Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:18951
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 5765 of 2024
….…..
Parmeshwar Sah, aged about 63 years, son of Panchu
Sah, resident of P.W.D. Colony, C. H. Area, P.O. & P.S.Bistupur,
Kalimali,
Jamshedpur,
District-East
Singhbhum (Jharkhand)
..… Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand.
2. The Secretary, Building Construction Department,
Govt. of Jharkhand, having office at Project Bhawan,
Dhurwa,
P.O.
&
P.S.-Dhurwa,
District-Ranchi
(Jharkhand)
3. The Superintending Engineer, Building Construction
Department, Govt. of Jharkhand, Chotanagpur Circle,
Ranchi,
G.P.O.,
P.S.-Kotwali,
District-Ranchi
(Jharkhand)
4.
Executive
Engineer,
Building
Construction
Department, Building Division, Govt. of Jharkhand,
Jamshedpur,
G.P.O.,
P.S.-Kotwali,
District-East
Singhbhum (Jharkhand)
5. Office of Principle Accountant General, through
Accountant General, Jharkhand having office at
Doranda,
P.O.
&
P.S.-Doranda,
District-Ranchi
(Jharkhand)
..... Respondent(s)
….…..
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
….…
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondents
For the Acct. Gen.
C.A.V. ON: 11/06/2026
: Mr. Saurabh Shekhar, Adv
Ms. Nidhi Kumari, Adv
: Mr. Rakesh Kr. Roy, A.C. to GA-III
: Dr. Ashok Kumar Singh, Adv
Ms. Sharon Toppo, Adv
PRONOUNCED ON:29/06/2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The instant writ application has been preferred by the
petitioner for the following reliefs:(i) For issuance of appropriate writ(s), order(s), direction(s), specifically a writ
in the nature of mandamus commanding upon the respondents to grant
benefit of pension and other post retiral dues, that is pending in favour of the
petitioner, in pursuance to his retirement from work charge establishment,
since he has completed more than 15 years of temporary services, and is
entitled to get the relief as such, in view of the judgment rendered by the Full
Bench of Hon'ble High Court in the case of Ram Prasad Singh Vs. State of
Jharkhand, reported in 2005 (3) JCR 9 (Jhr) (F.B.);
(ii) For issuance of appropriate writ(s), order(s), direction(s), specifically a writ
in the nature of mandamus considering the petitioner to be as regularized
employee and release the entire pensionary benefits in his favour, in
pursuance to the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
Prem Singh Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors., reported in (2019) 10 SCC 516
2026:JHHC:18951
Para-36;
(iii) For issuance of appropriate writ(s), order(s), direction(s), specifically a writ
in the nature of mandamus commanding upon the respondents to calculate
the pensionary benefits of petitioner, on counting of the entire past services,
as per the Govt. resolution dated 17.07.2023, and thus, count him in, as a
beneficiary of old pension scheme;
(iv) For issuance of appropriate writ(s), order(s), direction(s), specifically a writ
in the nature of mandamus commanding upon the respondents to release the
arrears of salary for the period between February 2019 to January 2020 and
January 2021 to February 2021, the period for which, he has rendered his
services but the salary has not been released in his favour;
3.
Briefly stated, the petitioner was earlier appointed on the
post of Choukidar/ Majdoor, in the pay scale of Rs.350-425/on work charge basis on 04.01.1986 by the Superintending
Engineer. The appointment letter is annexed as Annexure-1 of
the writ application. Thereafter, he has superannuated from
services in the month of February, 2021. During his entire
tenure, the Petitioner worked as a work charge employee
against a regular and sanctioned post. He was granted the
permanent pay scale and received increments which is evident
from the fixation of pay that is maintained in Form-B of Govt of
Jharkhand fixation of pay (Annexure 2).
4.
The petitioner also represented for payment of salary for
the periods from February 2019 to January 2020 and January
2021 to February 2021, during which he rendered services but
was not paid his salary. The Petitioner represented before the
Respondents for release of pensionary benefits; however, no
action was taken. Therefore, the petitioner has approached this
Court with a prayer to make payment of pensionary as well as
other post retiral dues, as he has completed more than 15 years
of services in temporary establishment.
2026:JHHC:18951
5.
It has been contended by Ld. Counsel for the petitioner
that this case is covered by the judgment of the Full Bench of
the Jharkhand High Court passed in the case of Ram Prasad
Singh Vs. State of Jharkhand, reported in 2005 (3) JCR 09 (JHR)
(FB). In this judgment, the Full Bench has decided at para-17(i)
that the work charge employees who have completed more than
05 years of services, they are entitled to be placed in permanent
(regular) establishment. Thereafter, at para-17(iii), it has
further been held that those work charge employees who
continued for 15 years and more, shall be entitled to get the
benefit of pension, gratuity, leave encashment, etc., particularly
when they have been working against a post, and in a regular
scale of pay.
6.
From bare perusal of the appointment letter, annexed at
Annexure-1, it is clear that the petitioner was appointed against
the post of ‘Choukidar’ and was receiving a fixed pay scale.
Therefore, the case of the petitioner is squarely covered, as per
the clause of para-17(iii). On that count alone, the petitioner
can be comfortably said to be entitled to get the benefit of
pension, gratuity, and other post-retirement benefits, even
though, he has not been regularized. This benefit accrues on
him as he has completed more than 15 years of services, for the
respondents in a temporary establishment.
2026:JHHC:18951
7.
The
position
that
an
employee
under
temporary
establishment will be entitled to get pension, on completion of
15 years of services is further fortified from the provision of
Rule-59 of the Jharkhand Pension Rules. This rule provides
that the Government is entitled to make relaxation and include
any particular services under the Pension Rules. Applying this
authority, the Govt. had adopted one liberalized pension
scheme, wherein, it was specified that there are many
temporary employees, who superannuate without confirmation
of their services. Under such circumstances, the benefit of
pension will be granted to such employees, if they have
completed 15 years of services, as otherwise, it will cause
hardship to them, if they are not allowed pension after their
retirement.
8.
Applying this provision of law, duly promulgated by the
Govt., under the provision of Pension Rules, it is clear that the
employee of temporary establishment is entitled to get pension
on completion of 15 years of services.
9.
The question that could now be raised is whether or not,
work charge employees are to be categorized as temporary
employees. This query has been answered by the Full Bench in
the case of Ram Prasad Singh (Supra) at para-13 & 14, wherein,
the Finance Department memo no.1344, dated 04.02.1949 has
been quoted. The resolution has been quoted to say that the
2026:JHHC:18951
condition of services of work charge establishment will
henceforth be identical with those of temporary Govt. servants.
This departmental memorandum has been further said to be
adopted under the provisions of proviso to Article-309 of the
Constitution of India, as has been stated in para-14 of the
judgment. Therefore, it has been held that the work charge
employees have been granted temporary status of employment,
as per the statutory mandate. Under such circumstances, the
Court has, thereafter applied the provisions of Rule-59 to hold
that the work charge employees, who are identical to the
temporary employees will be entitled to pension on completion
of 15 years of services.
10. Ld. Counsel for the petitioner has also relied upon the
judgment passed in the case of State of Gujarat & Ors. Vs.
Talsibhai Dhanjibhai Patel, reported in (2022) LIVE LAW
(SC), 187. In this case, it has been held that if the respondents
have not regularized the services of the employees, then, the
employees should not suffer for such delaying tactics on part of
the respondent-employer. If the employee has completed 20-30
years of services, then he will be entitled to be granted pension,
as if regularized.
11. In the present case, the petitioner was entitled to be
regularized, on completion of 5 years of services in work charge
establishment, as has been mandated by the Full Bench in the
2026:JHHC:18951
case of Ram Prasad Singh (Supra), at para-17(i). The fact that
the petitioner was not regularized in due time, should not be
allowed to work to his disadvantage. The case of Talsibhai
Dhanjibhai Patel (Supra) is squarely applicable in the facts of
the
present
case,
as
the
petitioner
has
suffered
non-
regularization for the delay on part of the respondents. Now, he
has superannuated and therefore, his past services should be
considered for pension.
12. Reference may be made to yet another judgment rendered
in the case of Bhikani Devi & etc Vs. Union of India & Ors.,
arising out of S.L.P. (Civil) No. 28802 – 28804 of 2019;
judgment and order dated 01.06.2026. In this case, the
employees were appointed on casual basis, as night-guards, in
the year 1971-72. The respondents thereafter, came-up with a
scheme
to
absorb
all
the
employees
in
temporary
establishment, in the year 1992. In this manner, a temporary
status was given to all the employees and it was further stated
that several benefits would be attached to the temporary status
that is being granted. The petitioners unfortunately, were not
absorbed in the temporary status, and they superannuated,
without being given that status. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
has framed the issue at para-32, which is as under:“32. Having heard the counsel for both the parties and on
perusal of pleadings and material on record, the issue that
arises for consideration can be carved out as follows:
Whether temporary status casual labourer, in the absence
2026:JHHC:18951
of a formal order of regularisation, would be entitled to
pensionary benefits on superannuation or not?”
13. The above-mentioned issue has been answered at para-76
of the judgment, which is being quoted herein below:“76. The question as framed in para-32 above stands answered as
follows:A temporary status casual labourer would be entitled to
pensionary benefits on superannuation even in the absence of
regularisation.”
14. It is thus clear that a temporary status casual labourer
would be entitled to pensionary benefits on superannuation,
even in the absence of regularization of services.
15. The respondents have taken a ground that the Cabinet
has taken a decision on 17.07.2023 wherein it has been
decided that the entire past services of employee under work
charge establishment shall be granted for pensionary benefits,
only if he has been granted the status of permanent regular
employee; as such, the case of the petitioner does not fall
squarely, as per the provision of the Cabinet decision notified
vide memo dated 17.07.2023. So far as the arrears of salary for
the period between February 2019 to January 2020 and
January 2021 and leave encashment is concerned; the
answering respondent has already paid an amount of Rs.
9,37,501/-on 01.03.2025 and 06.03.2025.
16. From the rival contention of the parties, it is clear that the
case of the petitioner requires consideration, in view of the fact
that he has rendered more than 15 years of services in
temporary establishment. The fact that the petitioner has
2026:JHHC:18951
rendered his services in temporary establishment is supported
in the present case, as because, he was working on work charge
establishment, which has been declared as a temporary status
passed by the Hon’ble Full Bench in the case of Ram Prasad
Singh (Supra). Therefore, the case of the petitioner is covered
under the provisions of Rule-59 of the Pension Rules to get the
benefit of pension.
17. As stated hereinabove, the case of the petitioner is further
supported by the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Talsibhai Dhanjibhai Patel (Supra), as because, the
regularization of the petitioner was delayed due to the action of
the respondents, and in the meantime, he has superannuated,
therefore, following the ratio of the above judgment, the past 30
years of services of the petitioner should be counted as pension.
18. The objection taken by the respondents that the past
services of an employee cannot be counted, for the reason being
that he is not regularized, has to be deprecated in light of the
recent judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court, passed in the case
of Bhikhani Devi (Supra), wherein, it has been held at para76, that temporary status casual labourer would be entitled to
pensionary benefits on superannuation, even in the absence of
regularization. In the said case the scheme of 1992 has been
interpreted by the Hon’ble Apex Court, which grants the benefit
2026:JHHC:18951
of pension, on the basis of which, pensionary benefits have
been decided for temporary employees.
19. Similarly, in the present case, the Rule-59, read with
liberalized pension scheme, provides that temporary employees
who have rendered 15 years of services are entitled to pension.
20. In view of the above discussion and finding, this Court is
of the opinion that the petitioner is entitled for pensionary
benefits. The fact that he has not been regularized, will not
come to hinder his case for grant of pensionary benefits. The
entire 30 years of services should be counted for grant of
pension, gratuity, leave encashment and other post-retirement
benefits.
21. Accordingly, the Respondents are directed to verify the
record of the petitioner and calculate entire post-retirement
including pension, gratuity, leave encashment and pay the
same to the petitioner within a period of 8 weeks from the date
of receipt/production of copy of this order.
22. As a result, the instant writ application stands allowed.
Pending I.As if any also stands disposed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
Dated:29/06/2026
Amardeep/
A.F.R
Uploaded on
01.07.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review