Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of reserving: 6th August, 2026
Date of Decision: 17th August, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
+
CRL.A. 695/2009
PREM RAJ & ANR.
Through:
.....Appellants
Ms. Suman Arora, Adv.
versus
STATE OF DELHI
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Satinder Singh Bawa, APP for
the State with SI Rahul, PS Mayapuri.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIMAL KUMAR YADAV
JUDGMENT
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J.
1.
An information through DD No. 74B, dated 15.03.2000 of Police
Station Mangolpuri, Delhi set the police machinery in action, which was
recorded at 11:30 PM. The said DD was assigned to SI Neeraj, which was to
the effect that some anti-social elements are fighting with each other having
knife, as was reported by one Kewal Krishan, R/o K-1166, Mangolpuri.
While SI Neeraj was assigned the said DD and was on his way, another
information came from the Police Control Room (‘PCR’), which was
reduced into writing as DD No. 75B dated 15.03.2000, which was recorded
at 11:40 PM in PS Mangolpuri. It is mentioned that the same had already
been assigned to SI Neeraj (PW-11) who reached at the place of incident
alongwith Const. Ranbir Singh (PW-3), where he came to know that the
injured in the incident had already been removed to Sanjay Gandhi Hospital
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
by the vehicle of the PCR. He went there at Sanjay Gandhi Hospital and
found Amol, Rajesh and Shambhu admitted in the hospital, whose MLCs
no. 385, 384 & 386 respectively were obtained by SI Neeraj Kumar. Amol
was not fit for statement and, therefore, statement of Rajesh was recorded
since both Rajesh and Shambhu were fit for statement as per the medical
opinion.
2.
The statement of Rajesh (Ex. PW-2/A), recorded by SI Neeraj was
endorsed by him through the endorsement Ex. PW-11/A, which led to the
registration of the FIR (Ex. PW-1/A), under Section 308/323/341/34 of
Indian Penal Code, 1860 (‘IPC’).
3.
Since Rajesh and Shambhu had not sustained any such injuries which
required hospitalisation, therefore, SI Neeraj came back to the spot
alongwith Rajesh and Shambhu i.e. in the alley in front of H. No. K-1166,
Mangolpuri and at the instance of Rajesh, a site plan (Ex. PW-11/B) was
prepared. Statement of other injured Shambhu was also recorded and bricks,
stones and wooden pieces (phatte), which were lying there at the scene of
occurrence, were seized by SI Neeraj through memo Ex. PW-3/A and were
sealed with the seal of NK.
4.
Accused Prem Raj and his sons Krishan and Chetan Prakash were
specifically named by Rajesh Kumar, therefore, Prem Raj and Kewal
Krishan both were arrested, whereas Chetan Prakash was found to be a
juvenile. Till the investigation was underway, statement of Amol could not
be recorded since he was not only admitted in the hospital at that time, but
was in coma.
5.
Against the backdrop of these facts and circumstances, the
chargesheet was filed under Sections 308/323/341/34 IPC. Charge under
Section 308/34 IPC and 323/34 IPC was framed against accused Prem Raj
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
and Kewal Krishan.
6.
The case of the prosecution traversing through 11 witnesses and
statement of accused of Prem Raj and Kewal Krishan, resulted into
conviction of both of them under Section 308/34 IPC and 323/34 IPC
through the impugned Judgment dated 24.08.2009. Order on Sentence dated
27.08.2009, sentenced both of them to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment
(‘RI’) for a period of three years with a fine of Rs. 25,000/- each under
Section 308/34 IPC and in default of payment of fine, they were ordered to
undergo RI for nine months each, whereas under Section 323/34 IPC, both
were sentenced to undergo RI for one year with a fine of Rs. 1000/- each
and in default of which, 2½ months each RI was awarded to them.
7.
The Appellants assailed the impugned Judgment on several counts, all
of which have been enumerated by the learned counsel for the Appellants in
the written submissions filed, which primarily revolves upon the fact that the
case of the prosecution is not credible enough to hold the Appellants guilty,
inasmuch as the testimonies are full of contradictions and one of the so
called injured i.e. Rajesh has disowned the case of the prosecution and has
turned hostile. There was no motive and one of the injured i.e. Amol has not
been cited as a witness, leave alone, had their statement recorded and
examined and for that matter, one Anil has totally vanished from the scene,
though it has been stated by the witnesses/injured that he too was with them
while they were consuming liquor in H. No. 1176, Mangolpuri, where all
four i.e. Amol, Rajesh, Shambhu and Anil had gathered.
8.
Learned counsel for the Appellants has questioned the case of the
prosecution in the written submissions on 12 counts. The same are hereby
taken one by one exactly in her own words from the written submissions
filed by learned counsel for the Appellants:
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
1. Argument No.1 (Gross anomaly by prosecution):– Most pertinent
to note that Amol Jha, for whom charge u/s 308/34 IPC was
framed has not been cited as witness by the prosecution. Order
dated 24.10.2007 of trial court at page 225 records the fact.
However, judgment is silent over this aspect.
It seems that the learned counsel for the Appellants has not
cared to go through the record as in that eventuality, this argument
could not have been there at all. Amol Jha is the person, who was
hit on his head and had become unconscious. He was removed to
the hospital, initially at Sanjay Gandhi Hospital, from there to Lok
Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan Hospital and finally to Apollo Hospital
and till the chargesheet was filed, he remained Comatose,
therefore, there was no question of recording his statement or
examining him as a prosecution witness. Amol Jha remained in
coma ever since he was hit, as PW-5 Shambhu who was examined
on 05.11.2001 has expressly stated so. Dr. Mahesh Kaith examined
as PW-10 has proved his discharge summary reflecting that Amol
Jha was discharged from Apollo Hospital on 11.01.2002, but he
was still in the same vegetative state. As such, learned Trial Court
had no occasion to examine and discuss his testimony as he could
not be there as a witness in the chargesheet and not even examined
during investigation, therefore, there was no occasion to discuss
his testimony, as it was not there.
2. Argument No.2 (Motive on wrong facts):– Motive on wrong facts
wrongly arrived at the conclusion that there was tenant-The
impugned judgment has landlord dispute between the parties. As
per judgment, injured Amol Jha and Shambhu (and probably
Rajesh too) were living at House No. 1176. On the contrary, it is a
matter of record that the address of all the accused is House No.
1166, Mangol Puri (page 54). PW5 in his evidence, stated that the
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
landlord of House no. 1176 was Kalu Ram, a resident of Uttam
Nagar (Page 76). Therefore, there is no relation of tenant-landlord
between the parties and clearly cannot be a motive.
The issue of motive has been brought by the learned counsel for
the Appellants, whereas the case of the prosecution does not talk
about any motive, as it was an instant fight. In any case, one of the
victims was residing in H. No. 1176, Mangolpuri, whereas the
Appellants were there in H. No. 1166, Mangolpuri. There is no
connection with them in any capacity, apart from the fact that they
may have been neighbours. The victims/injured were tenants in H.
No. 1176, which belong to one Kalu Ram, R/o Uttam Nagar.
Therefore, there was no occasion to bring in anything like a
landlord-tenant dispute. A non-existent issue has been tried to be
introduced as a landlord-tenant dispute, but it was not there at all.
The argument is factually non-existent. In any case, the motive, in
view of the direct evidence, becomes insignificant.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in a catena of judgments has held that
the prosecution is not required to prove motive, when it relies on
testimony of a trustworthy eye witness. Reference can be made in
this context to the judgments titled as Raghunandan v. State U.P.,
(1974) 4 SCC 186, Guru Dutt Pathak v. State of U.P., (2021) 6
SCC 116 and Chandan v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2024) 6 SCC
799.
3. Argument No.3 (Contradiction from prosecution witness
themselves):– Settled legal proposition — where the prosecution
evidence is totally inconsistent with medical evidence, it amounts
to a fundamental defect in the prosecution case and unless
reasonably explained, may discredit the entire case of the
prosecution. It has been case of Prosecution throughout that the
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
three injured namely Rajesh, Shambhu and Amol Jha sustained
injuries by the accused while all the injured and all the accused
were at the Ground Floor, outside the house of the accused. Per
Contra, the Expert-opinion of PW-10 Dr. Mahesh Kaith, CMO,
Apollo Hospital, suggests that "if a full-sized brick falls from a
height of 20 ft., the injuries suffered by patient Amol Jha could be
caused in such a case" (Page 83). Ld. Sessions Judge held that eye
witness PW5 was not confronted with the expert opinion (Page
59). The settled law is that where medical evidence makes ocular
version completely improbable, conviction cannot stand safely and
the benefit necessarily goes to the accused. (Abdul Sayeed v State
of M.P.- Supreme Court on 14.9.10 in Cr. Appeal No. 1243/2007
and Gangabhavani v Rayapati Venkat Reddy & Ors.-- Supreme
Court on 04.09.13 in Cr. Appeal No. 84/2011.
4. Argument No.4:– Moreover, the Complainant Rajesh (PW2) also
got recorded in the FIR (Page 128) that as a stone hit him, he
looked up to know who had hit him, which clearly suggests that
accused were not responsible for any causing any injury to the
injured.
5. Argument No.5 (Unreliable story of prosecution):– The
Complainant, Rajesh (PW2) resiled from his early statement and
denied having seen the accused at the scene of alleged scuffle. Still
the Ld. Sessions Judge concluded that since PW2 had identified
the accused, the accused were guilty of hitting the injured. (Page
48, 49). Clearly identification of accused was very natural owing
to them being neighbours.
While relying upon the judgment in Abdul Sayeed vs. State of
M.P., (2010) 10 SCC 259 and Gangabhavani v. Rayapati Venkat
Reddy & Ors., Criminal Appeal No. 84 of 2011 and 86 of 2011, it
has been contended on behalf of the Appellants that there is a
mismatch between the ocular evidence and medical evidence to the
extent that ocular version gets totally uprooted, then in that case,
the conviction cannot be recorded against the accused on the
strength of the deposition made by the injured. However, learned
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
counsel for the Appellants is unable to point out anything, which
may belie the ocular version coming through the mouth of the
injured witness. PW-2 Rajesh Kumar has though turned hostile,
but has not denied the incident, rather stated that he too had
sustained injuries, specifically stating that while he was in the
process of starting his two wheeler scooter, he was hit by a stone
on his head in the alley in front of H. No. 1176-1177, Mangolpuri
on 15.03.2000. He has basically tried to rule out the involvement
of the Appellants since he pleaded his ignorance about the
complicity of them, rather based his knowledge on being told by
somebody from the vicinity. He, however, says that the injuries
were sustained by Shambhu and Amol also. Despite the crossexamination by learned APP, the witness PW-2 maintained his
stand as was there in the examination-in-chief.
Learned counsel for the Appellants has with the aid of
testimony of PW-2 and Dr. Mahesh Kaith, examined as PW-10,
submitted that the injuries sustained by Amol Jha was on account
of a full size brick falling on his head from a height of 20 ft. In
fact, it was a kind of suggestion given to PW-10 Dr. Mahesh
Kaith, who only opined, that such an injury could be there if a full
size brick falls on the head of the victim from a height of about 20
ft. This has been interpreted by learned counsel for the Appellants
as a true fact as a stone was in fact, thrown on injured Rajesh
examined as PW-2. However, a probability cannot take the place
of the factual position inasmuch as only Rajesh got hit by a stone
on his head, which came from somewhere, whereas rest of the
other including Amol, were thereafter, assaulted with stone and
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
wooden planks in a one to one fight. The statement of PW-2
Rajesh nowhere refers that Amol was hit on his head by some
stone or brick, which was thrown from somewhere up. If the
testimony of PW-2 is read in conjunction with the statement of
PW-5 Shambhu, then it can be clearly inferred that whatever
happened to Amol Jha or to Shambhu or for that matter to Rajesh,
was all in the fight which took place in the alley, except that one
stone that hit Rajesh, while he was starting scooter. Shambhu too
endorsed this fact that the injured Amol Jha fell unconscious and
was still in Coma, unable to speak or move when the evidence of
Shambhu was recorded on 05.11.2001, whereas the incident took
place on 15.03.2000.
The judgments relied upon by the learned counsel for the
Appellants talks about the testimony of the injured witness and a
distinction and comparison has been made between the medical
and the ocular evidence, wherein a number of authorities on the
subject were taken into consideration by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court and it was ruled that where the evidence of the witnesses of
the prosecution is totally inconsistent with the medical evidence or
the evidence of the ballistic experts, then it amounts to a
fundamental defect in the prosecution’s case, unless reasonably
explained, then the entire case of the prosecution gets dislodged.
Thus, what is important is that either medical or the technical
evidence should go hand in hand with the testimony of the
witnesses and any inconsistency, which remains unexplained and
if so drastic having the potential of totally erasing the case of the
prosecution, then in that case, the entire case of the prosecution
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
goes. Incidentally, this very judgment Abdul Sayeed’s case
(supra), while referring State of Haryana v. Bhagirath & Ors.,
(1999) 5 SCC 96, it has been observed as follows:
―Drawing on Bhagirath's case (supra.), this Court has held
that where the medical evidence is at variance with ocular
evidence, it has to be noted that it would be erroneous to
accord undue primacy to the hypothetical answers of medical
witnesses to exclude the eyewitnesses' account which had to be
tested independently and not treated as the "variable" keeping
the medical evidence as the "constant". Where the
eyewitnesses' account is found credible and trustworthy, a
medical opinion pointing to alternative possibilities can not be
accepted as conclusive. The eyewitnesses' account requires a
careful independent assessment and evaluation for its
credibility, which should not be adversely prejudged on the
basis of any other evidence, including medical evidence, as the
sole touchstone for the test of such credibility. The evidence
must be tested for its inherent consistency and the inherent
probability of the story; consistency with the account of other
witnesses held to be creditworthy; consistency with the
undisputed facts, the "credit" of the witnesses; their
performance in the witness box; their power of observation etc.
Then the probative value of such evidence becomes eligible to
be put into the scales for a cumulative evaluation.‖
Taking into account the judgment in Solanki Chimanbhai
Ukabhai v. State of Gujarat, AIR 1983 SC 484 and State of U.P. v.
Hari Chand, (2009) 13 SCC 542, it has been observed as follows:
―Thus, the position of law in cases where there is a
contradiction between medical evidence and ocular evidence
can be crystallised to the effect that though the ocular
testimony of a witness has greater evidentiary value vis-à-vis
medical evidence, when medical evidence makes the ocular
testimony improbable, that becomes a relevant factor in the
process of the evaluation of evidence. However, where the
medical evidence goes so far that it completely rules out all
possibility of the ocular evidence being true, the ocular
evidence may be disbelieved.‖
It is evident that the oral or ocular evidence can only be
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
disbelieved where the medical evidence makes it improbable.
Thus, the evidence on record has to be evaluated comprehensively
juxtaposing the medical and the ocular evidence with each other
and analysing them, but also vis-a-vis the facts of the case. If it is
found that the medical evidence and the ocular evidence are going
in different directions, then the ocular evidence can be discarded,
otherwise, testimony of the eye witnesses more particularly of the
injured cannot be thrown out on the ground of inconsistency
between it and the medical evidence.
The injured witness, whereas, has been given primacy and
importance, which aspect has also been dealt with in Abdul
Sayeed’s case (supra), wherein, it has been observed as follows:
―The question of the weight to be attached to the evidence of a
witness that was himself injured in the course of the occurrence
has been extensively discussed by this Court. Where a witness
to the occurrence has himself been injured in the incident, the
testimony of such a witness is generally considered to be very
reliable, as he is a witness that comes with a built-in guarantee
of his presence at the scene of the crime and is unlikely to
spare his actual assailant(s) in order to falsely implicate
someone. "Convincing evidence is required to discredit an
injured witness". (Vide Ramlagan Singh & Ors. v. State of
Bihar, AIR 1972 SC 2593; Malkhan Singh & Anr. v. State of
Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1975 SC 12; Machhi Singh & Ors. v.
State of Punjab, AIR 1983 SC 957; Appabhai & Anr. v. State
of Gujarat, AIR 1988 SC 696; Bonkya alias Bharat Shivaji
Mane & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra, (1995) 6 SCC 447;
Bhag Singh & Ors. (supra); Mohar & Anr. v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, (2002) 7 SCC 606; Dinesh Kumar v. State of
Rajasthan, (2008) 8 SCC 270; Vishnu & Ors. v. State of
Rajasthan, (2009) 10 SCC 477; Annareddy Sambasiva Reddy
& Ors. v. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 2009 SC 2261;
Balraje alias Trimbak v. State of Maharashtra, (2010) 6 SCC
673).‖
Reference can also be made to the judgments i.e. Jarnail Singh
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
v. State of Punjab, (2009) 9 SCC 719, Shivalingappa
Kallayanappa v. State of Karnataka, 1994 Supp (3) SCC 235,
State of U.P. v. Kishan Chand, (2004) 7 SCC 629 and Krishan v.
State of Haryana, (2006) 12 SCC 459.
The evidence on record especially that of PW-2 and PW-5
when gone into, would reveal that the ocular evidence is in tandem
with the medical evidence and therefore, the judgments relied upon
by the learned counsel for the Appellants for the purpose
advocated by her, is not applicable, on the contrary, it goes against
her cause.
6. Argument No.6 (Intentional omission by prosecution knowing it
to be a false case):– Intentional omission by prosecution knowing
it to be a false case--The injured Shambu (PW-5) was not
produced by the prosecution before the JJB though Complainant
Rajesh had already resiled. Resultantly, the juvenile accused was
acquitted. (page 115). The Ld. Sessions judge wrongly stated that
the JJB judgment has no bearing on the present case.
Learned counsel for the Appellants has asserted that injured
Shambhu, examined as PW-5 in these proceedings was not
examined before the Juvenile Justice Board (‘JJB’), which
according to her was an intentional omission in order to cover up
truth as it was a false case. However, the evidence on record in this
case cannot be ignored. The witness in question has been
examined in the proceedings before the learned Sessions Judge and
given the narrative, there was no occasion to infer anything
arriving in favour of the juvenile. In any case, the acquittal of the
juvenile recorded by the JJB, has no bearing on the proceedings
before the learned Trial Court as both the proceedings were
independent. Thus, this argument is brushed aside having no
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
substance in it.
7. Argument No.7 (Ignoring the credibility of witness):– It is an
admitted case that all the injured viz. Rajesh (PW-2), Shambhu
(PW-5) and Amol Jha were drunk at the time of incident (Page 75PW5, 128-FIR and 44 Judgment). Therefore, their versions lack
credibility.
Learned counsel for the Appellants has put forth the contention
that all three injured i.e. Rajesh, Shambhu and Amol Jha were
drunk at the time of incident, therefore, their version cannot be
relied upon. Because of influence of liquor, their cognitive
faculties were not working in a responsible and credible manner.
This fact, according to learned counsel for the Appellants takes
away their testimony. Learned counsel for the Appellants is correct
to the extent that they had consumed alcohol, which has been
reflected in the MLC of both Rajesh and Shambhu, but can they be
treated as drunk? It would be a far-fetched assertion unless an
opinion is there to the effect that they were drunk. The alcohol
may have played some role in the fight, but then the faculties were
not crippled by the alcohol as can be seen from the fact that in the
MLCs that per the doctor has only found smell of alcohol and has
not opined that they were drunk. Even if they were drunk, still they
cannot be assaulted in the manner in which they were without any
provocation.
8. Argument No. 8 (Ignoring another key witness):– As per the
FIR, filed on the behest of PW2 Rajesh, there was another friend of
theirs namely ANIL, who was also present and was having alcohol
with the three injured. However, Prosecution has failed to record
his version.
Learned counsel for the Appellants has tried to gain mileage out
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
of non-availability of Anil, who according to her was with the trio
Rajesh, Shambhu and Amol, while they were consuming liquor in
H. No. 1176, Mangolpuri. It seems that Anil was not found there,
was not present there during the drinking session or left the place
early inasmuch his presence at the spot has not been deposed by
anyone when the incident took place. Therefore, he was neither
joined in the investigation nor examined nor cited as a witness.
This in itself, is of no consequence. Accordingly, this argument is
also brushed aside having no substance in it.
9. Argument No.9 (No discovery of weapons of offence):– As per
Expert Opinion (page 83) the cause of injury to Amol Jha was a
full-sized brick. No such brick has been seized/produced by the
Prosecution. On the other hand, the IO allegedly seized four stones
and a wooden plank exhibited as P1-P4 and P5. However, none of
the exhibits bore any blood stains (Page 87).
10.Argument No.10 (Unreliable version of witnesses because of
lack of light at the spot of incidence):– IO Neeraj Kumar (PW11)
stated that when he reached at the spot, there was no street light
(Page 86). The situation remained the same after the 10 reached
again at the spot after visiting the hospital and therefore, he
prepared seizure memo and rough site plan in the light of the
scooter. (Page 87). PW5 also stated the same when asked to
identify the stones exhibited as Ex. P1-P4, however, he said there
was some street light in the lane (Page 75). However, the Ld.
Sessions Judge has chosen to push this aspect under the carpet.
(Page 57, 58).
Learned counsel for the Appellants has again fallen back on the
so called expert opinion of Dr. Mahesh Kaith (PW-10) and stuck to
the two lines in the cross-examination, however, it was only a
possibility, which has been stated by the doctor, whereas the eye
witnesses are there, who have not stated this fact that a brick had
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
fallen on the head of Amol Jha he, in any case, was not in a
position to say so, rather stated that he was hit by a stone on his
head when the Appellants alongwith the juvenile came down in the
street and the fight ensued, that too based upon the record.
On the other hand, the articles or so called weapons of offence
i.e. stones and wooden plank, which were seized, have the
potential and possibility of causing the kind of injury sustained by
the victim Amol Jha, which has not been ruled out. Rather, PW-10
on the basis of record says that the victim was hit on the head by a
brick. If somebody is hit on his head by a stone or a brick with
force, then the impact would be the same as has been opined by
PW-10, by a brick falling from a height of 20 ft., so it either falls
on the head from a height and gets momentum and gathers force or
the same kind of force can be there, if somebody hits anyone on
the head with a certain degree of powerful blow.
The other limb of the arguments is that no blood stains, etc.
were found on any of the stones or the wooden plank seized by the
police. It has come in the evidence that the alley where the fight
took place or alley in which the fight took place was a poorly lit
area and in these circumstances, the possibility cannot be ruled out
that all those stones/bricks, which were used could not be seized.
In any case, it is not necessary that blood would be there on the
stone or on the wooden plank. The location of the injury reflects
that the stone or the plank hit the victim from above and the blood
has a tendency to flow downwards. Therefore, it is not necessary
that the blood stains should be there on the plank or the stone in
such circumstances.
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
A poor visibility arising out of poor lighting has been put
forth by the learned counsel for the Appellants to assert that the
stones, etc., could not have been identified and thus, seizure of
those stones and wooden plank cannot be connected with the
incident. However, PW-5 has stated that there was some streetlight
in the lane indicating that it was though a poorly lit area, but not
completely dark. In any case, the nature of injuries sustained by
the victims corroborates and raises a strong possibility of the use
of wooden plank and stones, therefore, the seizure and
identification of the stone and wooden plank cannot be treated as
unreliable or inconsequential.
11.Argument No.11 (Clear lapse on the part of prosecution by not
searching the past history of the injured):– The IO Neeraj Kumar
(PW11) admitted that he did not consider it necessary to find out
the criminal record of injured Rajesh and Shambhu (Page 88).
There was no occasion with the Investigating Officer to check
the antecedents of Rajesh (PW-2) and Shambhu (PW-5), as they
were at the receiving end and not the aggressors. In any case, if
something of this nature was available, even though they may be
involved in some criminal matters, still no adverse inference can
be drawn in view of the facts of the case. This in itself would not
help the Appellants in view of what has come on record.
12.Argument No.12 (Mismatch of timings and place of incident and
arrest of Prem Raj and Kewal Krishan):– According to FIR, the
time of incidence is 11.15 p.m. (Page 128). However, as per PW5
it was 10 p.m. dated 15/03/2000 (Page 75). According to
prosecution, accused Prem Raj was arrested at his residence on
17.03.2000 and accused Kewal Krishan was arrested at his uncle's
shop on 30.05.2000, (Pages 144 and 145). The absence of any
independent witness on the same casts a deep shadow over the
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
prosecution version. The IO, PW11 could not explain away on this
aspect (Page 87). Impugned judgment disbelieved the version of
the accused that they were called to the Police Station Mangol
Puri and were arrested there on very vague reasons (Page 60 and
61).
A very feeble argument has been put forth with regard to the
time of the incident and arrest of accused Prem Raj and Kewal
Krishan coupled with the absence of independent witness to the
incident or to the arrest of the accused persons/Appellants. This
contention is bereft of any strength inasmuch as the time of
incident is by large available. It is not as material as sought to be
pointed out in view of the fact that the witnesses have deposed
about the incident took place at around 11:00 PM or so, whereas
one of them i.e. Shambhu has stated it at 10:00 PM. This itself is
not going to take away the entire incident inasmuch as the other
evidences are there in the shape of the DD entries and the MLC,
etc., from where the timings can be inferred. One of the witnesses
giving a different time, does not makes the case of the prosecution
unbelievable in view of the fact that injuries are there, that too of
such a serious nature where one of the injured may still be under
coma after about two decades, as can probably be inferred from the
discharge summary of Amol Jha Ex. PW.10-/A, the relevant part
of which is reproduced hereinunder:
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
It is pertinent to note that the victim Amol Jha was discharged
on 11.01.2002, whereas the incident took place on 15.03.2000. In
such circumstances, it is unlikely that the victim would have been
able to regain his consciousness or would be able to live a normal
life, unless some miracle had happened/or happens. He was in
Coma till the order on sentence was passed on 27.08.2009.
The absence of independent public witness is inconsequential
so far as the incident is concerned, inasmuch as it took place at
around 11:00 PM and finding anybody at that time is unlikely and
then again the tendency of the general public to be not part of the
proceedings relating to the police or the courts on account of the
perceived harassment which normally deters general public. In
any case, there is no reason to disbelieve the injured and that
absence of the independent public witness is thus, immaterial and
nugatory. And so is the position in respect of arrest of Appellants.
No public witness being a part of arrest of Appellants, is of no
consequence.
9.
In view of the foregoing discussion, learned counsel for the
Appellants is unable to carve out a case in favour of the Appellants or to
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
point out any flaw in the impugned judgment so as to intervene in the
findings recorded by the learned Trial Court against the Appellants. As a
result, the judgment of conviction is upheld.
10.
On the aspect of sentence, nothing much has been argued by learned
counsel for the Appellants, however, the sentence awarded to the Appellants
cannot be treated as commensurate to what has been done by them. The
Order on Sentence dated 27.08.2009 itself reflects that the victim Amol Jha
was still in a vegetative state. The incident pertains to the year 2000 and the
situation vis-à-vis Amol Jha remains unaltered for about nine years. There is
no word thereafter as to what has happened to him, but irrespective of what
happened after 2009, what has been undergone by the victim Amol Jha and
his family for the last nine years, cannot be ignored and is very difficult to
visualise. Day to day life, leave alone a normal life, must have been a
harrowing experience. In such circumstances, the Appellants do not deserve
any lenience. There was no notice for enhancement of sentence given to the
Appellants and there were no arguments either. As a result, the sentence
awarded to them is also maintained.
11.
As a result, the appeal stands dismissed bereft of any substance.
12.
Appellants be called upon to surrender forthwith to undergo the
remaining sentence. Needless to say that they shall be entitled to the benefit
of set off under Section 428 Cr.P.C.
13.
Copy of the judgment be transmitted to the learned Trial Court and
Prison Authorities for information and necessary compliance.
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J
AUGUST 17, 2026/akc/ij
Signed By:ASHOK
KUMAR CHOUHAN
16:04:44
CRL.A. 695/2009
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review