Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA No. 5 of 2023
Date of Decision: 16.03.2023
Smti. Phielina Jyndiang
Vs.
State of Meghalaya
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This is an application under Section 439 Cr.P.C for grant of bail to
the accused person, Shri. Aylmer S. Hynniewta, son of the petitioner herein,
who was arrested in connection with CID P.S. Case No. 03(11) of 2022
under Sections 120(B)/409/420 IPC read with Sections 11/13(1)(a)/13(2)
PC Act, 1998.
2.
Heard Mr. Philemon Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioner,
who has submitted that the background facts of the case is that the police
department requiring a Mobile Forensic Van with equipments had sought
for quotations from M/s Bomver Force and the said firm in reply vide letter
dated 04.12.2018 had quoted a price of ₹ 42,50,000/- (Rupees forty two
lakhs fifty thousand) only for the same following which, the police
department issued a supply order vide letter dated 07.06.2019.
3.
In the said supply order, all the items that were required to be
suppled were listed and divided into three categories namely A, B and C, A
being the vehicle itself which is a Force Traveller Delivery Van 4020 (6
wheel), B being the equipments required for laboratory interior and C being
the testing equipments required to be kept in the vehicle.
4.
Again, it is submitted that on receipt of the said supply order, M/s
Bomver Force took steps to order the vehicle and all the required
equipments under A, B and C. The vehicle and interior fittings under A and
B was ordered from Force India, while the order for items categorized at C
was made from one company by the name of Technomaxx Forensics Pvt.
Ltd., Faridabad, Haryana for a sum of ₹ 3,92,940/- (Rupees three lakhs
ninety two thousand nine hundred forty) only.
5.
The vehicle along with the interior works on being completed and
temporary registration obtained, the firm wanted to deliver the same to the
police department, however with an endorsement that the testing equipment
at C is yet to be delivered as the same has not yet been supplied by the
supplier and to this effect, a personnel from the police department came and
took delivery of the vehicle with a check list wherein it was clearly marked
that the vehicle at category A and B was received except for C which was
not received but was however assured by the supplier firm that as soon as
the said items are received from Technomaxx Forensics, the same will be
handed over to the police department.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has then submitted that an
FIR dated 14.11.2022 was lodged by C.I.D Meghalaya Police alleging that
during the period between January 2019 to March 2020, Shri. G.K. Iangrai,
MPS, AIG (A) had entered into a criminal conspiracy with unknown public
servants and others to cause wrongful loss to the Government of Meghalaya
and wrongful gain to himself and others in the matter of procurement of
vehicles to the police department. In this regard, it is also said that Shri.
Iangrai had sanctioned an amount of ₹ 42,30,000/- (Rupees forty two lakhs
thirty thousand) only to M/s Bomver Force for the crime scene vehicle
which vehicle was delivered without any tools mentioned in the supply
order.
7.
Pursuant to the said FIR, the police inquired into the matter and
questioned the accused person as well as the petitioner and her daughter
who are the family members of the proprietor of the said M/s Bomver
Force, who by then, had since expired on 05.12.2021 and has eventually
arrested the son of the petitioner on 18.02.2023.
8.
The learned counsel has submitted that the accused person though
he is the son of the deceased proprietor of the firm, yet he is not the owner
of the firm as he is working in the said firm in the capacity of an employee
and has acted on behalf of the firm and the proprietor and not on his own
behalf even when dealing with the matter of supply of the said Mobile
Forensic Van. In his capacity therefore, he could not have entered into any
criminal conspiracy with anyone and as such, his arrest and detention is
without any sanction of law. Even otherwise, it is the commitment of the
firm that as and when the said equipments at category C are received, the
same will be supplied immediately to the department since the amount
against the said equipments has already been received by Technomaxx
Forensics. At the most, it could have been a deficiency of service which
should not have attracted criminal liability.
9.
It is also the submission of the learned counsel that all the
necessary papers and documents with regard to the case had been seized by
the police from the firm and the statement of the relevant witnesses
including that of the accused person has also been recorded and as such, at
this juncture there would be no impediment if the accused person is released
on bail.
10.
It is therefore, prayed that this petition may be allowed and that
the accused person be enlarged on bail with any conditions as deem fit and
proper to be imposed by this Court.
11.
Per contra, Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG, appearing for the
prosecution has submitted that a perusal of the case diary in which is
recorded the progress of investigation and the steps taken by the
Investigating Officer in this case would reveal that it is the accused person
who is responsible for the whole transaction as his name has appeared in all
the relevant documents as well as on the receipts of the cheque issued in
favour of M/s Bomver Force. It is submitted that the accused may not be
enlarged at this stage.
12.
This Court has given due consideration to the submission made
and has also perused the contents of the petition including the annexures
and also the contents of the case diary and all relevant papers produced by
the prosecution.
13.
The facts narrated above is found to be true inasmuch as the supply
order for the said Mobile Forensic Van has indeed been made by the police
department from M/s Bomver Force and the said vehicle has also been
supplied however without the equipments as categorized at C, which fact is
known to the police department at the time of taking delivery of the vehicle.
It is also in evidence and admitted by the accused person that a sum of ₹
42,30,000/- (Rupees forty two lakhs thirty thousand) only was received by
the firm. As to the equipments amounting to about ₹ 3,92,000/- (Rupees
three lakhs ninety two thousand) only which are yet to be supplied, nothing
has been said that such equipments will not be supplied in future.
14.
It is also seen from the records that the name of the accused person
did not figure in any of the correspondence or transaction, but it is only the
admission of the accused person himself who has stated that he has handled
the matter of delivery of the vehicle and had also received the cheque for
the agreed amount.
15.
This Court is in agreement with the learned counsel for the
petitioner that prima facie the accused person is not the proprietor of the
firm but is employed in the capacity of a sales manager.
16.
Be that as it may, the role of the accused person in the case has not
exactly been determined by the I/O at this stage and considering the facts
and circumstances of this case including the seizure made, there may no
longer be any requirement for the accused person to be further incarcerated
in custody.
17.
In the case of Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of
Investigation: (2012) 1 SCC 40 at para 21, 22 and 23, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has observed that: “21. In bail applications, generally, it has been laid down from the
earliest times that the object of bail is to secure the appearance of
the accused person at his trial by reasonable amount of bail. The
object of bail is neither punitive nor preventative. Deprivation of
liberty must be considered a punishment, unless it is required to
ensure that an accused person will stand his trial when called
upon. The courts owe more than verbal respect to the principle
that punishment begins after conviction, and that every man is
deemed to be innocent until duly tried and duly found guilty.
22. From the earliest times, it was appreciated that detention in
custody pending completion of trial could be a cause of great
hardship. From time to time, necessity demands that some
unconvicted persons should be held in custody pending trial to
secure their attendance at the trial but in such cases, “necessity”
is the operative test. In this country, it would be quite contrary to
the concept of personal liberty enshrined in the Constitution that
any person should be punished in respect of any matter, upon
which, he has not been convicted or that in any circumstances, he
should be deprived of his liberty upon only the belief that he will
tamper with the witnesses if left at liberty, save in the most
extraordinary circumstances.
23. Apart from the question of prevention being the object of
refusal of bail, one must not lose sight of the fact that any
imprisonment before conviction has a substantial punitive content
and it would be improper for any court to refuse bail as a mark of
disapproval of former conduct whether the accused has been
convicted for it or not or to refuse bail to an unconvicted person
for the purpose of giving him a taste of imprisonment as a lesson.”
18.
Again, in the case of Dipak Subhashchandra Mehta v. Central
Bureau of Investigation & Anr.: (2012) 4 SCC 134 at para 32, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that: “32. The court granting bail should exercise its discretion in a
judicious manner and not as a matter of course. Though at the
stage of granting bail, a detailed examination of evidence and
elaborate documentation of the merits of the case need not be
undertaken, there is a need to indicate in such orders reasons for
prima facie concluding why bail was being granted, particularly,
where the accused is charged of having committed a serious
offence. The court granting bail has to consider, among other
circumstances, the factors such as (a) the nature of accusation and
severity of punishment in case of conviction and the nature of
supporting evidence; (b) reasonable apprehension of tampering
with the witness or apprehension of threat to the complainant; and
(c) prima facie satisfaction of the court in support of the charge.
In addition to the same, the court while considering a petition for
grant of bail in a non-bailable offence, apart from the seriousness
of the offence, likelihood of the accused fleeing from justice and
tampering with the prosecution witnesses, have to be noted.”
19.
Here is a case where, in the opinion of this Court the discretionary
power for grant of bail has to tilt towards the accused person and as such,
this petition is found meritorious and the same is hereby allowed.
20.
The accused person, Shri. Aylmer S. Hynniewta is directed to be
released on bail on the following conditions:
i.
That he shall not abscond or tamper with the evidence and
witnesses;
ii.
That he shall appear before the Investigating Officer as and
when required;
iii.
That he shall not leave the jurisdiction of the State without
prior permission of the Investigating Officer or the court
concerned; and
iv.
That he shall furnish a personal bond of ₹ 30,000/- (Rupees
thirty thousand) only with two solvent sureties of like amount
to the satisfaction of the concerned court.
21.
Registry is directed to send back the case diary.
22.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
16.03.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review