Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on: 21.01.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 06.02.2026
+
W.P.(C) 10517/2025
PRERNA GUPTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Petitioner-in-person
versus
REGISTRAR GENERAL OF
DELHI HIGH COURT & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Kanika Agnihotri, Mr. Vidit
Pratap Singh and Ms. Khushi Anand, Advs.
for DHC.
Mr. Sanjai Kumar Pathak, Ms. Shashi Pathak,
Mr. Arvind Kumar Tripathi, Mr. Robin
Kumar, Ms. Shweta Jayshankar Dwivedi and
Ms. Smriti Singh, Advs. for R-2 & R-3
Mr. Naveen Nagarjuna, Adv. for R-5
Mr. Abhin Narula, Adv. for R-6
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE OM PRAKASH SHUKLA
JUDGMENT
06.02.2026
%
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J.
1.
The present writ petition raises a grievance arising out of the
Delhi Judicial Services Examination1 of 2023, wherein the petitioner
alleges unlawful interpolation and reduction of her marks at the final
stage of evaluation. It is the petitioner’s case that a reduction of twenty
1 “DJSE” hereinafter
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
marks in Paper-I of DJSE (Mains) (Written), 20232 examination was
effected after the initial evaluation, resulting in her candidature being
declared unsuccessful. The petitioner seeks restoration of the marks
originally awarded and consequential revision of the Final Result of
DJSE in accordance therewith.
FACTS
2.
The facts of the present case fall within a limited scope. It is
borne from the record that Respondent No. 1 issued a notification dated
06.11.2023 inviting applications for appointment to the Delhi Judicial
Services3 notifying 53 vacancies (44 existing and 9 anticipated) with
category-wise distribution of 34 General/Unreserved, 05 Scheduled
Castes, and 14 Scheduled Tribes vacancies. The notification clarified
that the number of vacancies was subject to variation and that admission
at all stages of the examination was provisional. The following is the
break-up of vacancies for DJS for 2023:
3.
In terms of the Delhi Judicial Services Rules, 19704, the selection
process comprises three stages: Preliminary Examination, Mains
“Mains examination” hereinafter
3 “DJS” hereinafter
4 “Rules” hereinafter
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
examination, and viva voce. To qualify the Mains examination, which
comprises of four Papers, a candidate must secure a minimum of 35%
marks in each paper and 45% in aggregate.
4.
The Mains examination was conducted on 13.04.2024 and
14.04.2024. The results were declared on 07.01.2025, pursuant to which
153 candidates, including the petitioner, were shortlisted for the vivavoce. Thereafter, by notification dated 13.08.2025, 53 candidates were
recommended for appointment. The final result was declared on
04.03.2025, wherein the petitioner was placed at Serial No. 12 of the
wating list (Rank No. 45 overall) with a total of 605 marks. The last
selected candidate in the same category, i.e., Respondent No. 2 herein,
secured 615 marks, while Respondent No. 3, placed first on the waiting
list, secured 612 marks.
5.
Upon being declared unsuccessful, the petitioner sought copies
of her answer scripts under the Right to Information Act, 20055 vide
application dated 10.04.2025. The same were furnished to her in May
2025.
6.
On examining her answer script for Paper-I (Legal Knowledge
and Language6), the petitioner noticed certain apparent alterations in the
marks awarded for Question Nos. 5 and 8, as well as corresponding
changes in the tabulation of marks on the front page of the answer
booklet.
5 “RTI Act” hereinafter
6 “Paper I” hereinafter
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
Specifically, Question No. 5, marks initially awarded as 25 were
7.
overwritten and reduced to 15. Similarly, in Question No. 8, marks
initially awarded as 30 were overwritten and altered to 20. These
changes were mirrored in the tabulated total on the front sheet, where:
(i)
The total was altered from 191 to 171;
(ii)
171 has thereafter been corrected to 169; and
(iii)
The total marks in words was overwritten to read “One
Hundred Sixty Nine only”
8.
According to the petitioner, the correction from 171 to 169 is
attributable to a minor arithmetical error. However, the deduction of
twenty marks from 191 to 171 is arbitrary, unexplained, and
unsupported by any recorded reasons or procedural safeguards. The
petitioner’s challenge is confined solely to this reduction of twenty
marks, which, if restored, would materially affect her position in the
merit list.
SUBMISSIONS
9.
The
petitioner,
appearing
in-person,
advanced
cogent
submissions alleging interpolation and reduction of twenty marks in
Paper I of the Mains examination, which resulted in her being placed at
Rank No. 45 instead of Rank No. 13. It was contended that the alteration
was not a bona fide correction but an afterthought with no underlying
rationale.
10.
It was submitted that the Mains result declared almost one year
after the examination, leaving the petitioner with no means of
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
discovering the alterations until copies of her answer scripts were
obtained under the RTI Act.
11.
The petitioner asserted that the unexplained alteration of her
marks, without disclosure as to whether similar changes were effected
in respect of other candidates, had no intelligible differentia for
“singling out” her answer script.
12.
It was contended that no statutory provision or rule authorises an
examiner to review, or revise marks after the aggregate has been
computed and recorded on the front page of the answer booklet. Since
the total of 191 marks has been recorded both in figures and in words,
any subsequent alteration could only have been made after finalisation.
13.
The petitioner submitted that Respondent No. 1 failed to disclose
any material justifying such revision, rendering the action arbitrary and
procedurally unfair. Reliance was placed on the decision of the
Allahabad High Court in K.K. Wadhwani v. Sunita Singh & Ors.7,
wherein interpolation of marks was held to vitiate the evaluation
process and restoration of original marks was directed.
14.
It was further urged that notwithstanding the prohibition on re-
evaluation under the DJS Rules, a writ court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India retains the power to intervene where manifest
arbitrariness or procedural impropriety is demonstrated. The maxim fiat
justitia ruat caelum was invoked to submit that justice cannot be
7 2005 (23) LCD 548
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
subordinated to administrative convenience.
15.
Per contra, the learned Counsel for Respondent No. 1 contended
that the petitioner’s grievance pertains to the assessment of subjective
answers, which lies within the exclusive domain of the examiner. In the
absence of any allegation of mala fide, judicial review under Article
226 of the Constitution of India is impermissible.
16.
It was argued that no rule prohibits revision of marks after
totalling, provided the answer scripts have not been handed over to the
examining authority. Reliance was placed on Nirmala Singh v. High
Court of Delhi8 to submit that the examiner retains authority to revise
marks before final submission. It was emphasised that the alterations,
in the present case, were duly initialled by the examiner and were made
prior to communicating them to Respondent No. 1.
17.
Respondent No. 1 denied any interpolation, submitting that the
term ‘interpolation’ itself implies mala fide, which is absent in the
present case. It was emphasized that evaluation was anonymous and
that examiner details were deliberately blurred in the RTI copies
furnished to the petitioner in order to preserve confidentiality.
18.
Learned Counsel submitted that out of 53 selected candidates, 51
have already joined service, including Respondent No. 3, the first waitlisted candidate. Any interference at this stage would disrupt settled
appointments.
8 2023 SCC OnLine Del 4143
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
19.
The learned Counsel further submitted that in several cases,
corrections to numerical totals and marks in words were carried out to
the benefit of candidates. In this regard, the original answer scripts of
certain candidates were produced for the Court’s perusal.
20.
Reliance was placed on Hardeep v. University of Delhi & Ors.9
to contend that courts should not substitute their judgment for that of
the examiner in matters of subjective evaluation.
21.
It was further submitted that Rule 15 of the DJS Rules expressly
prohibits re-evaluation, limiting the scope of interference to re-totalling
alone, as held in CBSE and Anr. v. Aditya Bandopadhyay and Ors.10.
Further reliance was placed on Registrar General, High Court of Delhi
v. Ravinder Singh11, to submit that where re-evaluation is prohibited
by the applicable rules, courts should intervene only if some material
error exists.
22.
The learned Counsel argued that the petitioner’s reliance on K.K.
Wadhwani (supra) was misplaced and distinguishable on facts since
the identity of the examiner therein was known and the examiner had
admitted an error, unlike the present case.
23.
On behalf of Respondent Nos. 2 and 3, it was argued that judicial
review in examination matters is narrow and does not extend to
9 2024 SCC OnLine Del 3382
10 (2011) 8 SCC 497
11 SLP (C) No. 3144/2023
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
reassessment of marks in the absence of mala fide or bias.
Appointments made in accordance with law ought not to be unsettled,
particularly where appointees have altered their positions irreversibly.
24.
The learned Counsel highlighted that the petitioner neither
challenged the selection process nor the appointment notification dated
13.08.2025, whereby 53 judicial officers were appointed. It was further
contended that having participated in the selection process without
demur, the petitioner is estopped from challenging the result in the
absence of demonstrable illegality.
25.
It was further submitted that Respondent No. 2 joined service on
21.08.2025, while Respondent No. 3 resigned from Haryana Civil
Service (Judicial Branch) to join DJS w.e.f. 22.09.2025, pursuant to the
appointment notification dated 13.08.2025. It was further submitted
that the petitioner did not challenge the appointment notification of
Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 and therefore, cannot seek relief to the
detriment of third parties. Any interference at this stage would therefore
be inequitable and contrary to the settled principles governing service
jurisprudence and would precipitate a ripple effect.
26.
It was submitted that only four candidates secured 170 marks or
above in Paper-I, while the petitioner secured 169 marks, rendering her
claim of 191 marks implausible. It was also argued that her marks could
have been reduced further in view of linguistic errors in her impugned
answer No. 5.
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
27.
The respondents, relying on Ran Vijay Singh & Ors. v. State of
Uttar Pradesh & Ors.12, contended that where the rules prohibit reevaluation, courts ought not to interfere and the benefit of doubt must
lie with the examining authority. Placing reliance on Anmol Kumar
Tiwari & Ors. v. State of Jharkhand & Ors.13 and Rajesh Kumar v.
State of Jharkhand & Ors.14, it was urged that, in the absence of any
allegation of fraud or mala fides, the appointments of Respondent Nos.
2 and 3, being innocent appointees who have altered their position,
ought not to be disturbed, as they cannot be prejudiced for any error of
the recruiting authority. Reliance was placed on Ramniklal N. Bhutta
and Anr. v. State of Maharashtra and Ors.15 to submit that courts must
balance competing equities.
28.
In rebuttal, the petitioner submitted that any deficiencies in her
answers ought to have been accounted for at the initial evaluation stage.
No justification was offered for reduction of marks in Question No. 8.
It was emphasized that successive alterations, first in individual
questions, then in the aggregate, and finally in the marks written in
words, cannot be characterized as correction made “at the first blush”.
29.
The petitioner further relied on the interim order dated
17.09.2025, whereby the appointment of Respondent No. 3 was made
subject to the outcome of the present petition and contended that no
vested rights had accrued when the petition was instituted.
12 (2018) 2 SCC 357
13 (2021) 5 SCC 424
14 2025 INSC 1146; SLP(C) No. 21752 of 2024
15 (1997) 1 SCC 134
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
30.
It was lastly submitted that the petitioner’s challenge is directed
not at a re-evaluation but at the decision-making process leading to the
alteration of marks. The writ court, it was argued, is duty bound to
scrutinize such process for arbitrariness, procedural impropriety, or
irrationality, even while refraining from substituting its own assessment
on merits.
FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS
31.
We have heard the petitioner-in-person and the learned Counsel
for the Respondents at length and carefully considered the rival
submissions. For the reasons that follow, we are unable to grant relief
to the petitioner.
32.
The petitioner’s principal grievance is the alleged arbitrary
reduction of twenty marks in Paper-I, which, according to her,
adversely impacted her merit position. Her contention rests on the
premise that once the aggregate marks are totalled and recorded in
figures and words on the front page of the answer booklet, the examiner
is functus officio and lacks authority to alter the same. The respondents,
on the other hand, submit that the allegation is speculative, that the
revision of marks lies within the examiner’s discretion so long as it
occurs prior to submission of the answer scripts to the examining
authority, and that judicial review is impermissible in the absence of
mala fide, bias, or fraud. It was further contended that re-valuation is
expressly barred under the DJS Rules and interference would unsettle
concluded appointments.
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
33.
The core issue that thus arises is whether the change of marks in
the petitioner’s answer script constitutes impermissible arbitrariness
warranting interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Ancillary to this is the question regarding the effect of any such
interference on the appointments already made.
34.
At the outset, we find merit in the submission of Respondent No.
1 that the expression “interpolation” carries an imputation of mala fide.
In the present case, the petitioner has neither pleaded nor established
mala fide, bias, or extraneous considerations against the examiner. In
the absence thereof, the use of such terminology is unwarranted.
35.
It is a settled principle of law that courts must exercise restraint
in academic matters and refrain from substituting their own assessment
for that of expert examiners. This position has been consistently
affirmed by the Supreme Court, inter alia, in Maharashtra State Board
of Secondary and Higher Secondary Education v. Paritosh
Bhupeshkumar Sheth16 and CBSE v. Khushboo Shrivastava17.
36.
Applying the aforesaid principles, we are of the considered view
that the prayer for restoration of the original marks cannot be acceded
to for two fundamental reasons. First, in the absence of any allegations
of mala fide, bias, or fraud, the examiner’s discretion in the evaluative
process cannot be questioned. Secondly, the answers in Question Nos.
5 and 8 are admittedly subjective. Evaluation of such answers
necessarily involves academic judgment, and there exists no objective
16 (1984) 4 SCC 27
17 (2014) 14 SCC 523
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
or infallible standard by which the Court can determine whether the
initial or revised marks were correct. Any attempt by the Court to do so
would amount to substituting its own opinion for that of the examiner,
which is impermissible.
37.
The petitioner contended that while errors were circled by the
examiner in Question No. 5, no such markings appear in Question No.
8 to justify the reduction in marks. This submission is untenable. The
questions in issue are purely subjective, requiring qualitative
assessment based on the examiner’s academic judgment. There exists
no objective or uniform benchmark by which the correctness of the
original or revised marks can be judicially ascertained. Any attempt at
re-evaluation would necessarily substitute one subjective opinion with
another, a course of action impermissible in law. The Court itself cannot
undertake such an exercise, nor can it legitimately appoint another
examiner in the absence of statutory sanction.
38.
The petitioner’s reliance on K.K. Wadhwani (supra) is misplaced
since the said decision was rendered in a factual matrix involving
established tampering, admitted oversight, and lack of anonymity of the
examiner, thereby enabling allegations of bias and mala fide. No such
circumstances exist in the present case.
39.
Notwithstanding the above, a writ court, being a court of equity,
is empowered to mould relief in appropriate cases. Therefore, even
while declining the prayer for restoration of marks, it becomes
necessary to examine whether a direction for re-evaluation of the
impugned answers can be issued.
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
40.
The Appendix to Rule 15 of the DJS Rules, which prescribes the
scheme of examination, expressly prohibits re-evaluation, as follows:
“D. GENERAL
***
3. There shall be no re-evaluation of answer sheets in respect of
Preliminary Examination and Mains Examination (Written). No
request for re-evaluation of answer sheets shall be entertained and
the same shall be liable to be rejected without any notice to the
candidates.”
41.
The scope of judicial review in such circumstances has been
authoritatively delineated by the Supreme Court in Ran Vijay Singh
(supra) as follows:
“30.1. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination
permits the re-evaluation of an answer sheet or scrutiny of an
answer sheet as a matter of right, then the authority conducting the
examination may permit it;
30.2. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination
does not permit re-evaluation or scrutiny of an answer sheet (as
distinct from prohibiting it) then the court may permit reevaluation or scrutiny only if it is demonstrated very clearly,
without any “inferential process of reasoning or by a process of
rationalisation” and only in rare or exceptional cases that a
material error has been committed;
30.3. The court should not at all re-evaluate or scrutinise the
answer sheets of a candidate—it has no expertise in the matter and
academic matters are best left to academics;
30.4. The court should presume the correctness of the key answers
and proceed on that assumption; and
30.5. In the event of a doubt, the benefit should go to the
examination authority rather than to the candidate.”
(emphasis supplied)
42.
The right of an examinee to seek re-evaluation is not inherent; it
is governed by the applicable statutory rules. Where the rules expressly
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
prohibit re-evaluation, courts may interfere only in rare and exceptional
cases involving demonstrable material error or manifest arbitrariness,
as reiterated in Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth (supra), Ran Vijay
Singh (supra), Monika v. High Court of Delhi18, Mayank Garg v.
High Court of Delhi19, and Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. Chairman,
Bihar Public Service Commission20. Although the latter decision
pertains to a situation where the applicable rules are silent, the
pragmatic considerations therein squarely apply in the present petition.
While setting aside the decision of the Single Judge directing reevaluation, the Court observed as follows:
“8. Adopting such a course as was done by the learned Single Judge
will give rise to practical problems. Many candidates may like to
take a chance and pray for re-evaluation of their answer-books.
Naturally, the Court will pass orders on different dates as and when
writ petitions are filed. The Commission will have to then send the
copies of individual candidates to examiners for re-evaluation which
is bound to take time. The examination conducted by the
Commission being a competitive examination, the declaration of
final result will thus be unduly delayed and the vacancies will
remain unfilled for a long time. What will happen if a candidate
secures lesser marks in re-evaluation? He may come forward with a
plea that the marks as originally awarded to him may be taken into
consideration. The absence of clear rules on the subject may throw
many problems and in the larger interest, they must be avoided.”
43.
A co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Nirmala Singh (supra),
further clarified that an examiner is entitled to correct or re-evaluate
marks “at the first blush”. The co-ordinate Bench of this Court, while
dismissing the petition, held as follows:
“18. In any event, it is open to the examiner to change and/or modify
the marks awarded at first blush to an examinee. In the present
18 2024 SCC OnLine Del 994
19 (2022) 5 HCC (Del) 483
20 (2004) 6 SCC 714
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
instance, the revision in the marks had been done by the examiner
before furnishing of the answer sheet to the examination body.”
(emphasis supplied)
44.
It was opined that if alterations are made before the answer
scripts are submitted to the examining authority, the same would not
give rise to any cause of action in favour of the examinee. The
expression “first blush”, as employed in Nirmala Singh (supra), cannot
be construed narrowly so as to denude the examiner of the authority to
correct or revisit marks while the evaluation process is still ongoing. To
hold that marks become immutable merely upon being tabulated on the
front page would impose an artificial and impractical constraint on
academic evaluation, contrary to ground realities and settled law. Such
an interpretation would unduly intrude upon the examiner’s discretion
and expertise and is expressly cautioned against in Paritosh
Bhupeshkumar Sheth (supra). Thus, since the revisions in the present
case were made while the answer scripts remained within the exclusive
domain of the examiner, i.e., before communicating the results to
Respondent No. 1, the same are legally permissible.
45.
Further, since the Appendix to Rule 15 of the DJS Rules
unequivocally proscribes re-evaluation, the sole question that survives
is whether the present case discloses any material error or exceptional
circumstance warranting departure from this statutory embargo.
46.
We find that the marks initially awarded to individual answers
and reflected in the aggregate were subsequently changed, does not, by
itself, establish arbitrariness or illegality, particularly where such
revisions were made prior to finalization of results and in the absence
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
of any allegation of mala fide or bias. The petitioner’s assertion that the
reduction was effected only to lower her aggregate remains conjectural
and unsupported by material evidence.
47.
The abovementioned position is also strengthened by the fact that
petitioner has failed to establish any material error, illegality, or
extraneous circumstance warranting re-evaluation despite the express
prohibition.
48.
The petitioner is also precluded by the doctrine of estoppel. The
Supreme Court has consistently held that a candidate who voluntarily
participates in a selection process with full knowledge of the applicable
rules cannot, upon being declared unsuccessful, turn around to
challenge the procedure or outcome. This principle has been reiterated
in Ashok Kumar v. State of Bihar21, Chandra Prakash Tiwari v.
Shakuntala Shukla22, Union of India v. S. Vinodh Kumar23,
Munindra Kumar v. Rajiv Govil24, Rashmi Mishra v. M.P. Public
Service Commission25, Madan Lal v. State of J&K26 and Monika v.
High Court of Delhi27.
49.
Further, Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 were impleaded in the present
writ petition in view of the potential impact of any relief granted to the
petitioner. Respondent No. 2 was the last selected candidate in the
General category, while Respondent No. 3 was placed at Serial No. 1
21 (2017) 4 SCC 357
22 (2002) 6 SCC 127
23 (2007) 8 SCC 100
24 (1991) 3 SCC 368
25 (2006) 12 SCC 724
26 (1995) 3 SCC 486
27 (2024) SCC OnLine Del 994
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
of the waiting list; the petitioner stood at Serial No. 12 in the waiting
list. Both respondents were recommended for appointment pursuant to
the notification dated 13.08.2025 issued under Rule 18 of the DJS
Rules. Significantly, the said appointment notification was never
challenged by the petitioner.
50.
The Supreme Court, in Anmol Kumar Tiwari (supra), Rajesh
Kumar (supra) and Vikas Pratap Singh v. State of Chhattisgarh28, has
adopted a pragmatic and equitable approach, holding that where
appointments are made without any fraud or misrepresentation on the
part of the appointees, such appointments ought not to be disturbed
merely due to errors attributable to the examining authority. This Court
itself is in respectful agreement with the aforesaid line of reasoning.
51.
In the present case, there are no allegations of fraud,
misrepresentation, bias, or procedural illegality against these
respondents, nor is any infirmity discernible in their appointments.
52.
It was brought to the notice of this Court that similar changes
were carried out in other answer scripts, including revisions beneficial
to the candidates. Any direction for re-evaluation would necessarily
require extending such exercise to all similarly placed candidates to
maintain parity, thereby disturbing concluded selections and disrupting
inter se seniority. Such uncertainty in public appointments is
antithetical to the principles of fairness, administrative stability and
predictability. Judicial interference in such circumstances would open
28 (2013) 14 SCC 494
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
floodgates, leading to cascading consequences and rendering the
process unworkable. Courts must therefore exercise restraint and accord
due latitude to examining authorities in the regulation of academic and
evaluating matters.
53.
The guiding principle articulated in Ran Vijay Singh (supra)
merits reiteration, sympathy cannot govern the examination process.
While individual grievances may arise, redressal must be balanced
against the larger imperative of preserving fairness, stability, and
integrity of the selection system.
54.
The petitioner’s grievance, though genuine, pertains to alteration
of marks in subjective answers. Any re-evaluation could result in an
increase, decrease, or retention of marks. However, in view of the
express bar on re-evaluation, the subjective nature of the assessment,
and the absence of any material error or exceptional circumstance,
judicial interference is unwarranted.
55.
Thus, tested on the anvil of the aforesaid precedents, the
petitioner’s case does not meet the threshold required to warrant judicial
interference. The petitioner has not challenged the validity of the rule
prohibiting re-evaluation. Her grievance is confined to the reduction of
marks from 191 to 171 in Paper-I, while accepting the subsequent
correction from 171 to 169 as an arithmetical adjustment.
56.
According to us, directing re-evaluation in the absence of any
substantiated allegation of mala fide or material illegality would risk
causing manifest injustice to other candidates who have been duly
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
selected. The petitioner has, therefore, failed to meet the threshold
required for judicial intervention.
57.
Consequently, this Court finds no justification to restore the
alleged original marks or to direct re-evaluation of the impugned
answers, having due regard to the autonomy of the examiner and the
settled limits of judicial review.
58.
As a sequel to the aforesaid, the present writ petition as being
without any merits, is dismissed accordingly. Pending applications, if
any, stand disposed of.
59.
There shall be no order as to costs.
OM PRAKASH SHUKLA, J
C.HARI SHANKAR, J
FEBRUARY 06, 2026/AT
Signed By:RAJEEV W.P.(C) 10517/2025
DHANKHAR
14:52:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review