendation made by the
Scrutiny Committee, dated 10.09.2024 was considered by the Press Council
of India in its meeting held on 27.09.2024 whereby all the recommendations
made by the Scrutiny Committee were accepted, including the
recommendation of rejection in respect of respondent No.1 – the Press Club,
Mumbai. It was, however, noticed in the minutes of the meeting of Press
Council of India held on 27.09.2024 that eight votes were cast against the
recommendation of the Scrutiny Committee in respect of the claim of the
respondent No.1 which was filed under the category of working Journalists
other than Editors. The relevant extract of the Minutes of the Meeting of the
Press Council of India held on 27.09.2024 is quoted herein below:
“Rule 5. Scrutiny of Claims.- ( 1) The claims filed by associations of
persons under rule 3 shall be scrutinized by a Scrutiny Committee
consisting of three persons to be nominated by the Chairman from
amongst members or (he Council who are not associated in any manner
with any of such claimant associations and shall submit its report to the
Council.
(2) The Council shall, after considering the report submitted by the
Scrutiny Committee, take appropriate decision and notify the associations
of persons as required under subsection (4) of section 5.
Provided that where the decision of the Council is at variance with the
recommendations of the Scrutiny Committee, such decision shall be taken
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
by not less than three fourth majority of members, other than members of
the Scrutiny Committee, present and voting, and in case of equality of
votes, the Chairman shall have the casting vote.
The Council proceeded to consider the report of the Scrutiny Committee.
All the claims in the Scrutiny Committee report (attached as annexure A)
and recommendations thereupon were read out before the full Council and
disapprovals, if any, on each decision were sought. Not a single decision
could muster three fourth (3/4th) of total members present (1 member
through video conferencing) and voting (17). Accordingly, the Council
adopted the Scrutiny Committee report in its entirety by majority.
However, eight votes were against the recommendations in case of Claim
No. 27 i.e. Mumbai Press Club filed under the Category Working
Journalists other than Editors.
12.
After notifying the eligible “associations of persons”, the Press
Council of India vide its notification dated 13.11.2024 invited panel of
names comprising twice the requisite number of working Journalists (14)
from the “associations of persons” notified vide notification dated
28.10.2024 for nomination to the Council as Members in terms of Section
5(4) of the Act. Being aggrieved by its non-inclusion, the respondent No.1
instituted the proceedings of the underlying writ petition with the prayer to
quash the recommendation of the Scrutiny Committee made by it in its
report dated 10.09.2024 so far as it related to the respondent No.1. A
direction was also sought for directing the appellant to notify the respondent
No.1 as “association of persons” in terms of Rule 3 of the Rules, 2021 and
Section 5(3)(a) of the Act and also to include the panel of the respondent
No.1 for constitution of the 15th Press Council of India. The learned Single
Judge by passing the impugned judgment and order dated 22.11.2024 has
held that the reasons given by the Scrutiny Committee rejecting its claim to
be included as “association of persons” are illegal, erroneous and thus not
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
sustainable. It is this judgment rendered by the learned Single Judge which
is under challenge herein.
SUBMISSIONS MADE ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
13.
Mr. Vikramjit Banerjee, learned ASG impeaching the impugned
judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge has argued that from
the material available on record, though it is apparent that the respondent
No.1 did not fulfill the eligibility as per the requirement of Rule 4 of the
Rules, 2021 read with the notice dated 09.06.2024 issued by the Council
inviting claims for nomination of “association of persons” for the purposes
of reconstitution of the 15th Press Council of India, the learned Single Judge
has erred in law in holding that the respondent No.1 was eligible.
14.
Relying on a judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Union
of India and Others v. Mahendra Singh, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 909,
learned counsel for the appellant has stated that if a statute provides for a
thing to be done in a particular manner then it has to be done in that manner
and not in any other manner, however, the learned Single Judge has
completely ignored the said legal principle and has returned a finding that
the application filed by the respondent No.1 was in order and that the
reasons given by the Scrutiny Committee for rejecting the claim of the
respondent No.1 were not sustainable.
15.
Mr. Banerjee referred to a Constitution Bench judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Commissioner of Central Excise, New Delhi v.
Hari Chand Shri Gopal and Others, (2011) 1 SCC 236 wherein it has been
held that the plea of substantial compliance is not available to a party in case
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
there is violation of clear statutory prerequisites which effectuates the object
and purpose of the statute and in case such statutory prerequisites have not
been met, the plea of substantial compliance is not available.
16.
He has further argued that in the facts of the present case, plea of
substantial compliance was not available to the respondent No.1 as the
application submitted by the respondent No.1 was in breach of essential
statutory requirements. On the plea made by respondent no.1 before the
learned Single Judge that its Members were nominated as Members of the
previous Press Council of India, learned ASG has argued that merely
because its Members were nominated as the Members of the previous
Council, it will not entitle the respondent No.1 to seek nomination of its
Members for the reason that it does not fulfill the eligibility as per the
conditions of eligibility and documents to be submitted by it, in terms of the
notice inviting claims for nomination dated 09.06.2024, were deficient.
17.
To substantiate his arguments, he has relied upon Chandigarh
Administration and Another v. Jagjit Singh and Another, (1995) 1 SCC
745 wherein, it has been held that in exercise of its powers under Article 226
of the Constitution of India, the High Court cannot ignore the law and well
accepted principle governing writ jurisdiction to say that because in one case
a particular order has been passed or a particular action has been taken, the
same must be repeated irrespective of the fact whether such an order or
action is contrary to law. On these counts it has been argued that learned
Single Judge has erred in law and facts, which vitiates the impugned
judgment.
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
18.
Mr. Akhil Sibal, learned senior counsel representing the respondent
No.1 has defended the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned
Single Judge and has submitted that the Scrutiny Committee has clearly
erred by ignoring the substance of the contents of the application submitted
by respondent No.1 and that the respondent No.1 in fact fulfilled all the
requisite conditions and therefore, the recommendation made by the
Scrutiny Committee was not sustainable. He has argued that the requirement
of eligibility of “association of persons”, as given in the notice dated
09.06.2024 has to be read in the light of what has been prescribed in Rule 4
of the Rules, 2021 and further that anything read beyond Rule 4 in the notice
is not sustainable.
19.
He has further submitted that the supportive documents to be filed as
per the notice dated 09.06.2024 are only to substantiate the claim of
eligibility, as given in Rule 4 and requirement of such supportive documents
cannot be read ignoring the eligibility as prescribed in Rule 4. It is his
submission that in any case, the certificate given by the competent person as
per the proforma contained in the notice dated 09.06.2024, clearly
establishes that respondent no.1 has been registered and has been conducting
its business continuously after its registration.
20.
Mr. Sibal has also argued that learned Single Judge has, in the
impugned judgment and order, clearly dealt with each and every objection
raised by the Scrutiny Committee and has returned a finding based on the
material available on record which in any manner cannot be faulted with. He
has relied upon Hari Chand Shri Gopal (supra) to submit that if essence of
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
a Rule regarding requirement of eligibility is met and some other aspects
which may amount to minor non-compliance are not met, doctrine of
substantial compliance, as laid down in Hari Chand Shri Gopal (supra)
will be attracted and, therefore, it was not open to the Scrutiny Committee to
have rejected the application of respondent no.1 on certain minor lacunae.
According to him, what is to be seen is actual compliance in respect to the
substance which is essential to object of the statute and therefore, learned
Single Judge has rightly determined that in the facts of the present case, the
application submitted by respondent No.1 fulfilled the requirement of
substantial and actual compliance keeping in view the object of the Rule and
hence, the finding recorded by learned Single Judge that reasons given for
rejection of the application of respondent no.1 are not sustainable need not
be interfered with.
21.
Learned senior counsel for the respondent has also relied upon T.M.
Jacob v. C. Poulose and Others, (1999) 4 SCC 274 and has submitted that
in the present case doctrine of substantial compliance has rightly been
invoked by the learned Single Judge. According to him, the minor defects
concerning eligibility of respondent No.1 were not such as could have
misled the Scrutiny Committee and therefore, Scrutiny Committee ought to
have treated respondent no.1 to be fully eligible for being nominated as an
eligible association.
DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
22.
In the backdrop of the provisions of the Act and the Rules, as also the
requirement as mentioned in the notice dated 09.06.2024 and the contents of
the application submitted by respondent No.1, if we analyse the judgment of
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
the learned Single Judge, we do not find any irregularity which may warrant
any interference by us in this appeal.
23.
The learned Single Judge after noticing the various provisions of the
Act and the Rules, as also the contents of the application, has arrived at a
categorical finding in respect of each objection raised by the Scrutiny
Committee to the application furnished by respondent No.1 putting forth its
claim for nomination and has held that requirement under the Rules stood
satisfied. The relevant portion of the judgment of learned Single Judge is
relevant to be extracted which reads as under:“20. The recommendations/objections raised by the Scrutiny Committee of
Respondent No. 1 reproduced in paragraph 11 of this order are arbitrary
and ex facie erroneous, contrary to the record, and unsustainable in the
face of law. Each of the Committee‟s objections is addressed in detail
below:
Objection regarding the Copy of Registration Certificate not being
legible:
(i) The Scrutiny Committee‟s first objection pertains to the alleged
illegibility of the copy of the Registration Certificate. We must
acknowledge that the original Registration Certificate dates back to 1971,
a document over half a century old. Naturally, with the passage of time,
the original certificate has faded, and consequently, the photocopy
submitted is faint. However, upon careful examination, the photocopy
remains legible.
(ii) The criteria under Rule 4 of the PC Rules require that the association
be registered under the relevant laws for at least six years prior to the last
date of filing the claims. In compliance with these requirements, the
Petitioner not only submitted the original Registration Certificate but also
provided a fresh Certificate of Registration dated 19th July 2024. This
updated Certificate was issued by the Assistant Registrar of Societies,
Greater Mumbai Region, Mumbai, and submitted along with the
Petitioner‟s claim dated 18thJuly, 2024. Therefore, the requirement under
the rules stood fully satisfied. The Certificate of Registration dated
19thJuly, 2024 is clear and ex facie legible.
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
(iii) The Scrutiny Committee‟s insistence on the legibility of the original
certificate, while disregarding the clear and updated Certificate of
Registration, amounts to placing form over substance. Such an approach
is antithetical to the principles of fairness and natural justice. It is a wellsettled legal principle that procedural rules are handmaidens of justice
and should not be used to thwart substantive rights. In light of the above,
it is clear that the Scrutiny Committee‟s objection regarding the legibility
of the Registration Certificate is devoid of merit.
Objection Regarding the Discrepancy in Name Between the Certificate
and the Application.
(i) The second objection pertains to the alleged fundamental discrepancy
between the name on the Registration Certificate and the name used in the
application. Specifically, the Certificate issued by the competent authority
is in the name of “Press Club Bombay,” while the application was
submitted under the name “Mumbai Press Club.” The Committee deemed
this inconsistency significant enough to warrant rejection of the
application.
(ii) To address this objection, it is imperative to consider the historical
context in which the Petitioner club was established. The Petitioner was
incorporated as a society in the year 1971 under the name “Press Club
Bombay,” corresponding to the official name of the city at that time.
However, in November 1995, the city‟s name was officially changed from
„Bombay‟ to „Mumbai.‟ As a direct consequence, the Petitioner began
using the name “Press Club Mumbai” to align with the new
nomenclature. Over the years, it has also become popularly known as
“Mumbai Press Club.”
(iii) In the claim dated 18th July 2024, the very first sentence explicitly
states: “The Press Club, Mumbai (Mumbai Press Club) is a member
of.."This phrasing clearly indicates that the claim is made by “The Press
Club , Mumbai,” and it defines “Mumbai Press Club” as its synonymous
identity. The parenthetical reference serves to clarify any potential
ambiguity, effectively bridging any nominal differences arising from the
change of the name of the city change. The use of both names is deliberate
and transparent. Furthermore, the letterhead on which the claim is
submitted bears the logo of “Mumbai Press Club,” consistent with its
current and commonly used name. Importantly, at the bottom of the
letterhead, the registration details of the Petitioner are provided,
including: The registered name as per the Certificate of Registration:
“The Press Club, Bombay”. The Petitioner has provided satisfactory
explanations, supported by documentation, to establish that the names
“Press Club Bombay” and “Mumbai Press Club” refer to the same legal
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
entity. The Scrutiny Committee has overlooked the substantive continuity
of the Petitioner‟s identity and operations.
Objection Regarding Notarization of Documents
(i) The third objection revolves around the notarization of the
documents(Copy of list of members, copy of the constitution/by-laws of the
Mumbai Press Club and minutes of meeting) submitted by the Petitioner.
The Committee has observed that all pages of the documents must carry
the signature along with the seal of a Notary Public for authentication to
be valid. Mr. Sibal has explained that in Mumbai, the established and
customary practice for notarization involves affixing the official seal,
signature, and stamp of the Notary Public on the last page of the
document, while the intervening pages bear a blue rubber stamp of the
Notary. This is a standard procedure recognized and accepted across all
courts in Mumbai, including the High Court of Bombay. He has further
argued that contrary to the Committee‟s assertion, it is factually incorrect
to state that only the first and last pages are notarized. The intervening
pages indeed bear the Notary‟s stamp, thereby authenticating the entire
document
(ii) In light of the foregoing explanation, the Committee‟s insistence on
having every page carry the Notary's signature and seal overlooks the
substantive compliance demonstrated by the Petitioner. The document, in
its entirety, has been duly notarized. Regarding the Minutes of the
Meetings, the statement that only the first page and two other pages carry
the Notary‟s signature is also factually erroneous. Each set of Minutes has
been notarized as a separate document, following the standard
notarization procedure elaborated above. Thus, every set of Minutes
submitted by the Petitioner has been duly authenticated and notarized.
Therefore, the said ground is ex facie arbitrary, unsustainable, erroneous,
misconceived and illegal.
No proof of submission of minutes to the appropriate Authority:
(i) The proof of submission of Minutes to the appropriate Authority is not
an eligibility criterion under the PC Rules. No statutory requirement for
separate submission of Minutes to the Registrar of Societies has been
shown to the Court. Therefore, the said ground cannot be the basis for
rejecting the claim of the Petitioner.
ii.) It is apparent that the said ground for recommending rejection is also
unsustainable, illegal, arbitrary and is beyond the statutory requirements,
as well as Respondent No. l ‟s own notice dated 09thJune, 2024.
There is no clear authorization letter to file the claim:
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
(i) The declaration in the form of a sworn Affidavit of the then Secretary of
the Petitioner submitted along with the claim dated 18thJuly,
2024mentions the authorisation to file the claim. The Secretary of the
Petitioner is ex-officio entitled and authorised to file the said claim.
Further, the said secretary has sworn on an Affidavit to this effect and in
paragraph 5 thereof expressly stated that the Petitioner has authorised
him to make the necessary application and declaration and provide the
necessary documentation for the same. In these circumstances, this
ground too is without substance or merit, is entirely arbitrary and cannot
be sustained either in fact or in law.”
24.
In respect of the first objection raised by the Scrutiny Committee
which pertained to illegible copy of registration certification, learned Single
Judge has observed that original certification was obtained in the year 1971
and with the passage of time it is not difficult to note that the original
certificate has faded and consequently the photostat copy submitted, is faint.
He has further noticed that in compliance of requirement of Rule 4 regarding
association’s registration under relevant law for at least six years, the
respondent No.1 had submitted not only the original registration certificate
but also provided a fresh certificate of registration issued on 19.07.2024 by
the Assistant Registrar of Societies, Greater Mumbai Region, Mumbai and
therefore, the requirement stood satisfied. The learned Single Judge has thus,
rightly observed that the objection in this regard raised by the Scrutiny
Committee amounts to placing form over substance.
25.
In our opinion, thus, the learned Single Judge has rightly invoked the
doctrine of substantial compliance as enunciated by Hon’ble Supreme Court
in Hari Chand Shri Gopal (supra). Paragraphs 32 to 34 of Hari Chand Shri
Gopal (supra) are relevant to be quoted here which read as under:
“Doctrine of substantial compliance and “intended use”
32. The doctrine of substantial compliance is a judicial invention,
equitable in nature, designed to avoid hardship in cases where a party does
all that can reasonably be expected of it, but failed or faulted in some minor
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
or inconsequent aspects which cannot be described as the “essence” or the
“substance” of the requirements. Like the concept of “reasonableness”, the
acceptance or otherwise of a plea of “substantial compliance” depends upon
the facts and circumstances of each case and the purpose and object to be
achieved and the context of the prerequisites which are essential to achieve
the object and purpose of the rule or the regulation. Such a defence cannot be
pleaded if a clear statutory prerequisite which effectuates the object and the
purpose of the statute has not been met. Certainly, it means that the Court
should determine whether the statute has been followed sufficiently so as to
carry out the intent for which the statute was enacted and not a mirror image
type of strict compliance. Substantial compliance means “actual compliance
in respect to the substance essential to every reasonable objective of the
statute” and the Court should determine whether the statute has been
followed sufficiently so as to carry out the intent of the statute and accomplish
the reasonable objectives for which it was passed.
33. A fiscal statute generally seeks to preserve the need to comply strictly
with regulatory requirements that are important, especially when a party
seeks the benefits of an exemption clause that are important. Substantial
compliance with an enactment is insisted, where mandatory and directory
requirements are lumped together, for in such a case, if mandatory
requirements are complied with, it will be proper to say that the enactment
has been substantially complied with notwithstanding the non-compliance of
directory requirements. In cases where substantial compliance has been
found, there has been actual compliance with the statute, albeit procedurally
faulty. The doctrine of substantial compliance seeks to preserve the need to
comply strictly with the conditions or requirements that are important to
invoke a tax or duty exemption and to forgive non-compliance for either
unimportant and tangential requirements or requirements that are so
confusingly or incorrectly written that an earnest effort at compliance should
be accepted.
34. The test for determining the applicability of the substantial compliance
doctrine has been the subject of a myriad of cases and quite often, the critical
question to be examined is whether the requirements relate to the “substance”
or “essence” of the statute, if so, strict adherence to those requirements is a
precondition to give effect to that doctrine. On the other hand, if the
requirements are procedural or directory in that they are not of the “essence”
of the thing to be done but are given with a view to the orderly conduct of
business, they may be fulfilled by substantial, if not strict compliance. In other
words, a mere attempted compliance may not be sufficient, but actual
compliance with those factors which are considered as essential.”
26.
In our conclusion, the finding recorded by learned Single Judge
regarding this aspect need not be interfered with as the Press Council of
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
India or the Scrutiny Committee should be concerned with substantial
compliance of the registration of respondent no.1 for the past six years in the
wake of the fresh certificate issued by the competent authority under the
Societies Registration Act, dated 19.07.2024. Merely because the original
certificate was not legible enough, in our considered opinion the Scrutiny
Committee could not have rejected the claim of the respondent No.1.
27.
The finding recorded by the learned Single Judge in respect of the
objection raised by the Scrutiny Committee regarding there being some
discrepancy in the name of the respondent No.1 appearing in the registration
certificate and its name in the application, also need not be interfered with.
The certificate issued by the competent authority is in the name of “Press
Club Bombay” while the application was submitted under the name
“Mumbai Press Club” and solely on this count the Committee found
inconsistency in the name and treated it to be a significant defect warranting
rejection of the application. The learned Single Judge, while considering the
said issue has returned a finding that the society was incorporated in the year
1971 under the name “Press Club Bombay” which corresponded to the
official name of the city at that time, however, in November, 1995, the name
of the city of Bombay was officially changed to Mumbai and as a
consequence the respondent No.1 began using the name “Press Club
Mumbai” to align with the new nomenclature assigned to the city of
Mumbai (the then Bombay). It has also been stated by the learned Single
Judge that over the years the respondent No.1 has been popularly known as
Mumbai Press Club. The learned Single Judge has also noticed the contents
of the claim application dated 18.07.2024 and has recorded a finding that the
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
very first sentence of the application clearly states, “The Press Club,
Mumbai (Mumbai Press Club) is a member of….”. According to the learned
Single Judge, the manner in which the first sentence has been phrased in the
claim application dated 18.07.2024 clearly reveals that the “Press Club
Mumbai” reflects itself as a synonym of “Mumbai Press Club”. It is
recorded by the learned Single Judge that the “Press Club Mumbai” and
“Mumbai Press Club” are synonymous identities. Further, the letter head on
which the claim application dated 18.07.2024 was filed by the respondent
No.1 gives the registration details and the registration name as per the
certificate of registration i.e. “Press Club, Bombay”. The learned Single
Judge has then found that explanation submitted by the respondent No.1 was
satisfactory to establish that the names “Press Club Bombay” and “Mumbai
Press Club” refer to the same legal entity.
28.
We find ourselves in complete agreement with the reasoning given by
the learned Single Judge for treating “Press Club Bombay” and “Mumbai
Press Club” as the same legal entity and, therefore, the finding returned by
the learned Single Judge in regard to about the illegality committed by the
Scrutiny Committee appears to us to be correct which does not warrant any
interference.
29.
Regarding notarization of documents, the learned Single Judge has
clearly opined that in Mumbai, it is the established and customary practice
for notarization which involves affixing of the official seal, signature and
stamp of the Notary Public to be on the last page of the document while the
intervening pages bear a blue rubber stamp of the Notary. The learned
Single Judge has also found that this is a standard procedure recognized and
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
accepted across Mumbai, including the High Court of Bombay and
therefore, the Scrutiny Committee’s insistence on each page carrying the
Notary’s signature and seal, overlooks the substantive compliance as
demonstrated by the respondent No.1. The learned Single Judge has opined
that the document has been duly notarized following the standard notarized
procedure which follows in Mumbai.
30.
The learned Single Judge in the wake of these facts has, thus, arrived
at a correct conclusion that such ground taken by the Scrutiny Committee
for rejecting the application of the respondent No.1 is ex facie arbitrary,
erroneous, misconceived and thus unsustainable. We are in complete
agreement with the said finding recorded by learned Single Judge.
31.
Regarding proof of submission of minutes to the appropriate
authority, what we find is that, that is not an eligibility criterion under the
Rules, 2021 and that there is no statutory requirement of separate
submission of minutes to the Registrar of Societies and, therefore, we agree
with the findings recorded by the learned Single Judge in this regard as well.
32.
About the objection raised by the Scrutiny Committee regarding there
being no clear authorization letter to file the claim, what we find is that the
then Secretary of the respondent No.1 had submitted a declaration in the
form of a sworn affidavit with the application dated 18.07.2024 clearly
mentioning therein the authorization to file the claim. Further, the Secretary
of the respondent No.1 is ex-officio entitled and authorized to file the claim.
33.
The learned Single Judge referring to paragraph 5 of the affidavit filed
along with the claim dated 18.07.2024, has observed that the said averment
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
made in the affidavit clearly stated that the respondent No.1 had authorized
the Secretary to make the necessary application and declaration and provide
necessary documentation for the said purpose. Based on these factual
aspects, the learned Single Judge has opined that in these circumstances this
petition is without any substance or merit; rather he found such ground for
rejection of application moved by respondent No.1 to be entirely arbitrary
and unsustainable either in fact or in law.
34.
We have no reason to differ from the said finding recorded by the
learned Single Judge in respect of this objection of the Scrutiny Committee
for rejecting the claim of the respondent No.1.
35.
At this juncture, reference can be had to what has been held by the
Supreme Court in T.M. Jacob (supra). T.M. Jacob (supra) was a case where
the matter pertained to election petition under the Representation of People
Act. An objection was taken in the said matter that since the proceedings in
election petitions are statutory proceedings and, therefore, Doctrine of
Substantial Compliance cannot be invoked. The Hon’ble Supreme Court,
analyzing the legislative intent of the Representation of People Act observed
that the legislative intent appears to be quite clear as it divides violations
into two classes, (1) those which would entail dismissal of the Election
Petition, like non-compliance of certain provisions and (2) those violations
which would not entail dismissal of the Election Commission where
Doctrine of Substantial Compliance can be imported/ invoked. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the facts of the said case concluded that the defects in the
Election Petition which were complained of, were not such as could have
mislead the authority concerned. The Court has further noticed that nonLPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
mention of the name of the Notary or absence of stamp or seal of the Notary
in an otherwise true copy supplied to a party to the said proceedings could
not be construed to be an omission or variation of a vital nature and thus a
defect, if at all it could be construed as a defect could not be construed as a
defect of vital nature. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has, thus, observed that
such a defect of non-vital nature will not attract consequences leading to
rejection of the Election Petition.
36.
Paragraph 38 and 39 of the judgment in T.M. Jacob (supra) are
extracted herein below:
“38. We are unable to agree with Mr Salve that since proceedings in election
petitions are purely statutory proceedings and not “civil proceedings” as
commonly understood, there is no room for invoking and importing the
doctrine of substantial compliance into Section 86(1) read with Section 81(3)
of the Act. It is too late in the day to so urge. The law as settled by the two
Constitution Bench decisions of this Court referred to above is by itself
sufficient to repel the argument of Mr Salve. That apart, to our mind, the
legislative intent appears to be quite clear, since it divides violations into two
classes — those violations which would entail dismissal of the election
petition under Section 86(1) of the Act like non-compliance with Section 81(3)
and those violations which attract Section 83(1) of the Act, i.e., noncompliance with the provisions of Section 83. It is only the violation of Section
81 of the Act which can attract the application of the doctrine of substantial
compliance as expounded in Murarka Radhey Shyam [AIR 1964 SC 1545 :
(1964) 3 SCR 573] and Ch. Subbarao [AIR 1964 SC 1027 : (1964) 6 SCR
213] cases. The defect of the type provided in Section 83 of the Act, on the
other hand, can be dealt with under the doctrine of curability, on the
principles contained in the Code of Civil Procedure. This position clearly
emerges from the provisions of Sections 83(1) and 86(5) of the Act which read
thus:
“83. Contents of petition.—(1) An election petition—
(a) shall contain a concise statement of the material facts on which the
petitioner relies;
(b) shall set forth full particulars of any corrupt practice that the
petitioner alleges, including as full a statement as possible of the
names of the parties alleged to have committed such corrupt
practice and the date and place of the commission of each such
practice; and
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
(c) shall be signed by the petitioner and verified in the manner laid
down in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) for the
verification of pleadings:
***
86. Trial of election petitions.—(1)-(4)***
(5) The High Court may, upon such terms as to costs and otherwise as
it may deem fit, allow the particulars of any corrupt practice alleged in the
petition to be amended or amplified in such manner as may in its opinion
be necessary for ensuring a fair and effective trial of the petition, but shall
not allow any amendment of the petition which will have the effect of
introducing particulars of a corrupt practice not previously alleged in the
petition.”
39. Applying the test as laid down in Murarka Radhey Shyam Ram Kumar
case [AIR 1964 SC 1545 : (1964) 3 SCR 573] to the fact situation of the
present case, we come to the conclusion that the defects complained of in the
present case were not such as could have misled the appellant at all. The nonmention of the name of the Notary or the absence of the stamp and seal of the
Notary in the otherwise true copy supplied to the appellant could not be
construed to be an omission or variation of a vital nature and thus the defect,
if at all it could be construed as a defect, was not a defect of any vital nature
attracting the consequences of Section 86(1) of the Act. Under the
circumstances, it must be held that there was no failure on the part of the
election petitioner to comply with the last part of sub-section (3) of Section 81
of the Act and, under the circumstances, Section 86(1) of the Act was not
attracted and the election petition could not have been dismissed by reason of
the alleged failure to comply with the provisions of Section 81 of the Act. In
this connection, it is also relevant to note that the appellant, neither in the
memo of objections nor in the written objections or in CMP No. 2903 of 1996
has alleged that he had been misled by the absence of the name, rubber stamp
and seal of the Notary on the copy of the affidavit supplied to him or that he
had been prejudiced to formulate his defence. Even during the arguments,
learned counsel for the appellant was not able to point out as to how the
appellant could have been prejudiced by the alleged omissions on the copy of
the affidavit served on him.”
37.
If we analyse the objections raised by the Scrutiny Committee
rejecting the claim of the respondent No.1, what we find is that such
objections were not those which can be said to have the potential of
misleading the Scrutiny Committee or the Press Council of India. The
defects pointed out can be said to be only a minor variation in the form and
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
not in substance and it is only a vital defect in substance which could lead to
rejection of application.
The variations, if any, in our opinion, were
insignificant so as to attract disqualification of the respondent No.1.
38.
For the reasons aforesaid, we do not find any good ground to interfere
with the impugned judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge.
The appeal is, therefore, dismissed.
39.
We have been informed that in compliance of the judgment passed by
the learned Single Judge, the Press Council of India vide an addendum
notification dated 02.12.2024 has notified the respondent No.1 as well in the
category under Section 5(3)(a) of the Act as representative body of working
journalists other than editors and, accordingly, we direct that the Press
Council of India shall proceed further accordingly.
40.
There shall be no order as to costs.
(DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA)
CHIEF JUSTICE
(TUSHAR RAO GEDELA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 16, 2026
N.Khanna
LPA 1242/2024
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
17:08:10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review