Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/CA/1912/2023
ORDER DATED: 07/08/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR CONDONATION OF DELAY) NO. 1912 of
In
F/FIRST APPEAL/31316/2023
With
CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR CONDONATION OF DELAY) NO. 2 of 2025
In
CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR BRINGING HEIRS) NO. 1 of 2025
In
R/CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1912 of 2023
With
CIVIL APPLICATION (FOR BRINGING HEIRS) NO. 1 of 2025
In
R/CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1912 of 2023
==========================================================
PATEL ASHVINBHAI BHAGVANJIBHAI LILA & ANR.
Versus
PATEL DHIRAJLAL VASTABHAI & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
DR. SHRENIK R JASANI(9486) for the Applicant(s) No. 1,2
MR VIMAL A PUROHIT(5049) for the Applicant(s) No. 1,2
MR. GAURAV A. GOGIA(14128) for the Respondent(s) No. 2,3,5,6,7
RULE SERVED for the Respondent(s) No. 1,4
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 07/08/2026
ORAL ORDER
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA)
Order in Civil Application No. 2 of 2025:
Looking to the averments made in the Civil Application, the delay
in preferring the Civil Application for bringing the legal heirs is allowed.
Civil Application is allowed.
Order in Civil Application No. 1 of 2025:
Looking to the averments made in the Civil Application, present
Civil Application for bringing the heirs and legal representatives of
C/CA/1912/2023
ORDER DATED: 07/08/2026
deceased respondent no.1 and 4 is allowed in terms of para-11(C).
Learned advocate is permitted to amend the cause title accordingly.
Order in Civil Application No. : 1912 of 2023:
1.
This application is filed seeking condonation of delay in filing First
Appeal. The delay of 475 days caused in preferring the captioned
filed No.F/FA/31316 of 2023.
2.
The brief facts necessary for adjudication of the Appeal are set out
as under:
(1)
The applicants had instituted Special Civil Suit No. 66 of 2010 in
the Court of Civil Judge, Gondal at Rajkot for declaration,
permanent injunction and specific performance of contract with
regard to suit property.
(2)
The Civil Court vide its judgment and decree dated 26.07.2017
was pleased to dismiss the suit on merits. Admittedly, neither the
plaintiff nor defendant had given an opportunity to led the
evidence. The Civil Court based on the available documents in the
form of xerox copies, decided the rights and liabilities of the
parties, as if, the parties have led the evidence. No issues were
framed. In such circumstances, the applicants being original
plaintiffs, on advice, challenged the judgment of dismissal of the
suit, filed a review petition on 19.08.2017, before the District
Court, Gondal at Rajkot. The said Review Application came to be
dismissed on 19.02.2021. The applicants herein, then approached
this Court by way of First Appeal, challenging the judgment of
C/CA/1912/2023
ORDER DATED: 07/08/2026
dismissal of suit, which came to be filed on 29.08.2023. However,
there is a delay according to calculation made by the applicants of
475 days in preferring the Appeal.
3.
The grounds of delay are explained as under :
(a)
That the judgment of dismissal of suit is against the provision of
Code of Civil Procedure. No issues were framed by the Court.
None of the parties had led their respective oral as well as
documentary evidence. Thus, instead of dismissing the suit for
want of prosecution, the Civil Court for reasons best known to
him, decided the suit on merits, which directly affect the
substantial rights of the applicants with respect to the suit
property, as the respondents failed to execute the sale deed after
getting substantial amount from the applicants herein. Thus,
there is a merit in the appeal and opportunity should be given to
decide the lis between the parties on merits.
(b)
The applicants had retained their advocate Mr. P. J. Gauda, who
expired on 03.05.2015, since then the applicants were not aware
about the pendency of the suit and its stage.
(c)
The applicants on advice, challenged the judgment by preferring
Review Application and therefore, when the party was pursuing
a wrong remedy, then as per Section 14 of the Limitation Act,
the period spent for pursing the review remedy from 29.08.2017
to 19.08.2021, is required to be excluded.
C/CA/1912/2023
(d)
ORDER DATED: 07/08/2026
There was Corona period between 2019 to 2021. The Supreme
Court suspended the period of limitation commencing from
15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022.
(e)
The delay was not intentional and no negligence or inaction
imputable on the part of the applicants.
4.
In the aforesaid grounds, it is stated that the delay has been
sufficiently explained and same may be condoned so as to do
substantial justice.
5.
Mr. Abhishek Sharma, learned counsel for Mr. Vimal Purohit,
learned advocate for the applicants has submitted that there are
chances in succeeding the appeal, as the respondents failed to
perform their part so far as terms and agreement of the contract is
concerned and now, due to escalation in price of the land, they
turned hostile and refused to perform their part by executing sale
deed of the suit land. The applicants were unaware about the death
of their lawyer and therefore neither the court nor the son of the
lawyer informed them about the dismissal of the suit. The approach
of Civil Court is contrary to the settled law. The Court should not
have dismissed the suit on merits without giving opportunity to the
respective parties. The maximum time was consumed in review
application proceedings and said proceedings was being filed
bonafide and as per Section 14 of the Limitation Act, the time
consumed in pursuing the Review Application, could be excluded.
The provision of the Limitation Act, being stayed during Corona
period. In such circumstances, it was submitted that, the delay
C/CA/1912/2023
ORDER DATED: 07/08/2026
cannot be said to be deliberate and considering the circumstances
as referred above, the delay has been explained satisfactorily and
therefore, it is prayed that, the technical approach may be avoided
and the grounds, as referred shall have to be liberally construed to
do substantial justice.
6.
Mr. Anand Gogia, learned advocate for the respondent vehemently
opposed the application. It was contended that, the applicants original plaintiffs remained negligent and grounds for delay as
referred are neither correct nor bonafide. The suit was instituted on
04.02.2010 and it came to be dismissed 26.07.2017. Against
which, the Review Application was filed on 19.08.2017 and same
came to be dismissed on 19.02.2021. Thereafter, after period of 2
years i.e. on 29.08.2023, the appeal along with present delay
condonation application filed before this Court. Therefore, it is
evident that, the applicants did remain negligent for about 7 years
and there was gross negligence on their part and the explanation
offered cannot be acceptable and convincing and as such, the
explanation would not to be treated as ‘sufficient cause’ for
condoning the delay. In support of the submissions, heavy reliance
been placed in case of State of Madhya Pradesh Vs. Ramkumar
Chaudhary (2025 (2) GLR 987), to contend that, the expression
‘sufficient cause’, cannot be liberally interpreted, if the negligence,
inaction or lack of bona-fides is attributed to the party and delay
should not be excused as a matter of generosity and rendering
substantial justice is not to cause prejudice to opposite party.
C/CA/1912/2023
7.
ORDER DATED: 07/08/2026
Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, the issue
falls for our consideration, as to whether ‘sufficient cause’ existed
for condoning the delay in filing the First Appeal?
8.
In the facts of the present case, after dismissal of the suit, the time
consumed in pursing the Review Application, whereby, the
judgment was challenged required to be excluded, as provided
under Section 14 of the Limitation Act because, the applicants had
been bona-fide pursing the wrong remedy. Thus, the time period
from 26.07.2017 to dismissal of the Review Application i.e.
19.02.2021, is required to be excluded in calculating the delay
caused in preferring the First Appeal. Admittedly, during the
pandemic time, the provision of Limitation Act being suspended,
commencing w.e.f. 15.03.2020 till 28.02.2022. Thus, from the date
of judgment of Review Application till 28.02.2022, the time period
is required to be excluded. The actual delay would require to be
calculated from 01.03.2022 to filing of First Appeal i.e.
29.08.2023, which would come to around 484 days. In such
circumstance, whether the delay of 484 days caused in filing First
Appeal, satisfactorily explained or not.
9.
This delay application is filed under Section 5 of the Limitation
Act, which says that, any appeal or application, may be admitted
after the prescribed period, if the appellant / applicant satisfies the
court that he has ‘sufficient cause’ for not preferring the appeal or
making the application within such period. At the outset, it needs
to be stated that, generally speaking the Courts have to adopt
C/CA/1912/2023
ORDER DATED: 07/08/2026
liberal approach in considering the application for condonation of
delay on the ground of ‘sufficient cause’ under Section 5 of the
Limitation Act. This principle is well settled and has been set out
succinctly in the case of Collector, Land Acquisition Anantnag
and Ors Vs. Katiji and Ors. (1987 (2) SCC 107). In the case of
N. Balakrishnan Vs. Krishna Murthy 1998 (7) SCC 123, it has
been reiterated by the Supreme Court that, rules of limitation are
not meant to destroy the rights of the parties. However, in the case
of Lanka Venkateswarlu Vs. State of A.P, (AIR 2011 SC 1199),
it was held and observed that, the Courts have to adopt a liberal
approach in considering the application for condonation of delay
but the concept of liberal approach, justice oriented approach and
substantial justice, cannot be employed to jettison the substantial
law of limitation. In another case, the Supreme Court (State of
Madhya Pradesh Vs. Ram Kumar Chaudhary (2025 (2) GLR
987) (supra), it was observed that, where the case has been
presented beyond limitation, the applicant has to explain the court
as to what was the ‘sufficient cause’, which means, an adequate
and enough reason which prevented him to approach the court
within limitation. The discretion to condone delay, has to be
exercised judicially, based on the facts and circumstances of each
case and that, the expression ‘sufficient cause’ cannot be liberally
interpreted, if the negligence, inaction or lack of bona-fide is
attributed to the party.
10.
In light of the settled principle of law and applying the same to the
facts of the present case, we are of the considered opinion that, the
C/CA/1912/2023
ORDER DATED: 07/08/2026
explanation offered for condonation of delay is found to be not
satisfactory. The applicants in their application have not given any
acceptable and genuine instances that, there was ‘sufficient cause’
preventing them to prefer the First Appeal. As pointed out, in
preceding para-8 of the order, the applicants, were inactive and
remained negligent. There was enough time to act promptly to file
an appeal even after the pandemic period. But somehow, they
could not approach this Court promptly with all due diligence,
which shows that they slept over their rights without any justifiable
reason. Thus, it shows that the applicants failed to demonstrate
reasonable diligence or bona-fide in pursing their rights. Thus,
therefore, in our opinion, the reasons set forth for the delay are
totally insufficient to condone the delay and the explanation is no
explanation much less sufficient or satisfactorily explanation,
which can be said to constitute ‘sufficient cause’ for not preferring
an appeal within prescribed time period.
11.
In view of the aforementioned reasons, the present application fails
and is accordingly dismissed. Notice discharged. No order as to
costs.
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
P.S. JOSHI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review