Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 2026:HHC:41193
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT
SHIMLA
Cr. MP(M) No. 1789 of 2026
Decided on : 25.9.2026
Praveen Kumar
State of H.P.
…Applicant
Versus
…Respondent
_______________________________________________________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge
Whether approved for reporting?
________________________________________________
For the Applicant :
Mr. Pankaj Mehta, Advocate.
For the Respondent :
Mr. H.S. Rawat, Addl. A.G.
Virender Singh, Judge (oral)
Applicant
Praveen
Kumar
has
filed
the
present application, under Section 483 of Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (hereinafter referred to as
‘the BNSS’) for releasing him, on bail, during the
pendency of the trial, arising out of FIR No. 207 of
2024, dated 25.8.2024, registered under Sections
103,
127 (2), 125(B), 61(2), 3(5) of the Bharatiya
2 2026:HHC:41193
Nyaya Sanhita, (hereinafter referred to as the ‘BNS’
Act), with Police Station, Baddi, District Solan, H.P.
2.
The applicant has pleaded the fact that he is
innocent person and has falsely been implicated, in
the present case, as he has no concern, whatsoever,
with the offences, for which, he has been arrested, by
the police, in this case.
3.
According to the applicant, vague allegations
have been levelled against him, which have been
described as false, baseless and concocted one.
According to him, he is in judicial custody since
27.8.2024.
4.
Investigation, in the present case, is stated to
be completed, and nothing is to be recovered from
him, or at his instance. All these facts have been
pleaded to show that custodial interrogation of the
applicant is no longer required by the police and no
useful purpose would be served by keeping him in
judicial custody.
3 2026:HHC:41193
5.
The applicant has earlier tried his luck by
moving bail application before the learned Additional
Sessions Judge, Nalagarh, District Solan,
H.P.,
however, the same was dismissed on 27.5.2026.
Thereafter, the applicant has again moved the bail
application, before the learned Additional Sessions
Judge, Nalagarh, District Solan, H.P., however, the
same has again been dismissed on 30.7.2026.
6.
Learned counsel for the applicant has prayed
for the relief of bail on the ground of parity also, as
his co-accused Yog Raj, Prakash Kumar, Nitin
Kashyap and Shantanu have been released on bail,
by this Court, vide orders dated 7.7.2025, 31.3.2026,
7.9.2026 and 9.9.2026, passed in Cr. M.P. No. 753
of 2025, Cr.M.P. (M) No. 70 of 2026, Cr.M.P.(M) No.
1621 of 2026, and Cr.M.P.(M) No. 1543 of 2026,
respectively.
4 2026:HHC:41193
7.
Apart from this, the applicant, through his
counsel, has undertaken to abide by the terms and
conditions, to be imposed by this Court, in case, he is
ordered to be released on bail, during the pendency
of the trial.
8.
On these submissions, a prayer has been
made to allow the bail application.
9.
When put to notice, the police has filed the
status report, disclosing therein, that on 25.8.2024,
HC Amarjeet Singh, I.O., Police Station, Baddi,
telephonically informed the Police that at a place
known as ‘Sandoli Khawadiyan’, on the road, one
person is lying in injured condition, and one person
is lying unconscious. Both these persons were stated
to be taken for treatment to CHC, Baddi, upon which,
Inspector/SHO,
alongwith
other
police
officials
reached at Sandoli Khawadiyan, in order to verify the
facts.
5 2026:HHC:41193
9.1
When, they reached at CHC, Baddi, two
persons were found injured, who were brought for
treatment. The Doctor declared injured Lakshmi Kant
as fit to make statement. Thereafter, Lakshmi Kant
was referred to PGIMER, Chandigarh, for treatment,
whereas, Rahul was declared dead.
9.2
At CHC, Baddi, statement of Lakshmi Kant
was got recorded, under Section 173 of BNSS,
disclosing therein that he is resident of the address,
mentioned in the complaint. He alongwith, two other
persons were stated to be residing in a rented
accommodation at Panchkula. Rahul was stated to
be the close friend of complainant.
9.3
The complainant has further got recorded in
his statement that on 25.8.2024, he, alongwith his
friends, have reached Baddi at about 3:30 p.m. After
reaching there, Rahul, alongwith two other persons,
went
to
bring
Ganja
(charas),
upon
which,
complainant objected that they came from outside
6 2026:HHC:41193
and they should spend the money wisely, however,
while paying the money for Charas, the persons, who
allegedly were selling the Charas, demanded more
money, and when, Rahul refused to pay the amount
to the said persons, then, a quarrel had taken place.
Those persons, being local residents, brought dandas
from nearby huts and
the complainant party was
mercilessly beaten.
9.4
According to the complainant, he does not
know the assailants, but can identify them, in case,
they are shown to him. The assailants were stated to
be the young persons, between 20 to 27 years of age.
The complainant was also not aware about the name
of the place, where incident had taken place.
However, the said place was near road. Thereafter,
complainant and his friend Rahul were taken to
CHC, Baddi, where complainant came to know that
his friend Rahul has expired. As such, he requested
7 2026:HHC:41193
that action be taken against those unknown persons,
upon which, the Police registered the FIR in question.
9.5
Thereafter, the spot was got inspected from
FSL expert. As per the direction of the FSL expert,
physical evidence, so found there, was preserved and
taken into possession. Thereafter, Section 127(2) of
the BNS was added, in this case. The dead body of
Rahul was brought to IGMC, Shimla, for post-mortem
examination. Thereafter, the dead body of Rahul was
handed over to his relatives, for performing his last
rites.
9.6
During investigation, involvement of Chetan
Singh, Ram Karan, Karan Kumar @ Soni Bangala
was found in the incident. These three persons were
associated in the investigation, and were arrested, on
26.8.2024, at 7:35 p.m.
9.7
Since, complainant had got recorded in his
statement, under Section 173 of BNSS that he can
identify the assailants, the Test Identification Parade
8 2026:HHC:41193
of the aforesaid three persons was to be conducted,
as such, they were kept, in muffled faces. Their
medico-legal examination was also got conducted
from CHC, Baddi, in the same condition (muffled
faces). The wearing apparels, worn by the aforesaid
persons, at the relevant time, were also taken into
possession.
9.8
On 27.8.2025, accused Chetan, Ram Karan
and Karan Kumar were produced before the Court
and were remanded to the judicial custody. During
investigation, the SIT also found involvement of Nitin
Kashyap, Sonu Kumar, Chhotu, Bablu Ahirwar,
Shantanu and Praveen (applicant). They were also
arrested on 27.8.2024 at 4 P.M. Since, their Test
Identification Parade, was also to be conducted, as
such, they were also kept in muffled faces.
9.9
Thereafter, accused Ravi Kumar was also
arrested on 30.8.2024. He was also kept in muffled
face, for conducting the Test Identification Parade.
9 2026:HHC:41193
Thereafter, accused Ajay Kumar was also arrested
and he has also been kept in custody in muffled face,
for conducting the Test Identification Parade.
9.10
On 4.9.2024, the Test Identification Parade
was conducted by the learned JMFC-2, Solan, and all
the 11 persons were got identified by Ankush.
9.11
On 4.9.2024, accused Rahul Kumar was
arrested, in this case. On 5.9.2024, accused, Rahul
Kumar, during police remand, has identified the
place and memo under Section 23 of the BSA was
prepared.
9.12
On 10.9.2024, accused Sonu Kumar made
statement,
under
Section
23 of
the
BSA and
identified the kiosk, and got recovered the bamboo
stick, which was also taken into possession. On
11.9.2024,
accused
Karan
Kumar
also
made
statement, under Section 23 of the BSA, and got
recovered the bamboo stick, painted with red colour
paint, from tin shed, situated at Chakka road, Baddi,
10 2026:HHC:41193
which was also taken into possession. CDRs of the
mobile phone numbers of accused persons were
obtained from the service provider.
9.13
On 11.9.2024, all the accused persons, had
identified the place of occurrence, hence, memo
under
Section
of
BSA
was
prepared.
On
11.9.2024, Sanjeev Kumar, @ Sonu made statement
under Section 180 of BNSS, according to which, Yog
Raj, had directed accused Chetan, through video call,
to bring the complainant party to the gambling place
at Chakka road. Thereafter, the unknown persons
are stated to have beaten them up, and without
providing them treatment, they were taken here and
there. Due to this fact, one person is stated to have
expired.
9.14
With
the
help
of
artificial
intelligence,
involvement of Prakash Chand was found and he was
associated in the investigation and later on, arrested
on 14.9.2024 at 6:30 p.m.
11 2026:HHC:41193
9.15
During investigation, on 17.9.2024, Prakash
Kumar made a statement, under Section 23 of BSA
and identified the shop of Yog Raj, allegedly used for
gambling, and got recovered the scanner, which was
also taken into possession.
9.16
On 18.9.2024, accused Lukesh @ Jassi was
associated in the investigation, and arrested on
19.9.2024. During investigation, on 21.9.2024, Yog
Raj has made a statement, under Section 23 of BSA
and identified the place of gambling and disclosed
that from his place of gambling, at Chakka road, he
can
get
recovered
the
scanner.
Thereafter,
compliance of Section 23 of BSA was made.
9.17
On 6.11.2024, accused Rakib was arrested
from Utter Pradesh. During investigation, accused
Rakib has disclosed that on 25.8.2024, he alongwith
his
companions,
Shantanu,
Praveen
Kumar
(applicant) and others had beaten the unknown
12 2026:HHC:41193
persons at truck union, Baddi. On 10.11.2024,
accused Rakib had identified the said place.
9.18
It has been mentioned in the status report
that on the basis of investigation, it has been found
that on 25.8.2024, deceased Rahul, alongwith his
companions, Lakshmi Kant, Saurav, Navneet @
Shiva,
Ankush,
Kapil,
Karan,
Ritik
and
Arjun
reached at Baddi, by bus. Thereafter, they are stated
to have gone to a place at bye pass road, near fire
station, where deceased Rahul
and Lakshmi Kant
had gone to kiosk to bring Ganja (charas), and the
other persons remained on the road. Accused Sonu,
Anmol @ Tejua, Ravi Kumar, Bablu Ahirwar
and
Nitin Kashyap were already present, where accused
Sonu had given a packet of ganja (charas) to Rahul
Rai, but dispute had arisen between them, with
regard to the value of said ganja (charas). Rahul Rai
(deceased) and Lakshmi Kant, after arguing with
them, are stated to have fled away from there. They
13 2026:HHC:41193
were stated to have been chased by accused Sonu,
Anmol @ Tejua, Ravi Kumar, Bablu Ahirwar
and
Nitin Kashyap, upto truck union, Baddi, where they
had nabbed Rahul and Lakshmi Kant, Ankush and
Navneet, whereas, other companions of deceased
Rahul, namely, Ritik, Arjun, Karan, Saurav and Kapil
are stated to have fled away from the spot.
9.19
Thereafter, accused persons, telephonically
called their companions, namely, Sonu, Praveen
(applicant),
Rahul,
Shantanu,
Prakash,
Lukesh,
Rakib, Chhotu, Chetan and CCL (a) (name withheld).
Thereafter, accused Sonu, Nitin Kashyap, Karan
Kumar, Ravi Kumar, Shantanu, Rakib and CCL (b)
had beaten up Rahul and Lakshmi Kant with the
sticks. From the spot, accused Chetan made a video
call to Yog Raj and shown him the injured persons,
upon which, Yog Raj stated that lesson is required to
be taught to them and further directed him to recover
14 2026:HHC:41193
their mobile phones and money and take them to
their gambling place.
9.20
Thereafter, at the instance of
Yog Raj,
accused Chetan alongwith other persons, brought
them in their vehicle, bearing No. HR-49J-4947 to
their gambling place.
9.21
It has been mentioned in the status report
that accused Karan Kumar @ Sonu Bangala and
Shantanu cut the hair of deceased Rahul and
thereafter, all the injured persons were taken to
Katha from
Khabadiya Sandoli,
where, due to
commotion, they threw the injured persons, near
cremation ground at Khabadiya Sandoli, from where
injured Ankush and Navneet left the spot by taking
lift from someone, whereas deceased Rahul and
injured Lakshmi Kant were lying on the spot.
9.22
It has further been mentioned in the status
report that accused Chetan and Yog Raj had talked
to each other, at the time of the incident.
15 2026:HHC:41193
9.23
On the basis of aforesaid facts, it is the case
of the Police that against accused Chetan, CCL(a),
CCL(b), Karan Kumar, Nitin Kashyap, Sonu Kumar,
Chhotu,
Bablu
Ahirwar,
Shantanu,
Praveen
(applicant), Ravi Kumar, Rahul Kumar, Prakash
Kumar, Lukesh @ Jassi, Rakiv and Yog Raj, charge
sheet has been prepared for the offences, punishable
under Sections 103, 3(5), 127(2), 125(2) and 61(2) of
BNS, whereas accused Ajay Kumar and Ram Karan
are stated to be kept in Column No. 12.
9.24
As per the further stand of the Police on
10.9.2024, co-accused Ram Karan @ Soni Bangala
disclosed/revealed to the I.O. that he was present
near Truck union, then, at about 2:00-3:00 p.m.,
stone pelting started. Commotion was also there. 910 persons were present there, who were having
knives and swords in their hands.
9.25
Charge Sheet is stated to have been filed on
23.11.2024, in the Court of learned Additional
16 2026:HHC:41193
Sessions Judge, Nalagarh and the case is listed on
various dates, in the month of September, 2026, for
recording the statements of prosecution witnesses.
9.26
On the basis of above facts, a prayer has been
made to dismiss the application.
10.
Involvement of the applicant, in the present
case, as per the stand taken by the Police, was found
on the basis of alleged disclosure/revelations made
by his co-accused. Whatever disclosed by other coaccused, was revealed by them, when, they were in
police custody. As such, the same cannot be used
against their co-accused. Hence, on the basis of
alleged revelation/disclosure made by other coaccused, nothing can be attributed against the
applicant.
11.
the
Whatsoever disclosed by the co-accused of
applicant
evidence.
against
him,
is
inadmissible
in
17 2026:HHC:41193
12.
Moreover,
considering
the
fact
that
co-
accused of the applicant, Yog Raj, Prakash Kumar ,
Nitin Kashyap and Shantanu have already been
released on bail by this Court, vide order dated
7.7.2025, passed in Cr. M.P.(M) No.753 of 2025,
titled as, ‘Yog Raj versus State of H.P.’,
vide order
dated 31.3.2026, passed in Cr. MP(M) No. 70 of 2026,
titled as, ‘Prakash Kumar versus State of H.P.’, vide
order dated 7.9.2026, passed in Cr.M.P.(M) No. 1621
of 2026, titled as, ‘Nitin Kashyap versus State of
H.P.’,
and vide order dated 9.9.2026, passed in
Cr.M.P.(M) No. 1543 of 2026, titled as, ‘Shantanu
versus State of H.P.’ this Court is of the view that the
applicant is also entitled for the relief, as prayed for,
in the application.
13.
In the absence of any specific role, attributed
in the crime in question, if the applicant is ordered to
be kept in judicial custody, that too, for indefinite
18 2026:HHC:41193
period,
it
would
be
nothing,
but
pre-trial
punishment, which is prohibited under the law.
14.
So far as the apprehensions, which have been
expressed by the Police, in the status report, are
concerned, reasonable conditions can be imposed
upon the applicant, in case, ordered to be released on
bail.
15.
Considering all these facts and the fact that
the trial of the case will take sufficient long time for
its conclusion, this Court is of the view that applicant
is able to make out a case, in his favour and no
useful purpose would be served by keeping him in
judicial custody, that too, for indefinite period.
16.
Consequently, the application is allowed and
the applicant is ordered to be released on bail, in
case
FIR No. 207 of 2024, dated 25.8.2024,
registered under Sections
103,
127 (2), 125(B),
61(2), 3(5), with Police Station, Baddi, District Solan,
H.P., on his furnishing personal bond in the sum of
19 2026:HHC:41193
Rs. 50,000/-, with two sureties, in the like amount,
to the satisfaction of learned trial Court.
17.
This order, however, shall be subject to the
following conditions:a) Applicant shall regularly attend the trial Court on
each and every date of hearing and if prevented by
any reason to do so, seek exemption from
appearance by filing the appropriate application;
b) Applicant shall not tamper with the prosecution
evidence nor hamper the investigation of the case in
any manner whatsoever;
c) Applicant shall not make any inducement, threat
or promises to any person acquainted with the facts
of the case so as to dissuade them from disclosing
such facts to the Court or the Police Officer, and
d) Applicant shall not leave the territory of India
without the prior permission of the Court.
18.
Any of the observations, made herein above,
shall not be taken, as an expression of opinion, on
the merits of the case, as these observations are
confined, only to the disposal of the present bail
application.
19.
It is made clear that the respondent-State is
at liberty to move an appropriate application, in case,
20 2026:HHC:41193
any of the bail conditions is found to be violated by
the applicant.
20.
The Registry is directed to forward a soft copy
of the bail order to the Superintendent of Model
Central Jail, Kishanpura, through e-mail, with a
direction to enter the date of grant of bail in the eprison software.
21.
In case, the applicant is
not released within a
period of seven days from the date of grant of bail, the
Superintendent of Model Central Jail, Kishanpura
is
directed to inform this fact to the Secretary, DLSA, Solan.
The
Superintendent
of
the
Model
Central
Jail,
Kishanpura is further directed that if the applicant fails
to furnish the bail bonds, as per the order passed by this
Court within a period of one month from today, then, the
said fact be submitted to this Court.
(Virender Singh)
Judge
September 25, 2026
(Kalpana)
21 2026:HHC:41193
KALPANA
Digitally signed
by KALPANA
Date: 2026.09.25
15:24:15 +0000
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review