Criminal
Parashuram S/O Mallappa Madar vs The State of Karnataka
Add to a compilation
Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index.
It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence.
Sign in · See the plans
Case No.
CRL.A 200028/2022
Cite this judgment
Citation
Copy citation
Link for your website or blog
Copy link code
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0 ).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
"
##
$% &$ ' # ()&*+$
(
,
!"
#
$
%
Digitally signed
by
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
&'
'
&'
'
(!
'
#
$
%
&
" ) $ %
&
&
) !(
&
&
$
&
%
!(
$
*
!( !
%
&
!
-2-
&
+
,
+
'
)
-
"
-./ 011203 ./ 4.526724 080.9/7 7-2 :;48<297 => 6=9?.67.=9
40724
) !(
!
10//24 .9
126.03
44.7.=903
2//.=9/
094 =5425 => /2972962 40724
0/2 $
%
=
;482 * &
$-252.90>725 52>25524 7= 0/ B3205924
7-2 3205924
126.03
!
!( !
@A 7-2 3205924
$
% 07
.:0A01;50
126.03
;482C% D-252@A
;482 6=9?.6724 7-2 066;/24 >=5 7-2
=>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
267.=9/ "
094 ")) =>
/29729624 -.< 7= ;94258= 5.8=5=;/ .<15./=9<297 >=5 125.=4 =>
7D= A205/ 094 7= 10A 0 >.92 =>
/ (! !!!
.9 42>0;37
7=
;94258= /.<132 .<15./=9<297 >=5 0 125.=4 => =92 <=97- >=5 7-2
=>>2962 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
267.=9 "
=>
&;57-25 -2 ./
/29729624 7= ;94258= 5.8=5=;/ .<15./=9<297 >=5 0 125.=4 =>
7D=A205/ 094 7= 10A 0 >.92 =>
/ (! !!!
.9 42>0;37
7=
;94258= /.<132 .<15./=9<297 >=5 0 125.=4 => =92 <=97- >=5 7-2
=>>2962 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
267.=9 ")) =>
7 ./ 03/= 4.526724
7-07 @=7- 7-2 /2972962/ .963;4.98 9=9 10A<297 => >.92 /-033 5;9
6=96;552973A
-3-
-2 0@5.4824 >067/ => 7-2 15=/26;7.=9 60/2 052 7-07
) ?.67.< 094 7-2 011233097 066;/24 @23=98/ 7=
.33082
-2 011233097 D297 7=
=0 7= 2E2 =;7 -./ 3.?23.-==4 094
-2 ;/24 7= ?./.7 -./ ?.33082 =660/.=9033A
D0/ D233 06F;0.9724 D.7- ?.67.<
;5.98 /;6- 7.<2 -2
) 094 -2 2G152//24 -./ 3=?2
7= -25 094 03/= .97294/ 7= <055A -25
!" !H !(
07 0@=;7 !(+"! 1 <
66=54.983A
>=5 0 125.=4 =>
2D094. 9205
" 40A/
>07-25 => ?.67.<
=9
7-2 011233097 7==E 7-2 ?.67.<
) >5=< 7-2 30D>;3 6;/7=4A => -25 105297/
98040825. ?.33082 7=
98040825.
/ ( 094
>5=<
;92 094 /70A24 7=827-25
9 7-2 <209D-.32 =9 !
!H !(
7-2
( 3=4824 0 6=<130.97 @2>=52 7-2 52/1=94297
=3.62 0@=;7 <.//.98 => -./ 40;8-725 /126.>.6033A 080.9/7
066;/24
=/ ( 7=
03328.98 7-07 066;/24
= ( -0/ E.4901124
-./ 40;8-725 07 7-2 .9/70962 => 066;/24
=/
7=
0/ 125
G (
"
9 7-2 /752987- =>
528./72524 7-2 60/2 .9
5.<2
G (
=( H
7-2 52/1=94297
!(
080.9/7 7-2 011233097
094 =7-25/ >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
(!H 5 D
267.=9 ()H =>
=3.62
0/ 125 G ))
267.=9/ " " 094
;@/2F;2973A
?.67.< 094 066;/24 D252 750624 =9
!H
07 I05.
7-2 52/1=94297
=3.62
.51=57
=04 07
=0
-2520>725
!(
)
-4-
526=5424 7-2 /7072<297 => 7-2 ?.67.< 094 .<13.60724 066;/24
= ( 094 =7-25/ .9 7-2 0332824 65.<2
.9?2/7.807.=9 7-2 52/1=94297
>725 6=94;67.98
=3.62 30.4 6-0582 /-227 080.9/7
7-2 066;/24 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
"
094 (!H 5 D
267.=9/
267.=9 ()H =>
094 ( =>
)
267.=9/ " "
267.=9
$3% 5 D
= 15=?2 7-2 6-0582/ 32?2324 080.9/7 7-2 066;/24
7-2 15=/26;7.=9 .9 7=703 2G0<.924
! D.792//2/ 0/
094 <05E24 )
G/ ( 7=
4=6;<297/ 0/
)
/ ( 7=
!
-2 066;/24
92.7-25 2G0<.924 09A D.792// =9 -./ @2-03> 9=5 <05E24 09A
4=6;<297/
>725
2?.42962
0//2//<297
7-2 3205924
126.03
=>
=503
4=6;<29705A
;482 6=9?.6724 7-2 066;/24
= ( 011233097 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
094 ")) =>
267.=9/ "
094 /29729624 -.< 0/ /70724 /;150
-2 /0.4
:;48<297 ./ 6-03329824 .9 7-./ 011203
2054 3205924 6=;9/23 >=5 7-2 011233097 094 3205924
.8-
=;57
=?259<297 320425 >=5 52/1=94297
-5-
1057 >5=< ;58.98 /2?2503 6=97297.=9/
3205924
6=;9/23 >=5 7-2 011233097 15.<05.3A 6=9729724 7-07 7-2 :;48<297
;9425 7-./ 011203 /;>>25/ >5=< 125?25/.7A 094 .332803.7A /.962
7-2 3205924
126.03 ;482 -0/ >0.324 7= 011526.072 7-2 2?.42962
.9 0 5.8-7 125/1267.?2
2 6=9729724 7-07
9=92 => 7-2
15=/26;7.=9 D.792//2/ /;11=5724 7-2 60/2
=> 15=/26;7.=9
.963;4.98 7-2 ?.67.<
D-= D0/ 2G0<.924 0/
6.56;</70962/ 7-2 3205924
)
9 /;6-
126.03 ;482 6=9?.6724 7-2 066;/24
@0/24 =9 /;5<./2/ 094 6=9:267;52/
2 03/= 6=9729424 7-07 7-2
?.67.< /126.>.6033A 429.24 -25 /7072<297/ ;9425 ( ( 094 ( ) =>
2?257-232// 7-2 15=/26;7.=9 03/= >0.324 7= 15=?2 7-2
082 => 7-2 ?.67.< 7-07 /-2 D0/ <.9=5 07 7-2 7.<2 => .96.4297
/;6- 6.56;</70962
7-2 :;48<297 => 7-2
/;/70.90@32 @=7- ;9425 30D 094 =9 >067/
5.03
=;57 ./ 9=7
66=54.983A -2 150A/
7= 033=D 7-2 011203
3205924
6=9729424 7-07 7-2 320924
.8-
2//.=9/
=;57
=?259<297
320425
;482 0>725 <27.6;3=;/3A
2G0<.9.98 7-2 2?.42962 =9 526=54 6=9?.6724 7-2 066;/24 .9 0
D233
520/=90@32
.9725>252962
:;48<297
D-.6-
4=2/
9=7 6033 >=5
09A
2 6=9729424 7-07 .9 7-2 ( ) /7072<297 => 7-2
?.67.< /-2 60728=5.6033A /70724 7-07 /-2 -04 3=?2 0>>0.5 D.7-
-6-
066;/24
= ( 094 E9=D.98 >;33A 7-07 /-2 D0/ <.9=5 07 7-2 7.<2
=> .96.4297 066;/24
>5=< 7-252 7=
= ( 70E29 -25 7=
2D094. 9205
;92 094
=0 094 -04 /2G;03 .97256=;5/2 =9 -25
9 /;6-
6.56;</70962/ 7-2 3205924
126.03 ;482 -0/ 5.8-73A 6=9?.6724
066;/24 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
")) =>
-=;8-
267.=9/ "
?.67.< 094 =7-25 D.792//2/ -0?2 9=7
/;11=5724 7-2 60/2 => 15=/26;7.=9 7-2
=;57 609 6=9?.67 7-2
066;/24 /.962 7-2 ?.67.< D0/ <.9=5 07 7-2 7.<2 => .96.4297
66=54.983A -2 150A/ 7= 4./<.// 7-2 011203
H
0?.98 -2054 7-2 3205924 6=;9/23 >=5 7-2 52/1267.?2
1057.2/ 094 =9 125;/03 => 7-2 .<1;8924 :;48<297 /= 03/= 7-2
<0725.03 0?0.30@32 =9 526=54 7-2 /=32 1=.97 7-07 D=;34 05./2 >=5
<A 6=9/.42507.=9 ./+
J -27-25 7-2 :;48<297 ;9425 7-./ 011203
/;>>25/ >5=< 125?25/.7A =5 .332803.7A 094 7-2 /0<2
52F;.52/ 09A .9725>252962 @A 7-./
(!
6052>;3
125;/03
4=6;<297/ 130624 @2>=52 7-./
?.67.< 094 066;/24
=>
=;57KL
7-2
2?.42962
=;57 .7 ./ 9=7 4./1;72 7-07 7-2
= ( @23=98/ 7= 7-2 /0<2 ?.33082
7-2 6=<130.97 0?25<297/ 07
7-2
G (
.7 ./ /70724 @A
/ 125
( 7-2
-7-
>07-25 => ?.67.< 7-07 066;/24
-./ 40;8-725
= ( 03=98 D.7- =7-25/ E.4901124
=D2?25 4;5.98 7-2 6=;5/2 => 2?.42962
(
7=7033A 8.?29 0 8= @A2 7= 7-2 6=<130.97 0?25<297/ 094 429.24
7-2 /0<2
-=;8-
( D0/ 65=// 2G0<.924 07 32987- @A 7-2
15=/26;7.=9 9=7-.98 D=57-D-.32 -0/ @229 23.6.724 >5=< -.< 7=
523A -./ 6=<130.97 07 G (
((
?.67.<
2?257-232//
)
7-=;8- 7-2 15=/26;7.=9 2G0<.924
D-252.9 /-2 -0/ 03/= /126.>.6033A 429.24 7-2
.96.4297 094 /70724 7-07 92.7-25 /-2 066=<109.24 066;/24
=(
0/ /70724 .9 7-2 6=<130.97 9=5 7-2 066;/24 >=5624 -25 7=
066=<109A -.< 7=
<055A.98 -25
2D094. 9205
;92 =5
=0 =9 7-2 8;./2 =>
-2 03/= /70724 7-07 07 7-2 7.<2 => .96.4297 /-2
-04 @229 7= -25 ;9632,/ -=;/2 094 /70A24 7-252 >=5 7-2 520/=9
7-07 -25 105297/ D252 >=56.@3A .9/./7.98 -25 7= 827 <055A
-2
?.67.< -0/ 03/= /126.>.6033A 429.24 7-2 /0<2 .9 -25 ( )
/7072<297
44.7.=9033A
7-2 <=7-25 => ?.67.< 03/= 7;5924
-=/7.32 7= 7-2 60/2 => 15=/26;7.=9
9 /;6- 6.56;</70962/ 7-2
15=/26;7.=9 -0/ >0.324 7= 15=?2 7-2 6-0582/ 32?2324 080.9/7
066;/24 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
=>
267.=9/ "
=5 "))
-252 052 9= /;6- 2?.42962 0?0.30@32 =9 526=54 2G6217
7-2 2?.42962 =>
9?2/7.807.98
>>.625 094 7-2 =7-25 =>>.6.03
-8-
D.792//2/
= 4=;@7
7-2 15=/26;7.=9 -0/ 130624 7-2 @.57-
6257.>.6072 => ?.67.< 0/ 125
D0/ 0824 0@=?2 (
A205/
G ") D-.6- 421.67/ 7-07 7-2 ?.67.<
=D2?25 D-29 7-2 ?25A .96.4297
.7/23> ./ 429.24 @A 7-2 ?.67.< 6=<130.9097 094 7-2 <=7-25 =>
?.67.< <;6- 65242962 6099=7 @2 07706-24 7= 7-2 082 15==> =>
?.67.< D-29 7-2 2?.42962 306E/ 7= 6=99267 066;/24
= ( .9 7-2
0332824 .96.4297 65.<2
(
7 ./ /277324 1=/.7.=9 => 30D 7-07 7-2 2?.42962 =>
=>>.6.03 D.792//2/ 6099=7 @2 4./605424 =93A >=5 7-2 520/=9 7-07
7-2A 052 7-2 =>>.6.03 D.792//2/
=9C@32
12G
@;7 .9 7-2 /0<2 7.<2
7-2
=;57 .9
521=5724 .9
-234 7-07 7-2 72/7.<=9A => 7-2 =>>.6.03 D.792// 6099=7 @2
4./605424 /=323A =9 7-2 @0/./ 7-07 7-2A 052 7-2 =>>.6.03 @;7 .9
7-2 /0<2 7.<2
D.7-=;7 7-252 @2.98 09A 6=55=@=507.=9
2?.42962 => 7-2 =>>.6.03 D.792// 6099=7 @2 06724 ;1=9
-2
7-2
=;57
-0/ 7= 3==E .97= 6=55=@=507.?2 1.262 => 2?.42962 => =>>.6.03
D.792// /.962 7-252 ./ 0 1=//.@.3.7A => >03/2 .<13.607.=9
"
("
&;57-25 7= 15=?2 7-2 6-0582 32?2324 ;9425
267.=9
=>
7-2 .98524.297/ => 7-2 =>>2962 -0/ 7= @2 15=?24 . 2
-9-
066;/24 <;/7 E.4901 7-2 ?.67.< >5=< 7-2 30D>;3 8;054.09
080.9/7 -25 D.33 @A 6=<1233.98 -25 7= <055A
9 7-2 .9/7097
60/2 7-2 ?.67.< -25/23> -0/ /70724 7-07 7-2 066;/24 07 9= 1=.97
=> 7.<2 -04 >=5624 -25 7= 066=<109A -.< =5 .9/./724 -25 7=
<055A -.<
"
=>
9 /;6- 6.56;</70962/ 7-2 .98524.297/ =>
267.=9
4=2/ 9=7 0775067/ .9 7-./ 60/2
()
-2
=9C@32
!
12G
=;57 .9 7-2 60/2 =>
" # 521=5724 .9
$$%
%&&
-0/ <042 09 =@/25?07.=9 .9 52/1267 => <=503 6=9?.67.=9 7-07
D09425.98 =9 /75=98 /;/1.6.=9 ./ 9=7 09 =17.=9 7= 426.42 0 60/2
@A 7-2
2//.=9/
=;57 094 -234 .9 10508501-
=
0/ ;9425+
&
!
"
#
- 10 -
$
%
&
%
&
'
(
9 7-2 .9/7097 60/2 03@2.7 7-252 ./ /-=57 => 2?.42962
7= 15=?2 7-2 6-0582/ 32?2324 080.9/7 066;/24
126.03
;482 6=9?.6724 066;/24
/;5<./2 094 6=9:267;52
= ( 7-2 3205924
= ( 011233097 @0/24 =9
9 <A 6=9/.42524 ?.2D
7-2 /0.4
6=9?.67.=9 =5425 6099=7 @2 /;/70.924 094 .9725>252962 ./
52F;.524 .9 7-2 .<1;8924 :;48<297 => 6=9?.67.=9 094 =5425 =>
/2972962
66=54.983A
09/D25 1=.97 50./24 0@=?2 .9 7-2
0>>.5<07.?2 094 15=6224 7= 10// 7-2 >=33=D.98+
$.%
-2
5.<.903
11203 ./
'' (
/
$..%
-2 :;48<297 => 6=9?.67.=9 40724
094 =5425 => /2972962 40724
.9
126.03
3205924
$
0/2 $
%
44.7.=903
2//.=9/
% 07
=
) !(
!
!( !
10//24
!(
@A 7-2
;482 * &
.:0A01;50 ./ -252@A /27 0/.42
- 11 -
$...%
=9/2F;2973A
7-2 011233097 066;/24
= ( ./
06F;.7724 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425
267.=9/ "
$.?%
094 ")) =>
0.3 @=94 => 7-2 066;/24 094 7-07 => -./ /;527.2/
/-033 /7094 609623324
$?%
-2 >.92 0<=;97 .> 09A 421=/.724 @A 066;/24
= ( ./ =542524 7= @2 52>;9424 7= -.< =9 4;2
.4297.>.607.=9 0>725 011203 125.=4 ./ =?25
28./75A 7= 4.526724 7= /294 @06E 7-2
03=98 D.7-
6257.>.24 6=1A => 7-./ :;48<297 7= 7-2 6=9625924
>=57-D.7-
.)
$
./7
+
=+(
=+(
(
=;57
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review