Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
13447 1
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY FIFTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRTJUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
WRIT PETITION Nos.38097 & 28552 OF 2025
WRIT P
TION NO : 38097 OF 2025
Between:
PEL PARBATI JV, A Partnership Firm having its office Plot No.13, HES
House, Shilpi Enclave, Gafoor Nagar, Madhapur, Hyderabad - 5OOOB1,
Telangana, lndia, Represented by its Authorised signatory Mr. IVR Krishnam
Raju
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Union of lndia, Ministry of Finance, Rep by Chief Commissioner of lncome
Tax, Having office at cF2F + J8F, LB stadium Rd, Band colony, Hill Fort
Road, Hyderabad, Telangana 500004
2. The lncome Tax officer, ward 8 (1) Aayakar Bhavan, LB Stadium Road,
Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an order or Direction in the nature of Mandamus declaring the action of the
Respondents in refusing to refund the excess lncome Tax of Rs. 5,26,12,0821for the
Assessment Year 2O2O-21to the Petitioner (PAN AAHAP34 27E), as intimated by the
DIN and Letter No ITBA/COM|F|17|2025- 26110766740018(1) dated 0510612025 as
illegal, arbitrary, capricious and consequently direct the Respondents to pay the
excess tax collected by them at Rs 5,26,12,082 /- or such other sum found collected
along with interest as per law.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in supporl of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
respondents to pay 50% of the excess tax collected from the petitioner (PAN
AAHAP3427E), for the Assessment year 2020-21, pending disposal of the writ
petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI K.VIJAYA BHASKAR REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO,
DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERIAL OF INDIA
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: Ms. J.SUNITHA, Sr. SC FOR !T
WP NO: 28552 OF 2025
Between:
Mantena Vasishta Micro JV, A Partnership Firm having its office At
2-56-331124, Mantena House, Khanamet, Madhapur, Hyderabad - 500081,
Represented by its Director/Authorised signatory Mr. M. Srinivas Raju S/o
Nagendra Raju.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Union of lndia, Ministry of Finance, Rep by Chief Commissioner of lncome
Tax, Having office al CF2F + J8F, LB Stadium Rd, Band Colony, Hill Fort
Road, Hyderabad, Telangana 500004.
2. The lncome Tax Officer, Ward I (1) Aayakar Bhavan, LB Stadium Road,
Hyderabad
..RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an order or Direction in the nature of Mandamus declaring that the Omission
of the Respondents in refunding the excess TDS collected from the Petitioner, in
(PAN AAJAM5618C), for the Assessment year 2020-21 as illegal, arbitrary,
capricious and consequently direct the Respondents to pay the excess tax collected
by them at Rs 8,25,01 ,1291- or such other sum along with interest as per law.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
respondents to pay 50% of the excess tax collected from the petitioner (PAN
AAJAM5618C), for the Assessment year 2020-21, pending disposal of the writ
petition.
Gounsel for the Petitioner: SRI V.SEETHARAMA AVADHAN!
Counsel for the Respondent No.l: SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO,
DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERIAL OF INDIA
counsel for the Respondent No.2: Ms. J.SUNITHA, Sr. SC FOR lT
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
WRIT PETITION Nos.38097 &28552 of2025
DATE:25.06.2026
Between:
PEL PARBATI JV.
...Petitioner
AND
Union of India, Ministry of Finance,
Rep. by Chief Commissioner of Income Tax,
Having office at CF2+J8F, LB Stadium Rd, Band Colony,
Hill Fort Road, Hyderabad,
Telangana - 500004 and Another.
...Respondents
COMMON ORDER: (per the Hon'ble $t Justice P.San Koslly)
Heard Mr. V.Seetharama Avadhani, and Mr. K.Vijaya Bhaskar
Reddy, leamed counsel for the petitioners; and Ms. J.Sunitha, leamed
Senior Standing Counsel for Income Tax Department.
Page 2 of l5
Since the issue involved
2.
in the instant Writ Petitions
parties also being
the same and the
anduedecided by
the same' they are heard together
this Common Order'
For convenience, the facts
3.
is one and
in Writ Petition No'38097 of 2025
are discussed hereunder'
4.
The instant Writ Petition
under Article 226 of the Constitution
by the petitioner
of India has been frled
challenging the action of
refusing to refund the excess
in
No'2
respondent
Rs.5,26,12,0821-
paid for the assessment year
income tax of
2020-21vide Letter No'
MJFI|7t2025-26t|0766740018(1)dated05'06.2025andto
and further direct them to
capricious
and
arbitrary
illegal'
declare it as
refund the amount
5.
of Rs'5'26'12'0824 with interest'
The facts of the case are that
the petitioner is an Association
by Patel Engineering
Persons (AOP) formed
private Limited for executing the
of
Limited and HES Infra
parbati pipe Network canal System
in Madhya Pradesh
Multipurpose Project
for the
to file its retum of income
and was statutorily required
assessment yezt 2020'21
was extended by the
before 15.02'2021, which
ot or
Central Board of
Page 3 of l5
Direct Taxes (for short 'CBDT') because of COVID-19. However, the
petitioner failed to frle its retum of income by the due date of
15.02.2021, due to a search being conducted at the premises of HES
Infra Private Limited (constituent partner) during the material time,
09.02.2021 to 12.02.2021, due to a prohibitory order which was
placed on the premises which remained till 10.04.2021. Due to the
search and prohibitory order, documents were seized and hence, the
petitioner could not file the retum. After lifting the prohibitory order
on 10.04.2021, the petitioner attempted to file the return, but the
return filing window had closed.
6.
'[he Department, acting on information flagged
under the RMS
(Risk Management Strategy) as Non-Filer pAN cases, identified that
the petitioner had substantial financial transactions despite non_filing
and in the absence of any return filed by the petitioner, such income
would constitute escaped assessment within the meaning of Section
147 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short the ,Act') after which in
response to the notice under Section 148 of the Act, the petitioner
filed its retum of income on 26.06.2024 declaring the following
figures:-
I
) Total sales
(as per business records) : Rs'2'50'02'27 '8631-
2) Business loss
: Rs'30'853/-
as refund of TDS : Rs'5'26'12'082/-
3) Amount claimed
Thereafter, the
petitioner also filed a rectification application
before respondent No.2
under Section 154 of the Act claiming a
refund of Rs.5,26,12,0821"
same, leading to filing
7.
Howevet' respondent No'2 refused the
of the instant Writ Petition'
Leurrcdcounsel for
have no statutory power
the petitioners submits that the respondents
to withhold or deny the excess tax paid by
the petitioner. Further, Section
be made immediately after
237 ofthe Act states that refund shall
the completion of assessment by the
Assessingofficerandalsoifthereisanyexcesstaxpaidbythe
assessee. Leamed counsel
for the petitioner further shred light on the
fact that the petitioner was
unable to retrieve the necessary documents
to file returns for t]1e assessment
year 2020-21, due to the search and
seizure operation being conducted
on its Joint venture Partner's
premiseswhichlastedfrom09.02.202|to|2.02.2021andthata
prohibitory order was placed on the premises of the said
partner's
premises preventing the petitioner from discharging his statutory
obligations.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner also submitted that the action
of respondent No.2 of withholding a huge amount of Pts.5,26,12,082/-
is causing great monetary crisis to the petitioner and preventing the
petitioner from incurring its regular expenditures for various project
works and withholding and refusing to refund the excess tax paid by
the petitioner without justification is unlawful, arbitrary and contrary
to ethical rules of the authorities.
9.
Lastly, the learned counsel for the petitioner contended that in
refusing the refund ofhuge sum ofadvanced tax paid by the petitioner
as TDS is illegal, unconstitutional and a grave violation of principles
ofnatural justice and violating the fundamental rights of the petitioner
from conducting its business by utilising its funds / monies and they
are left with no altemative remedy except to invoke the extraordinary
writ jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
10. Au Contraire, the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the
Income Tax Department vehemently opposed the Writ Petition on the
following grounds:-
a) The petitioner had ample amount of time and opportunity to
appeal under Section 246A of the Act before the Commissioner
of Income Tax (Appeals) and further appeal before the Income
Tax Appellate Tribunal under Section 253 of the Act, for their
grievance of refund. Thus, when petitioner failed in exercising
his right to statutory remedies under the Income Tax Act, the
same cannot be cured by way of invoking this writ jurisdiction
before this Hon'ble Court.
b) The legislative purpose behind Section 147 of the Act is to
garnish the escaped income from an assessee, which is
predominantly for the benefit of the Revenue Department and
is not of regular assessment in nature. Further, refund under
Section 239 of the Act pre-mandates that every claim of refund
should be made only by furnishing retums in accordance with
the provisions of Section 139 of the Act.
c) The search and prohibitory orders issued against the JV partner
only pertained to restriction on physical removal of files /
documents from the area of search and that the petitioner made
no attempt to the Department through any official means to
retrieve the said files for perusal and discharge of their
obligations.
ll.
At the outset, since the petitioner has approached this Court
without exhausting the remedies available to him under the Income
Tax Act, we would first decide the maintainabiliry / entertainability of
the Writ Petition and thereafter, if necessary, venture into the merits
of the case.
12. The impugned order under challenge in this Writ petition was
passed by the Assessing Officer under Section 147 read with Section
144B ofthe Act and it ought to have been appealed under 2464 ofthe
Act belbre the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) by the
petitioner for remedy, which was not done within the stipulated time
frame provided under the Act.
13. Prima facie the petitioner has not approached the statutory
appellate authority under the Income Tax Act for the remedies which
are readily available to him. Had he availed the statutory remedies
under the due procedure of taxation appellate hierarchy, he could have
been granted the appropriate relief which he is presently praying
before this Court.
14. With regard to maintainability I entertainability of a Writ
Petition when an altemative efficacious remedy already exists, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of CCT v. Glaxo Smith Kline
Consumer Health Care Ltd.l had held as under:
"74.1n the backdrop of these facts, the central question is:
Whether the High Court ought to have entertained the writ petition
/iled by the respondent? As regards the power of the High Court to
issue directions, orders or writs in exercise of its jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the same is no more res
integra. Even thoueh the High Court can entertain a writ oetition
asainst anv order or direction oassed/action taken bv the State
under Article 226 of the Constitution. it ousht not to do so as a
matter of course when the agsrieved oerson could have availed of
an effective alternative remedv in the manner orescribed bv law
(see Baburam Prakash Chandra Maheshwari v. Antorim Zila
Parishad [Baburam Prakash Chandra Maheshwari v. Antarim Zila
Parishad, AIR 1969 ,SC 5561 and also Nivedita
' (zozo) 19 scc 581 : (2020) 77 GsrR 342:2020 scc onLine sc 440
Page 9 of l5
,gharma v. COAI [Nivedita Shorma v. COAI, (201]) 14 SCC 337 :
O012) 4 SCC' (t.:ir,) 9471). ln Thansingh Nathmal v. Supt of
Taxes [Thansingh ,Yathmal v. Supt. oJ Taxes, AIR 1964 SC 1419],
the Constitution Rench of this Court made
clear that
althoush the no wor of the Hish Court under A icle 226 of the
restraint and
enle ain the writ oetition.
$a
to
an alternative
In para 7,
the Llourt observed thus: Q'hansingh Nathmal case tThansingh
Nathmal v. Supt. of T(aes, AIR 1964 SC lal9l , AlRp. laB)
"7. Againsl the order oJ the Commissioner an order for
reference coultl have been claimed iJ the appellants
satisJied the C'ommissioner or the High Court that a
question of law arose out oJ'the order. But the procedure
provided by the Act to invoke the jurisdiction of the High
Court was bypussed, the appellants moved the High Court
challenging lhe competence oJ the Provincial l,egislature to
extend the concept of sale, and invoked the extraordinary
jurisdiction ol rhe High Court under Article 226 and .sought
to reopen the decision of the taxing authorities on question
offacr. The jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226
of tha Constitttlion is couched in wide terms and the
exercise thereoJ'is not subject to any restrictions except the
territofial restriclions which are expressly provided in the
Articlcs. But the exercise of the jurisdiction is discretionary:
it is not exercised merely because it is lawful to do so. The
very amplitude ol lhe .jurisdiction demands lhdt it will
ordinurily be exercised subjecl to certain seU-imposed
limitations. Resort to that jurisdiction is not inlended as an
alternalive remedl, .[or relieJ which may he obtained in a
suil or olher motle prescribed by statule. Ordinarilv the
Page l0 ofl5
Court will not entertain a petition for a writ under Article
without beine undulv oneroas, orovides on eouallv
efficacious remedv. Again the High Court does not
generally enter upon a determination of questions which
demand an elaborate examination of evidence to establish
the right to enforce which the writ is claimed. The High
Court does not therefore act as a court of appeal agatnst
the decision of a court or tribunal, to correct errors of .fact,
and does not by assuming jurisdiction under Article 226
trench upon an alternative remedy provided by statute for
obtaining relief, Where it is open to the aggrieved petitioner
to move another tribunal, or even itself in another
.iurisdictionfor obtaining redress in the manner provided by
a statute, the High Court normally will not permit by
entertaining a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
the machinery created under the statute to be bypassed, and
will leave the party applying to it to seek resort to the
machinery so set up."
15. We may usefully refer
to the exposition of this Court
in Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Orissa [Titaghur Paper
Mitls Co. Ltd. v. State of Orissa, (1983) 2 SCC 433 : 1983 SCC
(fax) 131J , wherein it is observed that where a rieht or liabilitv is
the remedv provided bv that statute must onlv be availed of. In
para I 1, the Court observed thus : (SCC pp. 440-41)
"l
L (Jnder the scheme of the Act, there is a hierarchy of
authorities before which the petitioners can get adequate
redress against the wrongful acts complatned of The
petitioners have the right to prefer an appeal before the
Page 11 of15
Prescribed Authority under sub-section (l) of Section 23 of
the Act. If the pefitioners are clissatisfied with the decision
in the appeal, they can prefer a further appeal to the
Tribunal under sub-section (3) of Section 23 of the Act, and
then ask _fbr o co.te to be stated upon a question of law
for
the opinion o/ the High Court under Section 24 of the
Act. The Act provides for a complete machinery to
prescrtOea Ov *e
l
,
that statute onlv must be availed of. This rule was stated
with great clarity by LYilles, J. in Wolverhampton New
Ll/aterworks Co. v. Hawkesford [Wolverhampton New
li/arerworks Co. v. Hawkesford, (1559) 6 CBNS 336, 356 :
141 ER 486J in the.following passoge:
'There are three classes of cases in which a liability
may be established founded upon stotute. ... But there
is a third clas,s viz. where a liability not existing at
common law is created by a stotute which at the same
time gives o special and particular remedy for
enforcing it.... The remedy provided by the statute must
be followed, and it is not competent to the party to
pursue the course opplicable to coses of the second
class. The form given by the statute must be adopted
qnd adhered to.'
The rule laid down in this passage wos opproved by
the
Ilouse o.f Lords in Neville v. London Express Newspaper
Lrd. [Nevillev. London Express Newspaper Ltd.,
rglg AC 36s
(HL)l and has been reaffrmed
by the Privy Council in Attorney
Tobago v' Gordon Grant & Co'
&
General of Trinidad
&
of Trinidad' & Tobago v' Gordon Grant
of Statev'Mask &
532 (PC)l andSecy'
Co. Ltd., 1%5 AC
& Co'' 1940 SCC Online PC ]0 : AIR
Ltd. [Attorney Generat
Co. [Secy. of Statev'
Mask
]g40PCl05Jlthasalsobeenheldtobeequallyapplicableto
and has been followed by this Court
rights'
of
enforcement
was therefore justified in dismissing
Court
throughout. The High
the writ petitions in linine'
(emphasis supplied)
in Mafatlat Industries Ltd' v' Union of
(1997) 5 SCC
Ltd. v. Union of India,
India [Mafatlal Industries
an Act cannot bar and
on tu observe that
536J, this Court went
226 or 32 of the Constitution' The
curtail remedY under Article
that the
a word of caution and expounded
Court, however, added
note of the legislative
would certainly take
Court
Constitutional
of the Act and would exercise its
the
Provisions
in
intent manifested
enactment' To put
with the provisions of the
j uri s di ct io n c o ns is tu rtt
In the subsequent decision
statuta."
15. Further, in the case ofCIT
held that where an efftcacious
hierarchy is provided under
and prescribed form of appellate
a statute' writ Courts should avoid
entertaining cases by invoking
'eot+l l scc 603
vs' Chhabil Dass Agarwal2 it was
their writ jurisdictions' The relevant
Page l3 of I 5
paragraphs of the said judgment
for ready reference are reproduced
hereunder:
" 16.
n
A
e
191!!9[ ]n R am and Shyam Co. v. State oJ
267J this Court hcrs noticed that
C.laesar,s v,ife
Haryana [(19g5) 3 SCC
if an appeal is fi.om ,,(,aesar to
" the existence of alternative remedy
mirage anct an exercise infulitity.
17. In the instont cu,re, neither
has lhe writ petitioner assessee
described the avuilable alterndte
ineffectual ttnd non_fficacious while
oJ the High Court nor has the
would be a
remedy under the Act as
invoking the writ jurisdiction
High Court ascribed cogent and
salisfoclory rea.tons to have exercised
ils jurisdiction in the./itcts of
the instant cctst,. In light of the some,
we are of the considered
opinion that rhe wril court ought
not t. have enterrained lhe writ
perition filed by the assessee, wherein
he has only questioned the
correctness or otherwise of the
notices issued untler Section l4g
of
the Act, the reus;ressment ot
passed and the consequential
demancr notites i.\sued thereo::rs
16.
Hence, when the Income Tax Act
machinery for refund and other
provides for a complete
remedies in respect ofany
impugned
orders passed by the Revenue authorities, the petitioner / assessee
cannot be allowed to gun-jump all the appellate authorities under the
Income Tax Act and invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this
Court, while having adequate opportunities and time period for
appeals against the orders passed against itself. The petitioner in this
instant case has not availed or even attempted to avail any alternative
or prescribed procedures ofremedy against the impugned orders and
directly banged the doors of this Court with an attempt to undermine
the appellate authorities without any cogent or satisfactory reasons to
convince this Court to exercise writ jurisdiction.
17. The Hon'ble Supreme Court also in the judgments referred to
above has categorically held that an assessee cannot directly invoke
the writ jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution without first exhausting the statutory remedies available
under the Act. It was further held that unless a substantial question of
law is made out from the impugned orders passed by the Revenue, the
Writ Petition is not maintainable.
18. For the foregoing reasons and judgments cited, we are not
inclined to entertain the Writ Petition No.38097 of 2025, and it is
Page 15 of I 5
accordingly dismissed. Since we are declining to entertain the instant
writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the right
of the petitioner to avail other statutory remedies available is left
open. As a consequence, Writ petition No.2g225 of 2025 also stands
dismissed on similar lines.
19. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand
closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
SD'- P, PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY"
e
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SRI K.VIJAYA BHASKAR REDDY' Advocate [OPUC]
2. One CC to SRI V.SEETHARAMA AVADHANI' Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to Ms. J.SUNITHA' Sr' SC FOR lT [OPUC]
4. One CC to SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUry SOLICITOR GENERIAL OF
rrrrOrn, iigh Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad [OPUC]
5. Two CD CoPies
BsR l&-.
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2510612026
1$ e
S
rAre
Y
f
c
o
COMMON ORDER
.k
Ci:Si:AiC
DISMISSING BOTH THE WRIT PETITION'S,
Ct \1
\
ry
o
.b
t
WP.Nos.38097 & 28552 OF 2025
WITHOUT GOSTS
z
o6 Jutzm
iI
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review