Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1( 2026:HHC:12179 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No.594 of 2025
Reserved on 30.3.2026
Date of Decision : 17.04.2026
Prem Nath
...Petitioner
Versus
Naresh Kumar Jain & anr.
...Respondents
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma. Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner
: Mr. Neeraj Gupta, Sr. Advocate with Mr.
Ajeet Pal Singh Jaswal, Advocate.
For the respondents : Mr. Rajesh Mandhotra, Advocate.
Romesh Verma, Judge
The present petition arises out of the order as
passed by the learned Civil Judge, Court No.1 Dharamshala,
District Kangra, H.P., whereby the application filed by the
plaintiff/petitioner under Order XXVI Rule 9 read with Section
151 C.P.C for appointment of the Local Commissioner has been
ordered to be dismissed.
2.
The facts of the case are that the present
petitioner/plaintiff has filed a suit in the Court of learned Civil
Judge, Court No.1, Dharmshala, District Kangra, H.P. for
permanent prohibitory injunction restraining the defendants,
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2( 2026:HHC:12179 )
their
family members, friends and servants etc. from
interfering, collecting material, raising any construction and
changing the nature of the land comprised in Khata No. 353
min, Khatauni No. 767 min. , Khasra No. 722 area measuring
0-00-84 hectares of Up Mohal Lehsar, Mauza Yol, Tehsil,
Dharamshala, District Kangra, H.P. in any manner with further
prayer that mandatory injunction be passed in favour of the
plaintiff, in case the defendants succeeded in raising the
construction over the suit land during the pendency of the said
suit.
3.
It has been averred in the plaint that the plaintiff is
co-owner in possession of the land bearing Khasra No. 723. It
has further been averred that the respondents/ defendants are
owners in possession of the land bearing Khasra No. 2028/687
and 2029/687 in Up Mohal Lehsar, Mauza Yol, Tehsil
Dharamshala, District Kangra. In between the land of the
plaintiff and the defendants, there exists a Kuhl over the land
entered in Khata No. 353 min, Khatouni No. 767 min, Khasra No.
722, measuring
00-00-84 of Up Mohal Lehsar, Mauza Yol,
Tehsil Dharamshala, District Kangra, H.P . The plaintiff and
other residents of the area are using the Kuhl and there also
exist a passage on the sides of the Kuhl. The defendants have
3( 2026:HHC:12179 )
got no right, title or interest over the suit land bearing Khasra
No. 722. The defendants are threatening to trespass over the
suit land and they are trying to invade the rights of plaintiff
and other residents of the locality. Therefore, it was prayed that
decree for permanent prohibitory injunction be passed against
the defendants, their family members, friends, servants etc.
from interfering, collecting material raising any construction
changing the nature of the suit land bearing Khasra No. 722
with further prayer for mandatory injunction against the
defendants.
4.
The
defendants/respondents
filed
the
written
statement and raised preliminary objections with regard to
maintainability, locus standi, cause of action, limitation, non
joinder of necessary parties, etc. It was averred in the written
statement that the land of the plaintiff is situated on one side of
the Kuhl i.e in Khasra No. 722 and the land of the defendants is
on the other side. Further it has been stated that land bearing
Khasra No. 722 is not owned and possessed by the plaintiff. The
averments with respect to encroachment over Khasra No.722
were denied and it was stated that defendants sought a
demarcation of the land bearing Khasra No. 2028/687 and
2029/687 from the revenue authorities and as per the
4( 2026:HHC:12179 )
demarcation of the land, the construction was found to have
raised on the land owned and possessed by the defendants.
Therefore, the defendants prayed for dismissal of the suit filed
by the plaintiff.
5.
The plaintiff filed a replication to the written
statement and all the averments as made in the plaint were
reiterated.
6.
The case file reveals that on 20.05.2014, an
application under Order XXVI Rule 9 read with Section 151 C.P.C
for the appointment of the Local Commissioner was filed by the
present petitioner/ plaintiff. The said application was duly
contested by the defendants and the learned trial Court vide its
Order dated 05.12.2014, dismissed the said application.
7.
The issues were framed by the learned trial Court
on 11.08.2016.
8.
The
plaintiff/petitioner
again
filed
a
fresh
application for the appointment of the Local Commissioner
under the provisions of Order XXVI Rule 9 read with Section 151
C.P.C on 10.05.2024. It was averred in the application that
defendants/respondents have raised construction over the
portion of the suit land bearing Khasra No. 722 despite being
well aware of the injunction order passed by the Court and
5( 2026:HHC:12179 )
further encroached over the portion of the suit land/Kuhl
during the pendency of the Civil Suit in complete violation of
the injunction orders passed by the Court. Further it was
averred that the defendants further got conducted unilateral
demarcation of the land owned by him without arraying the
plaintiff
and other adjacent land owners, which
is not in
accordance with law. Therefore, it was prayed that the Local
Commissioner
be
appointed
and
local
investigation
/demarcation be ordered to be carried out to ascertain the
construction carried out and encroachment made by the
defendants, if any.
9.
The said application has been resisted by the
respondents/defendants and it has been averred that the
respondents did not raise any construction over Khasra No. 722
and in fact they have raised construction only on the land
owned and possessed by them and not beyond their land and
they did not encroach Khasra Number 722 in any manner.
Further it has been stated that land has been demarcated as per
the provisions of law by arraying of the stake holders.
10.
The learned trial Court vide its impugned order
dated 23.06.2025 dismissed the application under Order XXVI
Rule 9 C.P.C as filed by the plaintiff/petitioner.
6( 2026:HHC:12179 )
11.
Feeling dissatisfied, the plaintiff/petitioner has
approached this Court by assailing the impugned order.
12.
It is contended by Sh. Neeraj Gupta, learned Sr.
Advocate, assisted by Mr. Ajeet Pal Singh Jaswal, Advocate that
the impugned order as passed by the learned trial Court is bad in
the eyes of law and the same is not sustainable. He has further
submitted that the provisions of Order XXVI Rule 9 C.P.C have
not been interpreted by the learned trial Court legally and the
Court below ought to have allowed the application for the
demarcation of the suit land in order to resolve the issue once
for all.
13.
On
the
other
hand,
Sh.
Rajesh
Mandhotra,
Advocate, learned counsel for the defendants/respondents has
defended
the impugned order and has submitted that the
plaintiff/petitioner has approached the Court for grant of relief
of injunction and mandatory injunction and in order to prove
his case, it is for the plaintiff to establish the case of
encroachment if any, by the defendants.
He has further
submitted that the learned trial Court had framed the issues in
the matter on 11.08.2016 and issues with respect to relief of
permanent prohibitory injunction and mandatory injunction,
7( 2026:HHC:12179 )
onus is upon the plaintiff and it is for him to establish his case
beyond the reasonable doubt.
14.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and
have gone through the record of the case file carefully.
15.
The primary dispute in the present case is with
respect to appointment of the Local Commissioner. The
plaintiff has filed a Civil Suit before the learned trial Court on
the ground that he is owner in possession of Khasra No 723 and
the defendants are owners in possession of Khasra No.
2028/687, and 2029/687 in Up Mohal Lehsar, Mauza Yol, Tehsil
Dharamshala, District Kangra, H.P.
16.
It is the case of the parties that between the land of
the plaintiff and defendants, there exists a Kuhl over the land
comprised in Khasra No. 722. It is contended by the plaintiff
that the defendants are threatening to trespass the suit land
bearing Khasra No. 722 and are trying to invade upon the rights
of the plaintiff and other residents.
17.
The plaintiff in order to prove his case has to lead
evidence and in support of his contention, he has to establish
that there is any kind of encroachment by the defendants over
the suit land i.e Khasra No. 722.
8( 2026:HHC:12179 )
18.
The perusal of the case file reveals that (at page 57),
DW 2 Sh. Roshan Lal, Revenue Officer in his cross examination
in chief has stated that the Kuhl is shown in the ownership of
the State of H.P.
19.
As rightly pointed out by Sh. Rajesh Mandhotra,
learned counsel for the defendants that Khasra No. 722 is owned
by the State of H.P. and in the absence of the State, no relief in
the present application can be granted to the plaintiff. Though
the plaintiff has failed to establish any kind of encroachment
for the determination of the application in question yet for the
sake of arguments, in case there is any interference by the
defendants, in that event, the affected party is State of H.P. The
plaintiff is alleging interference and encroachment over Khasra
No.722, being owned by the State, on behalf of the defendants,
however, the plaintiff has failed to establish any right over the
same.
It is a basic principle of law that a person, who
alleges has to prove his case but allegations of interference and
encroachment after the passing of the injunction order has been
levelled and raised by the plaintiff, therefore, it is incumbent
upon the plaintiff to substantiate his case by leading and
placing on record material documents. The plaintiff cannot take
9( 2026:HHC:12179 )
an aid of the Court to collect evidence in order to corroborate his
case. It has neither been pleaded nor proved by the plaintiff that
any efforts were made by him to invoke the authority of the
Revenue Department or that any steps were taken to demarcate
the suit land. There is no due diligence on the part of the
plaintiff and the Court will not come to the aid of the plaintiff in
order to prove the alleged case.
The learned trial Court has rightly come to the
conclusion that provisions of Order XXVI Rule 9 C.P.C cannot be
invoked in order to collect the evidence to prove the alleged
facts. The application for the Local Commissioner cannot be
allowed in a routine manner and the same can be allowed only
in those cases, which are bonafide for the determination of the
controversy in question. Merely, on asking of the parties, the
Local Commissioner cannot be appointed. It would be the
provisions of Order XXVI Rule 9 C.P.C., read as follows:
“Commissions to make local investigations.—In
any suit in which the Court deems a local
investigation to be requisite or proper for the
purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or of
ascertaining the market-value of any property, or
the amount of any mesne profits or damages or
annual net profits, the Court may issue a
commission to such person as it thinks fit directing
him to make such investigation and to report
thereon to the Court:
Provided that, where the State Government has
made rules as to the persons to whom such
10( 2026:HHC:12179 )
commission shall be issued, the Court shall be
bound by such rules.”
22.
The plaintiff/petitioner has to stand on his own
legs by adducing independent and reliable evidence and he
cannot invoke the provisions of Order XXVI Rule 9 C.P.C and call
upon the Court to generate evidence for him. Therefore, in the
opinion of this Court, there is no error in the impugned order
passed by the learned trial Court .
Learned counsel for the respondents has relied
upon the judgment in Diwakar Dutt Shastri vs. Ranjit Singh
1997 (1)
SLJ 242, whereby it has been laid down that the
Courts cannot be held to be Local Commissioner in a suit based
on encroachment and the Court cannot grant evidence in favour
of the party . It was observed as under:
4.
It is too well-known that the Court is
not expected to create evidence forany of the
parties to the lis. It is for the plaintiff to prove
that the defendant has encroached upon his
land and this he can do so by leading evidence
as is permissible under the Evidence Act. The
learned trial Court has held that no case has
been made out for the appointment of Local
Commissioner to demarcate the suit land and
in my considered view, the order does not
suffer from any illegality, irregularity or error
of jurisdiction. Even otherwise, the order
would not amount to a case decided so as to
call for interference under Section 115 of the
11( 2026:HHC:12179 )
Civil Procedure Code. I am supported in my
view by a Division Bench judgment of Punjab
and Haryana High Court reported in 1990(2)
S.L.J. 636 (Pritam Singh and another vs.
Sunder Lal and others). There is, thus, no
merit in this revision petition and the same is
hereby ordered to be dismissed. No costs.”
Similarly, it was held in CMPMO No. 208 of 2019,
titled as Naseeb Deen and another versus Harnek Singh,
decided on 19.7.2019 that the onus is upon the plaintiff to prove
the encroachment and when there is no evidence that the
plaintiff had approached the revenue authority for the
demarcation of the suit land, it is not permissible to appoint the
Local Commissioner to demarcate the suit land.
In the present case, there is also no material on
record to demonstrate that the plaintiff at any stage has
approached the revenue authority for demarcation of
the
land in issue.
Therefore,
filing of the
by
the
but obvious
is
his
and this important aspect of the
plaintiff
evidence
in
favour
an attempt
application
to
create
matter has righty been taken into consideration by the learned
trial court.
26.
The said exposition of law has been reiterated in
CMPMO No. 272 of 2019 titled as Ram Nath & another vs.
12( 2026:HHC:12179 )
Kuldeep Singh & others, decided on dated 25.06.2019. Relevant
portion of the judgment reads as under:
“14. Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code inter alia provides that
in any suit in which the Court deems a local investigation
to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating
any matter in dispute, the Court may issue a commission
to such person as it thinks fit directing him to such
investigation and to report thereon to the Court.
15. In my considered view, primarily whenever any order
is passed, under Rule 9 of Order 26 of the Code, the
satisfaction has to be of the Court as to whether local
investigation for the purpose of elucidating any matter in
dispute is necessary or not. This satisfaction cannot be of
the plaintiffs or defendants. The plaintiff or the
defendant has to stand on its own legs and provisions of
Order 26, Rule 9 of the Code cannot be used to garner or
gather evidence for them through the Court process. This
is exactly what has been held by the learned Court below
by way of the impugned order. Learned Court has held
and rightly so that onus is upon the plaintiffs to prove
their case and the Court cannot lend a helping hand and
assist the plaintiffs to prove their case. These findings
returned by the learned Court below cannot be said to be
illegal as they are in consonance with the spirit of law
with regard to the interpretation of Order 26, Rule 9 of
the Civil Procedure Code. Plaintiffs cannot be permitted to
a local commissioner appointed simply because they have
not been able to lead cogent evidence to prove their case.
That is not the intent of Order 26, rule 9 of the Code”.
13( 2026:HHC:12179 )
From a perusal of the same, it is clear that Order
XXVI Rule 9 CPC is not a panacea that can be used by litigants as
a tool whenever they feel that they are not in a position to prove
their case.
28.
A similar view was taken in
CMPMO No. 195 of
2024, dated 19.06.2024, wherein it was observed.
“5. Having gone through the order passed by
the learned Court below and having heard
learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
petitioner/plaintiff as also learned Counsel for
the respondent/defendant, this Court does not
find any perversity in the impugned order.
When it is a matter of record that the petitioner
had sought amendment in the suit on the
ground that during the pendency of the suit,
certain part of the suit land stood encroached
by the defendant, this pre-supposes that the
petitioner was aware of his boundaries and
only thereafter, he levelled allegations against
the respondent of encroaching upon his land.
In this background, but natural, the petitioner
cannot be permitted to call upon the Court by
way of appointment of a Local Commissioner
to create evidence to prove his allegation as to
whether part of the suit land mentioned in the
application filed under Order 26, Rule 9 of the
Code of Civil Procedure stood encroached upon
by the defendant or not.”
14( 2026:HHC:12179 )
19. In the present case, the plaintiff had come
with a specific case that the defendants had
encroached upon the suit land and had
constructed a road on the same; therefore, the
burden was upon the plaintiff to establish this
fact and the learned Trial Court had rightly
held that recourse cannot be had to the Local
Commissioner to determine the nature and
extent of the encroachment. The discretion to
decline
the
appointment
of
a
Local
Commissioner was properly exercised and no
interference is required with the same.
Therefore, to prove and establish the case, the
burden is upon the plaintiff/petitioner and the learned trial
court has rightly held that the recourse cannot be held to the
Local Commissioner to determine the nature and extent of the
encroachment. There is no jurisdictional error on the part of
the learned trial Court, Therefore, the present petition being
devoid of any merit deserves to be dismissed.
30.
Ordered accordingly.
Petition stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
17.04.2026 (veena)
(Romesh Verma),
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review