Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 16.09.2026
Date of Decision: 01.10.2026
Uploaded on : 01.10.2026
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010586462012
CRL.M.C. 2222/2012 & CRL.M.A. 7884/2012
POONAM TANWAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Aditya Rawat and Mr. B.
Karunakaran, Advs.
versus
STATE & ORS
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Ajay Vikram Singh, APP, Mr.
Shishir Mathur, Ms. Chhavi Gupta,
Advs. for R-2 to R-6. SI Pooja
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
JUDGMENT
MADHU JAIN, J.
1.
The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has
been filed by the petitioner seeking setting aside of the order dated 11.01.2012
passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-03, South District, New
Delhi in Criminal Revision No. 24/2010, whereby the revision preferred by
respondent Nos. 2 to 6 against the order dated 02.06.2010 of the learned Trial
Court was partly allowed. Vide the impugned order, respondent Nos. 2 to 6
were discharged with respect to the offence punishable under Section 406 of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 [hereinafter referred to as ‘IPC’] and the charge
under Section 498-A IPC was set aside qua respondent Nos. 3 to 6, while
respondent No. 2 was directed to face trial for the offence under Section 498A IPC.
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
FACTS
2.
The present proceedings arise out of matrimonial disputes between the
petitioner and respondent No. 2. As recorded in the complaint, their marriage
was solemnised in February 2003, according to Hindu rites and ceremonies.
The petitioner joined her matrimonial home at Village Naraina, New Delhi,
on 21.02.2003. Respondent Nos. 3 and 4 are her father-in-law and mother-inlaw, respectively. Respondent Nos. 5 and 6 are her sisters-in-law.
3.
According to the petitioner, shortly after the marriage, respondent Nos.
2 to 6 began harassing her for bringing insufficient dowry and demanded
₹5,00,000/- and a Maruti Esteem car from her parents. She alleged, that she
was subjected to physical and verbal abuse in connection with these demands
and that respondent No. 2 compelled her to withdraw money from her bank
account and hand over her earnings to him.
4.
The petitioner conceived in November 2003 whereafter, she alleged,
that respondent No. 5 administered medicines to her on the representation that
these were beneficial for her pregnancy. According to her, when she
developed complications in January 2004, the respondents did not arrange
adequate medical treatment. She further alleged that respondent No. 2
declined to give his consent for the medical procedures that were advised to
her at the hospitals where she was being examined. On 11.02.2004, the
petitioner suffered a miscarriage at Sawan Neelu Angels Nursing Home,
Saket. She also states that the expenses of her treatment were borne by her
father.
5.
Thereafter, the petitioner returned to her matrimonial home on
24.02.2004. According to her, the harassment continued, and she was
compelled to resume household work and her employment, despite her
medical condition. She alleged that she was turned out of the matrimonial
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
home on 20.05.2004 and that subsequent efforts by her family to resolve the
disputes were also unsuccessful.
6.
On 19.08.2004, respondent No. 2 instituted a petition seeking divorce.
The petitioner alleged, that on 31.08.2004, her father approached the
respondents to resolve the matrimonial disputes, but they reiterated their
demands. She further alleged that her jewellery, cash, fixed deposits [FDs],
household articles and clothes remained with different members of her
matrimonial family and were not returned despite there being demands made
by her for the same. That she was again assaulted by respondent No. 2 when
she visited his shop with her brother on the day she went back to her
matrimonial home on 03.09.2004, following which she underwent a medical
examination and approached the police.
7.
The petitioner then submitted a complaint dated 08.09.2004 to the
Crime Against Women Cell [hereinafter referred to as ‘CAW’], Amar
Colony, against respondent Nos. 2 to 6 as a result of which an inquiry was
conducted into the complaint, during which the parties were called and the
allegations were examined. FIR No. 775/2005 was subsequently registered at
Police Station Malviya Nagar, District South, Delhi, under Sections 498-A
and 406 read with Section 34 of the IPC. Upon completion of the
investigation, a charge-sheet was filed against respondent Nos. 2 to 6 on
08.06.2006. Cognizance was taken on the same date, and the accused persons
were summoned.
8.
In the meantime, the divorce petition instituted by respondent No. 2
was dismissed by the learned Additional District Judge, Rohini Courts,
Delhi, vide judgment dated 30.04.2009.
9.
Vide order dated 02.06.2010, the learned Metropolitan Magistrate
[MM] directed framing of charges against respondent Nos. 2 to 6 under
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
Sections 498-A and 406 of IPC. The learned Magistrate observed that the
complaint contained specific allegations of dowry demands and beatings
against the accused persons, as well as allegations concerning the retention
and non-return of the petitioner’s dowry articles.
10.
Respondent Nos. 2 to 6 challenged the said order by filing Criminal
Revision No. 24/2010 and vide the impugned order dated 11.01.2012, the
learned Additional Sessions Judge-03, South District, Saket Courts, New
Delhi, partly allowed the concerned revision petition in the following terms:
Party/Parties
Status after the passing of the impugned
order
Respondent No.: 2
Discharged under Section 406 IPC
[Husband]
Not Discharged under Section 498-A IPC
Respondent Nos.: 3 – 6
Discharged, both under Sections 498-A IPC
[Father-in-law, Mother-in-
and 406 IPC
law, Sisters-in-law]
11.
The learned Revisional Court considered the complaint, the CAW Cell
inquiry and the medical material, and held that the material justified
proceeding under Section 498-A IPC against the husband alone. In relation to
Section 406 IPC, it held that the complaint lacked specific particulars of
entrustment of articles to the individual accused persons. It also took note of
the offer by the respondents to return the istridhan articles and their
subsequent deposit in the malkhana pursuant to the Court’s directions.
12.
Pursuant to the aforesaid revisional order, a charge under Section 498-
A IPC was framed against respondent No. 2 on 28.03.2012 wherein he
pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order dated
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
11.01.2012, the petitioner instituted the present petition under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India. Notice in the present case was issued on 13.02.2013.
13.
During the pendency of the present petition, respondent No. 2 was
acquitted under Section 498-A IPC by the learned Metropolitan Magistrate03, Mahila Court, South District, Saket Courts, New Delhi, vide judgment
dated 15.12.2022. The learned Magistrate recorded that the petitioner and her
mother could not be served despite repeated efforts and had therefore been
dropped from the list of witnesses. The petitioner’s father had also passed
away. In the absence of their testimony, the learned Magistrate held that the
remaining formal witnesses could not establish the prosecution’s case and
thereby, acquitted respondent No. 2.
14.
The petitioner thereafter filed CRL.M.A. 19546/2023 in the present
proceedings, seeking to set aside the aforementioned judgment of acquittal.
On 26.07.2023, the application was dismissed as withdrawn, with liberty to
initiate appropriate proceedings to challenge the said judgment.
15.
Subsequently, on 17.07.2026, this Court was informed that respondent
No. 3, Mr. Sube Singh, had passed away. Accordingly, the proceedings
against him were recorded as ‘abated’.
SUBMISSIONS ADVANCED
On behalf of petitioner
16.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the learned
Revisional Court exceeded the permissible scope of scrutiny at the stage of
framing of charge by undertaking a detailed assessment of the credibility and
sufficiency of the prosecution material. It is contended that the complaint
discloses specific incidents, dates and acts attributable to the accused persons,
which, taken at their face value, warranted framing of charges. That the truth
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
of those allegations and the explanations offered by the accused were matters
for trial.
17.
With regards to the offence under Section 406 IPC, the learned counsel
submits that the finding concerning the absence of entrustment is contrary to
the complaint itself. It is submitted that the petitioner specifically stated, that
her jewellery was with her mother-in-law, that the FDs and cash were with
her husband, that the furniture, television, air conditioner and other household
articles were with her father-in-law, and that her clothes and other personal
articles were with her sisters-in-law. It is submitted that the complaint further
records, that these articles were entrusted to the accused persons and were not
returned despite there being demands for the same. The learned counsel also
refers to the petitioner’s account of the Lagan ceremony held on 16.02.2003,
when the dowry articles were handed over to the matrimonial family.
According to the learned counsel, these averments could not have been
rejected as being vague without permitting the petitioner to lead evidence in
this regard.
18.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the allegations
under Section 498-A IPC extend beyond a general assertion of matrimonial
discord as the complaint describes repeated demands for ₹5,00,000/- and a
Maruti Esteem car, accompanied by threats of expulsion from the matrimonial
home. Particular exception is taken by the learned counsel to the Revisional
Court’s reasoning that a demand for the LXI variant was improbable because
it was not the highest model available. It is submitted that this reasoning rests
on conjecture, introduces a defence not advanced by the accused themselves,
and affords no basis for rejecting the allegation at the stage of charge.
19.
Learned counsel also assails the inference drawn from the petitioner’s
willingness to return to her matrimonial home. It is submitted that a woman’s
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
effort to preserve her marriage cannot, by itself, discredit her allegations of
cruelty or dowry-related harassment. That the social circumstances in which
a woman seeks reconciliation, including the stigma associated with the
breakdown of marriage, cannot be disregarded. It is on the basis of the
aforesaid that it is submitted, that the petitioner’s desire to resume
cohabitation was not inconsistent with her complaint.
20.
Adverting to the allegations concerning the petitioner’s pregnancy,
learned counsel submits that a specific role was attributed to respondent No.
5, who was then a dental student, that she administered medicines to the
petitioner under the guise of nutritional supplements, following which the
petitioner developed complications during her pregnancy. He further submits
that there are occasions on which medical assistance was allegedly withheld
and respondent No. 2 declined to consent to the treatment that was advised,
culminating in petitioner’s miscarriage. It is urged that the sisters-in-law’s
attendance at college did not answer these specific allegations or justify their
discharge.
21.
Learned counsel disputes the contention that the complaint was a
counterblast to the divorce proceedings by stating that respondent No. 2 relied
upon a pathological report suggesting that the petitioner suffered from the
herpes simplex virus to seek dissolution of the marriage and that the
subsequent medical evaluation at AIIMS did not support this allegation, and
the divorce petition was therefore, dismissed. According to the learned
counsel, the Revisional Court failed to give due consideration to these
circumstances while accepting the respondents’ explanation for the
matrimonial dispute.
22.
Lastly, the learned counsel submits that the opinion expressed during
the CAW Cell inquiry did not bind the learned Magistrate, who was required
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
to independently consider the complaint and the material accompanying the
charge-sheet. That the alleged acts occurred within the matrimonial home,
that the petitioner’s testimony was material to their determination and that its
credibility and evidentiary worth could be assessed only at trial. It is
accordingly urged that the impugned order be set aside and the order directing
framing of charges be restored.
On behalf of private respondents
23.
Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the private respondents
supports the impugned order and submits that the learned Revisional Court
examined the complaint, the CAW Cell inquiry and the medical record before
distinguishing the allegations against the husband from those directed
collectively against his relatives. It is contended that the allegations of dowry
demands and harassment against the family members were general and
repetitive in nature, without sufficient material connecting each of them to the
alleged offences.
24.
Learned counsel submits that the complaint was lodged in September
2004, after respondent No. 2 instituted divorce proceedings on 19.08.2004.
Relying upon the CAW Cell inquiry, it is urged by the learned counsel that
the matrimonial differences arose following the medical report concerning the
petitioner and that the subsequent criminal complaint was a counterblast to
the divorce petition filed by respondent no. 2. The learned counsel places
reliance on the detailed inquiry conducted, preceding registration of the FIR,
which ultimately recommended proceedings against the husband alone. It is
submitted that no additional material warranting prosecution of the other
family members was brought on record.
25.
In relation to Section 406 IPC, the learned counsel submits that the
complaint does not contain the necessary particulars of entrustment to the
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
individual accused persons. That it does not adequately identify, when, by
whom and to whom the articles were entrusted, or the circumstances in which
they were allegedly misappropriated. According to the learned counsel, an
assertion that certain articles remained in the custody of members of the
matrimonial family does not, without the requisite particulars, establish a
prima facie case of criminal breach of trust. It is further pointed out, that the
respondents offered to return the istridhan articles, but the petitioner declined
to
receive
them,
following
which
they
were
deposited
in
the malkhana pursuant to the Court’s directions.
26.
The learned counsel further submits that the allegation concerning the
administration of harmful medicines is unsupported by the contemporaneous
medical material. Reliance in this regard is placed upon the medical record
describing the miscarriage as being spontaneous in nature. It is contended that
no history of forced medication was disclosed to the attending doctor and that
the record did not connect the miscarriage with any act of the sisters-in-law
or other family members. The Revisional Court was, contended, therefore to
be justified in considering this material while examining whether there was a
basis to proceed against them or not.
27.
As regards the sisters-in-law, the learned counsel submits that the
inquiry disclosed that they were pursuing their respective courses and
ordinarily remained at college during the day. It is urged that the complaint
was filed to merely implicate the entire matrimonial family without there
being any material establishing their individual involvement. Reliance is
placed upon Neelu Chopra v. Bharti, (2009) 10 SCC 184, for stating the
requirement, that the concerned complaint must disclose the acts and role
attributed to each accused, Geddam Jhansi v. State of Telangana, 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 263 to caution against proceeding indiscriminately against
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
relatives in the absence of specific allegations and prima facie material of
their involvement and Digambar v. State of Maharashtra, 2024 SCC OnLine
SC 3836 for maintaining a distinction between a general allegation of cruelty
and conduct satisfying the ingredients of Section 498-A IPC.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
28. This Court has heard the learned counsels for the respective parties and
has also perused the material placed on record.
29. The challenge in the present case is to the order dated 11.01.2012 vide
which the learned Revisional Court retained the prosecution of respondent
No. 2 under Section 498-A IPC, while directing discharge of the other accused
persons under this very provision and of all the accused persons including
respondent No. 2 under Section 406 IPC.
30. Therefore, the questions that require consideration of this Court in this
judgment are whether the determination arrived at by the learned Sessions
judge in the impugned order, transgressed the permissible limits of scrutiny at
the stage of charge and whether any error warranting the exercise of
supervisory jurisdiction by this Court is disclosed.
Scope of jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
31. The jurisdiction invoked under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is
supervisory and corrective in nature, and does not confer a further right of
appeal on facts. In Garment Craft v. Prakash Chand Goel, (2022) 4 SCC
181, the Hon’ble Supreme Court explained that the High Court in exercise of
its supervisory jurisdiction does not reappreciate the material as a court of first
appeal, or substitute its own factual conclusion merely because another view
might be possible. The relevant portion of the aforesaid judgment reads as
under:
“15. Having heard the counsel for the parties, we
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
are clearly of the view that the impugned order¹
is contrary to law and cannot be sustained for
several reasons, but primarily for deviation from
the limited jurisdiction exercised by the High
Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India. The High Court exercising supervisory
jurisdiction does not act as a court of first appeal
to reappreciate, reweigh the evidence or facts
upon which the determination under challenge is
based. Supervisory jurisdiction is not to correct
every error of fact or even a legal flaw when the
final finding is justified or can be supported.
The High Court is not to substitute its own
decision on facts and conclusion, for that of the
inferior court or tribunal.³ The jurisdiction
exercised is in the nature of correctional
jurisdiction to set right grave dereliction of duty
or flagrant abuse, violation of fundamental
principles of law or justice. The power under
Article 227 is exercised sparingly in appropriate
cases, like when there is no evidence at all to
justify, or the finding is so perverse that no
reasonable person can possibly come to such a
conclusion that the court or tribunal has come
to. It is axiomatic that such discretionary relief
must be exercised to ensure there is no
miscarriage of justice.” [Emphasis Supplied]
32. It is needless to state, that the aforesaid restraint does not insulate an
order which ignores material allegations or applies a legally impermissible
standard. But what it requires the Court to do, is to identify an error, affecting
the determination of the dispute, rather, than undertaking an unrestricted
reconsideration of the dispute.
33. In the context of proceedings at the criminal side, Amit Kapoor v.
Ramesh Chander, (2012) 9 SCC 460, emphasises the limited character of
interference with orders concerning charge, the need to correct patent
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
illegality or perversity, and the prohibition against a meticulous assessment of
whether the prosecution will ultimately secure a conviction or not. A relevant
portion of the aforesaid, is extracted hereinunder:
“27.3. The High Court should not unduly
interfere. No meticulous examination of the
evidence is needed for considering whether the
case would end in conviction or not at the stage
of framing of charge or quashing of
charge.”[Emphasis Supplied]
34. The controlling inquiry in cases of the present kind remains, whether the
prosecution material supplies a sufficient foundation for presuming
commission of the alleged offence or not. In Union of India v. Prafulla
Kumar Samal, (1979) 3 SCC 4, the Hon’ble Supreme Court recognised the
power to sift the material for the limited purpose of determining whether a
prima facie case exists, while expressly excluding a roving inquiry into the
merits. Neither a mechanical acceptance of the accusation nor an evaluation
of proof as at the conclusion of trial is permissible at this very stage.
35. Of particular relevance is Onkar Nath Mishra v. State (NCT of Delhi),
(2008) 2 SCC 561, which also concerned charges under Sections 498-A and
406 IPC arising out of a matrimonial complaint. The portion relevant for
present purposes is as under:
“11. It is trite that at the stage of framing of
charge the court is required to evaluate the
material and documents on record with a view to
finding out if the facts emerging therefrom, taken
at their face value, disclosed the existence of all
the ingredients constituting the alleged offence.
At that stage, the court is not expected to go deep
into the probative value of the material on record.
What needs to be considered is whether there is
a ground for presuming that the offence has
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
been committed and not a ground for convicting
the accused has been made out. At that stage,
even strong suspicion founded on material
which leads the court to form a presumptive
opinion as to the existence of the factual
ingredients constituting the offence alleged
would justify the framing of charge against the
accused in respect of the commission of that
offence.” [Emphasis Supplied]
36. These principles therefore, govern the scrutiny of the impugned order in
the present case and as is clear from the aforesaid discussion, they do not
authorise this Court to conduct the trial which neither of the courts below were
required to conduct at that stage.
37.
Having noticed the governing principles, the challenge to the impugned
order must now be examined separately in relation to each of the offences
alleged. The question is not whether upon an independent assessment of the
material, this Court might have preferred the view taken by the learned
Magistrate, but whether, the conclusion reached by the learned Revisional
Court is so unsupported by the material, or so contrary to the governing legal
principles, so as to warrant correction by this Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
Section 498-A IPC
38.
Section 498-A IPC, insofar as the present petition is concerned,
contemplates two forms of cruelty. The first is wilful conduct of such a nature
as is likely to drive the woman to commit suicide or cause grave injury or
danger to her life, limb or health. The second is harassment directed towards
coercing her, or a person related to her, to meet an unlawful demand for
property or valuable security. The material on record must, therefore, disclose
conduct attributable to the concerned accused person[s], which bears the
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
character required by either clause of the Explanation to the concerned
provision i.e. 498-A IPC.
39.
Now where several relatives of the husband are sought to be
prosecuted, the complaint must be examined to ascertain whether it discloses
their respective participation in the alleged acts or not. The caution expressed
in Neelu Chopra v. Bharti, (2009) 10 SCC 184, and Kahkashan Kausar v.
State of Bihar, (2022) 6 SCC 599, does not permit the Court to disbelieve a
matrimonial complaint merely because several members of the family have
been named. It does, however, requires the Court to distinguish, a rolespecific allegation from a collective attribution made indiscriminately against
the entire family.
40.
In the present case, the complaint alleges that respondent Nos. 2 to 6
collectively demanded ₹5,00,000/- and a Maruti Esteem car and that the
petitioner was subjected to taunts, abuse and beatings. Similar collective
expressions have been employed while alleging that the petitioner was
compelled to resume employment, hand over her salary and withdraw money
from her bank account. In contrast, the allegation concerning the payment of
₹55,000/- is specifically attributed to respondent No. 2, the husband, to whom
the said amount is alleged to have been handed over. The incidents of physical
assault dated 22.01.2004, 29.06.2004 and 03.09.2004 are also attributed
principally to him. Thus, although certain dates have been mentioned, the
allegations against the other relatives continue, in material part, to proceed
upon a common attribution to all the accused persons without identifying their
respective acts.
41.
Insofar as respondent No. 4, the mother-in-law, is concerned, the
separate allegation is that, a few days after the petitioner returned to the
matrimonial home on 24.02.2004, she was required to perform household
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
work despite her physical condition. Now this allegation is not connected to
any demand for dowry on that occasion. Even if taken at its face value, it does
not, without further material, disclose wilful conduct of the nature and degree
contemplated by clause (a) of the Explanation to Section 498-A IPC. Every
insensitive or objectionable act occurring within a matrimonial household
does not, by itself, assume the character of statutory cruelty.
42.
The sisters-in-law are principally alleged to have taunted the petitioner
regarding her appearance and the dowry brought by her. Those allegations
remain part of the collective narrative against the family and do not identify
any distinct act by either sister-in-law, that might be connected with a
particular unlawful demand. A separate allegation is undoubtedly made
against respondent No. 5 that she caused the petitioner to consume medicines
during pregnancy by representing them to be nutritional supplements. The
learned Revisional Court, however, also had before it the medical material
collected during the investigation wherein the records described the
miscarriage as “spontaneous” and did not contain any contemporaneous
history of forcible administration of medicines
43.
Moving forward, the recommendation made by the concerned ACP
after the CAW Cell inquiry, to proceed against the husband alone was not
binding upon the criminal court and could not substitute the Court’s
independent assessment. It nevertheless formed part of the material collected
during the investigation. The learned Revisional Court could take it into
account as a corroborative circumstance, provided its ultimate conclusion
rested upon its own scrutiny of the allegations and the accompanying material.
44.
This Court must, at the same time, express its disapproval of certain
observations contained in the impugned order. The improbability attributed to
the demand merely because the LXI variant was not the highest model of the
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
vehicle was founded upon conjecture. Equally, the petitioner’s attempt to
return to the matrimonial home could not be treated as inherently inconsistent
with her allegations. The generalised observations concerning women
implicating the relatives of their husbands were also unnecessary and could
not constitute a lawful basis for discharge. These reasons are accordingly
eschewed from consideration.
45.
The presence of such observations does not, however, require the
impugned order to be set aside if its ultimate accused-wise conclusion is
independently supportable on legally relevant material. The allegations
against respondent No. 2 comprised particular acts of physical assault,
withdrawal and receipt of money and refusal of medical assistance. The
allegations against respondent Nos. 4 to 6 were either collective in character
or, insofar as an individual act was stated, were not supported by material
sufficient to generate grave suspicion of the statutory cruelty contemplated by
Section 498-A IPC. The distinction drawn by the learned Revisional Court
between the husband and the other relatives, therefore, represents a view
which was reasonably open on the basis of the record.
46.
Therefore, the conclusion directing discharge of respondent Nos. 4 to 6
under Section 498-A IPC cannot be termed perverse or patently illegal so as
to justify supervisory interference. The proceedings against respondent No. 3
have already abated on account of his death and no further determination is
required in relation to him.
Section 406 IPC
47.
The offence of criminal breach of trust contains two distinct elements.
There must first be entrustment of property, or dominion over it, creating an
obligation concerning the manner in which the property is to be dealt with.
There must thereafter be dishonest misappropriation, conversion, use,
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
disposal or retention of that property in breach of the obligation. Both
elements must be disclosed against the accused sought to be prosecuted.
48.
The complaint in the present case does use the expression that the
istridhan articles were “entrusted” to the accused persons. It further states
that the jewellery was with the mother-in-law, the FDs and cash were with the
husband, the furniture, television and air conditioner were with the father-inlaw, and the clothes and other personal articles were with the sisters-in-law.
It also alleges demands for their return on 31.08.2004 and 03.09.2004.
However, mere employment of the word “entrusted” is not conclusive. The
supporting facts must indicate how the concerned accused acquired dominion
over the specified property subject to an obligation to hold or return it. The
reference to articles having been presented at the Lagan or marriage ceremony
explains how the articles entered the matrimonial household, but does not
identify which article was delivered to which particular relative or the
circumstances in which such delivery created an individual obligation in
respect of that property. The later assertion as to where different categories of
articles were lying describes their alleged possession but does not, without
more, establish criminal entrustment to each member of the household.
49.
The alleged demands and refusal have also been attributed collectively
to the accused persons. The complaint does not state which accused responded
to the demand, what was stated by that accused, or how any particular accused
dishonestly converted, used, disposed of or retained the article alleged to be
in his or her possession. Continued presence of property in a shared
matrimonial household, without material disclosing the individual
entrustment and subsequent dishonest dealing, does not automatically
constitute criminal breach of trust against every member of that household.
Even Section 34 IPC cannot supply the foundational ingredients of
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
entrustment and dishonest misappropriation where those ingredients are not
otherwise disclosed against the concerned accused at the very threshold. Even
if at the stage of framing of charge, the mere assertion that the istridhan
articles were entrusted to the accused persons does not constitute sufficient
material to proceed against them under Section 406 IPC.
50.
Onkar Nath Mishra v. State (NCT of Delhi) [Supra], is also relevant
for the principle that creation of an obligation concerning the property and
dishonest dealing contrary to that obligation are separate and indispensable
ingredients. The learned Revisional Court’s conclusion must, therefore, be
tested against those ingredients and not upon a mechanical comparison of the
two complaints. And when tested against those very ingredients, the
conclusion arrived at, that the complaint did not sufficiently disclose
individualised entrustment and dishonest misappropriation against the
accused persons, cannot be said to be an impossible view.
51.
The discharge of the accused under Section 406 IPC, therefore, does
not disclose the degree of patent illegality or perversity necessary for the
exercise of supervisory jurisdiction. The challenge to that part of the
impugned order must also consequently, fail.
52.
Taking into account the aforementioned authorities and precedents, the
deficiencies in the foundational material against the discharged respondents
cannot be supplied by restoring the charges in the expectation that a more
particularised case may emerge during trial. The learned Revisional Court
differentiated the allegations against the husband from those against the other
respondents and reached a conclusion which, for the reasons recorded above,
was reasonably open on the material before it. The existence of another
possible view does not justify substitution of that view with the one already
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
taken in the exercise of supervisory jurisdiction of this Court under Article
227 of the Constitution of India.
CONCLUSION
53.
In view of the foregoing, this Court founds no ground, patent illegality,
perversity, material irregularity or jurisdictional error that would warrant an
interference by this Court in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, with the impugned order dated
11.01.2012 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge-03, South
District, New Delhi in Criminal Revision No. 24/2010.
54.
Accordingly, the present petition is dismissed, and thereby, disposed
of.
55.
The pending application also stands disposed of.
56.
Interim order[s], if any, stand[s] vacated.
57.
A copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned learned Trial Court
for necessary information, action and compliance.
58.
This judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
MADHU JAIN
[JUDGE]
OCTOBER 1, 2026/PG
Signed By:BHARTI
18:42:16
CRL,M.C. 2222/2012
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review