Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 439 of 2026.
Reserved on : 11.09.2026.
Date of decision: 16.09.2026.
Parkashvati
…..Petitioner.
Versus
Union of India and others
…..Respondents.
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1 Yes
For the Petitioner
:
Mr.Jagan Nath, Advocate.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Kanwalvir Singh Kang and Mr.
Rajesh Prakash, Advocates, for
respondent Nos. 1, 3 and 7.
Mr.
Diwakar
Dev
Sharma,
Additional Advocate General, for
respondent Nos.2, 4, 5 and 6.
Romesh Verma, Judge
The present petition arises out of the order as passed
by the learned Additional District Judge-II, dated 25.06.2026,
whereby an application filed under Order VIII Rule 1 of the Code of
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment?Yes
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
Civil Procedure (for short ‘CPC’) on behalf of the plaintiff-petitioner
was ordered to be dismissed.
2.
The facts, as emerge in the present case, are that the
plaintiff-petitioner filed a suit for decree of damages and also for
decree of permanent prohibitory injunction against the defendantsrespondents in the Court of learned District Judge, Shimla, District
Shimla, H.P. which was assigned to the learned Additional District
Judge-II, Shimla, District Shimla.
3.
The notices were issued to the defendants on
24.06.2025, returnable for 25.07.2025. The defendants were served
and thereafter on 25.07.2025 they sought time to file written
statement and the case was fixed for filing written statement on
06.09.2025. On 06.09.2025, the defendants again sought time to file
written statement and the case was fixed on 09.10.2025. The
defendants No.1 to 7 filed the written statement on 29.11.2025. On
the very same day, an application came to be filed by the plaintiffpetitioner under the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC with the
prayer that the written statement as filed may not be taken on record
and the right of the defendants-respondents to file the written
statement may be ordered to be closed.
4.
The
said
application
was
resisted
by
the
defendants/respondents by filing an exhaustive reply wherein all the
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
averments as made by the plaintiff-petitioner therein were refuted
and denied.
5.
The learned Additional District Judge-II, Shimla, vide its
impugned order dated 25.06.2026 dismissed the application as filed
by the plaintiff-petitioner.
6.
Feeling
dis-satisfied,
the
plaintiff-petitioner
has
approached this Court by assailing the said impugned order.
7.
It is contended by learned counsel for the plaintiff-
petitioner that the impugned order as passed by the learned Court
below is not sustainable in the eyes of law and after accepting the
present petition, the right to file the written statement on behalf of the
defendants may be ordered to be closed. It is further contended by
learned counsel for the plaintiff-petitioner that the learned Court
below has not adhered to the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC
and has wrongly dismissed the application filed by the plaintiffpetitioner by not closing the right of the defendants to file the written
statement.
8.
On the other hand, Mr. Kanwalvir Singh Kang and Mr.
Rajesh Prakash, Advocates, for respondents No.1, 3 and 7 have
defended the impugned order. It is contended by Mr. Kang that this
Court while exercising the powers under Article 227 of the
Constitution will not interfere with the impugned order.
Even
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
otherwise, the learned Additional District Judge-II has passed a wellreasoned order and it does not call for any interference.
9.
I have heard the learned counsel for both the parties.
10.
The plaintiff-petitioner approached the Court of learned
Additional District Judge-II, Shimla, by filing suit for damages against
the respondents.
The suit was listed before the learned District
Judge-II on 24.06.2025 when the said civil suit was registered and it
was ordered that the defendants be got served through ordinary
summons as well as RAD, returnable for 25.07.2025. On
25.07.2025, defendants No.1 to 7 sought time for filing written
statement and the same was allowed and it was ordered that let
written statement be filed on 06.09.2025.
On 06.09.2025, the
learned counsel for the defendants again sought time to file written
statement and the learned Additional District Judge-II allowed the
prayer of the learned counsel for the defendants and it was ordered
let the written statement be filed on 09.10.2025. The case was listed
before the learned Court below on 09.10.2025.
Again, the
defendants sought time and it was ordered let written statement be
filed on 29.11.2025, being last opportunity.
On 29.11.2025, the
written statement was filed by the defendants and the copy thereof
was supplied to the learned counsel for the plaintiff. The present
petitioner-plaintiff on the very same day filed an application under
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC with the prayer that the
written statement may not be taken on record and the defendants’
right to file the written statement be closed.
11.
The provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC read as
follows:
“WRITTEN STATEMENT, SET-OFF AND COUNTERCLAIM
1. Written statement-The defendant shall, within thirty days
from the date of service of summons on him, present a
written statement of his defence:
“Provided that where the defendant fails to file the written
statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall
be allowed to file the same on such other day, as may be
specified by the Court, for reasons to be recorded in
writing, but which shall not be later than ninety days from
the date of service of summons.”
12.
It is contended by learned counsel for the plaintiff-
petitioner that since as per the mandate of the CPC, the written
statement is required to be filed within a period of 30 days and outer
limit to file the written statement is 90 days. Therefore, after the
expiry of 90 days, the written statement as filed by the defendantsrespondents could not have been entertained. He further submits
that since 90 days expired in the present case on 30.09.2025,
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
therefore, the impugned order as passed by the learned Court below
is not sustainable in the eyes of law.
13.
On the other hand, it is contended by Mr. Kanwalvir
Singh Kang that though it is admitted fact that the defendants were
served for 25.07.2025 and they appeared before the learned Court
below on 25.07.2025 and on the request of learned counsel for the
defendants-respondents, time was granted to file the written
statement
09.10.2025,
on
06.09.2025.
time
was
Thereafter,
sought
by
on
learned
06.09.2025
and
counsel
the
for
defendants/respondents to file the written statement and the same
was allowed in the presence of learned counsel for the plaintiffrespondent. It has further been contended by Mr. Kang, learned
counsel for the defendants-respondents that at that time no
objection was raised by learned counsel for the plaintiff-petitioner.
Therefore, the objection, as is being raised now, is an afterthought
and not sustainable in the eyes of law.
14.
A perusal of the case file reveals that time was granted
to the defendants to file written statement in the presence of learned
counsel for the plaintiff and no objection of any kind was made at
that time. The defendants were granted time on 25.07.2025,
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
06.09.2025 and finally on 09.10.2025 whereby last opportunity was
granted to the defendants to file written statement.
The learned
Court below fixed the date for filing written statement on 29.11.2025
and the on very same day the written statement came to be filed by
the defendants and the same was never objected to by the plaintiffpetitioner. Therefore, the plea which is now being raised by the
plaintiff-petitioner is without any merit.
15.
Once, the Court had granted the permission to the
defendants to file written statement on different dates and the said
order stood complied with by the defendants by filing written
statement on 29.11.2025, therefore, the plea as raised by the
plaintiff-petitioner deserves to be rejected. The Court had granted
time and extended the period to file written statement, therefore, no
fault can be found in the impugned order, as passed by the learned
Court below, as rightly pointed out by Mr. Kang, learned counsel for
the defendants-respondents.
16.
The time was extended by the learned Court below in
the presence of learned counsel for the plaintiff-petitioner and when
last opportunity was granted on 09.10.2025, the needful was done
by the defendants/respondents by filing written statement.
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
17.
It is noticeable from the record that the application as
filed by the plaintiff-petitioner for closure of right of defendantsrespondents to file written statement came to be filed when the
written statement had already been filed and taken on record by the
learned Court below. Once, the learned Court below had extended
and granted time to the defendants to file written statement and the
same has been taken on record, the application which has been filed
by the plaintiff-respondent for the closure of the right of the
defendants to file written statement is without any substance. The
learned Court below has rightly exercised the jurisdiction and it does
not suffer from any infirmity.
18.
The Hon’ble Apex Court has repeatedly held that written
statement can be entertained by Court after 90 days of service of
summons as the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC (as
amended in 1999) does not specifically take away the power of
Court to entertain written statement beyond 90 days. Though, it is
admitted that extension of time can be allowed if it is needed to be
given for circumstances which are exceptional, occasioned by
reasons beyond the control of the defendant and grave injustice
would be occasioned if the time is not extended. Order VIII Rule 1
of CPC is procedural and not a part of substantive law.
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
19.
Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC after the amendment casts an
obligation on the defendant to file written statement within 30 days
from the date of service of summons on him and within the extended
time falling within 90 days. The provision does not deal with the
power of the Court and also does not specifically take away the
power of the Court to take the written statement on record though
filed beyond the time as provided for. Further, the nature of the
provision contained in Order VIII Rule 1 is procedural and it is not a
part of the substantive law. Order VIII Rule 1 intends to curb the
mischief of unscrupulous defendants adopting dilatory tactics
delaying the disposal of cases causing inconvenience to the
plaintiffs and petitioners approaching the Court for quick relief and
also to the serious inconvenience of the Court faced with frequent
prayers of adjournments. The object is to expedite the hearing and
not to scuttle the same.
20.
All the rules of procedure are the handmaid of justice.
The language employed by the draftsman of processual law may be
liberal or stringent, but the fact remains that the object of prescribing
procedure is to advance the cause of justice.
In an adversarial
system, no party should ordinarily be denied the opportunity of
participating in the process of justice dispensation. Unless
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
compelled by express and specific language of the statute, the
provisions of CPC or any other procedural enactment ought not to
be construed in a manner which would leave the Court helpless to
meet extraordinary situations in the ends of justice.
21.
Processual law is not to be tyrant but a servant, not an
obstruction but an aid to justice. Procedural prescriptions are the
handmaid and not the mistress. Merely because a provision of law is
couched in a negative language implying mandatory character, the
same is not without exceptions. The Courts when called upon to
interpret the nature of the provision may keeping in view the entire
context in which the provision came to be enacted hold the same to
be directory though worded in the negative form.
22.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 5066 of
2005 titled as Smt. Rani Kusum vs. Smt. Kanchan Devi and
others, decided on 16.08.2005, has held as follows:
“19. After elaborating the purpose for introduction of Order
VIII Rule 1, this Court in Kailash’s Case (supra) at paragraph
45 observed that no straightjacket formula can be laid down
except that observance of time schedule contemplated by
Order VIII Rule 1 shall be the rule and departure therefrom
an exception, made for satisfactory reasons only. The
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
conclusions have been summed up in Para 46. The relevant
portion reads as follows:
"(iv) the purpose of providing the time schedule for
filing the written statement under Order VIII Rule 1
CPC is to expedite and not to scuttle the hearing. The
provision spells out a disability on the defendant. It
does not impose an embargo on the power of the
Court to extend the time. Though the language of the
proviso to Rule 1 Order VIII CPC is couched in
negative form, it does not specify any penal
consequences flowing from the non-compliance. The
provision being in the domain of the procedural law, it
has to be held directory and not mandatory. The
power of the Court to extend time for filing the written
statement beyond the time schedule provided by
Order VIII Rule 1 CPC is not completely taken away.
(v) Though Order VIII Rule 1 CPC is a part of
procedural law and hence directory, keeping in view
the need for expeditious trial of civil cases which
persuaded Parliament to enact the provision in its
present form, it is held that ordinarily the time
schedule contained in the provision is to be followed
as a rule and departure therefrom would be by way of
exception. A prayer for extension of time made by the
defendant shall not be granted just as a matter of
routine and merely for the asking, more so when the
period of 90 days has expired. Extension of time may
be allowed by way of an exception, for reasons to be
assigned by the defendant and also be placed on
record in writing, howsoever briefly, by the court on its
being satisfied. Extension of time may be allowed if it
is needed to be given for circumstances which are
exceptional, occasioned by reasons beyond the
control of the defendant and grave injustice would be
occasioned if the time was not extended. Costs may
be imposed and affidavit or documents in support of
the grounds pleaded by the defendant for extension of
time may be demanded, depending on the facts and
circumstances of a given case."
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
23.
The Hon’ble Apex Court has held that extension of time
may be allowed by way of an exception for reasons to be assigned
by the defendant and also be placed on record in writing. Extension
of time may be allowed if it is needed to be given for circumstances
which are exceptional, occasioned by reasons beyond the control of
the defendant and grave injustice would be occasioned if the time
was not extended.
24.
In view of dictum of law as laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court, this Court does not see any infirmity, perversity or
illegality in the impugned order as passed by the learned Court
below. The time was extended by the learned Court below on the
request made by learned counsel for the defendants and within the
stipulated period when the case was fixed on 29.11.2025, being last
opportunity, the defendants filed written statement well within the
said period. Therefore, no fault or lapse can be attributed to the
defendants and on the given date, the defendants had filed the
written statement.
25.
As observed earlier, the written statement has been
taken on record and the present application came to be filed by the
plaintiff-petitioner only after filing of the same. This Court is of the
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
considered opinion that the learned Court below has exercised
jurisdiction in a legal and valid manner and it does not call for any
interference.
26.
The power under Article 227 is limited to see that the
Courts below function within the limits of their authority or
jurisdiction. The High Court cannot interfere with the findings of fact
recorded by the subordinate Court or Tribunal while exercising its
jurisdiction under Article 227. The Hon’ble Apex Court has held that,
over the last 50 years, it has consistently been observed that the
limited jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227 cannot be
exercised by interfering with findings of fact or by setting aside the
judgments of the courts below on merits.
27.
Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 2226 of 2010,
titled State of Haryana & others vs. Manoj Kumar, decided on
09.03.2010 has held as follow:“23. More than half a century ago, the Constitution Bench of
this court in Nagendra Nath Bora and Another v.
Commissioner of Hills Division and Appeals, Assam &
Others AIR 1958 SC 398 settled that power under Article
227 is limited to seeing that the courts below function within
the limit of its authority or jurisdiction.
24. This court placed reliance on Nagendra Nath's case in a
subsequent judgment in Nibaran Chandra Bag v. Mahendra
Nath Ghughu AIR 1963 SC 1895. The court observed that
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
jurisdiction conferred under Article 227 is not by any means
appellate in its nature for correcting errors in the decisions of
subordinate courts or tribunals but is merely a power of
superintendence to be used to keep them within the bounds
of their authority.
25. This court had an occasion to examine this aspect of the
matter in the case of Mohd. Yunus v. Mohd. Mustaqim &
Others (1983) 4 SCC 566. The court observed as under:"The supervisory jurisdiction conferred on the High
Courts under Article 227 of the Constitution is limited
"to seeing that an inferior Court or Tribunal functions
within the limits of its authority," and not to correct an
error apparent on the face of the record, much less an
error of law. For this case there was, in our opinion, no
error of law much less an error apparent on the face of
the record. There was no failure on the part of the
learned Subordinate Judge to exercise jurisdiction nor
did he act in disregard of principles of natural justice.
Nor was the procedure adopted by him not in
consonance with the procedure established by law. In
exercising the supervisory power under Article 227, the
High Court does not act as an Appellate Court or
Tribunal. It will not review or reweigh the evidence upon
which the determination of the inferior court or tribunal
purports to be based or to correct errors of law in the
decision."
26. This court again clearly reiterated the legal position in
Laxmikant Revchand Bhojwani & Another v. Pratapsing
Mohansingh Pardeshi (1995) 6 SCC 576. The court again
cautioned that the High Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution cannot assume unlimited prerogative to correct
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
all species of hardship or wrong decisions. It must be
restricted to cases of grave dereliction of duty and flagrant
abuse of fundamental principles of law or justice, where
grave injustice would be done unless the High Court
interferes.
27. A three-Judge Bench of this court in Rena Drego (Mrs.)
v. Lalchand Soni & Others (1998) 3 SCC 341 again
abundantly made it clear that the High Court cannot interfere
with the findings of fact recorded by the subordinate court or
the tribunal while exercising its jurisdiction under Article 227.
Its function is limited to seeing that the subordinate court or
the tribunal functions within the limits of its authority. It
cannot correct mere errors of fact by examining the evidence
and reappreciating it.
28. In Virendra Kashinath Ravat & Another v. Vinayak N.
Joshi & Others (1999) 1 SCC 47 this court held that the
limited power under Article 227 cannot be invoked except for
ensuring that the subordinate courts function within its limits.
29. This court over 50 years has been consistently observing
that limited jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 227
cannot be exercised by interfering with the findings of fact
and set aside the judgments of the courts below on merit.”
28.
To the similar extent, the Hon’ble Apex Court in Civil
Appeal No. 3072 of 2022, titled as Ibrat Faizan vs. Omaxe
Buildhome Private Limited, decided on 13.05.2022 has held as
follows: “14. In view of the above, in the present case, the High Court
has not committed any error in entertaining the writ petition
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India against the
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
order passed by the National Commission which has been
passed in an appeal under Section 58 (1) (a) (iii) of the 2019
Act. We are in complete agreement with the view taken by
the High Court. However, at the same time, it goes without
saying that while exercising the powers under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India, the High Court subjects itself to the
rigour of Article 227 of the Constitution and the High Court
has to exercise the jurisdiction under Article 227 within the
parameters within which such jurisdiction is required to be
exercised.
14.1
The scope and ambit of jurisdiction of Article 227 of
the Constitution has been explained by this Court in the case
of Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd., (2001) 8 SCC 97,
which has been consistently followed by this Court (see the
recent decision of this Court in the case of Garment Craft v.
Prakash Chand Goel, 2022 SCC Online SC 29). Therefore,
while exercising the powers under Article 227 of the
Constitution, the High Court has to act within the parameters
to exercise the powers under Article 227 of the Constitution.
It goes without saying that even while considering the grant
of interim stay/relief in a writ petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, the High Court has to bear in mind the
limited jurisdiction of superintendence under Article 227 of
the Constitution. Therefore, while granting any interim
stay/relief in a writ petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution against an order passed by the National
Commission, the same shall always be subject to the rigor of
the powers to be exercised under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.”
( 2026:HHC:39415 )
29.
In view of the aforesaid exposition of law and discussion
made hereinabove, the impugned order as passed by the learned
Court below does not suffer from any infirmity. Consequently, the
present petition is dismissed. Pending miscellaneous application(s),
if any, shall also stand disposed of.
30.
Before, parting, it is made clear that any observation
made here-in-above, shall not be taken as an expression of opinion
on the merits of the case and the same shall be adjudicated upon
uninfluenced by any observations made here-in-above which are
only for the purpose of instant petition.
16th September, 2026.
(krt)
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review