Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE UDAY KUMAR
CRR 4108 OF 2024
PRANABENDU BHATTACHARYYA & ANR.
-VSSTATE OF WEST BENGAL & ANR.
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Subhrojyoti Bhowmick
For the State
: Mr. Ramashish Mukherjee
Mr. Neel Chakraborty
Reserved on
: 12.08.2026
Pronounced on
: 18.08.2026
UDAY KUMAR, J.: –
I. INTRODUCTION
1.
It is an elemental tenet of our criminal jurisprudence that while the
State has an uncompromising duty to bring perpetrators of crime to
justice, the criminal process must never be permitted to degrade into an
engine of oppression, a tool of harassment, or an instrument of vexation
against individuals where the foundational materials fall miserably
short of establishing a prima facie case. The threshold stage of
considering an application for discharge under Section 239 of the Code
CRR 4108 OF 2024
of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (analogous to Section 262 of the Bharatiya
Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023) is a vital, statutory judicial filtering
mechanism devised by the legislature to screen out groundless
prosecutions, prevent the abuse of the process of any court, and shield
citizens from the unmitigated agony, financial drain, and social stigma
of a needless trial. Yet, courts are frequently confronted with situations
where standard pre-trial filters are invoked mechanically, or conversely,
where attempts are made to stifle genuine investigations prematurely by
weighing evidence like an appellate court.
2.
The instant criminal revisional application brings under judicial
scrutiny the legality, propriety, and correctness of the order dated July
30, 2024, passed by the Learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate,
2nd Court, Baruipur, in G.R. Case No. 2898 of 2022 (arising out of
Narendrapur Police Station F.I.R. No. 429 of 2022 corresponding to
Charge-Sheet No. 930 of 2022), whereby the learned Magistrate rejected
the application for discharge filed by the petitioners, who are Accused
Nos. 1 and 3 respectively, and posted the matter for framing of charges.
II. FACTUAL MATRIX LEADING TO THE FILING OF THIS
REVISIONAL APPLICATION
3.
The factual canvas emanates from a written complaint lodged on May 4,
2022, by the de facto complainant, Smt. Sonali Kar Bhattacharyya
(Opposite Party No. 2), directed against her husband, Sri Rituporno
Bhattacharyya @ Arjun, and members of the matrimonial home,
including the present petitioners (her father-in-law, aged about 78, and
CRR 4108 OF 2024
mother-in-law, aged about 76). The marriage between the complainant
and Sri Rituporno Bhattacharyya was solemnized on February 26,
2017, out of their own free will, and a female child named Natasha
Bhattacharyya was born from the wedlock.
4.
While the complainant alleged continuous physical and mental torture
subsequent to her marriage over domestic demands, the focal point of
the prosecution centers around an incident on April 30, 2022, at
around 03:00 hours. The complainant alleged that her husband, aided
by four to five unknown persons, forcefully hauled her out of the
matrimonial home, gagged her, bound her limbs, and admitted her to a
psychiatric rehabilitation center named "Rista Rehab" located at Patuli,
with the mala-fide design of branding her as a person of unsound mind
and administering tranquilizing drugs. She further alleged that her
minor child, valuable gold ornaments worth approximately Rs. 20
Lakhs, bank documents, and a shop containing merchandise were
wrongfully confined and retained by the accused persons.
5.
Upon coming to learn of this incident through reliable sources, the
complainant’s father intervened, rushed to the rehabilitation center,
had an acrimonious altercation with the management, and compelled
her discharge on May 3, 2022, in the presence of her husband.
Prompted by these allegations, Narendrapur P.S. Case No. 429 dated
May 4, 2022, was initiated under Sections 498A, 406, and 365 of the
Indian Penal Code, and investigation was set into motion.
6.
During the investigation, the Investigating Officer recorded statements
under Section 161 Cr.P.C., collected medical documents, secured the
CRR 4108 OF 2024
judicial statement of the complainant under Section 164 Cr.P.C.,
physically recovered the minor child, and retrieved stridhan articles
which were handed over to the complainant under a zimanama.
Ultimately, on September 27, 2022, Charge-Sheet No. 930 of 2022 was
submitted under Sections 498A, 406, and 365 IPC against four
individuals, including the present petitioners namely, Pranabendu
Bhattacharyya (father-in-law, aged about 78 years) and Bandana
Bhattacharyya (mother-in-law, aged about 76 years).
7.
The procedural history reveals that the petitioners earlier approached
this Court by filing C.R.R. No. 2357 of 2022 for quashing, which was
disposed of with liberty to seek discharge under Section 239 Cr.P.C.
upon
receipt
of
police
papers.
Subsequently,
upon
supply
of
documents, they filed C.R.R. No. 1949 of 2024. A coordinate Bench
disposed of C.R.R. No. 1949 of 2024 on May 13, 2024, directing the
Trial Court to assess i.
whether the invoked sections are applicable to all accused
persons, and
ii.
whether a case has been made out for the continuation of trial
on the materials collected, to be disposed of within three
months.
8.
Pursuant to this liberty, the petitioners filed their discharge application,
which was dismissed in a summary manner by the Learned Additional
Chief Judicial Magistrate on July 30, 2024, holding that sufficient
materials existed to go to trial. This order has triggered the present
revisional application.
CRR 4108 OF 2024
III. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES AND PRAYERS
A. Submissions on behalf of the Petitioners
9.
Mr.
Subhrojyoti
Bhowmick,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
petitioners, passionately argued that the impugned order is patently
illegal, perverse, passed upon an uncontroverted and mechanical
reading of the charge-sheet, and in complete defiance of the coordinate
Bench's binding mandate in C.R.R. No. 1949 of 2024 to record any
structured assessment on the two mandatory parameters dictated
thereby.
10. He forcefully contended that the petitioners are septuagenarians (aged
about 78 and 76 years), suffering from acute age-related ailments,
hypertension, and memory loss, and that Section 365 of the Indian
Penal Code has no manner of application against grandparents who
merely took protective custody of their minor grandchild, nor does
Section 406 survive since the stridhan articles claimed by the
complainant were fully recovered by the police and handed over to her
under a zimanama.
11. He further argued that the remaining allegations under Section 498A
are omnibus and vague, squarely falling within the mischief of the
principles enunciated in Neelu Chopra v. Bharti [(2009) 10 SCC 184],
Kahkashan Kausar v. State of Bihar [(2022) 6 SCC 599], and Geeta
Mehrotra v. State of Uttar Pradesh [(2012) 10 SCC 741].
12. Mr. Bhowmik accordingly prayed for setting aside of the impugned
order and discharging the petitioners from G.R. Case No. 2898 of 2022.
CRR 4108 OF 2024
B. Submissions on behalf of the State (Opposite Party No. 1)
13. Conversely, Mr. Ramashish Mukherjee, learned counsel appearing for
the State, supported the impugned order and relied upon the dictum of
the Apex Court in CBI v. Aryan Singh [(2023) 18 SCC 399] to contend
that a mini-trial cannot be conducted at the stage of consideration of
charge, and that the case diary materials disclose grave suspicion
warranting trial.
14. He contended that sufficient prima facie materials and grave suspicion
are writ large across the case diary reflecting a shared domestic
household, and that the advanced age or ailments of the petitioners do
not furnish a valid ground in law for pre-trial discharge.
15. Consequently, Mr. Mukherjee prayed for the dismissal of the criminal
revisional application.
IV. DISCUSSIONS ON FACTS, PRINCIPLES OF LAW, RATIO OF
CASES, SECTIONS, AND RELEVANT DOCUMENTS
16. The precise question that arises for judicial determination in the
present revision is whether the Learned Trial Court committed any
patent illegality, perversity, or jurisdictional error in dismissing the
petitioners' discharge application under Section 239 Cr.P.C. when the
case diary and the police report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. disclose
prima facie incriminating materials and grave suspicion connecting the
accused persons to the alleged offences, and whether the propositions
laid down in the cited judicial precedents apply to warrant discharge at
CRR 4108 OF 2024
the threshold stage, and whether a Revisional Court can evaluate
disputed questions of fact or conduct a mini-trial.
17. I have perused the impugned order, the materials collected in the case
diary, and the police report under Section 173 of the Code.
18. The statutory architecture governing the stage of discharge in warrant
cases instituted upon a police report is enshrined under Section 239 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (now corresponding to Section
262 of the Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023). This provision
mandates that if, upon considering the police report and the documents
sent with it under Section 173 and making such examination, if any, of
the accused as the Magistrate thinks necessary, and after giving the
prosecution and the accused an opportunity of being heard, the
Magistrate considers the charge against the accused to be groundless,
he shall discharge the accused, and record his reasons for so doing.
19. The expression "groundless" has a well-settled connotation. It means
that the materials produced before the Court do not furnish a basic
foundation or legal framework for framing charges, or that even if the
entire evidence collected is accepted as gospel truth, no conviction can
be sustained in law.
20. The parameters governing the exercise of the power of discharge of an
accused under Section 239 / 227 Cr.P.C. were authoritatively
delineated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of India v. Prafulla
Kumar Samal and Another [(1979) 3 SCC 4], wherein the Apex Court
formulated the following golden principles:
CRR 4108 OF 2024
1) That the Judge while considering the question of framing the
charges under Section 227 of the Code has the undoubted
power to sift and weigh the evidence for the limited purpose of
finding out whether or not a prima facie case against the
accused has been made out.
2) Where the materials placed before the court disclose grave
suspicion against the accused which has not been properly
explained, the court will be fully justified in framing a charge
and proceeding with the trial.
3) The test to determine a prima facie case would naturally depend
upon the facts of each case and it is difficult to lay down a rule
of universal application. By and large, however, if two views are
equally possible and the Judge is satisfied that the evidence
produced before him gives rise to some suspicion but not grave
suspicion against the accused, he will be fully justified in
discharging the accused.
4) That in exercising his jurisdiction under Section 227 of the
Code, the Judge cannot act merely as a post office or a
mouthpiece of the prosecution, but has to consider the
documents of the case brought on record by the police report
and reach a judicial mind whether the accused deserves to be
tried or not.
21. This principle was reiterated in Dilawar Balu Kurane v. State of
Maharashtra [(2002) 2 SCC 135] and Sheoraj Singh Ahlawat & Ors. v.
CRR 4108 OF 2024
State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. [(2013) 11 SCC 476], emphasizing that
where materials are such that even if unrebutted, they cannot make out
a conviction, the charge must be construed as groundless, warranting
discharge.
22. However, this Court must be equally mindful of the jurisdictional limits
and the caution sounded by the Supreme Court regarding mini-trials.
In CBI v. Aryan Singh (supra), the Apex Court emphatically held that a
Revisional Court or a Trial Court, while considering discharge, cannot
conduct a mini-trial or sift through evidence to evaluate disputed
questions of fact at the threshold stage. The probative value of materials
cannot be weighed with mathematical precision at this nascent stage;
matters requiring detailed appreciation of evidence must be left to the
crucible of cross-examination during trial. Thus, the delicate balance
that a court must maintain is to screen out patently groundless and
vexatious prosecutions while ensuring that cases disclosing prima facie
ingredients and grave suspicion are not stifled prematurely.
23. To test whether the present case falls within the category of a
groundless prosecution or discloses prima facie incriminating materials,
it is imperative to examine the judicial precedents pressed into service
by the petitioners, namely Neelu Chopra (supra), Kahkashan Kausar
(supra), and Geeta Mehrotra (supra). In Neelu Chopra, the Supreme
Court quashed criminal proceedings against aged parents because the
complaint was completely devoid of specific dates, particulars, or
distinct descriptions regarding the entrustment and subsequent refusal
to hand over ornaments, branding it as a vague and general accusation.
CRR 4108 OF 2024
Similarly, in Kahkashan Kausar, the Apex Court cautioned against
routine,
omnibus
implication
of
extended
family
members
in
matrimonial disputes absent specific role attribution and distinct overt
acts. Likewise, in Geeta Mehrotra, the Court set aside proceedings
where the FIR failed to disclose any specific overt act or distinct
criminal incident directly targeting the in-laws and relatives.
24. However, when the factual matrix of the present case is meticulously
contrasted with the factual settings of Neelu Chopra, Kahkashan
Kausar, and Geeta Mehrotra, a vital and decisive divergence emerges. In
those cited precedents, the allegations leveled against the family
members were purely abstract, isolated, or generic post-marriage
grievances completely devoid of any direct nexus to a contemporaneous
criminal transaction. In sharp contrast, the instant lis is anchored
around a specific, acute, and verifiable flashpoint on April 30, 2022, at
03:00 hours, wherein the de facto complainant was allegedly removed
from the matrimonial home and admitted to a psychiatric rehabilitation
facility ("Rista Rehab"), which was substantiated by contemporaneous
police actions, medical documentation, judicial statements recorded
under Section 164 Cr.P.C., the physical recovery of the minor child, and
the seizure of stridhan articles. The Investigating Agency, after
examining independent witnesses under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and
collecting substantive materials, submitted a charge-sheet under
Sections 498A, 406, and 365 IPC, pointing directly toward the joint
living and domestic milieu wherein these events transpired.
CRR 4108 OF 2024
25. When evaluated through the lens of Prafulla Kumar Samal (supra) and
CBI v. Aryan Singh (supra), the case diary and the police report under
Section 173 Cr.P.C. do not present a scenario of "groundless"
accusations where no conviction could ever be sustained. On the
contrary, they disclose a chain of circumstances and grave suspicion
connecting the household members to the occurrence. The arguments
advanced on behalf of the petitioners, such as the non-applicability of
Section 365 IPC due to temporary custody of the grandchild, or the
return of stridhan under zimanama rendering Section 406 IPC
untenable, constitute defense arguments and disputed questions of fact
regarding intent and culpability. As laid down by the Supreme Court,
such disputed factual aspects cannot be adjudicated or mini-tried at
the threshold stage of Section 239 Cr.P.C., but must be subjected to the
test of evidence during trial.
26. Furthermore, it is a well-established principle of criminal jurisprudence
that the mere advanced age of the petitioners, or the fact that they are
septuagenarians suffering from age-related illnesses, ailments, and
physical infirmities, cannot by itself serve as a valid ground in law for
granting pre-trial discharge or quashing criminal proceedings when
substantive prima facie materials and grave suspicion are clearly
discernible from the case records. While human compassion based on
age is a relevant consideration in sentencing or bail, it cannot override
the statutory parameters of a criminal trial where the investigating
agency has unearthed materials connecting household members to a
live criminal episode.
CRR 4108 OF 2024
27. Upon an anxious and meticulous appraisal of the case diary, the police
report under Section 173 Cr.P.C., and the rival submissions, my legal
and logical findings are summarized as follows:
First, the threshold requirement of Section 239 Cr.P.C. is
satisfied when the materials on record disclose "grave suspicion"
connecting the accused to the alleged crime. The case diary
contains statements of independent witnesses under Section
161 Cr.P.C., medical papers, and judicial statements under
Section 164 Cr.P.C. that prima facie point toward a live criminal
episode on April 30, 2022, involving the domestic unit.
Second, the factual matrix of the present case is clearly
distinguishable from the rulings in Neelu Chopra, Kahkashan
Kausar, and Geeta Mehrotra, as the allegations here are not
vague or omnibus post-marriage bickerings, but are anchored to
a concrete, contemporaneous transaction involving confinement
and institutionalization.
Third, defenses concerning the return of stridhan or the
protective custody of the grandchild relate to probative value
and factual appreciation, which cannot be made the subject
matter of a mini-trial at the stage of framing charges, as rightly
dictated by the Supreme Court in CBI v. Aryan Singh.
Fourth, while the advanced age of the petitioners commands
human empathy, it does not constitute a statutory ground for
CRR 4108 OF 2024
discharge when a prima facie case is made out by the
investigating agency.
Fifth, though the Trial Court's order dated July 30, 2024, was
brief, the ultimate conclusion arrived at by the learned
Magistrate in refusing to discharge the petitioners is a plausible,
legally sound view based on the record. There is no patent
illegality,
perversity,
or
jurisdictional
error
warranting
interference under our revisional jurisdiction.
V. CONCLUSION AND ORDER
29. In light of the aforesaid discussions, principles of law, and factual
findings, this Court is of the considered view that the petition lacks
merit.
30. Accordingly, the criminal revisional application being C.R.R. No. 4108
of 2024 stands dismissed.
31. The impugned order dated July 30, 2024, passed by the Learned
Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court, Baruipur, in G.R. Case
No. 2898 of 2022, is hereby affirmed.
32. The Learned Trial Court is directed to proceed expeditiously with the
framing of charges and the subsequent trial in accordance with law,
strictly uninfluenced by any observations made herein.
33. Interim orders, if any, stand vacated.
34. All connected applications stand disposed of.
35. There shall be no order as to costs.
CRR 4108 OF 2024
36. Case diary, if any, be returned forthwith.
37. Let a copy of this judgment along with the trial court records be
transmitted to the Learned Trial Court forthwith for information and
necessary compliance.
38. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.
(Uday Kumar, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review