Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision:16th January, 2026
%
+
RFA 49/2026, CM APPL. 3099-3100/2026
M/S PICCADILY HOTELS PRIVATE LIMITED
Through its Authorised Representative
Mr. Deepanshu Bansal
Having its registered office at
District Centre Janakpuri,
Janakpuri, New Delhi – 110058.
.....Appellant
Through:
Counsel for Appellant (appearance
not given)
versus
ION AQUA MEMBRANES PVT LTD.
Having its Registered Office at
WZ-250-C, Near MTNL Exchange,
Inderpuri, New Delhi – 110012
.....Respondent
Through:
None
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T (oral)
RFA 49/2026
1.
Appeal under Section 96 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 has been filed on behalf of the Appellant to challenge the
Judgment and decree dated 20.09.2025 whereby the Leave to Defend filed
under Order XXXVII Rule 3(5) CPC of the Appellant was dismissed, in a
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
Summary Suit under Order 37 CPC and the Suit of the Plaintiff/Respondent
has been decreed for Rs.3,40,328/- along with the interest @ 9% p.a.
Briefly stated, the Respondent / Plaintiff had filed a Suit under Order
2.
XXXVII CPC for recovery of Rs.4,58,408/- along with pendente lite and
future interest, from M/s Piccadily Hotels Pvt. Ltd. / Appellant. The
Respondent was running the business of testing facilities of water, Water
Testing Kits, Water Treatment Chemicals, Electronic Dosing System, RO
Membranes, etc.
The Appellant, a Company dealing in the hotel business, placed a
3.
Purchase
Order
vide
letter
dated
24.10.2012
bearing
reference
No.PHPL/Gurgaon/Membranes/RO/2012-13/01 to the Respondent, for the
supply, installation of Reverse Osmosis System (‘RO’) at Piccadily Hotel
“Hyatt Regency” Sector-83, Gurgaon Manesar Urban Complex, NH-8,
Gurgaon, Haryana.
The work was duly executed. The case of the Respondent is that it
4.
had supplied and completed the Order, in acknowledgement of which,
Respondent issued a Handing Over Letter dated 25.02.2013 to Mr. Sarabjit
Singh, FF & E Manager, Hyatt Regency Gurgaon, New Delhi NCR. The
following Bills / Invoices, were raised by the Respondent:
S. No. Bill /Invoice No.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
Date
Amount
1.
14.11.2012
Rs.3,54,375/(inclusive of 12.5% Sales Tax)
2.
23.11.2012
Rs.1,96,875/-
3.
08.01.2013
Rs.21,938/-
4.
29.01.2013
Rs.12,140/-
Total
Rs.5,85,328/-
RFA 49/2026
5.
The Appellant was liable to pay Rs.5,85,328/-, out of which he paid
an amount of Rs.2,45,000/-, which was adjusted against the running
Account between the Appellant and the Respondent, leaving an amount of
Rs.3,40,328/- as still outstanding, which the Appellant was liable to pay.
6.
The Respondent made a demand of the balance amount of
Rs.3,40,328/-, however the Appellant failed to pay. He consequently, issued
the Letter of Demand dated 25.11.2014, to which no response was ever
received from the Appellant. Despite several demands and requests, the
Appellant failed to respond and was not forthcoming. The Respondent/
Plaintiff filed a Suit under Order XXXVII C.P.C. for recovery of
Rs.4,58,408/- (Rs.3,40,328/- towards the principal amount and interest of
Rs.1,18,080/-, i.e. @ 12% p.a. from 01.01.2013 till December 2015), and
interest on the principal amount till realisation.
7.
The Summons for judgment under Order XXXVII Rule 3(4) CPC,
was received by the Appellant on 28.11.2018. Thereafter, an Application
under Order XXXVII Rule 3(5) CPC was filed for the grant of leave to
defend, within the prescribed period of time.
8.
The learned District Judge in the Impugned Judgment dated
20.09.2025, held that the defence being sought by the Appellant/ Defendant
was nothing but moonshine, and dismissed the Application seeking Leave to
Defend, decreeing the Principal amount of Rs.3,40,328/- along with interest
@ 9 % p.a.
9.
The grounds of challenge are that the Invoices were neither
acknowledged
nor accepted
by the
Appellant
/
Defendant.
No
contemporaneous record has been placed on record by the Respondent to
establish that the Appellant even consented to such excess billing or that the
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
Purchase order was revised / altered beyond 15.11.2012. These inflated
billing unsupported by acknowledgment, raise serious triable issues which
could not have been summarily brushed aside by the learned District Judge.
10.
The Appellant since the inception of the Suit, had denied the
authenticity of Handover Letter dated 25.02.2013 and claimed it to be a
completely false and fabricated documents, since it did not have any seal,
stamp, or authorized signature and was not prepared on Letter Head of the
Company, which itself depict that the same was manufactured and
fabricated. However, this triable issued was also not considered by the
learned District Judge.
11.
There is not an iota of evidence that Mr. Sarabjit Singh was ever
authorized by the Appellant to accept delivery or issue binding
acknowledgments on behalf of the Appellant Company, as it is commercial
practice that such acknowledgment would be made by an authorized
signatory with Company seal as a mandate. Mere silence on the part of the
Appellant in not responding to the Demand Letter dated 19.11.2014, would
not in itself result in the implied acceptance of contents stated therein.
12.
Further, this alleged Handover Letter purported to confirm
completion of supplies and installations to the satisfaction of the Appellant,
which directly contradicts that the Invoices raised were well beyond the
agreed Purchase Order amount of Rs.4,90,000/- and is also against the time
period for the completing the supply and installation of the RO system i.e.
15.11.2012.
13.
The relevant aspect pertaining to the Delivery Report has not been
considered. Respondent has failed to place on record any document to show
that the Letter was duly served upon the Appellant and therefore, no
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
presumption of deemed service can be drawn against the Appellant.
14.
The learned Trial Court did not consider the statement made by
learned counsel for the Respondent on 08.10.2016 that the Suit had been
inadvertently filed under order XXXVII C.P.C., as it is a simple Recovery
Suit.
15.
In various Judgments, the Hon’ble Apex Court has reiterated that
where the Defendant raises substantial / triable issue(s), the Plaintiff will not
be entitled to a summary judgement and the Defendant should be given
liberty to defend the Suit either unconditional or conditionally, as the case
may be. However, learned District Judge has failed to appreciate various
triable issues and had erroneously concluded that no grounds were raised for
defending the Suit, in the leave to defend Application.
16.
It has been further overlooked that Section 34 C.P.C. puts a restriction
upon the Court to grant / allow maximum interest @ 6% and not beyond.
Learned Trial Court has erroneously granted interest @ 9% by presuming
the Suit to be of commercial nature.
17.
There is sufficient material for setting aside the impugned Order and
granting permission to the Applicant to defend the suit.
18.
The Plaintiff / Respondent, had contested the Leave to defend
Application by asserting that the defences raised by the Appellant /
Defendant were frivolous and moonshine. The four Invoices, relied upon by
the Plaintiff, in support of the Work Order. In so far as the Handing Over
Letter dated 25.02.2013 was concerned, it was specifically pleaded in the
plaint that it was handed over to Mr. Sarabjit Singh, who was a Manager
with the Defendant / Appellant, which was accepted by him.
19.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
Significantly, in the Leave to Defend Application, the Defendant had
RFA 49/2026
remained completely silent with regard to Mr. Sarabjit Singh. It has not been
denied that Mr. Sarabjit Singh was a representative and Manager of the
Defendant Company. There is also no denial of his signatures in acceptance,
on this Letter. The averments made in the leave to defend Application that
the letter did not bear the signatures and stamp of the representative of the
defendant, are vague and in no way controverts that it has the signatures of
Mr. Sarabjit Singh, its Manager.
20.
The Learned District Judge had observed that Defendant has vaguely
averred in the Leave to Defend Application that the Plaintiff / Respondent
had failed to supply the material as per Purchase Order dated 24.10.2012.
However, no details whatsoever have been given, as to how the supply of
material was not complete. No document of correspondence were placed on
record to show that the Defendant has ever claimed that there was
incomplete supply of the material.
21.
It is further submitted that the allegation by the defendant in regard to
full and final settlement was also vague as no details or particulars of the
same have been given. No document has been placed on record to show that
there was any full and final settlement between the parties.
22.
Plaintiff had categorically pleaded in the plaint that he had issued a
Letter of Demand dated 25.11.2014, to which no response was given by the
Defendant / Appellant. The Letter of Demand has been filed along with the
plaint and the original Speed Post Receipts to show its dispatch on
25.11.2014. On account of this date of dispatch, Legal Notice in the plaint
has been referred to as dated 25.11.2014. Defendant was informed about the
Handing over of the work, through Handing Over Letter dated 25.11.2014 to
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
Mr. Sarabjit Singh, Manager and that balance of Rs.3,40,328/- was due.
23.
Pertinently, in the entire Leave to Defend Application, the Defendant /
Appellant is completely silent on the Letter of Demand and has not denied
not having received it. No response to the Letter of Demand had been given
by the Appellant.
24.
The defence raised in the leave to defend Application were moonshine
and have been rightly rejected by the learned District Judge, in the impugned
Order.
25.
Reliance is placed on IDBI Trusteeship Services Ltd. vs. Hubtown
Ltd., (2016) 11 SCR 660, to emphasize that if no substantial defence or a
genuine triable issue is raised by the Defendant and the Court finds such
defence to be frivolous or vexatious, then the Leave to Defend Application
shall be refused and the Plaintiff is entitled to the Judgment forthwith.
Submissions Heard and Record Perused.
26.
Appellant in its Leave to Defend Application has raised the following
triable issues:
(i) that there was no cause of action in favour of the Plaintiff as the
Plaintiff had failed to supply and install completely as per
Purchase Order dated 24.12.2012;
(ii) that the Suit of the Plaintiff did not come within the ambit of
Order XXXVII C.P.C.;
(iii) that the Suit is barred by limitation, as under Purchase Order
dated 24.10.2012, the Plaintiff / Respondent Company was under
the obligation to supply and install Reverse Osmosis (RO) system
on or before 25.11.2012, while Suit has been filed on 21.11.2015,
which is beyond the period of three years and is therefore, barred
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
by limitation;
(iv) that the Court had no territorial jurisdiction as the entire cause of
action arose beyond the territorial jurisdiction of the Court;
(v) that the material has not been supplied by the Plaintiff, in terms of
the Purchase Order dated 24.10.2012 and has raised false and
fabricated Invoices that had not been acknowledged by the
Defendant;;
(vi) that no Handing Over Letter dated 25.02.2013 was submitted to
the Appellant Company and that it does not bear the signatures
and stamp of the Defendant and the Letter was not acknowledged
by the Defendant Company; and
(vii) that the Defendant Company was fully satisfied with the material
supplied by the Plaintiff Company and there was final settlement
between the parties.
27.
Admittedly, the parties entered into a contract vide Purchase Order
dated 24.10.2012, whereby the Plaintiff / Respondent Company had to
supply and install Reverse Osmosis (RO) system at Appellant’s hotel i.e.
“Hyatt Regency” (a unit of Piccadily Hotels Pvt. Ltd.) situated at Gurgaon,
Haryana. According to the Plaintiff, despite completing the Work, part
payment remained due. Therefore, Respondent had filed a Suit for Recovery
of Rs.3,40,328/- along with interest @ 12%.
28.
First contention raised by the Appellant/Defendant is that Invoices
relied upon by the Respondent, do not correspond to the Purchase Order
dated 24.10.2012. The Purchase Order was placed for supply and installation
of Reverse Osmosis (RO) system having capacity of 2000 litre per hour
Hydropneumatics System with total value of Rs.4,90,000/-.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
29.
Pertinently, the unit price of Reverse Osmosis (RO) System was
Rs.3,15,000/-, which matches with the corresponding Invoice. Likewise,
Hydronaumetic System, that was mentioned in the Purchase Order,
correspond to the second Invoice, which is in the sum of Rs.1,75,000/-. The
goods have been supplied by Respondent to the Appellant through these
Invoices and in terms of the Purchase Order.
30.
Further, there are two Invoices dated 08.01.2013 for supply of Ultra
Valet System with capacity of 2000 liter per hour with stand of Rs.19,500/-,
and an Invoice dated 29.01.2013 for supply of 08 pieces of UV System, RO
Drain and Tank Drain, etc. for Rs.6,800/-. Two subsequent Invoices clearly
reflect that these goods too were supplied, which correspond completely
with the total amount claimed for goods supplied; the contention of the
Appellant that the Invoices were not in accordance with the Purchase Order,
is palpably incorrect.
31.
The Appellant has admitted Rs.2,45,000/- had been paid on account,
which had admittedly been adjusted in the outstanding payment of
Rs.5,85,328/- leaving the balance of Rs.3,40,328/-. The Appellant, therefore,
is not able to raise any triable issue, in regard to Invoices and delivery.
32.
Next controversy surrounds the Handing Over Letter dated
25.02.2013, which certified that R.O. Plant was commission tested, put in
operation and handed over to the Respondent. Pertinently, this Letter has the
signature of Mr. Sarabjit Singh, Manager, dated 25.02.2013 in acceptance.
Much has been contended by the Appellant that there is neither a seal nor
the stamp of the Appellant Company, to corroborate the acceptance by Mr.
Sarabjit Singh.
33.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
It has been rightly observed by the learned Trial Court that the
RFA 49/2026
emphasis has been led on the stamp and seal of the Company, but there is no
denial whatsoever, that Mr. Sarabjit Singh was not the Manager of the
Company at that time. Letter bears his signatures and the challenge to
Handing Over Letter dated 25.02.2013, has been rightly rejected.
34.
Next significant aspect is the Letter Of Demand dated 19.11.2014
that was duly issued by the Respondent Company to the Appellant Company
to make payment of balance amount of Rs.3,40,328/-. The original Receipt
dated 25.11.2014, vide which the said Letter had been put in the post, had
been annexed on the record.
35.
Leave to defend Application is completely silent about the demand
Notice. Learned District Judge has rightly observed that in the Leave to
DFefend Application, there is no denial that the Letter of Demand was not
received; in fact, it emerges from the record that the Appellant/Defendant
did not respond this Letter of Demand wherein all the facts as detailed in the
Plaint about the supply of goods vide Invoices and corresponding bills, had
been specifically stated.
36.
Learned Trial Court has rightly drawn the inference that the inaction
on the part of the Appellant, reflected it had nothing to controvert about the
facts mentioned therein. There is no cogent explanation or document filed
by the Appellant in support of its contentions.
37.
Significantly, a defence was taken by the Appellant that the account
had been settled. But pertinently, no date of settlement of accounts has been
mentioned and there is no document to show the reconciliation of the
accounts. It is further pertinent to note that while there is a claim of having
paid Rs.2,45,000/- to the Respondent, there is not a whisper about how the
balance amount was paid by the Appellant.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
38.
It is also significant to observe that while no date of settlement or
payment has been given, this Suit has been filed in November, 2015. There
is not a single correspondence in between, undertaken by the Appellant to
show that the amounts had been fully settled.
39.
It has further been contended that this was not commercial Suit
maintainable under Order XXXVII C.P.C. However, this argument also does
not hold any merit, as the Suit is based on Purchase Order and the Invoices,
which comes within the scope of Order XXXVII C.P.C.
40.
With respect to the objection taken in regard to the territorial
jurisdiction, it is observed that the Registered Office of the Defendant
Company is at Piccadily House, 275, Capt. Gaur Marg, Sriniwas Puri, New
Delhi – 110065. The Defendant was therefore, located in Delhi and the
Agreement/Contract took place in Delhi. The goods may have been supplied
and installed by the Plaintiff at the given address of “Hyatt Regency”
Gurgaon, Haryana, but the Defendant had its registered Office in Delhi and
the cause of action had arisen in Delhi. Hence, the ground of territorial
jurisdiction cannot be accepted in the present circumstance.
41.
Furthermore, with respect to the aspect of limitation, it is pertinent to
note that the Summary Suit was filed on 21.11.2015, while the Purchase
Order was dated 24.10.2012. Two Invoices were issued in November, 2012
and the other two Invoices were issued till 29.01.2013. Furthermore, the
Handing Over Letter was issued on 25.02.2013, and the Demand Letter was
issued on 25.11.2014. In these circumstances, the cause of action arose in
favour of the Plaintiff from the date of the issuance of the Invoices and then
again on the date of issuance of the Handing Over Letter, and finally on the
date of the issuance of Demand Letter to the Defendant. The cause of action
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
to file the Suit arose after the completion of Work, which was acknowledged
vide Handing Over Letter dated 25.02.2013. Hence, the Summary Suit has
been filed on 21.11.2015, is within the period of limitation.
42.
In the end, an issue has been raised about the interest rate. However,
learned District Judge has only awarded the principal amount of
Rs.3,40,328/- and the interest @ 9 % per annum has been granted on the due
amount in exercise of its discretion under Section 34 C.P.C.
43.
There is not merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby dismissed.
Pending Applications, if any, also stands disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 16, 2026
R
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
RFA 49/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review