Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Daily List
2025:MLHC:182-DB
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
W.A. No.12 of 2023
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
Date of CAV :20.02.2025
Date of Decision:18.03.2025
5019623, Hav (Clk), Prem Singh
5015473, Hav (Clk), Vinaya Kumar G
5015565, Hav (Clk), P C Zoram Chhana
5019291, Hav (Clk), Ajab Singh
5021040, Hav (Clk), Sangluaia
5025269, Hav (Clk), Aonugshi Jamir
5025338, Hav (Clk), Amarjit Singh
5025356, Hav (Clk), Pankaj Kumar
5025358, Hav (CIk), Avanish Kumar
5025403, Hav (CIk), Umesh Kumar
5027597, Hav (Clk), Dinesh Chauhan
5021056, Hav (Clk), Rajendra Kumar
5025405, Hav (Clk), Jay Karan
5025300, Hav (Clk), Kamlesh Kumar
5015022, Hav (Clk), Rajindra Kumar
5015625, Hav (CIk), Devendra Chauhan
5025396, Hav (Clk), Samar JoytiBoro
5027705, Hav (Clk), Hari S Das
5028459, Hav (Cik), Vinay Yadav
5018017, Hav (Clk), Solomon Lalropui Hmar
5022863, Hav (Clk), Gyanendra Kumar
5022949, Hav (Clk), Omkar Nath Sharma
5025351, Hav (Clk), Ashvani
5020999, Hav (Clk), Anil Kumar
5021022, Hav (Clk), Sagolshem Ajit Singh
5021416, Hav (Clk), Ravi Sharma
5025378, Hav (Clk), Sanjoy Singha
5025384, Hav (Clk), Jitendra Kumar
5025401, Hav (Clk), Surjeet Singh
5025582, Hav (Clk), Shyam Lal
5025590, Hav (CIk), Jitendra Singh
5025595, Hav (Clk), Mukesh Kumar
5027733, Hav (CIk), Keisham Herachandra Singh
2025:MLHC:182-DB
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
71.
5028466, Hav (Clk), Shivan Upadhya
5020805, Hav (Clk), Ashish Kumar
5018086, Hav (CIk), Girish G
5021009, Hav (Clk), Y Mhonyoma Tungoe
5025363, Hav (Clk), Jintu Mani Das
5025575, Hav (Clk), Manas Borah
5027739, Hav (Clk), Vishal Kumar Singh
5028467, Hav (Clk), Bikash Nayak
5028473, Hav (CIk), Sangey Tamang
5021031, Hav (Clk), Modi Ram Gurjar
5022808, Hav (Clk), Imran Alam
5025380, Hav (Clk), Lucky Kumar
5027794, Hav (CIk), Vishal Kumar Sharma
5016974, Hav (Clk), Ashok Kumar
5023027, Hav (Clk), N Khatnei
5023402, Hav (Clk), Devendra Singh
5025268, Hav (Clk), Vijay Kumar Sharma
5025532 Hav (Clk), Laishram Sanathoisingh
5027666, Hav (Clk), Gagan Kumar Tiwari
5028487, Hav (Clk), Sinruwg Welngam Anal
5028488, Hav (Clk), Sarabindu Ghosh
5021005, Hav (Clk), Mithilesh Prasad
5021078, Hav (Clk), Gaurav Yadav
5025362, Hav (CIk), Hemant Kumar Thapa
5025376,Hav (Clk), Waikhom Malempunba Meitei
5027683, Hav (Clk), Jitendra Kumar
5016745, Hav (Clk), Roshan Thapa
5020007, Hav (Clk), Anatha Krishna MR
5020863, Hav (Clk), Pamleiyo Hayam
5021087, Hav (Clk), Chandrakesh Mishra
5025387, Hav (Clk), Devendra singh
5027691, Hav (Clk), Amrendra Kumar
5028493, Hav (Clk), Pankaj Kumar
5015255, Hav (Clk), Anil Kumar
5021104, Hav (Clk), Rahul Roa
5022783, Hav (Clk), Surjeet Kumar
5025347, Hav (Clk), Hajari Singh
5027701, Hav (Clk), Mukesh Yadav
2025:MLHC:182-DB
72.
73.
74.
75.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
83.
84.
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
90.
91.
92.
93.
94.
95.
96.
97.
98.
99.
100.
101.
102.
103.
104.
105.
106.
107.
108.
109.
5028495, Hav (CIk), Jitendra Signh
5028502 Hav (Clk),Longshithung Yanthan
5015225, Hav (Clk), Y Chalamba Kumar Singh
5016614, Hav (Clk), Dhanajoy Barhma
5016779, Hav (Clk), Chandan Kumar Singh
5017111, Hav (Clk), Deepak singh Rana
5018198, Hav (Clk), Pankaj Choudhary
5021442, Hav (Clk), Surender Singh Kholiya
5025374, Hav (Clk), Nandigam Lingaraju
5027803, Hav (Clk), Suraj Kumar Shah
5028518, Hav (Clk), Vinayak Belgundkar
5016797, Hav (Clk), Vikash Rai
5019012, Hav (Clk), Bimal Gorain
5020050, Hav (CIk), Amit Thripathi
5021094, Hav (Clk), Abhaya Kumar Choudhary
5022922, Hav (Clk), Medo Angami
5027592,Hav (Clk),Santosh Kumar Pandit
5028524, Hav (Clk), Suraj Rai
5016637, Hav (Clk), Shyam Kumar Chhetri
5019669, Hav (Clk), Abraham Kez
5027696, Hav (Clk), Satrughan Singh
5028397, Hav (Clk), Rohit Kumar
5022851, Hav (Clk), Sujay Das
5023328, Hav (Clk), Vishal Polhrel
5016801, Hav (Clk), Prem Kumar Chhetri
5017024, Hav (Clk), Govind Kumar
5017281, Hav (Clk), Suman Newar
5019645, Hav (Clk), Praveen Kumar
5020645, Hav (Clk), Samir Khati
5023023, Hav (Clk), Vaibhav Yadav
5025331, Hav (Clk), Nijardhan Swargiary
5025333, Hav (Clk), Md. Jahangir Raza
5025359, Hav (Clk), Bittu Pradhan
5027635, Hav (Clk), Mihir Kumar Das
5017544, Hav (Clk), Ronal Tamang
5018105, Hav (Clk), SK Hasanuzzaman
5019097, Hav (Clk), Jitendra Sharma
5019504, Hav (Clk), Narendra Singh Bhandari
2025:MLHC:182-DB
110.
111.
112.
113.
114.
115.
116.
117.
118.
119.
120.
121.
122.
123.
124.
125.
126.
127.
128.
129.
130.
131.
132.
133.
134.
135.
136.
137.
138.
139.
140.
141.
142.
143.
144.
145.
146.
147.
5021091, Hav (Clk), Raju Shill
5025322, Hav (Clk), Sunny Rai
5025386, Hav (ClK), Jaideep Singh Negi
5027641, Hav (Clk), Nitin Rajauriya
5018167, Hav (Ck), Dipankar Biswas
5019642, Hav (Clk), Harish Chandra
5017280, Hav (CIk), Hasnain Ali
5020927, Hav (Ck), Pronot Chakma
5025250, Hav (Clk), Anil Kumar Kaunr
5025252, Hav (Clk), Dharmeshwar Goyary
5025265, Hav (Clk), Ravi Thakur
5025408, Hav (Clk), Rahul Yadav
5027645, Hav (Clk), Amit Kumar Dubey
5020997, Hav (Clk), Jarnail Singh
5021090, Hav (Clk), Ombir
5023385, Hav (Clk), Tripurari Mishra
5021048, Hav (Clk), Janak Bahadur Sunar
5025349, Hav (Clk), Naveen Kumar
5025407, Hav (Clk), Bhagavati Prasad Yadav
5027729, Hav (Clk), Satish Kumar
5028546, Hav (Clk), Ojha Ajit Kumar
5028547, Hav (Clk), Gobin Kumar Chhetri
5020913, Hav (Clk), Suraj Debbarma
5021075, Hav (Clk), Krishna Kukreti
5022775, Hav (Clk), Rajan Rai
5018955, Hav (Clk), Som Bir
5025260, Hav (Clk), Alezo Keyie
5025263, Hav (Clk), Rakesh Sinha
5025270, Hav (Clk), A Nil Chandra Singha
5025280, Hav (Clk), Gouminsang Gangte
5025345, Hav (CIk), Rahul Kumar
5025361, Hav (Clk), Sachin Nandal
5025394, Hav (Clk), Vijai Kumar Darjee
5025567, Hav (Clk), Prateek Rai
5027742, Hav (Clk), Rakesh Okram
5020291, Hav (Clk), Jitendra Singh
5020872, Hav (Clk), Khamsuanlien Zou
5021043, Hav (Clk), Parveen Kumar
2025:MLHC:182-DB
148.
149.
150.
151.
152.
153.
154.
155.
156.
157.
158.
159.
160.
161.
162.
163.
164.
165.
166.
167.
168.
169.
170.
171.
172.
173.
174.
175.
176.
177.
178.
179.
180.
181.
182.
183.
184.
185.
5021046, Hav (Clk), Sombir
5021061, Hav (Clk), D KatanouThangal
5027780, Hav (Clk), Kolambe Hukumchand
5028548, Hav (Clk), Son Singh Rawat
5021000, Hav (Clk), Jay Singh
5022802, Hav (Clk), Sambu Basfor
5022815, Hav (Clk), Gurmehar Singh
5025402, Hav (Clk), Jinu Vijay K
5015666, Hav (Clk), Vikash Kumar Singh
5017698, Hav (Clk), Raju Khuraijan
5019404, Hav (Clk), Namin Kumar
5019655, Hav (Clk), Anil Kumar
5023010, Hav (Clk), Durga Bahadur Chhetri
5025264, Hav (Clk), Vijay Kumar Singh
5025290, Hav (Clk), Prakash Tamang
5025330, Hav(Clk), Abujam Kiran Kumar Singh
5025340, Hav (Clk), Udaybeer Singh
5025392, Hav (Clk), Shubham Singh
5027827, Hav (Clk), Barun Tiwari
5017041, Hav (Clk), Manjeet Kumar
5021065, Hav (Clk), Yumnam Henba
5025364, Hav (Clk), Bachiter Singh
5025397, Hav (Clk), A Rishikanta Singh
5025406, Hav (Clk), Sanjay Kumar Paswan
5025577, Hav (Clk), Jakir Husen
5020105, Hav (Clk), Mukesh Kumar Sharma
5021011, Hav (Clk), Sunil Yadav
5021073, Hav (Clk), Minduboyiha Santhosh K
5023401, Hav (Clk), Prakash Kumar Jha
5027790, Hav (Clk), Bishwas Kumar
5028552, Hav (Clk), Ravindra Kumar
5028553, Hav (Clk), Pranab Kumar Mandal
5016814, Hav (Clk), Mukesh Kumar Thakur
5017285, Hav (Clk), Sanjay Thapa
5018176, Hav (Clk), Umesh Kumar
5019282, Hav (Clk), Banty Kr. VaidBalmiki
5021070, Hav (Clk), Bhuban Singh Mehra
5022895, Hav (Clk), Pooran Singh
2025:MLHC:182-DB
186.
187.
188.
189.
190.
191.
192.
193.
194.
195.
196.
197.
198.
199.
200.
201.
202.
203.
204.
205.
206.
207.
208.
209.
210.
211.
212.
213.
214.
215.
216.
217.
218.
219.
220.
221.
222.
223.
5025301, Hav (Clk), Kazipsing Makan
5017035, Hav (Clk), Gajendra Singh
5021047, Hav (Clk), Anoop kumar Joshi
5014916, Hav (Clk), Rakesh Singh
5020039, Hav (Clk), Niraj Singh
5023071, Hav (Clk), Ningthoujam Ibomcha Singh
5025285, Hav (Clk), Deepak Kumar Balmiki
5025346, Hav (Clk), Kishore Das
5025409, Hav (Clk), Dhruva Singh
5025563, Hav (Clk), Ramesh Chhetri
5028555, Hav (Clk), Sarabjit Singh
5028560, Hav (Clk), T Rengneising
5023005, Hav (Clk), Abdul Kadir Ansari
5023325, Hav (Clk), Botovi S
5025248, Hav (Clk), Cornelius Shadap
5025261, Hav (Clk), Sajan Prasad
5025276, Hav (Clk), Utpal Dey
5025310, Hav (Clk), Anil Kumar Arya
5025336, Hav (Clk), Ngangom Rabin Meitei
5025357, Hav (Clk), Baljeet Kumar
5025393, Hav (Clk), Mashi Das Barla
5027714, Hav (Clk), Dipu Borah
5028426, Hav (Clk), Narendra Singh
5023362, Hav (Clk), Yogendra Singh
5023373, Hav (Clk), Surender Kumar Yadav
5016989, Hav (Clk), Ajay Chhetri
5017925, Hav (Clk), Rakesh Kumar
5021084, Hav (Clk), Rahul Mazumdar
5021102, Hav (Clk), Biku Kumar
5022790, Hav (Clk), Harjeet Singh
5016863, Hav (Clk), Milan Kumar Malik
5025294, Hav (Clk), Subrato Chakrobartty
5027650, Hav (Clk), Arvind Kumar
5017105, Hav (Clk), Vikash Kumar
5021020,Hav (Clk), Roflint Rose Kharkongor
5025318, Hav (Clk), Guarav Saikia
5025339, Hav (Clk), Suraj
5025377, Hav (Clk), Govind Chetry
2025:MLHC:182-DB
224.
225.
226.
227.
228.
229.
230.
231.
232.
233.
234.
235.
236.
237.
238.
239.
240.
241.
242.
243.
244.
245.
246.
247.
248.
249.
250.
251.
252.
253.
254.
255.
256.
257.
258.
259.
260.
261.
5025389, Hav (Clk), Tej Raz Thapa
5025389, Hav (Clk), Anand Kumar Singh
5027688, Hav (Clk), Vibhor Kumar
5027799, Hav (Clk), Kilangtemsu Kichu
5028572, Hav (Clk), Santosh Singh Rawat
5015672, Hav (Clk), Rajesh Singh
5015895, Hav (Clk), Sandeep Adiwal
5018131, Hav (Clk), Shankar Deb Barma
5019603, Hav (Clk), Pintu Kumar
5021025,Hav (Clk), Chandra Shekhar Kandpal
5021058, Hav (Clk), Manish Kumar
5025286, Hav (Clk), Arvind Kumar Ram
5025327, Hav(Clk),Thokchom Bisanta Singh
5028585, Hav(Clk), Langewar S Panduranji
5028573, Hav (Clk), Sagar Kumar Prasad
5020383, Hav (Clk), Sharad Yadav
5020617, Hav (Clk), Durga Muang
5025257, Hav (Clk), Polash Chakma
5025275, Hav (Clk), NG Albert Moyon
5027732, Hav (Clk), Shiv Kumar Yadav
5028586, Hav (Clk), Lohar Arjun Shrirang
5017799, Hav (Clk), Rohit Singh Bora
5019055, Hav (Clk), Srikanta Ghosh
5021085, Hav (Clk), Vinay Pal
5021098, Hav (Clk), Amit Kumar Limbu
5021099, Hav (Clk), Rajinder Kumar
5021100, Hav (Clk), Pradeep Kumar
5027737, Hav (Clk), Dhruv Kant Tiwari
5017303,Hav (Clk), Deepak Kumar Pandey
5017306, Hav (Clk), Sukesh Kumar
5023320, Hav (Clk), Ajay Kumar Singh
5025287, Hav (Clk), Rahul Chhetry
5025570, Hav (Clk), Pradeep Kumar
5027755, Hav (Clk), Rahul M Prasad
5016816, Hav (Clk), Bimal Koirala
5019277, Hav (Clk), Bikram Rana
5022869, Hav (Clk), Mitul Chakma
5025540, Hav (Clk), S Rahul Singha
2025:MLHC:182-DB
262.
263.
264.
265.
266.
267.
268.
269.
270.
271.
272.
273.
274.
275.
276.
277.
278.
279.
280.
281.
282.
283.
284.
285.
286.
287.
288.
289.
290.
291.
292.
293.
294.
295.
296.
297.
298.
299.
5027730, Hav (Clk), Vaibhav Ananat Patil
5028591, Hav (Clk), Deepak Sharma
5016055, Hav (Clk), Prabir Kumar Adhikari
5017243, Hav (Clk), Sunil Kumar
5021024, Hav (Clk), Subhankar Samai
5022846, Hav (Clk), Sahindra Tripura
5023002, Hav (Clk), Ashish Kumar
5023080, Hav (Clk), Khuplenmang Haokip
5025369, Hav (Clk), Narendra Kumar Meena
5025404, Hav (Clk), Ram
5027619, Hav (Clk), Prakash Rabidas
5028600, Hav (Clk), Rupam Chakma
5015894, Hav (Clk), Pradeep Kumar
5016682, Hav (Clk), Rajeev Sharma
5017685, Hav (Clk), Ch Umanda Singh
5020681, Hav (Clk), Kishan Limbu
5021023, Hav (Clk), Prodyut Chakma
5021032, Hav (Clk), Navin Singh Farfijal
5025305, Hav (Clk), Vikrant Singh
5027625, Hav (Clk), Neeraj Kumar
5016746, Hav (Clk), Shashi Kant Yadav
5021029, Hav (Clk), Anil Kumar
5023315, Hav (Clk), Shiv Shankar Ram
5023333, Hav (Clk), Anil
5023390, Hav (Clk), Bhagirah Singh
5023395, Hav (Clk), Md Arif Khan
5025586, Hav (Clk), Mavatmi Kashungao
5028431, Hav (Clk), Pappu Kumar
5028435, Hav (Clk), Utsav Bhardwaj
5021026, Hav (Clk), Dhan Kumar Sonar
5021103, Hav (Clk), Yogesh Chandra Dani
5025293, Hav (Clk),Manoj Singh Shekhawat
5025297, Hav (Clk), Sumit Kumar Sharma
5025308, Hav (Clk), L Roman Saemah
5025400, Hav (Clk), Chandan James Singh
5014894, Hav (Clk), Sanal Kumar S
5016599,Hav (Clk), Shyam Kumar Paswan
5017242, Hav (Clk), Mintu
2025:MLHC:182-DB
300.
301.
302.
303.
304.
305.
306.
307.
308.
309.
310.
311.
312.
313.
314.
315.
316.
317.
318.
319.
320.
321.
322.
323.
324.
325.
326.
327.
328.
329.
330.
331.
332.
333.
334.
335.
336.
337.
5023074, Hav (Clk), Chandan Kumar
5027667, Hav (Clk), Bipin Kumar Yadav
5028617, Hav (Clk), Rakesh Singh
5018753, Hav (Clk), Ramesh Kumar
5020264, Hav (Clk), Dinesh Choudhary
5021072, Hav (Clk), Paradhaman R
5022989, Hav (Clk), Amit Singh
5025385, Hav (Clk), Nishant Kumar
5025538, Hav (Clk), Bikram Das
5027706, Hav (Clk), Soutan Biswas
5018476, Hav (Clk), Rodingliana
5018998, Hav (Clk), Abhay Kumar Tiwari
5019634, Hav (Clk), Herendra Singh
5020349, Hav (Clk), Pankaj Thakur
5021004, Hav(Clk), Moirangthem Sanjoy Singh
5021013, Hav (Clk), Satya Prakash
5021086,Hav (Clk), Purnakanta Biswakarma
5025259, Hav (Clk), Hijam Lakhsmikanta Singh
5016643, Hav (Clk), Jintendra Thakur
5021036, Hav (Clk), Gautam Kumar
5022892, Hav (Clk), Vikram Gujar
5016677, Hav (Clk), Sunil Yadav
5018077, Hav (Clk), D Siva Kumar
5025251, Hav (Clk), T HutoiSema
5025273, Hav (Clk), Abhishek Singh
5025304, Hav (Clk), Nitul Duwarah
5025311, Hav (Clk), Dharmendra Singh Yadav
5025328, Hav (Clk), Asem Dilip Singh
5025335, Hav (Clk), Arun T J
5025383, Hav (Clk), Ajeet Singh Rawat
5027802, Hav (Clk), Ravinder Singh
5017001, Hav (Clk), Shammi Kumar
5017230, Hav (Clk), Rakesh Kumar
5019375, Hav (Clk), Mani Kumar Chetry
5021045, Hav(Clk),OKram Rameshwor Singh
5021067, Hav (Clk), Sujeet Mech
5023324, Hav (Clk), S Hari Krishnan
5025395, Hav (Clk), Narendra Singh
2025:MLHC:182-DB
338.
339.
340.
341.
342.
343.
344.
345.
346.
347.
348.
349.
350.
351.
352.
353.
354.
355.
356.
357.
358.
359.
360.
361.
362.
363.
364.
365.
366.
367.
368.
369.
370.
371.
372.
373.
374.
375.
5028621, Hav (Clk), Rajput B K Dhanbahadur
5028623, Hav (Clk), Jacob Lalnutluanga
5015661, Hav (Clk), P C Vanlalhuma
5015695, Hav (Clk), Anand Singh Negi
5016934, Hav (Clk), Pradeep Gurung
5018075, Hav (Clk), Sharath Lal S S
5018888, Hav (Clk), Ravinder Singh
5021069, Hav (Clk), K C Vanlalnunpuia
5023299, Hav (Clk), BenrithungKikon
5025317, Hav (Clk), Prinsu Singh
5025372, Hav (Clk), Rajesh Das
5027824, Hav (Clk), Pathan Shahrukkha Faimkha
5015632, Hav (Clk), David Lalramawia
5017386, Hav (Clk), Ram Kumar Chhetri
5021052, Hav (Clk), Mahesh Joshi
5021055, Hav (Clk), Amit Kumar
5025554, Hav (Clk), Rajesh Kumar Ram
5014939, Hav (Clk), Pramod Kumar Yadav
5015868, Hav (Clk), Sajjan Singh
5019598, Hav (Clk), Sujith S
5025284, Hav (Clk), Ashwani Kumar
5018973, Hav (Clk), Pabitra Karmakar
5021093, Hav (Clk), Uday Kumar Singh
5021106, Hav (CIk),Deepak kr Suryawanshi
5025324, Hav (Clk), Rajesh kumar Gupta
5025332, Hav (Clk), Pukhrambam Shanti Kumar
5027624, Hav (Clk), Sunil Yadav
5028444, Hav (Clk), Pankaj Kumar
5025249, Hav (Clk), Gaidinreipou Pamei
5025313, Hav (Clk), Ajay Pal
5025366, Hav (Clk), Ajit Kumar Singh
5025368, Hav (CIk) Shanchuma Boro
5025371, Hav (Clk), Pranjal Pratim Borah
5017292, Hav (Clk), Ranjan Ram
5017378, Hav (Clk), Chanchal Singh Bisht
5017839, Hav (Clk), Y Dharmaraj
5018067, Hav (CIk), L Santosh Kumar
5018977, Hav (Clk), Kishor Oraon
2025:MLHC:182-DB
376.
377.
378.
379.
380.
381.
382.
383.
384.
385.
386.
387.
388.
389.
390.
391.
392.
393.
394.
395.
396.
397.
398.
399.
400.
401.
402.
403.
404.
405.
406.
407.
408.
409.
410.
411.
412.
413.
5021019, Hav (Clk), Jitendra Kumar
5025255, Hav (Clk), Vikas Kumar Sharma
5025382, Hav (Clk), Pawan Deep Singh
5028445, Hav (Clk), Bishal Gogoi
5021044, Hav (Clk), Neeraj Yadav
5023356, Hav (Clk), Akash Choudhary
5025288, Hav (Clk), Sandip Nath
5025352, Hav (Clk) Dipendra Chhetri
5025555, Hav (Clk), Anoop Singh
5018171, Hav (Clk), Manish Kumar
5018245, Hav (Clk), Janpoi Tesia
5020860, Hav (Clk), Lukram Bidyaraj Singh
5021041, Hav (Clk), Anup Chauhan
5023392, Hav (Clk), Devender
5025329, Hav (Clk), Karan Rajbanshi
5025337, Hav (Clk), Sudip Tirkey
5025597, Hav (Clk), Sunil Kumar Rawat
5027642, Hav (Clk), Naveen Singh
5028450, Hav (Clk), Kapil Kumar
5017608, Hav (Clk), L Rajesh Singh
5018718, Hav (Clk), Arun Saini
5022889, Hav (Clk), Asif Khan
5025278, Hav (Clk), Deepak
5025341, Hav (Clk), Mantu Talukdar
5025350, Hav (Clk), Pawan Kumar
5025576, Hav (Clk) Anil Minj
5027668, Hav (Clk), Amit Kuma
5028457, Hav (Clk), Sunny Dev
5022952, Hav (Clk), Pasang Lama
5023381, Hav (Clk), Paotinthang Haokip
5017690, Hav (Clk), Anil Kumar Sahu
5021010, Hav (Clk), Vinod Kumar
5025321, Hav (Clk), Satendra Kumar Rao
5016529, Hav (Clk), Vinay Kumar Mishra
5022821, Hav (Clk), Dhiraj Pandey
5023078, Hav (Clk), Dev Bahadur Sunar
5021702,Hav(Clk), Yogesh Kumar Dwivedi
5022777, Hav (Clk) Manik Chandra Das
2025:MLHC:182-DB
414.
415.
416.
417.
418.
419.
420.
421.
422.
423.
424.
425.
426.
427.
428.
429.
430.
431.
432.
433.
434.
435.
436.
437.
438.
439.
440.
441.
442.
443.
444.
445.
446.
447.
448.
449.
450.
451.
5022819, Hav (Clk), Surchandra Singha
5022912, Hav (Clk), Sandeep Yadav
5022930, Hav (Clk), Sanjay Kumar
5025281, Hav (Clk), Ashish Gurung
5025334, Hav (Clk), Ranjit Singh Bhau
5025587, Hav (Clk), Kundan Kumar
5018818, Hav (Clk), Sunil Kumar
5020618, Hav (Clk), Dhruv Kumar
5025342, Hav (Clk), Pradeep Thakur
5025584, Hav (Clk), Praveen Kumar
5015130, Hav (Clk), N Dhanshyam Singh
5016629, Hav (Clk), I L Meetai
5016630, Hav (Clk), Ajay Singh Bijarnia
5017100, Hav (Clk), Sandeep Singh
5017307, Hav (Clk), Deep Tamang
5017333, Hav (Clk), Irphan Khan
5018796, Hav (Clk) Hafizuddin Ahmed
5020261, Hav (Clk), Jatinder Singh
5021420, Hav (Clk), V Nagarjuna
5023077, Hav (Clk), Thoudam Digbijoy Meitei
5025306, Hav (Clk), Pankaj Kumar Jena
5025353, Hav (Clk), Ajit Singh
5025360, Hav (Clk), Shrawan Kumar
5015083, Hav (Clk), Amit Kumar
5014952, Hav (Clk) Lalit Kumar Janoti
5015883, Hav (Clk), Dinesh
5016054, Hav (Clk), Kiran Limbu
5016318, Hav (Clk), Veeraswamy Venkala
5016690, Hav (Clk), Jagat Jyoti Chhetri
5016831, Hav (Clk), Sheesh Pal
5017283, Hav (Clk), Shyam Sunder
5017284, Hav (Clk), Hare Krishna Roy
5017332, Hav (Clk), Lakshmikanth N
5017615, Hav (Clk), Ganesh Chhetri
5017636, Hav (Clk), Ng Omendro Singh
5018081, Hav (Clk), P Sudhakar Reddy
5018493, Hav (Clk), R L Pachuau
5018869, Hav (Clk), Subash Chand
2025:MLHC:182-DB
452.
453.
454.
455.
456.
457.
458.
459.
460.
461.
462.
463.
464.
465.
466.
467.
468.
469.
470.
471.
472.
473.
474.
475.
476.
477.
478.
479.
480.
481.
482.
483.
484.
485.
486.
487.
488.
489.
5019335, Hav (Clk), Gurmeet Singh
5019489, Hav (Clk), Bikky Lama
5019639, Hav (Clk), Abhay Pratap
5019751, Hav (Clk), Amar Nath
5019757, Hav (Clk), Anish Kumar Singh
5020000, Hav (Clk), Bikram Pun
5020068, Hav (Clk), Brajendra Kumar
5020102, Hav (Clk) Ashis Rai
5020255, Hav (Clk), Vivek Kukrety
5020857, Hav (Clk), Th Jemson Singh
5021001, Hav (Clk), H Vanlallawmkima
5021015, Hav (Clk), N Surajkanta Singh
5021018, Hav (Clk), Surgyan Singh Gurjar
5021028, Hav (Clk), Sandeep Kumar Sharma
5021038, Hav (Clk), Vikash Deoli
5021081, Hav (Clk), Rohit Thakur
5021082, Hav (Clk), Ravi Kumar
5021128, Hav (Clk), Ashu Kumar Ram
5021173, Hav (Clk), Mithlesh Kumar
5021432, Hav (Clk), Manoj Yadav
5022771, Hav (Clk), Goutam Sarkar
5022779, Hav (Clk), Maskare Chunnilal Jagdish
5022780, Hav (Clk), Rugantar Chakma
5022784, Hav (Clk), Atenjenba
5022850, Hav (Clk), Sanjay Rudra Paul
5022860, Hav (Clk), Dilliram Parajuli
5022870, Hav (Clk), Akshay Kumar Sinah
5022874, Hav (Clk), Shimborlang Kharshandi
5022897, Hav (Clk), Dan Singh Rana
5022913, Hav (Clk), Raju Thakur
5022916, Hav (Clk), Pappu Kumar
5022925, Hav (Clk), Tuhinkanti Kar
5022940, Hav (Clk), Hosang Gurung
5022942, Hav (Clk), Gol Mohammad
5022954, Hav (Clk), Neeraj Singh Soun
5022980, Hav (Clk), J Ramchungthang
5022995, Hav (Clk), Daljeet Singh Dogra
5023013, Hav (Clk), Gulshinder Singh
2025:MLHC:182-DB
490.
491.
492.
493.
494.
495.
496.
497.
498.
499.
500.
501.
502.
503.
504.
505.
506.
507.
508.
509.
510.
511.
512.
513.
514.
515.
516.
517.
518.
519.
520.
521.
522.
523.
524.
525.
526.
527.
5023028, Hav (Clk), Taushif Ahmad
5023029, Hav (Clk), Bikram Tamang
5023031, Hav (Clk), Vikram Singh
5023032, Hav (Clk), Samir Thapa
5023082, Hav (Clk), Mayengbam Johnson Meitei
5023086, Hav (Clk), Ningthoujam Romeo Singh
5023088, Hav (Clk), Dayamo Yendrembam
5023095, Hav (Clk), Haominlen Khongsai
5023361, Hav (Clk), Sandeep Prasad
5025253, Hav (CIk),Minishwrang Mushahary
5025262, Hav (Clk), B Nagabosanam
5025272, Hav (Clk), Sanjay Kumar
5025296, Hav (Clk), Raju Ansari
5025302, Hav (Clk), Bighneswar Samal
5025307, Hav (Clk), Deepak Kharab
5025314, Hav (Clk), Niranjan Kumar
5025319, Hav (Clk), Ravi Ranjan Kumar
5025320, Hav (Clk), Sudhir Yadav
5025323, Hav (Clk), Manoj Saurabh
5025325, Hav (Clk), Shakti Chhetri
5025367, Hav (Clk), Mukul Hazarika
5025379, Hav (Clk), Rakesh Kumar Saroj
5023397, Hav (Clk), Khaijamang Haokip
5025391, Hav (Clk), Abhijeet Brahma
5025541, Hav (Clk), Debendra Sinha
5025545, Hav (Clk), Suresh Kumar
5025553, Hav (Clk), Bulbul Chetia
5025572, Hav (Clk), Deepak Rasaile
5025583, Hav (Clk), Rajan Kumar Singh
5025600, Hav (Clk), Balram Ojha
5017342, Hav (Clk), Manoj Singh Bora
5017889, Hav (Clk), Balaji GR
5017936, Hav (Clk),Emmanuel Lalsanglien
5018788, Hav (Clk), G Arjun Singh
5018909, Hav (Clk), Harvinder Singh
5019316, Hav (Clk), Diwanshu Gaur
5020945, Hav (Clk), Ishrar Khan
5022833, Hav (Clk), Nithin Mohan
2025:MLHC:182-DB
528.
529.
530.
531.
532.
533.
534.
535.
536.
537.
538.
539.
540.
541.
542.
543.
544.
545.
546.
547.
548.
549.
550.
551.
552.
553.
554.
555.
556.
557.
558.
559.
560.
561.
562.
563.
564.
565.
5022872,Hav (Clk),Vikas Kumar Suryawnhi
5022898, Hav (Clk), Inderpal Yadav
5022932, Hav (Clk), Akhil Raj TR
5022947, Hav (Clk), Manejer Choudhary
5022963, Hav (Clk), Prem Bahadur Kharka
5023042, Hav (Clk), Shashi Bhushan Sharma
5023043, Hav (Clk), Boto I Wotsa
5023061,Hav (Clk), Livingstone Sochinghao
5023068,Hav (Clk), Khiuwangbou Abonmai
5023073, Hav (Clk), Sachin Kumar
5021014, Hav (Clk), Mukesh Sunar
5022823, Hav (Clk), Indrajeet Chakma
5022981, Hav (Clk), Arbind Kumar
5018183, Hav (Clk), Saiful Islam
5022957, Hav (Clk), Avinash Kumar
5023353, Hav (Clk), Michael Kharkhonga
5017915, Hav (Clk), Shaibud Lyngdoh Thabah
5020988, Hav (Clk), Pravin Kumar Rai
5021002, Hav (Clk), Rana Pratap Koach
5022769, Hav (Clk), Radha Kanta Sarkar
5022853, Hav (Clk), Benjamin V Zhimomi
5025271, Hav (Clk), Govindra Nomosudra
5025566, Hav (Clk), Kuldeep Singh
5025592, Hav (Clk), Indrajit Sinha
5016228, Hav (CIk), Rajesh Oraon
5018317, Hav (Clk), Uttom Deori
5018486, Hav (Clk), K Vanlalnghaka
5019970, Hav (Clk), Biju Chetri
5022955, Hav (Clk), Ganga DattKapadi
5023011, Hav (Clk), Satyendra Kumar
5023339, Hav (Clk), Mithlesh Singh
5025343, Hav(Clk), Gyan Prakash Gautam
5025355,Hav (Clk), Brijkishor Singh Tomar
5018028, Hav (Clk), Rambabu Balaka
5019736, Hav (Clk), Vishal Rajbonshi
5020033, Hav (Clk), Shailendra Pratap Singh
5025381, Hav (Clk), Pradeep Kumar Bugalia
5025535, Hav (Clk), Bappa Kumar Nath
2025:MLHC:182-DB
566.
567.
568.
569.
570.
571.
572.
573.
574.
575.
576.
577.
578.
579.
580.
581.
582.
583.
584.
585.
586.
587.
588.
589.
590.
591.
592.
593.
594.
595.
596.
597.
598.
599.
600.
601.
602.
603.
5015030, Hav (Clk), Sandeep Kumar
5017688, Hav (Clk), Akoijam Jotindro Singh
5018723, Hav (Clk), Ashu Yadav
5020281, Hav (Clk), Jaipal
5014928,Hav (Clk), Lokhande Arjun Baban
5017923, Hav (Clk), Sunil Sharma
5018052, Hav (Clk), Valireddy Pittu
5019026, Hav (Clk), Utpal Barman
5019370, Hav (Clk), Umed Singh Dhami
5020408, Hav (Clk), Anil Kumar
5021006, Hav (Clk), Rojit Singh Ch
5021027,Hav (Clk),S antosh Kumar Sahoo
5021066, Hav (Clk), Ramesh Bahadur Newar
5022901, Hav (Clk), Manoj Basnet
5022986, Hav (CIk), Shailendra Singh
5023047, Hav (Clk), Haveev Khan
5023359, Hav (Clk), Jagbir Singh
5025258, Hav (Clk), Suman Khongsit
5025283, Hav (Clk), Shyam Kishore
5025291, Hav (Clk), Suman Singha
5025315, Hav (Clk), Bishal Rai
5025344, Hav (Clk), Deepak Kumar
5017257, Hav (Clk), Sanjeev Kumar
5021214, Hav (Clk), Haret Singh Gujar
5022834, Hav (CIk), Rajesh Kumar Nayak
5021418, Hav (Clk), Abhishek
5017076, Hav (Clk), Vishu Kumar V
5017092, Hav (Clk), Prasant Limbu
5025596, Hav (Clk), Rakesh Gurung
5021080, Hav (Clk), Sulanthung Ngullie
5025399, Hav (Clk), Sandeep Gurung
5027771, Hav (Clk), Sher Singh
5027631, Hav (Clk), Pratyush Solanki
5028561, Hav (Clk), Sukalyan Saha
5022917, Hav (Clk), Ashish Kumar
5025326, Hav (Clk), Ankit Kumar
5025299, Hav (Clk), Avinash Kumar
5018967, Hav (Clk), Gopeswar Ghosh
2025:MLHC:182-DB
604.
605.
606.
607.
608.
609.
610.
611.
612.
5021035, Hav (Clk), Sambhu Pradhan
5021037, Hav (Clk), Pushkar Singh
5021092, Hav (Clk), Manoj Kumar
5027722, Hav (CIk), Dharmendr Gupta
5028463, Hav (Clk), Lunminlen Kipgen
5018982, Hav (Clk), Arun Kumar Gurung
5021030A, Hav (Clk), Ashwani Kumar
5025390, Hav (Clk), Debajit Pokrel Chetry
5028481, Hav (Clk), Koushik Mondal
…Writ Appellants
-VERSUS-
1.
2.
3.
4.
Union of India, represented by the Secretary to the Government of
India, Ministry of Home Affairs, New Delhi - 110001.
The Director General, Assam Rifles, HQ DGAR, Shillong - 793011.
The Brigadier (Personnel), HQ DGAR, Shillong -793011.
The Colonel (Administration), HQ DGAR, Shillong -793011.
…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. B. Pathak, Adv with
Mr. V. Kumar, Adv
Ms. P. Chettri, Adv
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. R. Debnath, CGC
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Note: For proper public information and transparency, any media
reporting this judgment is directed to mention the composition of
the bench by name of judges, while reporting this judgment/order.
2025:MLHC:182-DB
JUDGMENT
I.P. Mukerji, C.J.:
I have had the privilege of going through the draft judgment
prepared by my learned brother. I am in full agreement with the
conclusions and order proposed by his lordship.
The facts of this case have been narrated in great detail in the said
judgment. I will not try to regurgitate the same. I would only like to add a
few observations of my own.
Three reasons given by the learned single judge for rejecting the
writ petition are as follows:
The appellants sat on the fence and waited for the outcome of the
writ petitions filed by the other writ petitioners.
Secondly, they were recruited after 29th October, 2002 on initiation
of the 2002 Rules and were not on the same footing as the earlier writ
petitioners.
Thirdly, the earlier orders were in personam. The appellants could
not take the benefit of those orders.
I will take the second point first.
The 2002 Rules did not redesignate the rank or alter the pay scale
of the appellants, to make it equivalent to that of Warrant Officers in the
Central services. It was just that the name of the post was changed. The
2025:MLHC:182-DB
appellants in terms of rank and pay were in the same category as those of
the earlier writ petitioners.
Their nature and type of work and all other service conditions were
similar to the earlier batch of writ petitioners.
As far as the allegation against them of “sitting on the fence” is
concerned, I do not think that it is sustainable. It is for the following
reasons.
There is no period of limitation prescribed for preferring a writ
petition. Of course, it has to be instituted within reasonable time.
Inordinate and unexplained delay vitiates a writ petition.
The Supreme Court on 17th November, 2015 affirmed, with some
modification the order of the learned single judge dated 23 rd August, 2012.
It was implemented by Assam Rifles on 28 th June, 2016 leaving out 89 of
the 1232 number of writ petitioners who were appointed under the 2002
Rules on the ground that they were not covered by the Supreme Court
judgment. Finally, after contempt proceedings were initiated by 87 of
them, on 12th April, 2019, Assam Rifles implemented the entire order.
In those circumstances, it was only on or after 12th April, 2019 that
the appellants could have been aware of the fact that they were also
similarly situated as the earlier writ petitioners their legal rights flowing
from this knowledge and entitled to the same relief.
2025:MLHC:182-DB
Moreover, being bound and guided by Article 14 of the
Constitution, it became the duty of the government to extend similar
benefit to the appellants as the earlier writ petitioners, whether or not they
obtained orders of Court. This in my opinion is part of the principle of
equality, fairness, transparency and good governance which every State
should follow.
Therefore, the present writ petition of 2019 could never be
dismissed on the ground of “delay”, “fence sitting” or acquiescence.
It did not matter even if the earlier writ petition was an action in
personam or in rem. I am not expressing our opinion on this issue as it is
immaterial. The appellants are entitled to this benefit for the reasons
above.
The argument of learned counsel for the respondents was that
redesignation of 87 employees further to the contempt petition was an
irregular or illegal act. He contended that no advantage could be taken of
this illegal act, as it could not be acted upon as a precedent relying upon
[Union of India & anr v. Arulmozhi Iniarasu & ors reported in (2011) 7
SCC 397 and Director of Horticulture, Odisha v. Pravat Kumar Dash &
ors reported in (2019) 8 SCC 294]. This proposition and the above
authorities have no application because my reasoning above clearly shows
that all the appellants were similarly situated and entitled to the same relief
2025:MLHC:182-DB
as the earlier batch of writ petitioners and that the 87 employees were
rightly redesignated.
Union of India v. Dineshan K.K. reported in (2008) 1 SCC 586
cited by learned counsel for the appellants is applicable. Paragraphs 4, 9,
and 25 are set out below:
“4. The nub of the grievance of the writ petitioner, working in
the rank of a Radio Mechanic in Assam Rifles was that the
Ministry of Home Affairs and the Director General of Assam
Rifles having accepted in principle that the numbers of Assam
Rifles, should be given the same rank and pay structure as
was given to other Central paramilitary forces, yet the same
had been denied to them. …..”
9. ….. the High Court felt that it would be unreasonable and
discriminatory if the pay scales given to Radio Mechanics in
CRPF and BSF were denied to the Radio Mechanics in
Assam Rifles, when the qualifications and service
requirements in all the three organisations were identical.
Consequently, the High Court issued the aforenoted
directions, which are questioned in this appeal.
25. However, the Ministry of Home Affairs vide Letter dated
3-3-1998 while accepting the said proposal had recommended
redesignation of Havildar/RM as warrant officer but subject
to the condition that the prerevised and revised pay scales of
Havildar/RM in other paramilitary forces were identical to the
pay scales of Head Constable (RM) in CRPF and BSF. …..
The counter-affidavit does not even attempt to explain how
the case of Havildar/RM in Assam Rifles is different from
that of Radio Mechanics in other Central paramilitary forces.”
The following dicta was laid down by the Supreme Court:
“12. The principle of “equal pay for equal work” has been
considered, explained and applied in a catena of decisions of
this Court. The doctrine of “equal pay for equal work” was
originally propounded as part of the directive principles of the
State policy in Article 39(d) of the Constitution. In Randhir
Singh v. Union of India a Bench of three learned Judges of
this Court had observed that principle of equal pay for equal
2025:MLHC:182-DB
work is not a mere demagogic slogan but a constitutional
goal, capable of being attained through constitutional
remedies and held that this principle had to be read under
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. This decision was
affirmed by a Constitution Bench of this Court in D.S.
Nakara v. Union of India. Thus, having regard to the
constitutional mandate of equality and inhibition against
discrimination in Articles 14 and 16, in service jurisprudence,
the doctrine of “equal pay for equal work” has assumed status
of a fundamental right.
13. Initially, particularly in the early eighties, the said
principle was being applied as an absolute rule but realising
its cascading effect on other cadres, in subsequent decisions
of this Court, a note of caution was sounded that the principle
of equal pay for equal work had no mathematical application
in every case of similar work. It has been observed that
equation of posts and equation of pay structure being complex
matters are generally left to the executive and expert bodies
like the pay Commission, etc. It has been emphasised that a
carefully evolved pay structure ought not to be ordinarily
disturbed by the court as it may upset the balance and cause
avoidable ripples in other cadres as well. (Vide Secy., Finance
Deptt. v. W.B. Registration Service Assn. and State of
Haryana v. Haryana Civil Secretariat Personal Staff Assn.)
Nevertheless, it will not be correct to lay down as an absolute
rule that merely because determination and granting of pay
scales is the prerogative of the executive, the court has no
jurisdiction to examine and pay structure and an aggrieved
employee has no remedy if he is unjustly treated by arbitrary
State action or inaction, except to go on knocking at the doors
of the executive or the legislature, as is sought to be
canvassed on behalf of the appellants. Undoubtedly, when
there is no dispute with regard to the qualifications, duties and
responsibilities of the persons holding identical posts or ranks
but they are treated differently merely because they belong to
different departments or the basis for classification of posts is
ex facie irrational, arbitrary or unjust, it is open to the court to
intervene.”
The conclusion was:
“28. On a conspectus of the factual scenario noted above, we
do not find any infirmity in the impugned directions given by
2025:MLHC:182-DB
the High Court, warranting interference. There is no merit in
this appeal and it is dismissed accordingly with costs.”
The appellants are entitled to the same relief as the writ petitioners
in WP (C) No.277 (SH) 2010, granted by a learned single judge of this
Court on 23rd August, 2012, modified by a division bench of this Court on
30th April, 2013 and finally granted by the Supreme Court with
modifications by its judgment and order dated 17th November, 2015.
I, direct that the appellants may be granted relief in identical
manner as if the said orders of the Court were incorporated in this
judgment and order. Similar departmental orders may also be issued.
I grant the same relief as in the judgment and order of my learned
brother.
This appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment and order is set
aside.
No order as to costs.
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
B. Bhattacharjee, J.:
This writ appeal is directed against the Judgment dated 05-12-2022
passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No.244 of 2019 by which the
writ petition was dismissed being devoid of merits.
2025:MLHC:182-DB
The fact of the case is that in the year 2010, 1339 employees
belonging to the clerical cadre of Assam Rifles raised the issue of parity in
respect of pay, rank and status of Assam Rifles clerical cadre at par with
other Central Police Organization (CPO) by filing a writ petition No.
WP(C) No.277 (SH) of 2010 and sought for introduction of post of
Warrant Officer (Clerk) in Assam Rifles at the Entry Level post. The said
writ petition was disposed of by the Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012
directing the Director General of Assam Rifles to take up the matter with
the Secretary to the Govt. of India, Ministry of Home Affairs to bring
parity in respect of rank structure and a pay of the Assam Rifles clerical
cadre at par with other CPOs by introducing the rank of Assistant SubInspector (Warrant Officer) at the entry grade w.e.f. 01-01-1986 in the pay
scale of Rs. 1320-2040 (Rs.4000-6000) with all consequential benefits in
the light of the communication made through MHA letter No.270102/1/97 PC Cell/Pef-1 dated 10-10-1997.
The aforesaid Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012 of the learned
Single Judge was challenged in W.A. No.40 (SH) of 2012 wherein vide
Judgment and Order dated 30-04-2013 the direction of the learned Single
Judge was modified with regard to the date of application of the benefit of
arrear of financial benefits. Thereafter, the matter reached before the Apex
Court in Civil Appeal No. 13445 of 2015 (arising out of SLP (C) No.
2025:MLHC:182-DB
29908 of 2013) wherein by order dated 17-11-2015 the Judgment and
Order of the learned Single Judge was restored.
The Ministry of Home Affairs, thereafter, approved the
implementation of the Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012 by Memo
No. MHA U.O. 27013/2/2016.PF.IV dated 21-06-2016 wherein it was
communicated that the Ministry of Home Affairs in consultation with the
Ministry of Finance has agreed to implement the said Judgment and Order
in respect of petitioners therein as well as other similarly placed
employees.
Accordingly, the Directorate General Assam Rifles
implemented the Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012 extending the
benefit of the rank structure and pay of Warrant Officer to 1250 petitioners
in WP(C) No.277 (SH) of 2010 by Order No. A/Pers/II-04/Clk/2016/774
dated 28-06-2016.
However, the benefits were extended only to the
personnel of the clerical cadre who were in service as on 01-01-1986 and
who were enrolled thereafter upto 28-10-2002. As a result, 89 petitioners
in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 were left out and not conferred with the
above benefits.
The petitioners numbering 87 out of the aforesaid 89, who did not
get the benefit, approached this High Court by filing Contempt Case(C)
No.21 of 2016. At the stage of the consideration of the contempt matter,
the respondents agreed to implement the Judgment and Order dated 23-082012 to the remaining 89 writ petitioners. Consequently, the Director
2025:MLHC:182-DB
General of Assam Rifles issued Order No. Rec (Adm-I) MACPS (Court
Case)/2019/320 dated, Shillong the 12-04-2019 extending the benefits to
the remaining 89 writ petitioners in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) 2010.
Further, another batch of 192 Havildar (Clerks) of Assam Rifles,
who were enrolled in service after 28-10-2002, approached this Court by
filing WP(C) No. 198 of 2019 claiming benefits which fell due upon them
consequent to the passing of the Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012
and the order dated 12-04-2019 of the Directorate General Assam Rifles.
The said writ petition was allowed by the Judgment dated 17-02-2023.
Upon challenge made, the Apex Court declined to interfere with the said
Judgment dated 17-02-2023 and dismissed the SLP bearing No.
15217/2024 by order dated 17-05-2024.
As a result, the Directorate
General Assam Rifles vide order No. Rec(Adm-I)/Ajay Kumar/Court
Case/2024/112 dated 19-07-2024 conferred the rank and status of Warrant
Officer at the entry grade to the aforesaid 192 personnel w.e.f. the date of
their respective entry into service.
The appellants in this present writ appeal, who are serving as
Havildar (clerk) in Assam Rifles, have filed WP(C) No.244 of 2019
praying for issuance of mandamus directing the respondents to grant the
benefit of rank structure, status and pay-scale of Assistant Sub-Inspector
(Warrant Officer) in the pay-scale of Rs.1320-2040 (revised Rs.40006000) w.e.f. the date of enrollment in terms of the Judgment and Order
2025:MLHC:182-DB
dated 23-08-2012 passed by the erstwhile Guwahati High Court, Shillong
Bench in WP(C) No.277 (SH) of 2010.
The learned Single Judge vide impugned Judgment dated 05-122022 dismissed the writ petition by holding that the appellants are not
entitled to the benefits of the Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012
passed in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 as they did not join the issue with
their colleagues in the first round of litigation and the Judgment and Order
dated 23-08-2012 is a judgment in personam. The learned Single Judge
further held that the appellants cannot seek parity of any kind as they are
enrolled under the relevant Recruitment Rules of 2002 and the rules have
not been challenged. Moreover, the appellants are fence-sitters as they did
not choose to align with the 87(sic 89) petitioners when they filed WP(C)
No. 277 (SH) of 2010 and, hence, the principle of delay and latches and
acquiescence can be attributed to their action.
Assailing the impugned judgment dated 05-12-2022, Mr. B.
Pathak, learned Counsel for the appellants, submits that the appellants in
the present case are similarly situated with the petitioners in WP(C) No.
277 (SH) of 2010 and, therefore, entitled to the similar benefits as they are
also serving in the same clerical trade and performing equal duties. He
submits that the Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012 is a judgment in
rem as the direction made therein is meant to be implemented for the
purpose of bringing parity in respect of rank structure and pay of the
2025:MLHC:182-DB
Assam Rifles clerical cadre. He further submits that the Recruitment
Rules of 2002 was in force when the judgment and order dated 23-08-2012
was passed in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 and, hence, the said rules
cannot come in the way of conferring benefit to the appellants.
By
referring to the implementation order dated 21-06-2016, the learned
Counsel submits that it is clear from the contents thereof that the
competent authority had approved the introduction of the post of Warrant
Officer at the entry grade to bring parity in respect of rank structure of
Assam Rifles clerical grade at par with other CPOs and such benefit was
to be extended to all the persons in the clerical cadre. The learned Counsel
further contends that since the benefit of the Judgment and Order dated 2308-2012 and subsequent implementation order dated 21-06-2016 are to be
applied to the entire clerical cadre of the Assam Rifles, the learned Single
Judge could not have denied the relief to the appellants on the ground of
delay and latches by terming them fence-sitters. He submits that in any
view of the matter, the impugned Judgment dated 05-12-2022 cannot be
sustained in law and facts and is liable to be interfered with.
The
judgment of Union of India v. Dineshan K.K., (2008) 1 SCC 586 is pressed
into service by the learned Counsel.
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC, on the other hand, contends that the
appellants herein are not similarly situated with the petitioners in WP(C)
No. 277 (SH) of 2010 and, hence, cannot claim benefit of the Judgment
2025:MLHC:182-DB
and Order dated 23-08-2012. He submits that the appellants have entered
into service after 28-10-2002 when the amended Recruitment Rules of
2002 was in force and, as such, are guided by the stipulation made in the
said rules, wherein the post of Warrant Officer (clerk) is not provided as
an entry grade post in the clerical cadre of the Assam Rifles. He further
submits that the conferment of benefit to the 89 petitioners in WP(C) No.
277 (SH) of 2010, who were enrolled in the clerical cadre of Assam Rifles
after 28-10-2002, was through oversight and inadvertence and the
appellants cannot claim any benefit out of that as there can be no claim
based on negative equality.
For deciding the controversy between the parties, it would be
appropriate to refer to the operative part of the Judgement and Order dated
23-08-2012 in WP(C) No.277 (SH) of 2010 which is reproduced below: “14. In the result, this writ petition stands disposed of with
the direction to the respondent No.2, the Director General of
Assam Rifles to take up the matter again with the respondent
No.1, i.e. the Secretary to the Govt. of India, Ministry of
Home Affairs to bring parity in respect of rank structure and
pay of the Assam Rifles clerical cadre at par with other
CPOs by introducing rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector
(Warrant Officer) at the entry grade w.e.f. 1.1.1986 in the
scale of pay of RS1320-2040 (revised Rs. 4000-6000) w.e.f.
1.1.1996 or any other date as the authority deem it fit and
proper with all consequential benefits in the light of the
Government of India, Ministry of Finance resolution dated
20-09-1997 communicated through MH. Letter bearing
No.2701-02/1/97 PC Cell/Pef-1 dated 10.10.1997. The
whole exercise would be completed within a period of 6 (six)
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
judgment and order.”
2025:MLHC:182-DB
The learned Single Judge denied relief to the appellants by treating
the aforesaid Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012 as judgment in
personam. Normally, a judgment which binds only those who are parties
to it, is known as judgment in personam. Judgments, mention of which are
made in Section 41 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Section 35 of The
Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023), are referred to as judgment in rem.
Though, definition of judgment in rem has not been provided anywhere, it
has been understood as meaning a judgment which is conclusive not only
against the parties, but also against the whole world.
Perusal of the
operative part of the Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012 would
unambiguously show that the direction was issued for taking appropriate
steps for bringing parity in respect of rank, structure and pay of the entire
Assam Rifles clerical cadre at par with other CPOs. The direction was not
confined to giving benefit only to the persons who were petitioners in that
case. It is apparent that the intention was to give benefit to all similarly
situated persons, whether they approached the Court or not. Thus, it is
crystal clear that the Judgment and Order dated 23-08-2012 is a judgment
in rem and not a judgment of in personam.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Uttar Pradesh and Others
v. Arvind Jumar Srivastava and Others reported in (2015) 1 SCC 347 has
observed as follows:
2025:MLHC:182-DB
22.1. The normal rule is that when a particular set of
employees is given relief by the court, all other identically
situated persons need to be treated alike by extending that
benefit. Not doing so would amount to discrimination and
would be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
This principle needs to be applied in service matters more
emphatically as the service jurisprudence evolved by this
Court from time to time postulates that all similarly situated
persons should be treated similarly. Therefore, the normal
rule would be that merely because other similarly situated
persons did not approach the Court earlier, they are not to
be treated differently.
22.2. However, this principle is subject to well recognized
exceptions in the form of latches and delays as well as
acquiescence. Those persons who did not challenge the
wrongful action in their cases and acquiesced into the same
and woke up after long delay only because of the reason that
their counterparts who had approached the court earlier in
time succeeded in their efforts, then such employees cannot
claim that the benefit of the judgment rendered in the case of
similarly situated persons be extended to them. They would
be treated as fence-sitters and laches and delays, and/or the
acquiescence, would be a valid ground to dismiss their
claim.
22.3. However, this exception may not apply in those cases
where the judgment pronounced by the court was judgment
in rem with intention to give benefit to all similarly situated
persons, whether they approached the court or not. With
such a pronouncement the obligation is cast upon the
authorities to itself extend the benefit thereof to all similarly
situated persons. Such a situation can occur when the
subject-matter of the decision touches upon the policy
matters, like scheme of regularization and the like. On the
other hand, if the judgment of the court was in personam
holding that benefit of the said judgment shall accrue to the
parties before the court and such an intention is stated
expressly in the judgment or it can be impliedly found out
from the tenor and language of the judgment, those who
want to get the benefit of the said judgment extended to them
shall have to satisfy that their petition does not suffer from
either laches and delays or acquiescence.”
2025:MLHC:182-DB
It emerges from the above that when a particular set of employees
is given relief by the Court, the other identically situated persons shall be
treated alike and not doing so would amount to discrimination and,
therefore, violative of provisions of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
In such a situation, the authorities are obligated to extend the benefit
thereof to all similarly situated persons. It is settled by now, specially in
service law, that all similarly situated persons should be treated similarly.
Even, the principles of delay and laches as well as acquiescence are of not
much relevance for consideration of relief claimed in the case.
The law laid down by the Apex Court in Arvind Kumar Srivastava
(supra) has been followed in Shoeline Vs. Commissioner of Service Tax &
Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 104.
Before the coming of the Recruitment Rules of 2002 on 29-102002, recruitment of clerks in the Assam Rifles were made in the post of
Lance Naik (Writer). The post of Warrant Officer was introduced by the
Assam Rifles at the entry grade of the clerical cadre in compliance of the
Court’s order as an ex-cadre post in terms of the recommendation of the
5th Central Pay Commission without any provision in the recruitment
rules. There is no mention of any rank/post equivalent to Assistant SubInspector (Warrant Officer) in the recruitment rule which was in existence
prior to 2002 and also in the Recruitment Rules of 2002. The recruitment
rules framed in the year 2002 has only renamed the post of Lance Naik
2025:MLHC:182-DB
(Writer) as Havildar (Clerk). The concept of Warrant Officer came from
the recommendation of the 5th Central Pay Commission. The Recruitment
Rules of 2002 was in force when the Judgment and Order dated 23-082012 in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 was delivered and the Directorate of
Assam Rifles had to introduce the rank and pay of Warrant Officer at the
Entry Grade of the clerical cadre as Ex-cadre post without the same being
provided in the recruitment rule. Hence, the Recruitment Rules of 2002
cannot be an impediment to the grant of relief claimed for by the
appellants in the writ petition.
There is no dispute to the fact that both the posts of Warrant
Officer (Clerk) and Havildar (Clerk) are entry level posts at the Assam
Rifles clerical trade. There is no difference of requisite qualification and
performance of duty between the two posts. The normal rule is that when
a particular set of employees is given relief by the Court, all other similar
and identically situated persons should be treated alike by extending the
same benefit. There cannot be selective implementation, particularly when
the judgement passed by the Court was a judgement in rem, to create
unreasonable classification. There cannot be two different entry grades to
one Clerical Trade where some employees get higher rank and pay of
Warrant Officer and other similarly situated employees get lessor rank and
pay of Havildar. Simply because, the appellants herein did not come to
Court and joined the first round of litigation, they cannot be deprived of
2025:MLHC:182-DB
their legitimate rights. The respondents/employers are under legal
obligation to grant the benefit to all these similarly situated employees,
notwithstanding the fact as to whether they approached the Court or not.
It is pertinent to mention that the set of all the 89 persons, who
received the benefit of financial upgradation and rank and status of the
Warrant Officer by order No. Rec(Adm-I)/MACPS (Court Case)/2019/320
dated 12-04-2019, have entered into the service after 28-10-2002.
Another batch of 192 persons, who were conferred with the same benefit
vide order No. Rec(Adm-I)/Ajay Kumar(Court Case)/2024/112 dated 1907-2024 consequent to the Judgment dated 17-02-2023 passed in WP(C)
No. 198 of 2019, have also entered the service after 28-10-2002. Both the
sets of the aforesaid persons were enrolled in the service of the Assam
Rifles after the Recruitment Rules of 2002 came into force. In such a
situation, the contention raised on behalf of the respondents that the
appellants are not entitled to the benefit as the post of Warrant Officer is
not sanctioned by the rule is totally untenable and stands rejected.
The ground of delay and laches as well as acquiescence raised on
behalf of the respondents is also not tenable in view of the law laid down
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Arvind Kumar Srivastava (supra) as
discussed above. The respondents by no stretch of imagination can
discriminate the appellants by treating them as employees belonging to a
different class by making unreasonable classification and deny them the
2025:MLHC:182-DB
benefit which they are entitled to by virtue of the Judgment and Order
dated 23-08-2012 passed in WP(C) No.277 (SH) of 2010 and subsequent
approval of implementation issued vide Memo No. MHA U.O.
27013/2/2016.PF.IV dated 21-06-2016 of the Ministry of Home Affairs. I
also endorse the reasons given by my learned brother on the issue of delay.
For what has been discussed above, the appellants have made out a
case for interference with the impugned Judgement dated 05-12-2022
passed in WP(C) No.244 of 2019 and the same is hereby set aside.
Resultantly, the appellants are entitled to the relief claimed by them in the
writ petition.
The respondents are directed to issue necessary order granting the
benefit of rank and pay of Warrant Officer to the appellants w.e.f. their
respective date of appointment in terms of the benefits already extended to
the clerical cadre by implementation of the Judgment and Order dated 2308-2012 passed in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) 2010. The entire exercise should
be completed by the respondents within a period of four months from
today.
The writ appeal stands allowed. No costs.
(B. Bhattacharjee)
Judge
KHRAWDAPBOR BUHPHANG
Date: 2025.03.18 16:59:14
PDT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review