The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. On the other hand, learned advocate Mr. Kakadia for respondent Nos. 1 to 7 – original plaintiffs has C/SCA/586/2024 ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026 submitted that the plaintiffs have a right of way to approach their agricultural land through survey No.265, which is sub-divided between the petitioners and respondent Nos. 10 to 12 herein. The petitioners as well as respondent Nos. 10 to 12 herein have, in connivance with each other, tried to close the entire right of way of the plaintiffs and plaintiffs have no other alternative way to reach their agricultural field and therefore the Deputy Collector has rightly allowed the revision and directed the petitioners to open the way passing from the western side of land bearing Revenue Survey No.265 Paiki 1. He submits that the order passed by the Deputy Collector is in consonance with the provisions of the Mamlatdars’ Court Act as the objective of the Act is to ensure that no field is left uncultivated for want of a way. Therefore, the Deputy Collector could not be said to have committed any error of law and/or facts, which warrants any interference by this Court. He submits that as a temporary arrangement between the parties, on account of existence of two ways, some portion of land remained to be uncultivated and therefore all the parties agreed that respondents can use one way out of two existing ways and the said position continued for 10…
6. Having heard learned advocates appearing for the parties and having considered the materials placed on record, it transpires that respondent Nos. 1 to 7 herein – original plaintiffs have filed a suit under Section 5 of the Mamlatdars’ Court Act against the petitioners herein seeking a way from the southern boundary of land bearing Survey No.265/1, which is situated on the eastern side of various parcels of land of the plaintiffs. The said suit came to be dismissed by the Mamlatdar by holding that as per the say of the plaintiffs themselves, the way which is sought for by them has been blocked since last 10 years. As per the provisions of Section 5(3) of the Mamlatdars’ Court Act, the suit is required to be filed within a period of six months from the date on which the cause of action arose and therefore, in the C/SCA/586/2024 opinion of ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026 this Court, the Mamlatdar has rightly dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs keeping in mind the aforesaid provision of the Act. The respondent Nos. 1 to 7 herein have assailed the said order of the Mamlatdar by way of preferring revision before the Deputy Collector. It is pertinent to note that at the time of preferring the revision, the respondent Nos. to respondents, herein though have they been were joined not as joined party by the plaintiffs at the time of institution of the suit and the plaintiffs have completely cha…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/586/2024
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO.
586 of 2024
==========================================================
PATEL DINESHBHAI MOHANBHAI & ORS.
Versus
PATEL MORARBHAI KARSHANBHAI & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR. NISHIT P GANDHI(6946) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1,2,3
MR MEET D KAKADIA(11896) for the Respondent(s) No.
2,3,4,5,6,7
MR VEDANT D GAIKWAD(10444) for the Respondent(s) No.
2,3,4,5,6,7
NOTICE SERVED for the Respondent(s) No. 1,10,11,12
NOTICE SERVED BY DS for the Respondent(s) No. 8,9
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DIVYESH A. JOSHI
Date : 26/02/2026
ORDER
1.
By way of present petition under Articles 226
and 227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioners
have sought for the following main relief:
“A. Your Lordships may be pleased to issue a
writ of mandamus or a writ in the nature of
mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order
or directions directing quashing and setting
aside the impugned order dated 22.12.2023
passed by the respondent – Deputy Collector in
Mam. Court Revision Case No.01 of 2023.”
2.
The
facts
of
the
case
of
the
petitioners
in
nutshell can be summarized as under:
2.1. That respondent Nos. 1 to 7 herein – original
plaintiffs have filed a suit under Section 5 of the
C/SCA/586/2024
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
Mamlatdars’ Court Act against the petitioners herein
– original defendants seeking a way from the southern
side of land bearing Survey No.265/1, which belongs
to
the
petitioners,
to
enter
their
land
bearing
Survey Nos. 270 and 269 of village Anavada, Taluka &
District Patan. It is the case of the plaintiffs –
respondent
Nos.
ancestral
way
to
herein
that
they
have
to
reach
their
agricultural
an
field,
which has been closed by the defendants – petitioners
herein before 10 days of institution of the suit.
Pursuant
to
the
institution
plaintiffs,
a
notice
defendants
and
they
of
suit
by
the
to
be
issued
to
the
filed
a
detailed
reply,
came
have
inter alia, denying the averments made in the plaint
as
well
as
defendants
right
of
way
of
have
specifically
the
plaintiffs.
stated
that
The
the
plaintiffs have purchased land bearing Survey Nos.
270 and 269 from the owners of Survey No.268 and they
have a right of way from that Survey No.268. After
considering and appreciating the materials available
on record, the suit of the plaintiffs came to be
dismissed by the Mamlatdar essentially on the ground
that as per the say of the plaintiffs themselves, the
way which is sought by them has not been used by them
since last 10 years and during the course of spot
inspection,
the
way,
which
is
sought
for
by
the
with
the
plaintiffs, is not in existence.
2.2. Being
aggrieved
by
and
dissatisfied
said order, the plaintiffs – respondent Nos. 1 to 7
C/SCA/586/2024
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
herein have assailed the said order by preferring a
revision before the Deputy Collector, wherein, the
plaintiffs have completely changed their stand and
claimed the way from western side of Survey No.265
Paiki 1, which is going towards Survey No.271 and
thereafter to the field of the plaintiffs i.e. Survey
No.270. The said revision of the plaintiffs has been
allowed by the Deputy Collector by setting aside the
order of the Mamlatdar and directing the petitioners
to open the permanent old way which is on the western
side of Survey No.265 Paiki 1. Being aggrieved by the
said order of the Deputy Collector, present petition
is filed.
3.
Heard learned advocate Mr. Nishit P. Gandhi for
the petitioners and learned advocate Mr. Meet Kakadia
for respondent Nos. 1 to 7 and learned AGP Mr. Jay
Trivedi for respondent Nos. 8 and 9. Though served,
none appears for respondent Nos. 10 to 12.
4.
Learned advocate Mr. Gandhi submits that by way
of instituting the suit, the plaintiffs – respondent
Nos. 1 to 7 herein have sought a right of way from
the
southern
No.165
Paiki
side
of
land
1,
whereas,
bearing
by
Revenue
preferring
Survey
revision
before the Deputy Collector, the respondent Nos. 1 to
7 have completely changed their version and sought a
right of way from the western side of land bearing
Revenue
Survey
permissible.
He
No.165
submits
Paiki
1,
which
is
not
that
the
suit
of
the
C/SCA/586/2024
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
plaintiffs has been dismissed by the Mamlatdar by
specifically observing that the way which is sought
by the plaintiffs i.e. the way which is alleged to
have been used by the plaintiffs from western side of
land bearing revenue survey No.165 Paiki 1 has not
been used by the plaintiffs since last 10 years as
per their own admission. He has read the provisions
of Section 5(3) of the Mamlatdars’ Court Act and
submitted
that
the
suit
is
required
to
be
filed
within a period of six months from the date on which
the cause of action arose and therefore the Mamlatdar
has
rightly
dismissed
the
suit
of
the
plaintiffs
keeping in mind the aforesaid provision of the Act.
In support of his submission, learned advocate Mr.
Gandhi has heavily put reliance upon the decision of
this Court in the case of Rohit Sunderlal Kabutarwala
v. Ashokkumar Somabhai, reported in 2016 JX(Guj) 72
as
well
as
in
the
case
of
Kanjibhai
Godadbhai
Chaudhary v. Virsang Fuljibhai Chaudhary, reported in
JX(Guj)
28.
He
further
submits
that
by
preferring a revision before the Deputy Collector,
the plaintiffs have sought altogether a different way
which is passing from western side of land bearing
Revenue Survey No.165 Paiki 1. He submits that the
said
revision
has
been
allowed
by
the
Deputy
Collector. The view adopted by the Deputy Collector
is not just, fair and legal and based upon the sound
principle of law and therefore the order passed by
the Deputy Collector is required to be quashed and
set
aside.
He
further
submits
that
the
Deputy
C/SCA/586/2024
Collector
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
has
also
not
appreciated
the
fact
that
respondent Nos. 10 to 12 were not joined at the time
of institution of the suit and they have been joined
for
the
first
therefore
the
time
at
the
revision
stage
ought
of
not
revision
to
have
and
been
entertained by the Deputy Collector on the ground of
non-joinder and misjoinder of the parties. He further
submits
that
the
plaintiffs
had
made
a
false
statement on oath before the revenue authorities and
suppressed material facts and the Deputy Collector
has not appreciated the said aspect at the time of
allowing the revision filed by the plaintiffs and
therefore the order passed by the Deputy Collector is
not maintainable. Learned advocate Mr. Gandhi further
submits
that
it
is
well
settled
that
while
entertaining a revision, the revisional authority is
not
empowered
pleadings,
to
go
introduce
beyond
new
the
facts
scope
and/or
of
the
make
out
completely a new case that was not argued before the
lower authority and by doing so the Deputy Collector
has exceeded its jurisdiction and therefore also the
order passed by the Deputy Collector is required to
be quashed and set aside and order passed by the
Mamlatdar is required to be upheld. In support of his
submission,
learned
advocate
Mr.
Gandhi
has
put
reliance upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court
in the case of Dalip Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh,
reported in (2010) 2 SCC 114.
5.
On the other hand, learned advocate Mr. Kakadia
for respondent Nos. 1 to 7 – original plaintiffs has
C/SCA/586/2024
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
submitted that the plaintiffs have a right of way to
approach
their
agricultural
land
through
survey
No.265, which is sub-divided between the petitioners
and respondent Nos. 10 to 12 herein. The petitioners
as well as respondent Nos. 10 to 12 herein have, in
connivance with each other, tried to close the entire
right of way of the plaintiffs and plaintiffs have no
other
alternative
way
to
reach
their
agricultural
field and therefore the Deputy Collector has rightly
allowed the revision and directed the petitioners to
open the way passing from the western side of land
bearing Revenue Survey No.265 Paiki 1.
He submits
that the order passed by the Deputy Collector is in
consonance
with
the
provisions
of
the
Mamlatdars’
Court Act as the objective of the Act is to ensure
that no field is left uncultivated for want of a way.
Therefore, the Deputy Collector could not be said to
have committed any error of law and/or facts, which
warrants any interference by this Court. He submits
that as a temporary arrangement between the parties,
on account of existence of two ways, some portion of
land remained to be uncultivated and therefore all
the parties agreed that respondents can use one way
out
of
two
existing
ways
and
the
said
position
continued for 10 years. However, the petitioners as
well as respondent Nos. 10 to 12 have, in connivance
with each other, closed both the ways and therefore
respondents are not in a position to reach their
land. He further submits that if the prayer as sought
for by the petitioner is to be considered, in that
C/SCA/586/2024
event,
the
landlocked.
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
land
He
of
the
further
respondents
submits
that
it
would
be
is
well
settled that when no way is available for a person to
reach his agricultural filed, in that event, as per
the
provisions
concerned
is
of
the
empowered
Act,
to
the
revenue
authority
grant
shortest
possible
way. In support of his submissions, learned advocate
Mr. Kakadia has relied upon the decision of this
Court rendered in Civil Revision Application No.206
of 2014 on 24.06.2015 as well as decision in the case
of Faridmiya Majammiya Chavda v. State of Gujarat,
reported in 2015(0) AIJEL-HC-233667. He, therefore,
urges that the petition may be dismissed.
6.
Having heard learned advocates appearing for the
parties and having considered the materials placed on
record, it transpires that respondent Nos. 1 to 7
herein – original plaintiffs have filed a suit under
Section 5 of the Mamlatdars’ Court Act against the
petitioners herein seeking a way from the southern
boundary of land bearing Survey No.265/1, which is
situated on the eastern side of various parcels of
land of the plaintiffs. The said suit came to be
dismissed by the Mamlatdar by holding that as per the
say of the plaintiffs themselves, the way which is
sought for by them has been blocked since last 10
years. As per the provisions of Section 5(3) of the
Mamlatdars’ Court Act, the suit is required to be
filed within a period of six months from the date on
which the cause of action arose and therefore, in the
C/SCA/586/2024
opinion
of
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
this
Court,
the
Mamlatdar
has
rightly
dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs keeping in mind
the aforesaid provision of the Act. The respondent
Nos. 1 to 7 herein have assailed the said order of
the Mamlatdar by way of preferring revision before
the Deputy Collector. It is pertinent to note that at
the time of preferring the revision, the respondent
Nos.
to
respondents,
herein
though
have
they
been
were
joined
not
as
joined
party
by
the
plaintiffs at the time of institution of the suit and
the plaintiffs have completely changed their version
before the Deputy Collector and sought an altogether
different way i.e. the way which is passing from
western
boundary
of
land
bearing
Revenue
Survey
No.265 Paiki 1, which is on the southern side of
various parcels of land of the plaintiffs. The Deputy
Collector has allowed the said revision by directing
the petitioners and respondent Nos. 10 to 12 herein
to allow the respondents to use the way which is
passing from western boundary of land bearing Revenue
Survey No.265 Paiki 1, which is on the southern side
of various parcels of land of the plaintiffs. Thus,
it transpires that the Deputy Collector has allowed
the revision by directing the petitioner and others
to open an altogether different way, which is not
claimed by the plaintiffs at the time of institution
of the suit. I have also gone through the village map
as
well
as
satellige
map
produced
by
both
the
parties. It is well settled that while exercising the
revisional
powers,
the
revisional
authority
is
C/SCA/586/2024
ORDER DATED: 26/02/2026
required to consider and appreciate the legality and
validity of the order of the subordinate authority
and it shall not go beyond the pleadings instituted
before the subordinate authority and introduce new
facts and/or make out completely a new case that was
not argued before the lower authority.
7.
It is also pertinent to note that the suit of
the plaintiffs has been dismissed by the Mamlatdar
after appreciating and considering the materials and
documents placed on record as well as considering the
fact
that
the
plaintiffs
themselves
have
admitted
that the way, which is sought for by them has been
closed since last 10 years. Moreover, the way which
is
claimed
by
the
plaintiffs
is
also
not
in
existence. I have also gone through the orders passed
by
both
the
considered
revenue
view
that
authorities
the
and
Deputy
I
am
of
the
Collector
has
exceeded his jurisdiction while issuing directions to
the petitioners and respondent Nos. 10 to 12 herein
to allow the respondent Nos. 1 to 7 to use altogether
a different way which was not the subject matter of
the original suit. Thus, merely on the said ground,
the petition deserves consideration. Accordingly, the
petition is allowed. The impugned order passed by the
Deputy Collector is hereby quashed and set aside.
(DIVYESH A. JOSHI,J)
LAVKUMAR J JANI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review