Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:39784
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
LPA No.820 of 2025
Decided on : 14.09.2026
Pinki
...Appellant
Versus
Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission and Anr.
…Respondents.
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the appellant
:
For the respondent(s)
Mr. Surender Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Neeraj Sharma, Advocate.
:
Mr. Vikrant Thakur, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Shubham Singh Guleria, Advocate,
for respondent No.1.
Mr. Raman Jamalta, Advocate, for
respondent No.2.
Bipin Chander Negi, Judge
The present appeal has been preferred against the
impugned judgment
dated 21.08.2025 passed
in
CWP
No.3239 of 2024, titled Pinki Vs. Himachal Pradesh Public
Service Commission and Anr., whereby the writ petition
preferred by the present appellant has been dismissed.
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
-22026:HHC:39784
2.
The present appeal pertains to an appointment to
the post of Conductor in respondent No.2-Corporation, the
recruitment process whereof was initiated and conducted by
respondent No.1. Respondent No.2-Corporation, vide order
dated 23.03.1996 (Annexure P-1, page 90 of the paper-book),
with the prior concurrence of the Government of Himachal
Pradesh,
had
framed
the
Himachal
Road
Transport
Corporation (Class-I, II, III and IV) Services (Recruitment,
Promotion and Certain Conditions of Service Regulations),
1996. Thereunder, criteria for selection was provided in terms
of Regulation 7.
3.
The initial 1996 Regulations qua recruitment and
promotion for the post of Conductors in the respondent
No.2-Corporation have been placed on record at page 101 of
the paper-book (Annexure A-42 of Annexure P-2).
The
aforesaid Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of
Conductors were amended vide notification dated 21.11.2015
(Annexure P-2, page 107 of the paper book). In accordance
with the amendment so made, the minimum educational
qualification required for direct recruitment to the post of
Conductor in the respondent No.2-Corporation was 10+2 pass
-32026:HHC:39784
from any Board of School Education/University recognized by
the Government of Himachal Pradesh.
4.
Vide
04.04.2023,
Advertisement
respondent
No.4/4-2023
No.1-Commission
dated
initiated
the
process of direct recruitment for the post of Conductors. The
last date for submission of application and determination of
eligibility as per the same was 01.05.2023. Copy of the
advertisement so issued has been placed on record as
Annexure P-3 (page 110 of the paper-book).
5.
The total posts advertised were 360, out of which
130 were meant for the General category. The appellant in the
case at hand had applied for the General category post of
Conductor. The requisite educational qualification required
therein was 10+2 pass from a recognized Board of School
Education/University or equivalent.
6.
Other than the aforesaid, a Note had been
appended, whereby it had been provided in the advertisement
that in order for a candidate to be eligible for appointment to
the
post
of
Conductor,
he/she
should
have
passed
Matriculation and 10+2 from any School/Institution situated
within Himachal Pradesh. The aforesaid condition was not to
-42026:HHC:39784
apply to bona fide Himachalis. The Note so appended in the
advertisement is the bone of contention in the case at hand.
7.
In pursuance to the advertisement, the appellant
had applied. The application form has been placed on record
as Annexure P-5 (page 123 of the paper book). Admit Card
issued in pursuance to the application so made in favour of
the appellant is placed on record as Annexure P-6 (page 125
of the paper book). A written objective screening test was
held on 10.12.2023. In pursuance thereto, 826 candidates had
been shortlisted. The same is evident from notice issued in
this respect dated 02.02.2024, placed on record as Annexure
P-7 (page 127 of the paper book). The appellant had
successfully cleared the written objective screening test and,
in
pursuance
thereto,
had
been
called
for
document
verification, as is evident from notice dated 05.02.2024 issued
in this respect, placed on record as Annexure P-8 (page 130
of the paper book).
8.
Post verification of the documents, the candidature
of the appellant had been rejected on the account that she
was neither a bona fide Himachali, nor had she passed her
Matriculation and 10+2 from a School/Institution situated
-52026:HHC:39784
within the State of Himachal Pradesh. The aforesaid rejection
is evident from Annexure P-9 (page 135 of the paper book).
9.
It is in the aforesaid backdrop that the present
appellant had laid a challenge to the Note appended in the
advertisement dated 04.04.2023 (Annexure P-3), which
required that a candidate, in order to be eligible for
appointment, must have passed Matriculation and 10+2 from
any School/Institution situated within the State of Himachal
Pradesh. The same was assailed on two counts; i) namely, the
same being illegal as it was contrary to the Recruitment &
Promotion Rules meant for the post of Conductor as amended
vide notification dated 21.11.2015 (Annexure P-2), and
secondly, on the count that the same was violative of the
provisions of the Constitution as 100% recruitment in the case
at hand was being done on the basis of institutional
preference.
10.
No response in the case at hand was filed by
respondent No.2. In the response filed by respondent No.1Commission, a categorical stand had been taken that insofar
as the State of Himachal Pradesh is concerned, vide
notification dated 19.11.2019, placed on record at page 173
-62026:HHC:39784
of the paper-book, eligibility for appointment to Class-III and
Class-IV posts had been limited to individuals who had passed
their Matriculation and 10+2 from any School/Institution
situated within the State of Himachal Pradesh. Further, in the
response filed by respondent No.1-Commission, it had been
mentioned that vide office order dated 15.06.2020 (page 176
of the paper book), the Managing Director of the respondent
No.2-Corporation
had
been
authorized
to
adopt
all
notifications/instructions issued by the State Government in
future which are applicable to the HRTC.
11.
In the rejoinder filed, categorical stand taken by
the present appellant was that notification dated 19.11.2019
issued by the State Government, whereby recruitment to the
posts of Class-III and Class-IV had been limited to individuals
who had passed their Matriculation and 10+2 examination
from
Schools/Institutions
situated
within
the
State
of
Himachal Pradesh, had not been adopted by the HRTC, as
nothing has been placed on record.
12.
In the impugned judgment, the claim of the
appellant has been denied on account of the fact that once
having participated in the process, the appellant could not
-72026:HHC:39784
have turned back and challenged the same. Further, it has
been presumed that notification dated 19.11.2019 (page 173
of the paper book) has been adopted by the respondentCorporation.
13.
Admittedly, in the case at hand, the Recruitment &
Promotion Rules for the post of Conductor, as amended in the
year 2015 (Annexure P-2, page 107 of the paper book),
provide that for being appointed against the post of Conductor
through direct recruitment, a candidate is required to possess
a 10+2 from any Board of School Education/University
recognized by the Government of Himachal Pradesh.
14.
From the application form submitted by the
appellant in the case at hand (Annexure P-5, page 123 of the
paper book), it is evident that the appellant had passed her
10+2 from the Board of School Education Haryana, Bhiwani.
From a perusal of Annexure P-11 appended along with the
rejoinder (page 207 of the paper book), i.e., list of updated
recognized/equivalent
Boards/Universities/Bodies
as
on
24.07.2019 issued by the H.P. Board of School Education,
Dharamshala, it is evident from Sr. No.8 thereof that the
-82026:HHC:39784
Board of School Education Haryana, Bhiwani is a recognized
Board insofar as the State of Himachal Pradesh is concerned.
15.
In
appended
the
to
aforesaid
the
backdrop,
educational
when
the
Note
in
the
qualifications
advertisement issued for recruitment to the post of Conductor
in the case at hand (Annexure P-3, page 110 of the paper
book) is examined, it is evident that the Note which requires
a
candidate
to
pass
Matriculation
and
10+2
from
a
School/Institution situated within the State of Himachal
Pradesh for being eligible for the post of Conductor in the case
at hand, is nowhere mentioned in the Recruitment &
Promotion Rules. The addition is a patent illegal.
16.
Mere participation in a process which is illegal
would not bar the appellant from assailing the same, as the
principle of estoppel by conduct or acquiescence would have
no application.
In this regard, reference can be made to
(1997) 9 SCC 527, titled Raj Kumar and Ors. Vs. Shakti
Raj and Ors. (Bench of Three Hon’ble Judges). The relevant
extract of the same is reads as under:“16. Yet another circumstance is that the
Government had not taken out the post from the
purview of the Board, but after the examinations
-92026:HHC:39784
were conducted under the 1955 Rule and after
the results were announced, it exercised the
power under the proviso to para 6 of 1970
notification and the post were taken out from the
purview
thereof.
Thereafter
the
Selection
Committee was constituted for selection of the
candidates.
The
entire
procedure
is
also
obviously illegal. It is true, as contended by Shri
Madhava Reddy, that this Court in Madan Lal vs.
State of J & K [(1995) 3 SCC 486] and other
decisions referred therein had held that a
candidate having taken a chance to appear in an
interview and having remained unsuccessful,
cannot turn round and challenge either the
constitution of the selection Board or the method
of Selection as being illegal; he is estopped to
question the correctness of the selection. But in
his case,
the
Government have committed
glaring illegalities in the procedure to get the
candidates for examination under 1955 Rules, so
also in the method of selection and exercise of
the power in taking out from the purview of the
Board and also conduct of the selection in
accordance
with
the
Rules.
Therefore,
the
principle of estoppel by conduct or acquiescence
has no application to the facts in this case. Thus,
we consider that the procedure offered under the
1955 Rules adopted by the Government or the
Committee as well as the action taken by the
Government are not correct in law.”
-102026:HHC:39784
In this respect, see also (2017) 4 SCC 357, titled
Ashok Kumar and anr. Vs. State of Bihar and Others.
17.
Other than the aforesaid, in this respect reference
can also be made to (2019) 20 SCC 17, titled Dr (Major)
Meeta Sahai Vs. State of Bihar and Ors.
The relevant
extract of the same reads as under:“17. However, we must differentiate from this
principle insofar as the candidate by agreeing to
participate in the selection process only accepts
the prescribed procedure and not the illegality in
it. In a situation where a candidate alleges
misconstruction
of
statutory
rules
and
discriminating consequences arising therefrom,
the same cannot be condoned merely because a
candidate has partaken in it. The constitutional
scheme is sacrosanct and its violation in any
manner is impermissible. In fact, a candidate
may not have locus to assail the incurable
illegality or derogation of the provisions of the
Constitution, unless he/she participates in the
selection process.”
18.
The same was followed in (2024) 7 SCC 262,
titled Abhimeet Sinha and Ors. Vs. High Court of
Judicature at Patna and Ors. The relevant extract of the
same reads as under:-
-112026:HHC:39784
“36. As argued by the learned counsel for the
High Courts, the legal position is that after
participating in the recruitment process, the
unsuccessful candidate cannot turn around and
challenge the recruitment process. However, it
is also settled that in the principle of estoppel
cannot override the law. Such legal priniciple was
retireated by the Supreme Court in Meeta Sahai
V. State of Bihar, (2019) 20 SCC 17.”
19.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the appellant has drawn the attention
of the Court to the information obtained under the Right to
Information Act. The same pertains to the requisition dated
05.07.2022 sent by the respondent No.2-Corporation to the
respondent No.1-Commission for initiating the process of
recruitment of Conductors in the case at hand. From the
requisition, it is evident that it has been categorically
mentioned that recruitment has to be initiated in terms of the
Recruitment & Promotion Rules and the same have been
appended with the requisition sent. No reference of the
notification dated 19.11.2019 (page 173 of the paper book)
-122026:HHC:39784
has been made in the requisition, while specifying eligibility
for the post of Conductors in the case at hand.
Thereby
implying that till the date of sending the requisition, the same
had not been adopted by respondent No.2-Corporation. Even
otherwise, no material has been placed on record by
respondent No.2-Corporation to show that the Notification
Dated 19.11.2019 issued by the State of Himachal Pradesh
had been adopted by respondent No.2-Corporation.
20.
In pursuance to order dated 26.02.2026, an
affidavit had been filed by the Deputy Divisional Manager
(Legal), HRTC, Head Office, Shimla (placed at page 213 of the
paper-book). From a perusal of the same, it is evident that
one post of General category advertised in the case at hand is
lying vacant as a candidate selected against the General
category post, namely, one Shri Kailash Kumar, had not
joined.
21.
For the afore-stated reasons, the present appeal is
allowed and the impugned judgment passed by the learned
Single Judge is quashed and set aside. The appellant is held
entitled to the appointment against the vacant post of
-132026:HHC:39784
Conductor, along with all consequential benefits including
seniority on a notional basis.
22.
In the aforesaid terms, the present appeal is
disposed of, so also the pending miscellaneous application(s),
if any. It is made clear that the question of constitutionality
of the impugned note though raised has not been gone into
since the same is being set aside on other grounds.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
(Bipin Chander Negi)
Judge
14th September, 2026
s (Gaurav Rawat)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review