Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 07.01.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 20.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 20.01.2026
RFA(COMM) 348/2024
PRAMOD KUMAR
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Rajeev Kumar Rai, Adv.
versus
M/S GANNON DUNKERLEY AND CO. LTD. .....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Vaibhav Tyagi and Mr.
Kartikeya Misra, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
The present Appeal, preferred under Section 13 of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 [hereinafter referred to as „CC Act‟],
challenges the judgment and decree dated 30.04.2024 [hereinafter
referred to as „Impugned Judgment‟] passed by the Commercial
Court, whereby the Commercial Court dismissed the Appellant‟s suit
for recovery, holding that the dispute did not qualify as a “commercial
dispute” under Section 2(1)(c) of the CC Act.
2.
The Appellant is before this Court on a limited legal grievance
i.e., that even if the Commercial Court correctly identified the dispute
as non-commercial, it erred in law by dismissing the suit instead of
returning the plaint under Order VII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
RFA(COMM) 348/2024
18:26:11
Procedure, 1908 [hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟] for presentation
before the appropriate non-commercial forum.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
3.
The Appellant was appointed as a Junior Engineer with the
Respondent-company vide an appointment letter dated 31.08.1992.
After successfully completing a one-year probation period, his
services were confirmed. Over a long and dedicated tenure spanning
more than 27 years, the Appellant rose through the ranks to the
position of Deputy General Manager (Civil).
4.
On 03.02.2020, the Appellant applied for earned leave for the
period of 04.02.2020 to 04.03.2020 to attend his elder son‟s wedding.
However, on 06.02.2020, the Respondent-company summarily
terminated the Appellant‟s employment, purportedly invoking
Provision 14(a) of a revised terms and conditions of the letter dated
20.12.2012.
5.
Following this termination, the Appellant sought a full and final
settlement of his dues and claimed a total outstanding sum of
Rs.4,10,184/-, which included:
i.
Rs.1,00,000/- towards the balance of two months‟ basic salary
in lieu of notice (the Respondent-company having paid only one
month);
ii.
Rs.2,55,000/- for the encashment of 153 days of earned leave;
iii.
Rs.5,184/- for pending Travel Expense bills; and
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
RFA(COMM) 348/2024
18:26:11
iv.
Rs.50,000/- towards the refund of a laptop security deposit.
6.
The Respondent failed to settle the dues despite legal notices
dated 09.07.2020 and 09.12.2022. Consequently, the Appellant
instituted a recovery suit before the Commercial Court. The
Commercial Court, however, took the view that since the dispute was
essentially a service-related recovery matter between an employee and
a private employer, it did not satisfy the criteria of a "commercial
dispute" as defined under the CC Act. On this basis, the Commercial
Court dismissed the suit of the Appellant.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
7.
Learned counsel for the Appellant submits that the dismissal of
the suit has resulted in a gross miscarriage of justice. Learned counsel
argues that the Commercial Court‟s power, upon finding a lack of
subject-matter jurisdiction under the CC Act, was restricted to the
return of the plaint under Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC.
7.1
Learned counsel further submits that by dismissing the suit, the
Commercial Court has effectively shut the doors of justice on the
Appellant‟s substantive claims for his terminal benefits, whereas the
defect was merely one of the “wrong forum”. Learned counsel seeks a
de novo trial before the appropriate Court.
8.
Learned counsel for the Respondent, while defending the
Impugned Judgment, submits that the Appellant‟s termination was in
accordance with the revised company policy of 2012 and that all
legitimate dues had been settled.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
RFA(COMM) 348/2024
18:26:11
8.1
Learned counsel further submits that since the Appellant chose
to approach a specialized Commercial Court for a non-commercial
matter, the dismissal was a natural consequence of the suit being nonmaintainable before that specific forum. Learned counsel has also
submitted that the suit was vexatious and based on fabricated
documents.
ANALYSIS AND REASONING
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and with their able
assistance, perused the paperbook.
10.
The primary question before this Court is whether a Court, upon
finding that it lacks jurisdiction because a dispute is "noncommercial," can dismiss the suit or is mandated to return the plaint.
11.
Under Section 2(1)(c) of the CC Act, “commercial disputes” are
specifically enumerated. Judicial consensus, as well as the plain
reading of the statute suggests that a simple recovery of salary or
terminal benefits by an employee from a private employer does not
fall within the categories of “merchants, bankers, financiers and
traders” or other specified commercial transactions. Thus, this Court
finds no infirmity in the Commercial Court‟s conclusion that the
dispute was non-commercial.
12.
However, the procedural consequence of this finding is where
the Commercial Court erred. Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC clearly
stipulates as under:
“Subject to the provisions of rule 10A, the plaint shall at any stage
of the suit be returned to be presented to the Court in which the suit
should have been instituted.”
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
RFA(COMM) 348/2024
18:26:11
13.
In our measured opinion, “dismissal” of a suit is a final
adjudication on the merits or on a bar that prevents the claim from
ever being heard (such as res judicata or limitation). Conversely, the
“return of a plaint” is a procedural mechanism, which is used when a
Court finds it is not the correct forum to hear the matter. By
dismissing the suit, the Commercial Court treated a jurisdictional
defect as a substantive failure of the cause of action.
14.
The Bombay High Court in AJ Organica Pvt. Ltd. v. State of
Maharashtra1 explicitly held that when a Court holds that it lacks
jurisdiction over the subject matter, it is duty-bound to pass an order
under Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC for the return of the plaint. A
litigant cannot be left remediless simply for approaching the wrong
door of the courthouse, especially when the claim involves substantial
terminal benefits after 27 years of service.
15.
The Supreme Court in Ambalal Sarabhai Enterprises Ltd. v.
K.S. Infraspace LLP & Anr.2, while dealing with the strict
interpretation of “commercial disputes”, explicitly and unambiguously
suggested the procedure to be followed when a suit is found to be noncommercial. The Supreme Court observed as under:
“14. In that view it is also necessary to carefully examine and
entertain only disputes which answers the definition “commercial
disputes” as provided under the Act. In the instant case, as already
taken note, neither the agreement between the parties refers to the
nature of the immovable property being exclusively used for trade or
commerce as on the date of the agreement nor is there any pleading to
that effect in the plaint. Further the very relief sought in the suit is for
execution of the mortgage deed which is in the nature of specific
2019 SCC OnLine SC 1311
(2020) 15 SCC 1
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
RFA(COMM) 348/2024
18:26:11
performance of the terms of Memorandum of Understanding without
reference to nature of the use of the immovable property in trade or
commerce as on the date of the suit. Therefore, if all these aspects are
kept in view, we are of the opinion that in the present facts the High
Court was justified in its conclusion arrived through the order dated
1-3-2019 [K.S. Infraspace LLP v. Ambalal Sarabhai Enterprises Ltd.,
2019 SCC OnLine Guj 1926] impugned herein. The Commercial
Court shall therefore return the plaint indicating a date for its
presentation before the Court having jurisdiction.”
16.
What the Supreme Court demonstrated therein can be construed
as: if a dispute does not qualify as a “commercial dispute”, the
Commercial Court does not lose the power to do justice; rather, it
loses the jurisdiction to hear that specific matter, thereby necessitating
the return of the plaint to the appropriate forum.
17.
The dismissal of the suit on the grounds of the “wrong forum”
is liable to be set aside to allow the Appellant to pursue his claims on
merits before the appropriate Court. This necessitates a de novo trial
where the evidence and arguments can be appreciated by a Court of
competent jurisdiction.
CONCLUSION
18.
In view of the aforegoing, this Court finds that the Commercial
Court has erred in dismissing the suit filed by the Appellant. The
interest of justice requires that the Appellant be permitted to present
his case before the correct forum.
19.
Accordingly, the present Appeal is allowed. The Impugned
Judgment is hereby set aside, while directing as follows:
i.
The suit filed by the Appellant is restored to its original
position.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
RFA(COMM) 348/2024
18:26:11
ii.
The Commercial Court is directed to return the plaint (while
indicating the date for its presentation) to the Appellant in terms of
Order VII Rule 10A CPC, while giving the date of appearance to the
parties for presentation of the returned plaint, before the appropriate
Court of competent jurisdiction.
iii.
The Larger Bench of the Supreme Court in EXL Careers v.
Franklin Aviation Services3 has held that on return of the plaint under
Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC, de novo proceedings will have to take
place, however, in the present case, not only the respective pleadings
were filed by the parties but documentary and oral evidence was also
led after granting the parties complete opportunity to cross-examine
the witnesses. Hence, with the consent of the learned counsel
representing the parties, who will take a pragmatic view, the
Competent
Court
may
utilise
the
pleadings
and
evidence
(documentary and oral) which have already been produced by the
parties.
20.
The parties, through their counsel, are directed to appear before
the concerned Commercial Court on 03.02.2026.
21.
The present Appeal stands disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
JANUARY 20, 2026
jai/kb
(2020) 12 SCC 667
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
RFA(COMM) 348/2024
18:26:11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review