Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 10899/2018, CM APPL. 42512/2018 & CM APPL.
46947/2018
PREETI MATHUR
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Deeptakirti Verma & Ms. Neha
Sharma, Advocate.
versus
DIRECTORATE OF EDUCATION
.....Respondent
Through: Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, SC, GNCTD
with Mr. N. K. Singh, Ms. Aliza
Alam & Mr. Mohnish Sehrawat,
Advocates for R-1 to 5.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
09.02.2026
%
1.
This petition concerns disciplinary proceedings initiated against the
Petitioner, who is working as PGT (Political Science) at SRSD Senior
Secondary School. The Petitioner was initially appointed as PGT (Political
Science) in 1999 and, in 2008, was asked to discharge duties as Officiating
Principal. During the period 2013-2014, the school was taken over by the
Directorate of Education (“DoE”), pursuant to which the Petitioner reverted
to the post of PGT (Political Science).
2.
The case of the Petitioner is that between 2015 and 2017 she
submitted
several
complaints
to
departmental
authorities
alleging
administrative and financial irregularities committed by Ms. Sadhna Mittal,
who had been appointed as Authorised Officer by the DoE. According to the
W.P.(C) 10899/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:06:27
Petitioner, no action was taken on those complaints, compelling her to
escalate the matter by a complaint dated 27th February, 2017 addressed to
various authorities, including the Central Vigilance Commission (“CVC”).
3.
On 18th August, 2017, an Office Memorandum was issued to the
Secretary (Vigilance), GNCTD indicating that the complaint warranted
investigation. Shortly thereafter, a memorandum dated 9 th March, 2018 was
served upon the Petitioner, purportedly initiating disciplinary enquiry
proceedings. By a further order dated 20th April, 2018, Mr. K.C. Arora,
Education officer (Retd.), was appointed as the Inquiry Officer.
4.
The Petitioner challenges the aforesaid actions primarily on the
ground that the Disciplinary Action Committee (“DAC”) which initiated the
proceedings was not constituted in accordance with Rule 118 of the Delhi
School Education Rules, 19731 and that the proceedings are vitiated by bias.
5.
This Court, vide order dated 19th November, 2018, stayed the
operation of the memorandum dated 9th March, 2018 and the order dated
20th April, 2018 appointing the Enquiry Officer.
6.
Mr. Deeptakirti Verma, counsel for the Petitioner, raises two principal
objections. First, the DAC itself was unlawfully constituted, as the
impugned proceedings describe the Chairperson as “DDE (South East)
A&PS” and also refer to “DDE (Zone-25) A&PS” as the Director’s nominee,
which are not identifiable posts in the Directorate’s administrative structure
and do not appear in the departmental directory, thereby rendering the
initiation of proceedings without jurisdiction. Second, the DAC included a
Teacher Representative, Ms. Mamta Joshi, who is an accused in FIR No.
167/2011 dated 30th April, 2011, registered at P.S. Amar Colony, Delhi,
W.P.(C) 10899/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:06:27
which was lodged at the instance of the Petitioner in relation to an incident
dated 25th April, 2011, and her participation gives rise to a manifest and
reasonable apprehension of bias vitiating the proceedings at inception.
7.
On the other hand, Mrs. Avnish Ahlawat, Standing Counsel for the
Respondent, contests the maintainability of the petition, submitting that
ordinarily writ jurisdiction is not invoked to interdict disciplinary
proceedings at a preliminary stage and the Petitioner has an adequate
opportunity to respond before the enquiry authority.
8.
On the question of constitution of the DAC, the Respondent contends
that the designation “DDE (South East) A&PS” refers to a designated post
dealing with aided and unaided private schools in the district, and place
reliance on an office order dated 7th September, 2017 whereby Ms. Usha
Chaturvedi was posted as Deputy Director of Education (Aided and UnAided) and entrusted with such charge. However, beyond this, the Counter
Affidavit does not clarify the status, designation or authority referable to
“DDE (Zone-25) A&PS” described as the Director’s nominee. Further, the
response is conspicuously silent on the Petitioner’s specific plea regarding
the inclusion of Ms. Mamta Joshi and the criminal proceedings alleged
against her.
Analysis
9.
The scope of judicial review at the stage of a memorandum/charge-
sheet or memorandum is limited. The Supreme Court in Union of India &
Anr. v. Kunisetty Satyanarayana2 has cautioned that a charge-sheet
ordinarily does not give rise to a cause of action and that premature
“DSE Rules”
(2006) 12 SCC 28.
W.P.(C) 10899/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:06:27
interference would convert writ jurisdiction into a forum for stalling
disciplinary proceedings. Interference at this stage is therefore confined to
rare and exceptional situations, such as where the action is wholly without
jurisdiction or otherwise wholly illegal.
10.
On this touchstone, the Court is not persuaded to enter the merits of
the Petitioner’s narrative that the impugned proceedings reflect bias or are a
counterblast to her vigilance complaints. Those assertions traverse disputed
questions of motive and factual causation and would require examination of
chronology, internal correspondence and the evidentiary basis of the
proposed charges, an exercise neither appropriate nor necessary at this
incipient stage. The disciplinary process itself provides the forum to test the
allegations, the defence and surrounding circumstances. The Petitioner
remains at liberty to raise all available defences, including the plea of
victimisation or mala fides, before the competent authority and, if occasion
arises, to challenge any final adverse decision in accordance with law.
11.
The petition, however, does raise a more foundational concern. The
question is not whether the charges are correct, but whether the machinery
that set the disciplinary process in motion was legally constituted and free
from disqualifying bias. These issues do not belong to the realm of factual
defence; they go to the legality of the process itself and therefore fall within
the limited grounds on which judicial review at this stage remains
permissible.
12.
Rule 118 of the DSE Rules contemplates a specific disciplinary
framework, including a committee structure for major disciplinary decisions.
When a rule prescribes who must sit in judgment, the identity and authority
of those members cannot remain uncertain or inferential. The Respondent
W.P.(C) 10899/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:06:27
seeks to justify the description “DDE (South East) A&PS” by placing
reliance upon an office order dated 7th September, 2017, assigning Ms. Usha
Chaturvedi the charge relating to aided and unaided private schools within
the South-East district. That material may answer the Petitioner’s objection
in part, provided it is shown that the assignment preceded the memorandum
dated 9th March, 2018 and continued to subsist on the said date. The legality
of initiation cannot rest upon a subsequent arrangement or retrospective
explanation.
13.
The difficulty, however, arises in relation to the second designation,
“DDE (Zone-25) A&PS”, described as the Director’s nominee. The Counter
Affidavit does not disclose the administrative basis of such designation, the
officer holding that office on the relevant date, or the authority under which
such person acted as the Director’s nominee. In the absence of a clear and
verifiable explanation, the Court is unable to treat the constitution of the
DAC as unexceptionable.
14.
The Petitioner’s plea regarding Ms. Mamta Joshi stands on a different
plane. The Petitioner asserts that she is an accused in criminal proceedings
instituted at the Petitioner’s instance relating to an incident dated 25 th April,
2011. This assertion has not been controverted in the response. Nor is any
explanation offered as to why, out of the available teachers, a person facing
criminal proceedings at the instance of the delinquent employee was chosen
as the Teacher Representative on the DAC.
15.
The principle is elementary: justice must not only be done but must be
seen to be done. The test is not proof of actual prejudice; it is whether the
circumstances give rise to a reasonable apprehension in the mind of a fairminded observer that the decision-maker may not bring an impartial mind to
W.P.(C) 10899/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:06:27
the task.3 On the Petitioner’s unrebutted averments, the inclusion of Ms.
Mamta Joshi in a body that triggers and supervises disciplinary action
against the Petitioner fails this test and taints the proceedings at inception.
16.
In these circumstances, the Court is satisfied that the Petitioner has
made out a case for limited interference, confined to curing the foundational
infirmity in the constitution of the DAC and removing the reasonable
apprehension of bias. Beyond that, this Court does not express any view on
the merits of the allegations against the Petitioner or on the Petitioner’s
allegations against departmental officers. Those issues remain open.
17.
The writ petition is partly allowed in the following terms:
17.1. The order dated 20th April, 2018 appointing the Enquiry Officer is set
aside.
17.2. The Respondent shall reconstitute the DAC strictly in accordance
with Rule 118 of the DSE Rules, ensuring that each member is identifiable,
duly authorised, and free from any circumstance giving rise to a reasonable
apprehension of bias.
17.3. Ms. Mamta Joshi shall not form part of any DAC constituted in
relation to the Petitioner, having regard to the evident adversarial backdrop
between the Petitioner and the said person, which gives rise to a legitimate
and reasonable apprehension of bias.
17.4. If the Respondent proposes to include Ms. Usha Chaturvedi in the
capacity of Deputy Director of Education dealing with Aided and Un-Aided
Private Schools for South-East District, such inclusion shall be subject to the
Respondent placing on record the order by which she was entrusted with
that charge and demonstrating that the said entrustment existed prior to, and
See: Kumaon Mandal Vikas Nigam Ltd. v. Girja Shankar Pant & Ors. (2001) 1 SCC 182.
W.P.(C) 10899/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:06:27
was subsisting on, 9th March, 2018, which is the date of the impugned
memorandum. Failing such disclosure and confirmation, Ms. Usha
Chaturvedi shall not be shown as part of the Committee in that capacity and
the Respondent shall nominate the competent officer in accordance with
Rule 118 of the DSE Rules.
17.5 The reconstituted DAC shall reconsider the matter afresh and take an
independent decision, in accordance with law, on whether any disciplinary
proceedings are required to be initiated/continued against the Petitioner. If
the DAC forms the view that proceedings are warranted, it shall proceed
from the stage permissible in law, in a manner consistent with the applicable
rules.
18.
The interim stay granted earlier shall stand modified to the extent
indicated above. It is clarified that this Court has not adjudicated upon the
substance of the allegations against the Petitioner, and all rights and
contentions on merits are expressly left open.
19.
The petition and pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of in
the above terms.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
FEBRUARY 9, 2026/hc
W.P.(C) 10899/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 13/02/2026 at 11:06:27
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review