Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA No. 18 of 2023
Date of Decision: 20.07.2023
Shri. Pawan Bhama
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Anr.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. K.T.S. Tulsi, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. R. Singh, Adv.
Mr. K. Lyngdoh, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA
Ms. R. Colney, GA
ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The case diary in connection with Shallang P.S. Case No. 39(12)
2022 as called for has been produced before this Court today and the same is
accordingly perused.
2.
This is an application under Section 439 Cr.P.C for enlarging the
accused person, namely, Shri. Youdhistra Bhama preferred by the petitioner
herein who is the uncle of the said accused person.
3.
The events leading to the arrest of Shri. Youdhistra Bhama started
with the initiation of an FIR lodged by Shri. H. Kerwood Thabah, MCS ADC
cum SDO (Civil), Mawshynrut Civil Sub-Division, West Khasi Hills District
on 17.12.2022 before the Officer In-Charge, Shallang Police Station, West
Khasi Hills District.
4.
In the said FIR the informant has stated that on the strength of an
order issued by the Deputy Commissioner, West Khasi Hills District dated
16.12.2022 to shut down all illegal coke factories operating in West Khasi
Hills District which order is in compliance with this Court‟s order dated
16.12.2022 in PIL No. 14 of 2022, about 57 numbers of illegal coke plants
were shut down though the names and identity of the owners of such coke
plants was still unknown at that point of time.
5.
Accordingly, on receipt of the said FIR the police registered Shallang
P.S. Case No. 39(12) 2022 under Section 188/34 IPC read with Section
3(1)/21(1) MMDR Act read with Section 15 Environment (Protection) Act,
Section 3 of the Explosive Substances Act and Section 53(1) of the Benami
Transaction (Prohibition) Act, 2016 and investigation was launched.
6.
In course of investigation, the complainant was examined and huge
quantity of coal found at the site which is approximately 9000 MT and coke
of about 800 MT was seized from different locations of the said illegal coke
factories. The Investigating Officer (I/O) has also caused issuance of notices
under Section 41-A of the Code of Criminal Procedure, initially to about 31
persons who, in response to the said notice, appeared at Shallang Police
Station and their respective statements was recorded under Section 161
Cr.P.C. On 29.05.2023 the I/O has again issued another batch of notices under
Section 41-A Cr.P.C to another 47 suspected persons requiring their
attendance at Shallang Police Station on 13.06.2023. Shri. Youdhistra Bhama
was also one of those who were summoned and accordingly he appeared at
the Police Station on the said date with his statement was also recorded under
Section 161 Cr.P.C.
7.
The I/O has again summoned Shri. Youdhistra Bhama to appear
before him on 15.06.2023 and not being satisfied that he has fulfilled the
conditions of notice under Section 41-A Cr.P.C, the I/O after explaining to
him the reasons, has accordingly arrested him mainly on the ground that he be
prevented to commit further offence and also that he is a habitual offender
and more importantly to prevent the accused from causing the disappearance
of evidence and also to safeguard the life and property of an important
witness who has cited incriminating evidence against the accused.
8.
Heard Mr. K.T.S. Tulsi, learned Sr. counsel for the petitioner who
has submitted that, when it appears from the records that the accused person
Shri. Youdhistra Bhama was cooperating with the I/O on being summoned in
response to the notice under Section 41-A, therefore there is no reason why he
has to be arrested. Secondly, all the sections of law which comprises the
offences said to have been committed by the accused person are bailable in
nature and as such, the accused person ought not to have been arrested in the
case. Thirdly, since the accused person found that some key managerial
personnel of Kalyani Fuel Ltd. were illegally running the coke plant at
Shallang, he had also filed a cross FIR in this regard and as such, when there
are cross FIRs, the accused person ought not to have been arrested in the case.
Finally, it is submitted that when the offences are compoundable by the
statutes, bail ought to have been granted.
9.
In support of his contention, the learned Sr. counsel has referred to
the following cases:
i.
Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar & Anr.: (2014) 8 SCC 273
paras 11.2, 11.3, 11.4, 11.5, 11.6, 11.7,11.8 and 12;
ii.
Satender Kumar Antil v. Central Bureau of Investigation &
Anr.: 2022 SCC Online SC 825, paras 23, 24 and 25;
iii.
Santosh v. State of Maharashtra: (2017) 9 SCC 714, para 6;
iv.
Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of Investigation: (2012) 1
SCC 40, paras 39, 40 and 46;
v.
P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement: 2019 SCC
Online SC 1549, paras 23;
vi.
Sunil Bharti Mittal v. Central Bureau of Investigation: (2015)
4 SCC 609, paras 42, 43 and 44;
vii.
Nathi Lal & Ors. v. State of U.P. & Anr.: 1990 (Supp) SCC
145, para 2;
viii.
D.K. Shivakumar v. Directorate of Enforcement: 2019 SCC
OnLine Del 10691, paras 34, 35, 36 and 38.
10.
Per contra, Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG appearing for State
respondents has submitted that the accused person is a Director of Kalyani
Fuel Ltd. which is a coke plant operating in the West Khasi Hills District, the
same being operated illegally inasmuch as no necessary permission from the
competent authority was ever issued as far as Consent to Establish (CTE) and
Consent to Operate (CTO) are concerned. Therefore, on the strength of this
Court‟s order dated 16.12.2022 in PIL No. 14 of 2022, the authorities have
taken necessary steps leading to the accused person Shri. Youdhistra Bhama
to be finally arrested.
11.
The learned AAG has further submitted that all the necessary
formalities in compliance with relevant statutes and authorities of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court have been complied with in the process of arrest of the said
accused person. Initially, a notice under Section 41-A Cr.P.C was issued to
him and he was summoned to the police station where his statement was
recorded. On the basis of his statement and the relevant evidence collected in
course of investigation the I/O has recommended Shri. Youdhistra Bhama be
arrested. The reasons for such a course of action have been spelled out by the
I/O which reasons, inter alia, includes the need to prevent the accused person
from committing further offence and also from causing disappearance of
evidence as well as the apprehension that he may tamper with the witnesses.
12.
The learned AAG has further submitted that in compliance with the
guidelines as was given in the case of D.K. Basu v. State of W.B.: (1997) 1
SCC 416, para 29 (sic 35) was duly complied with when the mother of the
arrested person was informed of this fact.
13.
In reply, the petitioner has submitted that the reasons cited by the I/O
for which the arrest of the accused person is necessitated would not be
relevant as on date since about 35 days or so has passed when the accused
person was arrested. Leading this Court to the relevant portion at page 40 of
this application, the learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that one
of the reasons why the accused person was arrested is the fear of evidence
disappearing. However, by now the I/O would have collected relevant
evidence and there is no apprehension of tampering of such evidence.
14.
As to the allegation that the accused person is a habitual offender,
reference being made to Shallang P.S. Case No. 36 (12) 2022 under Section
506 IPC and Shallang P.S. Case No. 37 (12) 2022 under Section
324/506/307/34 IPC, it is submitted that the accused person in question has
been granted bail in such cases and that there is no apprehension of his
absconding or interference with the investigation as far as this case is
concerned.
15.
On point No. 3 at page 40 of this petition, the learned counsel has
submitted that one of the grounds for the arrest of the accused person is that
he has given a statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C indicating the involvement
of a number of coal suppliers from Assam and their truck drivers, which,
according to the I/O, if found to be true, is required to be investigated. This
would mean that if there is a contrary finding, then the accused person would
have been unnecessary and illegally arrested.
16.
This Court has given due consideration to the case of the respective
parties, facts as indicated above need not be reiterated. Suffice it to say that
what is required to be examined is whether the accused person Shri.
Youdhistra Bhama has been arrested without any basis or that his arrest is in
violation of relevant statutes or that his arrest is justified under the facts and
circumstances.
17.
At this juncture, it would be but proper to cite relevant authorities
dealing with the issue of bail. Needless to say, it is well settled that in bail
jurisprudence, the principle of „bail and not jail‟ is still prevalent in the
criminal justice system in our country. However, as far as the grant or nongrant of bail is concerned, it all depends on the particular facts and
circumstances of a case before the court.
18.
As indicated, there are guidelines and parameters governing the issue
of bail set out by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in a catena of cases, some of
which can be enumerated herein below as:
(i) While granting bail the Court has to keep in mind not only the
nature of the accusations, but the severity of the punishment, if the
accusation entails a conviction and the nature of evidence in support
of the accusations.
(ii) While it is not expected to have the entire evidence establishing
the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt but there ought
always to be a prima facie satisfaction of the Court in support of the
charge.
(iii) the larger interest of the public or the State and other similar
factors which may be relevant in the facts and circumstances of the
case has also to be considered.
(iv) whether the accused person is likely to abscond or to tamper
with the evidence and witnesses, particularly if such witnesses are
likely to be threatened.
19.
Coming to the authorities referred to by the petitioner, in the case of
Arnesh Kumar(supra) what is seen is that the Hon‟ble Supreme Court has
dealt with the provision of Section 41 and 41-A of the Cr.P.C and has
reiterated the law laid down therein. Failure to comply with such provisions
would invite the necessary implications for both the police officer and the
Judicial Magistrate concerned. It is however noticed that the mandate of this
judgment is confined only to cases where the punishment is for a period of
less than seven years or upto seven years imprisonment if convicted. At the
relevant period when the I/O has just commenced the investigation, he has
caused issuance of Notice under Section 41-A. In due course, it transpired that
one of the offences is Section 3 of the Explosive Substances Act, 1908 which
is a penalty provision for an offence of unlawful and malicious use of
explosive substance likely to endanger life or cause serious injury to property
and person carrying a sentence of imprisonment for life or rigorous
imprisonment which shall not be less than ten years. Obviously, this is a nonbailable offence and as such, the assertion of the learned counsel for the
petitioner that all the offences wherein the accused person in question is
involved are bailable offences is not correct.
20.
The case of Satender Kumar Antil(supra) inter alia, at para 22, 23
and 24 also speaks of or rather dealt with the aspect of Section 41 Cr.P.C
wherein it was held that “…There is no requirement of the aforesaid
procedure when the offence alleged is more than seven years, among other
reasons”.
21.
The proposition in the case of Santosh(supra) at para 6 of the same
that the purpose of custodial interrogation is not just for the purpose of
confession is indeed valid, however relating to the case of the accused person
herein, it cannot be said that he was arrested only on the basis of his so-called
confession.
22.
The case of Sanjay Chandra(supra) and the case of P.
Chidambaram(supra) and also in the case of D.K. Shivakumar(supra), at the
relevant paragraphs referred to by the petitioner speaks of the application of
the principle of bail as has been referred to above.
23.
As to the reliance in the case of Sunil Bharti Mittal at the paragraphs
referred to by the petitioner that is, 42, 43 and 44 what could be understood is
that an individual who has perpetrated the commission of an offence on behalf
of a company can be made accused, along with the company if there is
sufficient evidence of his active role coupled with a criminal intent. At this
point of time, only prima facie evidence is required to allow the I/O to take
necessary steps, even to the point of arrest of the alleged offender and as such,
it would be a matter of evidence at the trial to prove this aspect of the matter.
24.
The case of State of M.P. v. Mishrilal and also the case of Nathi Lal
v. State of U.P.(supra) was cited by the petitioner to prove a point that cross
cases should be tried together. It is too early in the day to come to any
conclusion that there are cross cases related to the same subject matter
involving the accused person herein. It would however depend on the
investigation by the I/O to come to any findings or conclusion on this aspect
but to say that such assertion is a ground for grant of bail cannot be fathom by
this Court.
25.
This Court has taken note of the matter in its entirety having
considered the gravity and nature of the situation and is of the view that the
custody of the accused person in question is justified for which the I/O should
be given ample opportunity to complete his investigation, albeit within the
mandatory period as prescribed by law since enlarging of the accused person
at this point of time may cause hindrances to the process of investigation.
26.
In view of the above, this petition is deemed to be devoid of merits
and the same is accordingly dismissed.
27.
The Registry is directed to send back the case diary.
Judge
Meghalaya
20.07.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review