Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:20424 )
THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
LPA No.506 of 2024 a/w
LPA No. 34 of 2025
Reserved on: 29.05.2026
Decided on : 29.05.2026
Uploaded on: 29.05.2026
1. LPA No. 506 of 2024
Mohit Gupta
...Appellant
Versus
State of H.P. and others
2. LPA No. 34 of 2025
Pratibha Chauhan
…Respondents
...Appellant
Versus
State of H.P. and others
…Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the appellant(s)
:
Mr. Suneel Awasthi, Advocate in both the
appeals.
For the respondent(s)
:
Mr. Varun Chandel, Additional Advocate
General, for respondents No. 1 to 4 in
LPA No. 506 of 2024 and for respondent
No.1 in LPA No. 34 of 2025
:
Mr. Vikrant Thakur, Advocate, for
respondent No.5 in LPA No. 506 of 2024
and for respondent No.2 in LPA No. 34 of
:
Respondent No. 6 in LPA No. 506 of
2024 and respondent No.3 in LPA No. 34
of 2025, already ex parte.
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?
-2-
:
Mr. Dilip Sharma, Sr. Advocate, with Mr.
Manish
Sharma,
Advocate,
for
respondents No. 7 to 11 and 13 to 15 in
LPA No. 506 of 2024 and for respondent
No.4 in LPA No. 34 of 2025
:
Mr.
J.P.
Sharma,
Advocate,
for
respondent No.12 in LPA No. 506 of 2024
Bipin Chander Negi, Judge
Since the aforesaid two appeals arise out of a common
judgment dated 20.11.2024 and raise a common question, hence they
are being taken up together. By virtue of the impugned judgment
dated 20.11.2024, petitions preferred by the present appellants were
dismissed by the learned Single Judge. For the adjudication of the
appeals in the case at hand facts in CWPOA No. 5329 of 2019
wherefrom LPA No. 506 of 2024 arises are being considered herein
below.
2.
The
present
respondent
No.5
had
issued
an
advertisement bearing No. IV-2013 dated 1.1.2013 for selection of
various posts to be filled up on the basis of Himachal Pradesh
Administrative and Allied Services Competitive Examination, 2013. A
perusal of the advertisement Annexure A-1 (page 16 of the writ paper
book) reflects that the Himachal Pradesh Administrative Combined
Competitive Examination consisted of three successive stages to
complete the selection process (See Clause 4 of the Advertisement).
Stage-1 was a preliminary examination; it is on the basis of the marks
obtained in the preliminary examination that a candidate was to be
-3-
declared to be qualified by respondent No.5 for admission to the next
stage i.e. main examination (See Clause 4.2.6 of the Advertisement).
Stage-2 was termed as the main written examination; a candidate
who qualifies the main examination was to be called for a viva voce
individually. The final selection was to be determined on the basis of
written performance in the main examination and viva voce (See
Clause 4.4 of the Advertisement). Viva voce was the third stage in the
selection process.
3.
In terms of the advertisement, specifically Clause 5
therein, for being eligible to participate in the selection process as per
the advertisement (Annexure A-1) in the case at hand, a candidate
was required to be a citizen of India, having minimum educational
qualifications as prescribed and having the requisite prescribed age
laid down in the advertisement. Insofar as age and payment of fee for
applying under the advertisement are concerned, “relaxed standards”
have been prescribed for the reserved category candidates therein.
4.
Admittedly, for the purpose of qualifying the preliminary
examination, different cut-off marks were prescribed for the General
Category and the Reserved Category candidates. It is the case of the
appellant that insofar as respondents No. 6 to 10 are concerned, they
had not qualified the preliminary examination by obtaining more marks
than those prescribed for the General Category candidates. According
to the appellant, respondents No. 6 to 10 had gained entry to the main
-4-
examination based on the “relaxed standards” i.e lower qualifying
marks prescribed for the reserved category candidates.
5.
The main grievance of the petitioner is that once
respondents No. 6 to 10 had cleared the preliminary examination on
the relaxed standards, then after the completion of the selection
process i.e. main examination and viva voce, the aforesaid
respondents could not have been recommended against posts meant
for General Category candidates even though
in
the main
examination, the said reserved category candidates i.e respondents
No. 6 to 10 may have secured higher marks than the benchmark
prescribed for the General Category candidates.
6.
In the response filed by respondent No.5, the stand taken
is that the preliminary examination is a screening test held to shortlist
candidates. The final merit list is to be determined on the basis of
marks obtained in the main examination and the viva voce. Since in
the main examination respondents No. 6 to 10 had obtained more
marks than the cut-off marks prescribed for the General Category,
therefore their candidature was considered against the General
Category. A similar stand has been taken by respondents No. 6 to 15
in the reply filed to the original application. In the rejoinder filed to the
reply filed by respondent No. 5, the appellant (petitioner) has
reiterated the stand taken in the petition.
7.
Heard counsel for the parties. Perused the record.
-5-
8.
There cannot be any dispute with the general proposition
that if some members belonging to, say, Scheduled Castes get
selected in the open competition field on the basis of their own merit;
they will not be counted against the quota reserved for Scheduled
Castes which stands well settled as laid down by the nine-Judge
Bench in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India 1992 supp(2) 217.
Relevant extract whereof reads as follow;
811.
“In this connection it is well to remember that the
reservations under Article 16(4) do not operate like a
communal reservation. It may well happen that some
members belonging to, say, Scheduled Castes get selected in
the open competition field on the basis of their own merit;
they will not be counted against the quota reserved for
Scheduled Castes; they will be treated as open competition
candidates.”
9.
The said view was reiterated in Post Graduate Institute
of Medical Education & Research v. K.L. Narasimhan, 1997(6)
SCC 283, wherein a three-Judge Bench of the apex Court held as
follows: (SCC p. 293)
“5. … It is settled law that if a Dalit or Tribe candidate
gets selected for admission to a course or appointment
to a post on the basis of merit as general candidate, he
should not be treated as reserved candidate. Only one
who does get admission or appointment by virtue of
relaxation of eligibility criteria should be treated as
reserved candidate.”
10.
It is also well settled that reservation is an enabling
provision. Manner and extent of the same can be provided by an
executive order including exemption, concession, migration of
reserved candidates into general category candidates, etc. In this
respect a reference can gainfully be made to the apex court
-6-
judgement in Gaurav Pradhan v. State of Rajasthan, (2018) 11 SCC
352: Relevant extract whereof reads as under;
22. Article 16 clause (4) of the Constitution is an
enabling provision empowering the State for
making any provision for the reservation of
appointments or posts in favour of any backward
class of citizens which, in the opinion of the State,
is not adequately represented in the services under
the State. The orders issued by the State
Government from time to time were the orders
contemplated by Article 16 clause (4). It is well
settled by the nine-Judge Constitution Bench that
reservation in favour of backward classes can be
provided by a State Government by an executive
order also.
23. The reservation being the enabling provision,
the manner and extent to which reservation is
provided has to be spelled from the orders issued
by the Government from time to time. In the present
case, there is no issue pertaining to the extent of
reservation provided by the State Government to
the SC, ST and OBC candidates. The issue involved
in the present case is as to whether the reserved
category candidates can be allowed to be migrated
into general category candidates. The reservation
is wide enough to include exemption, concession,
etc. The exemption, concession, etc. are allowable
to the reserved category candidates to effectuate
and to give effect to the object behind Article 16
clause (4) of the Constitution. The State is fully
empowered to lay down the criteria for grant of
exemption, concession and reservation and the
manner and methodology to effectuate such
reservation. The migration of reserved candidates
into general category candidates is also part and
parcel of larger concept of reservation and the
Government Orders issued on 17-6-1996, 4-3-2002
and 24-6-2008 were the Government Orders
providing for methodology for migration of
reserved category candidates into general category
candidates which was well within the power of
State. Neither before us nor even before the High
Court, the aforesaid government orders, last being
24-6-2008, were under challenge. As noted above,
the High Court itself
has returned a finding that
earlier methodology of providing for migration of
-7-
reserved category candidates into general category
candidates was reversed by order dated 11-5-2011
by which despite taking any special concession,
reserved category candidates could be migrated
into general category candidates.
(See also Niravkumar Dilipbhai Makwana v. Gujarat
Public Service Commission, (2019) 7 SCC 383 para
34)
11.
The question whether the benefit of lower examination
fees, higher age limits, etc. are crutches which disqualify reserved
category candidate from being appointed as a general category
candidate on merits was considered by the Apex Court in Jitendra
Kumar Singh and another vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and others
(2010) 3 SCC 119, wherein it was held that age relaxation and waiver
of examination fee enable a reserved candidate to compete with
others, but such relaxation/waiver is not reservation in itself is merely
an aid to reservation. The Apex Court went on to hold that if such a
candidate belonging to the reserved category takes benefit of waiver
of examination fees or concession in examination fees or of a higher
age limit prescribed and post claiming the same is selected on the
basis of his own merit in the written examination, then he is to be
appointed as a general category candidate and not as a reserved
candidate as on the basis of the same, no advantage has accrued in
favour of the Reserved category candidate in the selection process,
as the same has no relevance in determination of the inter se merit on
the basis of the final written test and viva voce. The Hon’ble Apex
Court held as follows:-
-8-
“48. In view of the aforesaid facts, we are of the
considered opinion that the submissions of the
appellants that relaxation in fee or age would
deprive the candidates belonging to the reserved
category of an opportunity to compete against the
general category candidates is without any
foundation. It is to be noticed that the reserved
category candidates have not been given any
advantage in the selection process. All the
candidates had to appear in the same written test
and face the same interview. It is therefore quite
apparent that the concession in fee and age
relaxation only enabled certain candidates
belonging to the reserved category to fall within the
zone of consideration. The concession in age did
not in any manner tilt the balance in favour of the
reserved category candidates, in the preparation of
final merit/select list.
49. It is permissible for the State in view of Articles
14, 15, 16 and 38 of the Constitution of India to
make suitable provisions in law to eradicate the
disadvantages of candidates belonging to socially
and educationally backward classes. Reservations
are a mode to achieve the equality of opportunity
guaranteed under Article 16(1) of the Constitution
of India. Concessions and relaxations in fee or age
provided to the reserved category candidates to
enable them to compete and seek benefit of
reservation, is merely an aid to reservation. The
concessions and relaxations place the candidates
on a par with general category candidates. It is only
thereafter the merit of the candidates is to
bedetermined without any further concessions in
favour of the reserved category candidates.
Xxx.. Xxx… xxx…
Xxx.. Xxx… xxx…
52. In the present case, the concessions availed of
by the reserved category candidates in age
relaxation and fee concessions had no relevance to
the determination of the inter se merit on the basis
of the final written test and interview. The ratio of
the aforesaid judgement in fact permits reserved
category candidates to be included in the general
category candidates on the basis of merit.”
The concessions availed of by the reserved
category candidates in matter of fee and age have
no relevance to determine the inter se merit which
is determined on the basis of interview and test.
-9-
12.
The aforesaid judgment came up for consideration in
Union of India and others vs. Sajib Roy, SLP (C) Nos.2139221393/2019, decided on September 09, 2025 (2025 INSC 1084),
wherein the Apex Court observed that the decision in Jitender
Kumar’s case (supra) was not founded on general principles, but on
interpretation of the relevant statutes, Government orders and
instructions regulating the selection process in the said case. Therein,
the Government instructions dated 25.3.1994 permitted the reserved
category candidates to avail concessions with respect to age limit, fee
(waiver) and after having availed such concessions, could still be
adjusted against the unreserved seats. To the contrary, in Sajib Roy,
there existed an Office Memorandum which prohibited a reserved
category candidate from migrating to an unreserved post if, during the
selection process, such reserved category candidate had availed of
“relaxed standards” (age limit, experience, qualification, number of
chances) while applying for the selection. After considering the entire
case law on the subject concerning the primacy of recruitment rules
governing migration, the Court in Sajib Roy observed and held as
follows:“Whether a reserved candidate who has availed
relaxation in fees/upper age limit to participate in
open competition with general candidates may be
recruited against unreserved seats would depend
on the facts of each case. That is to say, in the
event there is no embargo in the recruitment
rules/employment notification, such reserved
candidates who have scored higher than the last
-10-
selected unreserved candidate shall be entitled to
migrate and be recruited against unreserved seats.
However, if an embargo is imposed under relevant
recruitment rules, such reserved candidates shall
not be permitted to migrate to general category
seats”.
13.
Other than the aforesaid in Vikas Sankhala v. Vikas
Kumar Agarwal (2017), 1 SCC 350, the issue with regard to
migration of reserved category candidates into general category was
objected by the candidates belonging to general category on the
ground that they have been selected after obtaining relaxation of
marks permissible to reserved category candidates in TET. Hence it
was contended that they were not entitled to be included into general
category. The issue raised in Vikas Sankhala is mentioned in para 24
thereof, which is to the following effect: (SCC p. 364).
“24. It so happened that many candidates who
belonged to reserved category got higher marks
than the last candidates from the general category
who was selected for the appointment in the said
recruitment process. In terms of its various
circulars, which we shall refer to at the appropriate
stage, such reserved category candidates who
emerged more meritorious than the general
category candidates were allowed to migrate in
general category. Effect thereof was that these
candidates though belonging to reserved category
occupied the post meant for general category.
According to the writ petitioners (the respondents
herein), it was impermissible as these reserved
category candidates got selected after availing
certain concessions and, therefore, there was no
reason to allow them to shift to general category.
The High Court has accepted this plea treating the
relaxation in pass marks in TET as concession
availed by the reserved category candidates in the
selection process.”
-11-
14.
The Supreme Court, ultimately held that the relaxation
given in the marks in TET examination is not part of recruitment
process. In para 80 of the judgment, the apex Court reached on the
following conclusion: (Vikas Sankhala case, SCC p. 385)
“80. … Thus, in recruitment process no weightage
or concession is given and allocation of 20% of
TET marks is applied across the board. Therefore,
the High Court is not correct in observing that
concession was given in the recruitment process
on the basis of relaxation in TET.”
15.
Since relaxation given in TET was held not to be a part of
recruitment process, therefore circulars issued by the State of
Rajasthan were held not to be applicable. (See Gaurav Pradhan v.
State of Rajasthan, (2018) 11 SCC 352).
16.
However, the aforesaid judgment was distinguished by
the apex court in Government (NCT of Delhi) and others vs.
Praveen Kumar and others, (2019) 10 SCC 120 (Three Judge
Bench) wherein the question being considered was whether a
candidate qualifying CTET with relaxed marks from a State other than
Delhi could compete for unreserved vacancies in Delhi. Therein, the
essential qualification prescribed for passing CTET was 60% marks.
The respondent therein belonged to the OBC category from outside
Delhi and did not fulfill the eligibility criteria for passing CTET with
60% marks. Since the respondents therein did not possess an OBC
certificate issued by NCT of Delhi nor had passed the CTET with 60%
-12-
marks, therefore, the candidate could not be considered against the
open category and, hence, his claim was disallowed.
17.
In the aforesaid legal matrix, reliance has been placed on
the judgment 2026 SCC Online SC 457 titled Chaya and others vs.
State of Maharashtra and another, to contend that respondents No.
6 to 10 would be entitled to be considered against the general
category despite the fact that they have cleared the preliminary
examination on relaxed standards. In the said case, reserved
category candidates had challenged the merit list prepared in
pursuance to the Teacher Aptitude Intelligence Test (TAIT) whereby,
despite having obtained more marks than the general category
candidates, they had been excluded from the merit list on the ground
that they had availed the benefit of relaxation in the qualifying marks
in the Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) which was an eligibility condition
to appear at the (TAIT). In the said case, there existed no prohibition
in the recruitment rules/notification with respect to excluding reserved
category candidates, who were more meritorious than the last
selected General Category candidate, from being considered under
the General Category. In the aforesaid judgment, after considering the
entire case law, the following legal principles were enunciated, which
read as under:
(i) A concession/relaxation in a qualifying examination merely
enables entry of a candidate into the zone of consideration
and cannot be treated as relaxation in the standard prescribed
for qualifying the written examination if such relaxation does
-13-
not affect the merit which has to be determined solely on the
basis of performance in the main examination and the
interview, if any
ii. A relaxation or concession in the qualifying examination
merely creates a level playing field where no concession or
relaxation is granted in the ultimate selection and the same is
solely made on the basis of inter se merit.
(iii) If a candidate belonging to a reserved category. does not
fulfil the essential eligibility criteria prescribed for a selection,
he/she cannot be permitted to migrate to an open category
(iv) Migration of a reserved category candidate who has
availed of a concession/relaxation in qualifying examination
depends on the Recruitment Rules or the employment
notification. If such Recruitment Rules or employment
notification permits such migration, the same is permissible.
(v) Such migration shall also be permissible if the Recruitment
Rules or employment notification are either silent or do not
expressly prohibit it.
18.
After laying down the aforesaid, the Apex Court observed
that the qualifying marks for passing TET for the general category
were fixed at 60% by the NCTE. However, relaxation in TET marks
was expressly permitted by the NCTE, and in this respect, the State
Government, local bodies, and Government aided and unaided
institutions were granted the liberty to grant concessions to persons
belonging to the reserved categories. In pursuance thereto, the
concerned Government granted relaxation to the reserved category
candidates. The relaxed standard for qualifying TET with respect to
the reserved categories was 55%.
19.
In the aforesaid backdrop, the Apex Court was of the
view that the relaxation granted in favour of the reserved category
candidates in the qualifying examination i.e. TET only enabled the
reserved category candidates to participate in the main examination
-14-
i.e. TAIT and it only affected eligibility. Such relaxation only granted a
level playing field. Merit was to be solely determined inter se on the
basis of performance in the main examination i.e. TAIT. Moreover, as
has already been stated supra in paragraph 17, migration from
reserved category to unreserved category was permissible. It is in the
aforesaid backdrop that the Apex Court observed as follows:32.The appellants who admittedly are more
meritorious than the last selected candidate under
the general category cannot be excluded from
consideration under the general category, in the
absence of any express prohibition in the
Recruitment Rules/notification The relaxation in
qualifying criteria only affects eligibility and not
merit and migration is permissible in the absence
of any prohibition. The decisions of this Court in
Pradeep Kumar (supra), Union of India v. Sajib Roy
(supra) and union of India vs G. Kiran (supra) have
no application to the obtaining factual matrix of
these appeals, whereas decisions of this Court in
Jitendra Kumar Singh (supra) and Vikas Sankhala
(supra) apply to the facts of these appeals The
appellants are entitled to migrate to general
category.
We fail to understand as to how the aforesaid judgement
in Chaya and others cited supra helps the cause of the respondents.
20.
In the facts and attending circumstances of the case at
hand, reference can gainfully be made to Union of India vs. G. Kiran
and others, arising out of SLP (C) No. 4743 of 2020, decided on
6.1.2026, wherein the question that fell for consideration was whether
a reserved category candidate who availed relaxation while qualifying
Preliminary Examination, though secured more marks than cut-off of
the General Category candidate in the Main Examination and
-15-
Interview for personality test and secured place in the final merit list,
can be considered against an unreserved vacancy?
21.
Therein the examination consisted of two tiers-first tier
Preliminary Examination followed by tier two involving Main Exam
(Written) and Interview. Only those candidates who were found
suitable in the first tier could avail entry for the tier two. The opinion of
the court was that for allocation of unreserved vacancy to a candidate
of reserved category, the selection must be on ‘General Standard’
without availing any ‘Relaxed Standard’ in either eligibility or selection
criteria. Further by placing reliance upon Niravkumar Dilipbhai
Makwanav. Gujarat Public Service Commission, (2019) 7 SCC
383, the court was of the view that if a reserved category candidate
takes benefit of relaxation though at initial stage, it will effectively
amount to taking relaxation even at the final stage of the selection
process because without giving relaxation to him, he was not in a
position to participate in the Main examination and to set forth his
claim of cadre allocation. Hence the court opined that the distinction
sought to be drawn between the preliminary and final examination
was totally misconceived. The court held as follows;
“It is needless to say, respondent No.1, having
qualified the Preliminary Examination availing
‘relaxed standard, becoming eligible for the Main
Examination must be considered against the
reserved vacancies only and cannot be considered
on general/unreserved vacancies for the purpose
of cadre allocation”.
-16-
22.
From the advertisement (Annexure A-1) (page 16 of the
writ petition) issued in the case at hand, qua H.P. Administrative
Combined Competitive Examination, 2013, it is evident that the said
examination consists of three stages. Stage-1 is the preliminary
examination, Stage-2 consists of the main examination (written), and
the third stage is the interview. For screening suitable number of
candidates for the second stage i.e. main examination, all candidates
are required to qualify the preliminary examination. Without qualifying
the first stage i.e. preliminary examination, a candidate is not in a
position to participate in the main examination (written); therefore,
even though the preliminary examination is merely a screening test
and marks obtained may not be counted for determining final merit,
nonetheless it is an integral stage of the examination and relaxation
availed by any candidate even at the stage of preliminary examination
cannot be ignored. Admittedly, in the case at hand, respondents No. 6
to 10 have appeared in the main examination (written) on account of
“relaxed standards” in the “selection process” in the preliminary
examination held in the case at hand. It is pertinent to note that the
“relaxed standards” in the case at hand are not with respect to
“eligibility” i.e. age, qualification. The details of marks obtained by
them are as under:Category
General
SC
ST
Cut-off marks (minimum)
202.8
156.24
161.12
-17-
OBC
Gen. WFF
Gen. EX S Man
SC Ex S Man
ST Ex S Man
OBC Ex S Man
178.48
133.34
95.84
61.12
19.44
28.46
Sr. No. Names
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
23.
Sh. Pankaj Sharma (SC)
Shri Chet Singh (SC)
Shri. Anil Kumar (OBC)
Shri Chander Pal Singh (OBC)
Shri Chander Veer Singh (OBC)
Marks
Scored
156.24
165.98
181.24
188.20
185.40.
The “relaxed standards” in the “selection process” on the
basis of which the, respondents No. 6 to 10 have qualified the
preliminary examination to gain entry into the next stage (main
examination) is an incident of reservation under Article 16(4) of the
Constitution of India. In this respect reference can be made to the
apex court judgement in Niravkumar Dilipbhai Makwana v. Gujarat
Public Service Commission, (2019) 7 SCC 383,
’34…………………The distinction sought to be drawn
between the preliminary and final examination is totally
misconceived. It is evident from the advertisement that
a person who avails of an age relaxation at the initial
stage will necessarily avail of the same relaxation even
at the final stage. We are of the view that the age
relaxation granted to the candidates belonging to
SC/ST and SEBC category in the instant case is an
incident of reservation under Article 16(4) of the
Constitution of India.
(See Gaurav Pradhan v. State of Rajasthan,
(2018) 11 SCC 352 relevant extract already
stands reproduced supra at para 9)
-18-
24.
In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the
considered opinion that the candidates belonging to reserved
category, who had qualified the Preliminary Examination availing
‘‘relaxed standard’’, were not entitled to be migrated to the unreserved
vacancies. We, however, also take notice of the fact that the reserved
category candidates who had taken benefit of the’‘relaxed standard’’
and were migrated to the unreserved category have been working for
more than a decade. The reserved category candidates who were
appointed on migration against unreserved vacancies are not at fault
in any manner. Hence, we are of the opinion that reserved category
candidates who have been so migrated in reserved vacancies and
appointed, should not be displaced and allowed to continue in
respective posts. On the other hand, the unreserved candidates who
could not be appointed due to the above illegal migration are also
entitled for appointment as per their merit. The equities have to be
adjusted by this Court. (See Gaurav Pradhan v. State of Rajasthan,
(2018) 11 SCC 352 para 49, wherein candidates were not disturbed as they
had been working for the last five years).
25.
In Mohit Gupta CWPOA No. 5329 of 2019, the petitioner
therein i.e. appellant in LPA No. 506 of 2024 has not given any details
of marks he obtained in the main examination as well as the viva
voce. Conspicuous by absence in the original application filed by
Mohit Gupta is the fact as to how the said individual has been affected
-19-
due to placing of respondents No. 6 to 10 against the unreserved
seats.Would Mohit Gupta figure in the final select list, if respondents
No. 6 to 10 are excluded from the said list needs to be examined by
respondent No. 5 (HPPSC). On such examination benefit, if any,
accrues in favour of Mohit Gupta needs to be extended to the said
individual within two months of the passing of the judgment.
26.
However, in the case of Ms. Pratibha Chauhan CWPOA
No. 4268 of 2016, from the final merit list (Annexure A-3) thereof, it is
evident that the two individuals, Mr. Pankaj Sharma and Mr. Chet
Singh, have been placed at serial No. 1 & 2 of the final merit list and
Ms. Pratibha Chauhan has been placed at serial No. 11 of the final
merit list. She has been selected in the HPS.
27.
In the OA filed by the said Ms. Pratibha Chauhan, only
the aforesaid two individuals have been made parties. In the aforesaid
backdrop, benefit, if any, which would accrue to Ms. Pratibha
Chauhan on account of Mr. Pankaj Sharma and Mr. Chet Singh being
considered against reserved category needs to be considered by
respondent No. 5 (HPPSC) and if on such consideration there is an
improvement in the merit ranking of Ms. Pratibha Chauhan which
would help her being considered for the post of HAS benefit thereof
be given within two months of the passing of the judgment.
28.
For the reasons stated herein above, the appeals are
allowed in the aforesaid terms. The impugned judgment dated
-20-
20.11.2024 is set aside. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any,
also stand disposed of.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
29th May, 2026
(Tarun Singh)
(Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review