Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 15th January, 2026
Judgment pronounced on: 23rd February, 2026
+
EX.P. 87/2022 & EX.APPL.(OS) 3572/2022, EX.APPL.(OS)
3573/2022, EX.APPL.(OS) 3574/2022
PETER BECK UND PARTNER
VERMOGENSVERWALTUNG GMBH
.....Decree Holder
Through: Mr. Ankur Kashyap, Mr. Ajith S.
Ranganathan, Mr. Rohit Rajershi, Mr.
Aman Bajaj, Mr. Purushartha Singh &
Mr. Siddharth Dua, Advocates.
versus
PRAKASH INDUSTRIES LIMITED
.....Judgement Debtor
Through: Mr. Sandeep Sethi, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Ankur Chawla, Mr. Akshay
Ringe, Mr. C. B. Bansal, Mr. Gurpreet
Singh, Mr. Kunal Aggarwal, Mr.
Ishanee Kapoor, Ms. Janhavi Negi,
Mr. Shivam Bansal and Mr. Ravi
Sharma, Advocates.
Mr. Abhinav Sharma, Mr. Ankur
Sharma and Mr. Snehashish B.,
Advocates for RBI.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL
JUDGMENT
AMIT BANSAL, J.
1.
The present execution petition has been filed by the decree holder/
petitioner under Section 44A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’),
seeking execution of the final judgment dated 1 st April, 2022 along with the
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
ancillary order dated 20th May, 2022 (‘Foreign Decree’) passed by High
Court of Justice Business & Property Courts of England & Wales Commercial
Court, Queen’s Bench Division (‘English Court’).
2.
Peter Beck und Partner Wermogensverwaltung GMBH, the decree
holder in the present petition, shall hereinafter be referred to as ‘Peter Beck’.
Prakash Industries Limited, the judgment debtor in the present petition, shall
hereinafter be referred to as ‘Prakash Industries’.
PREFATORY FACTS
3.
Prakash Industries is an integrated steel and power company
incorporated in India.
4.
Prakash Industries issued ‘Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds’
(‘FCCBs’) in 2009 and 2010, which were subscribed by Peter Beck. A
Subscription Agreement dated 20th December, 2017 was entered between
Prakash Industries and Peter Beck (‘Subscription Agreement’). The said
Subscription Agreement was governed by the English law.
5.
FCCBs are subject to comprehensive regulatory regime under Foreign
Exchange Management Act, 1999 (‘FEMA’), including directions/circulars
issued by the RBI.
6.
In the present case, FCCBs subscribed by Peter Beck were duly
approved by RBI through its letter dated 8th November, 2017.
7.
Disputes arose between the parties on account of default committed by
Prakash Industries in paying the coupon interest on the aforesaid FCCBs.
8.
Prakash Industries instituted proceedings against Peter Beck before the
English Court, seeking a declaration of non-liability to pay the coupon interest
and damages for late conversions.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
9.
Peter Beck filed its counter-claim seeking payment of Early
Redemption Amount (‘ERA’) triggered by non-payment of coupon interest
and damages for late conversion of the FCCBs.
10.
The English Court pronounced its final judgment on 1st April, 2022 and
held that Prakash Industries defaulted in making payments of coupon interest
and delayed the conversion of the FCCBs into equity.
11.
Subsequently, the English Court vide ancillary order dated 20th May,
2022 directed Prakash Industries to pay to Peter Beck the following sums:
i. The debt amount in respect to ERA amounting to USD
11,230,700 along with an interest amounting to USD
2,634,915.15.
ii. Damages for late conversion of bonds amounting to USD
3,532,711.67 along with an interest amounting to USD
514,995.52.
iii. 60% of Peter Beck’s costs for the proceedings.
iv. An amount of GBP 558,034.99 as an interim payment on
account of the costs awarded.
v. Future Interest at a rate of 8% per annum, calculated from 4th
June, 2022 till the date of payment.
12.
Prakash Industries did not file any appeal against the aforesaid
judgment and decree passed by the English Court and hence, the judgment
/decree became final under the English law.
13.
The present execution petition has been filed on behalf of Peter Beck
under Section 44A of the CPC seeking execution of the judgment/ decree
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
passed by the English Court, being ‘Superior Court’ of a ‘reciprocating
territory’.
14.
Prakash Industries filed an application being EX.APPL. 3785/2022,
stating that this Court did not have territorial jurisdiction to entertain the
present petition since Prakash Industries does not have any immovable
property within the jurisdiction of this Court and no cause of action has arisen
within the jurisdiction of this Court. The said application was dismissed via
judgment dated 3rd May, 2023. The said judgment was challenged by Prakash
Industries by way of an appeal being EFA (OS) 9/2023, which was dismissed
as withdrawn vide order dated 10th April, 2024.
OBJECTIONS RAISED BY PRAKASH INDUSTRIES
15.
In the objections filed on behalf of Prakash Industries, it is stated that
the Foreign Decree is in violation of the provisions of FEMA and therefore,
falls within the exceptions provided under Section 13(c) and 13(f) of the CPC.
16.
Yet another objection taken on behalf of Prakash Industries is that under
the provisions of FEMA, payment under FCCBs can only be made to the
‘registered account’ of the bond holder within the meaning of contractual
definition and no such registered account of the bond holder was available in
the present case.
17.
In light of the objections raised by Prakash Industries with regard to the
FEMA violations, this Court issued a notice to the Reserve Bank of India
(‘RBI’) to clarify its position on the remittance of funds in satisfaction of a
Foreign Decree.
18.
On 5th November, 2024, counsel appearing on behalf of RBI made a
statement before the Court that there is no bar insofar as remittance of any
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
amount is concerned, since the same is in satisfaction of a judgment. Pursuant
to the aforesaid order, an affidavit dated 25th February, 2025 was filed on
behalf of the RBI. Yet another affidavit was filed on behalf of RBI on 18th
November, 2025, pursuant to the order passed on 8th September, 2025 and 10th
October, 2025.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF PETER BECK
19.
No ground relating to the violations of the FEMA was raised by Prakash
Industries before the English Court and therefore, Prakash Industries is now
precluded from raising this ground at the stage of execution.
20.
FEMA violations by themselves cannot bar execution of a foreign
decree. The issues arising under FEMA are only compliance related and do
not affect the execution of a decree. Ex-post facto permission, if required, can
be obtained from the RBI. Reliance in this regard is placed on the judgments
in NTT Docomo Inc. v. Tata Sons Limited1(‘NTT Docomo’) and Arun
Kumar Jagatramka v. Ultrabulk A/S,2 (‘Ultrabulk’).
21.
As per the ‘all-in-cost ceiling’ provided in paragraph 2.1(vii) of the
Master Direction of External Commercial Borrowing, Trade Credits and
Structural Obligations dated 26th March, 2019 issued by the RBI (‘Master
Direction-ECB’), pre-payment charges and penal interest upto 2% over and
above the contracted rate can be awarded. In the present case, the coupon rate
of FCCBs was 5.95%. Therefore, the interest awarded by the English Court
at 7.95% was within the 2% ceiling.
2017 SCC OnLine Del 8078.
2023 SCC OnLine Guj 3152.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
22.
Insofar as the claim for damages is concerned, it arises from a breach
of a contractual obligation by Prakash Industries, i.e. failure to convert FCCBs
into equity in a timely manner. Therefore, the Master Direction-ECB would
have no applicability on the question of damages. Neither paragraph 2.1(vi)
nor paragraph 2.1(vii) of the Master Direction-ECB refers to ‘damages’. The
imposition of interest is judicial determination made by the English Court,
which squarely falls within its jurisdiction.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF PRAKASH INDUSTRIES
23.
The Foreign Decree passed by the English Court is in violation of the
provisions of FEMA and the directions/circulars issued by the RBI and hence
is unenforceable under Section 13(c) and (f) of the CPC.
24.
The English Court has not followed the FEMA Regulations and the
directions/circulars issued by the RBI while awarding interest and/ or
damages. Under the Master Direction-ECB, the interest must be within the
‘all-in-cost ceiling’ and damages have to comply with stipulations of
paragraphs 2.1(vi) and 2.1(vii). The English Court has awarded an interest at
the rate of 7.95% per annum, which exceeds the permissible ‘all-in-cost
ceiling’ under the Master Direction-ECB.
25.
In terms of paragraph 2.1(vii) of the Master Direction-ECB, ‘other
costs’ including pre-payment charges should not exceed 2% of the contracted
interest rate, however, the English Court has awarded damages of USD
4,047,707, which is way beyond the 2% of the principal outstanding amount.
26.
The affidavit filed on behalf of RBI on 25th February, 2025 confirms
that interest awarded beyond the ceiling stipulated in the RBI’s ECB
guidelines would be in violation of Master Direction-ECB. Similarly, it has
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
been clarified by RBI in its affidavit dated 18th November, 2025 that any
damages or other costs payable in connection with ECB transaction must not
exceed 2% per annum over the contracted interest rate.
27.
The aforesaid ceilings prescribed by the RBI have a force of law and
are not merely regulatory guidelines. Any payments in excess of these limits
would be in contravention of FEMA. Therefore, the contention of Peter Beck
that the issue of violation of FEMA is only a regulatory issue and not a
substantial issue is misplaced.
28.
The judgments relied upon by Peter Beck are in relation to enforcement
of foreign arbitral awards. The statutory framework of foreign awards under
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 is distinct and materially different
from execution of foreign judgments under Section 44A read with Section 13
of CPC. Therefore, the aforesaid judgments would not be applicable in the
present case.
29.
Since the account furnished by Peter Beck is not in the name of a
registered bond holder, the amounts cannot be remitted to the said account.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
30.
I have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the material on
record.
31.
It is an undisputed fact that the United Kingdom is a ‘reciprocating
territory’ as per Section 44A of the CPC. It is also not in dispute that in the
present case, the judgment/decree has been passed by the High Court of
Justice Business & Property Courts of England & Wales Commercial Court,
Queen’s Bench Division, which would be a ‘Superior Court’ of a
‘reciprocating territory’.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
32.
To begin with, I will discuss the legal position with regard to execution
of a foreign judgment/decree under Section 44A of the CPC. In Alcon
Electronics Private Limited v. Celem S.A. of FOS 34320 Roujan, Frane and
Another3 (‘Alcon Electronics’), the Supreme Court has emphasised that
Courts of all nations should enforce judgments of the Foreign Courts. In the
said case, the appellant (judgment debtor) had taken a plea that the costs
imposed by the Foreign Court exceed the limit imposed under Section 35A of
the CPC and therefore, the said order of the English Court is not executable
in India. The aforesaid contention was rejected by the Supreme Court.
33.
Relevant extracts from the said judgment are set out below:
“31. The appellant has advanced an argument that as per Section 35-A
CPC, no court should pass any order for the payment of compensatory
costs exceeding Rs 3000 or exceeding the limits of its pecuniary
jurisdiction of the said court whichever amount is less. It is thus argued by
the appellant that in the present case, since the costs imposed exceed the
bar imposed by Section 35-A, therefore, the order of the English Court is
not executable in the present case.
32. This argument lacks merit and deserves to be rejected. A bare perusal
of Section 35-A shows that bar operates on the Indian Courts with regard
to imposition of costs in respect of false or vexatious claims or defences.
The bar is not attracted in the present case as the Court that has ordered
the costs is the High Court of Justice in England which is not governed by
the provisions of CPC...
***
***
***
37. It is to the reciprocal advantage of the courts of all nations to
enforce foreign rights as far as practicable. To this end, broad
recognition of substantive rights should not be defeated by some vague
assumed limitations of the court. When substantive rights are so bound
up in a foreign remedy, the refusal to adopt the remedy would substantially
deprive parties of their rights. The necessity of maintaining the foreign
rights outweighs the practical difficulties involved in applying the foreign
remedy. In India, although the interest on costs are not available due to
(2012) 2 SCC 253.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
exclusion of Section 35(3), the same does not mean that Indian Courts
are powerless to execute the decree for interest on costs. Indian Courts
are very much entitled to address the issue for execution of the interest
amount. The right to 8% interest as per the Judgments Act, 1838 of UK
can be recognised and as well as implemented in India.”
[emphasis supplied]
34.
A reference may be made to the judgment of Gujarat High Court in
Arun Kumar Jagatramka v. Ultrabulk A/S4 (‘Ultrabulk’), wherein the
Gujarat High Court was dealing with execution of a foreign judgment under
Section 44A of the CPC. The Court rejected the judgment debtor’s contention
that foreign judgement is not enforceable under Section 13(c) of CPC as
decree was made in contravention of FEMA Regulations. It was held that
transactions that violate FEMA cannot be held to be void and it is always open
to a party to seek permission of the RBI on a post-facto basis. Relevant
paragraph of the aforesaid judgment is set out below:
“12. Having considered these provisions, what is evident is that
transactions that violate FEMA cannot be held to be void. If any act
violates the provisions of FEMA, permission of RBI may be obtained
post- facto. Therefore, it cannot be said that the foreign judgement is in
breach of Indian law or fails to recognise such breach and therefore is
inconclusive. The reasonings of the learned Executing Court cannot be
faulted.”
[emphasis supplied]
35.
At the outset, it may be noted that the issue of violation of FEMA was
never raised by Prakash Industries before the English Court. Therefore, there
was no occasion for the English Court to give a finding on the said issue. A
foreign court cannot be expected to take cognizance of an Indian statute,
unless it has been pointed out by a contesting party. This is not a case of an ex
2023 SCC OnLine Guj 3152.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
parte decree as Prakash Industries was duly contesting the case before the
English Court.
36.
Nevertheless, I proceed to examine the objections raised by Prakash
Industries with regard to violations under the FEMA Regulations and the
directions/circulars issued by the RBI.
37.
In the affidavit filed on behalf of RBI on 25th February, 2025, it has
been stated that the RBI is empowered to make regulations by way of
notifications, to give effect to the provisions of FEMA and the rules made
thereunder. The RBI by exercising the powers conferred upon it, has issued
Foreign Exchange Management (Borrowing and Lending) Regulation, 2018
dated 17th December, 2018 which provides for borrowing and lending
between a person resident in India and a person resident outside India.
38.
Directions issued under the aforesaid Regulation in respect of
borrowing transactions have been compiled in the FED Master Direction
No.5/2018-19 dated 26th March, 2019 pertaining to External Commercial
Borrowings, Trade Credits and Structured Obligations (‘Master DirectionECB’) which has been placed on record by the RBI along with the said
affidavit.
39.
It may be relevant to refer to the definition of ‘all-in-cost ceiling’ given
in Master Direction-ECB:
“1.1. All-in-Cost: It includes rate of interest, other fees, expenses,
charges, guarantee fees, ECA charges, whether paid in foreign currency
or INR but will not include commitment fees and withholding tax
payable in INR. In the case of fixed rate loans, the swap cost plus spread
should not be more than the floating rate plus the applicable spread.
Additionally, for FCCBs, the issue related expenses should not exceed 4
per cent of the issue size and in case of private placement, these expenses
should not exceed 2 per cent of the issue size, etc. Under TC Framework,
all-in-cost shall include rate of interest, other fees, expenses, charges,
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
guarantee fees whether paid in foreign currency or INR. Withholding tax
payable in INR shall not be a part of all-in-cost. Various components of
all-in-cost have to be paid by the borrower without taking recourse to the
drawdown of ECB/TC, i.e., ECB/TC proceeds cannot be used for payment
of interest/charges.
[emphasis supplied]
40.
The relevant provisions of the aforesaid Master Direction-ECB
in relation the objections raised by Prakash Industries are set below.
“2.1. ECB Framework: The framework for raising loans through ECB
(hereinafter referred to as the ECB Framework) comprises the following
two options:
Sr. No. Parameters
vi
vii
FCY denominated ECB
INR
denominate
d ECB
All-in-cost
Benchmark Rate plus 550 bps Benchmar
ceiling per spread: For existing ECBs linked to k rate plus
annum
LIBOR whose benchmarks are 450 bps
changed to ARR.
spread.
Benchmark rate plus 500 bps spread:
For new ECBs.
All-in-cost ceiling has been temporarily increased
by 100 bps for ECBs raised till December 31, 2022.
The enhanced all-in-cost ceiling shall be available
only to eligible borrowers of investment grade rating
from Indian Credit Rating Agencies (CRAs). Other
eligible borrowers may raise ECB within the existing
all-in-cost ceiling as hitherto.
Other costs Prepayment charge/ Penal interest, if any, for
default or breach of covenants, should not be more
than 2 per cent over and above the contracted rate
of interest on the outstanding principal amount
and will be outside the all-in-cost ceiling.
[emphasis supplied]
41.
In terms of paragraph 2.1(vi) set out above, the ‘all-in-cost ceiling’ in
respect of Bonds in the present case would be LIBOR (London Interbank
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
Offered Rate) plus 550 BPS. The aforesaid ceiling would apply to the rate of
interest under the Subscription Agreement. In terms of Clause 5.1 of the
Subscription Agreement, the interest rate on the FCCBs was stipulated at
5.95% per annum. Since it is an undisputed fact that the RBI has approved the
Subscription Agreement, along with the coupon rate of 5.95% mentioned
therein, it has to be presumed that the interest rate was in terms of the limits
provided in paragraph 2.1(vi) of the Master Direction-ECB.
42.
The relevant extracts from the RBI Approval Letter dated 8th
November, 2017 are set out below:
[emphasis supplied]
\
43.
A reference may be made to Clause 7.6.1 and Clause 7.6.2 of the
Subscription Agreement, which provide for additional default interest of 2%
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
per annum which is in accordance with the 2% ceiling given in paragraph
2.1(vii) of the Master Direction-ECB. Clauses 7.6.1 and 7.6.2 are set out
below:
“7.6 Default Interest and Delay in Payment
7.6.1 If the Issuer fails to pay any sum in respect of the Bonds when the
same becomes due and payable under these Conditions, interest (including
interest of 5.95% per cent and additional default interest of 2 per cent)
shall accrue on the overdue sum. The additional default interest of 2 per
cent per annum shall accrue on the overdue sum until receipt of all sums
due in respect of the Bonds. Such interest and default interest shall accrue
on the basis of the actual number of days elapsed and a 360-day year.
7.6.2 The default interest at the rate of 2 per cent over the contracted
interest rate for default or breach of covenants will accrue in accordance
with paragraph 2.4.4 of the Master Direction on External Commercial
Borrowings, Trade Credit, Borrowing and Lending in Foreign Currency
by Authorised Dealers and Persons other than Authorised Dealers issued
by the RBI on January 1, 2016 and updated up to October 9, 2017.”
[emphasis supplied]
44.
Counsel appearing on behalf of Peter Beck submits that taking into
account the aforesaid provisions of the Master Direction-ECB, the amount
awarded by the English Court is within the permissible limits of RBI.
45.
Per contra, it is contended on behalf of Prakash Industries that the
amount awarded by the English Court is in excess of the aforesaid ceiling.
46.
In light of the aforesaid objections raised by Prakash Industries
regarding violations of FEMA, this Court issued notice to RBI to clarify its
stand and position on the issue of remittance of funds in satisfaction of a
Foreign Decree. The relevant extracts from the affidavit filed by the RBI on
25th February, 2025 are set out below:
“10. The amounts payable by the judgement debtor to the decree holder
in the present case is pursuant to the Foreign Decree passed by the Foreign
Court. The amount to be paid by the Judgement Debtor as the Early
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
Redemption Amount is a capital account transaction and amount to be
paid as damages and interest payments is a current account transaction
under FEMA.
11. The payment of the Early Redemption Amount is akin to the
repayment of FCCBs. If the minimum average maturity period of FCCBs
concerned is completed, such payment can be remitted under the general
permission available to the designated Authorised Dealer as per
Paragraph 13 of Schedule I of FEMA.3(R). Other payments pertaining to
damages and interest payments being of the nature of current account do
not require approval from RBI in terms of Section 5 of FEMA, 1999 read
with the Foreign Exchange Management (Current Account Transactions)
Rules, 2000 dated May 03, 2000. Nevertheless, as the interest and damages
are to be paid as part of a loan agreement between a person resident in
India and a person resident outside India, these have to necessarily
conform to the extant provisions of ECB guidelines under FEMA, i.e., the
interest shall be within the ‘All-in cost ceiling’ and damages will need to
comply with the other costs stipulation as defined in Para 2.1(vi) and Para
c respectively of Master Direction on External Commercial Borrowings,
Trade Credits and Structured Obligations dated March 26, 2019 (as
updated)….”
47.
Taking note of what has been stated in paragraph 11 of the RBI’s
affidavit set out above, this Court on 8th September, 2025 passed an order
directing the RBI to take instructions whether paragraphs 2.1(vi) and 2.1(vii)
of the Master Direction-ECB would apply on damages awarded by a Foreign
Court. The relevant paragraphs no. 3 and 4 of the aforesaid order are set out
below:
“3. In the portion highlighted above, the Reserve Bank of India has
stated that “damages will need to comply with other costs stipulation as
defined in Para 2.1(vi) and 2.1(vii) respectively of Master Direction on
External Commercial Borrowings, Trade Credits and Structured
Obligations dated March 26, 2019 (as updated).” However, a perusal of
the provisions of the Master Direction does not make any reference to
‘damages’.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
4.
Accordingly, counsel appearing on behalf of the Reserve Bank of
India shall take instructions whether paragraphs 2.1(vi) and 2.1(vii) deal
with the aspect of damages awarded by a foreign Court.”
48.
In response to the aforesaid order, an affidavit has been filed on behalf
of the RBI on 18th November, 2025, wherein it has been stated as under:“5.1 The paragraph 2.1 (vii) of the Master Direction on External
Commercial Borrowings, Trade Credits and Structured obligations dated
march 26, 2019 (as updated) regarding other costs provides that
Prepayment charge/ Penal interest, if any, for default or breach of
covenants, should not be more than 2 per cent over and above the
contracted rate of interest on the outstanding principal amount and will
be outside the all-in-cost ceiling.
5.2 The objective of the said provision is to ensure that the parties
entering into to an ECB agreement are aware even before the execution of
a such agreement that a non-resident lender could make a maximum
claim of up to 2 per cent of the outstanding principle (over and above the
all-in-cost ceiling) on the resident borrower in case of a breach of any
provision of the ECB agreement.
5.3 Although the penalty/ damages/ interest payable against a cross
border borrowing transaction are current account transactions, the
powers to impose conditions on such current account transactions, linked
to an underlying capital account transaction (ECB), flow from Section
6(2)(c) of FEMA, 1999. Accordingly, such restrictions on current account
transactions linked to ECB are part of the extant ECB Regulations and
Directions stipulated under FEMA, 1999. Therefore, the damages
payable by a resident borrower to a non-resident lender is required to be
subjected to limits as prescribed in para 2.1(vii) of the Master Direction.”
[emphasis supplied]
49.
As per the decree passed by the English Court, amounts have been
awarded in favour of Peter Beck under the following heads:
A. Early Redemption Amount (‘ERA’):
(i) USD 11,230,700.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
(ii) Interest on early redemption amount at the rate of 7.95% per annum
amounting to USD 2,634,915.
B. Damages for delay in conversion:
(i) damages amounting to USD 3,532,711.
(ii) interest on damages amounting to USD 514,995.
50.
The damages were awarded by the English Court on account of breach
committed by Prakash Industries of its contractual obligations i.e. failure to
convert the FCCBs into equity in a timely manner as was agreed in the
Subscription Agreement. The English Court has also awarded interest on the
aforesaid amount of damages, which was squarely within its jurisdiction.
51.
In my considered view, the amounts awarded by a competent Court,
whether Indian or foreign, towards damages for breach of contract, cannot be
subject to ceilings prescribed under FEMA and/or RBI directions/circulars.
52.
Even if amounts have been awarded under certain heads by a Foreign
Court of competent jurisdiction, which are not permissible in Indian law, the
decree passed by the Foreign Court would not become unenforceable. This
would be particularly true in cases where the contract between the parties is
governed by foreign law and the foreign court has adjudicated the case on the
basis of the said foreign law. In Alcon Electronics (supra), the Supreme Court
had rejected the objection raised by the judgment debtor that since costs
imposed by the Foreign Court were not in terms of Section 35A of the CPC,
the decree passed by the foreign Court is unenforceable. The Supreme Court
held that Indian courts can execute a foreign decree for interest on costs,
which are permissible under the UK law.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
53.
Even in the Master Direction-ECB, the reference in paragraph 2.1 (vii)
is to ‘other costs’, which only includes (a) prepayment charges and (b) penal
interest, both of which are interest related charges. By no stretch of
imagination, the damages awarded by a foreign court can be made subject to
the aforesaid provision. There is no reference to damages either in paragraph
2(vi) or in paragraph 2(vii) of the Master Direction-ECB or any other
provision in the Master Direction-ECB. Therefore, it is clear that aforesaid
Master Direction-ECB is not applicable to damages awarded by a foreign
court.
54.
RBI in its affidavit filed on 25th February 2025 has stated that amounts
paid towards damages is a current account transaction under FEMA and hence
do not require approval from RBI. However, the RBI proceeds to state that
since the said current account transactions are linked to an underlying capital
account transaction (ECB), the damages paid by a resident borrower to a nonresident lender would be subjected to limits as prescribed under paragraph
2.1(vii) of the Master Direction-ECB.
55.
Taking note of the contradiction in the stand taken by the RBI, this
Court vide order dated 8th September, 2025 had directed RBI to file an
affidavit. Even in the subsequent affidavit filed by RBI on 18th November,
2025, same stand was maintained.
56.
This Court is unable to accept the stand taken by RBI that the ‘damages’
awarded by a foreign court against a resident borrower and in favour of a nonresident lender would be subjected to limits prescribed in paragraph 2.1(vii)
of the Master Direction-ECB.
57.
It is manifest from reading of the judgment in NTT Docomo (supra)
that damages for breach of contract, such as those awarded by the English
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
Court in the present case, cannot be subjected to FEMA Regulations or RBI
guidelines. The RBI in NTT Docomo (supra) had raised an objection that
permission from the RBI is required for transmission of amount awarded as
damages by the Arbitral Tribunal. However, the Court held that in respect of
damages awarded by an Arbitral Tribunal, no general or special permission
from the RBI would be required. The Court while declining RBI’s request for
intervention in the enforcement proceedings, held that FEMA and RBI
directions/circulars could not be invoked to obstruct or dilute the enforcement
of a foreign award.
58.
Relevant extracts from the judgment in NTT Docomo (supra) judgment
are set out below:
“44. The very stand that RBI is now taking in this Court that without its
special permission there cannot be a transfer of monies by Tata to
Docomo, was taken by Tata before the AT and was expressly negatived
by the AT by a unanimous Award. The AT decided that since the sum
awarded to Docomo was in the nature of damages and not the Sale Price
of the shares, the question of having to seek the special permission of
RBI did not arise….
***
***
***
51. The Award is very clear on this issue. What was awarded to Docomo
were damages and not the price of the shares. The order that the share
scrips must be returned to Tata was only incidental and, in fact, Docomo
itself was not interested in retaining the share scrips. It could be seen as
an acknowledgment of Docomo volunteering to return the share scrips as
they were of no particular use to it. It is not open to RBI to re-characterise
the nature of the payment in terms of the Award to which there is no longer
any opposition from Tata, the only party which could possibly oppose its
enforcement. RBI has not placed before the Court any requirement for
any permission of RBI having to be obtained for Docomo to receive the
money as damages in terms of the Award.”
[emphasis supplied]
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
59.
Even though NTT Docomo (supra) pertains to a foreign arbitral award,
the aforesaid findings would equally be applicable in cases where a decree
awarding damages has been passed by a foreign court.
60.
Now, I shall deal with the objections in respect of amounts that have
been awarded by the English Court in favour of Peter Beck towards ‘Early
Redemption Amount’ and interest on the said amount at the rate of 7.95% per
annum.
61.
The ERA has been granted by the English Court in terms of Clause 10.1
and Clause 11.1 of the Subscription Agreement which provided for
acceleration of the bonds in the event of default, which occurred in the present
case due to non-payment of coupon interest by Prakash Industries. Clearly,
there is no bar under any of the FEMA regulations or the Master DirectionECB in respect of such early redemption.
62.
Insofar as interest is concerned, as noted above, the Subscription
Agreement provided for interest at the rate of 5.95% on the FCCBs and an
additional default interest of 2% per annum.
63.
In terms of paragraph 2.1 (vii), a penal interest with a cap of 2% could
be imposed as ‘pre-prepayment charge/penal interest’ over and above the
contracted rate of interest on the outstanding principal amount, which would
be outside the ‘all-in-cost ceiling’ imposed under paragraph 2.1 (vi).
64.
Viewed in this light, the interest awarded by the English Court on the
ERA at the rate of 7.95%, clearly falls within the cap of 2% provided under
paragraph 2.1 (vii) of the Master Direction-ECB. Therefore, there is no merit
in the objection taken on behalf of Prakash Industries that the interest has been
awarded by the English Court over and above what is stipulated in the Master
Direction-ECB.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
65.
Insofar as the objection raised by Prakash Industries with regard to
Peter Beck not providing a bank account, RBI has categorically stated that
payments can be made to the Euro account provided by Peter Beck in
paragraph no. 11 of its rejoinder dated 19th July, 2023.
66.
Paragraph no. 12 of the said RBI affidavit is set out below:
“12. The payment by the Judgment Debtor to the Euro account of the
Decree Holder, as stated in para 11 of the rejoinder or payment by a
cheque in USD or any other foreign currency is not barred by FEMA and
regulations issued thereunder in terms of FEMA 14(R) read with FEMA
3(R).”
[emphasis supplied]
CONCLUSION
67.
In view of the discussion above, it is held that the decree passed by the
English Court is executable under Section 44A of the CPC. The said Decree
does not fall under the exceptions provided under Section 13(c) and 13(f) of
the CPC.
68.
The objections raised on behalf of the Prakash Industries are
completely devoid of merits and have been filed solely to cause obstruction
and to cause delay in the execution of the Foreign Decree. Consequently, the
same are rejected with costs of Rs. 1,00,000 payable to the decree holder/Peter
Beck.
69.
In view thereof, Prakash Industries is liable to remit the decretal amount
in favour of Peter Beck along with costs.
70.
Accordingly, a direction is issued to the Registry of this Court to remit
the amounts deposited in Court, along with accrued interest to the Euro
dominated bank account, provided by Peter Beck in paragraph no. 11 of the
rejoinder which is set out below:
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
“11. …Recipient Name: Peter Beck und Partner Vermögensverwaltungs
GmbH
International Bank Account Number (‘IBAN’): DE17 6115 0020 0056 0830 95
Bank Identification Code (‘BIC’): ESSLDE66XXX
Bank: Kreissparkasse Esslingen-Nürtingen”
71.
The remaining amount shall be remitted directly by Prakash Industries
to Peter Beck in the aforementioned account.
72.
All pending applications stand disposed of.
AMIT BANSAL
(JUDGE)
FEBRUARY 23, 2026
at
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
10:52:08
EX.P. 87/2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review