Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1064 of 2025
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
sd/-
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
sd/-
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
yes
No
==========================================================
PRACHI HARISHCHANDRA BAROT
Versus
PADHIYAR JAIMIN JESANGBHAI
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR. VARUN G RAI(7135) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
MR. AMAN F MANSURI WITH MR MINHAJ M SHAIKH(6847) for the
Defendant(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 31/08/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI)
“Mere knowledge of the subsistence of an earlier
marriage cannot validate a second marriage, nor can it
cure its void-ness”.
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
1.
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
The present appeal has been filed by the appellant –
the original applicant under Section 19 of the Family Court
Act, 1984 to quash and set aside the judgment and decree
dated 25.02.2025 passed in Family Suit No.407 of 2023 by
the learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Vadodara,
whereby the suit moved by the appellant - wife praying to
declare that her so-called marriage registered with the
respondent dated 27.06.2022 is illegal and void, was
rejected.
2.
For the sake of brevity and convenience, the parties
are referred to as per their original status before the learned
Family Court.
3.
Brief facts of the case are as follows:
3.1
It is a case where the appellant - wife and the
respondent - husband are residents of same Village –
Mohalla and that they were in love. The respondent was a
married person and father of one child named Darshit and
the appellant was well aware of the said fact. Many a times,
the respondent used to tell the appellant - wife about his
miserable life with his first wife named Minaxi and for him
to take divorce from his first wife, he had initiated the
proceedings.
3.2
It is further the case that in February 2022, the
respondent tricked the appellant - wife by stating that he
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
was legally divorced with his first wife - Minaxi and that
now, he wants to marry her. By doing so, he took her to the
office of his known advocate at Manisha Chokdi, Vadodara
and obtained her signatures on the pre-prepared papers
relating to marriage registration and according to preprepared scheme, the spouse registered the marriage before
Marriage Registrar, Jhagadhia, Sultanpur Gram Panchayat
at regd. No.370 on 27.06.2022. Both the parties had kept
their respective families in the dark about the said fact.
Thus, the respondent told the appellant - wife that he has
legally taken divorce from his first wife and that it would
take time for getting judgment and decree from the Court.
By doing so, he compelled the appellant - wife to leave her
parental home and on 21.02.2023, they both left their home
and went to Surat and therefrom, they went to Goa.
3.3
It is further the case that the appellant - wife had left
her home without giving an intimation to her parents,
therefore,
she
contacted
her
acquainted
person
at
Vadodara, and at that time, she came to know that her
parents had lodged a missing complaint in Laxmipura Police
Station. She informed to her acquainted person that she got
married with the respondent and that they would return on
28.02.2023 and accordingly, she went to Laxmipura –
Gorwa Police Station and recorded her statement in the
missing complaint.
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
3.4
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
It is further the case that the appellant - wife came to
know about the written complaint given by the wife of the
respondent namely Minaxiben against her husband i.e. the
respondent on 28.02.2023 and that no divorce had taken
place between the respondent and his first wife. Further, the
respondent with the help of advocates of Vadodara/Padra,
obtained marriage registration form and described himself
as “Unmarried” and that she never got married by
performing the ceremony of ‘Saptapadi’ and had never seen
the two witnesses for registered marriage or the Priest who
had performed the marriage.
3.5
Therefore, the appellant – wife filed suit before the
learned Family Court, Vadodara being Family Suit No.407 of
2023 which came to be rejected by the judgment and decree
dated 25.02.2025. Being, aggrieved and dissatisfied by the
said judgment and decree, the present first appeal has been
preferred by the appellant – wife.
4.
Submissions
made
by
learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant are as under:
4.1
It is submitted that the learned Family Court erred in
failing to appreciate that the respondent – husband’s first
marriage was never legally dissolved by a decree of divorce
from a Competent Court. No cogent evidence was produced
during
the
recognizable
trial
to
custom
establish
within
the
the
existence
parties’
of
any
community
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
permitting divorce through the mere execution of a private
deed. It is further submitted that the respondent – husband
obtained the consent of the appellant – wife fraudulently by
stating that he has obtained divorce from his first wife
legally, however, the respondent – husband has not
produced any documentary evidence to that effect before the
learned Family Court. It is further submitted that in view of
the subsistence of the previous marriage of the respondent,
who otherwise by adopting illegal measures and has
suppressed the material facts and thereby assured and put
the appellant in confidence that his previous marriage had
been dissolved and thereby contracted a second marriage
with appellant herein.
4.2
It is submitted that at the time of registration of
marriage of respondent with the appellant, the respondent
declared himself as ‘Unmarried’ in the marriage registration
form. It is further submitted that the respondent in his
cross-examination admitted that he is having a son named
Darshit with his first wife – Minaxiben and since 2023, his
first wife – Minaxiben has been residing separately. The first
wife – Minaxiben of the respondent filed a missing complaint
against
the
respondent
at
Laxmipura
Police
Station,
Vadodara, whereby his statement was recorded by stating
that from now onwards he would not harass his first wife –
Minaxiben, which itself shows that first marriage of the
respondent is in existence and therefore, his second
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
marriage with the appellant is null and void under the
provisions of law.
4.3
Hence, it is submitted that the learned Family Court
Judge, without appreciating the material evidence on record
and the mandatory provisions of the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955 (for short, ‘the Act’), has committed error by rejecting
the suit of the appellant – wife and not declaring
her
marriage with respondent – husband as null and void
despite clear violation of Sections 5(i) and 11 of the Act.
4.4
Accordingly, it is prayed to allow this first appeal and
the impugned judgment and decree of the learned Family
Court be quashed and set aside by declaring the respondent
– husband’s marriage with the appellant – wife dated
27.06.2022 to be null and void.
5.
Submissions
made
by
learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent are as under:
5.1
Per contra, learned Counsel for the respondent has
submitted that the factum as to the previous marriage of
the respondent with his first wife – Minaxiben and having
blessed with a child was well-within the knowledge of the
appellant and with the aforesaid facts knowingly, the
appellant has contracted the second marriage with the
respondent and therefore, the appellant herein cannot take
the benefit of her own wrong. This aspect has been duly
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
considered by the learned Family Court. Therefore, it is
submitted by learned Counsel for the respondent that the
said suit filed by the petitioner has been rightly rejected by
the learned Family Court Judge and accordingly, submitted
to uphold the impugned judgment and decree and to reject
this appeal.
6.
Having heard learned Counsel for respective parties,
the core issue which requires to be determined is whether
the marriage in question dated 27.06.2022 having been
solemnized with the appellant by the respondent is legal
and valid as per the provisions of the Act or not.
7.
To deal with the aforesaid aspect, relevant provisions
of Section 5(i) and Section 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955 are reproduced herein-below:
...“5. Conditions for a Hindu marriage.-A marriage may be solemnized between
any two Hindus, if the following
conditions are fulfilled, namely;-(I) neither party has a spouse living at
the time of the marriage;
xxx xxx xxx
11. Void marriages.-- Any marriage
solemnized after the commencement of
this Act shall be null and void and may,
on a petition presented by either party
thereto against the other party, be so
declared by a decree of nullity if it
contravenes any one of the conditions
specified in clauses (i), (iv) and (v) of
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
Section 5.”...
8.
Applying the aforesaid provisions to the case on hand,
it is apparent that the respondent has failed to produce any
cogent documentary evidence or a decree of divorce from a
competent Court of law to establish that his first marriage
with Minaxiben was legally dissolved prior to 27.06.2022.
Furthermore, no legally recognized procedure within the
community permitting divorce through private deeds or
mutual
understandings
was
pleaded
or
proved.
The
continuous existence of the first marriage is heavily fortified
by
the
respondent's
own
admission
during
cross-
examination regarding his son, Darshit, and the police
records from Laxmipura Police Station showing that his first
wife was actively pursuing complaints against him around
the timeline of the second marriage.
9.
At this juncture, it would be apt to refer to the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Smt.
Yamunabai Anantrao Adhav vs. Anantrao Shivram Adhav &
Anr., reported in (1988) 1 SCC 530 , wherein, while
examining the status of a Hindu woman marrying a Hindu
male having a living spouse, has categorically held that for
appreciating the validity of such a marriage, the provisions
of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 must prevail. Interpreting
Sections 5(i) and 11 of the Act, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
observed that a lawful Hindu marriage requires that neither
party should have a spouse living at the time of the
marriage, and that a marriage solemnized in contravention
of this condition is null and void.
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
10.
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
In continuation of the aforesaid, even the learned
Family
Court
has
committed
error
by
rejecting
the
appellant’s case. Instead of pursuing whether the legal
provisions of the Hindu Marriage Act were complied with,
the learned Family Court
focused on what the appellant
knew or did not know about the first marriage.
11.
According to the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Smt. Yamunabai Anantrao Adhav
(supra), the rules of the Hindu Marriage Act are strict and
absolute. Once it is proven that the husband already had a
living wife at the time of the second marriage, the court has
no choice but to declare the second marriage null and void.
Therefore, the learned Family Court failed to apply this
mandatory law, making its judgment legally unsustainable.
12.
Section 5(i) of the Act creates an embargo, expressly
enunciating that a marriage may be solemnized between two
Hindus only if neither party has a spouse living at the time
of marriage. In the present case, it is admittedly established
that the respondent – husband had a legally wedded spouse
living at the time he contracted the second marriage with
the appellant herein. Consequently, the respondent –
husband’s second marriage with the appellant is hit by
statutory bar under Section 5(i) of the Act. By operation of
Section 11 of the Act, his second marriage with the
appellant herein becomes structurally ‘void ab initio’.
13.
The factum as to subsistence of the earlier marriage of
the respondent – husband with his first wife namely,
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
Minaxiben, and performing the second marriage during the
subsistence of the previous marriage cannot be said to be
valid, as clearly discussed under Section 5(i) read with
Section 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
14.
In a nutshell, the detailed discussion made in
foregoing paragraphs makes it abundantly clear that since
the question in the case on hand attracts the provision of
Section 5(i) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 as well as the
consequences
of
the
contravention
of
the
aforesaid
provisions, which again, falls within the provision of Section
11 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the learned Family
Court has committed error by solely confining itself that the
appellant had knowledge with regard to the previous
marriage while contracting the second marriage. However,
the said contention does not find any force or legs to stand,
as no material and credence seems to have been filed so as
to constrain the learned Family Judge to come to the
conclusion. Therefore, the conclusion arrived by the learned
Family Judge does warrant interference at the hands of this
Court.
15.
same
Accordingly, the appeal deserves consideration and the
is
allowed.
The
judgment
and
decree
dated
25.02.2025 passed in Family Suit No.407 of 2023 by the
learned Principal Judge, Family Court, Vadodara is quashed
and set aside.
16.
The marriage solemnized between the appellant – wife
and the respondent – husband dated 27.06.2022 is hereby
C/FA/1064/2025(GJHC240226102025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 31/08/2026
declared null and void.
17.
Record and proceeding be sent back to the concerned
Court forthwith.
sd/-
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
sd/(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
PARMAR KRISH
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review