Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH SHIMLA
CWP No. 16879 of 2026.
Decided on : 29th September, 2026
Poonam Thakur
...Petitioner.
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
....Respondents.
Coram:
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Vishal Mohan, Senior Advocate with
Mr. Vikram Thakur, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Rajat Chaudhary, Assistant Advocate
General.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge.
Petitioner, aged about 52 years, and currently serving as
Assistant Commissioner (State Taxes and Excise), seeks quashing of
seniority list of Excise and Taxation Inspectors, circulated by the
respondents on 8.11.2013.
2.
Heard and considered the case file.
3.
Petitioner joined the respondent department as an Excise
and Taxation Inspector (ETI) on 05.09.1998. On 26.08.2013, tentative
seniority list of Excise Taxation Inspectors was circulated by the
respondents inviting objections thereto. Admittedly, petitioner did not
prefer any objections to the tentative seniority list of ETIs. Final seniority
list of ETIs depicting the position as on 01.08.2013 was circulated by the
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
respondent department on 08.11.2013 (Annexure P-10). Name of the
petitioner figured at serial number 268 of this final seniority list.
Based upon this final seniority list of Excise and Taxation
Inspectors, the respondents issued notifications from time to time
promoting eligible ETIs to the post of Excise and Taxation Officers, Class-I
(Gazetted).
In this manner, petitioner, on the basis of aforesaid final
seniority list of ETIs circulated on 08.11.2013, was promoted as Excise and
Taxation Officer on 27.09.2017 (Annexure P-14). On 28.07.2021, the
respondent department circulated seniority list of Excise and Taxation
Officers. Petitioner felt aggrieved against this list and laid challenge to it
on several grounds in CWP No. 7305 of 2022, which is pending for
adjudication.
Instant writ petition was instituted by the petitioner on
09.09.2026, seeking quashing of final seniority list of ETIs circulated on
08.11.2013 (Annexure P-10).
4.
Having heard learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner and
on consideration of the case file, the claim of the petitioner has to be
turned down being hopelessly barred by unexplained delay, laches and
acquiescence. It is well-settled principle of service jurisprudence that
settled seniority positions cannot be unsettled after long lapse of time. In
Dr. Ashok Verma vs. State of H.P. and Others 2 relying upon Suresh Kapoor
and others vs. State of H.P. & others3 it was held that there has to be an
element of repose and a stale claim, more particularly to the one relating
to seniority and promotion, cannot be resuscitated. As regards the service
matters, more particularly pertaining to seniority and promotion, the
delay is to be strictly construed, or else it would amount to unsettling the
settled matters after a lapse of time. Seniority is a civil right which has an
important and vital role to play in one's service career. Future promotion
of a government servant depends either on strict seniority or on the basis
of seniority-cum-merit or merit-cum-seniority. Seniority, once settled, is
decisive in upward march in one's chosen work or calling and gives
certainty, assurance and boosts the morale to do quality work. It instills
confidence,
spreads
harmony
colleagues,
which
a
is
and
paramount
commands
respect
factor
good
for
amongst
and
sound
administration. If settled seniority is unsettled, it may generate bitterness,
resentment, hostility amongst the government servants. Relevant portions
from the decision are as under:“4(i).
Legal position may first be noticed:-
In Pervesh Kumari Versus State of Himachal Pradesh &
others (LPA No. 165 of 2022, decided alongwith connected
matter on 14.05.2024), the principle of law that settled
CWP No. 2662 of 2023, decided on 19.11.2024.
CWP No. 1218 of 2021, decided on 01.12.2022
seniority positions cannot be unsettled after a long lapse of
time, as enunciated in several precedents, was noticed as
under:“v) It is well settled principle of service jurisprudence
that settled seniority positions cannot be unsettled after
long lapse of time.
In Dayaram Asanand Gursahani vs. State of
Maharashta & others, (1984) 3 SCC 36, in absence of
satisfactory explanation for delay of nine years in
questioning under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the validity of seniority assigned to the petitioner,
his claim in that regard was held not entertainable.
In B.S. Bajwa & another vs. State of Punjab &
others, (1998) 2 SCC 523, a grievance was raised about
seniority positions by the incumbents in the year 1984
though they had entered the department in 1971-72.
During this entire period of more than a decade they
were all along treated as junior to the other persons.
The Apex Court held that inter se rights had crystallised
which ought not to have been reopened after the lapse
of such a long period; At every stage, the others were
promoted, seniority positions were known to the
aggrieved incumbents right from the beginning. It was
held that in service matters the question of seniority
should not be reopened in such situations after lapse of
a reasonable period because that results in disturbing
the settled position which is not justifiable. Inordinate
delay in making a grievance is sufficient in itself to
decline interference under Article 226 of the Constitution
and to reject the writ petition.
The aforesaid pronouncements were considered
by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Ajay Kumar Shukla &
others vs. Arvind Rai & others, Civil Appeal No.5966 of
2021 along with connected matter, decided 08.12.2021,
where the seniority list in question was held to have
been prepared in contravention to the Recruitment &
Promotion Rules. Hon’ble Apex Court held that the
appointing authority would be bound by the Statutory
Rules and any violation in this regard to the Statutory
Rules would vitiate the seniority list. The same would be
arbitrary, de hors the Rules and in conflict with Articles
14 & 16 of the Constitution. The only exception to above
would be where there is unreasonable delay which is
unexplained.
In this case, the seniority positions finalized on
7.01.2000 and accepted by all concerned were to be
altered by the State vide Office Memo dated 20.02.2020.
The purported premise for alteration was that incorrect
principle was adopted by the State for framing the
seniority list on 7.01.2000. Whether the reason assigned
was justified, correct or not; whether the State had
drawn correct seniority list in the year 2000 or not, is
not important at this stage. What is significant is that
more than twenty years have gone by from the date of
finalization of first seniority list of Patwaris drawn on
7.01.2000. This seniority list has been accepted by all
concerned including the appellants for more than
twenty years. It has been acted upon by the State during
all this period. Promotions of the incumbents have been
effected on the basis of this seniority list. Therefore, on
that ground alone, the seniority list finalized on
7.01.2000 could not have been altered in the year 2020.
In the instant case, seniority list was drawn on 7.01.2000
purportedly on the basis of Rules 15(A) & (B) of the 1992
R&P Rules. It is not that the list was contrary to the R&P
Rules. The only thing that can be said at best is that
Rules were not very happily worded. Be that as it may,
the appellants are deemed to have knowledge of the
seniority list, their seniority positions as well as the
principle on which the seniority list was drawn. Merely
saying now that appellants were not aware of the
seniority list or that they ranked junior to the writ
petitioners in that seniority list, is not sufficient
explanation to unsettle the settled seniority positions.
For more than twenty years, the seniority list was
accepted and acted upon. Promotions had also been
made on the basis of the seniority list. The appellants
have failed to give cogent reasons for not assailing the
seniority list within a reasonable period. The redrawal of
seniority list after more than twenty years would not just
affect a person or two but the seniority positions of
more than 45 persons would be upset. The settled
seniority position could not be unsettled. In R.S. Makashi
& others vs. I.M. Menon & others, (1982) 1 SCC 379, writ
petition was filed eight years after circulation of
seniority list challenging the principles on which it was
drawn. The Court held that belated petitions challenging
the principles of seniority was not maintainable.
Malcom Lawrence Cecil D’Souza vs. Union of
India & others, (1976) 1 SCC 599, holds that it is
essential that anyone who feels aggrieved with an
administrative
decision
affecting
one’s
seniority
shouldact with due diligence and promptitude and not
sleep over the matter. Raking up old matters like
seniority after a long time is likely to result in
administrative complications and difficulties. It would,
therefore, appear to be in the interest of smoothness
and efficiency of service that such matters should be
given a quietus after lapse of some time.
K.A. Abdul Majeed vs. State of Kerala & others,
(2001) 6 SCC 292 holds that after a long lapse of time
the question of initial appointment could not be
reopened at the instance of the private respondents and
that too for altering his seniority.
Shiba Shankar Mohapatra & others vs. State of
Orissa & others, (2010) 12 SCC 471, has held as under:
“30. Thus, in view of the above, the settled legal
proposition that emerges is that once the seniority
had been fixed and it remains in existence for a
reasonable period, any challenge to the same
should not be entertained. In [K.R. Mudgal & others
vs. R.P. Singh & others, (1986) 4 SCC 531], this Court
has laid down, in crystal clear words that a seniority
list which remains in existence for 3 to 4 years
unchallenged, should not be disturbed. Thus, 3 – 4
years is a reasonable period for challenging the
seniority and in case someone agitates the issue of
seniority beyond this period, he has to explain the
delay and laches in approaching the adjudicatory
forum, by furnishing satisfactory explanation.”
It will also be appropriate to take note of the Division
Bench decision of this Court rendered in Devinder Dutt Sharma
Versus State of H.P. & Others4. The petitioner therein was Joint
Director (Health). His seniority as Block Medical Officer, Chief
Medical Officer, Deputy Director (Health) and Additional
Director (Health) was sought to be reviewed by the private
respondent (therein) inis representation. The respondents
therein justified their action of rectifying the seniority list by
submitting that it was in their competence to rectify the errors
in the seniority list, which crept up as the inter-se merit of the
eligible incumbents was not considered appropriately by the
DPC. The Court took strong exception to the action of the
respondents in violating the rules of natural justice in not
hearing the petitioner before passing the adverse order against
him. While allowing the writ petition, the Court inter alia
observed as under on the unsettling of long settled seniority
position and violation of principles of natural justice:“14.
From
the
aforesaid
facts
and
attending
circumstances, it is clearly evident that the petitioner
was initially appointed as a Medical Officer way back in
the year 1992. The final seniority list of Medical Officers
as it stood on 30.03.2000 was issued on 05.03.2001.
Thereafter, the petitioner was promoted as a Block
Medical Officer on 08.11.2010 and the seniority list of
Block Medical Officer was circulated on 25.07.2013. In
the same, the petitioner was senior to Dr. Keshav Ram,
Dr. Harsharan Kaur and Dr. Ghanshyam Upadhaya.
The same was never challenged or assailed by the
aforesaid
three
individuals
subsequent
thereto
promotions were effected to the post of Chief Medical
Officer and the petitioner was promoted to the post of
CWP No.8185 of 2022, decided on 02.11.2023.
Chief Medical Officer on 27.12.2016 w.e.f. 24.05.2016.
Herein again a seniority list was circulated on
08.11.2017. In the said list again, Dr. Keshav Ram, Dr.
Harsharan Kaur and Dr. Ghanshyam Upadhaya were
junior to the petitioner. The same was never assailed
by the aforesaid three individuals.
15.
It is only when a representation is filed on
23.2.2019 by Dr. Keshav Ram that a review DPC is held
on 20.02.2020. In pursuance to the aforesaid review
DPC held on 20.02.2020, vide Notification dated
11.03.2020, the recommendations made for promoting
the petitioner to the post of Block Medical Officer, in
the panel for the year 2010, was altered. As has
already been stated supra, the seniority list pertaining
to Block Medical Officers was circulated vide memo
dated 25.07.2013. No objection qua the same were
ever filed by the aforesaid three individuals namely Dr.
Keshav Ram, Dr. Harsharan Kaur and Dr. Ghanshyam
Upadhaya. Hence, to lay a challenge to the same in the
year 2019 and to get the same reviewed in the year
2020 is patently illegal as the same has not been done
within the prescribed period i.e. 3 to 4 years as laid
down in the aforesaid authoritative pronouncement of
the Apex Court as relied upon by the petitioner.
16.
Besides the aforesaid, once a representation
laying challenge to the seniority assigned to the
petitioner had been filed by Dr. Keshav Ram on
23.02.2019. A copy of the same should have been
forwarded to the petitioner for his response. The same
was essential in order to comply with the Rules of
natural justice, as the allowing of the aforesaid
representation was to have serious civil consequences
on the petitioner. Rather than following the aforesaid
procedure, the respondents-authority held a review
DPC made alterations in the settled seniority of Block
Medical Officer. Thereafter, held a review DPC on
03.12.2021, whereby the date of promotion of the
petitioner to the post of Chief Medical Officer was
changed from 24.05.2016 to 09.01.2017 and further a
recommendation to withdraw promotion of the
petitioner to the post of Joint Director had also been
taken.
19.
For
the
aforesaid
reasons,
the
impugned
Notification dated 28th December, 2021 is quashed in
so far as it pertains to the petitioner. The respondents
are directed to restore the seniority of the petitioner
prior to the DPCs conducted on 20.02.2020 and
13.12.2021 with all consequential benefits.”
While dismissing the Letters Patent Appeal preferred against
aforesaid decision in Dr. Amit Gupta vs. Dr. Ashok Verma and Others 5
Hon'ble Division Bench held as under:
“8. The Apex Court way back in 1974 in P.S. Sadasivcaswamy v.
State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 1974 SC 2271 has held that the issue
of promotion and seniority, as such, had to be contested at the
earliest, preferably within six months and even one year’s grace
can be granted. In the present case, as noticed, from 2015 till
the 1st representation filed on 08.02.2021, a period of six years
had elapsed and the present appellant had consented and
accepted the fact that the writ petitioner was senior to him.
Thus, the Secretary had upset the well-settled seniority in the
Institute by placing the appellant at a position above the writ
petitioner without even adhering to the basic principles and
violating the principles of natural justice openly.
8(A).
The Apex Court has examined the said principle of
delay and laches in High Court of Judicature of Patna Versus
Madan Mohan Prasad and others, (2011) 9 SCC 65. Similarly,
in Vijay Kumar Kaul and others Versus Union of India and
others, (2012) 7 SCC 610, the Apex Court has held that the
claim for seniority is to be put-forth at the earliest and belated
approach is impermissible and equity which may exist in favour
of one melts into total insignificance and goes to the path of
LPA No. 223 of 2025, decided on 16.09.2025
extinction. Similarly, in State of Uttaranchal and another
Versus Shiv Charan Singh Bhandari and others, (2013) 12
SCC 179, the stale claims were not held liable to be entertained
by the Tribunal while noting the earlier decision in C.
JacobVersus Director of Geology and Mining, 1 (2008) 10 SCC
115, that consideration of representations, as such, would
revive the stale and dead claims and resultantly, the orders
passed by the Court below were set aside.
9.
In such circumstances, we are of the considered opinion
that the view which has been taken by the learned Single Judge,
does not require any interference and the appellant had to
agitate for his cause and fixation of his seniority at the earliest
in the years 2015-2016 and thereafter having accepted the
promotion of the writ petitioner, now cannot turn around and
claim to be placed at a higher pedestal. Resultantly, there is no
plausible reason to entertain the present appeal, which is
accordingly dismissed.”
Hon’ble Apex Court in The State of Tamil Nadu vs. R.
Sasipriya6 has reaffirmed the principle that fence sitters are barred from
raising dispute regarding seniority or challenging promotion order once
matter has reached its conclusion; That no party can claim relief as a
matter of right; One of the well recognized grounds for refusing relief is
that the person approaching the Court is guilty of delay and laches.
A
court exercising public law jurisdiction does not encourage the agitation
of stale claims, particularly in matter of seniority and promotion, where
the rights of third parties have crystallized in interregnum.
Civil Appeal Nos. 6883-6884 of 2026, decided on 04.03.2026.
In the instant case, admittedly, tentative seniority list of
Excise & Taxation Inspectors (ETIs) was circulated by the respondents on
26.8.2013. Petitioner did not object to the aforesaid list. Final seniority list
was circulated on 8.11.2013. It is not the case of the petitioner that
aforesaid lists were not to her knowledge at the relevant time. Based upon
the aforesaid seniority list, respondents have been making further
promotions to the post of Excise and Taxation Officers from time to time.
Petitioner herself has been the beneficiary of such an exercise, as vide
notification dated 27.9.2017, she was promoted to the post of Excise and
Taxation Officer. Petitioner had certain grievances to the seniority list of
ETOs that was circulated by the respondents on 28.7.2021. She took legal
recourse against the said seniority list by instituting CWP No. 7305 of
2022. Even at that stage, petitioner did not challenge the seniority list of
ETIs circulated on 8.11.2013. At this stage, her claim against the seniority
list of 8.11.2013 is highly belated, stale and suffers from acquiescence as
well. The petitioner cannot be allowed to lay challenge to the aforesaid
seniority list after lapse of 13 years, more so when she had taken legal
recourse in the year 2022 against the seniority list (dated 28.07.2021) of
Excise and Taxation Officers, i.e. the post to which she was promoted on
27.09.2017 on the basis of her position in the seniority list of ETIs dated
08.11.2013. Hence, there is no merit in this writ petition and the same is
dismissed. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
29th September, 2026.
(jai)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review