Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 10th February, 2026.
+
ITA 26/2026
PR COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX 4 NEW DELHI
Through:
versus
HCL INFOTECH PVT LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Shlok Chandra, SSC with Ms.
Naincy Jain, JSC.
.....Respondent
Mr. Rohit Jain & Mr. Deepesh Jain,
Advocates.
JUDGMENT
DINESH MEHTA, J. (Oral)
CM APPL. 3575/2026 (Delay in Re-filing)
1. The instant application has been filed under Section 5 of the Limitation
Act, 1963 read with Section 151 of CPC, seeking condonation of 690 days
delay in re-filing the appeal.
2. For the reasons stated in the application, the delay is condoned.
3. The application is allowed.
CM APPL. 3574/2026 (Exemption)
4.
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
5.
The application stands disposed of.
ITA 26/2026
6.
The present appeal arises out of the order dated 15.09.2023, passed by
the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Bench “B”, New Delhi (hereinafter
referred to as the „Tribunal‟), whereby the Tribunal has rejected the appeal
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
that was filed by the appellant against the order dated 06.06.2019, passed by
the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals)-4, New Delhi (hereinafter
referred to as „CIT(A)‟).
7.
The facts giving rise to the present appeal are that the respondent had
initially filed its original return of income on 30.11.2014 declaring a loss of
Rs. 129,36,64,391/- and claimed refund of Rs. 15,38,86,689/-.
8.
During the period interregnum, the respondent had submitted an
application for a composite scheme of arrangement between it, its subsidiary
companies, holding company which came to be approved under Section 391
of the Companies Act, 1956 vide order dated 30.10.2013 passed by this Court.
Accordingly system integration undertaking came to be merged with the
respondent company w.e.f. 01.11.2013 with the appointed date, being
01.01.2013.
9.
Consequent to the merger and the restructuring which had taken place,
the respondent filed a revised return of income on 31.03.2016 and declared a
loss of Rs. 130,25,67,160/- and claimed additional TDS credit/refund of Rs.
10,24,74,419/- making the total refund of the TDS to Rs. 25,63,61,108/-.
10.
It is the respondent's assertion that due to some technical glitch, though
an acknowledgement of filing the revised return was issued but no TDS claim
could be reflected when it filed/uploaded the return. Hence, without any
delay, it filed a complaint before the Centralised Processing Centre
(hereinafter referred to as „the CPC‟) on 04.04.2016 flagging that due to
some technical glitch, TDS credit was not reflected in its return of income,
though it was duly shown in the XML file which was uploaded.
11.
Vide letter dated 06.04.2016, the respondent informed the Assessing
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
Officer as well about the said technical glitch and the factum of having filed
complaint before the CPC. Along with the letter aforesaid, the respondent
furnished a copy of the acknowledgement of the revised return for assessment
year 2014-15; copy of computation of revised return of income; party-wise
list of TDS claimed and screenshot of the complaint lodged with the CPC.
12.
The Assessing Officer thereafter passed an assessment order under
Section 143(3) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as „the
Act of 1961‟). Though he had taken note of the factum of restructuring and
filing of the revised return and made certain adjustments to the income/loss
claimed by the respondent-assessee, but no amount was refunded in relation
to the TDS claim made by the respondent.
13.
On 25.01.2018, the respondent filed an application under Section 154
of the Act of 1961, seeking rectification of the assessment order and claiming
refund of the tax which has been deducted from the payments made to it.
14.
The Assessing Officer passed an order dated 26.04.2018, pursuant to
rectification application so filed by the petitioner and granted a refund of the
entire tax deducted from its source. He, however, did not grant interest under
Section 244A of the Act of 1961 by observing that the delay in claiming TDS
was attributable to the respondent-assessee.
15.
The respondent preferred an appeal under Section 250 of the Act of
1961 before the CIT(A) who allowed the appeal by discussing the facts in
detail and held that there was no delay on the part of the respondent. He,
therefore, held that the respondent was entitled for interest under Section
244A of the Act of 1961.
16.
Against the order of the CIT(A), the appellant-department preferred an
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
appeal before the Tribunal, which affirmed the order passed by the CIT(A)
vide its order dated 15.09.2023.
17.
Mr. Shlok Chandra, learned SSC for the appellant, submitted that the
respondent-assessee had filed its original return of income on 30.11.2014 and
the revised return on 31.03.2016 and thereafter moved rectification
application belatedly, i.e. on 25.01.2018, which was expeditiously disposed
of by the Assessing Officer on 26.04.2018.
18.
Having apprised the Court about the relevant dates, he argued that
having filed revised return on 31.03.2016, the respondent-assessee waited for
about 2 years (22 months), and the same was allowed by the Assessing
Officer without any delay vide its order dated 26.04.2018. He argued that in
the present facts, the interest under Section 244A of the Act of 1961 is not
payable to the respondent. He added that the CIT(A), so also the Tribunal,
have erred on facts and in law inasmuch as the delay in getting the refund is
majorly attributable to the respondent-assessee.
19.
Learned SSC for the appellant invited Court‟s attention towards
sub-section (2) of Section 244A of the Act of 1961 and submitted that in the
event, when the delay in processing of the refund is due to the fault of the
assessee, it is not entitled for refund under Section 244A of the Act of 1961.
20.
In support of his stand, learned counsel relied upon judgment of Kerala
High Court, rendered in the case of State Bank of India vs. The Chief
Commissioner of Income Tax reported in [2022] 286 taxman 650(Kerala)
and submitted that the appeal deserves to be allowed and the orders passed by
the CIT(A) so also the Tribunal are liable to be set aside.
21.
Mr. Rohit Jain, learned counsel for the respondent-assessee, on the
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
other hand, submitted that the facts as narrated by Mr. Shlok Chandra, learned
counsel for the appellant-Department are not complete. He submitted that if
the record and the order dated 06.06.2019 passed by the CIT(A) are
examined, it is clear that the respondent-assessee had to file an application for
rectification because of the subsequent development inasmuch as a scheme of
arrangement was approved by the High Court on 30.10.2013 which came into
effect on 01.11.2013 vide which one unit of System integration business of
the holding company came to be merged with the respondent-company and
due to legal fiction the assets and liabilities of the transferor company became
the assets and liability of the respondent-company, so also the loss of such
company.
22.
He submitted that though the scheme of arrangement was approved by
this Court vide order dated 30.10.2013 with appointed date 01.01.2013 but
after the same was done the accounts of the respondent-company were
recasted which took substantial time and the revised return came to be filed
thereafter.
23.
He submitted that the respondent-assessee was therefore, justified in
filing the revised return on 31.03.2016 and submitted that so far as the period
after the revised return had been filed is concerned, the entire fault lies with
the appellant-department and its software maybe the Assessing Officer is not
responsible for it.
24.
He nevertheless argued that maybe the refund remained pending with
the department because of the fault of the software system but in any case the
respondent-assessee cannot be blamed for the delay as there is none so far as
the respondent is concerned.
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
25.
Learned counsel argued that if provision of sub-section (2) of Section
244A of the Act of 1961 are taken into account, it clearly postulates that the
delay in proceedings should be attributable to the assessee and whether such
period is to be excluded for the purpose of payment of interest under Section
244 is to be decided by the „Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief
Commissioner‟ or „Principal Commissioner or Commissioner‟ and not by the
Assessing Officer. He therefore argued that if any period was to be excluded,
the same could be excluded by the authority mentioned under sub-section (2)
of Section 244 and not by the Assessing Officer himself.
26.
Mr. Rohit Jain, learned counsel for the respondent-assessee, relied
upon the following judgments in support of his submissions:
i.
Ajanta
Manufacturing
Ltd.
v.
Deputy
Commissioner
of
Income-tax; reported in [2016] 72 taxmann.com 148 (Gujarat).
ii.
Chetan N. Shah v. M.K. Moghe, Commissioner of Income-tax-1,
Mumbai; reported in [2015] 53 taxmann.com 18 (Bombay).
27.
Mr. Shlok Chandra, learned counsel for the appellant, in rejoinder
submitted that even if the first part of delay (i.e. from 30.11.2014 to
31.03.2016) is considered, it is to be seen that this Court approved the scheme
of arrangement on 30.10.2013 but the respondent-assessee revised its return
as late as on 31.03.2016 and did nothing besides writing one letter to CPC
dated 04.04.2016.
28.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the relevant material,
including the provision of Section 244A, more particularly, Sub-Section (2)
thereof.
29.
Before dilating upon the basic issue of the time lapse between the filing
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
of the return and acceptance of rectification application, we would like to
reproduce relevant part of the assessment order, which throws light on the
facts evincing as to how the respondent-company lost its right to claim
additional TDS accrued.
“2. The assessee company is engaged business of providing hardware
solutions business, system integration business, security business, sale of
office automation business. During the year the assessee company had a
turnover of Rs. 1442.00 crores as compared to Rs. 569.43 crores in last
year. During the year there was a order of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court
sanctioning a composite scheme of arrangement effective from
01.11.2013 with appointed date of 01.01.2013 between the company and
its holding company namely, HCL Infosystems Ltd. and fellow
subsidiaries companies namely, HCL Services Ltd., HCL Learning Ltd.
and HCL Infocom Ltd. The company HCL infocom Ltd merged with the
holding company. The holding company HCL Infosystems Ltd.
transferred its various undertakings to respective subsidiary company.
Accordingly, holding company transferred the system integration
undertaking to the assessee company effective from 01.11.2013 with
appointed dated 01.01.2013 for Nil consideration. The assessee
company re-casted its accounts forthe period from 01.01.2013 to
31.03.2013 and filed revised return for the A.Y. 2013-14. Further, the
assessee company, re-casted its accounts for the transactions from
01.04.2013 to 31.10.2013 from the accounts of its holding company
namely HCL Infosystems Ltd.”
30.
On perusal of the afore quoted portion out of the assessment order, it is
clear that this is because of the fact that one unit of respondent's holding
company, namely, HCL Infosystems, Ltd. came to be merged with the
respondent, which brought with it assets, liabilities, so also the loss and the
TDS deducted from the payments made to such unit of the amalgamating
company.
31.
As claimed by the respondent-assessee and accepted by the CIT(A), the
respondent-company had to recast its books of accounts to bring the same in
tandem with the order dated 30.10.2013 passed by the Delhi High Court. It is
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
after such recasting of the accounts that the respondent-company filed its
revised return on 31.03.2016.
32.
It is not in dispute that while the revised return was filed by the
respondent-company on 31.03.2016 claiming a refund of Rs. 25,63,61,108/the TDS could not be claimed because of the technical glitch or system error
about which the respondent-assessee had not only informed the Assessing
Officer but had also lodged a complaint before the CPC (ticket number
4039829) by way of communications dated 06.04.2016 and 04.04.2016
respectively.
33.
Maybe the Assessing Officer processed the rectification application
within a reasonable time and has allowed the same vide order dated
26.04.2018 but while doing so, though he allowed the refund of the TDS so
claimed by the respondent but did not pay the applicable interest thereupon as
per Section 244A of the Act of 1961.
34.
It will not be out of place to reproduce sub-section (2) of Section 244A
of the Act of 1961 as the interpretation thereof is the bone of contention
before the rival parties.
“244A....
(2) If the proceedings resulting in the refund are delayed for reasons
attributable to the assessee or the deductor, as the case may be, whether
wholly or in part, the period of the delay so attributable to him shall be
excluded from the period for which interest is payable under sub-section (1)
or (1A) or (1B), and where any question arises as to the period to be
excluded, it shall be decided by the Principal Chief Commissioner or Chief
Commissioner or Principal Commissioner or Commissioner whose decision
thereon shall be final.”
35.
According to us, if a natural meaning is given to sub-section (2) of
Section 244A, it is clear that an assessee is entitled for interest under Section
244A of the Act of 1961 as a matter of course and it is only in exceptional
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
circumstances that the same can be denied in the event of the assessee himself
being in default or remaining at fault.
36.
Looking at the language used in sub-section (2) of Section 244A of the
Act of 1961, we are of the firm opinion that in case, the Assessing Officer is
of the view that the delay in processing the request for refund has been caused
for reasons attributable to the assessee, it is „Principal Chief Commissioner or
Chief Commissioner‟ or „Principal Commissioner or Commissioner‟ who
shall decide the question as to which period is to be excluded.
37.
In other words, in case some period or a part of the period is to be
excluded from the period for the purpose of calculation of interest, this issue
has to be decided by the authorities prescribed under sub-section (2) of
Section 244A. The Assessing Officer himself cannot take onto himself power
and deprive an assessee from the interest payable under Section 244A of the
Act of 1961.
38.
A perusal of the order dated 26.04.2018 shows that the Assessing
Officer had given shoddy reasons for denying the interest by merely writing a
line that “the interest under Section 244A is not allowed in this case as there is
a lapse on the part of the assessee in claiming the same in its revised return of
income”.
39.
Though he has written 7-8 lines to the effect, but the same do not
constitute a valid reason. It will not be out of place to reproduce the so-called
reasons given by him in the impugned order.
“It is pertinent to mention here that at the time of revised return filed by
the Assessee, the TDS was not claimed by the assessee. But as per the
AIR information available on the system, the TDS is reflected in case of
HCL Infotech and HCL Infosystems in their respective 26AS. The
assessee has submitted Indemnity Bond in respect of claim of TDS and
has declared Income in respect of these TDS in the return of HCL
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
Infotech, in compliance to direction of Hon'ble High Court wherein the
scheme of arrangement was approved. The indemnity bond and the said
claim of TDS has been however filed with this application on
31.01.2018. Hence, the interest u/s 244A is not allowable in this case, as
there is a lapse on the part of the assessee in claiming the same In its
revised Return of Income.”
40.
According to us, having recorded assessee‟s contention that the TDS
was though reflected in the Form no.26AS of the respondent-assessee but was
not reflected, when the revised return was filed, the AO ought not to have
denied interest by saying that there was a lapse on the part of the assessee in
claiming the same in its revised return of income.
41.
According to us, the finding as recorded by Assessing Officer was
completely erroneous.
42.
Be that as it may. The CIT (A) has dealt with the facts of the case and
given reasons and recorded a finding while accepting the assessee‟s
explanation and held that there was no lapse on part of the assessee and since
the Tribunal has also affirmed the same, we do not feel that any question of
law, much less a substantial question of law arises, which warrants our
interpretation or answer.
43.
The appeal alongwith pending applications stands disposed of.
DINESH MEHTA
(JUDGE)
VINOD KUMAR
(JUDGE)
FEBRUARY 10, 2026/nk
Digitally Signed
By:NAVEEN KUMAR
11:04:37
ITA 26/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review