Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
PRADEEP KUMAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Shanker Raju and Mr. Nilansh
Gaur, Advocates.
versus
INSTITUTE OF ECONOMIC GROWTH & ANR
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Bhagvan Swarup Shukla, CGSC
with Mr. Mokesh Pandey, Advocate
for UOI.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
20.02.2026
The petition primarily challenges the Office Order dated 6th May,
%
1.
2016, by which the Petitioner’s services, as a probationer in the post of
Library Attendant (later redesignated as Multi-Tasking Staff) in the
Respondent Institute, were terminated on the ground that he did not possess
a valid certificate of the essential qualification in Library Science. The
Petitioner, inter alia, also assails the subsequent communication dated 5th
July, 2016, rejecting his representation and affirming the termination.
Facts
2.
The Respondent Institute issued an advertisement dated 6th
November, 2013 for the post of Library Attendant, including one post on
regular basis and another on ad hoc basis. The essential qualifications, as set
out on the Institute’s website, included: (i) Secondary School Certificate
(10th Standard); (ii) Certificate in Library Sciences/Library Information
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
Science; and (iii) Six months’ basic course in Computer Applications.
3.
On 25th November, 2013, the Petitioner applied for the post. Along
with his application, he enclosed copies of mark statements/certificates
issued by Eastern Institute for Integrated Learning in Management
University, Sikkim (“EIILM”), including for a Diploma in Library Science
(January, 2011 to December, 2011) and for Bachelor of Commerce for the
first and second years for the sessions July, 2010 to June, 2012.
4.
The Petitioner was issued an appointment letter dated 5 th August,
2014. He joined on 8th August, 2014. The appointment letter recorded that
he would be on “probation for a period of one year, extendable by a further
period of one year at the discretion of the Institute”. It also recorded that the
appointment was terminable by three months’ notice from either side, with a
power in the Director to waive notice in special cases. The letter of
appointment, reads as follows:
“August 5, 2014
Sub: Appointment for the post Library Attendant
Dear Mr. Pradeep Kumar,
With reference to your application and subsequent test, and interview
held on August 4, 2014 for the post of Library Attendant, I am writing
to inform that you have been selected for appointment to the post of
Library Attendant in the scale of pay of Rs.5200-20200 GP:1800 plus
usual allowances admissible from time to time at the Institute. The
other terms and conditions of your appointment are as under: 1. You will be on probation for a period of one year, extendable
by a further period of one year at the discretion of the Institute,
from the date of your joining the post.
2. You will be required to undertake such work as may be
assigned by the Institute from time to time.
3. You will not be allowed to engage yourself directly or indirectly
in any trade, business or profession, which carries any kind of
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
remuneration, without Director’s permission.
4. As regards working hours, leave rules and other conditions of
service, you will be governed by the Terms and Conditions of
Service, Rule 1979 of the Institute and amendments as be in
force from time to time.
5. Your appointment is terminable by three month’s notice from
either side. The notice period can be waived by the Director in
special cases.
6. You are required to furnish attested copies of your certificates
of education along with mark-sheets starting from High
School/Higher Secondary before or at the time of joining the
Institute.
7. You are required to produce medical fitness certificate at the
time of joining the Institute from the Medical Officer on the
approved panel of IEC.
8. The appointment of a candidate belonging to SC/ST/OBC is
provisional till such time the claim is verified from the
appropriate authority. In case the claim is found to be false,
his/her services will be terminated forthwith without assigning
any reason and without prejudice to further such action that
may be taken against him/her.
In case the above terms and conditions are acceptable,
you are required to sign second copy of this letter and join the
Institute on or before August 31, 2014.
Yours sincerely,
Sd/(Sushil Kumar Sen)
Academic Programmes Officer”
5.
Complaints were thereafter received questioning the validity of the
Petitioner’s qualification and the legality of his appointment. The
Petitioner’s probation was extended from time to time while the Respondent
Institute verified the qualification certificates.
6.
By an Office Order dated 6th May, 2016, the Respondent Institute
terminated the Petitioner’s services with effect from 6th May, 2016 (A.N.),
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
holding that the Petitioner did not have a valid essential qualification in
Library Science and treated the appointment as “null and void”. The Office
Order relies upon the University Grants Commission (“UGC”) letter dated
4th May, 2016, which clarified that validation by the State Government of
Sikkim was confined to the academic year 2009-10 and only for three
disciplines, namely B.A. (Hospitality and Tourism), BCA and MBA, for
students admitted within the territorial jurisdiction of the State of Sikkim,
and that degrees in other disciplines and beyond the academic year 2009-10
“shall not be valid”. On that basis, the Respondent Institute concluded that
the Petitioner did not possess the essential qualification.
7.
The Petitioner submitted a representation dated 13th May, 2016, which
was rejected by the Respondent Institute by communication dated 5th July,
2016. That communication explains the Respondent Institute’s reasoning in
detail, relying upon the regulatory position taken by UGC and the State
Government of Sikkim, and reiterating that the EIILM Diploma relied upon
was not a valid essential qualification. It also refers to the probation rules of
the Institute, and states that the Petitioner’s appointment could not be
sustained once the essential qualification was found “invalid”.
Submissions
8.
Mr. Shanker Raju, counsel for the Petitioner, makes the following
submissions in support of the petition:
8.1.
The Petitioner obtained a Diploma in Library Science in 2011 from
EIILM University and thereafter acquired a Degree in Library Science in
April 2015 from Madurai Kamaraj University. The post of Library
Attendant stood redesignated as Multi-Tasking Staff (“MTS”) with
retrospective effect pursuant to implementation of the 6 th Central Pay
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
Commission (“CPC”) recommendations and resolutions adopted by the
Respondent Institute, and under the Recruitment Rules applicable to MTS,
the essential qualification is only Senior Secondary, which the Petitioner
possesses. Once the post stood redesignated, insistence on a Diploma in
Library Science is untenable. Reliance is placed on M. Nagaraja v.
Government of A.P.1 to contend once the post stood redesignated as MTS
with retrospective effect, the applicable eligibility conditions must be read
accordingly.
8.2.
The UGC letter dated 4th May, 2016, pertained to graduate degrees
and was wrongly applied to a Diploma; in any event, it cannot operate
retrospectively to invalidate a qualification acquired earlier. Reliance is also
placed on the UGC Public Notice dated 23rd February, 2018, to contend that
degrees and diplomas awarded through Open and Distance Learning
(“ODL”) institutions recognised by the erstwhile Distance Education
Council (“DEC”)/UGC are to be treated at par with corresponding awards of
traditional universities. EIILM was established under a State Act, recognised
under Section 2(f) and empowered under Section 22 of the UGC Act, and
there was DEC recognition for distance programmes during the relevant
period. Even assuming any defect in Diploma, the Petitioner had acquired a
valid degree from a recognised University prior to termination and, thus,
satisfied the eligibility requirement on the date of discharge.
8.3.
Reliance is placed on Orissa Lift Irrigation Corp. Ltd. v. Rabi
Sankar Patro & Ors.2 to contend that the Supreme Court recognised degrees
awarded through distance mode and moulded relief to protect the aggrieved,
(2007) 11 SCC 522.
(2018) 1 SCC 468.
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
and that technical objections as to regulatory approval should not defeat
substantive rights where the qualification was obtained from a university
established under law.
8.4.
The Petitioner had successfully completed probation and was deemed
confirmed; the extension of probation was issued after expiry of the initial
period and therefore permanency must be presumed. Further, the termination
was not approved by the competent authority, namely the Board of
Governors, and suffers from jurisdictional infirmity. Treating the
appointment as “null and void” on the ground of alleged invalid
qualification amounts to imputing misconduct, necessitating disciplinary
proceedings under the applicable Service Rules. Reliance is also placed on
doctrines of legitimate expectation, promissory estoppel, and the power of
relaxation vested in the Board of Governors to alleviate undue hardship.
9.
Mr. Bhagvan Swarup Shukla, CGSC appearing for the Respondents,
opposes the present petition and contends as follows:
9.1.
The Petitioner’s appointment was premised upon satisfaction of a
valid essential qualification, namely a certificate or diploma in Library
Science. The Diploma relied upon by the Petitioner was obtained through
distance mode in 2011 and was not recognised for that course and period by
DEC/UGC. As per the DEC/IGNOU communication dated 9th September,
2009, recognition to EIILM for distance education was confined to the
academic year 2009-10 and to specified programmes, subject to territorial
limitation within the State of Sikkim. The Petitioner’s diploma in Library
Science was neither shown to be among the approved programmes nor
obtained within the recognised academic year.
9.2.
The UGC communication dated 4th May, 2016 merely clarifies the
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
regulatory position following the Fact-Finding exercise, and that no valid
approval existed for the programme pursued by the Petitioner in 2011.
Further, the UGC Public Notice dated 23rd February, 2018 applies only to
programmes conducted by ODL institutions duly recognised by DEC/UGC,
and cannot validate an unrecognised course or one pursued beyond the
period of approval.
9.3.
The redesignation of the post as MTS did not obliterate the essential
qualification applicable at the time of recruitment. The Petitioner was a
probationer, never formally confirmed, and his services were discontinued
upon discovery of ineligibility. The termination is a non-punitive discharge
founded on absence of a valid essential qualification, and no disciplinary
enquiry was required.
Analysis
Effect of redesignation of post as MTS:
10.
The argument founded on the plea of redesignation proceeds on an
erroneous premise. A change in nomenclature or pay structure pursuant to
pay commission recommendations does not, by itself, rewrite recruitment
qualifications. For recruitment, what matters is the rule or eligibility
condition governing entry into service for the post in question. The
Respondent Institute’s contemporaneous record shows that the post was
filled against a position described as Library Attendant with a specified
essential qualification that included a Library Science diploma/certificate.
11.
The Petitioner’s own case is that he was selected for appointment
after test and interview held on 4th August, 2014 for the post of “Library
Attendant”, and the appointment letter of 5th August, 2014, is issued for that
post. The later redesignation as MTS is an administrative re-labelling of
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
Group ‘D’ posts. It does not erase the essential qualification on which the
Petitioner’s candidature was evaluated and on the strength of which he was
selected. The Respondent Institute’s letter dated 5th July, 2016 also records
that the Recruitment Rules pertaining to the Library Attendant/MTS post
remained unchanged, including the requirement of a Library Science
diploma/certificate.
12.
The decision in M. Nagaraja is relied upon to say that rules can
operate retrospectively. That proposition, as a general principle, is not in
dispute. However, retrospective redesignation does not, cure ineligibility at
entry. The Petitioner’s eligibility must therefore be tested on the basis of the
essential qualifications applicable at the time of recruitment and
appointment.
Validity of the EIILM Diploma for employment purposes:
13.
The Petitioner leans heavily on EIILM’s status as a State private
university and its recognition under Section 2(f), coupled with its power
under Section 22 of the UGC Act to award degrees. That, however, does not
answer the question the case actually poses. The controversy is not about
EIILM’s existence as a university in the abstract. It is about the legal status
of the particular qualification relied upon by the Petitioner for public
employment.
14.
The regulatory architecture governing universities cannot be reduced
to the bare fact of incorporation under a State enactment. In Prof. Yashpal v.
State of Chhattisgarh3, the Supreme Court was confronted with a situation
where universities had been brought into existence in a mechanical manner
by issuance of gazette notifications, without regard to infrastructure,
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
teaching
facilities,
or
regulatory
control.
The
Court
held
that,
notwithstanding the State’s competence to legislate on incorporation of
universities under Entry 32 of List II, the field of coordination and
determination of standards in higher education is reserved to Parliament
under Entry 66 of List I, and any State action trenching upon that domain
would be impermissible. It was emphasised that the conferment of the status
of a university, and the power to award degrees under Section 22 of the
UGC Act, cannot operate in isolation from the statutory regime designed to
ensure uniform standards and regulatory oversight.
15.
In that backdrop, the mere fact that EIILM was established as a State
private university and recognised under Section 2(f) of the UGC Act does
not conclude the enquiry. The decisive question is whether the programme
relied upon by the Petitioner was conducted in conformity with the
applicable approval and regulatory framework governing distance education,
including authorisation for study centres or off-campus operations. The
material on record indicates that no such approval had been granted. The
issue, therefore, is not one of theoretical existence, but of lawful conduct of
the programme and recognition of the Diploma for employment purposes.
16.
The record further shows that a Fact-Finding Committee was
constituted by UGC in the light of complaints about EIILM’s activities,
including unauthorised study centres, franchising of higher education, and
issuance of degrees without the prescribed academic framework. The
Committee visited the University in April 2015. The material relied upon by
the Institute records that the Committee recommended dissolution of EIILM
University under the State Act, noted that EIILM, being unitary, had no
(2005) 5 SCC 420.
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
mandate to affiliate colleges and had not received permission to establish
off-campus/study/off-shore centres, and also recorded a limited validation
approach recommended to protect students admitted within Sikkim for
academic year 2009-10 in specified disciplines. A public notice was
thereafter issued by UGC on 5th August, 2015, and the State Government of
Sikkim proceeded with dissolution and stopped fresh admissions.
17.
The record reflects validation, if any, was confined to the academic
year 2009-10 and only to three disciplines, namely B.A. (Hospitality and
Tourism), BCA and MBA, and that too for students admitted within the
territorial jurisdiction of Sikkim, subject to verification from admission
records. The Petitioner’s qualification falls outside that narrow window on
both counts. It is a Diploma in Library Science, which does not feature in
the validated disciplines, and it was pursued and completed in 2011, beyond
the academic year 2009-10.
18.
The Petitioner’s attempt to treat the UGC communication dated 4 th
May, 2016 as confined to graduate “degree” programmes is unpersuasive.
The position reflected in the regulatory record, as explained by UGC and
reflected in the Institute’s record, is that distance education recognition was
granted for one academic year and for specific courses only, and that the
institution could not offer any other programme through distance mode
beyond what was approved. Once that is the premise, the debate about
whether the programme is styled as “degree” or “diploma” does not help.
The question is approval and recognition for that programme and that
period. The Petitioner has not shown any DEC/UGC recognition for
Diploma in Library Science for the year 2011.
19.
The public notice dated 23rd February, 2018 does not carry the
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
Petitioner’s case further. It speaks of equivalence for “degrees” and
“diplomas” awarded for programmes conducted by ODL institutions
recognised by the erstwhile DEC/UGC. It is not a curative device that
transforms an unapproved programme into an approved one.
20.
The Petitioner has contended that Diploma in Library Science formed
part of programmes approved by DEC. Even assuming there is a list that
reflects approval in principle for certain programmes, the decisive question
remains whether the specific programme pursued by the Petitioner in 2011
fell within the scope of a valid and subsisting recognition, both in terms of
academic year and territorial jurisdiction. The regulatory material on record
indicates that recognition, if any, was confined to the academic year 2009-10
and to specified disciplines. No contemporaneous approval covering
Diploma in Library Science offered in 2011 through distance mode has been
shown. Thus, the material on record does not establish that the Petitioner
possessed a recognised essential qualification at the time of appointment.
21.
The retrospectivity argument rests on an erroneous premise. The
Petitioner proceeds as though the UGC letter dated 4th May, 2016 created the
ineligibility. The regulatory record indicates otherwise. Recognition for
distance mode, if at all, was determined earlier through the DEC/IGNOU
communication dated 9th September, 2009, which was confined to the
academic year 2009-10 and to specified programmes. The 2016
communication merely sets out that position and records the regulatory
outcome following the Fact-Finding exercise. It does not withdraw an
existing approval with retrospective effect. It clarifies that, for the
Petitioner’s programme and period, no approval existed in the first place.
22.
Similarly, the Petitioner’s submission that he acquired a recognised
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
degree in Library Science in April 2015 does not cure the foundational
defect. Eligibility must exist on the date of appointment. A qualification
acquired subsequent to entry into service cannot retrospectively validate an
appointment that was deficient at inception, unless the governing rules so
permit. No such provision is shown here. It is also not disputed that the
Petitioner undertook the said course during his employment without seeking
prior permission, as required under Rule 16(f) of the Institute’s Service
Rules, which mandates prior approval for pursuing studies while in service.
While this factum is not determinative, the circumstance reinforces that the
subsequent acquisition of qualification cannot be invoked as a curative or
equitable ground to sustain an otherwise ineligible appointment.
23.
Once it is found that the Petitioner did not possess a valid essential
qualification at the time of appointment, the legal consequences must
follow. An appointment made contrary to essential eligibility conditions
cannot be sustained on considerations of equity, and that a candidate who
was ineligible on the cut-off date cannot claim a right to continue merely
because time has elapsed. The appointment does not gain legality by passage
of time or by internal recommendations. The employer is entitled, indeed
obliged, to correct the position when the defect is discovered.
Whether the termination is punitive or stigmatic:
24.
The Petitioner further contends that the termination is, in substance,
founded on allegations of fraud or misrepresentation and, therefore, could
not have been effected without disciplinary proceedings. The submission
requires the Court to identify the true foundation of the impugned action.
That enquiry begins with the operative order itself, not with expansive
language employed later while rejecting a representation.
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
25.
The Office Order dated 6th May, 2016 records the documents
furnished by the Petitioner, sets out the essential qualifications, refers to the
clarification received from UGC, and concludes that the Petitioner did not
possess a valid essential qualification in Library Science for the post. It then
treats the appointment as unsustainable on that footing and terminates the
Petitioner’s probationary service. The order does not return a finding of
misconduct, does not record an adjudication of fraud, and does not visit the
Petitioner with a penal consequence after an enquiry. Its premise is
ineligibility.
26.
The communication dated 5th July, 2016, while dealing with the
Petitioner’s appeal/representation, employs stronger language. Even so, the
thread running through that communication remains the same: the
qualification relied upon as essential was not valid for employment
purposes. On a proper reading, therefore, the foundation of the action is not
misconduct but lack of eligibility. In service law, termination founded on
absence of an essential qualification is not a punitive dismissal; it does not
attract the procedural requirements that become mandatory when an
employer seeks to impose a punishment for misconduct.
27.
The Petitioner also seeks to draw support from an ACR entry
suggesting permanence and from an internal recommendation for
confirmation. Neither advances his case. A recommendation is only a
recommendation. Confirmation follows only upon a formal order by the
competent authority. The contemporaneous record shows that the
Petitioner’s probation was extended up to the date of termination while the
Respondent Institute was verifying the validity of the essential qualification.
A stray description in an internal assessment record cannot, by itself, alter
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
the legal character of the appointment or foreclose an eligibility-based action
once the defect is established.
28.
The contention that the termination was not approved by the Board of
Governors and therefore suffers from jurisdictional infirmity does not
advance the Petitioner’s case. The impugned action is not a disciplinary
penalty, but a discontinuation founded on absence of essential eligibility.
Where an appointment is rendered unsustainable for want of a valid
qualification at entry, the employer is entitled to correct the position. Even
assuming some irregularity in internal approval procedure, such irregularity
cannot compel continuation of an appointment made contrary to statutory
eligibility conditions.
29.
The plea of deemed confirmation is equally untenable. Confirmation
does not follow automatically upon expiry of the initial probation period
unless the governing rules expressly so provide. The appointment letter
clearly stipulates probation “extendable by a further period of one year at
the discretion of the Institute”. In the absence of a formal order of
confirmation by the competent authority, no vested right of permanency
accrued to the Petitioner.
30.
The reliance on doctrines of legitimate expectation, promissory
estoppel and power of relaxation is misplaced. Legitimate expectation
cannot override statutory eligibility requirements. Nor can estoppel operate
against law. The power of relaxation, even if available, cannot be invoked to
validate an appointment made in the absence of a recognised essential
qualification unless the rules expressly permit relaxation of that very
condition. No such statutory relaxation of the essential qualification is
shown.
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
31.
The reliance on Orissa Lift Irrigation is misplaced. In that decision,
the Supreme Court categorically held that Engineering degrees awarded
through distance education mode without the requisite approval of AICTE
were illegal and stood suspended/cancelled. The Court did not validate such
degrees as a matter of right. Instead, having found systemic regulatory
failures, it fashioned a one-time equitable arrangement in the larger interest
of students by permitting them to undergo a supervised test process within a
stipulated time, failing which the degrees would remain cancelled. The relief
was thus transitional and conditional, not a declaration of inherent validity.
The present matter concerns public employment, where possession of a valid
essential qualification at the threshold is mandatory. The equitable, studentcentric directions issued in Orissa Lift Irrigation cannot be invoked to
compel recognition of an ineligible qualification for purposes of
appointment, nor can they justify sustaining an appointment that fails to
meet the basic eligibility condition at the point of entry.
Conclusion
32.
The writ petition is dismissed. The impugned orders/communications
do not call for any interference.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
FEBRUARY 20, 2026/as
W.P.(C) 5785/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 25/02/2026 at 15:45:37
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review