Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:2843
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 5485 of 2018
….…..
Pradip Prasad, aged 59 years, son of Late Gajanan
Prasad, resident of Korahat, P.O & P.S Chakradharpur,
District West Singhbhum, Chaibasa. ..… Petitioner (s)
Versus
1.
The State of Jharkhand
2.
Chief Secretary, Department of Personnel
Administrative Reform and Rajbhasa, having office at
Project Building, P.O. Dhurwa, P.S. Jagarnathpur,
District Ranchi.
3.
Principal Secretary, Department of Personnel
Administrative Reform and Rajbhasa, having office at
Project Building, P.O. Dhurwa, P.S. Jagarnathpur,
District Ranchi.
..... Respondent(s)
….…..
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
For the Petitioner(s)
….…
: Mr. Parth Jalan, Advocate
Ms. Shreya Shukla, Adv
: Mr. Rahul Saboo, G.P.-II
For the Resp.-State
….…..
C.A.V. ON: 15/01/2026
PRONOUNCED ON:03/02/2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The petitioner has, inter alia, prayed for issuance of a
writ of mandamus commanding the Respondent-State of
Jharkhand to grant promotion to the petitioner to the post
of Deputy Secretary with effect from 24.6.2013 and further
to the post of Joint Secretary with effect from 27.7.2018.
The petitioner has also prayed for the grant of all
consequential benefits.
In addition to the above, the petitioner prays that the
notification
dated
3.10.2019
(Annexure-7)
and
the
notification dated 17.11.2020 (Annexure-8), by which he
2026:JHHC:2843
has been granted notional promotion to the post of
Additional Collector/Deputy Secretary and to the post of
Joint Secretary, respectively, be quashed as they suffer
from gross illegality and arbitrariness.
3.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner had
submitted that the petitioner, after qualifying for the 37th
Bihar Public Service Examination, joined service in the year
1993. After the bifurcation of the State of Bihar, the
petitioner was allotted the Jharkhand cadre, and he joined
his services in the State of Jharkhand in 2003. The
otherwise
unblemished
career
of
the
petitioner
was
adversely affected when an order of minor punishment was
passed against him vide order dated 20.2.2013. The
petitioner assailed the same before this Court by filing a
writ petition, which was registered as W.P.(S) No. 4548 of
2013. This Court, vide its order dated 8.03.2016, set aside
the punishment order dated 20.02.2013 and quashed the
disciplinary proceeding. The respondent-authority accepted
the order of this Court and, vide order dated 19.08.2016,
recalled its order of punishment.
4.
Learned
counsel
had
also
submitted
that
after
recalling the punishment order dated 20.02.2013, the
respondent-authorities, acting illegally, issued a fresh
show-cause to the petitioner on 27.08.2016. The petitioner
2026:JHHC:2843
immediately filed another writ petition, W.P.(S) No. 5823 of
2016. This Court, after considering the entire case, was
pleased to set aside the show cause dated 27.08.2016 vide
order dated 5.07.2017.
It has been further submitted that the petitioner is
placed at serial number 664; however, despite orders
passed by this Court quashing the order of punishment,
persons below the petitioner on the gradation list were
promoted vide notification dated 24.06.2013. Persons
junior to the petitioner were also granted promotion to the
post of Joint Secretary on 25.7.2018.
It was also submitted that the respondent-authorities
granted notional promotion to the post of Additional
Collector/Deputy Secretary with effect from 24.06.2013 to
the petitioner vide notification dated 3.10.2019 but without
financial benefits. Thus, the petitioner was thereafter
granted promotion to the post of Joint Secretary vide
notification dated 17.11.2020, but again financial benefit
was not granted from the date of eligibility, i.e., the date
from
which
his
juniors
were
granted
promotion
–
25.7.2018.
5.
During the argument, the Ld. Counsel appearing for
the petitioner further submitted that during the pendency
of the instant writ petition, the petitioner has been granted
2026:JHHC:2843
promotion
to
the
post
of
Additional
Secretary
vide
notification dated 26.6.2023, with effect from 17.11.2021.
The notification is produced before this Court, which was
taken on record.
In crux, he had contended that the petitioner has been
deprived of financial benefit in the scale of Deputy
Secretary from 24.6.2013 and in the scale of Joint
Secretary from 27.7.2018. Further, on promotion to the
post of additional secretary, there is one additional
increment which is given, which, because of the non-grant
of scale in the Joint Secretary since 2018, has resulted in
lower pay in the post of Additional Secretary. This action is
having
civil
consequences
which
suffer
from
gross
arbitrariness and violation of the principles of natural
justice.
6.
Ld. Counsel had also argued that the petitioner is
entitled to be promoted once persons junior to him have
been granted promotion. He reiterated that once the
punishment order was quashed, the effect would go to the
date of the punishment order itself. The principle of ‘no
work, no pay’ would not apply to the case at hand, as it was
the respondent-authorities who prevented the petitioner
from working at the post to which he was otherwise
entitled.
2026:JHHC:2843
7.
Learned counsel lastly submitted that the petitioner
retired from services in September 2022, and considering
that it was the respondent’s illegal action of awarding minor
punishment and further inaction on part of the respondent
by complying with the order of this Court in true letter and
spirit that led to the delay in the petitioner’s promotion. He
contended that even after recall of the punishment order,
the respondent kept the matter with respect to the
petitioner pending for years together, which incapacitated
the petitioner in discharging his duty on the promotional
post of Deputy Secretary and Joint Secretary from the date
of his eligibility. Thus, the petitioner will not be hit by the
principle of ‘no work no pay’.
8.
Per
contra,
the
Ld.
Counsel
representing
the
respondent vehemently disputes the arguments of the
petitioner. He has submitted that the petitioner has no
right to promotion but has right ‘only to be considered for
promotion’. It is submitted that extending the benefits to
the petitioner from the date when the persons junior to the
petitioner
were
promoted
would
amount
to
giving
retrospective effect to the judgment.
The Ld. Counsel representing the respondent-State
has placed heavy reliance on Rule 58 of the Jharkhand
(Bihar) Service Code and Rule 74 of the Jharkhand Finance
2026:JHHC:2843
Rules to submit that even if the argument of the petitioner
is accepted, no benefit could be extended contrary to law.
Lastly, by placing reliance on the counter-affidavit
dated 8.12.2021, the Ld. Counsel for the respondent-state
has submitted that the petitioner’s Annual Confidential
Report was not upto the mark, and as such, the petitioner
was not promoted to the post of Joint Secretary in 2018,
but rather in the year 2020, only when the petitioner was
deemed
fit
for
promotion
considering
his
Annual
Confidential Report.
9.
Learned
counsel
for
the
respondent-State
also
submitted that the notification dated 26.6.2023 shows that
the respondent-State has been acting in a diligent manner,
as the petitioner has been given a promotion, along with all
benefits, to the post of Additional Secretary from the date of
his entitlement, i.e., 17.11.2021.
10. In reply to the arguments of the state, the Ld. Counsel
for the petitioner rejoins by submitting that Rule 58 of the
Jharkhand (Bihar) Service Code and Rule 74 of the
Jharkhand Finance Rules are based on the principle of ‘no
pay, no work’. However, the same would not apply to the
disadvantage of the petitioner, when it was the respondentauthorities themselves owing to which the petitioner could
not work on the post to which he was otherwise eligible.
2026:JHHC:2843
11. Heard the parties and considered the submissions
made at the bar and the documents on record. The
following issues are carved out for the purpose of
adjudication of the instant case: a.
Whether the petitioner has a right to be
promoted from the date when his juniors were
granted promotion, taking into consideration the
punishment order and the orders passed by this
Court in WP(S) 4548 of 2013 and WP(S) 5823 of
2016 ?
b.
Whether Rule 58 of the Jharkhand Service
Code and Rule 74 of the Jharkhand (Bihar)
Finance Rules prevent the petitioner from claiming
financial and other benefits for the period prior to
the grant of promotion?
12. Coming
to
the
first
issue,
the
facts
narrated
hereinabove that the petitioner was appointed to the
services in the year 1993, and after the bifurcation of the
State of Bihar, the petitioner was allotted the State of
Jharkhand, where he joined his services in the year 2003.
The admitted facts of the case are that persons junior to the
petitioner were promoted to the posts of Deputy Secretary
and Joint Secretary on 24.06.2013
and 25.07.2018,
respectively. The Ld. Counsel for the petitioner has argued
that the petitioner has a right to promotion when the
persons junior to him were promoted and further that the
2026:JHHC:2843
order of punishment and the fresh show cause notice were
set aside by this Court, holding it to be illegal.
It is the case of the respondent-State that at the
relevant time when the persons junior to the petitioner were
granted promotion, the punishment order dated 20.2.2013
and the show cause dated 27.08.2016 were in effect. The
order of this Court in W.P.(S) No. 4548 of 2013 and W.P.(S)
No. 5823 of 2016 came into effect later only.
13. This Court, in the case of Daya Ram v. State of
Jharkhand (W.P.(S) 4276 of 2024), has held that once a
junior person is promoted, a right accrues in favour of the
petitioner.
The
relevant
portion
of
the
judgment
is
reproduced as under: “5. In view of the fair submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties, this Court is of the view that though the promotion is not a
right of an employee, but the right of consideration is accrued when
junior to the employee concerned has been considered for
promotion….”
14. Now coming to the question of the punishment order
dated 20.2.2013 and the fresh show cause dated 27.8.2016
issued against the petitioner; this Court set aside the
punishment order dated 20.2.2013 in the order dated
8.3.2016 passed in W.P.(S) No. 4548 of 2013. This Court
finds it necessary to quote the operative portion of the
order. The same is as under:“6. On the cumulative effect of facts and reasons stated in the
foregoing paragraphs, the impugned order of punishment dated
2026:JHHC:2843
20.02.2013 being not legally sustainable is, hereby, quashed and set
aside.”
From bare perusal of the above-mentioned order, it is
evident that the punishment order dated 20.02.2013 was
set aside on the ground that it was not legally tenable.
15. The fresh show cause dated 27.08.2016 was also
quashed vide order dated 05.07.2017 passed in W.P.(S) No.
5823 of 2016. The relevant portion of this judgment is
reproduced as under: “6…Therefore, issuance of the show cause notice dated 27.8.2016
warrants interference by this Court on the same is set at naught to
meet the ends of justice”
16. The aforesaid orders clearly establish that the order of
punishment dated 20.02.2013 and the fresh show cause
notice dated 27.08.2016 were ‘set at naught’. It is a trite law
that once a punishment order is interfered with, the effect
of such order goes to the date when the punishment order
was passed. Reference is made to the case of Upendra
Kumar Bhagat v. The High Court of Judicature at
Patna through its Registrar General reported in (2025
(2) PLJR 321). The effect is always retrospective, unless it
is made operative in a prospective manner. Thus, once the
order dated 20.2.2013 and the show cause dated 27.8.2016
were set aside, they cannot be given any bearing on the
issue of promotion.
2026:JHHC:2843
17. At this stage, this Court finds it relevant to address the
issue
pertaining
to
the
Annual
Confidential
Report
pertaining to the petitioner with the contention that it was
not upto the mark. However, in the supplementary counteraffidavit
dated
21.10.2020,
the
respondent-state
has
submitted that the petitioner could not be considered for
promotion as the ACR of the petitioner was incomplete.
18. This Court, in the case of Daya Ram v. State of
Jharkhand (W.P.(S) 4276 of 2024), has already held that
non-consideration of the petitioner on the ground of
incomplete ACR is not tenable in the eyes of law. The
employee is not responsible for the preparation of his ACR.
If his ACR is not completed, the same cannot be said to his
fault. In any view of the matter, if there is any defect in the
ACR, to the disadvantage of the petitioner, it needs to be
communicated to the petitioner.
19. Thus, in attending facts of this case, it is held that the
petitioner was illegally deprived of being promoted, as there
exists a right to be promoted on the date when his juniors
were promoted.
20. The next issue pertains to the benefits to which the
petitioner would be entitled. The Ld. Counsel for the
respondent state has vehemently opposed the grant of any
financial benefit to the petitioner in terms of Rule 58 of the
2026:JHHC:2843
Jharkhand Service Code and Rule 74 of the Jharkhand
(Bihar) Finance Rules and the “no pay, no work” principle.
This Court finds it necessary to quote the relevant rules
relied upon by the State: “Rule 58: (a) Subject to any exceptions specifically made in these rules
and to the provisions of clause (b) of this rule, a Government servant
shall begin to draw the pay and allowances attached to his tenure of a
post with effect from the date on which he assumes the duties of that
post, and shall cease to draw them as soon as he ceased to discharge
those duties."
"Rule 74. All authorities which are competent to sanction revision of
pay or the grant of concession to Government servants should bear in
mind that retrospective effect should not be given to financial
sanctions, except in exceptional circumstances, without the special
approval of Government."
21. This Court, in the case of Singrai Tuti v. State of
Jharkhand (W.P.(S) No. 4023 of 2024), placing reliance on
several pronouncements of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India and the Division Benches of this Court, has held that
the said rules would not come to the aid of the State when
there are no latches on the part of the petitioner. In the case
at hand, this Court has already returned a finding that the
petitioner was not at fault. The order of punishment dated
20.2.2013 and the fresh show cause notice dated 27.8.2016
were already set aside by this Court.
Further, as juniors of the petitioner were granted
promotion, there was no occasion for the State to have kept
the promotion of the petitioner pending only to grant it at
much later dates, i.e., on 3.10.2019 to the post of the
Deputy Secretary (Annexure-7) and 17.11.2020 to the post
of Joint Secretary.
2026:JHHC:2843
22. As such, this Court is having no hesitation in holding
that
the
petitioner
is
entitled
to
all
financial
and
consequential benefits from the date when the persons
junior to the petitioner were granted promotion, i.e.,
24.6.2013 and 27.7.2018.
23. In light of the above discussion and finding, the
following directions are issued: a. The notification dated 3.10.2019 is set aside to
the extent that its grants only notional promotion
to the petitioner with effect from 24.6.2013;
b. The notification dated 17.11.2020 is set aside, as
it grants promotion and benefits to the petitioner
from the date of date of notification and not from
the date of his eligibility;
c. The petitioner is granted promotion along with all
financial and consequential benefits to the post of
Deputy Secretary with effect from 24.6.2013, i.e.,
the date on which juniors to the petitioner were
granted promotion;
d. The petitioner shall be entitled for all financial
and consequential benefits to the post of Joint
Secretary with effect from 27.7.2018, i.e., the
date on which juniors to the petitioner were
granted promotion;
e. The petitioner shall be entitled for the pay scale
considering his scale of Joint Secretary since
27.7.2018 and based on the same additional
increment on the date of his promotion as
Additional Secretary;
f. Since
petition
has
superannuated
since
September, 2022, all benefits of revision in pay
shall be taken into consideration for computation
of retiral benefits including revision of pension
and the arrears towards difference in retiral
benefit;
2026:JHHC:2843
g. The State is directed to grant and release all
benefits due to the petitioner, in terms of the
above direction within a period of 12 weeks from
the date of receipt/production of copy of this
order, failing which the petitioner shall be
entitled to 6 % simple interest from the date of
entitlement till the date of actual payment.
24. As a result, the instant writ petition stands allowed.
Pending I.As., if any, are closed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
Dated: 03 /02/2026
Amardeep/
NAFR/A.F.R
Uploaded
05.02.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review