Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 25TH DAY OF APRIL, 2026
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
BEFORE
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.2548 OF 2025 (A)
C/W
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 2273 OF 2025
IN CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.2548/2025
BETWEEN:
PRASANNA D. B.
S/O SRI VIREESH
AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS,
R/AT NO.5, NEAR MILK DIARY,
T DODDAPURA, THALAKADU HOBLI,
T NARASIPURA TALUK,
MYSORE 571 122.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. H.S.CHANDRAMOULI, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI. RAJATH, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY THE POLICE OF
SOLADEVANAHALLI P S
BENGALURU
REP BY THE STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
SMT. SAROJAMMA
W/O RAMANNA,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
R/AT NO.28, CHIKKABYLADAKERE,
SHIVAKOTE POST,
HESARAGHATTA HOBLI,
-2-
BENGALURU CITY - 560 089.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. PUSHPALATHA B., ADDL. SPP FOR R1;
SRI Y. KOTRESH, ADVOCATE FOR R2)
THIS CRL.A IS FILED U/S 14(A)2) OF SC/ST (POA) ACT,
PRAYING TO PASS AN ORDER ENLARGING THE APPELLANT ON
REGULAR BAIL IN SPL.C.NO.604/2025 ARISING OUT OF
CR.NO.132/2025 REGISTERED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.1 FOR
THE OFFENCE P/U/S 103,140(1),61(2),238 R/W 3(5) OF BNS
AND SEC.3(2)(B) OF SC/ST (POA) ACT.
IN CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.2273/2025
BETWEEN:
NANDAN B.,
S/O BEERESH
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS
R/AT NO.18, 4TH CROSS
2ND MAIN, NEAR BY POLICE CHOWKI
CHOUDESHWARI NAGAR
LEGGERE, BENGALURU - 560 058.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. RAKSHITH R., ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY SOLADEVANAHALLI P S
REP BY LEARNED SPP
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
BENGALURU - 560 001.
2.
SMT. SAROJAMMA
W/O RAMANNA,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
R/AT NO.28, CHIKKABYLADAKERE,
SHIVAKOTE POST,
HESARAGHATTA HOBLI,
BENGALURU CITY - 560 089.
…RESPONDENTS
-3-
(BY SMT. PUSHPALATHA B., ADDL. SPP FOR R1;
SRI. Y.KOTRESH, ADVOCATE FOR R2)
THIS CRL.A IS FILED U/S 14(A)2) OF SC/ST (POA) ACT,
PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED
22.09.2025 PASSED BY THE LEARNED II ADDL.DISTRICT AND
SESSIONS JUDGE, AT
BENGALURU RURAL
DISTRICT
BENGALURU
IN
CRL.MISC.NO.1689/2025
AND
CONSEQUENTIALLY ENLARGE THE APPELLANT ON BAIL IN
SPL.C.NO.604/2025 (CR.NO.132/2025) OF SOLADEVANAHALLI
P.S. PENDING ON THE FILE OF LEARNED II ADDL.DISTRICT
AND SESSIONS JUDGE, AT BENGALURU RURAL DISTRICT
BENGALURU FOR THE OFFENCE P/U/S 103,140(1),61(2),238
R/W 3(5) OF BNS AND SEC.3(2)(5) OF SC/ST POA ACT.
THESE CRIMINAL APPEALS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED ON 07.04.2026 FOR JUDGMENT COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, THIS COURT DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
CAV JUDGMENT
Criminal Appeal No.2548/2025 is filed by accused No.3
and Criminal Appeal No.2273/2025 is filed by accused No.2
seeking regular bail in Special Case No.604/2025 registered by
Soladevanahalli Police Station in Crime No.132/2025 for the
offences punishable under Sections 103, 140(1), 61(2), 236
read with Sections 3(5) of the BNS, 2023 and Sections 3(2)(v)
of
Scheduled
Caste
Atrocities) Act, 2015.
and
Scheduled
Tribe
(Prevention
of
-4-
2. The case of the prosecution is:
2.1. that a complaint came to be filed on 26.04.2025 by one
Smt. Sarojamma alleging that her son Chandrasekhar had been
abducted by some unknown persons over a dispute regarding
money and/or property. It is alleged that said Chandrasekhar
was leading his life by running a cab. That he was married to
one Vanaja for 18 years and they were blessed with two
children. That about 3 to 4 months since, there was discord
between said Chandrasekhar and his wife Vanaja due to which
she was residing with her mother at Doddabylakere. That there
was partition of ancestral property in Sy.No.78/9 in terms of
which Chandrasekhar has been given 8 guntas of land.
2.2. that on 26.04.2025 at about 6.30 a.m. as a routine said
Chandrasekhar had gone to have his tea to Doddabylakere on
his Discover bike bearing registration No.KA-50-B-2970 and
that while he was returning home at about 7.00 a.m. four
unknown persons who had come in a white colour Swift Dzire
Car bearing registration No.KA-04-AD-8551 waylaid him near
an
under construction building of Maruthi Nursing College on
Chikkabylakere-Raghavendra
Dhamma
Road
and
after
assaulting him by hands, forcibly took him away in the said car
leaving his bike at the spot, which incident has been witnessed
-5-
by one Muniraju, an acquaintance of the complainant who
informed about the said incident to the complainant at about
7.30 a.m. When the complainant went to the spot found the
bike lying near the said under construction building of Maruthi
Nursing College. Thus, complaint is filed against four unknown
persons.
3. Pursuant to the above complaint, a case was registered in
Crime No.132/2025 initially for the offences punishable under
Section 140(1) read with Section 3(5) of BNS Act, 2023.
4.
At about 1.30 p.m. on 26.04.2025 said Chandrashekar
was found dead with multiple injuries at Arekeredoddi. That
the
respondent
No.1-Police
conducted
the
investigation.
Arrested four accused persons namely, Nagaraj- Accused No.1,
Nandan B.-Accused No.2, Prasanna D.B.-Accused No.3, and the
wife of said Chandrashekar, Smt.Vanaja-Accused No.4 on
27.04.2025. In addition to these accused persons, there were
three children in conflict with law, J1 to J3 who were produced
before the Juvenile Board.
-6-
5.
After the investigation, a charge sheet is filed for the
offences punishable under Sections 103, 140(1), 61(2), 238
read with Sections 3(5) of the BNS, 2023 and Sections 3(2)(v)
of SC& ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
6.
Column No.17 of the Charge sheet indicate the following:
a).
That the deceased Chandrashekar belonged to
Bhovi (SC) community. He was married to accused
No.4-Vanaja, for about 18 years.
b).
Accused No.1 a resident of Aalaganji Village,
has been working in a petrol bunk at Doddabylakere
since 8 years.
c).
Accused No.1 is related to accused No.3.
Accused No.3 is a friend of accused No.2. Through
accused No.3, accused No.1 become aquatinted with
accused No.2. J1 to J3-Children in conflict with law
are the friends of accused No.2.
d).
That about eight years since accused No.1
became
aquatinted
with
accused
No.4,
who
continued
their
contact
through
phone
and
WhatsApp. This was the cause for Chandrashekar to
quarrel with accused No.1.
Yet, accused No.1
continued to have relationship with accused No.4.
-7-
e).
Accused No.4 had filed a complaint before
Women's
Police
Station,
North
Division
against
Chandrashekar. Accused No.4 and Chandrashekar
were living separately.
f).
Since, her husband Chandrashekar was an
obstacle,
accused
assistance
to
Accordingly,
No.4
accused
accused
had
No.1
No.1
offered
financial
to
eliminate
him.
had
discussed
with
accused Nos.2 and 3 for over one month and with J1
to J3 hatched a plan watching over the movements
of deceased Chandrashekar for a week.
g).
Accused
No.1
had
purchased
two
pepper
sprays, an iron pipe, a steel stick and a knife about a
month prior to the alleged incident and had kept the
same in a Swift Dzire car bearing No.KA-04-AD8551, which was given by his brother in law
Srikanta-CW.26 and had also prepared a letter as
purportedly written by one Karthik-J2 to be kept in
the pocket of deceased Chandashekar after the
murder.
h). On 26.04.2025, with the common intention of
murdering said Chandashekar, A1 along with A2, A3
and J1 to J3 were waiting in the swift car at 7:00 AM
in front of Maruthi Nursing College Building in
Chikkabyalakere,
Bengaluru
City.
When
Chandrashekar came in his bike bearing No.KA-50-V2970, they stopped him and assaulted him by their
hands, threatened him with the weapons which they
-8-
had brought and forcibly abducted him in the said
car.
i)
Due to lack of space in the car A1 got off and
asked A2, A3 and J1 to J3 to go to Channapatna and
he would come by bus.
j)
Thereafter they went to Mysore road via
Jalahalli, Sondekoppa, Tavrekere, where they bought
a knife from the shop of Mandrup Gurjar who is cited
as C.W.24.
k).
Thereafter they stopped the car at a vacant
land in Arekeredoddi via Kannalu from Channapatna.
When Chandrashekar tried to escape, accused No.2
assaulted him on the back of his head with an iron
pipe, J2 took pepper spray from the car and sprayed
it on Chandrashekar's face.
l).
Accused No.3 took the knife from the car and
stabbed him near the neck and J1, J2 and J3 took
the knife from accused No.3 and slit his throat and
stabbed him near the stomach.
m).
And thereafter accused No.3 took the steel rod
from the car and assaulted on his head and other
parts of the body.
n).
When Chandrashekar fell down after assault,
accused No.2 drove the car over his body two to
three times.
-9-
o).
Thereafter, accused No.3 picked up large stone
that was lying there and dropped it on deceased
Chandrashekar's face, murdering him on the spot.
p).
Accused
No.1
took
two
gold
rings
from
Chandrashekhar's hand and placed the letter written
by J-2 in the deceased Chandrashekhar's pocket.
q).
On their way back, they threw away the knife,
steel rod, iron pipe, pepper spray, and accused
No.2's blood stained slippers on the road. From
there, they went to Talakad in the same car, bought
new clothes and burned the blood-stained clothes to
destroy evidence.
r).
Accused No.1 picked up children in conflict with
law at Channapatna circle and thereafter accused
No.1,
called accused No.4 through WhatsApp and
informed her about Chandrashekhar's murder.
s).
Accused Nos.1 to 3 and J1 to J3 all went
together to the service station of CW.25 in T.
Narasipura to wash the car and destroy evidence.
t).
After that, they mortgaged one gold ring at
Tushar Kumar's shop who is cited as CW.27 in
Mysore and received Rs.26,000/-. Accused No.1
asked
accused
No.2
to
distribute
Rs.24,500/-
amongst themselves and left the money in the
dashboard.
- 10 -
7.
The trial Court has rejected the bail applications filed by
the accused persons. Being aggrieved by the same, present
appeals.
8.
Sri. H.S.Chandramouli, learned Senior counsel appearing
for Prasanna D.B-accused No.3 /appellant submitted;
8.1. that the entire case is based on circumstantial evidence.
8.2. that the prosecution has not prima facie established chain
of circumstances indicating the guilt of the accused.
8.3. that there are contradictions in the final report with regard
to the overt act attributed by the accused No.3, in that it is
alleged that Accused No.3 herein had stabbed the deceased
and had also dropped the stone on his head. While in the
statement of the co-accused the overt act attributed is
different.
8.4. that mere allegation of purchase of knife cannot be
sufficient
enough
to
implicate
accused
No.3,
much
less
attributing assault by the said knife in the absence of any direct
evidence.
8.5. that no test identification parade as required under law
has been conducted.
- 11 -
8.6. recovery of alleged incriminating materials have been
made on the joint statements made by all the accused persons.
Thus, joint recovery is not reliable.
8.7. presumption of accused being innocent untill proven
guilty is available in the instant case as the entire case is based
on circumstantial evidence.
8.8. Adding
of
provisions
of
Section
3(2)(b)
of
SC/ST
(Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 is only to exaggerate the
allegation, as no material evidence with regard to intention of
the accused persons to humiliate the deceased are made out.
8.9. that accused No.4 has already been granted bail. As such
the appellant/accused No.3 is entitled for similar relief on the
ground of parity.
Hence,
seeks
for
allowing
of
the
appeal
in
appearing
for
Crl.A.No.2548/2025.
9.
Sri.
Rakshith
R,
learned
counsel
Nandan/accused No.2 supplementing the submission made by
learned Senior counsel submitted;
- 12 -
9.1. that charge sheet has been filed and there is no
requirement of any custodial interrogation. That the accused
persons have been in confinement since 27.04.2025.
9.2. that the complaint was filed against unknown persons.
The implication of the accused persons is only on the statement
of accused No.1, which was recorded in the police station. The
same cannot be relied upon. The joint recovery of incriminating
materials have been done after lapse of two days which only
indicate manipulation of evidence. Hence, seeks for allowing of
the appeal in Crl.No.2273/2025.
10.
Per
contra,
Smt.
B.Pushpalatha,
learned
Additional
Special Public Prosecutor opposing the appeals submitted;
10.1. that prosecution has brought on record prima facie
material evidence which indicate the guilt of accused persons
who have conspired over a period of one month, which has
resulted in death of the deceased, that abduction of deceased
has been seen by Muniraju CW.4 at about 07:00 a.m. on
26.04.2025. It is upon the information furnished by him,
mother of the deceased had lodged the complaint without any
delay.
- 13 -
10.2. Recovery of incriminating material evidence such as use
of Swift car belonging to brother-in-law of accused No. 1,
purchase of knife by accused No.2 which has been captured in
the CCTV footage of CW.24's shop and payment of Rs.50/through phone pay and the call records of accused No.1
strongly indicate the involvement of the accused persons in
commission of offence.
10.3. that accused No.4 who was released on bail had
intimidated and threatened the mother of the deceased
resulting in she filing a complaint before the jurisdictional
police.
10.4. That the prosecution is also taking action seeking
cancellation of the said bail. That if the accused persons are
granted bail there is every likelihood of they influencing,
intimidating and threatening the witnesses and hampering the
progress of the trial. Therefore, the accused persons shall not
be granted bail. Hence, seeks for rejection of their appeals.
11.
Heard. Perused the records.
12.
Settled principle of law is that in a case involving
circumstantial evidence, the prosecution has to bring on record
- 14 -
prima facie evidence establishing the unbroken chain of links in
commission of an offence, indicating only hypothesis of accused
person committing the offence, and no other.
13.
In the case of Ishwarji Nagaji Mali v. State of Gujarat
reported in (2022) 6 SCC 609, the Apex Court at paragraph 7
has held as under;
"7. ………….The High Court has not at all
considered the material/evidence collected during
the course of the investigation even prima facie
and has directed to release Respondent 2 in such a
serious offence of hatching conspiracy to kill his
wife, by simply observing that as it is a case of
circumstantial evidence, which is a weak piece of
evidence, it is not legal and proper to deny bail to
Respondent 2. Merely because the prosecution
case rests on circumstantial evidence cannot be a
ground to release the accused on bail, if during the
course of the investigation the evidence/material
has been collected and prima facie the complete
chain of events is established. As observed
hereinabove, while releasing Respondent 2 on bail,
the learned Single Judge of the High Court has not
at all adverted to and/or considered any of the
material/evidence collected during the course of
the investigation, which is a part of the chargesheet".
14.
In the instant case the material produced by the
prosecution along with the final report against the accused
persons for the offences alleged to have been committed by
them are as under;
- 15 -
14.1.
CW4-Muniraju claimed to have seen some 4 to 5
persons
an
under
construction building at about 7:00 a.m on 26.04.2025
That
the
forcibly
dragging
said Muniraju
Chandrasekhar
is stated to
have
near
seen the
bike of
Chandrasekhar left behind at the spot from where he was
picked by the said four persons. Soon thereafter he has
informed the relatives of Chandrasekhar. Based on the said
information, complaint has been filed by the mother of the
deceased at 11.50 a.m. on 26.04.2025 after seeing the bike
belonging to deceased Chandrasekhar left behind at the place
where he was picked up. Accordingly, a case in Crime
No.132/2025 came to be registered by the respondent-Police
initially for the offence punishable under Section 140(1) read
with Section 3(5) of BNS Act.
14.2. That on the same day, a case in Crime No.55/2025 for
the offences punishable under Sections 103 and 238 of BNS
Act, 2023 came to be registered in Sathanur Police Station,
Kanakapura Taluk, Ramanagara upon the complaint given by
one Sri.Ningaraju-C.W.5 alleging that a body of a male aged
about 30 to 35 years had fallen in the land near, Kurubarahalli
Doddi, Arekattedoddi Village, Sathanur Hobli, Kanakapura
Taluk.
- 16 -
14.3. One of the items recovered from the dead body is 2
pages of writing containing purported signature of Karthik M
who is stated to be J2. The FSL report of the questioned
signature
and
questioned
writing
tallying
with
specimen
signature and specimen writing of Accused No.2-Nandan.
14.4. Purchasing of knife from the shop of one Mandrup GurjarCW.24
at about 8.30 am of 26.04.2025 and paying Rs.50/-
through phone pay i.e., from the account of Bhagyalakshmi
enterprises, transaction ID-T2504260826226759075916, UTR
No.943742591095 as well as CCTV footage recovered from the
said shop depicting purchase of knife by Accused No.2.
14.5. Tracing of white Swift Dzire car bearing No.KA-04-AD8551 to the ownership of Srikanta H M-CW26 brother -in-law of
accused No.1.
14.6. Statement of Ganesh Kumar-CW25, the owner of Ganesh
Service Centre at T.Narasipura town regarding accused No.1
going to his water service centre at about 5.00 p.m on
26.04.2025 and having Swift Dzire car bearing No.KA-04-AD8551 washed and paying charges of Rs.350/- through GPay and
screen shot of the transaction indicating payment of Rs.350/-
- 17 -
under UTR No.548244657965/QR in the name of one Srikanta
H.M.
14.7. Recovery of gold ring from the shop of Tushar Kumar,
CW.27 along with receipts and register extract of payment of
Rs.26,000/- against pledging of 4.100 grms. of gold ring.
14.8. Bank statement of accused No.2 reflecting receipt of
Rs.30,000/- from one Madhushree on 03.04.2025 which is
traced through the account of one Nagaraj, Manjula and
Bheemanna.
14.9. Call records pertaining to alleged calls from the
phone
number of accused No.1-Nagaraj- 9606234866 to the phone
numbers of
No.3-Prasanna
accused No.2-Nandana- 7411277753, accused
D.B-9353241145,
accused
No.4-
Vanaja-
990998437. The perusal of the call record indicate alleged
constant calls from the phone number of accused No.1 to the
phone numbers of accused No.2 and 3 between 25.04.2025
and 26.04.2025 and the alleged timings and the tower
locations.
14.10. The post mortem report indicate that the deceased has
sustained 22 injuries and the death is stated to be due to shock
- 18 -
and haemorrhage. The nature of severe injuries and manner of
inflicting indicate brutal attack on the deceased. The nature of
injuries are as under;
"1. Abrasion measuring 6.5cm x 4cm present over
the forehead involving right eyebrow.
2. Abrasion measuring 2.5cm x 1cm present over
the nose on right side.
3. Abrasion measuring 3cm x4cm present over the
right cheek.
4. Abrasion measuring 4cm x 2cm present over the
left cheek.
5. Incised wound measuring 2cm x 0.5cm x bone
deep present 2cm in front of the left ear.
6. Laceration measuring 5cm x 0.5cm x bone deep
present over the scalp on the back of head on left
side.
7. Three parallel incised wounds measuring 6cm x
1cm x muscle deep, 7cm x 1cm x muscle Deep
present over the front of the neck involving middle
and left side, at the level of thyroid cartilage. They
are directed outwards, upwards and backwards.
Tallinn of the wounds seen on left side.
8. Incited wound measuring 11cm x 4cm x neck
structures deep, involving the underling vein,
trachea just below the thyroid cartilage present
over the front and left side of the neck. It is
directed outwards upwards and backwards.
9. Incised wound measuring 6cm x 1cm x muscle
deep present on left side of the neck, 1cm below
the above injury.
- 19 -
10. An oblique incised wound measuring 5cm x
2cm x bone deep present over front of chest on the
midline.
11. Six stab wounds measuring 1cm x 0.5cm x
muscle deep to 1.2cm x 8 cm muscle deep present
over the outer aspect of the neck on right side.
Lower ends are blunt and upper ends are sharp.
12. Linear abrasion measuring 13cm x 1.2cm
present over the front of chest on left side,
involving left shoulder.
13. Multiple abrasions measuring 4cm x 5cm. 11cm
x6cm, 3cm x 4cm, 8cm x7cm present over the
front of chest and abdomen on left side.
14. Stab wound measuring 1 cm x 0.5cm x chest
cavity deep present over outer aspect of the chest
on left side just above the level of the nipple.
15. Abrasion measuring 3cm x4cm present on the
outer aspect of the abdomen on right side.
16. Abrasions measuring 3cm x2cm, 3cm x4cm
present over the outer aspect of right arm.
17. Multiple abrasions measuring 0.5cm x 1cm to
1cm x 1.5cm present overt right forearm and hand
at places.
18. Abrasions measuring 11cm x 3cm, 7cm x
2.5cm, 8cm x3cm present over back of left
shoulder and left arm.
19. Multiple abrasions measuring 1cm x0.5cm to
1cm x 2cm present over left forearm and hand at
places.
20. Laceration measuring 3cm x 05cm x muscle
deep present in the web space between right finger
and little finger.
21. Multiple abrasions measuring 4cm x 6cm to
8cm x 13cm present over the back of the body.
- 20 -
22. Multiple abrasions measuring 1cm x 0.5cm to
1.5cm x 2.5cm present over both lower limbs at
places".
15.
The injuries referred to above found on the body of the
deceased as per Post Mortem report indicate the nature and
gravity of offence. The punishment prescribed for the offence
alleged if proved is imprisonment for life or death.
16.
Though learned counsel for the appellants sought to treat
the accused Nos.2 and 3 herein on the principles of parity in
the light of accused No.4 -Smt.Vanaja having been released on
bail, perusal of the said order dated 21.07.2025 passed in
Crl.Misc.No.1135/2025 granting bail in favour of accused No.4
indicate that the Court has taken into consideration her alleged
role was only abettor or a conspirator and that she was not
present at the scene of the offence and she did not participate
in assaulting the deceased.
17.
Also necessary to note that accused No.4 is stated to
have threatened the complainant with dire consequences which
has now resulted in registration of FIR against accused No.4 on
17.03.2026 for the offences punishable under Sections 351(2)
and 352 BNS, 2023. Learned Addl. SPP has also submitted that
- 21 -
steps are being taken to seek cancellation of bail on this count.
No parity thus can be claimed by the appellants in the matter.
18.
Perusal of the aforesaid circumstantial material evidence
brought on record by the prosecution at this juncture indicate a
prima facie completion of chain of circumstances.
19.
On perusal of the aforesaid material and on consideration
of submissions for the counsel for the parties, this Court is of
the considered view that the appellants have not made out a
case for grant of bail at this juncture.
20.
Hence, reserving liberty to the accused Nos.2 and 3, the
appellants herein to seek grant of bail after recording of
evidence of eye witness and other important witnesses, these
appeals are dismissed.
Sd/(M.G.S. KAMAL)
JUDGE
RU, List No.: 1 Sl No.: 15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review