Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
Pronounced on
Uploaded on
+
: 11.02.2026
: 12.03.2026
: 12.03.2026
FAO 300/2022
POONAM & ORS.
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Rajan Sood, Ms. Ashima Sood,
Ms. Megha Sood, Advocates
versus
UNION OF INDIA
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. P.S. Singh, CGSC for UOI with
Ms. Shivangi Sharma, Mr. Mritunjay
K. Singh and Ms. Prachi, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1.
The present appeal has been filed under Section 23 of the Railway
Claims Tribunal Act, 1987, assailing the judgment dated 07.07.2022 passed
by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Delhi,(hereinafter as the “Tribunal”) in
Case No. OA II(U)/84/2019, titled “Smt. Poonam & Ors. v. Union of India”.
2.
Vide the aforesaid judgment, the Tribunal dismissed the claim
application filed by the appellants on the ground that the alleged incident did
not amount to an “untoward incident” within the meaning of Section 123(c)
of the Railways Act, 1989 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”).
3.
Briefly stated, the facts of the case, as set out in the claim application,
are that on 23.04.2018, one Navratan (hereinafter referred to as the
“deceased”) had purchased a journey ticket bearing No. 05823105 for
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:35:32
FAO 300/2022
travelling from Ajaibpur to Aligarh. It is the case of the appellants that while
the deceased was attempting to board the train, there was heavy rush of
passengers inside the compartment, as a result of which he was pushed and
fell from the train, sustaining grievous injuries which proved fatal.
Thereafter, the deceased was taken to the Government Hospital, District
Gautam Buddh Nagar, where the post-mortem examination was conducted.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellants contends that the Tribunal erred in
declining to confer the status of a bona fide passenger upon the deceased on
the ground that the alleged incident had occurred prior to the
commencement of the train journey. It is contended that once the validity of
the journey ticket produced by the appellants stood established, the initial
burden cast upon the appellants to prove the bona fide status of the deceased
stood discharged, and the mere inability of the deceased to complete the
train journey cannot defeat the claim of the appellants. Learned counsel
further contends that the incident in question squarely falls within the ambit
of an “untoward incident”, inasmuch as the deceased had accidentally fallen
from the train owing to a heavy rush inside the compartment. According to
the appellants, the Tribunal’s conclusion that the death was caused due to a
run-over is conjectural and unsupported by any evidence, as the mere fact
that the body of the deceased was found on the up main line instead of the
down line cannot lead to the conclusion that the deceased could not have
fallen from the train. It is also contended that the timing of the alleged
incident, as emerging from the record, is around 19:35 hrs, which broadly
corresponds with the schedule of the train in question and lends credence to
the appellants’ case that the death occurred due to an accidental fall from the
train.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:35:32
FAO 300/2022
5.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent supports the impugned
judgment and contends that the alleged incident was caused due to the
deceased being run over by a train, and not on account of an accidental fall.
It is contended that the record reflects that the body of the deceased was
found lying on the up main line, whereas the train in question had arrived at
the down loop line, both of which are situated at a considerable distance
from each other. Reliance is also placed upon the DRM report, which
attributes the cause of death to the negligence of the deceased, stating that he
was unauthorisedly crossing the railway tracks and was eventually run over
by a train.
6.
This Court has heard arguments of both the parties and perused the
material on record.
7.
In backdrop of the above facts, the main issues arising for
consideration before this Court are, whether the deceased was a bona fide
passenger and whether the alleged incident was an “untoward incident” as
defined under the Act.
8.
It remains undisputed that a journey ticket bearing No. 05823105 was
recovered during jamatalashi, which was subsequently verified in the DRM
as having been issued at 19:21 hrs at Ajaibpur Railway Station on the date
of the incident. The record further reflects that the deceased intended to
travel by Train No. 64114 EMU, which arrives at the said station at 19:34
hrs and departs at 19:35 hrs, thereby lending credence to the validity of the
ticket produced. The impugned judgment also notes this position. When
these circumstances are considered cumulatively, the foundational facts
necessary to establish the bona fide passenger status of the deceased stand
proved and the initial burden cast upon the appellants stands discharged.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:35:32
FAO 300/2022
Once the possession of a valid journey ticket is established, a presumption
arises that the victim was a bona fide passenger, unless the Railways are
able to rebut the same by leading cogent evidence to the contrary.
9.
The Tribunal, however, observed that since the deceased had died at
Ajaibpur Railway Station prior to commencement of the journey, he could
not be treated as a bona fide passenger. In the opinion of this Court, such
reasoning cannot be sustained. Section 124-A of the Act contemplates
compensation in cases where victims of untoward incidents are travelling or
intending to travel on the strength of a valid ticket. The mere fact that the
incident occurred prior to the formal commencement of the journey does not
take the deceased out of the ambit of a bona fide passenger, particularly
when he was in possession of a valid ticket and had claimed to have boarded
the train in question. In the absence of any reliable evidence produced by the
respondent to disprove the validity of the ticket or the intention of the
deceased to travel, the Tribunal’s conclusion that the deceased could not be
treated as a bona fide passenger cannot be sustained.
10.
Insofar as the issue whether the alleged incident amounts to an
“untoward incident” is concerned, the Tribunal concluded that the deceased
could not have fallen from the train on three grounds. Firstly, it observed
that the body of the deceased was found on the up main line, whereas the
concerned train had arrived at the down loop line. Secondly, it noted a
discrepancy between the reported time of the alleged incident and the
departure time of the train. Thirdly, it concluded that the accident was in fact
a run-over by Train No. 02365.
11.
Upon a reappreciation of the evidence on record, this Court finds that
the aforesaid conclusions are not borne out by the material placed before the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:35:32
FAO 300/2022
Tribunal. A perusal of the site plan placed on record shows that it merely
depicts the layout of Ajaibpur Railway Station, indicating four railway
tracks, and does not indicate the precise location where the body of the
deceased was found. The site plan itself is also undated. In such
circumstances, the tracing of the body on the up main line cannot be said to
have been conclusively established. Even otherwise, the mere location of the
body near a particular railway track, in the absence of clear evidence
regarding the precise point of impact, does not by itself rule out the
possibility of an accidental fall from the train, nor does it conclusively
establish that the death occurred due to a run-over. In this regard, gainful
reliance may be placed on the decision of this Court in Maya Devi v. Union
of India1, wherein it was observed that the mere fact that the body of the
deceased was found at some distance from the railway track cannot, by
itself, lead to the conclusion that the victim had not fallen from the train.
The relevant extract is herein below:
“6. The other conclusion of the Tribunal that since the body was lying
towards the down track and hence there was no train travel is equally
fallacious. Firstly, the Tribunal cannot conclude that merely because the
dead body was recovered in the field 6-7 meters away from the down track
adjacent to the up-track in which the deceased was travelling, this case
will not be a case of a fall from the train. It is very much possible that after
falling down from the train, the deceased had that much amount of life and
strength to move himself for a few meter before completely collapsing.
Merely because the body is found 6-7 meters away from the track cannot
mean that the deceased was not travelling on the train. This conclusion of
the Tribunal is also therefore quite clearly erroneous and is hence set
aside.”
12.
As regards the alleged discrepancy with respect to the timing of the
incident, the Tribunal was of the view that the occurrence must have
2014 SCC OnLine Del 3203
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:35:32
FAO 300/2022
preceded 19:35 hrs, i.e., the departure time of the train in question, since the
Station Master Memo records receipt of information regarding the incident
at 19:35 hrs. The Tribunal also relied upon the statement of one Pali, the
uncle of the deceased, who stated that he had received information about the
incident at around 19:30 hrs. This Court is unable to concur with the said
reasoning. Notably, Train No. 02365, as per the record, passed Ajaibpur
Railway Station at about 19:32 hrs, which itself post-dates the alleged
intimation at 19:30 hrs. Further, although the Station Master Memo records
receipt of information at 19:35 hrs, it also reflects that the information
regarding the incident was conveyed to GRP Dankaur only at 20:20 hrs. In
the absence of any explanation for this time gap, the precision of the
timeline relied upon by the Tribunal becomes doubtful.
13.
Pertinently, the site plan reflects that KM 1406/16, where the body of
the deceased was allegedly located, lies in front of the platform of Ajaibpur
Railway Station and in close proximity to the Station Building and the
Station Master’s room. In such circumstances, the possibility of the
deceased having fallen from the train and the incident being recorded around
19:35 hrs cannot be ruled out. On an overall conspectus of the material on
record, this Court is of the view that the broad timeline emerging from the
sequence of events does not rule out the possibility of an accidental fall from
the train. To insist upon a hyper-technical matching of timings in such
circumstances would amount to adopting an unduly rigid standard of proof,
which is contrary to the beneficial nature of the legislation governing
compensation for railway accidents.
14.
More importantly, no direct evidence has been produced to
substantiate the theory of a run-over. Neither the loco pilot nor the guard of
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:35:32
FAO 300/2022
Train No. 02365 was examined before the Tribunal, nor has any
documentary evidence been placed on record to support such a conclusion.
The inference of a run-over drawn by the Tribunal is therefore devoid of any
evidentiary basis and appears to be founded largely on surmises and
conjectures. A perusal of the post-mortem report reflects multiple
lacerations and abrasions sustained by the deceased. The Tribunal, despite
noting the nature and gravity of these injuries, concluded that they were
more indicative of a run-over than an accidental fall. Such an inference is
speculative and unsupported by any medical opinion on record.
15.
It is well settled that Section 124-A of the Railways Act embodies a
beneficial statutory scheme and must therefore be construed in a liberal
manner. The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that the provisions
governing compensation for railway accidents must receive a purposive
interpretation so as to advance the object of providing relief to victims of
railway accidents, rather than being defeated by hyper-technical objections.
In Union of India v. Prabhakaran Vijaya Kumar2, the Supreme Court held
that once the occurrence of an “untoward incident” is established and the
case does not fall within any of the statutory exceptions, the liability of the
Railways under Section 124-A is strict. In the present case, the respondent
has failed to establish that the death of the deceased falls within any of the
exceptions carved out under the proviso to Section 124-A of the Act.
Considering the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the view that
the Tribunal, in the present case, adopted an unduly rigid standard of proof,
overlooking the beneficial object of the Act and the settled principle that
(2008) 9 SCC 527
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:35:32
FAO 300/2022
proceedings thereunder are intended to provide prompt and efficacious relief
to the victims of railway accidents.
16.
The matter is remanded back to the Tribunal, which is requested to
assess the amount of compensation payable to the appellants in accordance
with law and direct the authorities concerned to disburse the same within
four weeks from the receipt of a copy of this order.
17.
For this purpose, the matter be listed before the Tribunal at the first
instance on 23.03.2026.
18.
Accordingly, the present appeal is allowed and disposed of in the
above terms.
19.
A copy of this judgment be communicated to the concerned Tribunal.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
MARCH 12, 2026
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
18:35:32
FAO 300/2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review