Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 05th February, 2026
Pronounced on: 16thJune, 2026
+
RFA 646/2024
PRAVEEN MALIK
S/o Shri Ramesh C. Malik
R/o A-81/3, DDA Flats, SFS, Saket,
New Delhi -110017
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. S.C. Anand Advocate.
versus
AITHENT TECHNOLOGIES PVT. LTD.
Through its Chief Executive Officer,
A-186, Okhla Industrial Area, Phase-I,
New Delhi-110020.
.....Respondent
Through: Ms. Venancio D'Costa and Ms. Gauri
Goel, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order
XLI of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as
“CPC”) has been preferred by the Appellant/Plaintiff, Praveen Malik,
assailing the Judgment and Decree dated 28.03.2024, whereby the Suit for
Recovery of Rs.6,14,220/- filed by the Appellant/Plaintiff has been partly
decreed by the learned District Judge, Delhi.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
2.
The Appellant/Plaintiff instituted CS DJ No.257/2016 seeking
recovery of Rs.6,14,220/- along with interest.
3.
Briefly stated, the case of the Appellant/Plaintiff was that he joined
the services of the Respondent Company on 01.02.1996 and continued in
employment till 14.04.2004. At the time of his resignation, he was serving
as a Project Manager and was drawing a gross monthly salary of Rs.59,000/4.
During the financial year 2002-2003, the Respondent Company faced
financial difficulties on account of substantial investments in infrastructure
and delayed payments from its overseas affiliated entities. Consequently, in
March 2002, the Defendant Company decided to defer a portion of the
salaries payable to employees drawing salaries above Rs.12,000/- per month
for the financial year 2002-2003 on a graded scale of 15%, 20%, 25% and
30% depending upon the salary range. The employees were also promised
one month’s salary as bonus compensation, to offset the financial hardship
occasioned by the deferment of salaries. The deferred salary was to be paid
on 01.04.2003.
5.
The deferment was implemented on a graded scale and since the
Appellant/Plaintiff was drawing a gross salary of Rs.59,000/- per month, his
salary was reduced by 25%, resulting in deferment of Rs.14,750/- per month
from April 2002 till March 2003.
6.
The Appellant/Plaintiff stated that during an Open House Meeting
held on 09.08.2002, the Management announced restoration of salaries of
certain employees belonging to the lowest salary group of Rs.12,001/- to
Rs.20,000/- per month and assured that the cases of other employees would
also be reviewed and their deferred salaries would be released.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
7.
As per the Appellant/Plaintiff, the said announcement had been made
with the approval of the CEO of the Defendant Company, who had sent an
e-mail dated 09.07.2002 to Mr. Raju Ahluwalia, with copies to Mr. Ajay
Malik and Mr. Sunil Vadhera regarding the preponement of the decision to
restore salaries to the earlier levels.
8.
While the original salary of the Appellant/Plaintiff of Rs.59,000/-
stood restored with effect from 01.04.2003, the management sought more
time to pay the arrears of the deferred salary along with the compensation
bonus. However, payment of the deferred salary and compensation bonus
continued to be postponed despite repeated requests.
9.
The Appellant/Plaintiff relied upon e-mails dated 17.12.2004 and
28.12.2004 addressed to the CEO of the Respondent Company seeking
release of his pending dues. The CEO is stated to have responded that efforts
would be made to ensure that funds were released at the earliest.
10.
The Appellant/Plaintiff further sent an e-mail dated 21.02.2006
demanding payment of his dues by 10.03.2006. However, no payment was
made.
11.
The Appellant/Plaintiff thereafter visited the office of the Respondent
Company at Okhla on 21.03.2006 to obtain his salary certificate. However,
according to the Appellant/Plaintiff, he was informed that the Respondent
Company had no plans to release his dues.
12.
The Plaintiff claimed the deferred component of salary aggregating
to Rs.1,77,000/-, agreed to be paid on 01.04.2003.
13.
The Appellant/Plaintiff further asserted that, as per the policy of
deferment, he was entitled to one month’s gross salary of Rs.59,000/- as
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
compensation bonus. Accordingly, a total amount of Rs.2,36,000/- became
due and payable to him as on 01.04.2003.
14.
The Appellant/Plaintiff also claimed that, on the date of his
resignation, a further amount of Rs.2,38,198/- became due towards salary,
HRA, reimbursement, leave encashment and gratuity.
15.
Consequently, the Appellant/Plaintiff instituted the Suit for recovery
of Rs.6,14,220/- together with interest.
16.
The Defendant/Respondent Company, in its Written Statement, raised
a preliminary objection regarding territorial jurisdiction and contended that
the employment of the Appellant/Plaintiff was at Gurgaon and therefore, the
Courts at Gurgaon alone had the jurisdiction.
17.
On merits, it was contended that there was no deferment of salary and
that the salaries of employees had merely been restructured, in view of the
prevailing business circumstances.
18.
It was contended that the salary structure had been revised and
accepted by the Appellant/Plaintiff and that there was no agreement for
payment of any deferred salary at a later date. The Respondent Company
denied that any amount was due and payable to the Appellant/Plaintiff, on
account of deferred salary or compensation bonus.
19.
The Respondent Company admitted that discussions had taken place
regarding payment of one month's salary as a loyalty bonus, but asserted
that the same was merely a moral incentive and not a legal commitment.
20.
The Respondent Company further relied upon the Letter dated
01.04.2002 issued to the Appellant/Plaintiff, regarding restructuring of
salary which had been duly accepted by him.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
21.
It was further stated that the salaries of the employees belonging to
the lowest salary group, were restored with effect from 01.08.2002 and not
from 01.10.2002 as alleged by the Appellant/Plaintiff. It was also contended
that salaries of the remaining employees, were restored with effect from
01.04.2003.
22.
The Respondent Company denied that any amount remained due and
payable to the Appellant/Plaintiff towards deferred salary or compensation
bonus and prayed for dismissal of the Suit.
23.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial Court
framed the following Issues on 25.01.2007:
“1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the recovery of Rs.
6,14,220/- from the defendant as prayed for? OPP
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the interest pendent
lite and future? If yes, then at what rate? OPD
3. Relief.”
24.
The Appellant/Plaintiff examined himself as PW-1 and tendered his
evidence by way of affidavit Ex. PW-1/A. He relied upon the service
certificate dated 14.04.2004 Ex. PW-1/1, salary certificate dated 21.03.2006
Ex. PW-1/2, salary slips Ex. PW-1/3 and Ex. PW-1/9 to Ex. PW-1/17,
appointment letters issued by subsequent employers Ex. PW-1/4 to Ex. PW1/8, copies of Form-16 for the relevant financial years Mark PW-1/A to
Mark PW-1/D, e-mails exchanged with the Respondent Company Ex. PW1/22 (Colly), letter dated 01.04.2005 issued by the CEO of the Respondent
Company Ex. PW-1/23 and the legal notice and postal receipts Ex. PW-1/24
to Ex. PW-1/27.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
25.
PW-2, Shri Sunil Vadhera, former Director and Head of India
Operations of the Respondent Company, tendered his affidavit Ex. PW-2/A
and supported the case of the Appellant/Plaintiff regarding deferment of
salaries during the financial year 2002-2003. He further relied upon the
certified
copy
of
the
e-mail
dated
09.07.2002
and
connected
correspondence, which was exhibited as Ex. PW-2/1.
26.
DW-1, Shri Bunty Bisht, Manager of the Defendant Company,
reiterated the stand taken in the Written Statement and denied existence of
any agreement regarding deferred salary. He, however, stated that an amount
of Rs.2,03,986/- had been offered by the Defendant Company to the
Appellant/Plaintiff towards full and final settlement of his dues, but was
refused by him.
27.
The learned Trial Court, upon appreciation of the evidence led by
the parties, concluded that the Appellant/Plaintiff had failed to establish any
contractual arrangement whereby the reduced component of salary was to be
repaid at a later date or that one month's salary was contractually payable, as
bonus. However, the learned Trial Court held that an amount of
Rs.2,38,198/- was payable to the Appellant/Plaintiff towards salary, HRA,
reimbursement, leave encashment and gratuity.
28.
Accordingly, the Respondent Company was directed to pay
Rs.2,38,198/- along with interest and the Suit was partly decreed vide
Judgment and Decree dated 28.03.2024.
29.
Aggrieved by the Judgment dated 28.03.2024 insofar as it rejects the
claim towards deferred salary and compensation bonus, the present Appeal
has been preferred by the Appellant/Plaintiff.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
30.
The grounds of challengeis that the learned Trial Court failed to
appreciate that the e-mail dated 09.07.2002 and the connected e-mail
correspondence, consistently used the expression “Deferred Salary” and
constituted the best evidence regarding the nature of the arrangement
between the parties.
31.
It is further contended that the learned Trial Court erred in relying
upon principles relating to Board Resolutions and authority of Directors,
while overlooking that the present dispute concerned the liability of the
Respondent Company, arising out of commitments allegedly made to its
employees.
32.
It is further submitted that the communication issued by the CEO of
the Respondent Company promising payment of dues together with interest,
was sufficient acknowledgment of the liability of the Respondent
Company.It is, therefore, contended that the learned Trial Court erred in
rejecting the claim towards deferred salary amounting to Rs.1,77,000/- and
one month's compensation bonus amounting to Rs.59,000/-.
33.
The Appellant has accordingly prayed that the impugned Judgment
and Decree dated 28.03.2024, be set aside.
34.
The Respondent, in its Written Submissions, has contended that the
management decided to restructure the salaries of employees on a graded
scale depending upon their salary levels, instead of resorting to retrenchment
of employees.
35.
The Respondent has submitted that the revised remuneration structure
was duly communicated to all employees through letters dated 01.04.2002,
which were accepted by the concerned employees, including the Appellant.
Reliance has been placed upon the letter dated 01.04.2002 signed by the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
Appellant, wherein the arrangement was expressly described as a
restructuring of remuneration. It is contended that the said document
contains no promise or commitment to repay the reduced component of
salary, on a future date.
36.
It is further contended that the Appellant resigned from the services of
the Respondent Company on 14.04.2004 and did not raise any claim
regarding alleged deferred salary, at the time of his resignation. The present
claim was raised only subsequently by way of the Suit instituted in the year
2006.
37.
The Respondent has further contended that no document has been
produced by the Appellant evidencing any commitment on the part of the
Respondent Company, to repay the reduced portion of salary. It is submitted
that the claim of deferred salary has been raised only as an afterthought by
certain senior employees, who instituted proceedings after leaving the
Company.
38.
The Respondent has also submitted that the amount awarded by the
learned Trial Court towards salary, HRA, leave encashment and gratuity has
already been paid to the Appellant together with interest and that no further
amount remains payable under that head.
39.
Reliance has also been placed upon the Judgment dated 06.08.2018
passed by this Court in M/s Aithent Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. Archana
Verma RFA 608/2014, wherein claims arising out of the same salary
restructuring exercise were rejected. It is accordingly submitted that the
present Appeal is devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
40.
The Appellant/Plaintiff, Mr. Praveen Malik, joined the services of the
Respondent Company on 01.02.1996 and continued in employment till
14.04.2004, as reflected in the service Certificate dated 14.04.2004 Ex. PW1/1. He was last employed as Project Manager in the category of “Sr.
Member Consulting Staff”, at the Gurgaon branch of the Respondent
Company. He further relied upon the salary certificate dated 21.03.2006 Ex.
PW-1/2 to show that he was drawing a gross salary of Rs.59,000/- per
month.
41.
It is not in dispute that the salary of the Appellant/Plaintiff was
reduced during the said period and was thereafter, restored with effect from
01.04.2003.According to the Appellant/Plaintiff, the reduction was not an
absolute reduction or restructuring, but only a deferment of part of the
salary. He claimed a sum of Rs.2,36,000/- towards deferred salary and
compensation bonus.
42.
The Respondent Company, on the other hand, has consistently
maintained that there was no deferment of salary and that the salaries of
employees were restructured for the Financial Year 2002-2003, on account
of financial constraints faced by the Company.
43.
Thus, the sole controversy is whether the reduction in the salary for
one year, i.e. from April 2002 to March 2003,was an exercise of deferment
and the arrears were to be paid after one year or was the reduction in
salary, part of a salary restructuring.
44.
The most material document is the letter dated 01.04.2002 Ex. PW-
1/D1, which was received and signed by the Appellant/Plaintiff. This letter
specifically records that due to business exigencies, the Management was
constrained to “re-structure the remuneration structure as an interim
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
measure” with effect from 01.04.2002. It further sets out the revised
remuneration structure and states that the review of the remuneration
structure would be made by the end of the accounting year. The Letter is
reproduced as under:
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
45.
A bare perusal of Ex. PW-1/D1 shows that there is no reference to the
reduced component being treated as deferred salary. There is also no
stipulation that the reduced portion of salary would be accumulated and
repaid on 01.04.2003 or at any subsequent date. The document clearly
records restructuring of remuneration, as an interim measure.
46.
The Appellant/Plaintiff sought to explain that he had merely
acknowledged receipt of Ex. PW-1/D1 and had not expressly accepted the
same. However, no such reservation or conditional acceptance, is reflected
from the document. It is also not the case of the Appellant/Plaintiff that his
signatures were obtained under coercion or duress.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
47.
Moreover, the admissions made by the Appellant/Plaintiff in cross-
examination are material. He admitted that Ex. PW-1/D1 was received by
him from the Respondent Company and bears his signatures at point A. He
also admitted that at the time of restructuring of salary, he never raised any
objection in writing against the decision of the Respondent Company. He
further admitted that till the time he remained in the Company, he never
demanded the allegedly deferred salary from the Company, in writing.
48.
In his further cross-examination, the Appellant/Plaintiff also admitted
that he had not received any written letter or document from the Respondent
Company stating that the deferred/restructured salary, would be paid in
future. These admissions clearly show that there was no written assurance or
enforceable commitment, to repay the reduced portion of salary at a later
stage.
49.
Though the Appellant/Plaintiff claimed that the reduced salary
became payable on 01.04.2003, but admittedly, no written demand was
raised by him during his employment, which continued till 14.04.2004. The
first written demand relied upon by him was the e-mail dated 17.12.2004 Ex.
PW-1/22 (colly), which was sent after he had already resigned from the
Respondent Company.
50.
The Appellant/Plaintiff has also relied upon the testimony of PW-2,
Mr. Sunil Vadhera, former Director and Head of India Operations of the
Respondent Company. PW-2 deposed that during the Financial Year 20022003, salaries of several employees were deferred on a graded scale for a
period of twelve months and that the decision had the approval of the CEO.
He relied upon the e-mail dated 09.07.2002 and connected correspondence
as Ex. PW-2/1.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
51.
However, the testimony of PW-2 does not establish any concluded
contractual obligation in favour of the Appellant/Plaintiff. In his crossexamination, PW-2 admitted that he had also filed a suit for recovery of his
alleged deferred dues against the Respondent Company. He further admitted
that he was one of the persons in charge of restructuring along with the
CEO.
52.
The evidence of PW-2, therefore, at best supports the plea that
discussions had taken place regarding deferment. However, it does not prove
any specific enforceable arrangement between the Appellant/Plaintiff and
the Respondent Company for repayment of Rs.1,77,000/- as deferred salary
or Rs.59,000/- as compensation bonus.
53.
The Appellant/Plaintiff has further placed reliance upon the letter
dated 01.04.2005 Ex. PW-1/23 issued by the CEO of the Respondent
Company. The said communication reads as under:
“April 1,2005
Dear Praveen,
Aithent has a history of valuing employees as partners in its
growth. Our philosophy ail through has been to achieve
organizational objectives by dovetailing employees'
personal growth plans and ambitions with organizational
business objectives. The management acknowledges your
valuable contribution in building Aithent and helping it
achieve its business goals.
In recent times Aithent was impacted by certain
environmental factors on which the management did not
have control. Consequently, Aithent passed through a rough
patch and despite our sincere efforts and intentions, we
could not meet some of the financial commitments that we
had made to you. As a result of this delay, you have gone
through hardship in the past few months and I am thankful
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
to you for your patience and thereby your exemplary
support to the organization in this hour of need.
I stand personally committed to honor all my commitments
and clear all your dues. In case these dues are not settled by
May 31", 2005, Aithent would pay an interest on the unpaid
dues @5% per annum for the period of delay w.e.f June 1,
2005.
I once again thank you for your unflinching support and
patience.
Wishing you the best in your professional and personal
endeavors.
Sincerely,
N Venu Gopal
CEO”
54.
The said communication, though relied upon as an acknowledgment,
does not quantify the dues allegedly payable to the Appellant/Plaintiff. It
does not specifically refer to the alleged deferred salary for Financial Year
2002-2003, nor does it mention any compensation bonus of one month’s
salary. It also does not state that the salary reduction effected in April, 2002
was a deferment, liable to be repaid as a matter of contractual obligation.
55.
The Appellant/Plaintiff has also placed emphasis on the e-mail dated
09.07.2002 Ex. PW-2/1 and the use of the expression “deferred salary”
therein.The said correspondence indicates that the management was
deliberating upon the financial position of the Company and the possibility
of restoring salaries which had earlier been reduced under the restructuring
exercise. The CEO, in his response dated 09.07.2002, also expressed
agreement with partially reversing the decision for a category of employees
with effect from 01.10.2002. However, the said correspondence is in the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
nature of an internal managerial communication and does not constitute a
communication addressed to the Appellant/Plaintiff creating any enforceable
right in his favour. Significantly, neither the e-mail dated 09.07.2002 nor the
connected correspondence records that the reduced component of salary
would be accumulated and repaid to the Appellant/Plaintiff on
01.04.2003.Even if the said e-mail and connected correspondence are read in
favour of the Appellant/Plaintiff, they do not establish the specific pleaded
case that the reduced amount of Rs.14,750/- per month was agreed to be
repaid to him on 01.04.2003, together with one month’s salary as
compensation bonus.
56.
It is not disputed that discussions may have taken place regarding
payment of bonus or some compensation to employees. However, the
Appellant/Plaintiff has failed to prove that such discussions crystallized into
a binding contractual obligation. In the absence of any written agreement,
board resolution, salary revision letter, policy document or communication
recording such obligation, the claim towards deferred salary and
compensation bonus, cannot be sustained.
57.
Much emphasis has been placed by the Appellant/Plaintiff on the
absence of any Board Resolution approving reduction of salary. However,
the present Suit is not one challenging the validity of the reduction or
seeking a declaration that the restructuring, was illegal. The case pleaded by
the Appellant/Plaintiff is that the reduced component remained payable as
deferred salary. DW-1 consistently stated that the salary was restructured
and not deferred. He admitted that the salary was reduced as per the graded
scale and that the letter regarding restructuring of salary had been issued by
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
him. The Appellant/Plaintiff has failed to discharge this burden to prove that
he was entitled to the arrears of reduced salary of one year.
58.
This conclusion also finds support from the judgment of a Coordinate
Bench of this Court in M/s Aithent Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. Archana Verma
(RFA 608/2014 decided on 06.08.2018), arising out of the same salary
restructuring exercise undertaken by the Respondent Company, during the
Financial Year 2002-03. The Coordinate Bench, while examining a similar
claim of deferred salary, observed that there was no material on record to
establish any arrangement of deferment and consequently, set aside the
decree granted by the Trial Court.
59.
In these circumstances, the learned Trial Court has rightly held that
the Appellant/Plaintiff failed to prove that the reduction in salary constituted
deferred salary payable on 01.04.2003. The claim for Rs.1,77,000/- towards
deferred salary and Rs.59,000/- towards compensation bonus was,
therefore, rightly dismissed.
60.
The next aspect pertains to the claim of the Appellant/Plaintiff
towards salary, HRA, reimbursement, leave encashment and gratuity. The
Appellant/Plaintiff had claimed Rs.2,38,198/- under this head. DW-1, in his
evidence by way of affidavit Ex. DW-1/1, admitted that an amount of
Rs.2,03,986/- had been offered to the Appellant/Plaintiff towards full and
final settlement, though the Appellant/Plaintiff refused to receive the same.
61.
The learned Trial Court noted that the Respondent Company had not
explained how the amount of Rs.2,03,986/- had been arrived at. It further
noted that the Respondent Company had not explained why the said amount
was not paid to the Appellant/Plaintiff at the time of his resignation on
14.04.2004. In these circumstances, the learned Trial Court accepted the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
claim of Rs.2,38,198/- as the amount due to the Appellant/Plaintiff towards
salary, HRA, reimbursement, leave encashment and gratuity.
62.
The said finding is based on appreciation of the pleadings and
evidence and does not call for interference. The learned Trial Court has
already granted the Appellant/Plaintiff the amount of Rs.2,38,198/- together
with interest. The grievance in the present Appeal is essentially confined to
rejection of the alleged deferred salary and compensation bonus, which, for
the reasons stated above, has no merit.
63.
The learned Trial Court has thus, rightly partly decreed the Suit only
to the extent of Rs.2,38,198/- and dismissed the claim towards alleged
deferred salary and compensation bonus.
64.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed
along with pending Applications.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 16, 2026/R
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:10:55
RFA 646/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review