Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment reserved on:21.01.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 05.02.2026
+
W.P. (C) 15086/2025 & C.M. APPL. 62060/2025
PRABHROOP KAUR KAPOOR & ORS.
Through:
....Petitioners
Mr. Rajshekhar Rao, Sr. Adv. With Mr.
Karan Nambiar, Mr. Lzafeer Ahmad B
F, Mr. Abeer Malik, Mr. Shubham
Arun, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANR.
....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Sahaj Garg, SPC for Respondent
No.1, Ms. Manisha Singh, Adv. for
Respondent No. 2
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE JASMEET SINGH
JUDGMENT
1.
The present writ petition has been filed by the petitioners under Article
226 of the Constitution of India seeking to set aside the notifications
dated 04.09.2025 and 15.09.2025 issued by the respondent No. 2.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.
The petitioners are students who have successfully completed their Class
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
XII Board Examinations in 2025 with the schools affiliated to the
respondent No. 2.
3.
The respondent No. 1 is the ministry which serves as the controlling
authority of the respondent No. 2. The respondent No. 2, Central Board of
Secondary Education (“CBSE”) is responsible for conducting Class X
and Class XII board exams inter alia designing and renewing curriculum.
4.
The examinations conducted by the CBSE are governed by Examination
Bye Laws, 1995 (“Bye Laws”). These Bye Laws are amended from time
to time to cater to the needs of changing time. One of such amendment
came in the year 2013 inserting Clause No. 43(i) thereby allowing the
students to appear in an Additional Subject as a private candidate within
six years of passing of the Class XII board examination. In the year 2021,
this time limit to appear in an Additional Subject by a private candidate
was reduced to two years.
5.
Subsequent to passing the examination in the year 2025, the petitioners
decided to take a gap year to prepare for an Additional Subject, i.e. the
sixth subject to enhance their career prospects and to fulfil the eligibility
criteria which mandate the requirement of such Additional Subject.
6.
The petitioners dedicated a full academic year to prepare for the
examination of the said subject with the expectation that the option to
register would still be available to them as per the prevailing policy of
CBSE. However, CBSE on 04.09.2025 issued a public notification for
2026 examination which eliminated the option of “Additional Subject”
category for private candidates who had already graduated. The
corresponding online registration portal which was opened by the CBSE
on 09.09.2025 confirmed the said change in the examination policy.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
7.
The petitioner No. 1 sought clarity regarding the same and sent a detailed
representation to CBSE via email dated 12.09.2025. The removal of
Additional Subject category was brought to the attention of CBSE and it
was further urged to reconsider the said decision to remove such
category. The petitioner No. 1 received the reply to her representation
from CBSE on the same day itself which stated that:a) the CBSE primarily provides education through “Face to Face mode.”
b) the students must have minimum 75% attendance to be eligible for
examination in a subject
c) there was a requirement of continuous internal assessment in all
subjects for which marks were awarded towards the final result.
d) classes X and XII are a two-year programme implying that subject
must be studied in full duration.
8.
On 15.09.2025, CBSE finally issued a formal public notification on its
website, reiterating the same justification provided in the email to the
petitioner No. 1. The notice additionally mentioned that the student not
fulfilling the above criteria shall not be eligible for examination in
Additional Subjects in board examinations as a private candidate. The
notification further drew a clear distinction between CBSE and National
Institute of Open Schooling (“NIOS”).
9.
The petitioners are, thus, aggrieved by the impugned notifications dated
04.09.2025 and 15.09.2025, which render the said decision of removal of
“Additional Subject” option, applicable to them, thereby, allegedly
extinguishing the prospect of admission to higher education programme
that requires a specific combination of subjects. Therefore, the present
petition.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
10. Mr. Raj Shekhar Rao, learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioners, prays for the quashing of impugned notifications dated
04.09.2025 and 15.09.2025 issued by the CBSE in so far as it does not
provide for the registration for Additional Subject to private candidates.
He further seeks direction by this court to direct CBSE to permit private
candidates to register for Additional Subject category so that the prospect
of pursuing higher education programme that requires specific
combination of subjects remains open with the petitioners.
11. He submits that the policy changes to discontinue the Additional Subject
facility was taken in December, 2024. However, the same was neither
notified to the public nor reflected in the examination Bye Laws on the
official website. By failing to communicate the same CBSE denied the
petitioners the opportunity to make an informed decision thereby trapping
them into forfeiting their college seat to take a drop year based on the
existing norm.
12. He further submits that the CBSE Bye Laws operate as law and judicial
scrutiny cannot be undermined by giving them artificial colour. These
Bye Laws are sole governing body of rules that govern their examination.
Therefore, since Bye Laws have force of laws any amendment must be
promulgated in a suitable manner in order to make it effective. Thus, it
will only take effect from the date of such publication. Reliance is placed
on Jigya Yadav v CBSE,1 and B.K. Srinivasan v. State of Karnataka2.
13. He states that by supressing such crucial change CBSE have misled the
(2021) 7 SCC 535.
(1987) 1 SCC 658.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
students into believing that the existing norms continued. This induced
the students to undertake a drop year which will now be a waste for no
fault of the petitioners.
14. Learned Senior counsel states that even though the decision to
discontinue the “Additional subject” facility is an administrative one, the
same creates a substantive disqualification for students who passed Class
XII in 2024-2025 and entered their drop year in April, 2025 based on the
choice they made in Class XI in 2023-24. A policy change cannot be
applied retrospectively to extinguish the rights of students who already
acted upon the decade long policy of CBSE. Reliance was placed on
Anushka Rengunthwar v. Union of India3.
15. It is also stated that the change is hit by the Doctrine of Legitimate
Expectation, fostered by a decade of consistent practice upon which the
petitioners irrevocably altered their academic and professional trajectory.
Reliance is placed on Rakesh Kumar v. Union of India4.
16. He argues that the decision suffers from manifest arbitrariness inasmuch
as it creates an unreasonable classification between similarly situated
candidates of private candidates without any intelligible differentia or
rational nexus. He points out that under the existing examination Bye
Laws a candidate is expressly permitted to appear for an Additional
Subject within a period of two years from the date of passing of Class XII
examination, this two year window constituted a legitimate option
available to all candidates at the time of passing the examination. The
change in examination rules creates an absurdity as, for instance, a
(2023) 11 SCC 209.
2017:DHC:2798-DB
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
student belonging to the batch of 2024 who opts for Additional Subject
was duly allowed to take the Additional Subject examination in the 2025
examination. However, any student of the same who bona fide relied on
the rule and waited for the second year to appear for the Additional
Subject has now been arbitrarily debarred from doing so. Therefore, such
ex facie differential treatment of the students from the same batch is
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
17. He further points out that that the said policy operates retrospectively and
penalises students for exercising a valid and lawful option which was
available for the second year. A right once granted cannot be curtailed
mid-way, retrospectively and without any prior notice. The impugned
policy lacks fairness as on one hand it permits re-examination or
improvement examination but on the other hand it prohibits academic
advancement by way of Additional Subject. Such an approach by CBSE
is not only arbitrary but also unreasonable.
18. Learned senior counsel further submits that in the year 2023, when the
CBSE withdrew the eligibility of female students residing in the
Delhi/NCR region and candidates belonging to the category of students
with special needs from appearing as Private Candidates, a conscious and
equitable decision was taken to incorporate a sunset clause. The said
clause protected students already within the system by providing advance
notice to the next batch and deferring the operation of the withdrawal by
one academic year. In stark contrast, the present policy change has been
implemented abruptly, without any transitional safeguard or prior notice,
thereby adversely affecting students who had already structured their
academic choices and future plans in reliance upon the existing Bye
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
Laws. This clearly demonstrates non-application of mind and complete
disregard to welfare and legitimate expectations of students who are
within the system.
19. It is further stated that CBSE’s contention that the petitioners may
alternatively appear through the NIOS is illusory and does not consider
the prevailing realties of the education system. The leading institutions
including University of Delhi and admissions through Joint Entrance
Examination (JEE) assess the candidate’s eligibility on the basis of one
consolidated marksheet issued by one recognised board. The split
marksheet issued by CBSE and NIOS renders the candidate ineligible
under the subject specific eligibility criteria prescribed by such
institutions. This will defeat the very purpose of the petitioner taking the
drop year and thus the petitioners will be compelled to reappear for a
minimum of five subjects a fresh.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
20. Per Contra, Ms. Manisha Singh, learned counsel for CBSE, at the outset
submits that the petition is not maintainable in law and is liable to be
dismissed. She states that the relief sought by the petitioners is in
violation of the provisions of the examination Bye Laws of CBSE. The
Bye Laws do not permit such Additional Subjects being offered to a
private candidate in the case where they have not studied the said subject
regularly for two years in class IX-X or XI-XII.
21. She further states that the petitioners do not possess any vested right to
opt for or appear in Additional Subjects which they have not studied
regularly. Earlier such students were permitted to opt for the Additional
Subject in terms of provisions of examination Bye Laws which permitted
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
the same. In the absence of such provision, due to the amendment in Bye
Laws, there remains no such provision which enables the petitioner to
claim any legal right to opt for Additional Subject as a private candidate.
She states that admittedly there is no challenge to the amendment itself.
22. It is stated that it the well settled in law that the Doctrine of Legitimate
Expectation does not apply where there is a change or discontinuance of
policy. Once a policy is amended or withdrawn in accordance with law,
no vested or enforceable right survives in favour of those who may have
benefited under the earlier policy. The petitioners, therefore, cannot claim
continuation of a benefit merely on the basis that such benefit was
available under the previous policy regime.
23. She states that the Hon’ble Supreme Court in catena of judgments has
held that no relief can be granted on the basis of Doctrine of Legitimate
Expectation where there is a change in policy, provided such change is
within the authority’s competence and is in furtherance of public interest.
In support, reliance is placed upon Madras City Wine Merchants
Association and Ors. v. State of T.N. &Ors.5and Jiwesh Kumar v. Union
of India6.
24. She states that the petitioners themselves have acknowledged, in
paragraph L of the grounds in the Writ Petition, that the CBSE could
restrict or prevent candidates from appearing in an Additional Subject
only by way of an amendment to the Examination Bye Laws. Pursuant to
the recommendations of the Examination Committee, and upon
ratification and approval by the Governing Body, the provision permitting
(1994) 5 SCC 509.
2024 SCC OnLine Del 2858.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
candidates to opt for an Additional Subject for the first time as private
candidates has been done away with. Consequently, the grievance sought
to be raised by the petitioners does not survive.
25. It is further submitted that the impugned policy has been uniformly
applied by CBSE across the country without any exception. No special or
preferential treatment has been granted to any candidate. The petitioners,
therefore, cannot claim any special right in their favour when all similarly
situated students have been treated alike.
26. Without prejudice to the aforesaid submissions, she states that, in any
event, no prejudice has been caused to the petitioners on account of the
said policy change. Any student who has passed Class X or Class XII
continues to have the option of offering and appearing in an Additional
Subject through the NIOS. The petitioners’ right to pursue further
education or a new course, therefore, remains unaffected.
27. She also submits that the eligibility criteria for competitive and
professional examinations such as NEET and JEE are prescribed by the
respective examining and admitting authorities and not by CBSE. Thus,
CBSE cannot be compelled to continue a policy contrary to its
Examination Bye Laws merely on account of perceived downstream
consequences in such examinations. Moreover, the eligibility norms for
the said professional courses uniformly require a candidate to have
regularly studied Biology or Mathematics, as the case may be, for a
continuous period of two years, along with the requisite practical training.
These mandatory conditions are admittedly not satisfied where a student
seeks to appear in an Additional Subject from the CBSE for the first time
as a private candidate. Such candidates, therefore, do not meet the
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
prescribed eligibility criteria for the said examinations.
28. Lastly, she states that in matters involving educational policy, it is settled
that Courts ordinarily exercise restraint and refrain from interfering, as
such decisions are best left to expert bodies possessing the requisite
domain knowledge. Educational policies are not static in nature and are
required to evolve in response to changing academic needs, requirements,
and dynamics. In support of this submission, reliance is placed upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in All India Council for
Technical Education v. Surinder Kumar Dhawan &Ors.7
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
29. I have considered the rival submissions advanced by the learned
counselsfor the parties and perused the material on record.
Whether notification amending the Clause No. 43 (i) was notified in
accordance with law so as to be made applicable to the petitioners
30. At the outset, it would be relevant to examine the legal status of the
Examination Bye Laws framed by the CBSE. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Jigya Yadav (supra), unequivocally held that the CBSE Bye
Laws are statutory in character, having binding force and regulating the
rights of students. Once framed, they operate as law. Relevant paragraphs
from the said judgment read as under:“117. Reverting to the CBSE Examination Bye-laws, the same
are couched in the form of a code. They provide for all
essential aspects relating to formal education of a student
including
admission,
examination,
migration,
transfer,
curriculum, fee for various services, issuance of verified
(2009) 11 SCC 726.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
certificates, modifications in certificates, etc. This bye-laws,
therefore, bind the parties and are duly enforceable in a court
of law, even by way of writ remedies as we have seen in the
present batch of petitions.
118. To put it differently, the bye-laws of the Board have the
force of law and must be regarded as such for all legal
purposes. It would serve no meaningful purpose to hold these
authoritative set of rules originating from an instrumentality
of the State as mere contractual terms despite there being
overwhelming public interest in their just application.
119. The argument that bye-laws of the Board are contractual
elements as CBSE is a registered society unbacked by a
statute cannot be accepted for at least four reasons — first,
CBSE is not a private corporate body. It is a juristic person
and a “State” within the meaning of Article 12, which in itself
warrants its amenability to the courts including constitutional
writ courts; second, the functions performed by the CBSE
Board are public functions and not private functions; third,
the test of “force of law” takes within its sweep the nature of
rule, its authoritative impact on the subjects, nature of
function performed by the rule-making body, the origin of the
body, the binding value of the rules, existence of any
competing set of rules and fourth, absence of statute does not
automatically render the rules to be contractual terms, as
already observed.
120. As in the ultimate analysis, the bye-laws operate as law,
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
the scrutiny of this Court cannot be undermined by giving
them an artificial colour. For a student enrolled with the
CBSE, there is no other body of rules but the subject bye-laws
for dealing with all significant aspects of her education. By
now it is an established tenet that even body corporates,
cooperative societies, registered societies, etc. can be
declared as instrumentalities of the State, for the only reason
that the outer form of organisation must not be allowed to
defeat the ultimate constitutional goal of protection of
fundamental rights as and when they suffer at the hands of the
State, directly or indirectly. The Court ought to intervene with
circumspection even when the public body derives its
authority from a government resolution.
31. Also, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in B.K. Srinivasan (supra) has held
that subordinate legislation, to be effective, must be duly promulgated
and made known to the public. A rule or regulation, though validly made,
does not acquire enforceability unless it is published or notified in a
manner reasonably capable of coming to the knowledge of those affected
by it. Relevant paragraphs from the said judgment are extracted below:“15. There can be no doubt about the proposition that where a
law,
whether
parliamentary
or
subordinate,
demands
compliance, those that are governed must be notified directly
and reliably of the law and all changes and additions made to
it by various processes. Whether law is viewed from the
standpoint of the “conscientious good man” seeking to abide
by the law or from the stand point of Justice Holmes's
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
“unconscientious bad man” seeking to avoid the law, law
must be known, that is to say, it must be so made that it can be
known. We know that delegated or subordinate legislation is
all-pervasive and that there is hardly any field of activity
where governance by delegated or subordinate legislative
powers is not as important if not more important, than
governance
by
parliamentary
legislation.
But
unlike
parliamentary legislation which is publicly made, delegated or
subordinate legislation is often made unobtrusively in the
chambers of a Minister, a Secretary to the Government or
other official dignitary. It is, therefore, necessary that
subordinate legislation, in order to take effect, must be
published or promulgated in some suitable manner, whether
such publication or promulgation is prescribed by the parent
statute or not. It will then take effect from the date of such
publication or promulgation. Where the parent statute
prescribes the mode of publication or promulgation that mode
must be followed. Where the parent statute is silent, but the
subordinate legislation itself prescribes the manner of
publication, such a mode of publication may be sufficient, if
reasonable. If the subordinate legislation does not prescribe
the mode of publication or if the subordinate legislation
prescribes a plainly unreasonable mode of publication, it will
take effect only when it is published through the customarily
recognised official channel, namely, the Official Gazette or
some other reasonable mode of publication. There may be
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
subordinate legislation which is concerned with a few
individuals or is confined to small local areas. In such cases
publication or promulgation by other means may be sufficient
[Narayana Reddy v. State of A.P., (1969) 1 Andh WR 77].”
32. Thus, it would be apposite to conclude from the above that the CBSE Bye
Laws shall have the force of law. The Bye Laws should be notified in a
manner prescribed by law, if there is no procedure prescribed by law then
the same should be notified through recognised mode of publication.
33. The subordinate legislation has to be enacted by due process. In case of
CBSE, an amendment of the Examination Bye Laws of has to be firstly
passed by the Examination Committee. Thereafter, subsequent to the
approval of Governing Body, the same is to be notified in the public
domain. Any amendment to examination Bye Laws is notified by a
circular on the website of CBSE.
34. In the present case, CBSE on Affidavit has stated that the minutes of the
140th meeting of the Governing Body had been published on the website
of CBSE since 26.12.2024. Thus, the amendment was notified in the
manner prescribed by law.
35. The publication of minutes of the meeting cannot be construed as
notification of amendment of Bye Laws. The same is an internal
document and will have no validity until it is put in the public that too
through the procedure prescribed by law. Prior amendments in Bye Laws,
subsequent to the decision taken by the Governing Body, were duly
notified on the website of CBSE.
36. The publication in the present case was only done on 04.09.2025 for the
first time by deleting the clause which enabled the students to appear as a
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
private candidate. Thereafter, further reasoning was notified only on
15.09.2025. The petitioners qualified the Class XII examination much
before the said notification i.e. on 13.05.2025, when the results were
published. By the time the amendment was notified the petitioners had
already made the decision to take a drop year.
37. Thus, in my considered opinion, the amendment was unjustly applied to
the petitioners without prior intimation. No reasonable person would be
expected to go through the minutes of the meeting of the Governing Body
to list down the decisions taken by the Governing Body. Any amendment
to the CBSE Bye Laws, particularly one which withdraws a benefit or
creates a disqualification, must not only be formally incorporated in the
Bye Laws, but also be adequately notified in advance so as to enable
affected candidates to regulate their conduct accordingly. The same shall
also apply prospectively, i.e from and after the date of notification dated
04.09.2025. Change in policy cannot be made to apply retrospectively
particularly when the same works in the detriment of the beneficiaries.
Doctrine of Legitimate Expectation
38. During the course of arguments, a submission was advanced by the
learned senior counsel for the petitioner, that the facility to appear as a
private candidate existed for more than a decade. Even after 2021
amendment in the said policy, the facility remained for two years. It is the
petitioner’s case that due to the existing practice the petitioner had
legitimate expectations that the they would be allowed to avail the said
facility in the year 2025-26.
39. In this regard, it would be relevant to discuss the Hon’ble Supreme
Court’s decision in Army Welfare Education Society v. Sunil Kumar
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
Sharma8, wherein the essentials for the Doctrine of Legitimate
Expectation were reiterated. The relevant paragraphs from the aforesaid
judgment read as under:
“60. Before parting with the matter, we deem it necessary to
answer the aforesaid submission of the respondents. This
Court in Union of India v. Hindustan Development Corpn.
[Union of India v. Hindustan Development Corpn., (1993) 3
SCC 499] enunciated that the doctrine of legitimate
expectation is a creature of public law aimed at combating
arbitrariness in executive action by public authorities….
61. In Ram Pravesh Singh v. State of Bihar [Ram Pravesh
Singh v. State of Bihar, (2006) 8 SCC 381 : 2006 SCC (L&S)
1986], this Court explained the doctrine of legitimate
expectation in detail as follows: (SCC pp. 390-391, para 15)
“15. What is legitimate expectation? Obviously, it is not a
legal right. It is an expectation of a benefit, relief or
remedy, that may ordinarily flow from a promise or
established practice. The term “established practice”
refers to a regular, consistent, predictable and certain
conduct, process or activity of the decision-making
authority. The expectation should be legitimate, that is,
reasonable, logical and valid. Any expectation which is
based on sporadic or casual or random acts, or which is
unreasonable, illogical or invalid cannot be a legitimate
expectation. Not being a right, it is not enforceable as
(2024) 16 SCC 598.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
such. It is a concept fashioned by the courts, for judicial
review of administrative action. It is procedural in
character based on the requirement of a higher degree of
fairness in administrative action, as a consequence of the
promise made, or practice established. In short, a person
can be said to have a “legitimate expectation” of a
particular treatment, if any representation or promise is
made by an authority, either expressly or impliedly, or if
the regular and consistent past practice of the authority
gives room for such expectation in the normal course. As
a ground for relief, the efficacy of the doctrine is rather
weak as its slot is just above “fairness in action” but far
below “promissory estoppel”. It may only entitle an
expectant: (a) to an opportunity to show cause before the
expectation is dashed; or (b) to an explanation as to the
cause for denial. In appropriate cases, the courts may
grant a direction requiring the authority to follow the
promised procedure or established practice. A legitimate
expectation, even when made out, does not always entitle
the expectant to a relief. Public interest, change in policy,
conduct of the expectant or any other valid or bona fide
reason given by the decision-maker, may be sufficient to
negative the “legitimate expectation”. The doctrine of
legitimate expectation based on established practice (as
contrasted from legitimate expectation based on a
promise), can be invoked only by someone who has
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
dealings or transactions or negotiations with an
authority, on which such established practice has a
bearing, or by someone who has a recognised legal
relationship with the authority. A total stranger
unconnected with the authority or a person who had no
previous dealings with the authority and who has not
entered into any transaction or negotiations with the
authority, cannot invoke the doctrine of legitimate
expectation, merely on the ground that the authority has a
general obligation to act fairly.”
….
63. A reading of the aforesaid decisions brings forth the
following features regarding the doctrine of legitimate
expectation:
63.1.First, legitimate expectation must be based on a right as
opposed to a mere hope, wish or anticipation;
63.2.Secondly, legitimate expectation must arise either from
an express or implied promise; or a consistent past practice or
custom followed by an authority in its dealings;
63.3.Thirdly, expectation which is based on sporadic or casual
or random acts, or which is unreasonable, illogical or invalid
cannot be treated as a legitimate expectation
63.4.Fourthly, legitimate expectation operates in relation to
both substantive and procedural matters;
63.5.Fifthly, legitimate expectation operates in the realm of
public law, that is, a plea of legitimate action can be taken
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
only when a public authority breaches a promise or deviates
from a consistent past practice, without any reasonable basis.
63.6.Sixthly, a plea of legitimate expectation based on past
practice can only be taken by someone who has dealings, or
negotiations with a public authority. It cannot be invoked by a
total stranger to the authority merely on the ground that the
authority has a duty to act fairly generally.”
40. CBSE, constituted under the Government of India Resolution dated
01.07.1929, is the central authority responsible for conducting public
examinations at the secondary and senior secondary levels. In discharging
functions of a public nature which have a direct impact on the right to
education, CBSE performs public duties and therefore falls within the
definition of “State” under Article 12 of the Constitution of India. In the
present case, a clear and enforceable right was created by the insertion of
Clause No. 43(i) in the Bye Laws, which expressly permitted students to
appear for an Additional Subject as private candidates. Initially, this
facility was available for a period of six years from the date of passing the
Class XII examination, which was later reduced to two years by an
amendment in 2021. The petitioners’ claim of legitimate expectation is,
thus, based on a specific right conferred by the Bye Laws and not on a
mere hope or assumption. The examination notifications issued by CBSE
for the years 2022, 2023 and 2024 further reflects a consistent practice of
allowing candidates to avail this facility. Clause No. 43(i) of CBSE
Examination Bye Laws reads as under:43. Additional Subject(s):
(i) A candidate who has obtained minimum Grade D in at
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
least five subjects (excluding the 6th additional subject) under
Scholastic Area A as per the Scheme of Studies and a
Qualifying
Certificate/Grade
sheet
cum
Certificate of
Performance at the Secondary School Examination/passed the
Senior School Certificate Examination of the Board may offer
an additional subject as a private candidate provided the
additional subject is provided in the Scheme of Studies and is
offered within six years of passing the examination of the
Board. No exemption from time limit will be given after six
years. Facility to appear in additional subject will be
available at the main examination only.
41. The said period of six years to appear for an Additional Subject was
subsequently reduced to two years vide circular dated 16.03.2021 which
reads as under:As per Examination Bye-Laws, a candidate who has passed
Boards' Examination can apply for additional subject from the
list of subjects within 06 years of passing the examination.
However, candidate cannot apply for an additional subject
involving practical work. As per approval of the Examination
Committee in its meeting held on 15th December 2020 and
approval of the minutes in the Governing Body meeting of the
Board on 23rd December, 2020, the period for applying for
additional subject(s) has been reduced from 06 years to 02
years only after passing the examination. This rule will be
effective from the 2021 examinations.
42. Even though, CBSE, in the given case, may have reasonable basis to
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
review and modify its examination framework, including the adoption of
an integrated system of assessment including regular face to face mode of
classroom and internal assessments, such considerations do not justify a
deviation from the past consistent practice insofar as the petitioners are
concerned. The petitioners acted in accordance with the existing Bye
Laws and the consistent past practice of CBSE and, therefore, had a
legitimate expectation that after passing Class XII examination on
13.05.2025 the right to appear as private candidates for the Additional
Subject examination, would be available to the petitioners and similarly
placed students like in the immediately preceding years. The sudden
withdrawal of this facility, without prior notice or any transitional
provision, does not meet the standards of fairness required of
administrative action.
43. The justification advanced by CBSE for discontinuing the facility is the
adoption of an integrated system of education and assessment, which
emphasizes face-to-face mode of course and continuous internal
assessment. While such a policy consideration may be relevant for
students who are presently enrolled or who seek to pursue a subject for
the first time within the regular school system, the same rationale does
not reasonably apply to the petitioners, who had already passed their
Class XII examinations and were governed by the existing Bye Laws at
the time of taking a conscious academic decision to pursue an Additional
Subject as private candidates. The petitioners acquired the right to appear
for the Additional Subject at the time when the petitioners qualified the
Class XII examination. The then unamended Clause No. 43 (i) of Bye
Laws, which was available in public domain, bestowed right upon the
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
petitioners and in furtherance, the petitioners took a conscious decision to
take a gap year to enhance career prospects. The petitioners cannot be
penalised by retrospective application of a Bye Laws. The petitioners
became eligible to appear as a private candidate for the Additional
Subject examination right after passing Class XII examination as per the
Bye Laws which were in the public domain at that time. The amendment
to Clause No. 43 (i) of Bye Laws was only in the Minutes of the Meeting
of the Governing Body dated 26.12.2024 and public notice was issued
only issued for the first time on 04.09.2025 and thereafter, on 15.09.2025.
44. Reliance placed on Madras City Wine Merchants Association (supra) by
CBSE to contend that in case of change in policy, question of legitimate
expectation would not arise. The judgement is binding on this Court but
the facts in the present case are distinguishable. As per the facts of
Madras City Wine Merchants Association (supra), the licence was
granted for one year with a clause for renewal subject to payment of
increased privilege amount as may be fixed by the state government in
that respect. The bar licensee in the said case could apply for renewal 30
days before the expiry of the licence. The decision to not renew the
licence was taken much before any licensee could apply for renewal.
Thus, the question of legitimate expectation did not arise. The right was
not conferred already but was subject to payment of required fee. In the
present case, the right has already been conferred to the petitioners back
in May, 2025. Thereafter, the petitioners took the conscious decision to
take a gap year because they were conferred with the right already.
Subsequently, the right was withdrawn in September, 2025 by which time
the petitioners had already altered their position.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
45. The judgment of Jiwesh Kumar (supra) is also distinguishable on facts.
As per the facts of the said case, the petitioners therein, were at the
relevant time were still pursing the course when the requirement for
National Exit Test was introduced in the curriculum to grant licence to
practice as registered medical practitioners. The same policy was not
made applicable to the students who had already been graduated and
obtained medical degrees. Therefore, the only students within the ambit
of the said policy change were those who had not obtained the degree in
question when the policy change was implemented. Thus, there was no
question of policy change being hit by legitimate expectation. This is in
stark contrast to the facts of the present case. The petitioners, herein, had
already passed the Class XII examination and were issued the grade
sheets and much after that the policy change was notified and
implemented. When the petitioners cleared their Class XII examination
i.e. in May, 2025 they had the benefit of two year window to take
Additional Subject as per Clause No. 43 (i) of Bye Laws, which was
taken away retrospectively in September, 2025.
46. The petitioners constitute a limited category of students who had already
acted upon the prevailing policy. Denying the facility results in serious
and irreversible prejudice to the petitioners, who have already invested an
academic year in preparation based on a legitimate expectation.
47. The law laid down in Surender Kumar Dhawan (supra) is also binding
upon this Court that in questions of education policy and academic
matters the Courts are to refrain from interfering. However, the said
judgement also holds that if any provision or principle of law is to be
interpreted, applied or enforced with reference to or connected with
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
education, the Courts are required to step in.9 This Court is neither
required to nor is going into the legality, justifiability or the basis which
has prompted/ necessitated the amendment to the examination policy.
However, this court, in the present case, is concerned with interpretation,
application and enforcement of amendment to Clause No. 43 (i) of Bye
Laws only to the graduates of Class XII of 2025 batch, which is working
to the detriment of the petitioner and is seeking to retrospectively
withdraw a valuable vested right. The applicability was abrupt and thus,
when the actions are arbitrary and unreasonable, it is imperative to
intervene in such a case.
48. CBSE’s submission that no prejudice is caused since students may appear
through NIOS does not cut much ice. The petitioners have demonstrated,
prima facie, that several universities and competitive examination
authorities insist upon a consolidated marksheet from a single recognised
board. The option of NIOS, therefore, cannot be treated as a real or
equivalent alternative, particularly where it compels students to repeat
multiple subjects afresh.
49. CBSE, being the principal national body entrusted with regulating
secondary and senior secondary education, cannot absolve itself of
responsibility to ensure coherence of rules of senior secondary education
with the rules the competitive of examination in this country. Education
system in India is intertwined in such a manner that senior secondary
education is not an isolated stage but forms the foundation upon which
higher and professional education is built. The structure of higher
education admissions in the country is intrinsically linked to the subjects
Supra n. 7, Paragraph No. 13.
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
studied and examinations taken in Class XII.
50. Eligibility criteria for professional courses are framed with reference to
specific subject combinations at the senior secondary stage. For instance,
admission to medical courses through NEET mandates the study of
Physics, Chemistry, and Biology at the Class XII level, while engineering
admissions require Physics, Chemistry, and Mathematics.
51. These requirements presuppose that such subjects have been pursued as
part of an integrated academic curriculum under a recognised Board. In
this context, directing the students who have already passed Class XII
under CBSE to seek recourse through NIOS disrupts the continuity of
their academic record and undermines the coherence of the education
system itself. In such a case the student would have to undergo the
examination of all 5 subjects, which can never be a viable option.
CONCLUSION
52. While the CBSE undoubtedly possesses the authority to amend its Bye
Laws, such power must be exercised in a fair and prospective manner. A
policy change which was not notified in the manner prescribed by law,
which creates a disqualification, without prior notice or transitional
protection and which adversely affects students who have already altered
their position and taken a gap year, cannot be sustained. The impugned
notifications, insofar as they apply to the petitioners who passed Class
XII in 2025 and acted upon the existing Bye Laws, suffer from
arbitrariness, violate the Doctrine of Legitimate Expectation, and fail to
meet the mandate of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
53. For the said reasons, the present writ petition is allowed and CBSE is
directed to take steps within 3 working days to make necessary
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
arrangements for registration of petitioners for Additional Subject
examination for the petitioners.
54. Needless to say, this judgment is being passed in the light of peculiar
facts of the present case wherein the students are graduates of Class XII
of the 2025 Batch.
55. The petition is disposed of along with pending applications, if any.
56. The documents handed over in the Court are taken on record.
JASMEET SINGH, J.
FEBRUARY 5, 2026/(MU)
Digitally Signed
By:MAYANK
14:05:39
W.P. (C) 15086/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review