Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved on: 30.05.2026
Delivered on: 18.06.2026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Appeal From Order No.305 of 2024
PepsiCo India Holdings Private Limited
………….Appellant
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and another
......…..Respondents
Present:- Mr. Rajesh Batra, Mr. Hari Mohan Bhatia and Ms. Sonia Kukreja
(through video conferencing), Advocates for the appellant.
Mr. Ganesh Kandpal, Additional Advocate General for the State.
JUDGMENT
Per: Hon’ble Ravindra Maithani, J.
The challenge in this appeal is made to the following:(i)
The judgment and order dated 31.05.2024, passed in
Appeal No.1 of 2019, PepsiCo India Holdings Private
Limited and another Vs. State of Uttarakhand and
another,
by
the
Food
Safety
Appellate
Tribunal,
Dehradun (“the appeal”); and
(ii)
Judgment and order dated 21.12.2018, passed in
Case No.2 of 2015, State vs. Shashibhushan Pant and
others, by the Adjudicating Officer/Additional District
Magistrate, Garhwal (“the case”), by which the penalty
of Rs.1.5 Lakhs have been imposed on each of the
appellants.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
3.
Briefly stated, according to the case, on 08.06.2015, the
Food Safety Officer, Garhwal inspected the shop owned by Mr.
Shashi Bhushan Pant in the name and style of M/s N.S.,
Enterprise, Agency, Badrinath Road, Srinagar, Pauri Garhwal. The
Food Safety Officer after disclosing his identity to the shop keeper
purchased four packets of “Lahar Aloo Bhujia”. One of the samples
was sent for examination to the Food Laboratory. The analyst
opined that the product is misbranded because the label contains
the phrase “Maha Value”. Subsequent to the report, sanction for
prosecution was sought and, thereafter, the case was filed before
the Adjudicating Officer.
4.
The Adjudicating Officer issued notice to the appellant,
which was replied. The first observation of the public analyst was
that the original label does not comply with the Food Safety and
Standards Act, 2006 (“the FSS Act”), Food Safety and Standards
Rules, 2011 (“the 2011 Rules”), as “Maha Value” is written in the
corner of the packet.
5.
It has been the case of the appellant that the phrase
“Maha Value” on the label could not be termed as violation under
the FSS Act and the phrase “Maha Value” is written on the product
to indicate/inform the consumer that the product retail package is
actually a value package in terms of quantity. The appellant also
responded that the product is not misbranded.
6.
The exact response given by the appellant is as follows:“Response to Observation 1:
At the outset, we wish to submit that the use of words ‘Maha Value’
do not in any manner relate to the food or its quality or nutritive
value of the retail package of Lehar Aloo Bhujia. The use of these
words cannot constitute violation of any provision of Food Safety and
Standards Act, 2006 or Packaging Regulations framed thereunder.
The use of the phrase ‘Maha Value is in compliance of the scheme of
Legal Metrology Act and The Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodity)
rules, 2011 framed thereunder. The Legal Metrology Act, 2009 is an
act to establish and enforce standards of weights and measures,
regulate trade and commerce in weights, measures and other goods
which are sold or distributed by weight, measure or number and for
matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. The phrase ‘Maha
Value’ is in compliance of Rule 12 of the The Metrology (Packaged
commodity) Rules, 2011 which provides that declaration of quantity
shall be expressed in terms of such unit of weight, measure or
number or a combination which would give an accurate and adequate
information to the consumers as regards the weight of the commodity
contained in the retail package sold by the company. As regards the
additional declaration of quantity, the same is also well within the
scheme of the Legal Metrology Act and the Legal Metrology (Packaged
Commodity) rules, 2011 framed therein.
Further, the use of term ‘Maha Value’ upon the product is to indicate
to the consumers that the product retail package is actually a Value
Package. The following provisions are being reproduced for ready
reference:
“5.
Specific
commodities
to
be
packed
and sold in
recommended standard packages. –
2[(1)] The commodities specified in the Second Schedule shall
be packed for sale, distribution or delivery in such standard
quantities as are specified in that Schedule.]
1[***]
2[(2)]
When one or more packages intended for retail sale
are grouped together for being sold as a retail package on
promotional offer, every package of the group shall comply
with provisions of rule 6.]
2[(3
Notwithstanding anything
contained in the Second
Schedule, the manufacturer or importer may sell the value
based package in terms of Re.1, Rs.2, Rs.3, Rs.4, Rs.5,
Rs.6, Rs.7, Rs.8, Rs.9 and Rs.10 after making the other
declarations specified in rule 6.]”
7.
After hearing the parties, the Adjudicatory Authority, by
the impugned judgment dated 21.12.2018 held that writing of
“Maha Value” on the label is in violation of Sections 3(1)(zf)(A)(i) of
the FSS Act as well as it is also violation of Rule 2.3.1 of the Food
Safety and Standards (Packaging and Labelling) Regulations, 2011
(“the Regulation 2011). Accordingly, under Section 52 of the FSS
Act, Rs.1.5 Lakhs penalty was imposed upon the appellant and
upon M/s Bikanerwala Food Products Pvt. Ltd. The Adjudicating
Authority did not impose any penalty upon the shopkeeper, he was
exonerated. Aggrieved by it, the appellant and M/s Bikanerwala
Food Products Pvt. Ltd. preferred an appeal before the Tribunal.
The Tribunal confirmed the judgment and order dated 21.12.2018,
passed by the Adjudicatory Authority. Hence, the appeal.
8.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that writing of
“Maha Value” on the label cannot be termed as misbranded. It has
not been proved that the label gives any false information. He would
submit that the phrase “Maha Value” refers to the quantity, not
quality of the food and there is no reasoning given in the Food
Analyst Report, as to why the food is misbranded or/and, as to why
the information is false? Therefore, it is argued that based on such
incomplete Food Analyst Report even prosecution is not permitted
and the penalty that has been imposed, is liable to be set aside.
9.
Learned Counsel has referred to Sections 3, 23 of the FSS
Act. Regulations 2011 have also been referred to.
10.
In support of his contention, learned counsel for the
appellant has placed reliance on the principals of law as laid down
in the cases of:- (1) Bal Kishan Thapar Vs. Municipal Corporation of
Delhi, (1979)2 SCC 459; Parakh Foods Limited Vs. State of Andhra
Pradesh and another, (2008)4 SCC 584; Sterling Agro Industrial
Ltd. and another Vs. State of Uttarakhand, 2014 SCC OnLine Utt
147;Pepsico India Holdings Pvt. Ltd. and another Vs. State of
Madhya Pradesh, M.C.R.C. No.6848/2011 decided on 18.06.2019;
Glaxo India Ltd. Vs. State of Assam and others, (2003) 1 Gauhati
Law Reports 407.
11.
In the case of Bal Kishan Thapar (Supra), preparation
called ‘Para Excellent’ and ‘Para Asli’ were purchased by the Food
Inspector and according to the Food Inspector, the shopkeeper sold
those
preparation
as
Saccharin.
It
was
argued
that
it
is
misbranding. In para 4 of the judgment the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that it is not misbranding. The Hon’ble Court observed as
follows:-
“4....................................................................................................
......................................................................................................
The words, “as sweet as saccharin' were merely meant to convey one
of the qualities of the preparation itself and not the quality of
saccharin at all. That, by itself, would not attract the provision of
Section 2(ix)(a) of the Act. It was then submitted that in one of the
labels under the directions it was mentioned that the preparation was
‘para saccharin” which also shows that the appellant intended to
pass on the preparation as some sort of saccharin. In the first place,
the use of the word ‘para saccharin’ appears to be a mistake in the
facts of the present case because this word is completely absent from
the Hindi portion of the directions contained in the same label.
Secondly, the word “para saccharin” would not indicate that the
preparation sold was saccharin in any form or of any kind. It was just
a way of describing it because according to the manufacturers the
preparation was as sweet as saccharin. This was mentioned because
saccharin being 500 times sweeter than sugar, the manufacturer
wanted to convey that the preparation was also much sweeter than
sugar and could be used for preparing soda water bottles. It is
obvious that if any person who purchased the preparation was not
conversant with the English language, he would not be misled at all.”
12.
In the case of Parakh Foods Limited (Supra), on a packet
of Soyabean oil there were pictures of vegetables like cabbage,
carrot, brinjal, capsicum, cauliflower, tomato and onions, it was
termed as misbranded by the Food Inspector. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court has held that it is not misbranding, the Hon’ble Court
observed as follows:-
“11. In the present case, it is true that the appellant has used
pictures of vegetables on the label of the product which is refined
soyabean oil, which according to the appellant is to depict the
purpose for which the oil can be used viz. preparation of the
vegetables depicted thereon. Unless the picture depicted on a label
of edible oils and fats exaggerates the quality of the product, it
would not fall within the mischief of Rule 37-D. In the present
case, the vegetables shown on the label of soyabean oil do not in
any way indicate that the quality of soyabean oil is “super-refined”,
“extra-refined”, “micro-refined”, “double-refined”, “ultra-refined”,
“anti-cholesterol”,
“cholesterol
fighter”,
“soothing
to
heart”,
“cholesterol friendly”, “saturated fat free”, etc. nor it indicates the
exaggeration towards the quality of the product to come within the
mischief of Rule 37-D of the PFA Rules. In our opinion the High
Court has committed a serious error in arriving at a finding that
the article of food (soyabean oil) was misbranded since the picture
contained on the label has nothing to do with the article of food in
question, completely ignoring the fact that the article of food can
be used for cooking the vegetables shown in the picture which
cannot be said to be exaggerating the quality of the food in
question.”
13.
In the case of Sterling Agro Industrial Ltd. (Supra), on a
packet of skimmed milk the phrase, “dream of healthy India” was
written. The Coordinate Bench of this Court referred to the
judgment passed by the other Courts on the subject and in paras 7
and 8 observed as follows:-
“7. The aforesaid view was also taken by Hon'ble Madras High Court
in Selvakumar v. State, (2011) 2 Crimes (HC) 106, wherein it was
observed : “8. ………………….. It is also appropriate to consider the decision of this
courtmade in Crl. O.P. (MD) No. 11867 of 2009, wherein this Court has
held as follows:
“A perusal of the complaint would reveal that it has been merely stated
that ‘sample’ is misbranded as it is not labelled in accordance with
Rules 32(f)(i) and 42(zzz) 147 of P.F.A. Rules, 1955. It is not quite clear
as to how the sample is misbranded and the averments made in
the complaint are also bereft of any particulars. There must be
a specific averment that the customers are being mislead on
account of misbranding and in the absence of any such clear
averments, it cannot be said that the customers are mislead or
misdirected.”
9. A perusal of the public analyst's report would reveal the Public
Analyst has simply stated that the sample was misbranded
since it is not labelled in accordance with the requirements of
Rule 37 of P.F.A. Rules, 1955, but he has not mentioned as to
how and what manner the sample was misbranded. There must
be a specific averment that the customers being mislead on account of
misbranding and in the absence of any such clear averments, it cannot
be said that the customers are mislead or misdirected.”
8. Similar view was also taken by Hon'ble Gauhati High Court
in Glaxo India Ltd. v. State of Assam, (2003) 1 GLR 407, wherein it
was held as follows : “18. Much reliance has been placed on a decision reported in 1993
Criminal Law Journal 1106 (Madras High Court) (Corn Products
Company,
Bombay v. Food
Inspector,
Tirunelveli
Municipality,
Tirunelveli). In that case, the Madras High Court, in dealing with
similar matter pertaining to report of the Public Analyst in relation to
GLUCOVITA GLUCOSE-‘D’ wherein it was opined by the Public Analyst
that the said product was adulterated, was of the clear view that the
GLUCOVITA GLUCOSE-‘D’ was a “proprietary food” and it cannot at all
be stated that any of Sub-clause (a) to (c) and (h) of Clause (ia) of
Section 2 of the Act was getting attracted on the face of the very
averments adumbrated in the complaint in the sense of the product
GLUCOVTTA GLUCOSE-‘D’ a proprietory food, shall be deemed to be
adulterated falling under any one of these sub-clauses (para 29).
Relying on the ratio of the said case, Mr. Bhattacharyya has submitted
that it is clear and obvious that a proprietory food cannot be a subjectmater of standardization laid down in the Appendix B to the Act.
Therefore, simply because the ingredients of the proprietory food do not
tally with the said standards, it cannot be said as ‘misbranded’.
20. Basically both the criminal proceedings are founded on the reports
of the Public Analyst. But amazingly those reports did not
reveal how the ingredients of the sample of Glucon-‘C’ and
Glucon-‘D’, were misbranded. It is seen that even no endeavour was
made at all by the Public Analyst in the reports in question to display
as to under which of the clause of Section 2(ix) of the Act, the present
articles of food would fall to be called as ‘misbranded’. if the reports
themselves failed to indicate how the products were misbranded, then
where is the scope for prosecution to proceed with the present criminal
proceedings? Therefore, it can be unhesitatingly held that those
reports are nebulous and bereft of details and there is no
material on records to justify the launching of the instant
criminal proceedings against the petitioner on account of
misbranding the products in controversy. Moreso, in view of total
silence maintained in the reports as regards the comprehensive
material facts and particulars, the petitioner is appeared to have been
deprived of either any opportunity to defend its case or the right to
know under what provision of Law, it has been prosecuted.
Accordingly this court finds sufficient force in the submission of the
learned sr. counsel of the petitioner and is of the view that the ratio of
Food Specialities Ltd., M-54 Connaught Circle, New Delhi v. The State
of Assam in Criminal Revision No. 422/89 is squarely applicable in
this case.””
(emphasis supplied)
14.
After discussing the law on the subject the principle
summed up by this Court in para 11, which is as follows:“11. To sum up, the allegation against the applicant is that the words
‘dream of healthy India’ were scribed on the packets of NOVA Dairy
Mix skimmed milk powder manufactured by the applicants, but
neither in the complaint nor in the Public Analyst's report there
was allegation that the said label contained false or misleading
statement. Neither the Food Inspector nor the Public Analyst said
anywhere that the words, i.e., ‘dream of healthy India’ on the packets
of NOVA Dairy Mix skimmed milk powder carry false or misleading
statement.”
(emphasis supplied)
15.
In the case of Pepsico India Holdings Pvt. Ltd. (Supra),
the Hon’ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh observed that without
reason the opinion of public analyst is as good as no opinion. In
para 22, the Court observed as follows:“22.
The opinion of the Public Analyst in it report is subjective and
not based upon analysis of sample neither it is supported by any
such document nor any reference as mentioned above. The opinion of
the Public Analyst is optional and non-mandatory. The opinion of the
analyst cannot be termed as ‘evidence of facts’ and the same is not
admissible as evidence under the law. The expertise of analyst is only
confined to the field of analysis of food articles; it does not in any
manner extend to the fields of medical sciences or law. In the
present situation where an opinion given by the Public Analyst is
devoid of any reasoning and is also in no manner directly or
indirectly relatable to the result of analysis, the same is as good
as no opinion given and again it would be left to the Court to
determine whether the said label constitutes any violation of the
Act.”
(emphasis supplied)
16.
In the case of Glaxo India Ltd. (Supra), the public analyst
has merely given an opinion that the articles were misbranded. The
Hon’ble Court held that, “if the reports themselves failed to
indicate how the products were misbranded, then where is the
scope for prosecution to proceed with the present criminal
proceedings?” and, accordingly, it was concluded that without
there being any reason for giving an opinion about misbranding of
the food, the prosecution fails to establish even prima facie case.
17.
On the other hand, learned State Counsel submits that
writing of “Maha Value” on the label of “Lahar Aloo Bhujia” is
misbranding under the provisions of the FSS Act.
18.
First and foremost, it has to be seen as to what is the
report of public analyst? It is as follows:“FORM B
Report of the Food Analyst
[(Refer regulation (ii) of 2.3.1)]
Report No. 180/SDFTL/JUN/15-PWL
I certified that I Rajeev Sharma duly appointed under the provisions of Food
Safety and Standards Act, 2006 (34 of 2006), for Uttarakhand State received
from Food Safety Officer, Sri Nagar, District- Pauri Garhwal U.K.. Sample of
Lahar Aloo Bhujia Namkeen bearing Code number and Serial B.S./158/2014.
Dated- 08.06.2015 of Designated Officer of Pauri Garhwal area, on 15.06.2015
for analysis.
…..………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
Analysis Report:(I) Sample Description – The sample was received in manufacturer’s original
pack.
(II) Physical appearance- Almost yellow coloured namkeen, free from visible
fungal growth, insects and any other visible extraneous matter.
(III) Label- Original label does not comply with (Packaging & Labeling) of Food
Safety and Standards Act 2006. Rules & Regulation 2011, as Maha Value
is written in the corner of the packet.
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
Opinion:The sample of Lahar Aloo Bhujia Namkeen bearing Code number
and Serial Number B.S./158/2014, is in contravention vide section
3,(1)(zf)(A)(i)(a) of Food Safety and Standards Act-2006, Rules & Regulations 2011
(Packaging & Labelling), for the above tested parameters. Hence Misbranded.
……………………………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………………………….
………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
19.
A bare perusal of the above report reveals that it has no
reason or reasoning as to why the product is misbranded. Specific
provision has been quoted by the analyst as to why the product is
misbranded and reference has been made to Sections 3(1)(zf)(A)(i) of
the FSS Act. It reads as follows:“3. Definitions.—(1) In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,—
……………………………………………………………………………………….
……………………………………………………………………………………
(zf) “misbranded food” means an article of food—
(A) if it is purported, or is represented to be, or is being—
(i) offered or promoted for sale with false, misleading or deceptive
claims either—
(a) upon the label of the package, or
(b) through advertisement, or”
20.
Section 23 of the FSS Act also makes provisions with
regard to the packaging and labelling of foods. It provides that the
label shall not contain any statement, claim, etc. which is false or
misleading. This Section reads as follows:“23. Packaging and labelling of foods.—(1) No person shall
manufacture, distribute, sell or expose for sale or despatch or deliver
to any agent or broker for the purpose of sale, any packaged food
products which are not marked and labelled in the manner as may be
specified by regulations:
Provided that the labels shall not contain any statement, claim,
design or device which is false or misleading in any particular
concerning the food products contained in the package or concerning
the quantity or the nutritive value implying medicinal or therapeutic
claims or in relation to the place of origin of the said food products.
(2) Every food business operator shall ensure that the labelling and
presentation of food, including their shape, appearance or packaging,
the packaging materials used, the manner in which they are arranged
and the setting in which they are displayed, and the information
which is made available about them through whatever medium, does
not mislead consumers.”
21.
There is another provision in the Regulation 2011.
Regulation 2.3 speaks of manner of declaration and according to
2.3.1.5 the label should not contain false or misleading statement.
It reads as follows:“2.3.1: General Conditions—
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………
5. Labels not to contain false or misleading statements: A label shall
not contain any statement, claim, design, device, fancy name or
abbreviation which is false or misleading in any particular
concerning the food contained in the package, or concerning the
quantity or the nutritive value or in relation to the place of origin of
the said food:
Provided that this regulation shall not apply in respect of
established trade or fancy names of confectionery, biscuits and
sweets, such as, barley, sugar, bull's eye, cream cracker or in
respect of aerated waters, such as, Ginger Beer or Gold Spot or any
other name in existence in international trade practice.”
22.
A reading of judgment dated 31.05.2024 of the Tribunal
shows that, in fact, the burden was shifted on the appellant to
prove as to what is the sense of using “Maha Value” on the label. In
fact, it is the prosecution to establish, as to why the information is
misleading. There is a Form VIII A for the report of the food analyst.
It requires reasons for the report.
23.
In the instant case, the public analyst report simply
states that it is misbranded in view of Section 3(1)(zf)(A)(i) of the
FSS Act. But, which information is false or misleading? In its initial
response, the appellant has stated that the word “Maha Value” was
written as to the quantity in compliance of the Scheme of the Legal
Metrology
Act,
and
the
Legal
Metrology
(Packaged
Commodities) Rules, 2011 framed there under. But, this aspect has
not been adverted to by the Adjudicating Authority or by the
Tribunal. It is up to the prosecution to establish that there is
misleading information in the label, which in the instant case the
prosecution has, in fact, failed to establish. Therefore, this Court is
of the view that the prosecution has not proved that the appellant
had committed violation of any provisions of the FSS Act. Both the
impugned judgments are not in accordance with law and are liable
to be set aside. Accordingly, the appeal deserves to be allowed.
24.
The appeal is allowed.
25.
The judgment and order dated 31.05.2024, passed in the
appeal and the judgment and order dated 21.12.2018, passed in
the case are hereby set aside.
(Ravindra Maithani, J.)
18.06.2026
Sanjay
SANJAY
KANOJIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=e50e50b49596520698eff87e0a08bbd5046
86df4d1afc60f54a287831dec46fe,
postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=26EEB7122ED0DD23233A255DD8EC
450A84B515A087CAEFD1B3179A7DEAE40699,
cn=SANJAY KANOJIA
Date: 2026.06.18 18:26:30 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review