The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. Reliance is also placed upon judgment dated 27.06.2023 passed in CWP No.2255 of 2023, titled Umesh Akre Vs. The State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors., wherein Division Bench, while placing reliance upon judgment passed in Tarun Bakshi (supra), allowed the prayer of the petitioner to grant planning permission on the application/building plan submitted as per law/rules as applicable on the said date within a specified period of time.
10. Consequently, in view of discussion made herein above as well as law taken into consideration, this Court finds merit in the present petition and accordingly, the same is allowed. Order dated
20. 03.2024 (Annexure P-8) is quashed and set aside. Respondents are directed to process the building plan submitted by the petitioner in the year 2015 and to sanction the same in accordance with bye-laws, notifications and Interim Development Plan in force at that relevant point expeditiously, preferably within eight weeks from today. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of. (Sandeep Sharma), Judge August 31, 2026 (sunil)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.14493 of 2025
Date of Decision: 31.08.2026
_______________________________________________________
Parmod Bamba
…….Petitioner
Versus
The Municipal Corporation & Anr.
… Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Vinay Kuthiala, Senior Advocate with Mr.
Diwan Singh Negi, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. Deepak Sharma, Advocate.
_______________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, Judge(oral):
By way of instant petition filed under Article 226 of
Constitution of India, petitioner has prayed for the following main
relief:“a. That a writ in the nature of mandamus may be kindly be
issued directing the respondents to process the Building plans
submitted by the petitioner in 2015 and to sanction the same
in accordance with the bye-laws, Notifications and Interim
Development Plan in force at that time.”
2.
Precisely, the case of the petitioner, as has been
highlighted in the petition and further canvassed by Mr. Vinay
Kuthiala, learned Senior Counsel duly assisted by Mr. Diwan Singh
Negi, learned counsel for the petitioner, is that revised plan submitted
by the petitioner in the year 2016 is required to be considered and
decided in the light of Interim Development Plan promulgated vide
1Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
Notification dated 13.08.2015, published in the Rajpatra (Annexure P2), for the reason that the same was submitted strictly in terms of the
aforesaid Notification. The revised plan of the petitioner, therefore,
cannot be considered and decided in the light of the Development
Plan, which subsequently came to be approved by the Hon’ble Apex
Court vide judgment dated 11.01.2024, as the said Development
Plan, for all intents and purposes, would come into force only from the
date of passing of the aforesaid judgment by the Hon’ble Apex Court.
3.
Precisely, the facts of the case as emerge from the
pleadngs as well as other material adduced on record by the
respective parties are that initial building plan of the petitioner was
approved vide sanction order No.261 (AP) dated 16.06.2011
(Annexure R-1/1) for the construction of a two-storeyed structure with
a sloping roof on Khasra Nos. 669 and 670, situate at North Bank
Estate, Shimla. Petitioner did not commence any construction work
pursuant to the aforesaid sanction order, however, submitted a
revised proposal (Annexure R-1/2), in respect of the same Khasra
numbers vide application dated 02.12.2015, proposing construction of
a four-storeyed building comprising a parking floor and a sloping roof.
The revised proposal was examined by the Municipal Corporation,
Shimla and returned with the following observations:
Submission of a fresh NOC from Public Works
Department (PWD) regarding access to the proposed
parking floor;
Front setback to be proposed as per Government
notification dated 28.6.2016; and
Submission of latest revenue documents and tax
NOC.
4.
Revised proposal remained unapproved for want of
certain documents and compliance with the requisite formalities.
However, subsequently the petitioner submitted a revised completion
plan on 14.12.2022, (Annexure R-1/3), showing construction of twostoreyed structure with a sloping roof, based upon the plan previously
sanctioned vide Order No.261(AP) dated 16.02.2011. However, fact
remains that till date, no decision has been taken upon the same, as a
result of thereof, petitioner is compelled to approach this Court in the
instant proceedings, praying therein for relief, as has been
reproduced hereinabove.
5.
Respondent-Municipal
Corporation
has
filed
reply,
wherein facts as have been noticed hereinabove, have not been
disputed, rather an attempt has been made to refute the claim of the
petitioner on the pretext that petitioner carried out construction work
on the basis of the plan sanctioned in the year 2011 and the revised
completion plan submitted in the year 2022 was examined and
returned with certain observations (Annexure R-1/4). Petitioner again
submitted a revised /completion plan, showing the existing twostoreyed structure and proposing construction of two additional
storeys plus a sloping roof, along with a proposal to open the existing
retaining wall to be used as parking floor. The proposal submitted in
the year 2015 was in respect of construction on a vacant plot,
whereas, at the time of submission of revised plan, the petitioner had
already constructed two storeys at the site on the basis of the plan
sanctioned in the year 2011. Therefore, the revised proposal
submitted in the year 2015 became untenable for consideration.
6.
In nutshell, case of the Municipal Corporation is that
revised proposal dated 02.12.2015 for construction of four-storeyed
building plus parking floor was never approved by the Municipal
Corporation and construction executed at site has to conform to the
plan sanctioned in the year 2011. It has been further stated in the
reply filed by respondent-Municipal Corporation that request to
consider the revised proposal submitted in the year 2015 as the basis
for grant of the present approval is not tenable, as the said proposal
pertained to a vacant plot, whereas the petitioner has already
constructed two storeys at the site on the basis of the plan sanctioned
in the year 2011.
7.
Admittedly, in the case at hand, no final decision till date
has been taken qua the revised proposal submitted by the petitioner
in the year 2015 for construction of four-storeys plus parking floor.
True it is that initially permission was granted to the petitioner to
construct two-storeyed structure vide sanction order No. 261(AP)
dated 16.02.2011, but before any construction could be carried out
pursuant to the aforesaid sanction order, petitioner submitted a
revised proposal vide application dated 03.01.2015 proposing the
construction of a four-storeyed building with a parking floor and a
sloping roof. It is not in dispute that the afore proposal was strictly in
terms of Interim Development Plan approved in the year 2015, but
before afore proposal could be taken to its logical end, National Green
Tribunal passed an order dated 16.11.2017, thereby imposing a
complete ban on construction activities in Shimla, as a result thereof,
revised proposal submitted by the petitioner remained pending
consideration. In the meantime, petitioner, who had already been
granted sanction vide Order No. 261 (AP) dated 16.02.2011 for
construction of a two-storeyed building, proceeded to construct the
said two storeys, but fact remains that till date, that partial
construction has not been approved. It is also not in dispute that the
aforesaid order dated 16.11.2017 passed by the National Green
Tribunal, whereby construction activities in Shimla were banned, was
set aside by the Hon'ble Apex Court vide order dated 11.01.2024
passed in Civil Appeals No. 5348 and 5349 of 2019, as a result
thereof, construction, if any, carried out by the petitioner or other
similarly situate persons pursuant to Interim Development Plan of
2015 was required to be considered for approval, but same has not
been done till date. Hon'ble Apex Court, while passing aforesaid
order, categorically permitted the State to proceed with the
implementation of the Development Plan as published on 20.06.2023,
meaning thereby, from the date of passing of aforesaid judgment by
the Hon'ble Apex Court, construction in the State of Himachal
Pradesh is required to be carried out in terms of Development Plan
published in the year 2023.
8.
However, question, which needs to be determined in the
case at hand, is whether plans, if any, submitted in terms of Interim
Development Plan of 2015 can be denied approval on the ground that
in terms of judgment passed by the Hon'ble Apex Court, construction
is necessarily required to be carried out strictly in terms of
Development Plan of 2023. Careful perusal of judgment passed by
the Hon'ble Apex Court nowhere suggests that Hon’ble Apex Court,
while permitting State of HP to proceed with the implementation of
Development Plan 2023, also directed that plans submitted prior to
publication of Development Plan 2023, in terms of Interim
Development Plan 2015, shall also be considered in light of
Development Plan 2023, meaning thereby, construction, if any,
carried out or proposal, if any, submitted pursuant to Interim
Development Plan 2015 is required to be considered strictly in terms
of Interim Development Plan of 2015 as has been held by the Division
Bench of this Court in judgment dated 23.08.2022 passed in Civil Writ
Petition No. 7876 of 2021, titled Tarun Bakhshi & Ors. Vs. State of
Himachal Pradesh & Ors. Relevant paras of the afore judgment are
extracted herein below:“21. From the aforesaid discussion, it is abundantly clear that
the respondents while rejecting the building plan of the
petitioners have acted contrary to their own instructions and,
therefore, their action is not sustainable.
22. That apart, respondents have unnecessarily and unduly
been influenced by the order passed by the NGT, which in the
given facts and circumstances of the case was neither
attracted nor applicable to the case of the petitioners more
particularly when the petitioners had submitted their building
plan on 03.08.2017 i.e. much prior to the order passed by the
NGT on 16.11.2017 and the same had even been examined
and thereafter referred to the inter-departments of the
Corporation for seeking NOC and also referred to the Forest
Department for grant of NOC vide communication dated
24.10.2017 i.e. again prior to the passing of the order of the
NGT.
23. In view of the aforesaid reasons stated above, we find
merit in this petition and we quash the order dated 04.12.2020
(Annexure P-49), order dated 29.12.2018 (Annexure P-21)
and also set aside and quash the orders/proceedings dated
17.12.2018, 08.07.2019 and 06.01.2020 of 45th, 49th and
54th meetings of House Plan Approval Committee of
respondent No. 4 and accordingly direct the respondents to
consider and if found in order, grant planning permission to
the petitioners on the application/building plan submitted on
03.08.2017, as per the law/rules, as applicable on the said
date within a period of three months from today and report
compliance on 18.11.2022.”
9.
Reliance is also placed upon judgment dated 27.06.2023
passed in CWP No.2255 of 2023, titled Umesh Akre Vs. The State
of Himachal Pradesh & Ors., wherein Division Bench, while placing
reliance upon judgment passed in Tarun Bakshi (supra), allowed the
prayer of the petitioner to grant planning permission on the
application/building plan submitted as per law/rules as applicable on
the said date within a specified period of time.
10.
Consequently, in view of discussion made herein above
as well as law taken into consideration, this Court finds merit in the
present petition and accordingly, the same is allowed. Order dated
20.03.2024 (Annexure P-8) is quashed and set aside. Respondents
are directed to process the building plan submitted by the petitioner in
the year 2015 and to sanction the same in accordance with bye-laws,
notifications and Interim Development Plan in force at that relevant
point expeditiously, preferably within eight weeks from today. Pending
applications, if any, stand disposed of.
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
August 31, 2026
(sunil)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review