Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 13.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 20.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 20.02.2026
+
W.P.(C) 64/2017
PAWAN KUMAR
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Rakesh Kumar Singh, Mr.
Ashok Anand, Mr. Deepak
Kumar Singh and Mr. Bipin
Bihari Singh, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Rohan Jaitley, CGSC with
Mr. Varun Pratap Singh, Mr.
Dev Pratap Shahi and Mr.
Yogya Bhatia, Advs. for UOI.
SI Prashant Malik for the State.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
The Petitioner has filed the present Writ Petition assailing the
order dated 31.05.2016 [hereinafter referred to as ‘Impugned Order’]
passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New
Delhi [hereinafter referred to as ‘Tribunal’] in O.A. No. 225/2013,
whereby his Original Application came to be dismissed.
2.
In order to appreciate the issues which arise for consideration in
the present case, the relevant facts may briefly be noticed.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
W.P.(C) 64/2017
13:10:35
3.
Pursuant to the Recruitment Notice of the Union Public Service
Commission Civil Services Examination, 2009, the Petitioner
participated in the selection process and, upon being declared
successful, was placed at Rank 860 in the general merit list and at
Rank 5 in the sub-category of Visually Impaired candidates. On the
basis of the said selection, he was allocated to and appointed in the
Armed Forces Headquarters Service.
4.
The Petitioner’s case is that subsequent to his appointment, the
decision of the Supreme Court in Government of India v. Ravi
Prakash Gupta1 clarified that reservation for persons with disabilities
is not dependent upon prior identification of posts and that backlog
vacancies are required to be computed from the date of enforcement
of the Disabilities Act, 1995. Placing reliance thereon, the Petitioner
claimed consideration against vacancies in the disabled category in the
Civil Services.
5.
The Petitioner initially instituted O.A. No. 4026/2010 seeking
allocation to a service higher in his preference. The said Original
Application was disposed of by the Tribunal vide order dated
15.02.2011 with a direction to the Respondents to consider his
candidature for the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) and other
services in accordance with his preferences. Pursuant thereto, the
Petitioner was re-allocated to the Indian Postal Service on 09.01.2012,
which he joined. After a lapse of nearly one year, the Petitioner
instituted a second Original Application, being O.A. No. 225/2013,
2010 (7) SCC 626
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
W.P.(C) 64/2017
13:10:35
seeking directions to the Respondents for his appointment against 1%
vacancies earmarked for visually impaired candidates in the alleged
backlog vacancies. The said Original Application came to be
dismissed by the Tribunal vide Order dated 31.05.2016. Relevant
findings in Paragraphs 13 and 14 are extracted as under:
“13. The backlog vacancies are required to be carried forward only
for two years. Normally the selections are to be confined to the
vacancies notified. All the Government Departments and Ministries
are legally bound to implement the provisions of the Disabilities Act,
1995, including the provisions of Section 33 of the Act which provides
for reserving the posts for the PH candidates. The Act also provides
mechanism for enforcement of the rights of PH persons. It stipulates
appointment of Chief Commissioner and Commissioners, empowers
them amply to enforce the rights of such persons (Sections 57-63 of
the Act). The proceedings before these Commissioners are to be
judicial proceedings. Hence, it can be safely assumed that no
Ministry/Department can dare violate the provisions of the Act.
14. The respondents have clearly stated-in their replies that no
backlog vacancies are available in IAS or IFS for accommodating the
applicant, which gets further fortified from the fact that the backlog
vacancies cannot be carried forward for more than two years. Taking
all these factors into consideration and also bearing in mind the ratio
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ravi Prakash Gupta
(supra), we are of the clear view that the prayers of the applicant in
this OA cannot be considered and that too at this belated stage.”
6.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner has filed the present Writ
Petition, which remained pending for a considerable period. As per the
affidavit of the Petitioner, as sworn in November 2016, the Petitioner
was about 37 years of age at that time and is presently more than 46
years old.
7.
On 10.01.2017, this Court, while issuing notice, recorded that
another candidate belonging to the disabled category, namely Ashish
Singh Thakur, who had initially been allocated the Indian Postal
Service and was subsequently offered the Indian Foreign Service, had
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
W.P.(C) 64/2017
13:10:35
not joined the said service and was pursuing his claim for the Indian
Administrative Service before the Tribunal. In that context, the Court
observed that the Petitioner, having accepted and joined the Indian
Postal Service without demur, could not claim appointment to the
Indian Foreign Service against the vacancy earlier held by the said
candidate. The Court, however, took note of the Petitioner’s
contention that one Yashwant G.V., who had been offered the Indian
Foreign Service under the disabled candidate category, was later
found not to be entitled to the benefit of the Disabilities Act and that
the Tribunal had not examined the Petitioner’s claim for allocation
against the vacancy arising therefrom. Notice was accordingly issued,
though interim relief was declined.
8.
In response, the Union of India filed written statement
explaining the adjustment of vacancies occupied by Sh. Yashwant
G.V. in paras 2 to 6, which are extracted as under:
“2. That the medical examination of Shri Yeshwanth G.V. was
conducted by Central Standing Medical Board (CSMB) at Safdarjung
Hospital and he had been declared as having 30% visual disability.
The medical examination by Appellate Medical Board was conducted
at RML Hospital, New Delhi and the findings of the Appellate Medical
Board were the same i.e. 30% visual disability and thus he was not
found to be a valid visually impaired candidate. Since Shri Yeshwanth
was found to be a non-PwD candidate as per findings of CSMB and
AMB, the matter was referred to UPSC for comments/inputs
regarding availing of relaxation for scribe, extra time and extra
attempts which are available to PwD candidates only. Meanwhile, one
General non-PwD vacancy was kept blocked in Indian Foreign
Services (IFS) as per his rank and availability of non-PwD vacancies
in UR category.
3. That later on, UPSC, vide letter dated 23.03.2010, informed this
Department that Shri Yeshwanth had availed extra time available for
VI category candidates. Therefore, he could not be treated as a NonPwD candidate and his candidature for allocation to a service on the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
W.P.(C) 64/2017
13:10:35
basis of CSE-2009 [both against PwD and non-PwD vacancy] was
cancelled.
4. That eventually, Shri Yeshwanth G.V. was allocated to IAS in
compliance with Hon’ble CAT, Bangalore Bench’s order dated
12.12.2013in TA No. 470/2013 and further upheld byHon’b1e High
Court of Karnataka vide its order dated 17.12.2014 in WP No.
44696/2014 and Hon’b1e Supreme Court of India vide its order dated
13.09.2018 in SLP No. 1018/2015, by creating a supernumerary post
under VI sub- category of PwD category for CSE- 2009.
5. That the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA), the Cadre Controlling
Authority for IFS, had indented 30 vacancies (15- UR, 10-OBC, 4-SC,
I-ST, including I-HI) for CSE-2009. No vacancy was earmarked for VI
sub-category candidate for CSE-2009 in IFS. Against these vacancies,
29 candidates (14- UR, 10-OBC, 4-SC, l-ST, including 1-HI) were
allocated to IFS on the basis of CSE-2009 and one General non-PwD
vacancy in IFS, which was blocked for Shri Yeshwanth G.V., could not
be allocated to any candidate on the basis of CSE- 2009.
6. That MEA, vide its email dated 20.04.2023, has informed that 25
candidates joined out of 29 allocated candidates on the basis of CSE2009 and 5 vacancies (4-UR + I-ST) could not be filled up through
CSE-2009. Subsequently, backlog 5 vacancies (4-UR+1-ST) from
CSE-2009 were added in CSE- 2011 and allocated to eligible
candidates of CSE-2011. Accordingly, one General Non-PwD
vacancy, which was kept blocked for Sh. Yeshwanth G.V., was also
filled up.”
8.1
It was stated that Yashwant G.V. was found to have 30% visual
disability by both the Central Standing Medical Board and the
Appellate Medical Board and was therefore not eligible to be treated
as a visually impaired candidate. Since he had availed concessions
admissible exclusively to such candidates, the matter having referred
to the UPSC, the UPSC opined that he could not be treated as a nonPwD candidate either, resulting in cancellation of his candidature for
allocation on the basis of CSE-2009.
8.2
It was also stated that he was subsequently allocated to the
Indian Administrative Service against a supernumerary post created
pursuant to orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Bangalore
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
W.P.(C) 64/2017
13:10:35
Bench, as affirmed by the High Court of Karnataka and the Supreme
Court. The Ministry of External Affairs had not earmarked any
vacancy for the visually impaired sub-category in the Indian Foreign
Service for CSE-2009. One general vacancy, which had remained
blocked on account of the said candidate, was carried forward and
stood filled in CSE-2011. The Respondents thus assert that no
vacancy in the Indian Foreign Service referable to CSE-2009 is
available for allocation to the Petitioner.
9.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and with
their able assistance, perused the material on record.
10.
Learned counsel representing the Petitioner submits that the
vacancy in the Indian Foreign Service, which had initially been kept
blocked on account of Yashwant G.V., ought to have been allocated to
him once the said candidate was found ineligible to be treated as a
visually impaired candidate and was subsequently accommodated in
the Indian Administrative Service against a supernumerary post. It is
contended that denial of such consideration is arbitrary and contrary to
the benefit of reservation available to candidates in the PH category.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondents submits that no
vacancy in the Indian Foreign Service referable to CSE-2009 is
presently available. It is pointed out that the vacancy which had
become available on account of Yashwant G.V. was carried forward
and stood filled in UPSC Civil Service Examination – 2011 as stated
in paragraph 06 of the written statement dated 02.04.2024, and
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
W.P.(C) 64/2017
13:10:35
therefore, no direction for allocation to the Petitioner can now be
issued.
12.
Having considered the rival submissions and the material
placed on record, this Court finds that the foundational premise of the
Petitioner’s claim, namely the availability of a vacancy in the visually
impaired sub-category in the Indian Foreign Service for Civil Services
Examination, 2009, is not borne out. The record indicates that no
vacancy was earmarked for the visually impaired sub-category in PH
Vacancies in the Indian Foreign Service for the said examination year.
13.
The vacancy which had remained blocked on account of
Yashwant G.V. was not a reserved vacancy for the visually impaired
sub-category and, in any event, stood carried forward and already
filled in the subsequent cycle of Civil Services Examination, 2011. In
the absence of a demonstrable reserved vacancy in the concerned
service and recruitment year, no enforceable right to allocation can
arise, and the concept of carry-forward of backlog cannot be invoked
in the abstract so as to claim allotment dehors the notified vacancy
position. This factual position has not been demonstrated to be
incorrect.
14.
It is also to be noted that the Petitioner accepted his allocation
to the Indian Postal Service (IPoS) and joined the said service without
demur. The challenge to non-allocation to a service higher in
preference was raised only thereafter.
15.
The Petitioner has remained a member of the IPoS for over
fourteen years. The present Writ Petition itself has remained pending
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
W.P.(C) 64/2017
13:10:35
for a considerable period, and the Petitioner is now over forty-six
years of age. At this stage, any direction for reallocation to another
service would unsettle a long-standing position and inevitably
impinge upon the rights of other candidates who are serving in their
respective allotted services, and have not been impleaded as a party in
this Writ Petition.
16.
The exercise of extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution is governed by principles of equity. The Petitioner’s
long-standing acquiescence in his current service, coupled with the
absence of a demonstrable reserved vacancy in the IFS for the
recruitment year CSE-2009, precludes the grant of any discretionary
relief. We find no jurisdictional error or patent illegality in the
Impugned Order passed by the Tribunal
17.
In view of the foregoing discussion, no ground is made out for
interference with the Impugned Order. The Writ Petition is,
accordingly, dismissed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
FEBRUARY 20, 2026
sp/ad
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
W.P.(C) 64/2017
13:10:35
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review