Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
#
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 19th August, 2026
Date of Uploading :21st August, 2026
CNR No. DLHC011049792025
ITA 770/2025
PR. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 4 NEW DELHI
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Shlok Chandra, SSC along with
Ms. Naincy Jain, JSC.
versus
M/S ANSAL PHALAK INFRASTRUCTURE PVT LTD (NOW
KNOWN AS NEW LOOK BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS PVT
LTD)
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sachit Jolly, Sr. Advocate with
Mrs. Mansha Anand, Mr. Abhyudaya
Shankar Bajpai, Mr. Sohum Dua, Ms.
Saloni Ray, Mr. Ghunaim Siddiqui,
Ms. Yahavi Sharma and Ms. Manvi,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DINESH MEHTA
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNEESH KUMAR GUPTA
JUDGMENT
Per DINESH MEHTA, J. (Oral)
1.
The revenue has preferred the present appeal assailing the order of the
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench: ‘E’ New Delhi (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Tribunal’), passed in ITA No. 5658/Del/2015 on
18.12.2024, whereby its appeal against the order of the Commissioner of
Income Tax (Appeals) (hereinafter referred to as the ‘CIT(A)’) dated
28.07.2015 was rejected.
2.
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
11:43:02
Narrated in a nutshell, the facts germane for the present case are that the
ITA 770/2025
Assessing Officer (hereinafter referred to as the ‘AO’) had made an addition
of Rs. 55 crores under Section 68 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter
referred to as the ‘Act of 1961’) against the assessee for Assessment Year
(AY) 2011-12, alleging that investment made by two companies namely M/s
New Dimension Holdings Ltd. of Mauritius and M/s Velford Ventures Ltd. of
Cyprus, in the respondent-assessee company was unexplained.
3.
The backdrop facts are that during the course of assessment, it came to
the notice of the AO that the above referred two companies had made
investment and subscribed to assessee’s shares and Compulsory Convertible
Debentures (hereinafter referred to as ‘CCDs’) to the tune of Rs. 55 crores,
which raised a doubt in the mind of the AO. Since the amount involved an
international transaction, he made a reference to the Transfer Pricing Officer
(hereinafter referred to as ‘TPO’) while also making a reference to the
Foreign Tax and Tax Research (hereinafter referred to as ‘FT&TR’), who in
due course of time sent their reports.
4.
The AO, having a suspicion that why would two foreign companies
make such a huge investment in the shares of the respondent-assessee,
conducted an enquiry and doubted the creditworthiness of those companies
and vide assessment order dated 31.03.2015 has held that the onus to prove
creditworthiness of the amount so received lay upon the assessee and since it
failed to discharge such burden, he added the amount of Rs. 55 crores under
Section 68 of the Act of 1961 in the hands of the respondent-assessee.
5.
The assessee challenged the above assessment order dated 31.03.2015
by way of appeal before the CIT(A), who allowed the assessee’s appeal vide
its order dated 28.07.2015, after going through the record, additional evidence
which the assessee had produced during the course of appeal being audited
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
11:43:02
ITA 770/2025
accounts of M/s Redfort India Real Estate Fund II LLC, Mauritius, being
parent investor of the original investor companies, who had invested in
respondent-company. Apart from the above, the CIT(A) dealt with the
material, which the assessee had produced before the AO and then recorded a
categorical finding that these two companies of Mauritius and Cyprus had
entered into an agreement with the respondent-assessee due to which even the
name of respondent was changed. He noted that an interest @16% p.a. or 16%
coupon was paid on the CCDs.
6.
The revenue challenged the said order passed by the Appellate
Authority before the Tribunal, which affirmed the findings recorded by the
CIT(A) by way of the order dated 18.12.2024, which is subject matter of
present appeal.
7.
Mr. Shlok Chandra, learned Senior Standing Counsel, firstly pointed
out that the assessment year in question is 2011-12 i.e., prior to the
amendment brought in Section 68 of the Act, 1961 which was introduced with
effect from 01.04.2013 and thus, the AO could well ask an assessee to satisfy
about the ‘source of the source’ and then argued that the AO, having doubt in
his mind about the genuineness of the investment made by the companies of
Mauritius and Cyprus of huge amount of Rs. 55 crores, called upon the
respondent-assessee to explain the investment, which the assessee miserably
failed. He took the Court through the assessment order dated 31.03.2015 and
submitted that the AO having given enough opportunity to the respondent,
has recorded a finding that the respondent-assessee has not produced any
satisfactory reply to justify that why would companies of Mauritius and
Cyprus invest such a huge amount with the assessee, which was a novice in
the real estate business.
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
11:43:02
ITA 770/2025
8.
He argued that since the investment remained unexplained, addition
under Section 68 of the Act, 1961 was totally justified, and therefore, both the
Appellate Authorities have erred in deleting such additions.
9.
Mr. Sachit Jolly, learned Senior Counsel, on the other hand, submitted
that it is an irony that in spite of the material, and due explanation having been
given by the assessee, the AO deliberately did not deal with the same. He took
the Court through para nos. 2 and 3 of the assessment order and pointed out
that the AO had made reference of TPO’s report and he had recorded that the
TPO had given no adverse report, so also the fact that the assessee had
produced in evidence, copy of agreement between the investor companies and
the respondent-assessee. He argued that the factum of 16% CCDs was known
to the AO and yet, he had completely ignored such fact and dealt with only
that part, which suited his view point rather whims, while ignoring the reply,
which served the cause of the respondent-assessee.
10.
He, thereafter, took the Court through the order of the CIT(A) and
submitted that the Appellate Authority has painstakingly gone through the
material available on record and since by that time, the assessee was able to
procure the audited balance-sheet of M/s Redfort India Real Estate Fund II
LLC, Mauritius, being the investor in those two companies which have
invested in respondent-company, the CIT(A) went on to examine the same as
well and recorded a finding in assesee’s favour that the investment was
genuine and duly explained. He submitted that the Tribunal has not only gone
through the order of the CIT(A), but has also reproduced relevant part of the
order of the Appellate Authority which clearly establishes that the demand so
raised by the AO had no legs to stand.
11.
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
11:43:02
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the order of the
ITA 770/2025
Tribunal and the part of the Tribunal’s order where it has reproduced para no.
4.6 of the CIT(A)’s order. The same reveals that the Appellate Authority has
gone through and carefully dilated upon the transaction and recorded finding
that the respondent-company was incorporated on 13.09.2010 in the name of
Phalak Infrastructure Ltd. with the share capital of 1,00,000 by Ansal Group
for carrying out real estate development and the same entered into
investment-cum-collaboration agreement with New Dimension Holdings
Ltd., Mauritius and Velford Ventures Ltd., Cyprus, and as a part of the
collaboration agreement, name of the company was changed to Ansal Phalak
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. with effect from 03.05.2011 and Article of
Association and Memorandum of Association were also revised. It was also
found that on execution of the agreement, both the foreign investors invested
money in the assessee company-New Dimension Holdings Ltd., Mauritius
acquired 25.9% shares of the respondent-company for Rs. 5,70,50,000/-,
while Velford Ventures Ltd., Cyprus acquired 14 shares of the
respondent-assessee for Rs.2,03,000/- and invested Rs. 49,90,47,000/- in
CCDs issued by the respondent-company. It was also found that both these
companies are registered in Mauritius and Cyprus, and are taxpayers in their
respective
jurisdiction.
The
CIT(A)
has
also
recorded
that
the
respondent-assessee had also filed before the AO, copies of the prescribed
Certificate of Foreign Inward Remittance, issued by Hongkong and Shanghai
Banking Corporation Limited setting out all details of remittance, purpose of
remittance, description of remittance like equity shares application money as
well as issue of CCDs. It is also to be noted that the respondent-assessee had
filed copies of audited balance-sheet of both the investors companies. In the
face of these findings recorded by the CIT(A) and as affirmed by the Tribunal,
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
11:43:02
ITA 770/2025
which findings are based on material available on record and the revenue has
not been able to show them to be perverse in any manner. We do not find any
question of law emanating from the order passed by the Tribunal.
12.
We, therefore, reject the appeal.
13.
While dismissing the appeal, we cannot but leave the matter without
making an observation about the way and manner in which the AO has dealt
with the reply and defence of the assessee. When we look at the order of the
CIT(A), we find that the Appellate Authority has dealt with each of the
documents filed by the assessee with great detail and care – while giving page
no. of the paperbook – while the AO has completely ignored them. He has not
even referred to them, let alone dealing with them. We hasten to add that an
adjudicatory process enjoins upon an AO to deal with the reply and
documents filed by the assessee in an objective manner and his duty as an AO
is not only to watch interest of revenue and generate revenue for the country,
but also to judiciously consider the reply and pleas including judgments and
documents which an assessee relies upon or furnishes. Brushing aside or
ignoring documents filed by an assessee leads to breach of principles of
natural justice and hits at the procedural fairness and cause injustice which, in
the instant case, has been meted out to the assessee.
DINESH MEHTA
(JUDGE)
RAJNEESH KUMAR GUPTA
(JUDGE)
AUGUST 19, 2026/v
Signed By:NAMITA
DHYANI
11:43:02
ITA 770/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review